Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an exotic scalar boson in the b b barW+W- single lepton final state at sqrt s =13 TeV with the ATLAS experiment

summary

The gist

Search for Higgs boson pair production where one Higgs boson decays via H to b b bar and the other Higgs boson decays via H to W* to nu q q bar (= e, mu).

In short

The search looked for Higgs boson pair production where one decayed to $bar{b}$ and the other to a leptonic W decay, assuming Standard Model dynamics. No evidence was found, setting an upper limit 35 times the Standard Model prediction. The same method was applied to search for resonant production of heavy scalars X and S decaying into SH.

Key concepts

Non-resonant Higgs pair production
This searches for two Higgs bosons produced directly in a way that doesn't involve a specific intermediate resonance. The analysis looks for the signal where one Higgs decays into bottom quarks ($bar{b}$) and the other decays into a leptonic W boson decay, using kinematic variables to distinguish this from background processes like top quark pairs.
Resonant production of X to SH
This searches for exotic physics where two heavy, hypothetical particles (X and S) are produced, one decaying into the Higgs (H) and the other decaying into a W boson pair ($W^+W^-$). The search sets limits on the production rate of these heavy scalars based on their assumed masses.
Higgsness and Topness variables
These are kinematic measurements used to separate different types of events. Higgsness specifically helps distinguish between the signal process (like $HH$) and backgrounds like top quark pairs ($tar{t}$), while Topness is another variable used in this discrimination.
Neural Networks for Classification
The analysis uses sophisticated machine learning models, specifically neural networks trained on many input variables. These networks help the detector distinguish between the desired signal (like $HH$ or $SH$) and various backgrounds ($tar{t}$, $W+$jets) by exploiting complex correlations among the measured physical observables.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an exotic scalar boson in the b b barW+W- single lepton final state at sqrt s =13 TeV with the ATLAS experiment · Read on arXiv

The ATLAS Collaboration

EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN)

A search for Higgs boson pair production where one Higgs boson decays via H to b b bar and the other Higgs boson decays via H to WW* to νq q bar (=e,μ) is presented. This search uses the complete Run 2 data sample recorded by the ATLAS detector at the LHC from 2015 to 2018 at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 140 fb-1. The analysis looks for non-resonant Higgs boson pair production assuming Standard Model dynamics. No evidence for Higgs-boson pair production is observed and an upper limit at 95% confidence level is set at 35 times the Standard Model prediction. The same selection is used to target Beyond the Standard Model theories predicting the resonant production of the heavy scalars, X and S, with m X > m S > m H, undergoing the process X to SH, S to W+W-, H to b b bar. Limits are set on the resonant X to SH production for several combinations of the two scalar's masses within the m X mass range 350-3000 GeV and m S mass range 170-2500 GeV.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an exotic scalar boson in the b b barW+W- single lepton final state at sqrt s =13 TeV with the ATLAS experiment".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Search for Higgs boson pair production where one Higgs boson decays via H to b b bar and the other Higgs boson decays via H to W* to nu q q bar (= e, mu).

Kai: This search uses the complete Run 2 data sample recorded by the ATLAS detector at the LHC from 2015 to 2018 at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 140 fb-1.

Mira: The analysis looks for non-resonant Higgs boson pair production assuming Standard Model dynamics.

Kai: No evidence for Higgs-boson pair production is observed and an upper limit at 95% confidence level is set at 35 times the Standard Model prediction.

Title and authors: Kai: So, to start, let's look at what this paper is about in its title: "Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an exotic scalar boson in the b b barW+W- single lepton final state at sqrt s = thirteen TeV with the ATLAS experiment" <ref:2611.08241#pg1,Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an>. It basically lays out the specific search channel they ran.

Mira: I think what it means is they are looking for two ways to get that signal: either a standard Higgs pair production, or something new where you have an exotic scalar X and a standard Higgs H colliding to make this final state.

Lev: The title tells us the exact process they are targeting: the b b W bar W- single lepton final state at thirteen TeV <ref:2611.08241#pg1,single lepton final state at>. It's very specific, which is good for setting limits, but it also means they are looking for a very rare event if it's not the standard model.

Kai: The implication is that if we don't see anything, we can put constraints on new physics models that predict these heavy scalars X and S. It’s about testing those theories against real data.

Mira: And the authors are using a very specific set of criteria, which usually means they are trying to be as sensitive as possible to this particular signature.

Lev: They are also exploring combinations of masses for X and S, specifically with m X in the range three hundred fifty to three thousand GeV and m S between one hundred seventy and two thousand five hundred GeV. That's a wide range to cover.

Kai: So, they’re not just looking for one specific particle; they are mapping out where these new heavy particles might hide in the mass spectrum, which is how you constrain their possible existence.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now, let's break down the summary of this paper. It says they looked for two things: non-resonant Higgs boson pair production and resonant production through X to SH and S to W+W-.

Mira: Essentially, the first part is testing if we can even see regular Higgs pair production in this decay mode without new physics interfering. The second part is hunting for that specific chain involving the heavy scalars X and S.

Lev: The summary clarifies the assumptions they make about these new particles. They assume that both S and X have a narrow width, around ten MeV. That's a big assumption you have to make when you're not directly measuring the particle itself.

Kai: And there’s a crucial setup detail: they choose the sum of the masses of S and H to be smaller than the mass of X. This is important because it ensures that both S and H can be produced on-shell without being suppressed by some kinematic reason.

Mira: That condition sets up a specific region where they expect to see these resonant production signals if those new particles exist. It’s a way to maximize the probability of seeing the signal.

Lev: And remember, they explicitly state that they are neglecting the standard model Higgs pair production in their background processes for both searches. That means any excess they find is supposed to be from those new physics scenarios, not just some weird SM fluctuation.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out several improvements they made compared to previous work, especially concerning the selection and discrimination of the signals.

Mira: They introduced neural networks that are trained on forty input variables to output probabilities for four different processes: Higgs pair, X and S, top-top pairs, and W plus jets. This is a big step in how they separate the signal from everything else.

Lev: That’s the signal region definition you mentioned earlier; using those discriminant variables like dHH or dSHi to define mutually exclusive regions. It makes the selection much more powerful than just looking at simple cuts on a few kinematic variables.

Kai: They also improved background rejection using another neural network that exploits correlations between observables, like the azimuthal angle of two light jets with the highest transverse momentum and the lepton's phi.

Mira: That’s smart because it means they aren't just looking at individual particles; they are looking at how different parts of the event are connected, which helps them distinguish signal from backgrounds more effectively.

Lev: They also used maximum-likelihood fits across six background control regions plus four signal regions to get precise upper limits on the cross-section times branching fraction for various scalar masses m X and m S. That’s how you get the tightest constraints on new physics parameters.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, this paper presents some very strong results. For non-resonant Higgs pair production, they found an upper limit on the cross-section ratio of thirty-five times the standard model prediction, and they didn't find any excess over that prediction <ref:2611.08241#pg1,35 times the standard model prediction>.

Mira: And for the resonant searches involving X and S, they also found no statistically significant discrepancy in any of their signal regions. They set exclusion limits on the production cross-section multiplied by branching fraction for various mass hypotheses.

Lev: The main implication is that they've tightened the constraints on these hypothetical heavy scalars, which helps prune the parameter space for theories predicting them.

Kai: Before we go, I want to mention one thing about their method: they incorporated various systematic uncertainties as nuisance parameters in their likelihood fit, including modeling uncertainties for top-top pairs and W plus jets.

Mira: And they quantified that total systematic uncertainty budget, which is eighty-four percent for the non-resonant Higgs pair production hypothesis. That gives you a good idea of how much confidence you should have in those limits.

Lev: From my side, it shows that if we were to run this on real hardware, the overhead from implementing these kinds of complex analyses would be substantial, but it’s what we need for precision measurements.

Kai: So, this paper on "Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an exotic scalar boson in the b b barW+W- single lepton final state at sqrt s = thirteen TeV with the ATLAS experiment" gives us solid constraints on these new particles using high luminosity data <ref:2611.08241#pg1,Search for Higgs boson production in association with another Higgs or an>.

Mira: It’s a good piece of work for testing both standard model expectations and searching for physics beyond the standard model in this specific decay channel.

Lev: We'll keep an eye on how these constraints evolve as we get more data, because that’s where the real power is in narrowing down those mass ranges you talked about.

More episodes

← Home