Quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflect their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion
summary
The gist
Cold accretion and quenching are closely related aspects of galaxy evolution, as sustained gas supply is required to maintain star formation The authors measure quiescent fractions in a sample of 16…
In short
Researchers studied 16 galaxy groups at high redshift to see how their quiescent fraction relates to gas accretion states (hot vs. cold). They found that quiescent fractions are high (~50%) in hot-accretion groups and zero in cold-accretion groups, suggesting the transition from cold to hot accretion drives galaxy quenching through inside-out starvation.
Key concepts
- Quiescent Fraction
- This is the percentage of galaxies within a group that are not actively forming stars. The study measures this fraction by analyzing galaxy light (SEDs) and using membership probability to determine which galaxies belong to the group.
- Hot-Accretion Regime
- This describes groups where gas accretion is dominated by hot, shock-heated intra-group medium. In these environments, the study found a significant correlation with a high quiescent fraction, suggesting this state is linked to galaxy quenching.
- Cold-Accretion Regime
- This describes groups where gas accretion is dominated by cold gas streams. Groups in this regime showed zero quiescent galaxies, indicating that the cold accretion state does not lead to quenching in these specific structures.
- Inside-Out Starvation
- This proposed mechanism suggests that quenching happens because the supply of cold gas is disrupted or starved from the outside in. This is linked to filament disruption by shock-heated intra-group gas, which starves galaxies from new fuel.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflect their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion · Paper Radio
- Ly-alpha emission reveals two satellite halos around massive groups at z 3: the puzzling case of a quiescent central galaxy
- Statistical Properties of Cold Streams In Massive Star-Forming Halos in TNG50
- Dissecting the Perseus-Pisces supercluster observed with CFHT-MegaCam: Investigating environmental effects on galaxy morphology · Paper Radio
- The stellar mass function of quiescent and star-forming galaxies and its dependence on morphology in COSMOS-Web
- Under the glare of a luminous quasar, the FIR continuum is still an excellent tracer of the ISM down to the central kiloparsec
- BEACON: JWST NIRCam Pure-parallel Imaging Survey. IV. A Systematic Search for Galaxy Overdensities and Evidence for Gas Accretion Mode Transition
- A quiescent galaxy in a gas-rich cosmic web node at z 3
- Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z = 2.51 · Paper Radio
- Noema formIng Cluster survEy (NICE): A Census of Star Formation and Cold Gas Properties in Massive protoclusters at 1.5<z<4
The paper
Quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflect their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion · Read on arXiv
Université Paris-Saclay · INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Trieste · IFPU-Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe · Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris UMR 7095 CNRS Sorbonne University · School of Astronomy and Space Science Nanjing University · Key Laboratory of Modern Astronomy and Astrophysics Nanjing University · Cosmic Dawn Center DAWN Denmark · DTU Space Technical University of Denmark Elektrovej 327 DK-2800 Kgs Lyngby Denmark · Instituto de F༿isica Pontificia Universidad Catolica de ValparaÑo Valparaíso Chile · Niels Bohr Institute University of Copenhagen
Cold accretion and quenching are closely related aspects of galaxy evolution, as sustained gas supply is required to maintain star formation. High-redshift galaxy groups therefore provide a valuable laboratory for testing how the thermal state of accreting gas relates to the emergence of quiescence. We measure quiescent fractions in a sample of 16 spectroscopically confirmed galaxy groups at 1.6<z<3.6, spanning halo masses from 10 12.8, M to 10 13.9, M, by fitting the SEDs of candidate member galaxies selected from the COSMOS2020 catalog and using a membership-probability approach to estimate group quiescent fractions. We compare these quiescent fractions to the expected cold or hot accretion state of each halo and find evidence for a correlation: quiescent fractions reach about 50 percent in groups in the hot-accretion regime and are consistent with zero in groups in the cold-accretion regime. In mature hot-accreting groups, massive quiescent galaxies are preferentially found in the inner regions (R<0.5R vir), with a 4.4-sigma excess relative to the outskirts. Most groups lack a clearly established brightest group galaxy and instead show small stellar-mass gaps, typically M*,1/M*,2<3, indicating that they remain in an active assembly phase rather than being dynamically evolved systems. Consistently, the stellar-mass excess of the dominant galaxy, measured relative to the SHMR expectation, does not predict the group quiescent fraction. Taken together, our results support a picture in which the cold-to-hot transition in gas accretion contributes to the onset of quiescence, possibly through inside-out starvation associated with filament disruption in shock-heated intra-group gas, and suggest that environment plays a greater role than internal processes in shaping the quiescent galaxy population in these structures.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflect their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Cold accretion and quenching are closely related aspects of galaxy evolution, as sustained gas supply is required to maintain star formation The authors measure quiescent fractions in a sample of 16 spectroscopically confirmed galaxy groups at 1.6 < z < 3.6, spanning halo masses from 1012.8 M⊙ to 1013.9 M⊙, by fitting the SEDs of candidate member galaxies selected from the COSMOS2020 catalog and by using a membership-probability approach to estimate group quiescent fractions They compare these quiescent fractions to the expected cold or hot accretion state of each halo and find evidence for a correlation: quiescent fractions reach ∼ 50% in groups in the hot-accretion regime and are consistent with 0% in groups in the cold-accretion regime In mature hotaccreting groups, massive quiescent galaxies are preferentially found in the inner regions (R < 0.5Rvir), with a 4.4σ excess relative to the outskirts Most groups lack a clearly established BGG and instead show small stellar-mass gaps, typically M∗,1/M∗,2 ≲ 3, indicating that they remain in an active assembly phase rather than being dynamically evolved systems Taken together, our results support a picture in which the cold-to-hot transition in gas accretion contributes to the onset of quiescence, possibly through inside-out starvation associated with filament disruption in shock-heated intra-group gas, and suggest that environment plays a greater role than internal processes in shaping the quiescent galaxy population in these structures Quiescent Fraction vs.
Vera: Accretion State The study investigates how the quiescent fraction of galaxy groups relates to the hot-or-cold state of gas accretion, which is crucial for understanding quenching mechanisms The key finding is a correlation where quiescent fractions reach ∼ 50% in groups in the hot-accretion regime and are consistent with 0% in groups in the cold-accretion regime This suggests that the cold-to-hot transition contributes to the onset of quiescence, possibly through inside-out starvation caused by filament disruption in shock-heated intra-group gas The correlation is quantified by fitting an affine function where quiescent fractions decrease as Mstream/Mh values move towards the cold accretion regime, finding a value of a = −0.13 ± 0.06 with a significance of 2.1σ Galaxy Population Structure in Groups The analysis revealed distinct spatial patterns for quiescent and star-forming galaxies within groups based on the accretion regime In groups undergoing hot accretion (Mstream/Mh < 0.2), there is a 4.4σ excess of massive quiescent galaxies in the central parts of evolved groups compared to the outskirts In the intermediate regime (0.2 < Mstream/Mh < 1), quiescent galaxies become prevalent enough in the inner regions to match star-forming galaxies in numbers, while they are still almost absent in the outskirts In the late evolutionary stage (Mstream/Mh < 0.2), quiescent galaxies in the inner region become the prevalent dominant population, outnumbering star-forming galaxies (although with a low significance of 1.6σ) and quiescent galaxies are much more numerous in the inner regions compared to the outskirts, with a 4.4σ excess in the highest mass bin Role of Stellar Mass and Internal Processes The research tested whether stellar mass or internal processes drive group-wide quenching, finding that neither is a primary driver Specifically, stellar mass does not seem to be the main driver of quiescence in groups because quiescent fractions in groups undergoing hot accretion decrease at the highest stellar masses and quiescent fractions do not correlate with how overmassive the most massive member is Furthermore, there is no evidence for a trend where quiescent fractions increase with stellar mass, which contradicts low redshift expectations This supports the idea that internal processes are unlikely to be the main reason for group-wide quiescence The results consistently support a picture where cold/hot accretion has a substantial impact on the onset of quiescence in groups, suggesting quenching occurs from the inside-out as a result of starvation caused by filament disruption by the gravitational shock-heated intra-cluster medium Massive galaxies are predominantly quiescent in evolved groups, and distance to the group is found to be the most important factor when assessing the quiescence of galaxies as opposed to stellar mass The findings provide observational confirmation that cosmic web accretion can drive and shut down star-formation in galaxies Methodological Robustness The methodology employed is robust, as the results are consistent to field contamination, variations of the quiescent criteria, and maximum scanning radius used The authors developed a new method to select member galaxies, fit their SEDs with physically appropriate M13 stellar templates and classify them as quiescent according to several criteria based on their physical properties while propagating statistical and classification uncertainties consistently The procedure for estimating the group quiescent fraction accounts for both measurement uncertainties in galaxy classifications and statistical field contamination corrections through weighting factors Limitations and Future Directions The study acknowledges limitations, noting that obtaining spectroscopic confirmation of membership would allow to better constrain statistics derived on groups especially for low mass galaxies where contamination is more important Expanding the sample and deepening the understanding of their member galaxies would allow to refine our understanding of the cold to hot accretion transition and its impact on the onset of quiescence The exact manner in which filaments connect to and feed groups is subject to a lot of speculation, but probing quiescent fractions allows for direct probing of how much is available to be converted into stars The presence of quiescent galaxies in the middle of a giant gas reservoir shows that having cold gas is not sufficient for enabling star-formation, as this gas can be rendered inefficient either by AGN feedback, morphological quenching or other processes The center of RO-1001-Sat may have just entered the state in which cold filaments get disrupted and filamentary accretion becomes inefficient The presence of quiescent galaxies in groups close to the boundary between cold and hot accretion or even within the cold accretion regime is not incompatible with the cold accretion paradigm Stellar Mass Gap Interpretation The study finds that most groups exhibit much smaller stellar-mass gaps, typically M∗,1/M∗,2 ≲ 3, which indicates that the most massive galaxy does not yet strongly dominate the massive end of the group population This modest gap suggests that these systems are in an active assembly phase rather than as dynamically evolved systems analogous to the large-gap groups often identified at low redshift The stellar-mass excess of the dominant galaxy is not a useful predictor of the group quiescent fraction in our sample, with a Spearman rank coefficient between fq and ∆M∗,max being rs = −0.099, with a p-value of 0.72 BGG Absence The analysis indicates that in general there is not a clear established BGG in the majority of the groups studied The most interesting and robust trend is visible in the highest stellar mass bin, where quiescent galaxies are much more numerous in the inner regions compared to the outskirts, with a 4.4σ excess in the highest mass bin Most groups have low ratios of the stellar masses of the most to second most massive galaxies, showcasing the absence of a clearly established BGG Stellar Mass Distribution Trends In groups in early evolutionary phase (1 < Mstream/Mh, right panel), the high-mass end of the distribution is dominated by star-forming galaxies in the inner parts of the groups, and there is a 4.4σ excess of star-forming galaxies in the inner regions compared to quiescent galaxies In the late evolutionary stage (Mstream/Mh < 0.2, left panel), quiescent galaxies in the inner region become the prevalent dominant population, outnumbering star-forming galaxies (although with a low significance of 1.6σ) and quiescent galaxies are much more numerous in the inner regions compared to the outskirts Final Summary Taken together, these results are consistent with cold/hot accretion having a substantial impact on the onset of quiescence in the groups we study Groups seem to quench from the inside-out as a result of starvation caused by filament disruption by the gravitational shock-heated intra-cluster medium Massive galaxies are predominantly quiescent in evolved groups, and distance to the group is found to be the most important factor when assessing the quiescence of galaxies Groups seem well in the process of assembling and to start virializing for the ones that are well into the hot accretion regime The study investigates in depth the robustness of our results with regards to the cuts and thresholds choices made in our study and they hold when varying these parameters Acknowledgments This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 101148925 R.
Jocelyn: G.
Vera: acknowledges funding from project ANID Fondecyt 1231661 S.L.
Paper summary: Vera: So, wrapping up the "Quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflect their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion" paper, the central message is that cold or hot accretion has a substantial impact on when galaxies in groups stop forming stars.
Jocelyn: They conclude that quenching seems to happen from the inside out as a result of starvation caused by filament disruption by the gravitational shock-heated intra-group medium <ref:2604.22401#pg3>.
Subrahmanyan: And they emphasize that massive galaxies are predominantly quiescent in evolved groups, and distance to the group is found to be the most important factor when assessing this quiescence compared to stellar mass <ref:2604.22401#pg3>.
Vera: It's a strong observational confirmation that cosmic web accretion can drive and shut down star formation in galaxies at high redshifts <ref:2604.22401#pg3>.
Jocelyn: The paper shows us that when you look at the accretion state, you get a direct picture of the quenching mechanism happening, which is very helpful for figuring out what to look for next in follow-up observations <ref:2604.22401#pg2>.
Conclusion: Vera: So, basically, this paper is looking at how many galaxies in galaxy groups are actually dead—quiescent—and linking that number directly to whether those groups are currently taking in cold or hot gas.
Jocelyn: Right. The title says it's about the quiescent fractions in high-redshift galaxy groups reflecting their hot-or-cold state of gas accretion. It’s connecting the fuel supply to whether a galaxy is forming stars or not.
Subrahmanyan: From my side, what this implies is that we can start using these accretion states as a diagnostic for when and how galaxies stop growing in these dense environments. It helps us pinpoint the physical processes causing that shutdown.
Vera: Exactly. The authors are measuring this across a sample of sixteen galaxy groups at redshifts between one point six and three point six, covering halo masses from about one thousand twelve point eight solar masses to one thousand twelve point nine solar masses. That’s a pretty tight range for the study.
Jocelyn: And they use some membership probability approaches to figure out how many of those galaxies are actually in the group versus just background noise in their selection catalog. That adds a layer of complexity there.
Subrahmanyan: I think that statistical rigor is important because if you get a biased sample, your whole picture about the accretion transition gets skewed. But looking at the results, they find a clear split: groups with hot accretion have about fifty percent quiescent galaxies, while those in cold accretion regimes show zero of them.
Vera: That’s the core correlation they found. It suggests that shifting from cold to hot gas is what really triggers the onset of that quiescence we see in groups. It's a big piece of evidence for how cosmic web accretion dictates galaxy evolution at these early stages.
Jocelyn: So, it seems like the transition itself, rather than just having a massive galaxy, is the key driver for quenching in these structures. That really shifts our focus to the role of that shock-heated intra-group gas and how it disrupts things internally.
Subrahmanyan: Yeah, and that points toward an inside-out starvation mechanism being important here. It’s not just a global process; it’s localized disruption caused by the environment feeding the group. If you want to confirm this, we need observations that can map out that gas shock front directly.
Vera: Right. So, looking at what these authors did, they aren't just counting galaxies; they’re using accretion history as a proxy for the physical state of the gas reservoir itself and seeing how that state determines whether a group is star-forming or not.
Jocelyn: It sets up this really interesting direction for follow-up work, because if we can link these accretion states to observable features in the gas—like shock fronts—that could settle a lot about how galaxies transition into the quiescent population.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO