Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z = 2.51
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z = 2.51".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg3>.
Vera: Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51 <ref:2503.21724#pg2>.
Jocelyn: These single-tailed gas distributions, which extend notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503.21724#pg2>.
Vera: These very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked quenching pathway <ref:2503.21724#pg2>.
Paper summary: Vera: To summarize this paper, they found clear evidence from ALMA of extended gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = two point five one, which points to ram-pressure stripping as a mechanism <ref:2503.21724#pg1,cluster at z = 2.51>.
Jocelyn: The authors claim that these single-tailed gas distributions extend past the stellar emission seen by JWST in isolated galaxies, which is unusual and suggests ram-pressure stripping is happening here.
Subrahmanyan: It matters because they highlight the critical role of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, which we often overlook when studying galaxy quenching.
Vera: They are looking at a structure called CLJ1001, which has a total mass close to a mature cluster, and it contains fourteen star-forming galaxies with stellar masses greater than ten point five times the solar mass within the central three hundred forty kiloparsecs <ref:2503.21724#pg1>.
Jocelyn: The paper suggests that most of these massive star-forming galaxies are expected to become quiescent very soon because of their low gas fraction.
Subrahmanyan: They are using this cluster as a laboratory to investigate how a dense environment affects the formation of massive galaxies during their peak assembly time, z equals two point fifty-one.
Vera: The authors also looked at the spatial distributions of molecular gas and stars using JWST and NIRCam imaging to see how these processes are spatially organized within CLJ1001.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So, looking at the full picture, this paper by Ke Xu et al., titled "Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z = two point five one," really focuses on showing that ram-pressure stripping is a plausible way to strip gas from galaxies in forming clusters when they are very young <ref:2503.21724#pg1,Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z>.
Vera: The title itself, focusing on z equals two point fifty-one tells us we are seeing this effect much earlier than previously thought for massive galaxy quenching.
Subrahmanyan: What this implies for the bigger picture is that the quenching of massive galaxies happens not just in fully formed clusters but also in these actively assembling structures when they're at high redshift.
Jocelyn: The main implication is that the presence of a dense intracluster medium, even if it’s still developing, can be what removes the gas supply from star-forming galaxies and stops them from forming stars.
Ke Xu, Tao Wang, Emanuele Daddi, David Elbaz, Hanwen Sun, Longyue Chen, Qiaoyang Hao, Raphael Gobat, Anita Zanella, Daizhong Liu, ¦Mengyuan Xiao, ¦Renyue Cen, ¦Tadayuki Kodama, ᵂKotaro Kohno, Tiancheng Yang, Can Xu, Zhi-Yu Zhang, Luwenjia Zhou, Francesco Valentino
School of Astronomy and Space Science, Nanjing University · Key Laboratory of Modern Astronomy and Astrophysics, Nanjing University · ¦Université Paris-Saclay, Université Paris Cit⠾, CEA, CNRS, AIM · Instituto de Fca, Pontificia Universidad Cat⠾clica de Valparaőso · Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF), Padua · Purple Mountain Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences Nanjing · State Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy and Technology, Purple Mountain Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences Nanjing · Department of Astronomy, University of Geneva Versoix · Centre for Cosmology and Computational Astrophysics Institute for Advanced Study in Physics and Institute of Astronomy School of Physics Zhejiang University Hangzhou · Astronomical Institute, Tohoku University Sendai · Institute of Astronomy School of Science The University of Tokyo Tokyo · Research Centre for the Early Universe School of Science The University of Tokyo Tokyo
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2025-03-27
Updated: 2026-06-22
Comments: Published in Nature Astronomy
Journal ref: Nature Astronomy 10, 1208-1217 (2026)
DOI: 10.1038/s41550-026-02892-9
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg3>.
Key concepts
- Ram-Pressure Stripping (RPS)
- This process occurs when a galaxy moves rapidly through the dense hot gas (intracluster medium) within a cluster. The pressure exerted by this moving gas physically strips the galaxy's cold gas supply, which is essential for star formation. The paper uses extended tails in galaxies to confirm this stripping mechanism.
- Intracluster Medium (ICM)
- The ICM is the hot, dense plasma that fills the space between galaxies within a massive cluster. It acts as a fluid medium that exerts pressure on galaxies moving through it. The presence and density of this medium are crucial because they determine how effectively ram-pressure stripping can occur.
- Galaxy Quenching
- Quenching refers to the process where a galaxy stops forming new stars, usually by removing its cold gas supply. This paper suggests that environmental effects like RPS can cause this quenching much earlier than in mature clusters, showing that dense environments influence galaxy evolution at high redshifts.
Terminology
Summary
Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts <ref:2503. p. 1 E-mail(s): taowang@nju. cn;
Abstract
Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts. Whether their quenching is driven
by internal processes or environmental effects is a matter of debate that has
been challenging to resolve due to the lack of observations during their peak
formation epoch. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. Whether their quenching is driven
by internal processes or environmental effects is a matter of debate that has
been challenging to resolve due to the lack of observations during their peak
formation epoch. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. 13Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe
(WPI), The University of Tokyo, Chiba, Japan. 1
arXiv:2503. 13Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe
(WPI), The University of Tokyo, Chiba, Japan. 1
arXiv:2503. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Context and Significance
Direct evidence of the impact of environmental effects on cluster galaxies during their major formation epoch, z ≈ 2–4, has so far been lacking <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. The structure CLJ1001 at z = 2. p. 1 A novel type of structures has recently been discovered at z ≳ 2 [1–9],
that exhibits high overdensities of galaxies (and high halo mass) in the core but is
dominated by star-forming galaxies. Among these structures, CLJ1001 [10, 11] at
z = 2. Among these structures, CLJ1001 [10, 11] at
z = 2. 51 with a total mass close to a mature cluster (M ∼ 0. 51 with a total mass close to a mature cluster (M ∼ 0. 5 − 1 × 1014 M⊙) [10],
could serve as a crucial bridge between more extended protoclusters and fully formed
galaxy clusters. The abundance of massive star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and X-ray
detections indicating the forming hot halo [10] make CLJ1001 an ideal laboratory to
investigate whether and how the dense environment affects massive galaxy formation. CLJ1001 harbours 14 SFGs with log(M⋆/M⊙) > 10. CLJ1001 harbours 14 SFGs with log(M⋆/M⊙) > 10. 5 within the central 340 kpc,
most of which are expected to transition into quiescent galaxies soon, as indicated
by their low gas fraction[12], compact sizes[13], and a top-heavy galaxy stellar mass
function[14]. 5 − 1 × 1014 M⊙) [10],
could serve as a crucial bridge between more extended protoclusters and fully formed
galaxy clusters. The abundance of massive star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and X-ray
detections indicating the forming hot halo [10] make CLJ1001 an ideal laboratory to
investigate whether and how the dense environment affects massive galaxy formation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Morphological Disturbance Analysis
The spatial distributions of molecular gas and stellar components for these member galaxies show that the majority (9/20, disturbed galaxies: D1 to D9) are relatively isolated galaxies with asymmetric CO(3-2) structures <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. Among these disturbed galaxies, D2, D4, D5, D6 and D7 exhibit extended gas tails in one direction <ref:2503. p. 2 02; shown in Extended
Data Figure 2), implying a less gravitationally bound gaseous component in disturbed
galaxies. Among these disturbed galaxies, D2, D4, D5, D6 and D7 exhibit extended
gas tails in one direction. This is consistent with typical ram-pressure stripping (RPS)
cases, and we classify them as the high-fidelity sample. D1, D3, D8 and D9 exhibit
more complex or shrunken gas distributions, which could undergo a mixture of multiple
processes and are classified as the candidate RPS sample. The 20% merger fraction
(4/20) is consistent with previous studies of z ≈ 2 clusters [15, 16], which is higher
than field galaxies. The degree of morphological disturbance is further quantified by two parameters:
the asymmetry of the CO(3-2) distribution relative to the centre of the stellar component (A) and the radius of the CO(3-2) disks (rgas); rgas is derived as the mean
3 Figure 3 shows the distribution of the 16 non-merging CO(3-2)-detected members
in the morphological parameter space. The visually classified disturbed galaxies exhibit
systematically larger A and/or rgas/reff,⋆ (reff,⋆ is the effective radius from ALMA
point spread function (PSF)-convolved F444W image), while the galaxies classified
as ‘normal’ (N1 to N7, CO moment-0 maps shown in Extended Data Figure 3) and
the field galaxies at similar redshift are more symmetric and compact. Excluding N4, which hosts a radio active galactic nucleus (AGN) [10],
D2 and D4 nevertheless lie towards the higher end of the asymmetry distribution
compared to most normal and field galaxies. This verifies that the two populations have distinct molecular gas distributions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Mechanism Discrimination
The analysis suggests that the observed disturbed gas morphology is likely caused by ram-pressure stripping (RPS) from galaxy-intracluster medium (ICM) interactions rather than tidal stripping from galaxy-galaxy interactions <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. From a morphological perspective, examining the concentration and asymmetry of the stellar light distributions, disturbed galaxies have similar stellar morphologies to normal cluster members except for D4 <ref:2503. p. 3 The major difference between the two is that tidal stripping would also strip and
influence the stellar components. From a morphological perspective, by examining the
concentration and asymmetry of the stellar light distributions, we find that the disturbed galaxies in CLJ1001 have similar stellar morphologies to those of the normal
cluster members and field galaxies at the same redshift, except for D4 (panel (a) in
Extended Data Figure 5). From a kinematic perspective, the extended gas
structures of some disturbed galaxies (such as D1, D4 and D5 in the lower panel of
Fig. 2) inherit the kinematics from the rotating disk of their hosts, indicating their origins in the host galaxies, as also seen in simulations [27, 28] and observations of RPS
events in the nearby Universe [29, 30]. unlikely to play a dominant role in disturbing their gas components. Similar to cluster
galaxies at lower redshifts [31–33], these galaxies are probably suffering from several
perturbing mechanisms, by which tidal interactions could aid RPS via loosening the
potential well.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Physical Consequences of Stripping
The study derives the truncation radius (Rtrunc) using the classical criterion for ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The calculation suggests that about 20–50% of the gas could be easily disturbed and stripped from their host galaxies <ref:2503. p. 4 Under the RPS scenario, we calculate the truncation radius of the CLJ1001 galaxies,
which is around 1–2 effective radii of their gas distribution (except for D3 and D9;
see Methods). Hence about 20–50% of the gas could be easily disturbed and stripped
from their host galaxies. From a kinematic perspective, the extended gas
structures of some disturbed galaxies (such as D1, D4 and D5 in the lower panel of
Fig. 2) inherit the kinematics from the rotating disk of their hosts, indicating their origins in the host galaxies, as also seen in simulations [27, 28] and observations of RPS
events in the nearby Universe [29, 30]. Molecular gas is the fuel for star formation, and in the right panel of Fig. 4,
we find that the disturbed galaxies exhibit higher star formation efficiencies
(SFE= SFR/Mgas; where SFR is the star formation rate and Mgas is the molecular gas
mass), about 0. This seems to be mainly driven
by their systematically lower gas surface densities, which are ∼0. 56 dex lower than
those of normal SFGs in CLJ1001.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Environmental Implications
The results reveal the occurrence of RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. This implies that a sufficiently dense ICM must have been in place, reflecting the highly stochastic assembly of clusters at early cosmic times <ref:2503. p. 6 While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place. This probably reflects the highly stochastic assembly
of clusters at early cosmic times, characterized by complex infall trajectories, the convergence and merging of filaments, and—critically—the early emergence of abundant,
clumpy ICM in cluster cores, as recently confirmed at z ≈ 4 [50]. CLJ1001 is at
the interface of several filaments on a large scale and the RPS candidates locate well
on these identified filamentary structures. Compared with galaxies in the CLJ1001
core, those disturbed galaxies along the outer filament spine are more massive than
the surrounding ones and inhabit a lower-density environment, where strong tidal
interactions are unlikely and RPS is expected to be more effective along filaments [62]. This
means that these galaxies fall nearly straight onto the cluster centre with high radial
velocities or have large peculiar velocity in the background or foreground of the cluster
centre, resulting in small redshift offsets; this large differential velocity is the dominant
factor of the strong RPS event, as also shown in simulations [43, 45]. Different from
the RPS candidates in the centre, those in the outer region are most likely to be going
through their first infall, as shown by their relatively high gas contents. The other disturbed galaxies are located in the outer cluster region with
R ≥ 1 R200c, but have low relative velocity differences from the cluster centre. This
means that these galaxies fall nearly straight onto the cluster centre with high radial
velocities or have large peculiar velocity in the background or foreground of the cluster
centre, resulting in small redshift offsets; this large differential velocity is the dominant
factor of the strong RPS event, as also shown in simulations [43, 45].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Methodology Summary
The methodology involved using CO(3-2) observations from ALMA combined with high-resolution imaging from JWST/NIRCam to study spatial distributions <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. Morphological parameters like asymmetry (A) and gas disk radius (rgas) were derived by reserving pixels with SNR ≥ √2 σ <ref:2503. p. 2 The 20% merger fraction
(4/20) is consistent with previous studies of z ≈ 2 clusters [15, 16], which is higher
than field galaxies. The degree of morphological disturbance is further quantified by two parameters:
the asymmetry of the CO(3-2) distribution relative to the centre of the stellar component (A) and the radius of the CO(3-2) disks (rgas); rgas is derived as the mean
3 We note that we
mean the convolved effective radius when comparing between the ALMA and JWST
observation. In Extended Data Figure 5, we also show the distribution of the stellar concentration and asymmetry of cluster members and some field galaxies in the COSMOS
field using unconvolved F444W imaging at 2 < z < 3 computed from GaLight [65]
(images for field galaxies from ref. Again, the disturbed galaxies exhibit larger Q within approximately the inner
1. 5 reff,⋆, than the normal galaxies, suggesting more stable gas disks that contradict
their star-forming states. Figure 3 shows the distribution of the 16 non-merging CO(3-2)-detected members
in the morphological parameter space. The visually classified disturbed galaxies exhibit
systematically larger A and/or rgas/reff,⋆ (reff,⋆ is the effective radius from ALMA
point spread function (PSF)-convolved F444W image), while the galaxies classified
as ‘normal’ (N1 to N7, CO moment-0 maps shown in Extended Data Figure 3) and
the field galaxies at similar redshift are more symmetric and compact. A recent study [34]
substantiated the different responses of young and older stellar populations to RPS. While the tidal stripping affects stars of all ages similarly, RPS would more efficiently
affect the newly formed stars by disturbing the gas from which they are born.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Availability
The ALMA data are available via the ALMA Archive under project numbers 2016.1.01155.S, 2017.1.099, 2021.1.039, 2024 and others <ref:2503. p. 0 13Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe
(WPI), The University of Tokyo, Chiba, Japan. 1
arXiv:2503. Space Telescope (JWST)/Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) from the COSMOS-Web
Survey (a JWST Cycle 1 Treasury programme), enable studies of the spatial distributions of both molecular gas and stars, which are among the most sensitive probes
of various environmental effects. Results
The CO(3-2) observations cover member galaxies in CLJ1001 both in the centre and
in the outskirts, up to twice the virial radius (throughout this work, we approximate
the virial radius as the radius within which the mean density is 200 times the critical
density of the Universe, denoted R200c), with a resolution of 1. More details are summarized in ref. Source detection and classification with ALMA data
We carried out observations of the CO(3-2) transitions (rest-frame frequency
345.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Key Findings Summary
The paper concludes that RPS should be a more plausible mechanism for the gas disturbance in most of the disturbed galaxies than tidal stripping or mergers <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. The truncation radius calculation indicates that about 20–50% of the gas could be influenced by the cluster environment <ref:2503. p. 4 , manuscript in preparation) in CLJ1001 also show that hot ICM is already present in this young cluster. Under the RPS scenario, we calculate the truncation radius of the CLJ1001 galaxies,
which is around 1–2 effective radii of their gas distribution (except for D3 and D9;
see Methods). This probably reflects the highly stochastic assembly
of clusters at early cosmic times, characterized by complex infall trajectories, the convergence and merging of filaments, and—critically—the early emergence of abundant,
clumpy ICM in cluster cores, as recently confirmed at z ≈ 4 [50]. The environmental
effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe that have relatively low halo
masses and are actively assembling demonstrate that the quenching of massive cluster
galaxies happens not only in mature clusters, but also in an earlier epoch. Different from
the RPS candidates in the centre, those in the outer region are most likely to be going
through their first infall, as shown by their relatively high gas contents. That is, the
RPS may have just started for many of them as we observed, and has not removed a
large portion of their cold gas. Kinematic and star-formation properties of disturbed galaxies
To explore the effects of gas stripping on the properties of these cluster galaxies, we
examine the stability in gas disks by deriving the resolved Toomre Q parameter from
CO(3-2) moment maps (see Methods). We show the cumulative distribution function
(CDF) of median Q within stellar effective radius in Fig.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Extended Data Table Summary
The Extended Data Table 1 provides the physical properties of the CO(3-2)-detected Cluster Members in CLJ1001, including log M⋆, log LCO(3-2), eff rgas, reff,⋆, and derived SFR and gas fractions <ref:2503.21724#pg9>. This table details the specific measurements for each galaxy ID (M1 to N7) <ref:2503. p. 6 ), and the
JWST COSMOS-Web survey [53]. More details are summarized in ref. The median stellar mass of the disturbed galaxies is smaller than that of the
normal galaxies and mergers (log(M⋆/M⊙) = 10. 55 versus 11.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on RPS Efficiency
The RPS criterion is applicable when the velocity vector of the galaxy is perpendicular to its gas disk, where RPS is maximized <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The larger the angle between the velocity vector and the disk normal, the more difficult it is for ram-pressure effect to occur <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. As such, it is likely that most visible ram-pressure effects occur in the maximum scenario <ref:2503. p. 1 The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. From a kinematic perspective, the extended gas
structures of some disturbed galaxies (such as D1, D4 and D5 in the lower panel of
Fig. 2) inherit the kinematics from the rotating disk of their hosts, indicating their origins in the host galaxies, as also seen in simulations [27, 28] and observations of RPS
events in the nearby Universe [29, 30]. From a kinematic perspective, the extended gas
structures of some disturbed galaxies (such as D1, D4 and D5 in the lower panel of
Fig. 2) inherit the kinematics from the rotating disk of their hosts, indicating their origins in the host galaxies, as also seen in simulations [27, 28] and observations of RPS
events in the nearby Universe [29, 30]. We calculate the asymmetry for each cluster
galaxy in the F150W-F277W colour diagram and find that the disturbed galaxies are
more asymmetric in the spatial colour distribution but have no obvious differences in
the stellar shape asymmetry compared with field galaxies at the same redshift with
controlled stellar masses (Extended Data Figure 8), which further supports the RPS
scenario. Therefore the gas disturbance in most of the disturbed galaxies is unlikely to
be caused by tidal stripping or mergers, and RPS should be a more plausible mechanism.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Insights on Assembly
The research demonstrates that environmental effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe, despite generally low halo masses, can lead to the quenching of massive cluster galaxies <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. This suggests that quenching happens earlier than previously thought, driven by complex infall trajectories and the early emergence of abundant ICM <ref:2503. p. 6 This probably reflects the highly stochastic assembly
of clusters at early cosmic times, characterized by complex infall trajectories, the convergence and merging of filaments, and—critically—the early emergence of abundant,
clumpy ICM in cluster cores, as recently confirmed at z ≈ 4 [50]. The environmental
effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe that have relatively low halo
masses and are actively assembling demonstrate that the quenching of massive cluster
galaxies happens not only in mature clusters, but also in an earlier epoch. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts. While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place. RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts. While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place. RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts. While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Summary of Results
The paper reports clear evidence from extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51, providing direct evidence of ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503. p. 1 These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. Main
Direct evidence of the impact of environmental effects on cluster galaxies during their
major formation epoch, z ≈ 2–4, has so far been lacking. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. Main
Direct evidence of the impact of environmental effects on cluster galaxies during their
major formation epoch, z ≈ 2–4, has so far been lacking. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. From a morphological perspective, by examining the
concentration and asymmetry of the stellar light distributions, we find that the disturbed galaxies in CLJ1001 have similar stellar morphologies to those of the normal
cluster members and field galaxies at the same redshift, except for D4 (panel (a) in
Extended Data Figure 5). This provides evidence for the absence of strong tidal interactions and for the necessity of RPS. Under the RPS scenario, we calculate the truncation radius of the CLJ1001 galaxies,
which is around 1–2 effective radii of their gas distribution (except for D3 and D9;
see Methods). Hence about 20–50% of the gas could be easily disturbed and stripped
from their host galaxies.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Extended Data Figure Analysis
Extended Data Figure 3 shows the distribution of CO(3-2) line emission for normal cluster galaxies, where white contours show the distribution levels <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. Extended Data Figure 4 illustrates the significance of detections of extended structures in disturbed galaxies <ref:2503. p. 3 2
′′ (Methods), the asymmetric structures cannot be explained solely by positional uncertainties, and external
forces competing with the galaxy’s anchoring pressure should come into effect. In
Extended Data Figure 4, we also show the significance of the extent structures in
some disturbed galaxies. The major difference between the two is that tidal stripping would also strip and
influence the stellar components. From a morphological perspective, by examining the
concentration and asymmetry of the stellar light distributions, we find that the disturbed galaxies in CLJ1001 have similar stellar morphologies to those of the normal
cluster members and field galaxies at the same redshift, except for D4 (panel (a) in
Extended Data Figure 5). 1
′′, we performed the same morphological diagnostics used for the
cluster galaxies. The result is shown in Fig. Figure 3 shows the distribution of the 16 non-merging CO(3-2)-detected members
in the morphological parameter space. The visually classified disturbed galaxies exhibit
systematically larger A and/or rgas/reff,⋆ (reff,⋆ is the effective radius from ALMA
point spread function (PSF)-convolved F444W image), while the galaxies classified
as ‘normal’ (N1 to N7, CO moment-0 maps shown in Extended Data Figure 3) and
the field galaxies at similar redshift are more symmetric and compact. These galaxies may directly fall towards the centre of CLJ1001, following the filament’s trajectory at high differential velocity, and potentially interact
with the dense clumps within the filaments [42], thereby undergoing more effective
RPS. To gain further insights into the nature of the disturbed galaxies, we examine their
distribution in the phase-space diagram in the right panel of Fig.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Conclusion on Quenching
The environmental effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe demonstrate that quenching of massive cluster galaxies happens not only in mature clusters but also in an earlier epoch <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The findings emphasize that ram-pressure stripping is a critical, often-overlooked quenching pathway at high redshifts <ref:2503. p. 1 The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These
very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role
of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked
quenching pathway. Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a
young cluster at z = 2. 51
Ke Xu •1,2, Tao Wang•1,2*, Emanuele Daddi•3
, David Elbaz•3
,
Hanwen Sun•1,2, Longyue Chen•1,2, Qiaoyang Hao•1,2
,
Raphael Gobat•4
, Anita Zanella•5
, Daizhong Liu•6,7
,
Mengyuan Xiao•8
, Renyue Cen•9
, Tadayuki Kodama•10
,
Kotaro Kohno•11,12, Tiancheng Yang•1,2, Can Xu•1,2,13
,
Zhi-Yu Zhang•1,2, Luwenjia Zhou•1,2, Francesco Valentino•14,15
1School of Astronomy and Space Science, Nanjing University, Nanjing,
China. Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a
young cluster at z = 2. 51
Ke Xu •1,2, Tao Wang•1,2*, Emanuele Daddi•3
, David Elbaz•3
,
Hanwen Sun•1,2, Longyue Chen•1,2, Qiaoyang Hao•1,2
,
Raphael Gobat•4
, Anita Zanella•5
, Daizhong Liu•6,7
,
Mengyuan Xiao•8
, Renyue Cen•9
, Tadayuki Kodama•10
,
Kotaro Kohno•11,12, Tiancheng Yang•1,2, Can Xu•1,2,13
,
Zhi-Yu Zhang•1,2, Luwenjia Zhou•1,2, Francesco Valentino•14,15
1School of Astronomy and Space Science, Nanjing University, Nanjing,
China. 13Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe
(WPI), The University of Tokyo, Chiba, Japan. 1
arXiv:2503. We calculate the asymmetry for each cluster
galaxy in the F150W-F277W colour diagram and find that the disturbed galaxies are
more asymmetric in the spatial colour distribution but have no obvious differences in
the stellar shape asymmetry compared with field galaxies at the same redshift with
controlled stellar masses (Extended Data Figure 8), which further supports the RPS
scenario. Therefore the gas disturbance in most of the disturbed galaxies is unlikely to
be caused by tidal stripping or mergers, and RPS should be a more plausible mechanism. RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts. While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place. RPS events in clusters at the highest redshifts. While tidal interactions are expected
to be common in these high-z, compact (proto-)cluster cores, RPS can already operate
efficiently only 3 billion years after the Big Bang, implying that a sufficiently dense
ICM must have been in place. This probably reflects the highly stochastic assembly
of clusters at early cosmic times, characterized by complex infall trajectories, the convergence and merging of filaments, and—critically—the early emergence of abundant,
clumpy ICM in cluster cores, as recently confirmed at z ≈ 4 [50]. The environmental
effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe that have relatively low halo
masses and are actively assembling demonstrate that the quenching of massive cluster
galaxies happens not only in mature clusters, but also in an earlier epoch.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Summary Statement
The paper reports clear evidence from extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51, providing direct evidence of ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. These single-tailed gas distributions extend notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in isolated galaxies, highlighting ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503. p. 1 Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a
forming cluster at z = 2. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend
notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are
very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. CLJ1001 harbours 14 SFGs with log(M⋆/M⊙) > 10. 5 within the central 340 kpc,
most of which are expected to transition into quiescent galaxies soon, as indicated
by their low gas fraction[12], compact sizes[13], and a top-heavy galaxy stellar mass
function[14]. CLJ1001 harbours 14 SFGs with log(M⋆/M⊙) > 10. 5 within the central 340 kpc,
most of which are expected to transition into quiescent galaxies soon, as indicated
by their low gas fraction[12], compact sizes[13], and a top-heavy galaxy stellar mass
function[14].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The RPS criterion is applicable when the velocity vector of the galaxy is perpendicular to its gas disk, where RPS is maximized <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The larger the angle between the velocity vector and the disk normal, the more difficult it is for ram-pressure effect to occur <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. As such, it is likely that most visible ram-pressure effects occur in the maximum scenario <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The rotational signature of dislodged gas in galaxies D1, D4 and D5 shows signatures conformal to the host galaxy, which is consistent with RPS events <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The study ultimately supports the hypothesis that RPS is a more plausible mechanism for gas disturbance than tidal stripping or mergers <ref:2503. p. 4 We calculate the asymmetry for each cluster
galaxy in the F150W-F277W colour diagram and find that the disturbed galaxies are
more asymmetric in the spatial colour distribution but have no obvious differences in
the stellar shape asymmetry compared with field galaxies at the same redshift with
controlled stellar masses (Extended Data Figure 8), which further supports the RPS
scenario. Therefore the gas disturbance in most of the disturbed galaxies is unlikely to
be caused by tidal stripping or mergers, and RPS should be a more plausible mechanism. This probably reflects the highly stochastic assembly
of clusters at early cosmic times, characterized by complex infall trajectories, the convergence and merging of filaments, and—critically—the early emergence of abundant,
clumpy ICM in cluster cores, as recently confirmed at z ≈ 4 [50]. The environmental
effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe that have relatively low halo
masses and are actively assembling demonstrate that the quenching of massive cluster
galaxies happens not only in mature clusters, but also in an earlier epoch.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51 <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. These single-tailed gas distributions, which extend notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. These very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked quenching pathway <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is that CLJ1001 harbours 14 SFGs with log(M⋆/M⊙) > 10.5 within the central 340 kpc, most of which are expected to transition into quiescent galaxies soon <ref:2503.21724#pg3>.
The environmental effects in CLJ1001-like structures in the early Universe demonstrate that quenching of massive cluster galaxies happens not only in mature clusters but also in an earlier epoch <ref:2503.21724#pg3>. The findings emphasize that ram-pressure stripping is a critical, often-overlooked quenching pathway at high redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. The study confirms the role of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts <ref:2503.21724#pg2>. Ram-pressure stripping caught in action in a young cluster at z = 2.51 is the pr…
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can identify ram-pressure stripping events by analyzing CO(3-2) moment-0 maps and JWST/NIRCam images, as these provide
clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51.
-
Improved AI system can classify galaxy morphology using derived morphological parameters such as asymmetry (A) and gas disk radius (rgas), which are used to
classify galaxies on the basis of their gas morphologies,
distinguishing betweendisturbed
andnormal
galaxies based on Figure 3. -
Improved AI system can determine the most plausible quenching mechanism by comparing stellar morphology with gas morphology, as it is found that
the disturbed galaxies in CLJ1001 have similar stellar morphologies to those of the normal cluster members and field galaxies at the same redshift, except for D4,
providingevidence for the absence of strong tidal interactions and for the necessity of RPS.
-
Improved AI system can predict gas truncation radius by applying a classical criterion derived from ram pressure stripping, using Equation 3, which states that
about 20–50% of the gas could be easily disturbed and stripped from their host galaxies
based on ICM models. -
Improved AI system can assess the stability of gas disks by calculating the Toomre Q parameter, finding that
the disturbed galaxies have larger Q than the normal galaxies, except for N4,
suggestingmore stable gas disks that contradict their star-forming states.
Abstract
Galaxy clusters in the local Universe are dominated by massive quiescent galaxies with old ages, formed at high redshifts. Whether their quenching is driven by internal processes or environmental effects is a matter of debate that has been challenging to resolve due to the lack of observations during their peak formation epoch. Here we report clear evidence from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array of extended and elongated gas tails in five galaxies in a forming cluster at z = 2.51. The single-tailed gas distributions, which extend notably beyond the stellar emission probed by JWST in galaxies that are relatively isolated and lack signatures of mergers or interactions (features that are very uncommon in the field), provide evidence of ram-pressure stripping. These very distant confirmed cases of ram-pressure stripping highlight the critical role of environmental effects in gas removal at high redshifts, an often-overlooked quenching pathway.
Sources
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation