Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with 3D Modelling
summary
The gist
We measure galaxy structural properties and colour gradients using HST images to trace the evolution of galaxy components.
In short
The study used joint 3D modeling of galaxy structures across multiple HST bands to measure bulge and disk properties. Findings show that galaxies are largely disk-dominated, characterized by a disk-like bulge with a Sérsic index of n=1.0 and a size ratio Re/hd of 0.15, suggesting pseudo-bulges formed through secular evolution rather than classical bulges.
Key concepts
- Sérsic Index (n)
- This parameter describes the shape or profile of a galaxy's light distribution, specifically how steeply the light falls off from the center. A low value like n=1.0 indicates a disk-like structure where the surface brightness decreases exponentially outwards, rather than a steep de Vaucouleurs profile typical of classical bulges.
- Bulge-to-Disk Size Ratio (Re/hd)
- This ratio compares the effective radius of the bulge (Re) to the scale length of the disk (hd). The derived value of 0.15 suggests that for these galaxies, the bulge is relatively small compared to its disk, which is a key indicator supporting models where bulges are formed through slow, secular processes like internal instabilities.
- Secular Evolution
- This refers to slow internal evolutionary processes within a galaxy that gradually change its structure over long timescales. The paper suggests that the observed pseudo-bulges are the result of these processes, such as bar-driven gas flows and disc instabilities, rather than rapid mergers or other violent events.
- Dust Extinction Modeling
- The authors modeled how dust in galaxies obscures light differently based on the galaxy's viewing angle (inclination), wavelength, and dust density. By using synthetic models like P11, they could correct the observed structural parameters to reveal the intrinsic properties of the galaxy structure.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with 3D Modelling · Paper Radio
- Bulge Formation via Mergers in Cosmological Simulations
- Shear measurement bias I: dependencies on methods, simulation parameters and measured parameters
- Wide-Field InfrarRed Survey Telescope-Astrophysics Focused Telescope Assets WFIRST-AFTA 2015 Report
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: The Spatial Distribution of Star Formation and its Dependence on Mass, Structure and Environment
- Deep learning for galaxy surface brightness profile fitting
The paper
Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with 3D Modelling · Read on arXiv
Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh · Department of Physics, University of Oxford
We measure galaxy structural properties and colour gradients using HST images to trace the evolution of galaxy components. We develop and apply a physically motivated 3D bulge+disk modelling framework, jointly fitting the components in 2505 galaxies in GOODS-South across seven bands (bvizYJH) to I AB=25.5, accounting for different component ellipticities and inclination-dependent dust extinction. Extinction strongly affects structural parameters and colour gradients in about 26% of the sample - primarily edge-on galaxies with central obscuration (B-band face-on optical depth τ 4) that reveal clear bulge components in the near-infrared. Despite irregular morphologies, the model captures observed colour gradients well. Bulges at z about 1 differ markedly from z about 0, with typical Sérsic index n about 1.0 and bulge-to-disc size ratio R e/h d about 0.15, suggesting most galaxies host pseudo-bulges formed via secular evolution. Galaxy ellipticity correlates strongly with disk scale-length. We trace bulge and disk evolution from z about 0 to z about 2.5: bulges are redder than disks (observed-frame) at z < 1.4, but colours converge at higher redshifts and fainter magnitudes. Redder galaxies show redder cores relative to their outskirts, and brighter galaxies have redder cores. These results provide new measurements of bulge and disk structural properties at z about 1 and observational constraints on their evolution, while also providing empirically motivated input distributions for assessing colour gradient systematics in weak lensing surveys.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with 3D Modelling".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. We measure galaxy structural properties and colour gradients using HST images to trace the evolution of galaxy components.
Vera: The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: Bulges at z ∼ 1 differ markedly from z ∼ 0, with typical S´ersic index n ∼ 1.0 and bulge-to-disc size ratio Re/hd ∼ 0.15, suggesting most galaxies host pseudo-bulges formed via secular evolution.
Jocelyn: Modeling Methodology The authors jointly fit 3D bulge and disk models to 2505 galaxies in GOODS-South across seven bands (bvizYJH) to IAB = 25.5, accounting for different component ellipticities and inclination-dependent dust extinction.
Vera: They define 3D analytical models for bulge and disk surface brightness using Monte Carlo points drawn from an analytic function that describes the surface brightness distribution for each component.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper by Welikala et al., titled "Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with three dee Modelling" <ref:2510.11156#pg1,Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations>. It’s pretty straightforward work—they use those deep Hubble Space Telescope images to study how galaxy structure, specifically bulges and disks, changes over time.
Jocelyn: Yeah. What’s interesting is that they aren't just looking at a snapshot; they are tracing the evolution of these components by fitting three dee models across seven different color bands <ref:2510.11156#pg1>. It sounds like they want to see how galaxies have grown structurally from earlier times to today.
Subrahmanyan: Exactly. The implication here is that we’re moving past simple measurements and trying to build a physical picture of galaxy growth, which is crucial for understanding how structure forms in the universe on large scales.
Vera: Right. So the core idea they are pushing is that they are jointly fitting three dee bulge and disk models to about two thousand five hundred galaxies in GOODS-South, using data from seven different filters, down to an IAB magnitude of twenty-five point five <ref:2510.11156#pg1,3D bulge and disk models to>. They specifically accounted for different component ellipticities and inclination dependent dust extinction.
Jocelyn: That sounds complicated but necessary because we know that the dust and how a galaxy is tilted really mess up the measurements if you don't account for them properly. So they are modeling those effects directly into their fitting process rather than just trying to correct them after the fact.
Subrahmanyan: That’s key. When you ignore those inclination dependent extinction effects, you bias your structural parameters, which means your understanding of the galaxy’s true shape and evolution becomes skewed. The paper suggests that this approach gives a much more accurate constraint on what we are actually measuring.
Vera: They define these three dee analytical models using Monte Carlo points drawn from an analytic function that describes the surface brightness distribution for each component <ref:2510.11156#pg1>. For the disk, they assume it has cylindrical geometry, with its surface brightness profile described by I of r equals I naught e minus r over h d.
Jocelyn: And for the bulge, they model it as a prolate spheroid, assuming an intrinsic shape of a spheroid with zero ellipticity, which is then flattened to make it prolate. It’s like taking a sphere and stretching it along one axis to get that football-like shape.
Subrahmanyan: That setup is important because they are testing different shapes. They also test different values for the Sersic index, n, from zero point five up to four in steps of zero point five when generating the bulge models for each value of n > zero point five <ref:2510.11156#pg3,for each value of n>.
Title and authors: Vera: And they generate these bulge models by randomly drawing the inclination angle theta b for each radial point, just like they did for the disk’s inclination angle theta d. Then they derive the x i and y i coordinates of each point from the spherical coordinates, r, and angle theta.
Jocelyn: That means for every single galaxy in their sample, they are essentially creating many possible 2D projections based on those three dee shapes to see which projection best matches what we actually see in the HST images <ref:2510.11156#pg1>. That’s a lot of computational work.
Subrahmanyan: And they do this across all those n values, which is why the paper mentions generating bulge models for each value of n going from zero point five to four in steps of zero point five. They are testing if different underlying shapes fit the data better.
Vera: Now let’s talk about how they handle the tricky part—the dust. They model extinction effects as functions of inclination angle, wavelength, and dust opacity using synthetic images called P11 models.
Jocelyn: The weight they calculate per Monte Carlo point i is the ratio of the pixel value that particle falls into in the dusty P11 map to the corresponding pixel value in the dust free P11 map. That’s a way to quantify how much light is being suppressed by dust at a specific point.
Subrahmanyan: That weighting scheme is how they determine if a dusty model with an extra degree of freedom tau is favored over a dustless one for Dusty galaxies using an F test. It's like they are statistically deciding if the extra complexity of modeling dust actually helps explain the data or just makes things unnecessarily complicated.
Vera: Structurally, their single Sersic fitting of three dee models suggests a disk like nature for the HST population with n equals one point zero <ref:2510.11156#pg1>. With two component fitting, the sample is largely disk dominated and is best characterized by n equals one point zero for the bulge and a bulge effective radius to disk scale length ratio of zero point one five.
Jocelyn: That ratio of zero point one five, Re over h d, that’s a specific way they are characterizing how big the bulge is compared to how long the disk is <ref:2510.11156#pg1>. It sounds like most galaxies fit this pattern.
Subrahmanyan: That finding about n equals one point zero for the bulge and that size ratio of zero point one five suggests that most galaxies host pseudo bulges formed via secular evolution, which aligns well with what we expect from disc instabilities and gas flows in the universe.
Title and authors: Vera: They find the median h d is zero point two two arcseconds plus or minus zero point zero zero four arcseconds for the full sample when looking at a magnitude limit of IAB less than twenty-five point five <ref:2510.11156#pg1>.
Jocelyn: That median value gives us a concrete number to work with for how long those disks are, which is helpful for our time-domain studies too. But what about the color information they’re getting?
Subrahmanyan: They find that the median colour gradient is consistent with zero for all other redshift bins, but there's a strong correlation with the overall V minus I colour of the galaxy. Redder galaxies show redder cores, and bluer galaxies have close to zero median colour gradients.
Vera: So if you look at the color gradient, redder galaxies have more positive colour gradients, meaning their core is redder than their outskirts. The model captures this bulk variation in the colour gradients well.
Jocelyn: That correlation with the overall V minus I color seems like a strong link between structure and stellar populations. It tells us that the bulge and disk aren't just structural things; they are tied to how old or metal-rich the stars are in those regions.
Subrahmanyan: This connects back to galaxy formation scenarios because these findings suggest that central regions of HST galaxies share similar structural properties to Freeman type one late-type spiral galaxies and local dwarf galaxies.
Vera: And the distribution of n from the two component fitting to the full sample is consistent with pseudo bulges whose profiles resemble exponential or near exponential discs rather than de Vaucouleurs profiles, which are characteristic of classical bulges with n equals four point zero.
Jocelyn: So they are strongly arguing against these classical bulge shapes dominating what we see in this HST population. This points us toward the secular evolution picture where slow internal processes shape the galaxy over time.
Subrahmanyan: That is exactly what the standard picture invokes, through things like bar-driven gas flows, disc instabilities, and stellar migration. The implication is that the building blocks of these galaxies are following a path dictated by internal physics rather than just big mergers at all times.
Vera: Because they did this joint fitting across seven bands to IAB point five, it gives them much stronger constraints on galaxy structural parameters than fitting to just one band alone.
Jocelyn: And they also derived new weak lensing priors from this work, finding that the median h d is zero point two two arcseconds to a depth of IAB equals twenty-five point five <ref:2510.11156#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: Those measurements are important because they help reconstruct accurate distributions of bulges and discs that are essential for cosmic shear calibration, which is vital for measuring dark energy. They also observed a weak correlation between galaxy ellipticity and redshift, and a strong correlation between galaxy ellipticity and disk scale length.
Title and authors: Vera: And the median colour gradient is consistent with zero for all other redshift bins when looking at those measurements.
Jocelyn: It’s interesting that they found this correlation with galaxy ellipticity—the shape of the galaxy—and the disk scale length. It suggests a physical link between how long a disk is and how elongated it is, which isn't immediately obvious from just looking at structure.
Subrahmanyan: That structural relationship, combined with the color gradient analysis, means that we need to be careful when we use these HST measurements for things like ultra-precise dark energy measurements.
Vera: And they pointed out a specific issue: a colour or environment dependent correction to the colour gradient bias may therefore be needed for ultra-precise dark energy measurements.
Jocelyn: So the paper is laying out the necessary groundwork for future work that needs to account for these subtle systematic effects when we try to use galaxy structure data in cosmology.
Subrahmanyan: Exactly. The effect of those outliers on shear bias may need to be investigated via simulations and emulations, which is a necessary next step in connecting this structural detail to the broader cosmological puzzle.
Vera: So, to wrap up this whole piece, the main thing is that by doing this three dee modeling with extinction accounted for, they are providing a robust characterization of these galaxies that points toward pseudo-bulges and secular evolution <ref:2510.11156#pg1>.
Jocelyn: It’s a lot of detail on how things are modeled—the P11 models, the Monte Carlo sampling—but the result is clear: for this HST sample, we see a disk dominated structure with n equals one point zero and Re over h d equals zero point one five.
Subrahmanyan: And that structural finding, combined with the color gradient analysis and the weak lensing priors derived from this work, tells us that these central regions are structurally very similar to local dwarf galaxies.
Vera: So they are using these deep HST images to look at how structure evolves over cosmic time, and what they found is a disk-like nature for most of the sample with n equals one point zero.
Jocelyn: It’s about using this detailed modeling to give us better priors for weak lensing, which is essential for calibrating dark energy measurements across different redshifts.
Subrahmanyan: We are looking at the paper "Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with three dee Modelling" <ref:2510.11156#pg1,Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations>. It’s a solid piece of work that uses complex three dee modeling to provide a robust characterization of galaxy evolution through secular processes <ref:2510.11156#pg1>.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, this paper is taking all that complex three dee modeling and fitting seven different color bands to about two thousand five hundred galaxies in GOODS-South, and what they found is that the HST population looks mostly disk-like structurally.
Jocelyn: Yeah, so they used these Monte Carlo points to build their models for the bulge and the disk separately, and when you combine those fits with accounting for inclination dependent dust extinction, it shows that most galaxies have a bulge structure characterized by an n value of one point zero.
Subrahmanyan: That n equals one point zero is key here because it means they aren't seeing those big de Vaucouleurs profiles that we usually associate with classical bulges, which have an n value of four point zero.
Vera: Right. And when they use the two component fitting method, which is more detailed, the sample ends up being largely disk-dominated and fits best with a bulge effective radius to disk scale length ratio of zero point one five.
Jocelyn: So that zero point one five ratio tells us how big that bulge is compared to how long the disk stretches out. It's a specific structural fingerprint for this population.
Subrahmanyan: And they connect that back to galaxy formation, suggesting these are pseudo bulges, which means they form through secular evolution—slow internal processes like bar-driven gas flows and disc instabilities, not just big mergers.
Vera: They also looked at the color gradients, and they found that the strongest correlation is with the overall V minus I color of the galaxy itself. Redder galaxies have more positive colour gradients, meaning their core is redder than their outskirts.
Jocelyn: That tells us that structural properties like bulge size are tied to how old or metal-rich the stars are in those central regions. It’s not just a shape thing; it's a stellar population thing too.
Subrahmanyan: And this connects to what we see in local dwarf galaxies, suggesting they share similar structures, which supports the secular evolution idea for these early universe systems.
Vera: The paper also points out that while most of the sample can be modeled without dust correction, about eighteen percent of them are edge-on with significant central obscuration. They found a dust opacity value tau equal to four point zero for that obscuration.
Jocelyn: That tau value is what they use to quantify how much light is being blocked in those dusty systems, which is essential for getting the intrinsic structural parameters right.
Subrahmanyan: This whole analysis provides new weak lensing priors, specifically finding a median disk scale length of zero point two two arcseconds when looking at that magnitude limit of IAB less than twenty five point five.
Vera: Those measurements are crucial because they help us reconstruct accurate maps of bulges and disks, which we need for calibrating cosmic shear measurements in future dark energy studies.
Jocelyn: They also found some correlations between galaxy ellipticity—the shape of the galaxy—and its disk scale length, which is a physical link between how long a disk is and how elongated it is.
Subrahmanyan: That structural relationship combined with the color gradient analysis means we need to be careful with any correction we apply when using these HST measurements for ultra-precise dark energy measurements.
Vera: The authors suggest that they might need a correction to the colour gradient bias that depends on whether you are looking at a galaxy's environment or its color itself.
Jocelyn: So, the paper is laying out the necessary groundwork for future work that needs to account for these subtle systematic effects when we try to use galaxy structure data in cosmology.
Subrahmanyan: The effect of those outliers on shear bias might need to be investigated through simulations and emulations, which is a necessary next step in connecting this structural detail to the broader cosmological puzzle.
The paper's improvements: Vera: So, we've seen how they used those three dee models to get those structural parameters like the n value of one point zero and that bulge to disk ratio of zero point one five, and now they're talking about how this work can be improved for future studies.
Jocelyn: Yeah, so the authors are suggesting that incorporating inclination dependent ellipticities into their three dee models would give us more precise galaxy size priors when we use Bayesian shape estimation and calibration simulations.
Subrahmanyan: That makes sense. If you get better priors on the galaxy size, you get a tighter constraint on how we model structure in cosmic shear surveys, which is vital for calibrating dark energy measurements.
Vera: And they also mention using measured colour gradient distributions from those HST data to forward model systematic shear bias in Euclid, which would help us quantify how that bias works.
Jocelyn: That's interesting because it means we can use these HST colour gradients to predict how much error we might get when we try to measure the weak lensing signal in the Euclid survey.
Subrahmanyan: It connects this structural work directly to a major upcoming cosmological experiment, so if they can model that bias, it helps us plan better observations for dark energy density constraints.
Vera: They also suggest improving how dust attenuation effects are modeled by explicitly using synthetic images like P11 models to account for inclination angle and wavelength.
Jocelyn: So instead of just applying a simple correction, they want to model the dust as a function of those physical parameters, which should allow us to retrieve the intrinsic structural parameters without that observational bias.
Subrahmanyan: If you can get those intrinsic parameters clean, it enables more robust component stellar evolution modeling through appropriate dust opacity corrections for future work.
Vera: This whole discussion around improving the data handling methods shows how important these detailed physical models are for getting reliable results from deep sky observations.
Conclusion: Vera: So, to wrap up this paper on "Measuring the Evolution of Bulge, Disk and Colour Gradients in HST Observations of Galaxies with three dee Modelling," we've seen how they used these detailed three dee models to confirm that most galaxies have a disk-like structure with an n value of one point zero.
Jocelyn: Right. And they showed that this structural characterization, combined with color gradients, links the central regions of these galaxies to Freeman type one late-type spirals and local dwarf galaxies.
Subrahmanyan: That means we're seeing a consistent picture across cosmic time for how structures build up from slow, internal processes rather than just sudden mergers.
Vera: The implication is that this detailed modeling gives us much better structural priors for weak lensing, which is essential when we try to calibrate dark energy measurements across different redshifts.
Jocelyn: They also highlighted the need for careful correction of colour gradient bias depending on where you are looking, which means future cosmological observations have to account for those environmental differences.
Subrahmanyan: And the effect of those outliers on shear bias needs investigation through simulations, so this work sets up a clear path for how we can use these structural details in cosmology.
Vera: Overall, the study using three dee modeling and extinction correction gives us a robust characterization of galaxy evolution based on what we observe with HST data.
Jocelyn: It's pretty cool how much detail you can get out of those deep images when you put that kind of physical modeling into it.
Subrahmanyan: This paper really solidifies the idea that secular evolution is a major driver in shaping galaxy morphology over time, which is what we need to test against other cosmological observations.
More episodes
- 2607.08835-Hybrid Simulations of Proton Acceleration at Oblique High- beta Shocks
- 2606.29552-Improving the Precision of Line-by-Line Radial Velocities: A Data-Driven Iterative Algorithm for Spectral Line Selection
- 2609.05312-Evidence for LP 890-9d via Transit Timing Variations
- 2609.10319-Extending the Little Red Dot population at intermediate redshift with VIPERS
- 2611.14233-Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- 2610.21722-Hydrostatic Equilibrium Estimate of the Fuzzy Dark Matter Mass from Dwarf Spheroidals: Method and Systematics
- 2610.40550-An Empirically Calibrated [C II] Luminosity-Halo Mass Relation for Line Intensity Mapping
- 2607.27328-PANTERA. I. Hunting for the Most Metal-Rich Stars in the Solar Neighborhood with High-Resolution Spectroscopy
- 2607.09850-Low-hard to high-soft spectral state transitions in the faintest early-X-ray-detected optical tidal disruption event TDE 2025aarm
- 2611.14028-Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation from PeV Gamma Rays of Cygnus X-3 Observed by LHAASO