An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. I. Formulation

summary

The gist

An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets develops a new model to quantify the atmospheric thermal torque and its dependence on tidal frequency across different planetary…

In short

This analytical model quantifies how atmospheric thermal tides affect a rocky planet's rotation over time. It develops a new framework to understand the thermal torque and its dependence on tidal frequency across different atmospheres, providing a foundation for studying long-term planetary rotational evolution.

Key concepts

Atmospheric Thermal Torque
This is the twisting force exerted by heat variations in the atmosphere due to tidal forcing. The model calculates this torque and shows how it changes depending on how fast the tides are occurring, which is crucial for understanding how a planet's rotation evolves.
Isothermal Profile
This describes an atmospheric temperature profile where the temperature is uniform throughout the entire air column. It represents a simplified case where heat distribution is perfectly even, serving as one of the two main types of profiles used to test the model.
Forced Lamb Waves
These are waves that propagate horizontally across a planet's atmosphere when subjected to tidal forcing. The model uses these waves to describe the atmospheric response, and resonance occurs when the tidal frequency matches the natural frequency of these specific wave modes.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. I. Formulation · Read on arXiv

Pierre Auclair-Desrotour, Mohammad Farhat, Gwenaël Boué, Jacques Laskar

LTE, Observatoire de Paris · Department of Astronomy, University of California, Berkeley · Department of Earth and Planetary Science, University of California, Berkeley

Atmospheric thermal tides arise from the diurnal contrast in stellar irradiation. They exert a significant influence on the long-term rotational evolution of rocky planets because they can accelerate the planetary spin, thereby counteracting the decelerating effect of classical gravitational tides. Consequently, equilibrium tide-locked states may emerge, as exemplified by Venus and hypothesised for Precambrian Earth. Quantifying the atmospheric thermal torque and elucidating its dependence on tidal frequency -- both in the low- and high-frequency regimes -- is therefore essential. In particular, we focus here on the resonance that affected early Earth, which is associated with a forced Lamb wave. Within the framework of linear theory, we develop a new analytical model of the atmospheric response to both gravitational an thermal tidal forcings for two representative vertical temperature profiles that bracket the atmospheres of rocky planets: (i) an isothermal profile (uniform temperature) and (ii) an isentropic profile (uniform potential temperature). Dissipative processes are incorporated via Newtonian cooling. We demonstrate that the isothermal and isentropic cases are governed by the same general closed-form solution, and we derive explicit expressions for the three-dimensional tidal fields (pressure, temperature, density and wind velocities) throughout the spherical atmospheric shell. These results constitute the foundation for two forthcoming papers, in which analytical formulae for the thermotidal torque will be presented and compared with numerical solutions obtained from General Circulation Models (GCMs).

DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202558507

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. I. Formulation".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets develops a new model to quantify the atmospheric thermal torque and its dependence on tidal frequency across different planetary atmospheres because it provides a foundation for understanding how thermal tides influence the long-term rotational evolution of rocky planets.

Vera: Formulation and Methodology The study develops a new analytical model of the atmospheric response to both gravitational and thermal tidal forcings for two representative vertical temperature profiles: an isothermal profile (uniform temperature) and an isentropic profile (uniform potential temperature).

Jocelyn: Dissipative processes are incorporated via Newtonian cooling.

Vera: The approach bridges the gap between analytical and numerical solutions by showing quantitatively how they may converge or diverge from each other.

Paper summary: Vera: So, this paper, "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. I. Formulation," it's setting up a new way to look at how atmospheric thermal tides affect the long-term spin of a rocky planet.

Jocelyn: It seems like the core idea is developing a new analytical model to figure out the atmospheric thermal torque and how that torque changes with different tidal frequencies across different planetary atmospheres.

Subrahmanyan: So, it's building a foundation for understanding how these thermal tides influence the long-term rotational evolution of rocky planets. That's significant because we're trying to understand things like why some planets lock into certain spin states while others don't <ref:2512.10578#pg1>.

Vera: Right, it claims this framework can provide a way to quantify the atmospheric response to both gravitational and thermal tidal forcings for two different temperature profiles: an isothermal one and an isentropic one.

Jocelyn: And they’re incorporating dissipative processes through Newtonian cooling in their approach. It's trying to bridge the gap between purely analytical solutions and numerical ones by showing exactly where they might match up or where they diverge <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: That's interesting because it’s generic enough to apply to both Earth and those extrasolar rocky planets we’re studying, which is a big plus for theoretical work <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: The paper analyzes the atmospheric structure by showing that the isothermal and isentropic cases actually follow the same general closed-form solution when you look at it.

Jocelyn: They frame this by looking at two idealized vertical profiles: one where there’s no mean buoyancy, called strictly isentropic, and one where the temperature is uniform everywhere in an isothermal case <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: They introduce a bulk temperature as a way to measure the total thermal energy content of the atmosphere per unit mass <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: Then they characterize the tidal response by expressing it as a series of forced Lamb waves, which are these horizontally propagating acoustic waves that have planetary-scale wavelengths.

Jocelyn: Resonance happens when the tidal frequency equals the eigenfrequency of one of those tidal modes, and they express this resonance frequency using sigma L n equals one over R d g H lambda m n divided by one minus gamma <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: That formula includes the sign of the eigenvalue, which is important for knowing whether the resonance is stable or not, I suppose <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: They point out their model limitations mostly stem from assuming things like ignoring large-scale circulation and horizontal variations in the atmospheric structure when solving the tidal equations analytically.

Jocelyn: They also use Newtonian cooling for dissipation, which means it doesn't account for more complex things like surface friction or internal radiative transfer <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: But they state that this model is a versatile tool to probe the parameter space and complements the numerical solutions that come from general circulation models, GCMs <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: The key finding they highlight is that atmospheric thermal tides can actually drive planet-star systems away from classical states of equilibrium, especially synchronisation.

Jocelyn: And they show that the atmospheric torque is smaller than what ocean tides cause, but it's still about the same magnitude as the torque you see exerted on the Earth’s solid regions <ref:2512.10578#pg2>.

Subrahmanyan: That's a big thing because if we can get this right, it means atmospheric effects matter significantly in how these planets evolve over long timescales <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: They also show that for Venus, its longitude of declination could have been stalled for hundreds of millions of years because ocean and thermotidal torques were compensating each other <ref:2512.10578#pg2>.

Jocelyn: The resonance frequencies they recover are expressed as functions of the relevant physical parameters, which is useful for testing the theory against real observations <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like the authors are laying out a solid analytical path to compare against those complex GCM simulations they mentioned earlier <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: The paper is designed to quantify the atmospheric thermal torque and clearly show how it depends on the tidal frequency in both low- and high-frequency regimes.

Jocelyn: That dependence on frequency is what they focus on, which is crucial for understanding different types of tidal forcing <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: It’s going to be important when we try to express the tidal torque induced by semidiurnal thermal tides on rocky planets as a function of the tidal frequency and all those physical setup parameters <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: So, they are essentially creating an analytical formula for that torque that we can use to compare directly with what GCM simulations produce.

Jocelyn: The comparison part is what makes it useful; the analytical approach is designed to benchmark itself against those GCM simulations <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: This analytical framework is especially relevant for studies dealing with thin planetary atmospheres on extrasolar rocky planets because it offers a concise structure to examine the tidal dynamics <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: The paper cites a lot of foundational work, including things like Laplace's masterwork and studies on atmospheric dynamics from people like Lindzen and Chapman in one thousand nine hundred sixty-nine <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Jocelyn: They also bring in recent observational constraints, even from the James Webb Space Telescope regarding exoplanet atmospheres <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: The framework is built on established concepts like the Brunt-Väisälä frequency and Lamb waves, which gives it a strong theoretical grounding <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: They have detailed appendices for calculating those resonance frequencies, including a table showing expansion coefficients connecting Hough functions to ALFs <ref:2512.10578#page 4 of that work reads: "Appendix A: Nomenclature" and other appendix details>.

Jocelyn: So they’ve done the heavy lifting on the mathematical machinery to ensure the reader can follow how they get those frequency conditions <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: The paper is really setting up a way to analytically express that tidal torque induced by semidiurnal thermal tides as a function of both the tidal frequency and the physical setup parameters <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Vera: The big picture here is that atmospheric thermal tides can drive planet-star systems away from classical equilibrium, which means synchronisation is not always the final state <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Jocelyn: It’s also showing that these torques are comparable to the torque on solid regions of Earth, which suggests they aren't just small atmospheric noise <ref:2512.10578#pg2>.

Subrahmanyan: The main implication for cosmology is that we need better models for how planetary atmospheres interact with tidal forces to accurately predict long-term orbital and rotational stability <ref:2512.10578#pg3>.

Conclusion: Vera: So, this paper lays out a new mathematical framework for studying atmospheric tides on rocky planets by looking at how thermal forces create torque and how that torque changes depending on the tidal frequency across different atmospheres.

Jocelyn: It’s essentially building a foundation to understand the long-term rotational evolution of these rocky planets when you factor in both gravitational and thermal tidal forcings.

Subrahmanyan: The authors use this model to quantify the atmospheric thermal torque and show how it depends on the tidal frequency across different atmospheric setups, which is a big step for seeing how thermal tides influence spin.

Vera: They look at two main temperature profiles: one where the temperature is uniform all over, and another where the potential temperature is uniform, like in an isentropic atmosphere.

Jocelyn: And they use Newtonian cooling to account for energy loss within the system, bridging that gap between simple math and what you'd get from a computer simulation.

Subrahmanyan: They establish that these two different cases actually follow the same general mathematical solution when you look at the atmospheric structure itself, which is interesting because it simplifies things for us.

Vera: The core finding here is that these atmospheric thermal tides can drive planet-star systems away from their usual states of equilibrium, especially when we talk about synchronisation.

Jocelyn: And they show that this atmospheric torque isn't as strong as the torque from ocean tides, but it’s about the same size as what you see acting on Earth’s solid parts.

Subrahmanyan: That comparison suggests that atmospheric effects are more significant than we might initially think when we look at long-term planetary evolution.

Vera: They also found that for Venus, its longitude of declination could have been stalled for hundreds of millions of years because the ocean and the thermotidal torques were balancing each other out.

Jocelyn: That’s a neat result, showing how competing forces can stabilize something over a long time.

Subrahmanyan: The resonance frequencies they derive are expressed as functions of the specific physical parameters of the system, which is useful for testing this theory against real data we get from observations.

Vera: The paper sets up analytical formulas to compare directly with results from general circulation models, or GCMs.

Jocelyn: This framework is particularly relevant for studying thin atmospheres on extrasolar rocky planets because it gives us a concise way to examine the tidal dynamics.

Subrahmanyan: They cite foundational work from people like Lindzen and Chapman, and they even reference recent data from the James Webb Space Telescope regarding exoplanet atmospheres.

Vera: It’s a solid piece of work for setting up the analytical tools needed to tackle these complex atmospheric interactions on rocky worlds.

Jocelyn: What they’re doing here is giving us a way to analytically express that torque induced by semidiurnal thermal tides as a function of both the tidal frequency and all those physical setup parameters.

More episodes

← Home