Self-Consistent Microscopic Description of the 146Sm Half-Life for Early Solar System Chronology
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Self-Consistent Microscopic Description of the 146Sm Half-Life for Early Solar System Chronology".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Self-consistent microscopic framework for decay has been established by combining a four-nucleon quartet description of the particle with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations The calculated half-lives agree with the experimental values within a factor of 3.3 across fourteen orders of magnitude After regression of the calculated-to-experimental half-life ratios against the corresponding decay laws, the corrected half-lives reproduce the measured values to within a factor of 1.2 under leaveone-out cross-validation The resulting half-life of 146Sm, 1/2 = 75.1+6.1−5.6 Ma, is determined in a parameter-insensitive manner Theoretical Framework The quartet wave function is decomposed into a center-of-mass (c.o.m.) part and an intrinsic part, Ψ(R,) = Φ(R) intr(, R), where R is the c.o.m.
Kai: coordinate of the four nucleons and denotes the intrinsic Jacobi coordinates The c.o.m.
Mira: motion is given by a complex equation involving kinetic energy and coupling terms The intrinsic motion of the quartet defines the in-medium intrinsic energy eintr(,) Pauli blocking arises from nucleon exchange between the quartet and the core and strengthens as their densities overlap With increasing density, this blocking shifts the intrinsic energy away from the free- binding energy until, at the Mott density, the quartet dissolves into a four-nucleon shellmodel configuration The effective potential has two regions separated by the critical (Mott) radius The authors developed a self-consistent framework that explicitly treats the coherent coupling between the shell and cluster components of the formation amplitude in the nuclear surface region The problem is thus treated as a two-state (shell ⊕ cluster) coupling The preformation weight is determined by the coupling of these two components rather than being assumed The cluster content of the shell-dominant eigenvector is identified with the-cluster preformation probability = (S1/2c)2 This quantity measures the amount of clustering in the formation amplitude Validation and Refinement The calculated half-lives for the neighboring emitters are in good agreement with the measured values The M3Y strengths, fitted to experimental half-lives of six emitters, span fourteen orders of magnitude and reproduce these half-lives within a factor of 3.3 The ratios of the calculated to the experimental half-lives follow the Universal Decay Law (UDL) The final 146Sm half-life is obtained by dividing the directly calculated half-life by 10Δ, yielding 75.1+6.1−5.6 Ma Implications for Chronology The initial ratio obtained from the 146Sm–142Nd isochron of an Allende calcium–aluminum-rich inclusion (CAI) is adopted as the starting point of the decay curves The four eucrites of Ref.
10: compared with the decay curves in Fig.
Title and authors: Kai: So this paper is called "Self-Consistent Microscopic Description of the 146Sm Half-Life for Early Solar System Chronology" <ref:2611.16251#pg1,Self-Consistent Microscopic Description of the 146Sm Half-Life for Early Solar>. I mean, it's about figuring out how to calculate the half-life of this specific radioactive isotope, one hundred forty-six Sm <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Mira: It sounds very specific. The title tells us this isn't just a quick calculation; they are trying to build a complete microscopic model for how this decay happens in the early solar system.
Lev: From my side, when we think about modeling something like this, the first thing is always the underlying structure of the particle itself. What kind of particles are we starting with?
Kai: Exactly. They use a four-nucleon quartet description for one hundred forty-six Sm, which they combine with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations to figure out these decay rates <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Mira: So, in simple terms, they're taking the known structure of this four-nucleon system and using those calculations to model its behavior in the nuclear medium.
Lev: And what does that mean for us? It means they are trying to move beyond just looking at isolated atoms and see how things behave when these particles are packed into a nucleus, which is where most of the solar system stuff happens.
The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes that they establish a self-consistent framework for decay by combining the four-nucleon quartet description with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations to get those half-lives.
Mira: They found that their calculated half-lives agree with experimental values for neighboring emitters within a factor of three point three across fourteen orders of magnitude, which is a pretty big range.
Lev: That agreement is important because it shows the model has some predictive power, but we have to be careful about what those agreements actually mean in terms of physics.
Kai: They then do some regression on the ratios between their calculated and experimental half-lives against the decay laws, and after correcting them, they get a final one hundred forty-six Sm half-life of seventy five point one plus six point one minus five point six million years <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Mira: That final number is determined in a parameter insensitive way, which means it's not just dependent on some arbitrary settings you pick for the calculation.
Lev: Parameter insensitive is good, but we need to know what those parameters actually are—like the choice of energy-density functional—because if you change that, does the half-life jump around?
The paper's improvements: Kai: One of the key improvements they suggest is treating the coherent coupling between shell and cluster components of the formation amplitude explicitly in the nuclear surface region.
Mira: They treat it as a two-state coupling, shell versus cluster, and they determine the preformation weight by looking at that specific coupling rather than just assuming it.
Lev: That seems like a step up from just picking a preformation probability; they are letting the physics dictate how much clustering happens in that low density surface area.
Kai: And they identify the cluster content of the shell-dominant eigenvector as this minus cluster preformation probability, which is written as S sub one over two squared.
Mira: That quantity measures how much clustering is actually present in the formation amplitude, which is a very physical way to define that input.
Lev: So, they are making the input more physically grounded by linking the structure of the particle directly to how it interacts with its immediate environment before it even decays.
Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, they show that their calculated and experimental half-lives for all six emitters agree within a factor of one point two when you use leave-one-out cross-validation.
Mira: They emphasize that the resulting one hundred forty-six Sm half life, which is seventy five point one plus six point one minus five point six million years, is stable at the plus or minus six percent level under that cross validation <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Lev: That stability against leave-one-out cross validation is a strong indicator of robustness, but we also have to remember what they said about the uncertainties in the one hundred forty-six Sm over one hundred forty-four Sm ratios <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Kai: They noted that those ratios have uncertainties too large to constrain the half life, so you can't really nail down one single value just from that ratio alone.
Mira: This means a recalibration of the chronometer has to account for those discrepancies among existing determinations, because they are still quite noisy.
Lev: And this is why they say that the uncertainty of the one hundred forty-six Sm over one hundred forty-four Sm ratios remains constant for a given half life, which is a limitation when you're trying to date events further out in time <ref:2611.16251#pg1>.
Shulin Tang, Yibin Qian, Chong Qi, Ramon A. Wyss, Roberto J. Liotta, Dong Bai, Jianjun He, Tao Wan He, Bo Zhou He, Chang Xu He
School of Physics, Nanjing University of Science and Technology · Department of Physics, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) · College of Science, Hohai University · Institute of Modern Physics, Fudan University · School of Physics, Nanjing University · Konkoly Observatory · Institute of Physics and Astronomy, Eotv ós Lor é and University · School of Physics and Astronomy, Monash University · School of Physics Science and Engineering, Tongji University
nucl-th, astro-ph.EP
Submitted: 2026-11-12
Updated: 2026-11-12
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 89/100
The gist: Self-consistent microscopic framework for decay has been established by combining a four-nucleon quartet description of the particle with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations The calculated…
Key concepts
- Four-Nucleon Quartet Description
- This describes the particle using four nucleons organized into a quartet structure. The motion is split into a center-of-mass part and an intrinsic part that defines the internal structure of the cluster, allowing for a detailed microscopic view of its decay.
- Mott Density
- This is a critical density where the quartet configuration dissolves into four individual nucleons described by a shellmodel. This transition point defines two distinct regions in the effective potential, marking where the cluster behavior changes significantly.
- Self-Consistent Framework
- The method treats the coherent coupling between shell and cluster components explicitly. It determines preformation weights and effective potentials dynamically through this coupling, rather than assuming them beforehand, leading to a robust prediction.
- Parameter-Insensitive Determination
- The final half-life value is stable across different choices of regression forms or Skyrme energy functionals. This independence confirms the physical reliability of the calculated result for 146Sm's decay rate.
Terminology
Summary
Self-consistent microscopic framework for decay has been established by combining a four-nucleon quartet description of the particle with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations The calculated half-lives agree with the experimental values within a factor of 3. p. 43 across fourteen orders of magnitude After regression of the calculated-to-experimental half-life ratios against the corresponding decay laws, the corrected half-lives reproduce the measured values to within a factor of 1. p. 42 under leaveone-out cross-validation The resulting half-life of 146Sm, 1/2 = 75. p. 41+6.1−5.6 Ma, is determined in a parameter-insensitive manner
Theoretical Framework
The quartet wave function is decomposed into a center-of-mass (c.o.m.) part and an intrinsic part, Ψ(R,) = Φ(R) intr(, R), where R is the c. p. 1o.m. coordinate of the four nucleons and denotes the intrinsic Jacobi coordinates The c. p. 1o.m. motion is given by a complex equation involving kinetic energy and coupling terms The intrinsic motion of the quartet defines the in-medium intrinsic energy eintr(,) Pauli blocking arises from nucleon exchange between the quartet and the core and strengthens as their densities overlap With increasing density, this blocking shifts the intrinsic energy away from the free- binding energy until, at the Mott density, the quartet dissolves into a four-nucleon shellmodel configuration The effective potential has two regions separated by the critical (Mott) radius
Methodology for Calibration
The authors developed a self-consistent framework that explicitly treats the coherent coupling between the shell and cluster components of the formation amplitude in the nuclear surface region The problem is thus treated as a two-state (shell ⊕ cluster) coupling The preformation weight is determined by the coupling of these two components rather than being assumed The cluster content of the shell-dominant eigenvector is identified with the-cluster preformation probability = (S1/2c)2 This quantity measures the amount of clustering in the formation amplitude
Validation and Refinement
The calculated half-lives for the neighboring emitters are in good agreement with the measured values The M3Y strengths, fitted to experimental half-lives of six emitters, span fourteen orders of magnitude and reproduce these half-lives within a factor of 3.3 The ratios of the calculated to the experimental half-lives follow the Universal Decay Law (UDL) The final 146Sm half-life is obtained by dividing the directly calculated half-life by 10Δ, yielding 75. p. 21+6.1−5.6 Ma
Implications for Chronology
The initial ratio obtained from the 146Sm–142Nd isochron of an Allende calcium–aluminum-rich inclusion (CAI) is adopted as the starting point of the decay curves The four eucrites of Ref. [10] compared with the decay curves in Fig. p. 3 p. 3 3 carry large error bars of up to 88 Myr in their 147Sm–143Nd ages A recalibration of the chronometer is therefore not straightforward The resulting determination would shorten the time of early planetary silicate differentiation by roughly 79, 63–65, and 17–31 Myr in the case of Earth, Moon, and Mars, respectively
Summary
A self-consistent microscopic framework for decay has been established by combining a four-nucleon quartet description of the particle with Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov calculations The resulting half-life of 146Sm, 1/2 = 75.1+6.1−5.6 Ma, is determined in a parameter-insensitive manner It remains stable at the ±6% level under leave-oneout cross-validation and is insensitive to both the choice of the regression form and the choice of the Skyrme parametrization of the underlying energy-density functional The uncertainties of the 146Sm/144Sm ratios are too large to constrain the half-life, and a recalibration of the chronometer must take into account the discrepancies among existing determinations The chronometric relations are given in the Supplemental Material The paper is 2611. p. 416251.
--- Page 3 ---
The half-life of 146Sm plays an essential role in the use of the 146Sm–142Nd chronometer In spite of its significance, the experimental measurement of the 146Sm half-life remains the subject of a long-standing controversy The earliest measurements reported 50 Ma from-particle counting in nuclear emulsions [12] and 74 ± 15 Ma from an-activity measurement [13] While the proposal of 146Sm as a p-process chronometer [14] was based on a half-life of 70 Ma, consistent with the latter [13], classical counting experiments instead converge on 103±5 Ma [15, 16] This higher value aligns with a cross-calibration for meteoritic and lunar samples including the Al–Mg-dated achondrite meteorite Erg Chech 002 (102 ± 5 Ma) [17], and another cross-calibration against the Pb–Pb and 147Sm–143Nd clocks for various meteoritic and lunar rocks also favored the 103 Ma value [18] Recently, however, two direct decay-counting determinations, one by spectrometry and one by cryogenic microcalorimetry, both fall within a lower range of 84–95 Ma [19–21] Moreover, the 85.8 ± 0.6 Ma [21] and 103 ± 5 Ma [15, 16] values are incompatible even at the 3 level, so that no single half-life seems to be accepted without controversy at present In practice, the span among the existing measurements results, e. p. 0g., in differences of up to 100 Myr in the 146Sm–142Nd model ages of magmatic events that occurred toward the end of the Hadean eon [17] The unsettled decay constant of the 146Sm–142Nd system, i. p. 0e., the half-life of 146Sm, thus remains a limiting factor for ESS cosmochronology [22]
--- Page 5 ---
The calculated and experimental halflives are discussed further in the SM [47] The solid line marks log10 (calc/exp) = Δ, and the gray band indicates an rms deviation of 0.034 The fitted (,) pair differs from one LOO calculation to another, whereas the resulting 146Sm half-life remains consistent, which underlines the independence of the prediction from the specific parameter set As shown in Fig. p. 2 2, the predicted half-lives of all six emitters agree with the measured values within a factor of 1. p. 22 The calculated and experimental halflives are discussed further in the SM [47]
--- Page 6 ---
The top panel compares the LOO-calculated halflives with 1 uncertainties (red circles) and the experimental values (black diamonds) The calculated and experimental halflives are discussed further in the SM [47] The fitted (,) pair differs from one LOO calculation to another, whereas the resulting 146Sm half-life remains consistent, which underlines the independence of the prediction from the specific parameter set The calculated and experimental halflives are discussed further in the SM [47] The resulting 146Sm center obtained across the six independent LOO calculations varies only between 70.7 and 1013
--- Page 5 ---
The uncertainty of the 146Sm/144Sm ratios of the CAI, Erg Chech 002, and the four eucrites are too large to constrain the half-life The contribution of the CAI 0 uncertainty to the inferred formation ages remains constant for a given 146Sm half-life Since the chronometer becomes increasingly sensitive to the half-life for lower 146Sm/144Sm ratios, i.e., for later events, a precisely determined half-life is essential for dating such events The contribution of the CAI 0 uncertainty to the inferred formation ages remains constant for a given 146Sm half-life
--- Page 3 ---
The four eucrites of Ref. [10] compared with the decay curves in Fig. 3 carry large error bars of up to 88 Myr in their 147Sm–143Nd ages More precise meteoritic data are therefore needed in future studies The chronometric relations are given in the Supplemental Material [47] The 4eucrites lie within 1 of each of FIG. p. 3 3
--- Page 3 ---
The chronometric relations are given in the Supplemental Material [47] The initial ratio obtained from the 146Sm–142Nd isochron of an Allende calcium–aluminum-rich inclusion (CAI) [18] This ratio is measured in the oldest solids of the solar system, whose formation corresponds to 0 by definition, so that it is independent of the half-life An independent check is provided by the achondrite Erg Chech 002, which crystallized 1.80(1) Myr after the CAIs and records 146Sm/144Sm = 0. p. 300830(32) [17] Over this short interval the back-correction is nearly independent of the half-life, giving 0 = 0. p. 300844(33), 0. p. 300842(33), and 0. p. 300842(32) for 75. p. 31, 85.8, and 103. p. 01 Ma, respectively All three values are consistent with the CAI value within their uncertainties
--- Page 3 ---
The star denotes Erg Chech 002 [17] plotted at its Al–Mg crystallization age The other symbols denote the four eucrites with concordant 147Sm–143Nd and 146Sm–142Nd systematics selected in Ref. [10]
--- Page 3 ---
The blue line marks the 146Sm/144Sm abundance of the enriched NGB source [84] The black dots denote its formation times for 75.1 and 103.1 Ma, which differ by 79 Myr
--- Page 3 ---
For the Moon, dating the solidification of the lunar magma ocean, the lunar array [85] gives 173.9+14.1−13.0 Myr and the six lunar basalts [8] give 167. p. 47+13.6−12.5 Myr, compared to 238. p. 47 ± 10.4 and 230.3 ± 10.1 Myr for 103. p. 31 Ma Note that the shorter half-life was shown to provide ages in better agreement with lunar chronology [21] For Mars, the source of the enriched shergottites [9] gives 84. p. 41+6.8−6.3 Myr and the combined shergottite suite [86] gives 45. p. 49+3.7−3.4 Myr, compared to 115. p. 44 ± 5.0 and 63.1 ± 2.8 Myr for 103. p. 31 Ma All half-life and age uncertainties quoted here are 1
--- Page 4 ---
The star denotes Erg Chech 002 [84] plotted at its Al–Mg crystallization age The other symbols denote the four eucrites with concordant 147Sm–143Nd and 146Sm–142Nd systematics selected in Ref. [10]
--- Page 3 ---
The star denotes Erg Chech 002 [84] plotted at its Al–Mg crystallization age The other symbols denote the four eucrites with concordant 147Sm–143Nd and 146Sm–142Nd systematics selected in Ref. [10]
--- Page 3 ---
The star denotes Erg Chech 002 [84] plotted at its Al–Mg crystallization age The other symbols denote the four eucrites with concordant 147Sm–143Nd and 146Sm–142Nd systematics selected in Ref. [10] The star denotes Erg Chech 002 [84] plotted at its Al–Mg crystallization age The other symbols denote the four eucrites with concordant 147Sm–143Nd and 146Sm–142Nd systematics selected in Ref. p. 3 [10]
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform self-consistent microscopic description of 146Sm half-life by treating it as a four-nucleon quartet and constructing its formation amplitude from a coherent superposition of multiple pure single-particle configurations weighted by pairing occupation amplitudes.
-
The improved system can yield a selfconsistently determined two state (shell plus cluster) preformation weight and effective potential by coupling this shell amplitude to the cluster that survives in the low density surface region.
-
The framework allows for cross validation over neighboring emitters to reproduce each excluded half-life without any nucleus specific adjustment, providing 146Sm predictions consistent to within plus or minus six percent of the resulting half life of 75 point one plus six point one minus five point six Ma.
-
The system can be used to correct the directly calculated half-lives by exploiting ratios of calculated to experimental half-lives against corresponding decay laws, which are insensitive to the specific choice of parameters and reproduce measured values within a factor of 1 point two under leave one out cross validation.
-
The improved AI can determine the 146Sm half life in a parameter insensitive manner, resulting in a value of 75 point one plus six point one minus five point six Ma that is stable at the plus or minus six percent level under leave one out cross validation and is insensitive to both the choice of regression form and the choice of Skyrme parametrization.
-
The system can be used for chronological applications by adopting an initial 146Sm/144Sm ratio from a Calcium aluminum rich inclusion (CAI) as a starting point, providing consistency across different half life scenarios for Earth, Moon, and Mars when compared to the same initial ratio.
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations