Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime

arXiv:2611.16141 · gr-qc · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime construct a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, a nonstationary rotating black-hole geometry whose mass varies with the retarded or advanced time The construction requires two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), one for each null congruence, together with the hemisphere sign σ(ϑ) = sign(cos ϑ) and two integrating factors λ and λV Construction of Null Coordinates The paper constructs a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, which involves deriving two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), one for each null congruence.

Kai: These functions are determined by solving the two master equations and the two integrating-factor quadratures.

Mira: The outgoing and ingoing canonical null one-forms require two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), together with two integrating factors.

Kai: Derivation of Null One-Forms The eikonal equation is derived from the null condition gµν∂µU ∂νU = 0 for an axisymmetric function U = U(u,r, ϑ).

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper "Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime" successfully constructs those double null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime. The main requirement is having two independent Carter type functions, K and K with a tilde, one for each null congruence Mira.

Mira: That construction is validated by checking the residual of the master equation and those closure conditions we talked about earlier Lev. It’s a solid way to see if your setup actually works.

Kai: The result is a metric in double null form that becomes regular at the horizon when extended with a time-dependent surface gravity Lev. That's the main structural achievement here.

Mira: It means that even for these nonstationary rotating black holes, we can get a coordinate system where things stay well-behaved near the horizon for physical calculations Kai.

Lev: The paper also mentions that because the mass is changing, you need two different equations for closure conditions, which is why you need those two independent functions K and K with a tilde instead of just one Mira.

Kai: It’s a good piece of work because it shows exactly what’s needed to handle the nonstationarity correctly in this geometry Lev.

Mira: Overall, this paper provides a robust framework for studying these black holes dynamically, which is something we need if we want to look at evaporation models more closely Kai.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at the "Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime" paper Mira. It basically shows they built a way to describe a rotating black hole where the mass isn't constant over time, using two different types of null coordinates.

Mira: Right. They needed two independent Carter type functions, K and K tilde, one for each incoming or outgoing light path, because when the mass is changing, you can't use just one function for both Kai. It’s a technical fix to handle that time-varying aspect of the geometry.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint Mira, what they actually achieved is getting those two master equations solved numerically, which gives us a metric in double null form. That’s the actual output we can work with on hardware simulations Kai.

Kai: So the big implication here is that this doesn't just give us a fancy coordinate system; it gives us a regular chart at the horizon when you use an extended Kruskal type extension with some time-dependent surface gravity Lev. That’s crucial because the naive coordinates actually blow up right at the event horizon Mira.

Mira: Exactly. It means we can study things like massless scalar fields or build global diagrams without immediately running into singularities, which is a major hurdle in these nonstationary systems Kai.

Lev: The paper shows that this extended chart behaves nicely, even with an exponential dependence on time for evaporating models, which gives us something concrete to test against real hardware constraints Mira.

Kai: So what we're seeing here is a way to handle the dynamics of these black holes when their mass is evolving Lev. It opens up new avenues for how we model gravitational collapse and evaporation processes in a more rigorous way.

Mira: That’s right. Next up, we'll look at how this coordinate system actually impacts the physics we can measure near these objects.

Xiao-Kan Guo, *, *Xiankai Pang, *

School of Mathematics & Physics, Yancheng Institute of Technology · School of Physics and Astronomy, China West Normal University

gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: 18 pages, 7 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime construct a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime…

Key concepts

Kerr-Vaidya Spacetime
This is a mathematical model for a rotating black hole where the mass is not constant; it changes depending on whether you use retarded or advanced time. This nonstationary geometry requires specialized coordinate systems to describe its changing structure accurately.
Carter-type Functions (K and K˜)
These are two independent functions, K and K˜, that are necessary to define the outgoing and ingoing null light rays. They are determined by solving complex master equations derived from the geometry's properties, especially when the mass is changing.
Double Null Coordinates
This refers to a pair of null coordinates used to describe spacetime. The construction requires two separate sets of functions (one for each congruence) to properly map out the geometry, which is crucial for studying light paths near the black hole horizon.

Summary

Double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetime construct a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, a nonstationary rotating black-hole geometry whose mass varies with the retarded or advanced time The construction requires two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), one for each null congruence, together with the hemisphere sign σ(ϑ) = sign(cos ϑ) and two integrating factors λ and λV

Construction of Null Coordinates

The paper constructs a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, which involves deriving two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), one for each null congruence. These functions are determined by solving the two master equations and the two integrating-factor quadratures. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Section V contains the two master equations and the integrating-factor quadratures, and the numerical solutions of both sectors are described in Section VI. If the two Carter-type functions and the two integrating factors are known, we obtain the explicit form of the KerrVaidya metric in the double null coordinates, which is given in Sec.

The outgoing and ingoing canonical null one-forms require two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), together with two integrating factors. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Second, and this is the new element of the present work, when M′ ̸= 0 the outgoing and ingoing canonical null one-forms satisfy different closure conditions. Consequently a single Carter-type function cannot serve both congruences, and one needs two independent functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), together with two integrating factors, one for each null one-form.

Derivation of Null One-Forms

The eikonal equation is derived from the null condition gµν∂µU ∂νU = 0 for an axisymmetric function U = U(u,r, ϑ). Setting ∂uU = 1 and solving the resulting quadratic for ∂rU yields the canonical null one-form of the outgoing congruence ω. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The ingoing congruence is treated in exactly the same way, but with an independent parameter K˜(u,r, ϑ). Setting ∂uV = 1 and defining K˜ ≡ (∂ϑV) 2 + a 2 sin2 ϑ, the plus branch of the corresponding quadratic gives the ingoing null one-form ωV = du + AV dr + BV dϑ, AV = (r 2 + a 2 ) + P˜ ∆ = K˜ r 2 + a 2 − P˜ , BV = +σ(ϑ) p K˜ − a 2 sin2 ϑ, (26) with P˜ ≡ q (r 2 + a 2) 2 − ∆K˜, ˜h ≡ p K˜ − a 2 sin2 ϑ.

Similarly, an independent parameter K˜(u,r, ϑ) is used to define the ingoing null one-form ωV. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The ingoing congruence is treated in exactly the same way, but with an independent parameter K˜(u,r, ϑ). Setting ∂uV = 1 and defining K˜ ≡ (∂ϑV) 2 + a 2 sin2 ϑ, the plus branch of the corresponding quadratic gives the ingoing null one-form ωV = du + AV dr + BV dϑ, AV = (r 2 + a 2 ) + P˜ ∆ = K˜ r 2 + a 2 − P˜ , BV = +σ(ϑ) p K˜ − a 2 sin2 ϑ, (26) with P˜ ≡ q (r 2 + a 2) 2 − ∆K˜, ˜h ≡ p K˜ − a 2 sin2 ϑ.

Closure Conditions and Independence

The closure conditions for the outgoing and ingoing canonical one-forms are different equations. This difference is due to the fact that when M′ ≠ 0, a single Carter-type function cannot serve both congruences, necessitating two independent functions K and K˜. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Second, and this is the new element of the present work, when M′ ̸= 0 the outgoing and ingoing canonical null one-forms satisfy different closure conditions. Consequently a single Carter-type function cannot serve both congruences, and one needs two independent functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ), together with two integrating factors, one for each null one-form.

A single function is not sufficient when M′ ≠ 0 because it would have to satisfy an additional algebraic constraint (39) which is incompatible with the master equation except in the static limit. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(39) But (35) already determines ∂uK in terms of the spatial derivatives of K. Hence a single function would have to satisfy, in addition to the master equation, the algebraic constraint (39).

Numerical Solutions and Horizon Behavior

The two master equations are solved numerically to obtain the Kerr-Vaidya metric in double-null form. The numerical integration of the outgoing equation (43) and the ingoing equation (45) is performed using specified grids and schemes. p. 7

Where the paper says it

2] and ϑ ∈ [0, π/2], using the reflection symmetry about the equator, with Nξ × Nϑ = 241 × 121 points. The ingoing equation (45) is integrated on the same ϑ grid and on ξ ∈ [0, 0.

The analysis shows that while the unextended null coordinates are singular at the horizon, a Kruskal-type extension with a time-dependent surface gravity is regular at the horizon. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also show that the unextended null coordinates are singular at the horizon, where the advanced coordinate diverges logarithmically and the metric determinant vanishes. We construct the corresponding Kruskal-type extension with a time-dependent surface gravity and show that it is regular at the horizon.

Physical Implications

The resulting double-null form of the Kerr–Vaidya metric allows for the study of massless scalar fields and the construction of global conformal diagrams. The analysis shows that the departure from stationary surfaces encodes the M′(u) terms, quantifying how evaporation reshapes the congruence. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We do not display λV, whose equation involves the same singular coefficient and whose value therefore depends on the gauge at ξ = 0. The departure from the static surfaces encodes the M′ (u) terms.

The extended chart is regular at the horizon to leading adiabatic order, and its behavior is governed by an exponential dependence on time for evaporating models.

Conclusion

The paper successfully constructs a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, which requires two independent Carter-type functions K(u,r, ϑ) and K˜(u,r, ϑ). The construction is validated by the residual of the master equation and closure conditions. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Its overall magnitude, |λ| ≲ 10−4 , shows that the integrating factor is a small but nonvanishing correction to the null one-form. The numerical scheme is validated by the residual of the master equation (43) and of the closure conditions (50)–(51), which are satisfied to better than 10−8 and 10−6 , respectively, over the full grid.

The resulting metric in double-null form is regular at the horizon when extended with a time-dependent surface gravity. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We also show that the unextended null coordinates are singular at the horizon, where the advanced coordinate diverges logarithmically and the metric determinant vanishes. We construct the corresponding Kruskal-type extension with a time-dependent surface gravity and show that it is regular at the horizon.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI systems can construct double null coordinates for Kerr-Vaidya spacetimes by solving two independent master equations and two integrating factor quadratures numerically to obtain the Kerr-Vaidya metric in double null form. This allows the AI to generate explicit coordinate representations of nonstationary rotating black hole geometries where mass varies with time.

  2. The improved system can handle the non-closure of canonical null one-forms by determining two independent Carter type functions K and K, and two integrating factors, which are necessary because when M' != 0 the outgoing and ingoing canonical null one-forms satisfy different closure conditions. This enables accurate description of causal structures in realistic evaporating black hole scenarios.

  3. The AI can implement a Kruskal-type extension with a time dependent surface gravity to regularize the metric at the horizon, demonstrating that the corresponding Kruskal-type extension with a time dependent surface gravity and show that it is regular at the horizon. This capability allows for physically meaningful descriptions of black hole evolution across horizons.

  4. The system can analyze the departure of null geodesics from a straight line by evaluating the accumulated change of the ingoing null coordinate produced by the evaporation, which is quantified as the imprint of the outgoing radiation on the ingoing congruence. This enables precise modeling of how mass variation reshapes spacetime structure near horizons.

  5. The AI can perform numerical integrations on uniform grids for both sectors, using specific schemes such as a fourth order Runge Kutta RK4 step for radial integration and a three point backward difference for ∂uk, ensuring high accuracy in solving the master equations. This provides robust numerical solutions to the complex coupled system of differential equations governing the null coordinates.

Abstract

We construct a pair of null coordinates for the Kerr-Vaidya spacetime, a nonstationary rotating black-hole geometry whose mass varies with the retarded or advanced time. The metric is naturally written in Eddington-Finkelstein-type coordinates, but the corresponding time coordinate fails to be null when the spin is nonzero, so each null coordinate must acquire a correction of the Carter type that depends on the polar angle. We show that the outgoing and ingoing null congruences require two independent Carter-type functions. The canonical null one-forms obtained from the eikonal equation are not closed when the mass varies, and their closure conditions are different equations. For constant mass both closure equations reduce to the equation found by Argañaraz and Moreschi. We derive the two master equations together with the two integrating-factor equations, solve both sectors numerically, and obtain the Kerr-Vaidya metric in double-null form. We also show that the unextended null coordinates are singular at the horizon, where the advanced coordinate diverges logarithmically and the metric determinant vanishes. We construct the corresponding Kruskal-type extension with a time-dependent surface gravity and show that it is regular at the horizon.

Related papers