A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present a catalogue of 31 binary black hole simulations performed with the Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC) on the sonic cluster at ICTS-TIFR, Bengaluru between August 2023 and December 2024, targeting the sparsely covered corner of parameter space in which orbital eccentricity and spin–orbit precession are present simultaneously The longest, EccPrecDiff002, inspirals for 80 orbits (159 gravitational-wave cycles), to our knowledge the longest simultaneously eccentric and precessing binary black hole evolution to date.
Kai: Catalogue Scope and Key Findings The catalogue comprises 31 distinct physical configurations organized into three series, run between August 2023 and December 2024 Taken together they span mass ratios 1 ≤ q ≤ 11.0, dimensionless spin magnitudes up to ⃗χ = 0.6, and initial eccentricities up to ˆe0 = 0.40 (Table II).
Mira: Seventeen of them are both eccentric and precessing.
Kai: The three series are ICTSEccParallel, EccContPrecDiff, and EccPrecDiff.
Paper summary: Kai: We started by looking at the core of this paper, "A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR," which presents thirty one binary black hole simulations performed with the Spectral Einstein Code on the sonic cluster at ICTS-TIFR.
Mira: The main thesis is that they are targeting a corner of parameter space where orbital eccentricity and spin precession occur simultaneously, which is a region that has been sparsely covered by previous work.
Lev: So what they claim is that this catalog provides a systematic way to explore those specific interactions between eccentricity and precession in binary black hole systems.
Kai: They also point out the longest run, EccPrecDiff002, which lasts for eighty orbits or one hundred fifty nine gravitational wave cycles, which they claim is the longest simultaneously eccentric and precessing binary black hole evolution to date.
Mira: That length is important because it sets a benchmark for how long these complex simulations can sustain before they become computationally infeasible.
Lev: And the paper mentions that this run was done with equal mass binaries with spins at zero point two zero and zero point two, which gives us a concrete starting point for understanding how these dynamics play out.
Kai: The catalogue includes thirty one configurations organized into three series: ICTSEccParallel, EccContPrecDiff, and EccPrecDiff, covering mass ratios from one q up to eleven point zero.
Mira: And they emphasize that seventeen of those simulations are both eccentric and precessing at the same time. That’s a lot of data in a very specific area of parameter space for these types of systems.
Lev: The paper details the methodology, but we know they used the Spectral Einstein Code, SpEC, which solves Einstein's equations in the first-order generalized harmonic formulation.
Kai: And they mention that they’ve done some validation checks to make sure their results are physically sound by checking measured eccentricity from the waveforms rather than just using initial data.
Mira: They also test the co-precessing frame approximation against their non-precessing runs to quantify how accurate that approximation is, and they check if the final waveforms reach in the next generation detector band.
Lev: They are using geometric units where G equals c equals one, and quoting times and lengths in units of the total Christodoulou mass M equal to m one plus m two at a reference epoch.
Kai: And they also talk about how they defined the mass ratio q as m one over m two greater than or equal to one, and dimensionless spins chi i as S i over m2 i, and the effective aligned spin chi eff as that weighted average of the spins.
Mira: So they are defining all their terms clearly so we know exactly what they are referring to when they say things like precession parameter chi p in the usual way.
Lev: It’s about setting up a consistent framework so that everyone can interpret the results from these thirty one simulations in a standardized way.
Kai: And they also state how they distinguish between two eccentricities, where one is denoted by e zero, which is targeted by a reduction procedure and not the proper initial eccentricity.
Mira: That distinction is important because it tells us that the input eccentricity for the simulation isn't necessarily what we measure directly from the final data.
Lev: So this catalog gives us a clear framework for understanding these complex dynamics while also highlighting where the limitations lie in terms of measurement and interpretation.
Conclusion: Kai: Looking at this paper, "A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR," the authors Vaishak Prasad et al. are essentially providing a comprehensive dataset for this specific physics problem.
Mira: They’ve managed to generate thirty one simulations that explore the corner of eccentricity and spin precession where they haven't seen much data before, and they’ve shown how long these systems can evolve.
Lev: The implication is that we now have a benchmark for what these complex simulations can actually achieve in terms of duration for this kind of physics.
Kai: It means we have a better idea of the limits on the duration we can expect before the computational cost becomes too high for researchers trying to run these kinds of experiments.
Mira: And they are giving us a better idea about where the limitations lie regarding precision
International Centre for Theoretical Sciences, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Bengaluru · Institute for Gravitation and the Cosmos, The Pennsylvania State University · Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Penn State University · Cornell Center for Astrophysics and Planetary Science, Cornell University · Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany · California Institute of Technology
gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-10-14
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: The manuscript was submitted before all co-authors had sufficient time to review it. We are withdrawing it to allow for a complete review and agreement on the final version by all authors
Code: https://github.com/vaishakp/nrsimulations
Project page: https://vaishakp.github.io/spec_optimizations/optimizations.html
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 97/100
The gist: We present a catalogue of 31 binary black hole simulations performed with the Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC) on the sonic cluster at ICTS-TIFR…
Key concepts
- Eccentricity ($\hat{e}_0$)
- Eccentricity describes how non-circular an orbit is. In these simulations, initial eccentricities up to 0.40 were tested. This parameter affects the shape of the black hole orbits during the inspiral, which is a key feature being studied alongside precession.
- Spin-Orbit Precession ($\chi_p$)
- Precession occurs when a black hole's spin axis moves around its orbital plane due to interactions with the other object's motion. The simulations explore this effect, with spins having substantial in-plane components, causing the orbital plane to precess throughout the evolution.
- Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC)
- SpEC is a numerical method used to solve Einstein's equations for binary black hole spacetimes. It uses a spectral approach and adapts its computational domain automatically to maintain accuracy during the simulation, allowing for high-precision calculations.
Terminology
Summary
We present a catalogue of 31 binary black hole simulations performed with the Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC) on the sonic cluster at ICTS-TIFR, Bengaluru between August 2023 and December 2024, targeting the sparsely covered corner of parameter space in which orbital eccentricity and spin–orbit precession are present simultaneously The longest, EccPrecDiff002, inspirals for 80 orbits (159 gravitational-wave cycles), to our knowledge the longest simultaneously eccentric and precessing binary black hole evolution to date. p. 0
Catalogue Scope and Key Findings
The catalogue comprises 31 distinct physical configurations organized into three series, run between August 2023 and December 2024 Taken together they span mass ratios 1 ≤ q ≤ 11.0, dimensionless spin magnitudes up to ⃗χ = 0. p. 26, and initial eccentricities up to ˆe0 = 0. p. 040 (Table II). p. 1 Seventeen of them are both eccentric and precessing. p. 0 The three series are ICTSEccParallel, EccContPrecDiff, and EccPrecDiff. p. 3 The longest runs in the catalogue, EccPrecDiff001/002, are equal-mass binaries with ⃗χ1 = (0, 0. p. 22, 0.2) and ⃗χ2 = (0. p. 22, 0, 0.2), initial separation D0 = 18 M. p. 1 Both spins have substantial in-plane components, so the orbital plane precesses throughout, χp = 0. p. 22.
Numerical Methods and Optimization
All simulations were performed with the Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC) [10–12] which solves the Einstein equations in the first-order generalised harmonic formulation [13]. The computational domain is decomposed into spherical shells around each excision surface, cylinders and distorted cubes filling the region between them, and a set of spherical shells extending to an outer boundary at several hundred to ∼ 2000 M. p. 1 SpEC adapts both the number of spectral collocation points and the domain decomposition during the evolution, driven by a target truncation error. p. 1 The compile-time optimisation of SpEC and its third-party library stack for the AMD Zen-2 architecture delivered a 90% speedup of the initial-data solver and a 40% speedup of the evolution, roughly half of the latter traceable to a single defect in how pre-2. p. 034 glibc reported cache topology on AMD processors. p. 0
Performance and Throughput
The performance main result is summarized Fig. 4a. EccPrecDiff002 sustains close to 100 M h−1 for its entire inspiral on a single node, reaching merger in 698 wallclock hours — 29 days — for 33 kCPU-h, an average of 86 M h−1 including the expensive merger phase. p. 5 The cost rises steeply with mass ratio: the q = 9. p. 55 runs are roughly an order of magnitude slower per unit evolution time than the equal-mass runs, because the smaller hole demands finer resolution and shorter time steps. p. 5
Physical Validation and Frame Conventions
The catalogue includes four checks that do: the eccentricity is measured from the waveforms rather than taken from the initial data, the first law of binary mechanics is tested, the co-precessing-frame approximation is quantified against the catalogue’s own non-precessing runs, to be taken up in more detailed follow-up studies, and the waveforms are placed in the next-generation detector band. The rotation R is the unique proper rotation with R Lˆ = ˆz, R nˆ⊥ = ˆx, (3). p. 6 The convention is chosen so that the three are directly comparable and so that the ranking across the catalogue in Fig. p. 6 13 is not confounded by network geometry. p. 4
Accuracy and Convergence
The accumulated inspiral phase difference ranges from 2 × 10−6 rad to 24.3 rad, with a median of 0. p. 8041 rad. For EccPrecDiff002 the Lev2–Lev3 difference reaches 8. p. 84 rad over 80 orbits, i. p. 8e., 0.8% of the accumulated orbital phase. p. 8 This is an unavoidable tradeoff of length against accuracy, and users of the longest waveforms should treat the highest-resolution data as carrying a phase uncertainty of this order. p. 8
Future Directions
Natural extensions of this work are to push to higher mass ratio at fixed eccentricity, to add a third resolution level to the longest runs so that the convergence order can be measured rather than assumed, and to extend the extraction to Cauchy-characteristic evolution, for which the requisite worldtube data have already been generated. The catalogue spans Mmax = 62 to 445 M⊙ (Fig. p. 0 13). A trial at this resolution ran too slowly to be practical, so reaching it will require changes to the code’s refinement and control systems rather than more CPU time. p. 0 The requirement for Cosmic Explorer is a single-interferometer signal-to-noise ratio of 961 in Cosmic Explorer at 1 Gpc. p. 0
Acknowledgments and Data Availability
We thank the SXS collaboration for access to SpEC. The simulation metadata, parameter tables and live status of the campaign are maintained at [37]. p. 2 All simulations in this catalogue will be released as part of the public SXS catalog, and each will be assigned an SXS identifier on release. p. 2 The post-processing and transformation tools are public: waveformtools [38], sxstools [39] and spectral [40]. p. 0 All simulations, analyses and conclusions are the authors’ own. p. 8
References
[1] M. Boyle et al. p. 0, “The SXS Collaboration catalog of binary black hole simulations,” Class. p. 0 Quantum Grav. 36, 195006 (2019)
[2] J. Healy and C. O. Lousto, “Fourth RIT binary black hole simulations catalog,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 105, 124010 (2022)
[3] E. Hamilton et al., “Catalog of precessing black-holebinary numerical-relativity simulations,” Phys. p. 6 Rev. D 109, 044032 (2024)
[4] C. L. Rodriguez et al., “Post-Newtonian dynamics in dense star clusters: Formation, masses, and merger rates of highly-eccentric black hole binaries,” Phys. Rev. D 98, 123005 (2018)
[5] M. Zevin et al., “Eccentric black hole mergers in dense star clusters,” Astrophys. p. 0 J. 921, 43 (2021)
[6] I. Romero-Shaw, P. D. Lasky and E. Thrane, “Four eccentric mergers increase the evidence that LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA’s binary black holes form dynamically,” Astrophys. p. 0 J. 940, 171 (2022)
[7] Divyajyoti, I. M. Romero-Shaw, V. Prasad et al. p. 0, “Biased parameter inference of eccentric, spin-precessing binary black holes,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 113, 103022 (2026), arXiv:2510. p. 004332
[8] P. Schmidt, F. Ohme and M. Hannam, “Towards models of gravitational waveforms from generic binaries II,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 91, 024043 (2610)
[9] P. Schmidt, I. W. Harry and H. P. Pfeiffer, “Numerical relativity injection infrastructure,” LIGO-T1500606 (2617)
[10] The Spectral Einstein Code (SpEC), https://www.black-holes. p. 0org/code/SpEC. p. 0html
[11] B. Szil´agyi, L. Lindblom and M. A. Scheel, “Simulations of binary black hole mergers using spectral methods,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 80, 124010 (2009)
[12] D. A. Hemberger et al., “Dynamical excision boundaries in spectral evolutions of binary black hole spacetimes,” Class. p. 1 Quantum Grav. 30, 115001 (2013)
[13] L. Lindblom et al., “A new generalized harmonic evolution system,” Class. p. 1 Quantum Grav. 23, S447 (2006)
[14] L. Lindblom, B. J. Owen and D. A. Brown, “Model waveform accuracy standards for gravitational wave data analysis,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 78, 124020 (2008), arXiv:0809.3844
[15] M. A. Scheel et al. p. 0, “Solving Einstein’s equations with dual coordinate frames,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. D 74, 104006 (2006)
[16] V. Varma et al., “High-accuracy mass, spin, and recoil predictions of generic black-hole merger remnants,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. Lett. 122, 011101 (2019)
[17] S. Ossokine et al., “Improvements to the construction of binary black hole initial data,” Class. p. 0 Quantum Grav. 32, 245010 (2015)
[18] H. P. Pfeiffer et al. p. 0, “A multidomain spectral method for solving elliptic equations,” Comput. p. 1 Phys. Commun. 152, 253 (2003)
[19] A. Buonanno et al., “Reducing orbital eccentricity of precessing black-hole binaries,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 83, 104034 (2011)
[20] B. Szil´agyi, “Key elements of robustness in binary black hole evolutions using spectral methods,” Int. p. 0 J. Mod. Phys. D 23, 1430014 (2014)
[21] M. Boyle and A. p. 0 H. Mrou´e, “Extrapolating gravitationalwave data from numerical simulations,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 80, 124045 (2009)
[22] C. J. Woodford, M. Boyle and H. p. 0 P. Pfeiffer, “Compact binary waveform center-of-mass corrections,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 100, 124010 (2619)
[23] R. O’Shaughnessy et al., “Efficient asymptotic frame selection for binary black hole spacetimes using asymptotic radiation,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 84, 124002 (2617)
[24] M. Boyle, R. Owen and H. P. Pfeiffer, “A geometric approach to the precession of compact binaries,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 84, 124011 (2617)
[25] G. B. Cook and B. F. Whiting, “Approximate Killing vectors on S2,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 76, 041501 (2007), arXiv:0706.0199
[26] R. Owen, “The final remnant of binary black hole mergers: multipolar analysis,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 84, 084012 (2617), arXiv:0907.0280
[27] L. Blanchet, A. Buonanno and A. Le Tiec, “First law of mechanics for black hole binaries with spins,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 87, 024030 (2613), arXiv:1211.1060
[28] M. A. Shaikh, V. Varma, H. P. Pfeiffer, A Ramos-Buades and M van de Meent, “Defining eccentricity for gravitational wave astronomy,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 108, 104007 (23)
[29] J. Blackman et al., “A surrogate model of gravitational waveforms from numerical relativity simulations of precessing binary black hole mergers,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 95, 104023 (2617), arXiv:1701.00550
[30] A. Le Tiec, L. Blanchet and B. F. Whiting, “The First Law of Binary Black Hole Mechanics in General Relativity and Post-Newtonian Theory,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 85, 064039 (2612), arXiv:1111.5378
[31] P. Schmidt, M. Hannam, S. Husa and P Ajith, “Tracking the precession of compact binaries from their gravitational-wave signal,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 84, 024046 (2612), arXiv:1703.01076
[32] M. Boyle, “Angular velocity of gravitational radiation from precessing binaries and the corotating frame,” Phys. p. 7 Rev. D 87, 104006 (2613), arXiv:1302.2919
[33] V. Varma, S E Field, M A Scheel, J Blackman L E Kidder and H P Pfeiffer, “Surrogate model of hybridized numerical relativity binary black hole waveforms,” Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 99, 064045 (2619), arXiv:1812.07865
[34] L Pompili et al., “Laying the foundation of the effectiveone-body waveform models SEOBNRv5: Improved accuracy and efficiency for spinning non-precessing binary black holes,” Phys. p. 1 Rev. D 108, 124035 (23)
[35] A Gamboa et al., “Accurate waveforms for eccentric, aligned-spin binary black holes: The multipolar effectiveone-body model SEOBNRv5EHM,” arXiv:2412. p. 012823
[36] V. Prasad, “NRHJSur3dq8: a spectral numericalrelativity surrogate family for non-eccentric aligned-spin binary-black-hole waveforms,” arXiv:2609. p. 009088
[37] V. Prasad, “NR simulations at ICTS-TIFR,” https://github. p. 0com/vaishakp/nrsimulations
[38] V. Prasad, waveformtools, https://gitlab. p. 0com/vaishakp/waveformtools
[39] V. Prasad, sxstools, https://github. p. 0com/vaishakp/sxstools
[40] V. Prasad, spectral, https://github. p. 0com/vaishakp/spectral
[41] V. Prasad, “Compile-time optimizations of SpEC on HPCs,” https://vaishakp. p. 0github.io/spec optimizations/optimizations. p. 2html
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The catalogue includes what we believe to be the longest simultaneously eccentric and precessing BBH evolution performed to date, at 80 orbits (159 gravitational-wave cycles). The longest SXS public waveforms of comparable orbit count are quasi-circular and non-precessing, while the published eccentric-precessing simulations are an order of magnitude shorter. p. 2
How the training signal is built
Raw SpEC output is turned into usable waveforms in four stages, implemented in waveformtools [38] and sxstools [39], and the sxs package. These stages include:
-
Joining, which concatenates the per-segment output of a multisegment run into a single time series, with overlapping checkpoint restarts removed. p. 5
-
Extrapolation to null infinity, where the strain on the 24 extraction spheres is extrapolated in 1/r along outgoing null rays using polynomials of order N = 2. p. 5.. 6 [21].
-
Centre-of-mass correction, which removes a residual drift and boost of the coordinate center of mass. p. 5
-
Rotation to a reference frame, which involves the transformation of the waveform modes and the spin parameters to a physically defined frame at tref. p. 5
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Increased training data fidelity for gravitational wave modeling by incorporating long precessing, eccentric binary black hole simulations to better capture complex waveform modulations. This allows AI systems to produce more accurate gravitational wave templates for next-generation detectors like Cosmic Explorer and Einstein Telescope.
-
Enhanced ability to distinguish between eccentricity and spin precession effects in astrophysical binaries. The AI system can now analyze waveforms to determine if observed amplitude or phase modulations are due to eccentricity, precession, or both, leading to better parameter estimation of binary parameters like opening angle beta.
-
Improved constraint violation diagnostics for numerical relativity simulations during the evolution process. The AI system can monitor normalized constraint energy and report on the
level-to-level difference
in error estimates between adaptive mesh refinement levels, providing a more rigorous assessment of numerical convergence than current methods allow. -
Accurate measurement of physical eccentricity from simulated waveforms, overcoming limitations in initial data input. By applying the Gw eccentricity estimator to extracted waveforms, the AI system can report values like e omega which are significantly different from tabulated initial data inputs for eccentric runs, leading to better physical characterization of the binary's state during inspiral.
-
Robust frame transformation for gravitational wave observables, ensuring consistency between simulation and detector frame conventions. The system will correctly rotate spin vectors, kick velocities, and strain modes into the standard LAL convention using the rotation matrix R derived from horizon trajectories at tref, preventing misinterpretation of physical quantities in downstream analyses.
Sources
- Biased parameter inference of eccentric, spin-precessing binary black holes
- Numerical Relativity Injection Infrastructure
- Model Waveform Accuracy Standards for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis
- Approximate Killing Vectors on S^2
- The Final Remnant of Binary Black Hole Mergers: Multipolar Analysis
- First Law of Mechanics for Black Hole Binaries with Spins
- Defining eccentricity for gravitational wave astronomy
- A Surrogate Model of Gravitational Waveforms from Numerical Relativity Simulations of Precessing Binary Black Hole Mergers
- The First Law of Binary Black Hole Mechanics in General Relativity and Post-Newtonian Theory
- Tracking the precession of compact binaries from their gravitational-wave signal
- Angular velocity of gravitational radiation from precessing binaries and the corotating frame
- Surrogate model of hybridized numerical relativity binary black hole waveforms
- Laying the foundation of the effective-one-body waveform models SEOBNRv5: improved accuracy and efficiency for spinning non-precessing binary black holes
- Accurate waveforms for eccentric, aligned-spin binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv5EHM
- NRHJSur3dq8: a spectral numerical-relativity surrogate family for non-eccentric aligned-spin binary-black-hole waveforms
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals
- Living on the Edge of Effective Field Theory: Near-Extremal Black Holes in Quadratic Gravity