Crater Scaling Relationships for Gas Impingement on Planetary Regolith

arXiv:2611.16040 · astro-ph.EP, astro-ph.IM · Submitted 2026-11-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Crater Scaling Relationships for Gas Impingement on Planetary Regolith".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Plume-surface interaction (PSI) effects remains a major uncertainty for operations on regolith-covered planetary bodies Resolving this problem is important not only for spacecraft safety, but also because controlled thruster interactions could provide an active geotechnical experiment during asteroid reconnaissance.

Vera: The surfaces of rocky and icy small solar system bodies can be covered by a layer of unconsolidated pebbles, cobbles, and boulders, that is often termed regolith.

Jocelyn: The geotechnical properties of a small body’s regolith and interior, such as particle size distribution and shape, bulk density, porosity, cohesion, and angle of internal friction are critical aspects for the design of in-situ exploration (R.

Vera: D.

Title and authors: Jocelyn: Let's look at the title again, "Crater Scaling Relationships for Gas Impingement on Planetary Regolith." It sounds very specific about what they are testing here.

Vera: It’s about relating the size of a crater formed by gas—like nitrogen gas—to the properties of both the gas itself and the target material, which is that regolith.

Subrahmanyan: So it’s not just about hitting something; it’s about how that interaction scales with different conditions like gravity and nozzle shape >

Jocelyn: The paper uses this to build a general scaling relationship. They show they can describe the volume of a gas crater based on the gas, the target, the gravity, and even the nozzle properties.

Vera: That means if we know those input variables—the gas type, how heavy it is relative to gravity—we should be able to predict how big a crater will be before we actually test it in space.

The paper's summary: Subrahmanyan: So the core idea is using these scaling relationships to predict outcomes for unknown surfaces, which is crucial because we don't know much about asteroid interiors beforehand >

Jocelyn: They are taking what they found in laboratory experiments—near-vacuum, pulsed nitrogen gas in a cohesionless regolith analog—and comparing it to other tests too.

Vera: They’re adapting something called projectile-cratering scaling, and they found that this relationship can describe the gas crater volume as a function of the gas, the target, gravity, and nozzle properties >

Subrahmanyan: The paper gives a general equation for this in the gravity regime: pi Vg equals K1 times alpha to two times pi h to negative one over three plus K2 times alpha to minus one over three times pi Y,g multiplied by two plus mu divided by two minus mu divided by two plus mu >

Jocelyn: They found scaling constants K1 and mu for the cohesionless experiments, which were K1 equals zero point seven seven and mu equals zero point five five >

Vera: And they even compared this to a low-gravity drop-tower experiment result, which fit within one sigma of the gravity regime relationship, giving some support for its validity across different gravitational settings >

The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors are looking ahead about what needs to be done next. They suggest that future work should focus on sensitivity to target properties and long-duration thrusting effects >

Subrahmanyan: That’s smart. If we can constrain the material properties better, it directly helps with designing planetary defense strategies, which is a big deal for missions like DART >

Jocelyn: They also flag that their current calibration is limited in several areas: gravity, target strength, firing duration, and thruster class >

Vera: So what this means for us on the ground is that we need more data to make these predictions really robust. It's not a complete picture yet >

Conclusion: Jocelyn: So to wrap up, this paper provides a preliminary crater-volume scaling framework that lets us predict crater volumes from known maneuver and surface conditions >

Vera: And more importantly, it suggests we can use the dimensions of thruster craters to constrain those poorly known regolith properties >

Subrahmanyan: This supports the idea that spacecraft thrusters could serve as active geotechnical tools during future small-body reconnaissance missions >

Jocelyn: It’s a path toward using these interactions not just for safety, but for actually learning about the geology of these bodies >

Vera: That's what it is. We can use the thruster interaction itself as an active experiment while we’re exploring asteroid surfaces >

Ronald L. Ballouz, Olivier S. Barnouin, Mitsuhisa Baba, Vicki L. Toy-Edens, Noble Hatten, Parvathy Prem, Maarij Qureshi

Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory · JAXA · ÈInstitut Supérieur de l’ Aeronautique et de l’ Espace, Universitǩ de Toulouse

astro-ph.EP, astro-ph.IM

Submitted: 2026-11-11

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 45 pages, 12 figures, submitted to the Planetary Science Journal

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Plume-surface interaction (PSI) effects remains a major uncertainty for operations on regolith-covered planetary bodies Resolving this problem is important not only for spacecraft safety…

Key concepts

Regolith Geotechnical Properties
These are the physical characteristics of surface material like pebbles and rocks covering planetary bodies. Key factors include particle size distribution, shape, bulk density, porosity, cohesion (stickiness), and the angle at which particles naturally settle.
Crater Scaling Relationships
This is a mathematical model that relates the physical size and volume of an impact crater to various input variables such as the gas used for excavation, gravity on the body, nozzle design, and target material properties. It helps predict outcomes before conducting costly experiments.
Gas Crater Volume Scaling Relationship
A specific equation derived from experiments that describes how the volume of a crater created by gas impingement scales with several factors: the gas used, the target material's properties, the local gravity, and the nozzle geometry. This relationship is crucial for predicting excavation outcomes on unknown surfaces.
Cohesionless vs. Cohesive Targets
The study primarily focused on cohesionless gravel to simplify initial modeling. However, future work aims to generalize these scaling relationships to cohesive soils where the material has internal strength, which would introduce a term accounting for how the material's strength influences particle mobilization during excavation.

Terminology

Summary

Plume-surface interaction (PSI) effects remains a major uncertainty for operations on regolith-covered planetary bodies Resolving this problem is important not only for spacecraft safety, but also because controlled thruster interactions could provide an active geotechnical experiment during asteroid reconnaissance. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Although spacecraft exhaust can erode surfaces, form craters, and accelerate ejecta, existing PSI relationships are largely derived for scenario-specific lunar and Martian landing conditions and are not yet reliably generalizable. Resolving this problem is important not only for spacecraft safety, but also because controlled thruster interactions could provide an active geotechnical experiment during asteroid reconnaissance.

Introduction to the Problem

The surfaces of rocky and icy small solar system bodies can be covered by a layer of unconsolidated pebbles, cobbles, and boulders, that is often termed regolith. The geotechnical properties of a small body’s regolith and interior, such as particle size distribution and shape, bulk density, porosity, cohesion, and angle of internal friction are critical aspects for the design of in-situ exploration (R. p. 1

Where the paper says it

INTRODUCTION The surfaces of rocky and icy small solar system bodies can be covered by a layer of unconsolidated pebbles, cobbles, and boulders, that is often termed regolith. The geotechnical properties of a small body’s regolith and interior, such as particle size distribution and shape, bulk density, porosity, cohesion, and angle of internal friction, are critical aspects for the design of in-situ exploration (R.

D. Lorenz 2011). p. 1
Where the paper says it

The geotechnical properties of a small body’s regolith and interior, such as particle size distribution and shape, bulk density, porosity, cohesion, and angle of internal friction, are critical aspects for the design of in-situ exploration (R. Lorenz 2011) and planetary defense missions (A.

Historically, little is known about an asteroid or comet’s regolith geotechnical properties a-priori and extrapolations from prior surface exploration missions are typically used to justify design choices and operation strategies. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Stickle et al. Historically, little is known about an asteroid or comet’s regolith geotechnical properties a-priori and extrapolations from prior surface exploration missions are typically used to justify design choices and operation strategies.

The near-surface and interior geotechnical properties of an asteroid are critical to the design of planetary defense strategies. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the event of the discovery of a hazardous asteroid, spacecraft reconnaissance can provide valuable information on the asteroid’s physical properties in order to formulate an optimized mitigation strategy. The near-surface and interior geotechnical properties of an asteroid are critical to the design of planetary defense strategies.

Cratering as a Geotechnical Probe

Impact craters are ubiquitous on planetary surfaces. For asteroids, crater-scaling relationships can relate a crater’s physical properties to the asteroid’s surface gravity, density, and strength and the impactor’s radius, density, and impact speed. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Housen et al. For asteroids, crater-scaling relationships can relate a crater’s physical properties to the asteroid’s surface gravity, density, and strength and the impactor’s radius, density, and impact speed.

The OSIRIS-REx mission sampled the surface of asteroid Bennu through a touch-and-go (TAG) maneuver that involved contact of the TAG sample acquisition mechanism (TAGSAM), penetration of the TAGSAM into the Bennu regolith for ∼1 s, and firing of pressurized nitrogen gas (N2) from the TAGSAM. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Watanabe et al. NASA’s OSIRIS-REx mission sampled the surface of asteroid Bennu through a touch-and-go (TAG) maneuver that involved: 1) contact of the TAG sample acquisition mechanism (TAGSAM), which

This combination led to an elliptical crater with dimensions of 9. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Bierhaus et al. The combination of TAGSAM penetration, TAGSAM gas firing, and thruster firing led to the formation of an elliptical crater with dimensions of 9.

0 by 6.5 m, with its long axis oriented from the asteroid’s north-to-south poles. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The combination of TAGSAM penetration, TAGSAM gas firing, and thruster firing led to the formation of an elliptical crater with dimensions of 9. 5 m, with its long axis oriented from the asteroid’s north-to-south poles.

Gas Impingement and Scaling Relationships

The authors investigate gas-driven excavation using near-vacuum, pulsed-N2 experiments in a cohesionless asteroid regolith analog and comparisons with a low-gravity droptower experiment and historical chemical-thruster tests. They adapt projectile-cratering π-scaling, finding that these relationships can describe gas crater volume as a function of gas, target, gravity, and nozzle properties. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We investigate gas-driven excavation using near-vacuum, pulsed-N2 experiments in a cohesionless asteroid regolith analog and comparisons with a low-gravity droptower experiment and historical chemical-thruster tests. We adapt projectile-cratering π-scaling, and find that these relationships can describe gas crater volume as a function Email: ronald.

The general gas crater volume scaling relationship in the gravity regime is given by Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

A common gravity-regime relationship describes the laboratory data and is consistent with an experimental low-gravity result. Generalizing the π-scaling relationship for cohesive targets shows consistency with Apollo-era chemical-thruster cases.

14: πV,g = K1[π2,gπhπ−1/34 + K2(π−1/34 πY,g)(2+µ)/2] −3µ/(2+µ).

Experimental Methodology and Findings

The experiments were conducted at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory’s Impact Lab (IL) using a light gas gun to perform gas-only “impact” experiments. The regolith targets were made of a cohesionless gravel with a bimodal particle distribution intended to mimic the properties of the surface material seen on Bennu. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(2026) concluded that variability in surface response to the thrusters indicated that the material properties of the sampling site regolith varied laterally. Cratering as a probe of small body interior geotechnical properties The irregular mass distribution inside rubble-pile asteroids is manifested in their gravity field.

The resulting craters had diameters, D, from 17 cm to 32 cm and depths, d, from 3. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Toy-Edens,1 Noble Hatten,1 Parvathy Prem , 1 Maarij Qureshi , 1 and Cecily Sunday 3 1Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory, Laurel, MD 20723, USA 2JAXA, Sagamihara, Kanagawa , 252-5210, Japan 3 Institut Sup´erieur de l’A´eronautique et de l’Espace, Universit´e de Toulouse, Toulouse, 31055, France ABSTRACT Plume-surface interaction (PSI) effects remains a major uncertainty for operations on regolith-covered planetary bodies. Although spacecraft exhaust can erode surfaces, form craters, and accelerate ejecta, existing PSI relationships are largely derived for scenario-specific lunar and Martian landing conditions and are not yet reliably generalizable.

1 to 9.6 cm. The normalized nozzle height plays an important role in determining the depth-to-diameter ratio of gas craters. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(2025a) investigated the influence of ambient pressure outside the nozzle, Pa, on PSI, as gaseous flows have different behaviors at reduced ambient pressures due to gas molecule interactions. The degree to which a fluid can be treated as a continuum is typically parameterized through the Knudsen number, Kn, a dimensionless number that is the ratio of the molecular mean free path, λ, to a characteristic length of gas flow, L: Kn = λ L = kBTa √ 2πd2 aPaD , (4) where kB is the Boltzmann constant, Ta is the ambient temperature, and da is the diameter of the atmospheric particle (M.

General Scaling and Future Work

The analysis yielded scaling constants K1 = 0.77 and µ = 0.55 for the cohesionless 1-g experiments. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Such information is particularly relevant to planetary defense, where uncertainty in near-surface properties can strongly affect the outcome of kinetic-impact mitigation and the interpretation of momentum transfer. We investigate gas-driven excavation using near-vacuum, pulsed-N2 experiments in a cohesionless asteroid regolith analog and comparisons with a low-gravity droptower experiment and historical chemical-thruster tests.

The low-gravity drop-tower experiment result falls within the 1-sigma uncertainty of the gravity-regime relationship, providing supporting evidence for its validity across gravity regimes. p. 1
Where the paper says it

of gas, target, gravity, and nozzle properties. A common gravity-regime relationship describes the laboratory data and is consistent with an experimental low-gravity result.

Future work should focus on sensitivity to target properties, long-duration thrusting effects, and gas-crater ejecta-scaling relationships. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Crater Scaling Relationships for Gas Impingement 7 trackable ejecta at multiple points on the surface of a PHA. Characterization of the thruster-formed crater and tracking of ejected particles can be used to estimate the geotechnical properties of a PHA.

The present calibration remains limited in gravity, target strength, firing duration, and thruster class. p. 3
Where the paper says it

For asteroids, crater-scaling relationships can relate a crater’s physical properties to the asteroid’s surface gravity, density, and strength and the impactor’s radius, density, and impact speed. When the impactor and impact parameters are known, then an observed crater’s size may be used to estimate target properties.

Conclusion

The results provide a preliminary crater-volume scaling framework that offers a path toward predicting crater volumes from known maneuver and surface conditions and, ultimately, toward using observed thruster crater dimensions to constrain otherwise poorly known regolith properties. This framework supports the broader concept that spacecraft thrusters could serve as active geotechnical tools during future small-body reconnaissance missions. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Generalizing the π-scaling relationship for cohesive targets shows consistency with Apollo-era chemical-thruster cases. These results provide a framework for using spacecraft thrusters as active geotechnical tools during small-body reconnaissance.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory and a NASA Yearly Opportunities for Research in Planetary Defense grant, award 80NSSC25K7434. C.S. acknowledges support from CNES. ChatGPT-5.6 Sol was used to convert tables and equations to the LATEXformat. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Stickle et al. Historically, little is known about an asteroid or comet’s regolith geotechnical properties a-priori and extrapolations from prior surface exploration missions are typically used to justify design choices and operation strategies.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system will be able to estimate near-surface geotechnical properties of Potentially Hazardous Asteroids (PHAs) by utilizing spacecraft thrusters as active geotechnical tools during small-body reconnaissance. This allows for constraining regolith density, strength, porosity, and particle properties that are otherwise difficult to determine remotely.

  2. Improved system can predict the outcome of gas cratering experiments on unknown surfaces by applying a general gas crater volume scaling relationship derived from laboratory and low-gravity experiments. This framework relates crater volume as a function of gas, target, gravity, and nozzle properties using the equation pi Vg = K1[pi2,g pi h pi-1/3 4 + K2(pi-1/3 4 piY,g) (2+mu)/2] -3mu/(2+mu).

  3. Improved system can generalize crater scaling relationships for cohesive targets by incorporating a strength term into the formalism. This allows it to predict outcomes for cohesive soils where viscous erosion may become the dominant mode of regolith particle mobilization.

Abstract

Plume-surface interaction (PSI) effects remains a major uncertainty for operations on regolith-covered planetary bodies. Although spacecraft exhaust can erode surfaces, form craters, and accelerate ejecta, existing PSI relationships are largely derived for scenario-specific lunar and Martian landing conditions and are not yet reliably generalizable. Resolving this problem is important not only for spacecraft safety, but also because controlled thruster interactions could provide an active geotechnical experiment during asteroid reconnaissance. Measurements of thruster-formed craters and ejecta may constrain regolith density, strength, porosity, and particle properties that are otherwise difficult to determine remotely. Such information is particularly relevant to planetary defense, where uncertainty in near-surface properties can strongly affect the outcome of kinetic-impact mitigation and the interpretation of momentum transfer. We investigate gas-driven excavation using near-vacuum, pulsed-N 2 experiments in a cohesionless asteroid regolith analog and comparisons with a low-gravity drop-tower experiment and historical chemical-thruster tests. We adapt projectile-cratering π-scaling, and find that these relationships can describe gas crater volume as a function of gas, target, gravity, and nozzle properties. A common gravity-regime relationship describes the laboratory data and is consistent with an experimental low-gravity result. Generalizing the π-scaling relationship for cohesive targets shows consistency with Apollo-era chemical-thruster cases. These results provide a framework for using spacecraft thrusters as active geotechnical tools during small-body reconnaissance.

Related papers