An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque

arXiv:2611.07060 · astro-ph.EP, physics.geo-ph · Submitted 2026-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The thermodynamic acceleration induced by atmospheric thermal tides significantly impacts the rotation of temperate rocky planets where gravitational and radiative tidal forcings are comparable in strength, driving them away from synchronous rotation and affecting their climate, large-scale circulation, and surface conditions.

Vera: The primary objective is to constrain the dependence of the thermotidal torque on tidal frequency and physical parameters characterizing the star-planet system.

Jocelyn: An analytical model successfully reproduces present-day thermotidal bulge and torque inferred from barometric observations when direct absorption is assumed, showing good agreement with General Circulation Model (GCM) results, accurately capturing frequency dependence for both paleo-Earth and present-day Earth.

Vera: The solutions capture the torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification associated with Lamb-wave resonance.

Paper summary: Vera: So we’re looking at this paper titled "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque." Basically, they’re showing how these thermal tides in our atmosphere can actually change how fast a planet spins when the gravitational and radiative forces are pretty similar in strength Jocelyn right?

Jocelyn: Exactly, Vera. The main thing this paper claims is that this thermodynamic acceleration caused by the atmospheric thermal tides really impacts the rotation of temperate rocky planets, pushing them away from spinning in sync with their stars Subrahmanyan so it affects their climate and how things move around on the surface.

Vera: And they want to get a better handle on how much that thermotidal torque depends on two things: the frequency of the tide and these physical parameters describing the star-planet system Jocelyn like mass and radius.

Jocelyn: Right, so they’re trying to constrain this dependence, which is important because it tells us a lot about what's happening physically there Subrahmanyan. They use an analytical model that successfully reproduces the present-day thermotidal bulge and torque we see from barometric observations when they assume direct absorption Vera of the heat.

Vera: But they also show how well this model matches results from General Circulation Models, GCMs, capturing frequency dependence for both paleo-Earth and our present Earth Jocelyn. They even capture that torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification that happens when you get Lamb-wave resonance Subrahmanyan.

Subrahmanyan: That's interesting because near that resonance point, the GCM results show a braking torque with a larger amplitude than the accelerating torque Vera so they reproduce this by allowing tidal heating to lag behind insolation. It suggests that in benchmark simulations, the thermal tides are driven mostly by an indirect thermal forcing characterized by a substantial time delay Jocelyn.

Jocelyn: That phase lag is significant for rotational evolution because it can strongly suppress or attenuate the accelerative tidal torque near Lamb-wave resonance Vera which means we can't just assume direct absorption is what dominates semidiurnal tides on present-day Earth.

Vera: So, they go on to derive explicit formulas for the thermotidal torque based on atmospheric parameters for both isentropic and isothermal atmospheres Jocelyn and apply this model to present-day Earth using actual barometric measurements Subrahmanyan. They characterize frequency dependence through functional analysis and compare their analytical theory against GCM simulations for Earth, Venus, and dry rocky planets Vera.

Jocelyn: A key finding is the derived scaling laws characterizing the resonant peak properties as functions of dimensionless control parameters like the adiabatic index Subrahmanyan. They conclude that inferred tidal heating is characterized by substantial phase lags and large effective absorption fractions that don't match just assuming direct atmospheric absorption alone Vera.

Vera: This suggests a stalled day length of approximately nineteen hours would require a resonant day length between seventeen hours and eighteen hours depending on whether the tidal heating is delayed or in phase with insolation Jocelyn. The analytical solution they develop can be put right into planetary evolution models to look at equilibrium states and long-term rotational evolution Subrahmanyan.

Jocelyn: In a detailed analysis, they approximated the resonant daylength, which they call LODL;two to be twenty-two point one hours, which is only about zero point five percent larger than some previous best fits for that resonant daylength Vera. They also found estimated values for the dimensionless parameter epsilon to be around zero point two four three for an isentropic atmosphere and zero point one nine eight for an isothermal one Subrahmanyan.

Subrahmanyan: Those epsilon values are about five percent smaller than what they got numerically using minimization methods, which is consistent with the error you get when you reduce series to leading-order terms, which is order epsilon squared Jocelyn <ref:2611.07060#pg3>. They also deduced phase angles: phi lag around zero point two two four radians and phi H around zero point five one three radians for the isentropic case or zero point three eight seven for the isothermal case Vera.

Vera: The accuracy of these inferred parameters is limited by how well we can resolve the frequencies in GCM datasets, with a ratio of zero point zero two three corresponding to an uncertainty of about two point three percent in figuring out LODL;two Jocelyn. That uncertainty then carries over to all the other quantities they inferred and adds to that epsilon squared error Subrahmanyan.

Jocelyn: So, what this means for us is that we need a more complete picture of how these atmospheric tides interact with the planet's rotation, especially near resonance Vera because the phase lag suggests our simple direct absorption model might be missing something important. The paper "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque" gives us a better tool for modeling this interaction Subrahmanyan.

Conclusion: Vera: So, we’ve been talking about how atmospheric thermal tides affect planetary rotation, and now we’re looking at the conclusion of this paper titled "An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque."

Jocelyn: It wraps up the whole idea that they built this model to figure out exactly how much that thermal bulge actually kicks a planet into spin or slows it down.

Subrahmanyan: They used this analytical framework to test different atmospheric conditions, both isentropic and isothermal, on Earth, Venus, and other rocky planets.

Vera: The main thing they found is that the inferred tidal heating isn't just simple direct absorption of heat from the atmosphere alone. It requires a substantial time delay between when the atmosphere heats up and when it actually transfers that torque to the planet.

Jocelyn: That phase lag is crucial because it can strongly suppress or even cancel out that accelerative torque, especially near those resonance points where things get really interesting.

Subrahmanyan: So, this suggests that our current simple models for how atmosphere and planet interact are missing a big piece of the puzzle regarding rotational evolution over long timescales.

Vera: Right. They also found some specific numbers for these atmospheric parameters, like a resonant daylength around twenty-two point one hours, which is pretty close to what some previous studies suggested they were finding.

Jocelyn: The uncertainty in those inferred parameters comes mostly from how well the General Circulation Models can resolve the frequencies in their simulations, with that uncertainty adding some error to their final numbers.

Subrahmanyan: If we can use this analytical framework effectively, it gives us a way to input these complex tidal interactions into planetary evolution models for long-term rotational history.

Vera: It’s a solid tool for seeing how those atmospheric dynamics translate into real physical changes on the surface of rocky worlds.

Jocelyn: And understanding that phase lag really opens the door to exploring what happens when we look at things like day length stability in more detail.

Pierre Auclair-Desrotour, Jacques Laskar, Mohammad Farhat, Gwenaël Boué

Observatoire de Paris · University of California, Berkeley

astro-ph.EP, physics.geo-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: 26 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

Code: https://github.com/JuliaNLSolvers/LsqFit.jl

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 96/100

The gist: The thermodynamic acceleration induced by atmospheric thermal tides significantly impacts the rotation of temperate rocky planets where gravitational and radiative tidal forcings are comparable in…

Key concepts

Thermotidal Torque
This is the force exerted by atmospheric thermal tides on a planet that influences its rotation. The paper seeks to constrain how this torque depends on the tidal frequency and the physical characteristics of the star-planet system.
Lamb-wave Resonance
This occurs when tidal forcing matches a natural oscillation frequency within the planet's atmosphere, leading to significant amplification of rotational effects. The model shows that near this resonance, a braking torque can become larger than the accelerating torque.
Phase Lag ($\varphi_{lag}$)
The study found that tidal heating is characterized by a substantial time delay or phase lag relative to insolation. This lag suggests the thermal tides are driven by indirect forcing, which can suppress or attenuate the accelerative tidal torque near resonance.

Terminology

Summary

The thermodynamic acceleration induced by atmospheric thermal tides significantly impacts the rotation of temperate rocky planets where gravitational and radiative tidal forcings are comparable in strength, driving them away from synchronous rotation and affecting their climate, large-scale circulation, and surface conditions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The thermodynamic acceleration induced by atmospheric thermal tides has a major impact on the rotation of temperate rocky planets, where gravitational and radiative tidal forcings are of comparable strength. This acceleration drives planets away from synchronous rotation, thereby affecting their climate, large-scale circulation, and surface conditions.

The primary objective is to constrain the dependence of the thermotidal torque on tidal frequency and physical parameters characterizing the star-planet system. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This acceleration drives planets away from synchronous rotation, thereby affecting their climate, large-scale circulation, and surface conditions. These implications underline the need to better constrain the dependence of the thermotidal torque on the tidal frequency and on the physical parameters characterising the star-planet system, as this relationship remains insufficiently understood.

An analytical model successfully reproduces present-day thermotidal bulge and torque inferred from barometric observations when direct absorption is assumed, showing good agreement with General Circulation Model (GCM) results, accurately capturing frequency dependence for both paleo-Earth and present-day Earth. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The analytical model reproduces the present-day thermotidal bulge and torque inferred from barometric observations when direct absorption is assumed. It also agrees well with GCM results, accurately capturing the frequency dependence of both surfacepressure oscillation amplitudes and tidal torque for paleo-Earth, as well as that of the tidal torque for present-day Earth.

The solutions capture the torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification associated with Lamb-wave resonance. p. 0
Where the paper says it

It also agrees well with GCM results, accurately capturing the frequency dependence of both surfacepressure oscillation amplitudes and tidal torque for paleo-Earth, as well as that of the tidal torque for present-day Earth. More generally, the solutions capture the torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification associated with Lamb-wave resonance, although incomplete GCM spectra limit some quantitative comparisons.

Crucially, near resonance, GCM results indicate a braking torque of larger amplitude than the accelerating torque; this is reproduced by allowing tidal heating to lag behind insolation, suggesting that thermal tides in benchmark simulations are driven predominantly by an indirect thermal forcing characterized by a substantial time delay, unlike direct absorption dominating semidiurnal tides on present-day Earth. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The agreement with GCM spectra constrains the free parameters of our model. It further suggests that thermal tides in the benchmark simulations are driven predominantly by an indirect thermal forcing characterised by a substantial time delay, in contrast to the direct absorption of sunlight that dominates semidiurnal tides on present-day Earth.

This phase lag has important implications for rotational evolution, as it can strongly attenuate or suppress the accelerative tidal torque near Lamb-wave resonance. p. 0
Where the paper says it

It also agrees well with GCM results, accurately capturing the frequency dependence of both surfacepressure oscillation amplitudes and tidal torque for paleo-Earth, as well as that of the tidal torque for present-day Earth. More generally, the solutions capture the torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification associated with Lamb-wave resonance, although incomplete GCM spectra limit some quantitative comparisons.

The study derives explicit formulations of the thermotidal torque as functions of atmospheric parameters for isentropic and isothermal atmospheres and applies the model to present-day Earth using empirical barometric measurements. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2, we derive explicit formulations of the thermotidal torque as functions of the atmospheric parameters for both isentropic and isothermal atmospheres. Additionally, we apply the model to the presentday Earth, for which the semidiurnal tidal bulge is determined empirically from barometric measurements.

The analysis characterizes frequency dependence through functional analysis and benchmarks the analytical theory against GCM simulations for Earth, Venus, and dry rocky planets. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Section 3 characterises the frequency dependence of the tidal response through a quantitative functional analysis. 4, the analytical theory is benchmarked against recent GCM simulations addressing the cases of Earth, Venus and dry rocky planets.

Key results include derived scaling laws characterizing resonant peak properties as functions of dimensionless control parameters, such as the adiabatic index. p. 3
Where the paper says it

(8)); γ, ζ, and λ are dimensionless parameters given by (Paper I, Eqs. (30) and (77)) ζ “ " ´κ (isentropic), 0 (isothermal), γ “ ζ ` κ, λ “ 1 ´ iα p1 ` ζq 2 p1 ´ iαq , (17) with κ “ pΓ1 ´ 1q {Γ1 being a function of the adiabatic index, Γ1, and α “ σC{σ denoting the ratio between the Newtonian cooling frequency, σC, and the tidal frequency, σ.

The study concludes that inferred tidal heating is characterized by substantial phase lags and large effective absorption fractions, departing markedly from the assumption of direct atmospheric absorption alone. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Consequences of phase-shifted tidal heating In Sect. 6, the thermal forcing inducing the semidiurnal thermal tides is assumed to be in phase with insolation, which corresponds to the regime of direct absorption: the tidal bulge arises from the absorption of the incident stellar flux.

This suggests that a stalled day length of approximately 19 hr would require a resonant day length between 17 hr and 18 hr depending on whether tidal heating is delayed or in phase with insolation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Several studies have revisited the tidal-locking hypothesis proposed by Zahnle & Walker (1987), who suggested that the Earth’s length of day (hereafter LOD) may have remained nearly constant for several hundred million years as a result of a balance between thermal and gravitational tidal torques. This hypothesis relies on the resonant excitation of global-scale atmospheric compressibility modes known as Lamb waves (e.

The analytical solution is readily incorporated into planetary evolution models for investigating equilibrium states and long-term rotational evolution. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Earth – hydrodynamics – planet-star interactions – planets and satellites: atmospheres – planets and satellites: terrestrial planets. Introduction The long-term rotational evolution of atmosphere-bearing rocky planets located within the habitable zone of their host stars is governed by both gravitational and thermal tides.

In the detailed analysis, the resonant daylength (LODL;2) was approximated to be 22. p. 6

Where the paper says it

3 suggest that the GCM datasets of Deitrick & Goldblatt (2024) and Wu et al. (2023) are in fact characterised by the same resonant daylength, LODL;2 “ 22.

1 hr, which is only 0.5% larger than best-fitting values in prior studies for the resonant daylength. p. 6
Where the paper says it

However, they are 0. 2 hr larger than the 22 hr resonant LOD obtained by fitting the analytical model to the same GCM dataset (see Sect.

The normalized Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) is expressed as delta X 12;M proportional to LODL;2 over pLOD2 - LOD1q. Estimated values for the dimensionless parameter epsilon are found to be epsilon about 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

(6) The parameter cf introduced in Eqs. (5) and (6) is a dimensionless shape factor that quantifies the degree to which the latitudinal structure of semidiurnal pressure variations resembles a quadrupolar pattern.

243 (isentropic) and epsilon about 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Adopting Ts “ 288 K for present-day Earth (U. Standard Atmosphere Working Group 1976), we obtain T “ 243 K for the isentropic configuration via Eq.

198 (isothermal), which are approximately 5% smaller than those obtained numerically using minimization methods, consistent with the error of order epsilon squared introduced by reducing series to leading-order terms. The phase angle phi H is deduced from the ratio between the two extrema of the imaginary part, yielding phi lag about 0. p. 9
Where the paper says it

aa58544-25 sequently, the resulting atmospheric response is also delayed, which generates an offset in the imaginary part of surface pressure oscillations. We examine here how the phase of the tidal heating affects the dependence of the resulting thermotidal torque on tidal frequency.

224 rad and phi H about 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

For the isentropic configuration, where γ “ 0, we obtain σL;2 “ 1. 51 ˆ 10´4 rad s´1 .

513 rad (isentropic) or 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

For the isentropic configuration, where γ “ 0, we obtain σL;2 “ 1. 51 ˆ 10´4 rad s´1 .

387 rad (isothermal). p. 6
Where the paper says it

51 ˆ 10´4 rad s´1 . In the isothermal case, γ “ κ yields σL;2 “ 1.

The accuracy of inferred parameters is inherently limited by the frequency resolution of GCM datasets, with a ratio of 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The analytical model reproduces the present-day thermotidal bulge and torque inferred from barometric observations when direct absorption is assumed. It also agrees well with GCM results, accurately capturing the frequency dependence of both surfacepressure oscillation amplitudes and tidal torque for paleo-Earth, as well as that of the tidal torque for present-day Earth.

023 corresponding to an uncertainty of approximately 2. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, substantial variations may arise if a spherical harmonic of degree l ě 4 were resonantly amplified to amplitudes comparable to that of the degree2 component at the equator, as discussed in Sect. The empirical estimate inferred from Schindelegger & Ray (2014) further indicates that converting δˆp 2,σ s;2 into δp σ s;eq introduces a relative uncertainty of approximately 8% in the corresponding thermotidal torque.

3% in the determination of LODL;2, which propagates to all inferred quantities and adds to the epsilon squared uncertainty. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, substantial variations may arise if a spherical harmonic of degree l ě 4 were resonantly amplified to amplitudes comparable to that of the degree2 component at the equator, as discussed in Sect. The empirical estimate inferred from Schindelegger & Ray (2014) further indicates that converting δˆp 2,σ s;2 into δp σ s;eq introduces a relative uncertainty of approximately 8% in the corresponding thermotidal torque.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can accurately predict surface pressure oscillations for Earth by using Equation 6 and empirical constraints from Schindelegger & Ray (2014), achieving a predicted amplitude of 119.6 Pa when using the isentropic model at damping ratio epsilon equals 0.25.

  2. Improved AI can constrain free parameters like the radiative cooling time or absorbed flux fraction by fitting analytical solutions to numerical results from GCM simulations, providing an explicit relationship between resonance characteristics and key atmospheric parameters such as the adiabatic index and cooling time.

  3. Improved AI can determine if tidal locking is likely by comparing the resonant length of the day LODL with the LOD at which the change in torque's sign occurs, noting that the difference is not negligible, as it approximately corresponds to a 100 Myr gap in geological time for Earth.

  4. Improved AI can distinguish between heating mechanisms by analyzing the phase lag of tidal heating; specifically, it can identify that "the phase lag of tidal heating is sufficiently large to entirely offset the resonant advance of the thermotidal bulge, thereby suppressing the positive torque peak and leaving only its negative counterpart in the spectrum."

  5. Improved AI can estimate if a stalled day length of approximately 19 hr is required for geological evidence by comparing model predictions to those from GCM simulations like Wu et al. (2023) and Deitrick & Goldblatt (2024), noting that "the gap observed between model predictions and the scenario proposed by Mitchell & Kirscher (2023) and Wu et al. (2023) tends to corroborate the conclusions by Laskar et al. (2024), who note that there is no geological evidence for a stalled day length of 19 hr."

Abstract

The thermodynamic acceleration induced by atmospheric thermal tides has a major impact on the rotation of temperate rocky planets, where gravitational and radiative tidal forcings are of comparable strength. This acceleration drives planets away from synchronous rotation, thereby affecting their climate, large-scale circulation, and surface conditions. These implications underline the need to better constrain the dependence of the thermotidal torque on the tidal frequency and on the physical parameters characterising the star-planet system, as this relationship remains insufficiently understood. In particular, the role of resonantly excited Lamb waves requires clarification due to its potential impact on Earth's length of day (LOD) during the Precambrian. Building on a previous work, which provided a fully analytical formulation of the atmospheric tidal response of rocky planets, we apply this framework to isentropic and isothermal atmospheres. We perform a comprehensive functional analysis of the resulting torque and compare the analytical predictions with numerical solutions from earlier general circulation model (GCM) studies. The analytical model agrees well with GCM results, accurately capturing the frequency dependence of tidal torque both for paleo-Earth and present-day Earth. More generally, the solutions capture the torque peak near synchronous rotation and the amplification associated with Lamb-wave resonance. Near resonance, the GCM results exhibit a stronger braking torque than accelerating torque. This asymmetry is reproduced by allowing tidal heating to lag behind insolation. The agreement with GCM spectra suggests that thermal tides in the benchmark simulations are driven predominantly by an indirect thermal forcing characterised by a substantial time delay, in contrast to the direct absorption of sunlight that dominates semidiurnal tides on present-day Earth.

Related papers