Searching for Massive Scalar Fields with non-minimal Curvature Couplings in LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Ringdown Signals

arXiv:2611.15914 · gr-qc · Submitted 2026-11-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Searching for Massive Scalar Fields with non-minimal Curvature Couplings in LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Ringdown Signals".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We search for massive scalar fields with non-minimal curvature couplings using the loudest ringdown signals observed by LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA We find that current ringdown observations do not provide informative constraints on the scalar-field mass We nevertheless constrain the coupling length scale for scalar fields satisfying Mµ < 1, where µ is the scalar-field mass, yielding marginalized 90% credible upper limits of 60.4 km and 59.8 km for dynamical Chern–Simons and scalar Gauss–Bonnet couplings, respectively Theoretical Framework The theory considers two massive spin-0 fields coupled to quadratic curvature invariants, following Refs.

35, 56: The theory is described by the Lagrangian density given in Eq.

Mira: (1).

Kai: Here, ϑ1 is a scalar field of mass µ1 coupled to the Gauss–Bonnet invariant (G), while ϑ2 is a pseudoscalar field of mass µ2 coupled to the Pontryagin invariant (P).

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap what we just talked about, this paper investigates searching for massive scalar fields using the loudest ringdown signals from LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA. The core thesis is that these observations don't give us strong constraints on the mass of the scalar field itself.

Mira: And instead, they do manage to constrain the coupling length scale for two specific theories: dynamical Chern-Simons gravity and scalar Gauss-Bonnet gravity. These limits are derived from analyzing those ringdown signals.

Lev: The paper sets up this by considering two specific cases for the curvature couplings. They look at setting one of the coupling length scales to zero, which gives them massive scalar Gauss-Bonnet theory, and setting the other to zero, which gives them dynamical Chern-Simons gravity.

Kai: And they use some previously computed quasinormal mode spectra from a reference paper to perform this search across a range of observed gravitational wave events. They jointly infer the coupling length scale and the scalar field mass.

Mira: The methodology is pretty specific about what they're analyzing, including event selection, ringdown start times, and handling those extrinsic parameters from the merger itself. They also have to account for where their perturbation model actually holds up when they are sampling.

Lev: And to keep things valid within their search space, they impose some conditions during the sampling process that involve the coupling length scale being less than black hole mass and the scalar field mass being less than one.

Kai: So, it’s not just a theoretical exercise; they are applying it to real gravitational wave data like GW150914, GW190521 seventy-four thousand three hundred fifty-nine GW200129 sixty-five thousand four hundred fifty-eight GW231226 one hundred one thousand five hundred twenty and also the newer ones like GW250114 eighty-two thousand two hundred three.

Mira: That's a big sample of events they used for their analysis. The paper uses Bayesian inference with a tool called pyRing to do the time-domain analysis.

Lev: And what they find in the results is that when looking at the two dimensional posterior distribution in the coupling length scale and scalar field mass plane, support drops off quickly as you increase the coupling length scale.

Kai: But it's interesting because, even though they don't constrain the mass well, they still see some support right up to a mass of one for both theories.

Mira: That’s what makes this interesting: the analysis doesn't give us informative constraints on the scalar field mass when it is less than one, which is a result that needs careful interpretation.

Lev: So, what does that mean for the next steps? It suggests that while we can constrain the coupling scale under certain conditions, we aren't getting a tight handle on the fundamental mass parameter from these ringdown signals alone.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this discussion on "Searching for Massive Scalar Fields with non-minimal Curvature Couplings in LIGO-Virgo–KAGRA Ringdown Signals." The main authors are Adrian Ka-Wai Chung and the team at St John’s College and Cambridge.

Mira: The implication here is that gravitational wave observations can connect these Lagrangian densities in theories of fundamental physics to what we see astronomically. It shows how these different theoretical models can leave a footprint on the signals we detect.

Lev: And it points toward a future direction, which is using inspiral ringdown analysis instead of just ringdown alone to get more information. They suggest that by combining the information from scalar radiation during the inspiral with the mass-dependent quasinormal mode spectrum of the remnant, we could get complementary data.

Kai: So what they are suggesting is that a joint analysis approach could exploit both types of signals—the scalar radiation during the inspiral and the spectral dependence on remnant mass. It’s a way to gather more comprehensive information about these theories.

Mira: This spectral-inference framework they developed here could be adapted for searching for ultralight bosonic environments around stellar-mass black holes once we have better quasinormal mode spectra for those systems.

Lev: That sounds like a concrete path forward, focusing on how to make the models more predictive by using multiple pieces of data from a single event rather than just one aspect of the ringdown.

Adrian Ka-Wai Chung

St John’s College · Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, Centre for Mathematical Sciences, University of Cambridge

gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-11-11

Updated: 2026-11-11

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: We search for massive scalar fields with non-minimal curvature couplings using the loudest ringdown signals observed by LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA We find that current ringdown observations do not provide…

Key concepts

Curvature Invariants
These are mathematical expressions derived from the spacetime curvature (like Ricci tensor components) that describe how gravity behaves at different scales. The paper focuses on two specific invariants: the Gauss–Bonnet invariant (G), which involves the square of the Ricci scalar, and the Pontryagin invariant (P), which is related to a specific combination of Riemann tensor components.
Dynamical Chern–Simons Gravity
This theoretical model describes gravity where a pseudoscalar field ($\vartheta_2$) couples to the Pontryagin invariant (P). This coupling introduces new dynamics into gravity, potentially leading to modifications of spacetime structure at different energy scales. The paper uses this framework to constrain the coupling length scale.
Scalar Gauss–Bonnet Theory
This theory involves a massive scalar field ($\vartheta_1$) coupled to the Gauss–Bonnet invariant (G). This model explores how a massive scalar field interacts with quadratic curvature terms. The coupling length scale ($\ell$) characterizes the strength of this interaction, and the study constrains its possible values based on gravitational wave data.

Terminology

Summary

We search for massive scalar fields with non-minimal curvature couplings using the loudest ringdown signals observed by LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA We find that current ringdown observations do not provide informative constraints on the scalar-field mass We nevertheless constrain the coupling length scale for scalar fields satisfying Mµ < 1, where µ is the scalar-field mass, yielding marginalized 90% credible upper limits of 60. p. 04 km and 59.8 km for dynamical Chern–Simons and scalar Gauss–Bonnet couplings, respectively

Theoretical Framework

The theory considers two massive spin-0 fields coupled to quadratic curvature invariants, following Refs. [35, 56] The theory is described by the Lagrangian density given in Eq. p. 0 (1). Here, ϑ1 is a scalar field of mass µ1 coupled to the Gauss–Bonnet invariant (G), while ϑ2 is a pseudoscalar field of mass µ2 coupled to the Pontryagin invariant (P). p. 0 The corresponding coupling length scales are denoted by l1 and l2. p. 0 The curvature invariants in Eq. p. 0 (2) are defined as G = R squared − 4RµνRµν + RµνρσRµνρσ, and P = R˜µνρσRµνρσ. p. 0 Setting (l1, l2) = (l, 0) gives the massive scalar–Gauss–Bonnet theory considered here, whereas (l1, l2) = (0, l) gives massive dynamical Chern–Simons gravity. p. 1

Search Methodology

The search utilizes the recently computed quasinormal-mode spectra of rotating black holes surrounded by massive scalar fields with these curvature couplings. The corresponding spectra have recently been obtained in the regime Mµ < 1. p. 0 We use the recently computed quasinormal-mode spectra of rotating black holes surrounded by massive scalar fields with these curvature couplings [56] to perform such a search using some of the loudest ringdown signals observed by the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA detectors. p. 0 We jointly infer the coupling length scale l and scalar-field mass µ, while accounting for the parameter-dependent validity domain of the perturbative quasinormal-mode model. p. 0

Data Analysis and Constraints

The data analysis closely follows the prescription of [57], including the event selection, ringdown start time, treatment of extrinsic parameters, priors on the remnant and mode parameters, and the timedomain Bayesian analysis with pyRing. We analyze GW150914, GW190521 074359, GW200129 065458, GW231226 101520, and GW250114 082203. p. 1 To restrict the analysis to the parameter space over which the quasinormal-mode frequencies of Ref. p. 1 [56] are valid, we impose the following theory-validity conditions during sampling: l < M, Mµ < 1, and Im ω(P) nlm < 0 for the relevant parity sectors and modes. p. 1

Results Summary

Figure 1 shows the two-dimensional posterior distributions of l and Mµ for massive scalar fields with dynamical Chern–Simons (left) and scalar Gauss–Bonnet (right) couplings, obtained from Bayesian inference of the ringdown signal of GW250114 082203. The posterior support decreases rapidly toward large l, with little support remaining by l ∼ 80 km. p. 2 In contrast, the posterior retains substantial support up to the validity boundary Mµ = 1, indicating that our analyses do not provide informative constraints on the scalar-field mass. p. 2

Conclusion and Outlook

We conclude that current ringdown observations do not provide informative constraints on µ. The results reported in this work illustrate how gravitational-wave observations can connect Lagrangian densities in theories of fundamental physics to astronomical observations. p. 4 A joint inspiral–ringdown analysis could exploit complementary information from scalar radiation during the inspiral and from the mass-dependent quasinormalmode spectrum of the remnant. p. 4 The spectral-inference framework developed here could be adapted to searches for ultralight bosonic environments around stellar-mass black holes once sufficiently accurate quasinormal-mode spectra for such systems become available. p. 4

Table I Summary

Table I lists the marginalized 90% upper credible limits on the coupling length scale l for massive scalar fields with dynamical Chern–Simons and scalar Gauss–Bonnet couplings, obtained from the individual ringdown signals and from their combination. The combined upper limits are 48. p. 25 km for dynamical Chern–Simons gravity and 60. p. 04 km for scalar Gauss–Bonnet gravity. p. 0

Figure Interpretation

Figure 2 shows the 90% credible contours of the reweighted posteriors in the (l, µ) plane for massive scalar fields with dynamical Chern–Simons (solid) and scalar Gauss–Bonnet (dashed) couplings, combined across the analyzed ringdown signals according to Eq. 9. The horizontal lines mark the corresponding marginalized 90% credible upper limits on the coupling length scale, l90 = 60. p. 34 km for dynamical Chern–Simons gravity and l90 = 59. p. 08 km for scalar Gauss–Bonnet gravity. p. 0 Although the combined 90% credible regions are confined to µ ≲ 3 × 10−12 eV, this apparent upper boundary should not be interpreted as an informative constraint on the scalar-field mass. p. 3

Figure Interpretation (Event-by-Event)

Figure 5 shows the event-by-event reweighted posterior distributions in the (l, µ) plane for massive scalar fields with dynamical Chern–Simons (top) and scalar Gauss–Bonnet (bottom) couplings. The grayscale shows the reweighted posterior density, while the contour marks the 90% credible region for each event. p. 9

Figure Interpretation (Posterior Distribution of ζ)

Figure 4 shows the marginalized posterior distributions of ζ [defined in Eq. (3)] for massive scalar fields with dynamical Chern–Simons (left) and scalar Gauss–Bonnet (right) couplings, obtained from the individual ringdown events analyzed in this work. p. 2 The posterior support is concentrated predominantly at ζ ≲ 0. p. 72, well below the validity boundary l = M, corresponding to ζ = 1. p. 7

Figure Interpretation (Remnant Parameters)

Figure 3 compares the marginalized 90% credible regions in the detector-frame remnant mass and spin (Mz, af) plane inferred from GW150914 under general relativity, massive dynamical Chern–Simons gravity, and massive scalar Gauss–Bonnet gravity. The credible regions exhibit substantial overlap, indicating that the inferred remnant mass and spin remain consistent across the three models. p. 3

Acknowledgments

The author thanks Gregorio Carullo and the participants of the “Ringdown in Lisbon” meeting for extremely stimulating discussions. The author acknowledges support from a Title E Fellowship at St John’s College, University of Cambridge. p. 4 The calculations and results reported in this paper were produced using the computational resources of the Illinois Campus Cluster, which is a computing resource that is operated by the Illinois Campus Cluster Program (ICCP) in conjunction with National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA), and the computational resources of Scientific and High Performance Computing at DAMTP, Cambridge. p. 4

Data Availability

The gravitational-wave strain data analyzed in this work are publicly available through the Gravitational Wave Open Science Center (GWOSC) at https://gwosc.org/. The Bayesian inference is performed using the time-domain inference package pyRing, which is publicly available at https://git. p. 4ligo.org/lscsoft/pyring. p. 4 The posterior samples produced in this work are available at [? p. 4].

References

[3] S Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40, 223 (1978)

[56] L Lui and A K.-W Chung, (2026), arXiv:2610. p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 516054

[38] R Jackiw and S Y Pi, Phys. Rev. D 68, 104012 (2003)

[57] A K.-W Chung and N Yunes, Phys. p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 Rev. D 114, L021505 (2026)

[60] S Maenaut, G Carullo, P A Cano, A Liu, V Cardoso, T Hertog, and T G F Li Phys. Rev. D 113, 044039 (2026)

[62] P Wagle, D Li, Y Chen, and N Yunes (2026), arXiv:2610.27116

References List

[3] S Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40, 223 (1978)

[56] L Lui and A K.-W Chung, (2026), arXiv:2610.16054

[38] R Jackiw and S Y Pi, Phys. Rev. D 68, 104012 (2003)

[57] A K.-W Chung and N Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 114, L021505 (2026)

[60] S Maenaut, G Carullo, P A Cano, A Liu, V Cardoso, T Hertog, and T G F Li Phys. Rev. D 113, 044039 (2026)

[62] P Wagle, D Li, Y Chen, and N Yunes (2026), arXiv:2610.27116

References List (Full)

[3] S Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40, 223 (1978)

[56] L Lui and A K.-W Chung, (2026), arXiv:2610.16054

[38] R Jackiw and S Y Pi, Phys. Rev. D 68, 104012 (2003)

[57] A K.-W Chung and N Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 114, L021505 (2026)

[60] S Maenaut, G Carullo, P A Cano, A Liu, V Cardoso, T Hertog, and T G F Li Phys. Rev. D 113, 044039 (2026)

[62] P Wagle, D Li, Y Chen, and N Yunes (2026), arXiv:2610.27116

[3] S Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 40, 223 (1978)

[56] L Lui and A K.-W Chung, (2026), arXiv:2610.16054

[38] R Jackiw and S Y Pi, Phys. Rev. D 68, 104012 (2003)

[57] A K.-W Chung and N Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 114, L021505 (2026)

[60] S Maenaut, G Carullo, P A Cano, A Liu, V Cardoso, T Hertog, and T G F Li Phys. Rev. D 113, 044039 (2026)

[62] P Wagle, D Li, Y Chen, and N Yunes (2026), arXiv:2610.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced constraint determination for scalar-field mass by analyzing how the coupling dependence inherits the quartic scaling zeta proportional to l to power of 4, whereas omega q varies more mildly with mu. This allows AI systems to better distinguish between constraints on the coupling length scale and those on the scalar-field mass when interpreting ringdown signals.

  2. Improved ability to probe theory validity domains by utilizing the fraction of the event-specific nuisance prior satisfying the guard is Ni(l, mu) and using p hat i (l, mudi) proportional to p hat i (l, mudi) / Ni(l, mu). This enables AI systems to rigorously quantify which physical parameters are constrained by current observations versus those limited by the perturbative model validity.

  3. Development of a joint inspiral-ringdown analysis capability by exploiting complementary information from scalar radiation during the inspiral and from the mass-dependent quasinormalmode spectrum of the remnant. This allows AI systems to perform comprehensive searches across full gravitational-wave coalescence signals, rather than just ringdown phases.

  4. Refined parameter estimation for remnant black hole properties by leveraging the breaking of isospectrality gives rise to distinct complex quasinormalmode frequencies for the axial and polar sectors and their dependence on Mz, af, l, mu. This capability allows AI systems to potentially distinguish between remnant parameters from scalar-field parameters.

Sources

Related papers