Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation

arXiv:2611.15902 · astro-ph.EP · Submitted 2026-11-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Elemental abundance trends with condensation temperature are unrelated to planet formation because neither terrestrial planet formation nor giant planet gap opening is responsible for the observed low refractory-to-volatile ratios in host stars The paper investigates whether the depletion of refractory elements in host stars of terrestrial and giant exoplanets is predicted by models, finding no evidence that these scenarios explain the solar photosphere's abundance pattern Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The study examines two primary formation scenarios—terrestrial planet formation and giant planet gap opening—to determine their effect on photospheric refractory-to-volatile ratios The authors use stellar evolution models to assemble samples of solar-type dwarf stars with low-mass surface convective envelopes, focusing on those relevant to Kepler or Doppler surveys They evaluate the predicted depletion by comparing observed abundance–Tc slopes against theoretical predictions derived from these formation mechanisms How the training signal is built The analysis involves two main comparative tests using different metrics For terrestrial exoplanet systems, the authors use the root mean square slope Sobs of refractory element abundance versus condensation temperature Tc to relate it to sequestration mass Mfrac They find that for Kepler-discovered terrestrial exoplanet system host stars, the observed Sobs values are not statistically consistent with the predicted Spred values from the terrestrial planet formation scenario The probability of this match is essentially zero, suggesting that sequestration of rocky material does not lead to inverse relationships between elemental abundance and condensation temperature in these photospheres 3 For giant exoplanet systems, the authors use the refractory-to-volatile abundance difference ∆ as a metric, calculating the relative refractory offset parameter R The Monte Carlo simulation results show that points in the ∆host–∆analog plane preferentially lie below and to the right of the line y = x, suggesting that giant exoplanet host stars are refractory-rich rather than depleted This finding contradicts scenarios where giant planet formation is responsible for creating low refractory-to-volatile ratios 4 Where the gains come from The key findings are that terrestrial planet formation does not result in the depletion of refractory elements in host star photospheres, as evidenced by the lack of statistical consistency between observed and predicted abundance–Tc slopes Similarly, giant exoplanet host stars are not refractory depleted but rather slightly enriched in refractory elements by about 0.0063±0.0004 dex This enhancement is possibly a higher-order consequence of the connection between host star total metallicity and giant exoplanet occurrence The paper concludes that neither terrestrial planet formation nor the gap opening by giant planets systemically affects the photospheric refractory-to-volatile ratios of their host stars Instead, other processes, such as Galactic chemical evolution, must be responsible for the differences between solar and solar twin photospheric elemental abundances Acknowledgments Le-Chris Wang was supported by Johns Hopkins University through a Summer Provost’s Undergraduate Research Award and a Dean’s Arts and Sciences Projects, Investigations, and Research Endeavors (ASPIRE) grant This material is based upon work supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under Grant No.

Vera: 80NSSC23K0266 issued through the Exoplanets Research Program (XRP) Funding for SDSS-III has been provided by the Alfred P.

Jocelyn: Sloan Foundation, the U.S.

Vera: Department of Energy Office of Science, and the Participating Institutions Funding for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV has been provided by the Alfred P.

Paper summary: Vera: So we're looking at this paper, "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation," which is a pretty direct challenge to an idea that has been floating around. The main point they’re making is that the way refractory elements are depleted in host stars doesn't actually follow what you’d expect just because of whether a terrestrial planet or a giant planet formed there.

Jocelyn: That sounds like it could be pretty surprising, Vera. So, if we take this paper "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation," what is the central claim they're pushing? What do they think is the big takeaway for us as observers?

Vera: They're basically investigating whether models predict a depletion of refractory elements in host stars of terrestrial and giant exoplanets. They use stellar evolution models to check if these formation scenarios explain the observed abundance patterns we see on solar-type dwarf stars, specifically looking at the solar photosphere’s abundance pattern.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like they are testing two specific formation scenarios: terrestrial planet formation and giant planet gap opening. The question is whether these processes are responsible for the low refractory-to-volatile ratios we've observed in host stars.

Jocelyn: And their main finding seems to be that neither of those scenarios actually explains the solar photosphere’s abundance pattern, which is what they call "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation."

Vera: Exactly. For terrestrial exoplanet systems, they use the root mean square slope Sobs of refractory element abundance versus condensation temperature Tc to relate it to sequestration mass Mfrac. They find that for Kepler-discovered terrestrial exoplanet system host stars, the observed Sobs values are not statistically consistent with the predicted Spred values from the terrestrial planet formation scenario.

Subrahmanyan: So, when you look at those Kepler systems, you're saying they don't show that inverse relationship between elemental abundance and condensation temperature that terrestrial planet formation predicts? That’s a big hurdle for that hypothesis.

Jocelyn: And then they do something similar for giant exoplanet systems. For those, they use the refractory-to-volatile abundance difference delta as a metric, calculating the relative refractory offset parameter R. The Monte Carlo simulation results show that points in the delta host delta analog plane preferentially lie below and to the right of the line y equals x.

Vera: That suggests that giant exoplanet host stars are refractory-rich instead of depleted. This finding directly contradicts scenarios where giant planet formation is responsible for creating those low refractory-to-volatile ratios we thought might be linked to them.

Subrahmanyan: So, the implication here is that the expected depletion from either terrestrial or giant planet formation isn't happening in the host stars themselves according to these models. It shifts the focus of where this abundance pattern comes from.

Paper summary: Jocelyn: That's right. The paper says that neither terrestrial planet formation nor the gap opening by giant planets systemically affects the photospheric refractory-to-volatile ratios of their host stars. Instead, other processes must be responsible for the differences we see between solar and solar twin photospheric elemental abundances, as stated in "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation."

Vera: So what does this mean for how we interpret these abundance patterns? If planet formation doesn't cause the depletion, then what's driving the observed differences in refractory element abundances between stars.

Subrahmanyan: The authors suggest that things like Galactic chemical evolution must be responsible for those differences. They point to other factors beyond planet formation creating similar results for the solar photosphere. This means we need to look at broader cosmic processes when we try to explain these stellar abundance patterns.

Jocelyn: It really puts the genie back in the bottle regarding how we link planet formation directly to surface elemental chemistry in a host star. The paper suggests that while planet formation might be important for detecting exoplanets, it doesn't necessarily dictate the refractory abundance structure of those host stars.

Vera: It also found that giant exoplanet host stars aren't depleted either; they are actually slightly enriched in refractory elements by about zero point sixty-three plus or minus zero point four dex. That enhancement is possibly a higher-order consequence of the connection between host star total metallicity and giant exoplanet occurrence.

Subrahmanyan: So, it's not depletion in either case, but rather some kind of enrichment tied to the overall metallicity of the star system. That connects the planet formation context back to a larger stellar property.

Jocelyn: It’s interesting because it shows that even when we look at giant planet hosts, we still find something there that isn't simply zero depletion. This is what "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation" tells us about the local chemical environment around these stars.

Vera: So, to wrap up this part of the discussion, the main implication is that we shouldn't immediately look for a direct link between planet formation and photospheric depletion based on these abundance trends. The paper suggests that other factors, like Galactic chemical evolution, are more likely responsible for the variations we observe in refractory element abundances across different stars.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a clear boundary being drawn between what planet formation can explain and what we need to look at next in terms of stellar physics and galactic history. The paper points us toward those larger scales of cosmic evolution when we try to understand these solar twin differences.

Jocelyn: And that means for follow-up work, instead of focusing on how planets might carve out depletion zones, maybe we should be looking at the overall chemical enrichment history of the stars themselves. That’s what this study seems to be pushing us toward.

Conclusion: Vera: So we're wrapping up this paper, "Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation." The main message is that looking at the elemental ratios in host stars doesn't prove whether a terrestrial or giant planet formed there.

Jocelyn: Right, so it’s not about finding a direct link between the planet type and what we see in the star's atmosphere? What are this paper's authors, Vera and Jocelyn, actually saying about that connection?

Vera: The authors used stellar evolution models to test if there was any depletion of refractory elements in host stars for both terrestrial and giant exoplanets. They found no evidence that these formation scenarios explain the solar photosphere's abundance pattern.

Subrahmanyan: That's significant because it means we can stop assuming a direct link between planet type and those specific elemental patterns in the star's atmosphere. It’s not about depletion caused by planet building, but something else entirely.

Jocelyn: So for someone just listening to the radio show, what does this mean for our understanding of these stars? What changes when you hear that the connection isn't there?

Vera: It means other processes, like how galaxies evolve chemically over time, have to be responsible for the differences we see between a normal star and one that hosts a giant planet.

Subrahmanyan: Exactly. The authors suggest that Galactic chemical evolution is what drives those variations in refractory element abundances across different stars instead of planet formation itself.

Jocelyn: That shifts our focus away from local planetary formation effects toward the larger history of our galaxy, which is a big change for how we model these systems.

Vera: Yeah, so the authors are telling us that the link between planet type and photospheric depletion isn't real based on their tests. It’s not about what happens in the star's immediate neighborhood.

Subrahmanyan: It really highlights that when we look at stellar chemistry, we have to consider those bigger cosmic timescales instead of just the local formation events. This opens up new avenues for how we model star evolution and chemical mixing across vast regions of space.

Le-Chris Wang, Kevin C. Schlaufman

Johns Hopkins University · Princeton University

astro-ph.EP

Submitted: 2026-11-11

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 20 pages, 9 figures, 2 tables. Accepted by ApJ

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: Elemental abundance trends with condensation temperature are unrelated to planet formation because neither terrestrial planet formation nor giant planet gap opening is responsible for the observed…

Key concepts

Refractory-to-Volatile Ratios
This ratio compares the amount of elements that are difficult to vaporize (refractory) versus those that easily vaporize (volatile) in a star's atmosphere. The paper investigates if planet formation scenarios change this ratio, but finds they do not.
Terrestrial Planet Formation Scenario
This model suggests that the sequestration of rocky material into terrestrial planets should lead to a specific inverse relationship between the abundance of refractory elements and their condensation temperature in the host star's photosphere. The study found no statistical match for this prediction.
Giant Planet Gap Opening Scenario
This scenario hypothesizes that giant planets carving gaps in protoplanetary disks might influence stellar material. The analysis showed that giant planet host stars are not refractory-depleted; instead, they appear slightly enriched in refractory elements by about 0.0063 dex.
Abundance–Tc Slope (Sobs)
This metric measures how the abundance of a specific element changes as the condensation temperature (Tc) varies across a star's atmosphere. The authors compared the observed slopes from real stars to those predicted by planet formation models, finding no consistency.

Terminology

Summary

Elemental abundance trends with condensation temperature are unrelated to planet formation because neither terrestrial planet formation nor giant planet gap opening is responsible for the observed low refractory-to-volatile ratios in host stars The paper investigates whether the depletion of refractory elements in host stars of terrestrial and giant exoplanets is predicted by models, finding no evidence that these scenarios explain the solar photosphere's abundance pattern

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The study examines two primary formation scenarios—terrestrial planet formation and giant planet gap opening—to determine their effect on photospheric refractory-to-volatile ratios The authors use stellar evolution models to assemble samples of solar-type dwarf stars with low-mass surface convective envelopes, focusing on those relevant to Kepler or Doppler surveys They evaluate the predicted depletion by comparing observed abundance–Tc slopes against theoretical predictions derived from these formation mechanisms

How the training signal is built

The analysis involves two main comparative tests using different metrics

** For terrestrial exoplanet systems, the authors use the root mean square slope Sobs of refractory element abundance versus condensation temperature Tc to relate it to sequestration mass Mfrac They find that for Kepler-discovered terrestrial exoplanet system host stars, the observed Sobs values are not statistically consistent with the predicted Spred values from the terrestrial planet formation scenario The probability of this match is essentially zero, suggesting that sequestration of rocky material does not lead to inverse relationships between elemental abundance and condensation temperature in these photospheres 3**

** For giant exoplanet systems, the authors use the refractory-to-volatile abundance difference ∆ as a metric, calculating the relative refractory offset parameter R The Monte Carlo simulation results show that points in the ∆host–∆analog plane preferentially lie below and to the right of the line y = x, suggesting that giant exoplanet host stars are refractory-rich rather than depleted This finding contradicts scenarios where giant planet formation is responsible for creating low refractory-to-volatile ratios 4**

Where the gains come from

The key findings are that terrestrial planet formation does not result in the depletion of refractory elements in host star photospheres, as evidenced by the lack of statistical consistency between observed and predicted abundance–Tc slopes Similarly, giant exoplanet host stars are not refractory depleted but rather slightly enriched in refractory elements by about 0.0063±0.0004 dex This enhancement is possibly a higher-order consequence of the connection between host star total metallicity and giant exoplanet occurrence

Conclusion

The paper concludes that neither terrestrial planet formation nor the gap opening by giant planets systemically affects the photospheric refractory-to-volatile ratios of their host stars Instead, other processes, such as Galactic chemical evolution, must be responsible for the differences between solar and solar twin photospheric elemental abundances

Acknowledgments

Le-Chris Wang was supported by Johns Hopkins University through a Summer Provost’s Undergraduate Research Award and a Dean’s Arts and Sciences Projects, Investigations, and Research Endeavors (ASPIRE) grant This material is based upon work supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under Grant No. 80NSSC23K0266 issued through the Exoplanets Research Program (XRP) Funding for SDSS-III has been provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the U. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Holtzman et al. 2010) or the Sloan Foundation 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

Holtzman et al. 2010) or the Sloan Foundation 2.

S. Department of Energy Office of Science, and the Participating Institutions Funding for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV has been provided by the Alfred P. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Brewer & D. Fischer (2018) catalog, we use a similar procedure to define both terrestrial exoplanet host star and Kepler-observed star samples using data collected during the third and fourth phases of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS; D.

Sloan Foundation, the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, and the Participating Institutions The SDSS-IV acknowledges support and resources from the Center for High Performance Computing at the University of Utah

Data Availability

The MESA inlist and related output files for each star modeled in this work are also publicly available on Zenodo The paper has made use of data from the European Space Agency (ESA) mission Gaia, processed by the Gaia Data Processing and Analysis Consortium (DPAC) This research has made use of the NASA Exoplanet Archive, which is operated by the California Institute of Technology under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under the Exoplanet Exploration Program The paper has made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France This research has made use of the VizieR catalog access tool

References

Abdurro’uf, Accetta, K., Aerts, C., et al. 2022, ApJS, 259, 35 Adibekyan, V. p. 0

Where the paper says it

2010, 2013; V. Adibekyan et al.

Z., Gonz´alez Hern´andez, J. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2025a,b), its accuracy has also been questioned (e. Gonz´alez Hern´andez et al.

I., Delgado Mena, E., et al. 2014, A&A, 564, L15 Adibekyan, V. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2010, 2013; V. Adibekyan et al.

Z., Santos, N. C., Sousa, S. G., et al. 2012, A&A, 543, A89 Akeson, R. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(2018) hosted by the NASA Exoplanet Archive (R. Akeson et al.

L., Chen, X., Ciardi, D., et al. 2013, PASP, 125, 989 Allende Prieto, C. p. 6
Where the paper says it

As part of SDSS DR17, these spectra were reduced and analyzed with the APOGEE Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundance Pipeline (ASPCAP; C. Allende Prieto et al.

, Beers, T. C., Wilhelm, R., et al. 2006, ApJ, 636, 804 Alvarez, R. p. 6
Where the paper says it

2016) using an H-band line list, MARCS model atmospheres, and model-fitting tools optimized for the APOGEE effort (R. Alvarez & B.

, & Plez, B. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Alvarez & B. Plez 1998; B.

1998, A&A, 330, 1109 Asplund, M. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Alvarez & B. Plez 1998; B.

, Grevesse, N., Sauval, A. J., & Scott, P. 2009, ARA&A, 47, 481 Astropy Collaboration, Robitaille, T. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Mel´endez et al. (2009) proposed that the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio could be attributed to fact that approximately two Earth masses of refractory elements initially present in the protosolar nebula were sequestered in Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars by the terrestrial planet formation process.

P., Tollerud, E. J., et al. 2013, A&A, 558, A33 Barnes-Hoyle-Lyttleton equation for planet formation and accretion Baraffe, I. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Other explanations unrelated to terrestrial planet formation for the low refractory-to-volatile ratio in the solar photosphere compared to nearby solar twin stars have been put forward. The tidal disruption and accretion of a super Earth-mass exoplanet that occurs after a solar twin star reaches the zero-age main sequence could boost that star’s refractory-to-volatile ratio from the low solar value to the value observed in most nearby solar twin stars (e.

, & Chabrier, G. 2010, A&A, 521, A44 Beaton, R. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Wilson et al. Beaton et al.

L., Oelkers, R. J., Hayes, C. R., et al. 2021, AJ, 162, 302 Bedell, M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Gonzalez 2011; M. Bedell et al.

, Bean, J. L., Mel´endez, J. p. 0
Where the paper says it

08 dex or 20% relative to volatile elements in the solar photosphere when compared to nearby solar twin stars (e. Mel´endez et al.

, et al. 2018, ApJ, 865, 68 Behmard, A. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2024) advocated for a planet disruption and accretion rates of 20%–35% and at least 8% respectively, A. Behmard et al.

, Dai, F., Brewer, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

To obtain such a sample of stars, we join the J. Brewer et al.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

To obtain such a sample of stars, we join the J. Brewer et al.

M., Berger, T. A., & Howard, A. W. 2023aa MNRAS, 521, 2969 Behmard, A. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2024) advocated for a planet disruption and accretion rates of 20%–35% and at least 8% respectively, A. Behmard et al.

, Ness, M. K., Cunningham, E. C., & Bedell, M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Gonzalez 2011; M. Bedell et al.

2023b AJ, 165, 178 Blanton, M. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Behmard et al. (2023b) who showed that the abundances of Kepler-discovered exoplanet host stars are indistinguishable from the abundances of similar stars without Kepler-observed exoplanets, at least down to the precision floor of their data at about 0.

R., Bershady, M. A., Abolfathi, B., et al. 2017 AJ, 154, 28 Booth, R. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Piskunov & J. Valenti 2017) with the Kepler Data Release (DR) 25 Kepler Object of Interest (KOI) list presented in S.

A., & Owen, J. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2009) argued that the formation of the solar system’s terrestrial planets was the best explanation for the low refractory-to-volatile ratio in the solar photosphere compared to nearby solar twin stars, R. Owen (2020) and L.

E. 2020 MNRAS, 493, 5079 Brewer, J. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2009) argued that the formation of the solar system’s terrestrial planets was the best explanation for the low refractory-to-volatile ratio in the solar photosphere compared to nearby solar twin stars, R. Owen (2020) and L.

M., & Fischer, D. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Brewer & D. Fischer (2018) catalogs of stellar parameters and elemental abundance inferred from Keck/HIRES spectra (S.

A. 2018 ApJS, 237, 38 Brewer, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Brewer & D. Fischer (2018) catalogs of stellar parameters and elemental abundance inferred from Keck/HIRES spectra (S.

M., Fischer, D. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Brewer & D. Fischer (2018) catalogs of stellar parameters and elemental abundance inferred from Keck/HIRES spectra (S.

A., Valenti, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Piskunov & J. Valenti 2017) with the Kepler Data Release (DR) 25 Kepler Object of Interest (KOI) list presented in S.

A., & Piskunov, N. p. 5
Where the paper says it

1994) using Spectroscopy Made Easy (SME; N. Piskunov & J.

2016 ApJS, 225, 32 Brugamyer, E. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Choi et al. Dotter 2016).

, Dodson-Robinson, S. E., Cochran, W. D., & Sneden, C. 2011 ApJ, 738, 97 Carlos, M. p. 1
Where the paper says it

However, recent observational studies do not support the prediction that giant-planet host stars should preferentially display solar-like refractory depletion. Carlos et al.

, Amarsi, A. M., Nissen, P. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Adibekyan et al. Nissen 2015; L.

E., & Canocchi, G. 2025 A&A, 700, A127 Chambers, J. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Nibauer et al. (2021) subsequently found that at least 70% of a sample of 1,700 solar-analog stars from the Apache Point Galactic Evolution Experiment’s second phase (APOGEE-2) displays a refractory-to-volatile ratio similar to the solar photosphere though, further complicating the interpretation of this abundance–Tc pattern as a signature of terrestrial planet formation.

E. 2010 ApJ, 724, 92 Cheng, Z. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2023a) and Z. Cheng et al.

, Xuesong Wang, S. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Draft version November 13, 2026 Typeset using LATEX twocolumn style in AASTeX7. 1 Elemental Abundance Trends with Condensation Temperature are Unrelated to Planet Formation Le-Chris Wang (王乐) 1, 2 and Kevin C.

, Liu, F., et al. 2026 arXiv e-prints arXiv:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

(2009) proposed that the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio could be attributed to fact that approximately two Earth masses of refractory elements initially present in the protosolar nebula were sequestered in Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars by the terrestrial planet formation process. Because they were locked up in terrestrial planets, those refractory elements were prevented from accreting onto the young Sun and raising its photospheric refractoryto-volatile ratio to the value observed in nearby solar arXiv:2611.

03504 Choi, J. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We adopt a MESA configuration that mimics the configuration used in the generation of the MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST; J. Choi et al.

, Dotter, A. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Choi et al. Dotter 2016).

, Conroy, C., et al. 2016 ApJ, 823, 102 Christiansen, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Akeson et al. Christiansen et al.

L., McElroy, D. L., Harbut, M., et al. 2025 PSJ, 6, 186 Cowley, C. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2018) sought to correct for Galactic chemical evolution and recovered a low refractory-to-volatile ratio in the solar photosphere, though C. Cowley & K.

R., & Y¨uce, K. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Cowley & K. Y¨uce (2022) emphasized that possible refractory depletion of the solar photosphere depends sensitively on the selection of comparison stars.

2022 MNRAS, 512, 3684 Crida, A. p. 6
Where the paper says it

To identify exoplanets massive enough to open gaps in their parent protoplanetary disks, we use the criterion given as Equation (15) in A. Crida et al.

, Morbidelli, A., & Masset, F. 2006 Icarus, 181, 587 Cumming, A. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Owen (2020) also noted the similar occurrence of refractory depletion and longperiod giant exoplanets (e. Cumming et al.

, Butler, R. P., Marcy, G. W., et al. 2008 PASP, 120, 531 Cunha, K. p. 6
Where the paper says it

2013, 2021; K. Cunha et al.

, Smith, V. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Plez 2012; V. Smith et al.

V., Johnson, J. A., et al. 2015 ApJL, 798, L41 Dotter, A. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Choi et al. Dotter 2016).

2016 ApJS, 222, 8 Eggenberger, P. p. 2
Where the paper says it

As is common practice, we account for stellar rotation only after a star reaches the zero-age main sequence (ZAMS) (e. Eggenberger et al.

, Meynet, G., Maeder, A., et al. 2008 Ap&SS, 316, 43 Eisenstein, D. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Fischer (2018) catalog, we use a similar procedure to define both terrestrial exoplanet host star and Kepler-observed star samples using data collected during the third and fourth phases of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS; D. Eisenstein et al.

J., Weinberg, D. H., Agol, E., et al. 2011 AJ, 142, 72 Fischer, D. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Gonzalez et al. Gonzalez 2011; M.

A., & Valenti, J. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Piskunov & J. Valenti 2017) with the Kepler Data Release (DR) 25 Kepler Object of Interest (KOI) list presented in S.

2005 ApJ, 622, 1102 Fressin, F. p. 1
Where the paper says it

(2009) found that only about 15% of nearby solar twin stars display the abundance pattern they proposed to be indicative of terrestrial planet formation, the frequency of small-radius exoplanets in the Kepler was found by F. Fressin et al.

, Torres, G., Charbonneau, D., et al. 2013 ApJ, 766, 81 Fulton, B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Cumming et al. Fulton et al.

J., Rosenthal, L. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Fischer (2018) catalog with planetary and stellar companions reported in L. Rosenthal et al.

J., Hirsch, L. A., et al. 2021 ApJS, 255, 14 Gan, T. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Nibauer et al. (2021) subsequently found that at least 70% of a sample of 1,700 solar-analog stars from the Apache Point Galactic Evolution Experiment’s second phase (APOGEE-2) displays a refractory-to-volatile ratio similar to the solar photosphere though, further complicating the interpretation of this abundance–Tc pattern as a signature of terrestrial planet formation.

, Bedell, M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Gonzalez 2011; M. Bedell et al.

, Wang, S. X., et al. 2021 MNRAS, 507, 2220 Gonzalez Hern´andez, J. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2025a,b), its accuracy has also been questioned (e. Gonz´alez Hern´andez et al.

I., Delgado-Mena, E., Sousa, S. G., et al. 2013 A&A, 552, A6 Gonzalez Hern´andez, J. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Gonz´alez Hern´andez et al. 2010, 2013; V.

I., Israelian, G., Santos, N. C., et al. 2010 ApJ, 720, 1592 Gunn, J. p. 6
Where the paper says it

5-m Telescope (J. Gunn et al.

E., Siegmund, W. A., Mannery, E. J., et al. 2006 AJ, 131, 2332 Gustafsson, B. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Plez 1998; B. Gustafsson et al.

, Edvardsson, B., Eriksson, K., et al. 2008 A&A, 486, 951 Haisch-Jr. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Most protoplanetary disks dissipate in just a few million years (e. Haisch et al.

, K. E., Lada, E. A., & Lada, C. J. 2001 ApJL, 553, L153 Holtzman, J. p. 6
Where the paper says it

2021) on the New Mexico State University 1-m Telescope (J. Holtzman et al.

A., Harrison, T. E., & Coughlin, J. L. 2010 Advances in Astronomy, 2010, 193086 Holtzman, J. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Holtzman et al. 2010) or the Sloan Foundation 2.

A., Shetrone, M. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Cunha et al. Shetrone et al.

, Johnson, J. A., et al. 2015 AJ, 150, 148 Hsu, D. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Spina et al. 2015, 2021; S.

C., Ford, E. B., Ragozzine, D., & Ashby, K. 2019 AJ, 158, 109 Hubeny, I. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Gustafsson et al. Hubeny & T.

, & Lanz, T. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Hubeny & T. Lanz 2011; B.

2011 Synspec: General Spectrum Synthesis Program H¨uhn, L. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Ram´ırez et al. (2009), as we present in Table 1 and Figures 5, 6, and 7 in general we find negative slopes for the linear relation between between photospheric elemental abundance and Tc for the individual host stars of these terrestrial exoplanet systems.

-A., & Bitsch, B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

H¨uhn & B. Bitsch (2023) instead identified the formation of the giant planet Jupiter as the more important factor.

2023 A&A, 676, A87 Hunter, J. p. 1
Where the paper says it

H¨uhn & B. Bitsch (2023) instead identified the formation of the giant planet Jupiter as the more important factor.

D. 2007 Computing in Science & Engineering, 9, 90 Iglesias-Rogers equation of state for stellar modeling Kermes equation of state for stellar modeling Kunitomo, M. p. 2
Where the paper says it

STELLAR EVOLUTION MODELING We seek to evaluate the possible role of terrestrial and giant planet formation on the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio and its relationship between elemental abundance and condensation temperature. To identify stars that could be expected to evince the smallest refractory-to-volatile ratios and the strongest elemental abundance–Tc relationships if terrestrial or giant planet formation were responsible for those features, we calculate the mass in the surface convective envelope of stars as a function of the four independent variables of stellar evolution mass, age, composition, and rotation using the state-of-the-art stellar evolution code Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA; B.

, Guillot, T., Ida, S., & Takeuchi, T. 2018 A&A, 618, A132 Kunitomo-Guillot-Ida-Takeuchi modeling Kurucz equation of state for stellar modeling Lodders, K. p. 2
Where the paper says it

STELLAR EVOLUTION MODELING We seek to evaluate the possible role of terrestrial and giant planet formation on the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio and its relationship between elemental abundance and condensation temperature. To identify stars that could be expected to evince the smallest refractory-to-volatile ratios and the strongest elemental abundance–Tc relationships if terrestrial or giant planet formation were responsible for those features, we calculate the mass in the surface convective envelope of stars as a function of the four independent variables of stellar evolution mass, age, composition, and rotation using the state-of-the-art stellar evolution code Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA; B.

2003 ApJ, 591, 1220 Mel´endez, J. p. 0
Where the paper says it

08 dex or 20% relative to volatile elements in the solar photosphere when compared to nearby solar twin stars (e. Mel´endez et al.

, Asplund, M. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We start with M. Asplund et al.

, Gustafsson, B. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Plez 1998; B. Gustafsson et al.

, & Yong, D. 2009 ApJL, 704, L66 Nibauer-Baxter-Jain modeling Nidever, D. L., Holtzman, J. p. 6
Where the paper says it

2021) on the New Mexico State University 1-m Telescope (J. Holtzman et al.

A., Allende Prieto, C. p. 6
Where the paper says it

As part of SDSS DR17, these spectra were reduced and analyzed with the APOGEE Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundance Pipeline (ASPCAP; C. Allende Prieto et al.

, et al. 2015 AJ, 150, 173 Nissen, P. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Adibekyan et al. Nissen 2015; L.

E. 2015 A&A, 579, A52 Ochsenbein-Bauer-Marcout modeling Oh, S. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We then use both data sets to evaluate the level of refractory-to-volatile depletion in the samples, and we find that neither sample displays the depletion predicted by the terrestrial/giant planet formation explanations for the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio. We describe our stellar modeling in Section 2 and our sample selection techniques in Section 3 and our statistical evaluation of the tests described above in Section 4.

, Price-Whelan, A. M., Brewer, J. M., et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can distinguish between terrestrial planet formation scenarios by analyzing abundance-condensation temperature relationships in host stars of Kepler-discovered terrestrial exoplanets versus giant exoplanet hosts, finding that neither sample displays the depletion predicted by the terrestrial/giant planet formation explanations for the solar photosphere’s low refractory-to-volatile ratio.

  2. Improved AI can quantify the relative refractory offset parameter R to determine if giant exoplanet host stars are refractory rich or depleted; specifically, it found that giant exoplanet host stars are more refractory rich than their analogous stars without detected giant exoplanets, contradicting prior scenarios.

  3. Improved AI can assess the significance of observed abundance-condensation temperature slopes by performing statistical tests, concluding that "even for the systems expected to have the largest signals, the probability that the observed photospheric elemental abundances of Kepler-observed terrestrial exoplanet system host stars matches the prediction from the I. Ram´ırez et al. (2009) refractory sequestration scenario as modeled by J. E. Chambers (2010) is essentially zero."

  4. Improved AI can evaluate whether gap-opening giant planets explain the solar photosphere's low refractory-to-volatile ratio, finding no evidence that the host stars of giant exoplanets capable of opening gaps in their parent protoplanetary disks when compared to stars with similar masses, metallicities, and ages exhibit the depletion predicted by R. A. Booth & J. E. Owen (2020) and L.-A. H¨uhn & B. Bitsch (2023).

  5. Improved AI can predict the observed slope of photospheric elemental abundance versus condensation temperature for terrestrial exoplanet host stars, finding that none of the observed lines are statistically consistent with the J. E. Chambers (2010)-predicted slopes given the total observed terrestrial exoplanet mass in each system.

Abstract

It has been suggested that the photosphere of the Sun is depleted in the abundances of the refractory elements relative to the photospheres of nearby solar twin stars and that the degree of depletion depends on condensation temperature T c. While the formation of the solar system's terrestrial and/or giant planets may play some role in the refractory depletion of the solar photosphere, it has also been shown that other processes can produce similar results. If the terrestrial and/or giant planet formation explanations are correct, then the depletion of refractory elemental abundances in the photospheres of terrestrial/giant exoplanet host stars should be more pronounced and therefore observable even without achieving the highest possible elemental abundance inference precisions in systems with host star surface convective zones less massive than the Sun's. For stars that host Kepler-discovered systems of terrestrial exoplanets and have low-mass surface convective zones, we do not observe the dependence of depletion on T c predicted by the terrestrial planet formation scenario. For a sample of stars that has been uniformly searched with the Doppler technique for giant exoplanets, we likewise show that giant exoplanet host stars are not depleted but enhanced by about 0.0063 plus or minus 0.0004 dex in refractory abundances compared to stars of similar masses and metallicities without giant exoplanets. Since gaps opened in protoplanetary disks by giant planets are thought to produce photospheric refractory depletion in their host stars, our observations imply that at constant metallicity giant planets are more likely to form in disks with high refractory abundances.

Sources

Related papers