Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1). NISP spectroscopy of gravitational arcs and multiple images
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1). NISP spectroscopy of gravitational arcs and multiple images".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models, which require accurate measurements of on-sky positions of multiple images and of the redshifts of the background sources from which they originate This work exploits Euclid slitless spectroscopic data to determine the redshifts of four spatially extended lensed sources, and to reconstruct emission-line images This work represents a proof of concept for the exploitation of Euclid slitless spectroscopic data in the study of strong gravitational lensing, providing one of the first determinations of spectroscopic redshifts for strongly lensed features from NISP spectra.
Vera: Selected Strong Lensing Systems Three out of four analyzed strong lensing systems were classified as secure strong gravitational lenses by B26 These systems exhibit bright strong lensing features, with integrated magnitudes of HE < 21.5.
Jocelyn: Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are cluster-scale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607.9+681651 is a galaxy-scale lens in EDF-N.
Vera: The remaining system, PS1J1821+7130, is a galaxy-galaxy strong lensing system identified in the northern Euclid DR1 area using neural networks specifically designed to find strong lenses in Euclid imaging data.
Paper summary: Vera: So, to give you the gist of what this paper is about, they focus on exploiting Euclid's slitless spectroscopic data to get redshifts for four extended lensed sources and reconstruct their emission-line images >
Jocelyn: They look at three out of those four systems as secure strong gravitational lenses identified by B26, which are bright features with integrated magnitudes less than twenty-one point five >
Subrahmanyan: Specifically, they highlight SPT-CLJ0411−four thousand eight hundred nineteen and Abell two thousand two hundred eighty as cluster-scale lenses found in the Euclid Deep Field South and North areas respectively >
Vera: And they also mention WHJ181607 point 9+six hundred eighty-one thousand six hundred fifty-one which is a galaxy-scale lens in the North area of the Euclid Deep Field North > <ref:2611.15891#pg2>
Jocelyn: They also have PS1J1821+seven hundred thirty which they found as a galaxy-galaxy strong lensing system using neural networks specifically designed to find strong lenses in Euclid imaging data >
Subrahmanyan: The paper notes that the results are based primarily on the NISP slitless spectroscopic channel, which was used to identify specific emission-line features to determine these redshifts >
Vera: They detail how they did the spectral extraction using a custom Python package called GELSA1, which produces emission-line maps by resampling the images at fixed wavelength >
Jocelyn: These maps aren't perfectly monochromatic because they subtract the continuum, but they still superimpose nearby lines like H alpha and N ii that are shifted along the dispersion direction >
Subrahmanyan: The key result is that for SPT-CLJ0411−four thousand eight hundred nineteen WHJ181607 point 9+six hundred eighty-one thousand six hundred fifty-three and PS1J282304, they measured redshifts from the peak wavelength of the most prominent detected emission line >
Vera: For Abell two thousand two hundred eighty a single extraction position was used on the brighter part of what they called the ELSA analysis tools developed by Euclid >
Jocelyn: The conclusion is that these measured spectroscopic redshifts are consistent with photometric redshifts derived from other Euclid data sets like IE, YE, JE, and HE >
Conclusion: Vera: So looking at the title of this paper, "Euclid Data Release one (DR1) <ref:2611.15891#pg1,Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1>. NISP spectroscopy of gravitational arcs and multiple images," it really sums up what they did: they used the NISP channel from Euclid data to look at these lensed features >
Jocelyn: And the authors are highlighting that this work is a pilot proof of concept, showing how feasible it is to apply this spectroscopic approach to a much larger sample of lenses that Euclid finds >
Subrahmanyan: The implications here are that spectroscopic redshift measurements for multiple images and giant arcs in strong lensing systems are an indispensable ingredient for developing high-precision models >
Vera: Exactly. They show that you can get these redshifts, like the one of one point six seven zero plus or minus zero point twelve for Abell two thousand two hundred eighty which is a single emission line identified as H alpha >
Jocelyn: And for SPT-CLJ0411−four thousand eight hundred nineteen they got a redshift of one point seven seven one plus or minus zero point six determined by three lines: H alpha and O iii lambda five hundred zero point eight nanometers and H beta transitions >
Subrahmanyan: It’s interesting to see that the measured spectroscopic redshifts for SPTCLJ0411−four thousand eight hundred nineteen Abell two thousand two hundred eighty and WHJ181607 point 9+six hundred eighty-one thousand six hundred fifty-three are consistent with the photometric redshifts derived from Euclid IE, YE, JE, and HE data >
Vera: They even validated the spectroscopic redshift of the prominent Einstein ring for PS1J282304 using DESI optical spectrum >
Jocelyn: This work provides both a methodology and some dedicated tools to analyze this type of data, paving the way for developing the first strong lensing models based entirely on Euclid spectrophotometric observations >
INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna · Dipartimento di Fisica "Aldo Pontremoli" Università degli Studi di Milano · Dipartimento di Fisica e Scienze della Terra Università degli Studi di Ferrara · INFN-Sezione di Bologna · INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera · Universitäts-Sternwarte München Fakultät für Physik Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München · Instituto de Física de Cantabria · INAF-IASF Milano · Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics Garching, Germany · Aix-Marseille Université CNRS Institut d’astrophysique spatiale Marseille France · Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation University of Portsmouth UK · University of Helsinki Finland · University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Northwestern Switzerland School of Engineering Switzerland · European Space Agency ESAC/ESA Spain
astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-11-11
Updated: 2026-11-19
Comments: Paper intended for the A&A Special Issue "Euclid First Data Release". 15 pages, 5 figures
Code: https://github.com/elsa-euclid/gelsa
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 89/100
The gist: Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models…
Key concepts
- Strong Gravitational Lensing
- This phenomenon occurs when massive objects, like galaxy clusters, bend the fabric of spacetime significantly. This bending acts like a giant lens, magnifying and distorting the light from distant background sources into multiple images or giant arcs visible on Earth.
- NISP Spectroscopic Data (NISP-S)
- This refers to the slitless spectroscopic channel within Euclid's data release. It is used to detect specific emission lines in the light of lensed objects. These lines act as reliable tools because their observed wavelengths allow astronomers to calculate the precise distance (redshift) of the source galaxy.
- Emission-Line Maps
- These are images created by analyzing the dispersed light from a lensed source at a specific wavelength. While not perfectly monochromatic, these maps show where specific emission lines—like H$\alpha$ or [N II]—are located across the distorted image, helping to pinpoint the exact position of the background galaxy.
Terminology
Summary
Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models, which require accurate measurements of on-sky positions of multiple images and of the redshifts of the background sources from which they originate This work exploits Euclid slitless spectroscopic data to determine the redshifts of four spatially extended lensed sources, and to reconstruct emission-line images This work represents a proof of concept for the exploitation of Euclid slitless spectroscopic data in the study of strong gravitational lensing, providing one of the first determinations of spectroscopic redshifts for strongly lensed features from NISP spectra. p. 0 (Full author list and affiliations details can be found after the references)
November 13, 2026
ABSTRACT
Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models, which
require accurate measurements of on-sky positions of multiple images and of the redshifts of the background sources from which they originate. In
this context, Euclid is a unique facility, as it simultaneously provides high-resolution multi-band photometric imaging and slitless spectroscopy for
an unprecedentedly large sample of gravitational lenses, most of which are newly discovered.Where the paper says it
Selected Strong Lensing Systems
Three out of four analyzed strong lensing systems were classified as secure strong gravitational lenses by B26 These systems exhibit bright strong lensing features, with integrated magnitudes of HE < 21.5. Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are cluster-scale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607. p. 1 Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are clusterscale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and
North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607. 9+681651 is
a galaxy-scale lens in EDF-N (see also Euclid Collaboration:
Walmsley et al. Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are clusterscale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and
North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607. 9+681651 is
a galaxy-scale lens in EDF-N (see also Euclid Collaboration:
Walmsley et al. The remaining system, PS1J1821+7130
(Fig. 4), is a galaxy-galaxy strong lensing system identified in
the northern Euclid DR1 area using neural networks specifically
designed to find strong lenses in Euclid imaging data (Euclid
Collaboration: Lines et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Euclid Spectrophotometric Dataset
The results presented are primarily based on spectroscopic data obtained with the Euclid NISP slitless spectroscopic channel (NISP-S), which were used to identify emission-line features employed to determine the redshifts of the lensed sources. Specifically, the NISP spectra were obtained with two red grisms, RGS000 and RGS180, at all orientations available as part of DR1. p. 2 These data were used to identify the emission-line features employed to determine the redshifts of the lensed sources with the
methodology described in Sect. Specifically, the NISP spectra
were obtained with the two red grisms, RGS000 and RGS180,
at all orientations available as part of DR1. 9+681651
have so far been observed with 38, 9, and 3 Euclid spectroscopic exposures, respectively, corresponding to a comparable
number of distinct dispersion orientations, as part of the EDS
(Table 1). Each spectroscopic exposure has an integration time
of 550 seconds. 372 nm px−1
(Euclid Collaboration: Fumana et al. At the EWS depth, NISP-S is
capable of detecting emission lines down to a line flux of approximately 2 × 10−16 erg cm−2
s
−1
at a significance level of 3. At the EWS depth, NISP-S is
capable of detecting emission lines down to a line flux of approximately 2 × 10−16 erg cm−2
s
−1
at a significance level of 3. 5σ, as
estimated at a wavelength of 1. 5σ, as
estimated at a wavelength of 1. 6 µm for a source with a diameter
of 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Spectral Extraction and Emission-Line Maps
The customized spectral extractions were carried out on the calibrated NISP-S frames using the GELSA1 Python package to perform a nearly automated spectral extraction of strong lensing features. GELSA produces emission-line maps by resampling the dispersed images in right ascension and declination at fixed wavelength. p. 2 These limitations can be overcome by extracting emission-line maps from
slitless spectroscopy. GELSA produces emission-line maps by resampling the dispersed images in right ascension and declination
at fixed wavelength. Emission-line
maps from slitless spectroscopy differ from narrow-band imaging or integral-field spectroscopy. Emission-line maps are not
truly monochromatic; the emission line is isolated by applying
continuum subtraction on the 2D dispersed image, but emission
from neighbouring lines such as H α and [N ii] that are displaced
along the dispersion direction are superimposed on the map.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Results
The spectral extractions were performed at positions marked by cyan crosses in the bottom-left panels of the respective figures. For SPT-CLJ0411−4819, WHJ181607. p. 1 These systems exhibit bright strong
lensing features, with integrated magnitudes of HE < 21. Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are clusterscale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and
North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607. For SPT-CLJ0411−4819,
WHJ181607. 9+681651, and PS1J1821+7130, these positions
correspond to two high-fidelity candidate counterimages of the
same background galaxy or, in the case of PS1J1821+7130, to
two opposite sides of the Einstein ring. For Abell 2280, instead,
a single extraction position located on the brighter portion of the
1 https://github. com/elsa-euclid/gelsa, developed as part of
the Euclid Legacy Science Advanced analysis tools (ELSA) project. Specifically, we ensure that the dispersion traces
do not intersect other counterimages whose emission lines could
otherwise contaminate the extracted spectra at different positions
along the spectral axis. The redshifts of the background lensed sources are measured
from the peak wavelength of the most prominent detected emission line of the “Spec1” spectrum, if such a line can be uniquely
identified.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions
Spectroscopic redshift measurements for multiple images and giant arcs in strong lensing systems are an indispensable ingredient for developing high-precision strong lensing models. The Euclid spectra of the gravitational arcs in Abell 2280 and PS1J1821+730 show a single emission line, which was identified as the H α transition, yielding a redshift of z sp s = 1. p. 7 The Euclid spectra of the gravitational
arcs in Abell 2280 and PS1J1821+7130 show a single emission
line, which we identified as the H α transition. Under this assumption, we measured a redshift of z
sp
s = 1. 008, respectively. In the NISP spectra of the giant arc in the SPT-CLJ0411−4819 system, we identified three
emission lines corresponding to H α, [O iii] λ500. In the NISP spectra of the giant arc in the SPT-CLJ0411−4819 system, we identified three
emission lines corresponding to H α, [O iii] λ500. 8 nm, and H β
transitions, which allowed us to securely determine the redshift
of the background source as z
sp
s = 1. 9+681651, we identified
two emission lines that we associated with the [O iii] doublet, together with a tentative detection of H β, yielding a spectroscopic
redshift of z
ph
s = 2. The measured spectroscopic redshifts of SPTCLJ0411−4819, Abell 2280, and WHJ181607. The measured spectroscopic redshifts of SPTCLJ0411−4819, Abell 2280, and WHJ181607. 9+681651 are
consistent with the photometric redshifts derived from Euclid
IE, YE, JE, and HE data, complemented by ground-based Hyper
Suprime-Cam (HSC), MegaCam, and Dark Energy Camera
(DECam) observations (Appendix A). As for PS1J1821+7130,
a strong validation of the Euclid spectroscopic redshift of the
prominent Einstein ring, based on the identification of the
H α line at z
sp
s ≃ 1. 366, was obtained from the DESI optical
spectrum. From the NISP slitless spectroscopic data, we generated
continuum-subtracted emission-line maps at the wavelength of
the most prominent emission line detected in each system. The
features observed in these maps closely match the morphology
of the lensed images in the VIS/NISP photometric data, further
supporting the robustness of our results. These results also highlight the
potential of using collections of emission-line maps generated
over a range of wavelengths as a powerful method for identifying counterimages in strong-lensing systems revealed by Euclid
data. The present work represents an important milestone for future studies that will exploit Euclid spectroscopic data to measure redshifts of strongly lensed giant arcs and multiple images. The present work represents an important milestone for future studies that will exploit Euclid spectroscopic data to measure redshifts of strongly lensed giant arcs and multiple images. In addition, it provides both a methodology and a presentation of dedicated tools to analyse such data. A sizeable fraction of these systems are expected
to exhibit detectable emission lines within the NISP wavelength
range, thereby providing the critical spectroscopic information
required for robust strong-lensing analyses. Lastly, this study
paves the way for the development of the first strong lensing
models based entirely on Euclid spectrophotometric observations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix A
In this appendix, photometric redshift estimates are derived for the lensed galaxies in SPT-CLJ0411−4819, Abell 2280, and WHJ181607.9+681653 systems to independently corroborate the NISP spectroscopic results. p. 5 At the same time, these findings
provide further evidence that the multiple images originate from
the same lensed background source. To further corroborate the reliability of the Euclid spectroscopic redshift measurements, which for two of the four systems
are based on the identification of a single emission line, in Appendix A we compare the Euclid-NISP redshift values with photometric redshift estimates. The photometric redshift estimates for
SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and WHJ181607. 9+681651 are consistent,
within 1σ, with the NISP-based spectroscopic redshift measurements. 9+681651 are consistent,
within 1σ, with the NISP-based spectroscopic redshift measurements. For Abell 2280, the spectroscopic redshift lies on the edge
of the 1σ confidence interval of the photometric redshift posterior distribution. Subsequent visual inspection of Q1 data by B26 revealed
the galaxy-scale strong lensing nature of the system, which was
assigned the maximum lensing grade (Plens = 1, see B26). As
shown in the bottom-left panel of Fig. We stress that this approach yields redshift uncertainties that are affected by the morphological broadening inherent to slitless spectroscopy, in addition to the instrumental broadening. In general, when the arc is visible in individual grism exposures, the redshift can be determined precisely during the construction of the emission-line map through the alignment of different grism orientations accounting for the source morphology. 9+681651, and PS1J1821+7130, respectively. From these rough estimates of the Einstein radii, we
derive M(θE) values of 1×1013 M⊙ and 3×1013 M⊙ for the clusterscale lenses SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280, respectively. These systems exhibit bright strong
lensing features, with integrated magnitudes of HE < 21. Specifically, SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280 are clusterscale lenses located in the Euclid Deep Field South (EDF-S) and
North (EDF-N), respectively, whereas WHJ181607. (Full author list and affiliations details can be found after the references)
November 13, 2026
ABSTRACT
Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models, which
require accurate measurements of on-sky positions of multiple images and of the redshifts of the background sources from which they originate. In
this context, Euclid is a unique facility, as it simultaneously provides high-resolution multi-band photometric imaging and slitless spectroscopy for
an unprecedentedly large sample of gravitational lenses, most of which are newly discovered. 2020; Richard et al. 2015), as well as for studying the
physical properties of magnified (up to several orders of magnitude) high-redshift galaxies (e. 2026; Grillo et al. The robustness of strong lensing models critically depends
on precise measurements of the positions of the largest possible
sample of multiple images associated with distinct background
sources, which provide the primary constraints on the lens mass
distribution, as well as on accurate spectroscopic determinations
of the lens and source redshifts, from which the relevant cosmological distances can be inferred.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Automated redshift determination for strong lensing systems can be enhanced by exploiting emission-line maps generated from slitless spectroscopy to confirm that
the morphology of the line-emitting regions closely reproduces that of the observed strong lensing features.
This allows for a robust confirmation thatthe multiple images originate from the same lensed background source, thus ruling out the hypothesis that the detected emission arises from contamination by unrelated sources.
-
The system can perform independent validation of Euclid spectroscopic redshift measurements by comparing them with photometric estimates, as shown in Appendix A where
we compare the Euclid-NISP redshift values with photometric redshift estimates
and notes that for two systems,the photometric redshifts appear to be systematically underestimated, with an offset of ∆zsyst = zspec−zphot ≃ 0.3.
-
The system can generate preliminary rough estimates of total mass within the Einstein radius using the formula provided: M(thetaE) = c squared / (4G Dd Ds Dds theta squared E). These values can be used to derive approximate enclosed masses, such as
1×1013 M⊙ and 3×1013 M⊙ for the clusterscale lenses SPT-CLJ0411−4819 and Abell 2280, respectively.
Abstract
Applications of strong gravitational lensing in astrophysics and cosmology critically depend on building reliable strong lensing models, which require accurate measurements of on-sky positions of multiple images and of the redshifts of the background sources from which they originate. In this context, Euclid is a unique facility, as it simultaneously provides high-resolution multi-band photometric imaging and slitless spectroscopy for an unprecedentedly large sample of gravitational lenses, most of which are newly discovered. In this work, we exploit Euclid slitless spectroscopic data to determine the redshifts of four spatially extended lensed sources, and to reconstruct emission-line images. Specifically, two of the target sources are lensed into giant arcs by the massive galaxy clusters SPT-CLJ0411 - 4819 (z d=0.424, where "d" denotes the lensing deflector) and Abell 2280 (z d=0.326). The third system is a quadruply imaged active galactic nucleus (AGN) candidate strongly lensed by a massive galaxy at z d=0.68, while the fourth is a galaxy-scale Einstein ring produced by a lens galaxy at z d=0.235. This work represents a proof of concept for the exploitation of Euclid slitless spectroscopic data in the study of strong gravitational lensing, providing one of the first determinations of spectroscopic redshifts for strongly lensed features from NISP spectra. These results demonstrate the feasibility of applying the same methodology to the very large sample of gravitational lenses that Euclid has started to discover and is expected to identify over the course of the mission.
Sources
- Euclid Quick Data Release (Q1). AstroVink: A vision transformer approach to find strong gravitational lens systems
- The Dark Energy Survey
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference