The impact of DNA replication on the timing of cellular events
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Genomics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest computational biology and genomics papers.
Ines: I'm Ines.
Marcus: And I'm Marcus, here with Yuki.
Ines: We're looking at the paper: "The impact of DNA replication on the timing of cellular events".
Marcus: Here's the gist of the paper. Cellular timing often relies on the accumulation of a regulatory protein to a threshold The coupling of protein accumulation to DNA replication can push the noise in the FPT below the counting limit 1/λ Furthermore, there is an optimal mean replication time at which the timing precision is maximal Model of Coupling and Timing Precision The study models a gene G that synthesizes a stable protein P and undergoes replication as an N-step process The time to DNA replication is modeled as an Erlang distributed variable TR, with mean ⟨TR⟩ = N/α and squared coefficient of variation CV2 TR = 1/N Protein P is produced at rate k before replication and at the amplified rate Λk after replication, where Λ ≥ 1 captures the change in gene dosage The exact first-passage-time distribution h˜(s) is obtained by solving a chemical master equation using Laplace transform techniques The FPT distribution reflects the competition between two clocks: an effective replication delay and subsequent accumulation at the boosted rate Noise Below the Counting Limit The coupling of accumulation to replication can push the noise in the FPT below the counting limit 1/λ For any threshold λ ≥ 1, any dosage factor Λ > 1, and any number of replication steps N ≥ 1, CV2 T attains its minimum at some mean replication time ⟨TR⟩∗ in (0, ∞), with CV2 T⟨TR⟩∗ < 1/λ This reduction cannot arise if production depends only on the current protein count Noise Above the Counting Limit The same coupling can also make timing less precise than counting alone (Fig.
Ines: 2(i)) At fixed ⟨TR⟩, the excess noise CV2 T − 1/λ vanishes at, and is negative just above, Λ = 1, changing sign at most once as Λ increases Each replication time ⟨TR⟩ therefore has its own threshold dosage above which the noise exceeds 1/λ Optimal Replication Time Characterization The optimal mean replication time ⟨TR⟩∗ is characterized by a condition derived from the second moment of the FPT distribution For deterministic replication (N → ∞), ⟨TR⟩∗ is found asymptotically as k⟨TR⟩∗ = λ − sλ ln λΛ2/2π + O√λ(ln λ)−3/2 This optimal time lies about ln(λΛ2/2π) 1/2 standard deviations before the mean crossing time without replication DNA replication acts as a second, count-independent clock Its coupling to protein accumulation through gene dosage can push timing precision beyond the counting limit, or amplify noise above it when replication is itself imprecise Noise is reduced by a dosage increase, which is why (unique) troughs are still observed for deterministic replication (Theorem V.3) Peaks, by contrast, require variability in replication timing and hence vanish in the limit as N → ∞ (Corollary V.4) Bursty Gene Expression Considerations When gene expression is bursty, the limiting values of CV2 T for ⟨TR⟩ → 0+ and ⟨TR⟩ → ∞ no longer equal 1/λ The noise is therefore normalised by CV20,∞ The mean FPT is given by ⟨Tb⟩ = λ + bk/b Location of the Minimum in the Deterministic Limit The location of the unique minimum ⟨TR⟩∗ of CV2 Y, in the deterministic limit (N → ∞), is given by k⟨TR⟩∗ = λ − √λL + O√λL−3/2 The constant implied by O
(ln λ)−2: in (S98) is given by Λ − 1 Bursty Gene Expression Considering DNA Replication The limiting values of CV2 T for ⟨TR⟩ → 0+ and ⟨TR⟩ → ∞ no longer equal 1/λ The noise is therefore normalised by CV20,∞ Equation (S102) allows us to normalise the results shown in Figure S.1, ensuring comparability between plots Final Summary of Findings DNA replication acts as a second, count-independent clock Its coupling to protein accumulation through gene dosage can push timing precision beyond the counting limit, or amplify noise above it when replication is itself imprecise The paper shows that for every λ ≥ 1, N ≥ 1, and Λ > 1, there exists a mean replication time at which the noise falls below the counting limit 1/λ and that it exceeds that limit for some ⟨TR⟩ if and only if Λ exceeds a critical dosage Λc The coupling of accumulation to replication hence makes the threshold crossing more precise than molecular counting alone allows References
1: P.
Marcus: S.
Ines: Swain, M.
Paper summary: Ines: To summarize this paper "The impact of DNA replication on the timing of cellular events," Juan David Marmolejo-Lozano, Nikola Popović, Ramon Grima, and others are investigating how coupling DNA replication and protein accumulation influences cellular timing precision. The core idea is that the standard counting limit for timing precision is a fundamental constraint in this system.
Marcus: They solve a stochastic model that links these two processes: protein P production at a rate k before replication, and then at a boosted rate lambda k after replication, where lambda is the gene dosage factor. This coupling lets them see how the noise in the first-passage time distribution behaves.
Yuki: The paper claims that by finding an optimal mean replication time TR star, this coupling can push timing precision below that fundamental counting limit one over lambda for any threshold lambda greater than one <ref:2611.15356#pg1>.
Ines: But they also found a boundary condition: if you increase the gene dosage factor lambda beyond a critical value, things start to become less precise than just counting alone allows at certain replication times.
Marcus: The key takeaway is that DNA replication acts as a second clock in this system, and its timing can be tuned to enhance precision beyond what molecular counting could achieve on its own. This is significant because gene expression itself is inherently noisy due to random biochemical events.
Yuki: For population genetics, this means that the developmental timing of certain genes might be more robust than we initially thought if replication cycles are timed correctly within the cell cycle.
Ines: So it's about finding a balance between how fast you replicate and how much protein you accumulate to get the best precision. What do you think about that trade-off, Marcus?
Marcus: It really hinges on that optimal mean replication time TR star we discussed earlier; if the cell replicates at that specific rate, the noise is minimized below one over lambda <ref:2611.15356#pg1>. But as we saw, if we change how much protein is made after replication by changing lambda, things can get messy again.
Conclusion: Ines: So wrapping up "The impact of DNA replication on the timing of cellular events," we see that DNA replication isn't just a passive process; it's an active part of setting when biological events happen. The authors found a specific mean replication time where this interaction maximizes timing precision, pushing it past the limits imposed by simple molecular counting.
Marcus: It means that when we try to understand how cells time their processes, we have to look at the interplay between protein production rates and replication speed, not just one factor in isolation. The paper suggests that dosage control through replication can actually make timing more precise than if you only looked at the protein counts.
Yuki: From a broader perspective, this offers a way to think about how cellular regulation might be more finely tuned than we previously thought, especially when considering developmental processes where timing is everything.
Ines: It’s about recognizing that the system has multiple clocks working together, and tuning one of those clocks—the replication timing—can give us a much sharper picture of the underlying biological mechanism. That's what this work is all about.
Marcus: Yeah, it gives us a new parameter to consider when we model these systems; if you want high precision, you might need to adjust your replication timing based on the dosage you're aiming for.
Yuki: It definitely points toward a more integrated view of cell biology where timing isn't just about reaching a threshold, but about the dynamic path taken to get there.
Juan David Marmolejo-Lozano, Nikola Popovi´c, Ramon Grima
School of Biological Sciences, The University of Edinburgh · School of Mathematics, The University of Edinburgh · Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences, The University of Edinburgh
q-bio.MN
Submitted: 2026-11-11
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 32 pages (main text + SM); 3 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Cellular timing often relies on the accumulation of a regulatory protein to a threshold The coupling of protein accumulation to DNA replication can push the noise in the FPT below the counting limit…
Key concepts
- FPT distribution
- This describes the probability of when a specific event (like DNA replication) occurs after a certain time. The model uses this to see how the combined effects of protein accumulation and replication delay influence the overall timing precision of cellular events.
- Counting Limit (1/λ)
- This represents the fundamental limit on how precisely you can measure an event based solely on counting discrete occurrences. The paper investigates if coupling protein levels to replication can make the timing more precise than this simple counting mechanism allows.
- Dosage Factor (Λ)
- This factor captures how much the gene's dosage changes after DNA replication. Increasing this factor, Λ > 1, represents an amplification of protein production following replication, which is a key mechanism explored to manipulate timing noise.
Terminology
Summary
Cellular timing often relies on the accumulation of a regulatory protein to a threshold The coupling of protein accumulation to DNA replication can push the noise in the FPT below the counting limit 1/λ Furthermore, there is an optimal mean replication time at which the timing precision is maximal
Model of Coupling and Timing Precision
The study models a gene G that synthesizes a stable protein P and undergoes replication as an N-step process The time to DNA replication is modeled as an Erlang distributed variable TR, with mean ⟨TR⟩ = N/α and squared coefficient of variation CV2 TR = 1/N Protein P is produced at rate k before replication and at the amplified rate Λk after replication, where Λ ≥ 1 captures the change in gene dosage The exact first-passage-time distribution h˜(s) is obtained by solving a chemical master equation using Laplace transform techniques The FPT distribution reflects the competition between two clocks: an effective replication delay and subsequent accumulation at the boosted rate
Noise Below the Counting Limit
The coupling of accumulation to replication can push the noise in the FPT below the counting limit 1/λ For any threshold λ ≥ 1, any dosage factor Λ > 1, and any number of replication steps N ≥ 1, CV2 T attains its minimum at some mean replication time ⟨TR⟩∗ in (0, ∞), with CV2 T⟨TR⟩∗ < 1/λ This reduction cannot arise if production depends only on the current protein count
Noise Above the Counting Limit
The same coupling can also make timing less precise than counting alone (Fig. 2(i)) At fixed ⟨TR⟩, the excess noise CV2 T − 1/λ vanishes at, and is negative just above, Λ = 1, changing sign at most once as Λ increases Each replication time ⟨TR⟩ therefore has its own threshold dosage above which the noise exceeds 1/λ
Optimal Replication Time Characterization
The optimal mean replication time ⟨TR⟩∗ is characterized by a condition derived from the second moment of the FPT distribution For deterministic replication (N → ∞), ⟨TR⟩∗ is found asymptotically as k⟨TR⟩∗ = λ − sλ ln λΛ2/2π + O√λ(ln λ)−3/2 This optimal time lies about ln(λΛ2/2π) 1/2 standard deviations before the mean crossing time without replication
Conclusion on Mechanism
DNA replication acts as a second, count-independent clock Its coupling to protein accumulation through gene dosage can push timing precision beyond the counting limit, or amplify noise above it when replication is itself imprecise Noise is reduced by a dosage increase, which is why (unique) troughs are still observed for deterministic replication (Theorem V.3) Peaks, by contrast, require variability in replication timing and hence vanish in the limit as N → ∞ (Corollary V. p. 3 The limit exceeds 1/λ when N < λ and
τ > τc = 2N/(λ − N): when replication is less precise than accumulation and dominates the timing, a
sufficiently large dosage factor therefore produces a peak, which implies that Λc is finite. Peaks hence reflect
variability in replication timing, while troughs correspond to a dosage increase, whose initial effect, Eq.Where the paper says it
Bursty Gene Expression Considerations
When gene expression is bursty, the limiting values of CV2 T for ⟨TR⟩ → 0+ and ⟨TR⟩ → ∞ no longer equal 1/λ The noise is therefore normalised by CV20,∞ The mean FPT is given by ⟨Tb⟩ = λ + bk/b
Location of the Minimum in the Deterministic Limit
The location of the unique minimum ⟨TR⟩∗ of CV2 Y, in the deterministic limit (N → ∞), is given by k⟨TR⟩∗ = λ − √λL + O√λL−3/2 The constant implied by O[(ln λ)−2] in (S98) is given by Λ − 1
Bursty Gene Expression Considering DNA Replication
The limiting values of CV2 T for ⟨TR⟩ → 0+ and ⟨TR⟩ → ∞ no longer equal 1/λ The noise is therefore normalised by CV20,∞ Equation (S102) allows us to normalise the results shown in Figure S.1, ensuring comparability between plots
Final Summary of Findings
DNA replication acts as a second, count-independent clock Its coupling to protein accumulation through gene dosage can push timing precision beyond the counting limit, or amplify noise above it when replication is itself imprecise The paper shows that for every λ ≥ 1, N ≥ 1, and Λ > 1, there exists a mean replication time at which the noise falls below the counting limit 1/λ and that it exceeds that limit for some ⟨TR⟩ if and only if Λ exceeds a critical dosage Λc The coupling of accumulation to replication hence makes the threshold crossing more precise than molecular counting alone allows
References
[1] P. S. Swain, M. B. Elowitz, and E. D. Siggia, Proc. Natl. Acad Sci USA 99 12795–12800 (2002)
[2] M B Elowitz, A J Levine, E D Siggia, and P S Swain, Science 297 1183–1186 (2002)
[3] K R Ghusinga, J J Dennehy, and A Singh, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 114 693–698 (2017)
[4] K Rijal, A Prasad, A Singh, and D Das, Phys Rev Lett 128 048101 (2022)
[5] L Ham, M A Coomer, K Ocal, R Grima, and M P H Stumpf Nat Commun ¨ 15 5286 (2024)
[6] U Alon An Introduction to Systems Biology Design Principles of Biological Circuits (Chapman and Hall/CRC 2019)
[7] T R J Lappin, D G Grier, A Thompson, and H L Halliday Ulster Med J 75 23 (2006)
[8] T Montavon and N Soshnikova Semin Cell Dev Biol 34 76–84 (2014)
[9] T Young, J E Rowland, C van de Ven, M Bialecka, A Novoa, M Carapuco, J van Nes, W de Graaff I Duluc J N Freund F Beck M Mallo and J Deschamps Dev Cell 17 516–526 (2009)
[10] H K Matthews, C Bertoli, and R A M de Bruin Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 23 74–88 (2022)
[11] C J Zopf, K Quinn, J Zeidman, and N Maheshri PLoS Comput Biol 9 e1003161 (2013)
[12] Y Voichek, R Bar-Ziv, and N Barkai Science 351 1087–1090 (2016)
[13] Z Cao and R Grima Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 117 4682 (2020)
[14] C H Beentjes, R Perez-Carrasco, and R Grima Phys Rev E 101 032403 (2020)
[15] C Jia, A Singh, and R Grima PLoS Comput Biol 18 e1010574 (2022)
[16] C Jia and R Grima iScience 26 105746 (2023)
[17] J R Peterson, J A Cole, J Fei, T Ha, and Z A Luthey-Schulten Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 112 15886 (2015)
[18] R Dessalles, V Fromion, and P Robert PLoS ONE 15 e0226016 (2020)
[19] A K Verma, H K Barman, K Rijal, and D Das bioRxiv 10.64898/2026. p. 0 15356v1 [q-bio. MN] 11 Nov 2026 The gene advances through the states G0 → G1 → · · · → GN at some constant rate α; the corresponding
N steps represent progression from the initial time t = 0 to replication of the gene, which doubles its copy
number in the final transition (N − 1 → N). The time to DNA replication is therefore Erlang distributed,
arXiv:2611.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[20] C A Yates, M J Ford, and R L Mort Bull Math Biol 79 2905 (2017)
[21] H X Chao, R I Fakhreddin, H K Shimerov, K M Kedziora, R J Kumar J Perez J C Limas G D Grant J G Cook G P Gupta and J E Purvis Mol Syst Biol 15 MSB188604 (2019)
[22] Q Sun, F Jiao, G Lin, J Yu, and M Tang PLoS Comput Biol 15 e1007017 (2019)
[23] M R Dowling, A Kan S Heinzel J H S Zhou J M Marchingo C J Wellard J F Markham and P D Hodgkin Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 111 6377–6382 (2014)
[24] S O Skinner, H Xu, S Nagarkar-Jaiswal P R Freire T Zwaka and I Golding eLife 5 e12175 (2016)
[25] I Kalita, I A Iosub L McLaren L Goossens S Granneman and M El Karoui eLife 13 RP94918 (2025)
[26] A Sukys and R Grima Nucleic Acids Res 53 gkaf295 (2025)
[27] B Schwanh¨ausser, D Busse, N Li G Dittmar J Schuchhardt J Wolf W Chen and M Selbach Nature 473 337–342 (2011)
[28] R Mosteller, R Goldstein, and K Nishimoto J Biol Chem 255 2524–2532 (1980)
[29] M Gupta, A N T Johnson E R Cruz E J Costa R L Guest S H-J Li E M Hart T Nguyen M Stadlmeier B Bratton T Silhavy N Wingreen Z Gitai and M W¨uhr Nat Commun 15 5890 (2024)
[30] N G van Kampen Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry 3rd ed Elsevier Amsterdam 2007
[31] DLMF NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions https://dlmf.nist.gov Release 1.2.8 of 2026-09-15 F W J Olver A B Olde Daalhuis D W Lozier B I Schneider R F Boisvert C W Clark B R Miller B V Saunders H S Cohl and M A McClain eds DLMF NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions https://dlmf.nist.gov Release 1.2.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can accurately predict timing noise in molecular processes by using DNA replication as a second, count-independent clock, allowing them to determine when timing precision will either be suppressed or amplified relative to the theoretical counting limit of 1/lambda.
-
Improved AI systems can optimize gene expression timing by identifying an optimal mean replication time at which timing precision is maximal, which occurs at a specific value of DNA replication time regardless of protein count fluctuations, as described in Theorem III.6 and Section V.3 for deterministic replication.
-
Improved AI systems can distinguish between noise reduction and noise amplification effects based on the dosage factor Lambda, allowing them to predict whether the timing variability will push the precision below or above what is allowed by molecular counting alone, as shown in Theorem IV.5 regarding the critical dosage Lambda c.
-
Improved AI systems can model bursty gene expression accurately by incorporating geometric distributions for burst sizes and non-null events, enabling them to predict how bursting modifies the limiting noise values when DNA replication timing is at its extremes (TR approaches 0 or infinity).
-
Improved AI systems can identify the unique global minimum of timing noise in deterministic regimes by finding the critical point TR asterisk where CV2 T attains its minimum below 1/lambda, which is characterized by a specific relationship between mean replication time and threshold parameters.
Abstract
Cellular timing often relies on the accumulation of a regulatory protein to a threshold. For a stable protein produced at a constant rate, the threshold alone sets timing precision: the squared coefficient of variation of the first-passage time is the inverse of the threshold number of molecules. This counting limit appears to be a fundamental constraint. However, production rates vary across the cell cycle. By solving exactly a stochastic model coupling DNA replication and protein accumulation, we show that when a gene replicates at an optimal time, precision exceeds the counting limit.
Related papers
- A disease-contextualized atlas of proteome-scale molecular influences of natural products
- Convex Analysis of Relaxation Dynamics in Chemical Reaction Networks and Generalized Gradient Flows
- Triangularity of the Jacobian on siphon faces, the Metzler property of its transversal component and other results
- Generative discovery of chemical reaction networks
- GINsim 3.1: Qualitative modelling and dynamical analysis of logical regulatory networks
- PathwayDesigner: an interactive SBML/KEGG/Reactome/Escher compatible editor for biochemical network diagrams