PathwayDesigner: an interactive SBML/KEGG/Reactome/Escher compatible editor for biochemical network diagrams

arXiv:2611.14930 · q-bio.MN · Submitted 2026-11-11 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Genomics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest computational biology and genomics papers.

Ines: We're looking at the paper: "PathwayDesigner: an interactive SBML/KEGG/Reactome/Escher compatible editor for biochemical network diagrams".

Marcus: Here's the gist of the paper. PathwayDesigner is an interactive editor for biochemical network diagrams that supports community standards like SBML and Escher The application aims to provide a practical environment for constructing, annotating and modifying biochemical networks while maintaining the connection between their visual representation and underlying model structure Core Functionality and Standards Support PathwayDesigner is designed to be a modern cross-platform editor for SBML based network diagrams that utilize the layout and render standards It supports reading and writing SBML with layout and render The tool can also open Escher maps directly, read the SBML Layout format exported by Reactome, and read KEGG KGML files Other components of the model such as events, rules, functions, and units are kept and can be edited within the application Design Objectives and Implementation The main objective of this project was to develop a modern cross-platform and practical platform for editing SBML based network diagrams that use the layout and render standards The author established four key objectives for the development process Exchange.

Ines: The editor will read and write formats including SBML with layout and render and Antimony It will also have read capabilities for Escher maps and Reactome exported SBML Building and distributing.

Marcus: A key objective is to create a single code base that can be run on all four platforms, Windows, Mac, Linux and Web Rust was chosen as the development language based on its modern tool chain A simple notation.

Ines: To minimize friction, drawing of reactions requires minimal mouse action, such as placing two species and clicking the reactant and then the product Annotation.

Title and authors: Ines: Now let's talk about the title and who wrote this paper, "PathwayDesigner: an interactive SBML/KEGG/Reactome/Escher compatible editor for biochemical network diagrams" by Herbert M. Sauro and his team <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: So the title is pretty descriptive, listing all the formats it handles: SBML, KEGG maps, Reactome maps, and Escher maps <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Ines: It immediately tells you this isn't just for one type of network; it’s a multi-format editor that bridges different biological modeling standards <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: And what I find interesting is that they also mention Antimony in the description, which is another key format for describing network structures <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Yuki: When you look at the authors, they come from the University of Washington and eScience Institute, which suggests a strong foundation in both computational biology and large-scale data analysis <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Ines: They are tackling a problem where existing editors have different priorities, so this paper proposes combining graphical manipulation with preserving mathematical structure <ref:2611.14930#pg2>.

Marcus: And the authors clearly set out four main objectives for what they wanted to achieve with this project: exchange, building and distributing, simple notation, and annotation <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Ines: That's a good breakdown of their design philosophy; they weren't just trying to build one feature, but a whole system architecture <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Yuki: I wonder if having those four distinct objectives helped them keep the complexity manageable while still achieving that broad compatibility goal <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Marcus: It seems like they were focused on making it practical for real-world use, which is often where these kinds of tools fall short <ref:2611.14930#pg2>.

The paper's summary: Ines: The paper summarizes the core idea as creating an interactive editor that lets you draw networks directly or write them in Antimony, and then the software handles the layout and drawing using SBML Layout and Render <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: They emphasize that PathwayDesigner can read and write these formats, but it also has limited support for KEGG maps because those don't have reaction curve information, which is a specific caveat <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Yuki: It also keeps the kinetic model details like rate laws and parameters right there with the drawing so when you save it, it’s still ready to be simulated by other tools <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Ines: They also propose a subset of the SBML render standard that most tools actually support, which is a smart way to ensure their output is usable <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Marcus: The summary highlights that they focused on creating a single code base that runs on Windows, Mac, Linux, and Web using Rust as the development language <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Yuki: That cross-platform goal sounds ambitious for an editor tool and it shows they were thinking about accessibility across different user environments <ref:2611.14930#pg2>.

Ines: They also mention that species and reactions can be annotated with references to any database, which is a huge feature for adding context to the models <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: Overall, it's summarized as a new editor designed to address the challenges of balancing intuitive graphical manipulation with preserving biochemical semantics and interoperability <ref:2611.14930#pg2>.

The paper's improvements: Ines: The authors suggest four key objectives for their development process: first, exchange—reading and writing SBML Layout and Render, Antimony, Escher maps, and Reactome exported SBML <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Marcus: Then building and distributing—creating that single code base that works across all those platforms Windows Mac Linux and Web using Rust <ref:2611.14930#pg3>.

Yuki: They also focused on a simple notation for drawing reactions to make it easier, minimizing the mouse action needed for things like placing reactants and products <ref:2611.14930#pg2>.

Ines: And finally, annotation—they added reasonably comprehensive support for searching and adding notes to species, reactions, and compartments <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: On the analysis side, they include basic stoichiometric analysis that lets you compute the stoichiometry matrix N to find conservation laws and a basis for the flux null space using known algorithms <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Yuki: That stoichiometric analysis is interesting because it uses a visual representation of the network to derive mathematical properties like independent fluxes <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Ines: They show that their SBML reader correctly reads and rewrites all nine thousand three hundred fifty Level two and three files of the SBML Test Suite, which is a big validation point <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: Plus, they showed that the desktop and browser versions give the exact same output when saving or exporting as Antimony or SBML <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Conclusion: Ines: So to wrap up, PathwayDesigner is presented as a first visual editor that can read and write both SBML Layout and Render standards, plus Antimony, and it handles Escher maps too <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: It supports annotating species with things like CheBi or Uniprot references for reactions, which really brings external biological context into the model <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Yuki: For me, the main implication is that it’s a cross-platform tool that complements other tools like SBMLNetwork which work via Python scripts <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Ines: And they showed it can round-trip through Antimony and SBML without changing the model structure at all, which proves its fidelity to the original data <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Marcus: The authors also noted a limitation, though, that the network structure analysis is limited to about six hundred species and reactions <ref:2611.14930#pg4>.

Yuki: And another limitation they mentioned is that SBGN maps aren't supported because SGBN is more of a visualization standard than a modeling exchange format <ref:2611.14930#pg5>.

Ines: It seems like the main idea here is combining several existing features into one practical editor that keeps the kinetic model with its drawing, which helps bridge the gap between visualization and simulation <ref:2611.14930#pg1>.

Marcus: So, PathwayDesigner is available for everyone to use from their repository and web app, providing a practical environment for constructing and modifying these complex biochemical networks <ref:2611.14930#pg5>.

Herbert M. Sauro, eScience Institute, University of Washington

University of Washington

q-bio.MN

Submitted: 2026-11-11

Updated: 2026-11-11

Code: https://github.com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs

Project page: https://sys-bio.github.io/PathwayDesigner-rs

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: PathwayDesigner is an interactive editor for biochemical network diagrams that supports community standards like SBML and Escher The application aims to provide a practical environment for…

Terminology

Summary

PathwayDesigner is an interactive editor for biochemical network diagrams that supports community standards like SBML and Escher The application aims to provide a practical environment for constructing, annotating and modifying biochemical networks while maintaining the connection between their visual representation and underlying model structure

Core Functionality and Standards Support

PathwayDesigner is designed to be a modern cross-platform editor for SBML based network diagrams that utilize the layout and render standards It supports reading and writing SBML with layout and render The tool can also open Escher maps directly, read the SBML Layout format exported by Reactome, and read KEGG KGML files Other components of the model such as events, rules, functions, and units are kept and can be edited within the application

Design Objectives and Implementation

The main objective of this project was to develop a modern cross-platform and practical platform for editing SBML based network diagrams that use the layout and render standards The author established four key objectives for the development process

** Exchange.**

The editor will read and write formats including SBML with layout and render and Antimony It will also have read capabilities for Escher maps and Reactome exported SBML

** Building and distributing.**

A key objective is to create a single code base that can be run on all four platforms, Windows, Mac, Linux and Web Rust was chosen as the development language based on its modern tool chain

** A simple notation.**

To minimize friction, drawing of reactions requires minimal mouse action, such as placing two species and clicking the reactant and then the product

** Annotation.**

It was decided to add reasonably comprehensive support for annotating and searching for annotations in PathwayDesigner so that users can examine annotations, add annotations, and notes to a model, species, reactions and compartments

Representation of Network Elements

Species are drawn as nodes including a box or circle with its Id or display name inside or beside it Aliases allow a heavily used species to be drawn next to each reaction instead of at the center of a web of reaction lines Reactions are hyperedges joining reactants to products through a junction point stored with the model Modifiers, such as rate laws, are automatically connected to the junction by a dashed modifier line when a species is not used up in the rate law Compartments can be drawn as nested boxes, and species are associated with the compartment they reside in

Network Structure Analysis

PathwayDesigner has basic stoichiometric analysis functionality that can display the stoichiometry matrix N From this matrix, one can compute the network’s conservation laws and a basis for its flux null space using well known published algorithms The results of the stoichiometric analysis are shown in a Structure tab which displays the rank and the numbers of independent fluxes and conservation laws The QR factorization works on the whole matrix, zeros included, so its cost grows steeply with network size

Model Exchange and Round-Tripping

PathwayDesigner’s SBML reader correctly reads and rewrites all 9,350 Level 2 and 3 files of the SBML Test Suite Every Gallery model, saved as SBML with Layout and Render, passes libSBML’s consistency checks The desktop and browser versions give the same output when saving, exporting as Antimony and SBML and reading back

Comparison with Other Tools

PathwayDesigner is closest in purpose to SBMLNetwork, which lays out and styles models from a script It can read an Escher map directly, with its curves and labels The comparison shows the combination of an interactive editor that runs in a browser without installation, keeps the kinetic model with its drawing, reads and writes SBML Layout and Render and Antimony, and can open Escher, KEGG and Reactome maps

Limitations

The annotation lookup only finds metabolites and metabolic reactions since the services it searches hold little else Annotations that other tools write for their own use, such as COPASI’s, are kept and written back unchanged except those of CellDesigner and JDesigner Some elements of a diagram cannot be exchanged in full because SBML Layout and Render cannot specify whether a reaction is drawn as a single line or that its junction Beziers are smooth The network structure analysis is limited to about 600 species and reactions

Future Directions

A significant omission is the ability to render SBGN maps since SGBN is more of a visualization standard that a modeling exchange format and PathwayDesigner is specifically designed for simulatable models The network structure analysis could be updated to work on networks greater than about 600 species and reactions by using sparse factorization

Conclusion

PathwayDesigner is the first visual editor that can read and write both SBML Layout and Render standards It can also read and write Antimony, both the layout/render notation and a more concise alternative notation As well as supporting SBML, the tool can also read the Escher format It supports the ability to annotate SBML models such as annotating species (CheBi, Uniprot, etc) and reactions (such a Rhea or E.C number)

Availability

All code and binaries are available from the repository https://github.com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs and the web application is available at https://sys-bio. p. 0

Where the paper says it

PathwayDesigner is released as open source under the MIT licence, at https://github. com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs, and runs in the browser at https://sys-bio.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

PathwayDesigner is released as open source under the MIT licence, at https://github. com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs, and runs in the browser at https://sys-bio.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

PathwayDesigner is released as open source under the MIT licence, at https://github. com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs, and runs in the browser at https://sys-bio.

github.io/PathwayDesigner-rs The repo provides build instructions as well as user documentation and a Gallery of sample models

Use of AI

Claude Code (Anthropic, Opus 5.5, medium) was used to assist in writing the software and in preparing this manuscript Specifically Claude was used to help write the software, debug the code, create the tests and handle submissions of code to the GitHub repo

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by NIH Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering award P41 EB023912 through HMS at the Center for Reproducible Biomedical Modeling HMS acknowledges Joe Hellerstein for useful discussions related to AI assistance for application development

Appendix A: A proposed minimal subset of SBML Render

This appendix proposes a minimum that a writer can keep to and a reader can be expected to draw based on files that tools actually write It lists the rules for writing the subset, such as giving each glyph exactly one style chosen by its id The rules for reading the subset are also listed, advising readers to apply inheritance and defaults but not depend on a writer having used them

Appendix B: Validation

Every check was run on all the example models in PathwayDesigner’s Gallery, which range from a two-species reaction to the 95-reaction Escher map of E. coli core metabolism and the 68-reaction kinetic model of Millard et al. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The Systems Biology Markup Language (SBML) [4] provides a machine-readable format for representing biochemical models, including species, reactions, and kinetic laws, enabling models to be exchanged among compatible simulation and analysis tools. However, the core SBML specification does not fully define how a model should be arranged visually.

[29] The SBML files were checked with libSBML [55] (python-libsbml 5. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Reading a model into the drawing uses an Antimony reader written for PathwayDesigner in Rust. This library was checked against 1,788 test models and 708 curated BioModels models.

20.5) and simulated with libRoadRunner [18, 56] (2. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The application will have limited support for KEGG maps, because KEGG maps don’t have reaction curve information and access is difficult. As with many editing tools, the kinetic model (rate laws, parameters, initial values, rules and events) is kept with the drawing, so a file written by PathwayDesigner can be simulated by other tools.

9.1) Round tripping through Antimony was done on the entire curated branch of the BioModels suite The round trip through SBML showed that every drawn came back, with two things not written being the theme and the boxes of hidden compartments The results show that all 9,350 Level 2 and 3 files of the SBML Test Suite were read and written without change The comparison between desktop and browser builds showed that the saved files, the Antimony, the SVG and the PDF were the same byte for byte in every model The stoichiometry matrix, rank, conservation laws and null-space basis were compared against those of libRoadRunner [56] The sparse basis shortened the vectors by reducing the mean number of reactions per vector from 6. p. 9
Where the paper says it

What differs between the desktop and browser versions. Desktop Browser Open File dialog, the file manager, or the list of recent files File dialog Save Back to the opened file Back to the opened file in Chromium-based browsers (File System Access API); elsewhere a downloaded copy Preferences, saved styles, autosave Files in the user’s settings folder The browser’s local storage Recovery after a crash Offered on the next start Offered on the next visit Without a network Everything but the Gallery Everything but the Gallery, once the page has been opened Every push is tested on Linux and macOS (and the author’s own builds on Windows) with about 1,450 automated tests, the reading and writing of every file in the SBML Test Suite, the validity of every exported SBML file, and the drawing of PDF files.

2 to 3.9 over the BioModels The round trip through Antimony showed that species, initial values, boundary and constant species came back unchanged in every model The exported SBML without a layout came back unchanged apart from the name of seven models that had none The results show that the conservation laws spanned the same space as libRoadRunner’s K matrix The sparse basis found in 95 ms on the desktop and 207 ms in the browser for a larger network The final conclusion is that PathwayDesigner is a cross-platform that complements other tools like SBMLNetwork which work via Python scripts

References

The references listed are 57, 58, 59, 60, and others The reference list contains entries for tools like JDesigner [1], CellDesigner [2], Newt [3], COPASI [17], and libRoadRunner [18] The paper references the SBML standard, Escher maps, and Reactome knowledgebase The work is supported by NIH Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering award P41 EB023912 through HMS at the Center for Reproducible Biomedical Modeling The software is released as open source under the MIT licence The authors used Claude Code (Anthropic, Opus 5.5, medium) to assist in writing the software and in preparing this manuscript The work is available at https://github. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Diagrams were exchanged in both directions with COPASI and SBMLNetwork. PathwayDesigner is released as open source under the MIT licence, at https://github.

com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs and the web application is available at https://sys-bio.github.io/PathwayDesigner-rs The paper was written on November 13, 2026 The references include entries for the SBML Test Suite and various simulation libraries like libRoadRunner [55], COPASI [17], and libSBML [55] The paper addresses the limitations of existing tools by showing how PathwayDesigner combines features from several other tools The paper discusses future directions including rendering SBGN maps and updating network structure analysis for larger networks

The paper is 2611.14930. Every sentence must end with a reference token. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Each reactant and product is joined to the junction by a leg. A reaction can be drawn in several ways (Fig 4): with straight legs meeting at the junction; each leg a cubic B´ezier curve whose two handles can be dragged; Bezier curves with a smooth junction, where the curves pass through the junction without the same slope, or for compatibility with Escher reactions [12], with a stem, a straight center line that the reactants join at one end and the products leave from the other.

The token names the page and quotes the words it rests on, copied word for word from that page BARE

PathwayDesigner has basic stoichiometric analysis functionality that can display the stoichiometry matrix N From this matrix, one can compute the network’s conservation laws and a basis for its flux null space using well known published algorithms The results of the stoichiometric analysis are shown in a Structure tab which displays the rank and the numbers of independent fluxes and conservation laws

All code and binaries are available from the repository https://github.com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs and the web application is available at https://sys-bio.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can create a cross-platform editor that reads and writes SBML Layout and Render standards, allowing diagrams to be reused by other applications while maintaining a unified file containing both the computational model and its visual representation.

  2. The improved system can integrate modern AI assistance to build pathway editors, as done with the Iridium platform, enabling one developer to maintain and extend the editor through automated code generation and debugging.

  3. The system can perform limited stoichiometric analysis by exploiting the visual representation of networks, specifically computing the network’s stoichiometry matrix N to derive conservation laws and a basis for its flux null space using algorithms like QR factorization.

  4. The system can support advanced annotation searching by automatically finding and adding references to databases like BiGG, ChEBI, PubChem, and Rhea based on a component's ID or contextually with reactants and products.

  5. The system can facilitate complex network analysis by computing the conservation laws and flux null space on the diagram itself; for instance, a vector of the null space can be drawn where every species steady state concentration remains unchanged.

Abstract

PathwayDesigner is an interactive editor for biochemical network diagrams. A network can be drawn directly on the screen, or described as an Antimony model, which PathwayDesigner then lays out and draws. PathwayDesigner reads and writes SBML using the Layout and Render packages, writing Render in a form that other tools can interpret correctly. PathwayDesigner can read and write a diagram's layout and appearance using either Antimony's own layout statements or in a new, more concise format that we propose. PathwayDesigner can also open Escher maps, KEGG maps and Reactome's SBML-based maps. Other components of the model, such as events, rules, functions, and units, are kept and can be edited within the application. Species and reactions can be annotated with references to any database, and PathwayDesigner can find and add annotation references automatically by searching the BiGG, ChEBI, PubChem, and Rhea databases with a component's Id or Display Name, or contextually with a reaction's reactants and products. The network's stoichiometry matrix, conservation laws, and flux null space are computed and visualized on the diagram. The visual style of a diagram can be set with named styles or themes, saved and reused across models. One built-in theme follows the Escher style. The software is written in pure Rust as one code base for Windows, macOS, Linux, and the web browser, where it runs as WebAssembly. The web version is hosted on a GitHub page so that a user doesn't need to manually install code. All 1,062 curated BioModels models and the 1,823 semantic cases of the SBML Test Suite were read and written back without change. Diagrams were exchanged in both directions with COPASI and SBMLNetwork. PathwayDesigner is released as open source with MIT licence, at https://github.com/sys-bio/PathwayDesigner-rs, and runs in the browser at https://sys-bio.github.io/PathwayDesigner-rs/.

Sources

Related papers