Minimum observations for accurate Exoplanetary mass estimation with Radial Velocity Analysis (MINERVA)
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Minimum observations for accurate Exoplanetary mass estimation with Radial Velocity Analysis (MINERVA)".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Precise planetary mass measurements are essential for constraining the internal structure and envelope properties of exoplanets Estimating the observational effort needed to reach the desired mass precision is therefore fundamental for the optimisation of current and future radial velocity (RV) surveys.
Vera: MINERVA Tool Overview MINERVA is a tool designed to estimate the required number of RV observations to measure transiting planet masses to a given precision, providing a robust scheduling framework for large-scale samples.
Jocelyn: The code acts as an ab initio population forward-modelling simulator, generating the expected activity-induced RV signal entirely from scratch by treating targets statistically as part of a synthetic stellar population.
Vera: It is designed to be an automated, computationally lean code that determines the number of observations required to measure the mass of transiting planets orbiting FGKM-type stars.
Paper summary: Jocelyn: So to wrap up, MINERVA is essentially a tool designed to tell us exactly how many radial velocity observations you need to plan before you can get a reliable mass measurement of a transiting planet.
Subrahmanyan: The authors, Di Maio and colleagues, use this simulation approach to show that for the Ariel Masses Survey, which aims at determining masses of transitional planets in the radius valley using HARPS-N data, we're looking at needing around one thousand one hundred forty-five RV measurements on average.
Vera: They’ve established a baseline for observational effort. The implication is that if you want to get those precise mass constraints needed to break atmospheric degeneracies, you need to plan your survey based on these numbers rather than just hoping you get enough data.
Jocelyn: It's about making the planning robust against the noise and activity that we know exist in real stars, which is what their dynamic activity modeling handles so well.
Subrahmanyan: The big picture here is that if we can secure these mass measurements early on, it gives us the necessary constraints to evaluate those expected atmospheric signals before we even launch the mission.
Vera: Exactly. It’s about moving from just collecting data to strategically planning how much data you need and when you need it to get meaningful physics out of those exoplanets.
Conclusion: Vera: So we've seen how MINERVA simulates needing thousands of observations just to get a good mass measurement for these transiting planets, and now we're looking at the final conclusions of this paper.
Jocelyn: I think the title itself, "Minimum observations for accurate Exoplanetary mass estimation with Radial Velocity Analysis," really sums up what they did—it’s about setting a floor on how much time we need to spend watching stars to get reliable masses.
Subrahmanyan: For the theoretical side, this means that before we even start looking at those atmospheres and trying to understand planet formation, we have a baseline requirement for our data collection strategy. It puts a real constraint on what’s possible with current or near-future radial velocity surveys.
Vera: Exactly. They showed how activity and noise—the stuff that makes star wobbles messy—actually dictates that required number of measurements, which is crucial because you can't just pick any stars randomly and expect a good mass result.
Jocelyn: And the authors used this simulation to test it on a real sample, specifically the Ariel Mission Candidate Sample, using HARPS-N data as their reference instrument. They found that for most of those planets, they needed less than three hundred measurements to get a mass estimate.
Subrahmanyan: That number is pretty interesting when you look at the median total effort they calculated with the Monte Carlo bootstrap approach—around eleven hundred and forty five measurements for the whole sample. That gives us a concrete target for mission planners.
Vera: It changes things because it highlights where we're currently running short on data, especially for those planets that are hard to detect in terms of mass due to low signal-to-jitter ratios. If you want reliable masses, you need to plan your observation schedule around this simulation.
Jocelyn: So what does this mean practically? It means we might have a clearer idea of the observational budget needed for next generation surveys before we even launch them.
Subrahmanyan: And that’s the link to cosmology and structure formation; if we can reliably measure these masses, it becomes a key piece of evidence when modeling how planets interact with their host stars in dense stellar environments.
Vera: Absolutely. We need this data foundation to really start talking about what those planets are actually doing out there on the sky. Next up, we're going to look at some of the specific caveats they mentioned regarding stellar activity regimes and how that affects these required numbers.
C. Di Maio, S. Benatti, S. Colombo, G. Piccinini, R. Spinelli, V. Fardella, R. Claudi, G. Micela
INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Palermo University of Palermo Department of Physics and Chemistry INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica Universita Roma Tre
astro-ph.EP, astro-ph.IM
Submitted: 2026-11-11
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures, accepted by A&A
Code: https://github.com/EXOPA-OAPa/MINERVA
Project page: https://www.tng.iac.es/instruments/harps/tools/NSTS.jar
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Precise planetary mass measurements are essential for constraining the internal structure and envelope properties of exoplanets Estimating the observational effort needed to reach the desired mass…
Key concepts
- MINERVA Tool
- MINERVA is an automated simulator that estimates the number of RV observations required to measure transiting planet masses. It models the expected noise and stellar activity from scratch by treating targets statistically as part of a synthetic stellar population, providing a robust scheduling framework for large surveys.
- Stellar Activity Regimes
- The simulation dynamically generates realistic stellar noise by incorporating variability based on three activity levels: low, intermediate, and high. The complexity of the injected signal changes according to these regimes, modeling effects like differential rotation and amplitude evolution that mimic real star behavior.
- Signal Recovery Criteria
- A planetary signal is only considered fully recovered when it meets strict criteria involving statistical significance, physical accuracy, and required precision simultaneously. This ensures that the estimated mass is both statistically reliable and physically accurate for use in further analysis.
- Kpl/Kact Ratio Threshold
- Non-detections are systematically caused by a critical threshold where the planet's signal-to-jitter ratio (Kpl/Kact) drops below 1. This low ratio results from either extremely high stellar activity or the inherent smallness of the planetary signal, guiding future target selection.
Terminology
Summary
Precise planetary mass measurements are essential for constraining the internal structure and envelope properties of exoplanets Estimating the observational effort needed to reach the desired mass precision is therefore fundamental for the optimisation of current and future radial velocity (RV) surveys. p. 0 For current and future characterisation programs, such data are crucial to break key degeneracies in atmospheric retrievals. Estimating the observational effort needed to reach the desired mass precision is therefore fundamental for the optimisation of current
and future radial velocity (RV) surveys.Where the paper says it
MINERVA Tool Overview
MINERVA is a tool designed to estimate the required number of RV observations to measure transiting planet masses to a given precision, providing a robust scheduling framework for large-scale samples. The code acts as an ab initio population forward-modelling simulator, generating the expected activity-induced RV signal entirely from scratch by treating targets statistically as part of a synthetic stellar population. p. 1 Unlike data-dependent fitting tools that require prior
observations for single targets, MINERVA acts as an ab initio population forward-modelling simulator, generating the expected
activity-induced RV signal entirely from scratch. It achieves this
by treating the targets statistically as part of a synthetic stellar
population: fundamental properties (such as mass, age, and rotation) are either drawn from catalogues or sampled from representative demographic distributions. To address the specific needs of population-level forecasting prior to data collection, we present the MINERVA (MInimum
observations for accurate Exoplanetary mass estimation with Radial Velocity Analysis) tool2
. It is an automated, computationally
lean code designed to determine the number of observations required to measure the mass of transiting planets orbiting FGKMtype stars.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Simulation Setup and Modeling
The simulation involves defining a three-year total baseline composed of alternating six-month observing seasons and six-month visibility gaps, with 60 time stamps generated randomly within each window to mimic realistic, non-uniform scheduling constraints. The total dispersion of the intrinsic noise component is obtained by combining instrumental noise, photon noise, and contribution from additional planets in the system. p. 2 Definition of the RV noise floor and measurement
uncertainties
To simulate the dispersion of the RV time series, we generated
an intrinsic noise component using a Gaussian distribution. The
total dispersion of this distribution, σ, is obtained by combining several independent physical and instrumental contributions. All three noise terms are implemented in the code as userdefined parameters, allowing full flexibility in adapting the simulations to different instruments, observing strategies, or scientific goals. The effective RV scatter injected into the simulated
time series is thus given by
σ =
q
σ
2
RV,instr + σ
2
RV,ph + σ
2
RV,pl.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Stellar Activity and Noise Generation
The stellar activity signal is dynamically generated by incorporating variability that could mimic effects like differential rotation, amplitude evolution, and phase incoherence based on three activity regimes: low activity (log R′HK < −5.0), intermediate activity (−5. p. 4 Notably, these literature
curves are plotted exclusively within the activity range explored
in their original paper, highlighted by the vertical dot-dashed
lines. The background colours highlight different stellar activity level regimes based on log R
′
HK: low activity (green shaded
area, log R
′
HK < −5), intermediate activity (orange shaded area,
−5 ≤ log R
′
HK < −4. Clearly, this approach represents an idealised case
that is rarely achievable under real observing conditions. Initial benchmarking tests performed on simulated quiescent stars
(log R
′
HK < −5. As the authors
themselves noted, their original K-star dataset did not probe extreme activity regimes (log R
′
HK > −4. Due to gyrochronology, such high and very high activity levels are physically tied to
early evolutionary stages (i. The
complexity of the injected signal dynamically adapts to the activity regime. For the low-activity case, we assume the star hosts stable,
long-lived active regions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Signal Recovery and Estimation
The number of RV data points required to fully recover the injected planetary signal is determined through an incremental approach where 5 subsequent measurements are added at a time until all recovery criteria are met. The pipeline uses a frequentist, non-linear least-squares minimization approach via the Trust Region Reflective (trf) algorithm to optimize parameters. p. 6 The formal modelling within the
MINERVA pipeline is executed through a frequentist, non-linear
least-squares minimization approach rather than a stochastic Bayesian sampling (MCMC), ensuring the high computational efficiency required to simulate thousands of independent observing campaigns. The optimization is performed using the Trust Region Reflective (trf) algorithm implemented
via scipy. Finally,
model selection is performed via the Bayesian information criterion (BIC = χ
2 + k ln N), evaluating the statistical evidence of
the full model against the null hypothesis. We define a signal as fully and robustly recovered only when
the following criteria are simultaneously satisfied by the final fit:
- Statistical significance: The adopted model (planet or simultaneous) must be strongly statistically favoured over a noplanet model.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Application to Ariel Sample
MINERVA was applied to a subsample of the Ariel Mission Candidate Sample (MCS) using HARPS-N at the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (TNG) as the reference instrument. The results indicate that for 1482 out of 1541 planets, a mass was successfully recovered in less than 300 RV measurements, including 67 planets from the KPC. The median total observational effort for the entire sample rises to 1145 ± 130 RV measurements when using a Monte Carlo bootstrap approach. p. 8 Because the median is not an
additive operator, we computed the full-sample statistics using
a Monte Carlo bootstrap approach, drawing 104
random realisations from the complete simulation outcomes of all targets. Using this statistical treatment, the median total observational
effort for the entire sample rises to 1145 ± 130 RV measurements.Where the paper says it
Strategic Implications for Survey Planning
The analysis reveals that non-detections are systematically driven by a critical threshold in the signal-to-jitter ratios (Kpl/Kact ≲ 1), which arises either from extreme stellar activity or from the intrinsic smallness of the planetary signal. This suggests a selection framework for finalising the Ariel MRS where targets falling within these specific physical regimes must be prioritized or explicitly excluded to prevent severe depletion of the observational budget. The results highlight that securing mass measurements well ahead of launch is crucial because accurate mass constraints are a fundamental prerequisite to evaluate expected atmospheric signals and drive the final selection and prioritization of the MRS.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved planning for radial velocity (RV) campaigns by using MINERVA to estimate required observations to measure transiting planet masses to a given precision, providing a robust scheduling framework for large-scale samples.
-
Enhanced ability to evaluate undersampling risks in active stars by using MINERVA's probabilistic architecture, which allows the evaluation of
the evaluating undersampling risks in active stars.
-
Dynamic guidance of population-wide characterisation strategies by enabling the optimization of ongoing RV campaigns and the dynamic guidance of population-wide characterisation strategies.
-
Accurate prediction of required observational effort for characterizing transiting planets by simulating realistic RV time series, including weather interruptions and seasonal visibility gaps, based on a
three-year total baseline composed of alternating six-month observing seasons and six-month visibility gaps.
-
Robust simulation of stellar activity using empirical calibrations derived from local neighborhood distributions to derive rotation and magnetic activity levels, translating these into time-varying RV signals.
-
Realistic modeling of measurement uncertainties by assigning a formal measurement uncertainty deltaRVi calculated by summing in quadrature the nominal instrumental noise, photon noise, and an activity-driven extraction term (sigmaact extr).
-
Accurate characterization of stellar populations by autonomously modeling a synthetic stellar population representative of the solar neighbourhood, propagating physical parameters through a chain of scaling laws to derive chromospheric activity indices.
-
Modeling complex stellar activity signals by incorporating variability that mimics
differential rotation, amplitude evolution, and phase incoherence
through three mechanisms: phase resets, amplitude evolution (Ks), and harmonic complexity/strong beating. -
Precise determination of the number of RV measurements required for signal recovery by using an incremental approach, iteratively adding data points and performing periodogram analyses to assess the signal recovery process.
-
Ability to stress-test scheduling strategies against unfavourable orbital configurations by allowing users to manually define non-zero eccentricities and arguments of periastron in the simulation engine.
Abstract
Precise planetary mass measurements are essential for constraining the internal structure and envelope properties of exoplanets and to break key degeneracies in atmospheric retrievals. Estimating the observational effort needed to reach a desired mass precision is therefore fundamental for the optimisation of current and future radial velocity (RV) surveys. We present MINERVA, a tool designed to estimate the required number of RV observations to measure transiting planet masses to a given precision, providing a robust scheduling framework for large-scale samples. MINERVA simulates realistic RV time series for targets orbiting FGKM-type stars. The code ingests real-world observational timestamps to account for weather interruptions and seasonal visibility gaps. To model stellar activity, the pipeline draws ages from local neighbourhood distributions, uses empirical calibrations to derive rotation and magnetic activity levels, and translates these into time-varying RV signals. We also derived a new empirical calibration between chromospheric activity and RV dispersion for K-type stars, using Global Architecture of Planetary Systems (GAPS) and Ariel Mass Survey (ArMS) data. We validated MINERVA on targets with known planetary masses, yielding required observational efforts highly consistent literature values. To demonstrate its capabilities on statistically significant samples, we applied the code to a subsample of the Ariel Mission Candidate Sample. Adopting HARPS-N/TNG as the reference instrument, we estimated the observing nights necessary to achieve a 30% planetary mass precision, providing an optimised observational roadmap for atmospheric characterisation. MINERVA's probabilistic and flexible architecture allows the optimisation of ongoing RV campaigns, the evaluating of undersampling risks in active stars, and the dynamic guidance of population-wide characterisation strategies.
Sources
- The GAPS programme at TNG LXXIX. New mass constraints for the infant planets in the V1298 Tau system through a long-term radial velocity monitoring with HARPS-N
- The GAPS Programme at TNG LXXXI. The puzzle of the HeI absorption signal in the atmosphere of V1298 Tau b with GIARPS@TNG
- The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets. XXXI. Magnetic activity cycles in solar-type stars: statistics and impact on precise radial velocities
- The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXIV. Occurrence, mass distribution and orbital properties of super-Earths and Neptune-mass planets
Related papers
- A Bright L4 Neptune Trojan Found by Stacking Archival ZTF Images
- PDS 70 c and SR 12 c: Observational Constraints on Giant-Planet and Satellite Formation
- JWST Rocky Worlds DDT Observations of LTT 1445 A b and c in Secondary Eclipse Using MIRI/F1500W
- A Joint Study of Epoch Astrometry and Radial Velocities of Gaia-4b
- Using Structure Functions to Characterize Protoplanetary Disk Velocity Residuals
- An analytical framework for atmospheric tides on rocky planets. II. Semidiurnal thermotidal torque