Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material as it grew constraining Theia to be small and relatively oxidized

arXiv:2611.14842 · astro-ph.EP · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: I'm Vera.

Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material as it grew constraining Theia to be small and relatively oxidized".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates Solar System formation scenarios using a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model applied to Classical, Annulus, and Grand Tack scenarios to constrain the characteristics of Proto-Earth and Theia.

Vera: The model finds that a strong oxidizing gradient among the initial solids in the protoplanetary disk is necessary to reproduce Earth’s mantle chemistry.

Jocelyn: For these scenarios to successfully produce Earth's composition, two conditions must be met: first, there must be a positive oxidation gradient with distance in the inner protoplanetary disk, and second, Earth must accrete increasingly more oxidized material on average as it grows.

Vera: The study concludes that the mantle of the Earth can be accurately reproduced through various dynamical pathways if a redox gradient exists in the disk that cuts across building block materials, allowing Earth to form from reduced and oxidized material.

Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at the paper titled "Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material as it grew constraining Theia to be small and relatively oxidized," and what they did with that title is that it’s essentially using Earth's mantle chemistry to figure out if these different formation ideas—the Classical, Annulus, and Grand Tack scenarios—can actually produce Earth.

Jocelyn: And the core idea here is how the chemistry of the Earth’s mantle acts like a filter for those formation models. They aren't just guessing; they are using that chemistry to constrain what Theia, our Moon-forming impactor, has to be like in terms of size and its initial redox state.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like they are trying to see if the required chemical evolution matches the physical constraints of these different dynamical pathways, which is a big connection between structure formation and planetary geochemistry.

The paper's summary: Vera: So what the paper actually finds is that for Earth’s mantle chemistry to work in these simulations, you need a strong oxidizing gradient among the initial solids in the protoplanetary disk. They say this isn't just some fine detail; it’s a necessary condition for reproducing Earth’s mantle chemistry.

Jocelyn: And then they lay out two main conditions that have to be met for any of these scenarios to succeed: first, there needs to be this positive oxidation gradient with distance in the inner protoplanetary disk, and second, Earth has to accrete increasingly more oxidized material on average as it gets bigger.

Subrahmanyan: That implies that the early accretion history dictates a chemical trend that must continue throughout Earth's growth for its mantle composition to come out right. It links the initial disk conditions directly to the final bulk silicate earth composition they are trying to match across those scenarios, like Classical or Grand Tack >

The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors suggest a few ways this research is better than what came before, mostly focusing on how they’ve refined the model itself. They use a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model, which means they are simulating both the physical collisions and the subsequent chemical changes happening inside the planet.

Jocelyn: And that coupling is key because it allows them to adjust the initial redox state of those building blocks in a synthetic protoplanetary disk until the mantle of their simulated Earth closely matches what we see in bulk silicate earth.

Subrahmanyan: It’s important to know that they are building on earlier work, like Rubie et al., two thousand eleven 2015b, and two thousand sixteen but they are applying that framework to test these specific formation scenarios <ref:2611.14842#pg2>. This approach is what lets them move beyond just matching the final composition and into testing the physics of how a planet actually forms under different gravitational histories >

Conclusion: Vera: So wrapping up this paper, the main thing we see is that Earth’s mantle can be reproduced through various dynamical pathways if there's a redox gradient in the disk that cuts across building block materials, allowing Earth to form from reduced and oxidized material.

Jocelyn: And they found something interesting about when things happen; late accretion is inherently more oxidizing than earlier stages, which really restricts the combinations of Theia’s mass and composition they can have.

Subrahmanyan: If Theia and Proto-Earth were similar in size, both must possess a mantle iron oxide, or FeO abundance comparable to present-day Earth. But if Theia was smaller than Proto-Earth, it could have a wider range of that FeO abundance ranging from about zero percent to thirty percent.

Vera: It seems like the best fit for the Earth analog happens when Theia is smaller relative to Proto-Earth, and this trend is even stronger when you look at mass ratios greater than zero point three.

Jocelyn: And they also found that reconciling isotopic similarity between Earth and the Moon requires some degree of equilibration, which they suggest likely happened because of a high-velocity Theia rather than an extremely massive one.

Subrahmanyan: So because a large Theia is less often associated with the correct Earth mantle composition, and is worse when it does yield it, an equal-mass impact scenario seems less feasible in their model.

Vera: Overall, these findings support that late accretion of increasingly oxidized material is a consistent outcome in simulations forming Earth analogs matching Bulk Silicate Earth across those diverse formation scenarios like the Classical or Grand Tack >

Department of Earth & Environmental Sciences, Michigan State University

astro-ph.EP

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 43 pages, 31 figures (including appendix). Accepted for publication in Icarus

Journal ref: Nathan, G. I., Nguyen, H. D., & Jacobson, S. A. (2026). Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material as it grew constraining Theia to be small and relatively oxidized. Icarus, 117355

DOI: 10.1016/j.icarus.2026.117355

Code: https://github.com/gijnathan/Earth_Theia_accretion_ICARUS2026

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 90/100

The gist: The study investigates Solar System formation scenarios using a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model applied to Classical, Annulus…

Key concepts

Oxidizing Gradient
This refers to a change in the concentration of oxygen or oxidized materials within the protoplanetary disk as you move closer to the Sun. A positive gradient means that material gets progressively more oxidized (more oxygen-rich) closer to the central star, which is crucial for explaining Earth's mantle chemistry.
Late Accretion
This describes the process where a planet gains its final significant amount of material after a major impact event. The research found that late accretion is inherently more oxidizing than earlier accretion stages, meaning later growth phases are naturally richer in oxidized materials.
Theia and Proto-Earth Mass Ratio
This compares the relative sizes of the impactor (Theia) and the target planet (Proto-Earth). The study determined that for Earth analogs to match Bulk Silicate Earth composition, a smaller Theia is generally required compared to Proto-Earth, especially when their mass ratio is greater than 0.3.

Terminology

Summary

The study investigates Solar System formation scenarios using a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model applied to Classical, Annulus, and Grand Tack scenarios to constrain the characteristics of Proto-Earth and Theia. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Here, we use the chemistry of Earth’s mantle to determine whether proposed Solar System formation scenarios can produce Earth and to constrain the characteristics of both the Proto-Earth and the Moon-forming impactor, Theia. To do this, we use a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model (Rubie et al.

The model finds that a strong oxidizing gradient among the initial solids in the protoplanetary disk is necessary to reproduce Earth’s mantle chemistry. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This model calculates the mantle chemistry of Earth-like planets in Solar System formation simulations and adjusts the initial redox state of the building blocks in a synthetic protoplanetary disk until the mantle of the simulated Earth closely matches the bulk silicate Earth. We find that a strong oxidizing gradient among the initial solids of the protoplanetary disk is favored to reproduce the chemistry of Earth’s mantle, in agreement with Rubie et al.

For these scenarios to successfully produce Earth's composition, two conditions must be met: first, there must be a positive oxidation gradient with distance in the inner protoplanetary disk, and second, Earth must accrete increasingly more oxidized material on average as it grows.

The study concludes that the mantle of the Earth can be accurately reproduced through various dynamical pathways if a redox gradient exists in the disk that cuts across building block materials, allowing Earth to form from reduced and oxidized material. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Nguyen, Seth A. Jacobson • The Earth mantle can be reproduced in a variety of dynamical models • Late accretion to the Earth is more oxidized than earlier stages • A small Theia could have had a range of redox states and is favored in our models • If Theia was large it must have possessed a similar redox state to present-day Earth arXiv:2611.

Furthermore, late accretion is inherently more oxidizing than earlier stages, which restricts viable combinations of Theia's mass and composition. Specifically, if Theia and Proto-Earth were similar in size, both must possess a mantle FeO abundance comparable to that of present-day Earth. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, in simulations that successfully reproduce Earth’s composition, Proto-Earth and Theia may possess a wide range of mantle compositions and mass ratios. However, because late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth’s mantle.

However, if Theia was smaller than Proto-Earth, it could exhibit a wider range of mantle FeO wt. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, in simulations that successfully reproduce Earth’s composition, Proto-Earth and Theia may possess a wide range of mantle compositions and mass ratios. However, because late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth’s mantle.

% abundances (ranging from approximately 0 wt. p. 4
Where the paper says it

For now, we focus on whether it is possible to reproduce the Earth’s mantle in Earth-like planets from each terrestrial planet scenario and, if so, determine what geochemical gradient is required to reproduce the Earth’s mantle composition. Redox states in the Solar System The redox states of Solar System materials vary greatly, ranging from IW-8 to IW+2 (Righter et al.

% to 30 wt.%). The Earth analog is best reproduced when Theia is smaller relative to Proto-Earth, and this trend is most pronounced for mass ratios greater than 0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Earth accreted increasingly oxidized material Figure 1: Representative estimates of observed Fe-in-metal fraction for a range of planetary bodies show a trend of increasingly oxidized bulk composition at greater heliocentric distances. Mercury, for example, has a large iron core (∼70% of Mercury’s total mass) and a small amount of FeO in its mantle (∼2 wt% of mantle), meaning nearly all of its Fe is reduced (Hauck et al.

3. A smaller Theia yields a wider range of reasonable FeO compositions, whereas a large Theia requires an FeO composition closer to that of present-day Earth. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, in simulations that successfully reproduce Earth’s composition, Proto-Earth and Theia may possess a wide range of mantle compositions and mass ratios. However, because late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth’s mantle.

To reconcile isotopic similarity between Earth and the Moon, some degree of equilibration must have occurred; this suggests the energy for such equilibration likely originated from a high-velocity Theia rather than an extremely massive one. p. 6
Where the paper says it

To reconcile the isotopic similarity of the Earth and Moon with proposed Moon-forming impact scenarios, three solutions have been proposed. One approach is to assert that there was already a high degree of initial isotopic similarity between Proto-Earth and Theia (Dauphas, 2017).

Consequently, because a large Theia is less frequently associated with the correct Earth mantle composition—and is worse when it does yield it—an equal-mass impact scenario is deemed less feasible. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Theia and Proto-Earth The formation of the Earth-Moon system is frequently hypothesized to be the result of a giant impact (Hartmann, 1975; Cameron and Ward, 1976), but both the physical and chemical properties of the impactor are debated. The giant impact hypothesis is compelling because it directly explains the angular momentum state of the Earth-Moon system without invoking subsequent dynamics to drain excess angular momentum from the Earth-Moon system; these constraints prompted the canonical theory of lunar formation involving a roughly Mars-sized body, Theia, impacting Proto-Earth (Benz et al.

Overall, the findings support that late accretion of increasingly oxidized material is a consistent outcome in simulations forming Earth analogs matching Bulk Silicate Earth (BSE) composition across diverse formation scenarios. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, in simulations that successfully reproduce Earth’s composition, Proto-Earth and Theia may possess a wide range of mantle compositions and mass ratios. However, because late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth’s mantle.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can constrain Solar System formation scenarios by using Earth mantle chemistry to determine whether proposed scenarios can produce Earth, as stated in the abstract. This allows for testing of Classical, Annulus, and Grand Tack scenarios against observed bulk silicate Earth compositions.

  2. Improved AI can evaluate the characteristics of Theia by determining its required redox state based on accretion history, specifically concluding that Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth’s mantle. This constrains Theia's size and composition relative to Proto-Earth.

  3. Improved AI can predict the required initial disk conditions, such as a strong positive oxidation gradient with distance in the inner protoplanetary disk, needed to reproduce Earth's mantle chemistry, thereby guiding simulations toward viable formation scenarios.

  4. Improved AI can differentiate between formation scenarios by finding that late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, allowing researchers to test whether Theia and Proto-Earth can both have mantles more oxidized than present-day Earth's mantle under different conditions.

  5. Improved AI can constrain the mass ratio and composition of Proto-Earth and Theia by determining which combinations are compatible with the bulk silicate Earth, specifically noting that smaller Theia analogs produce Earth analogs with mantles that are closer matches to the composition of the bulk silicate Earth.

  6. Improved AI can predict the timing constraints on lunar formation, finding that the later the Moonforming giant impact on the Earth analog, the less material is added afterwards, and providing a constraint on late accretion mass based on scenario type.

Abstract

Many different Solar System formation scenarios successfully reproduce the main astrophysical properties of the inner Solar System. Here, we use the chemistry of Earth's mantle to determine whether proposed Solar System formation scenarios can produce Earth and to constrain the characteristics of both the Proto-Earth and the Moon-forming impactor, Theia. To do this, we use a coupled N-body accretion and core-mantle differentiation model (Rubie et al., 2011, 2015b) applied to a range of proposed formation scenarios (Classical, Annulus, and Grand Tack scenarios). This model calculates the mantle chemistry of Earth-like planets in Solar System formation simulations and adjusts the initial redox state of the building blocks in a synthetic protoplanetary disk until the mantle of the simulated Earth closely matches the bulk silicate Earth. We find that a strong oxidizing gradient among the initial solids of the protoplanetary disk is favored to reproduce the chemistry of Earth's mantle, in agreement with Rubie et al. (2015b). The Solar System formation scenarios examined here successfully reproduce the composition of Earth if two related conditions are met: 1) there is a strong positive oxidation gradient with distance in the inner protoplanetary disk and 2) Earth accretes increasingly more oxidized material (on average) as it grows. Furthermore, in simulations that successfully reproduce Earth's composition, Proto-Earth and Theia may possess a wide range of mantle compositions and mass ratios. However, because late accretion is oxidizing across all proposed Solar System formation scenarios, Theia and Proto-Earth cannot both possess mantles that are more oxidized than the present-day Earth's mantle. Similarly, Theia's mantle may be significantly more oxidized than present-day Earth's mantle, but only if it is relatively small compared to the Proto-Earth.

Sources

Related papers