Viscosity heats, diffusion drains: Open-system thermodynamics in unimodular cosmology
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Viscosity heats, diffusion drains".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In general relativity with bulk viscosity and in unimodular gravity with energy diffusion, the matter sector is non-adiabatic, and its balance, entropy and temperature equations coincide under the identification Π ↔ Q/˙ 3H <ref:2611.13269#pg6>.
Kai: Formal Correspondence The formal correspondence between bulk viscosity in general relativity and energy diffusion in unimodular gravity is restricted to the internal balance, entropy, and temperature equations of the matter sector.
Mira: This correspondence fails when the Friedmann constraint and the entropy of the receiving sector are included.
Kai: The authors show that assigning a temperature TD to the hidden reservoir that absorbs the diffused energy unifies these two prescriptions as limiting cases of open-system entropy production.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "Viscosity heats, diffusion drains: Open-system thermodynamics in unimodular cosmology." It’s by Miguel Cruz and Samuel Lepe. The title tells you immediately that it’s about how viscosity in general relativity and energy diffusion in unimodular gravity relate when we look at the whole open system picture.
Mira: Yeah, and what’s interesting is the authors aren't just comparing the equations for GR versus unimodular gravity; they are showing how they finally coincide under a specific identification between terms, which is that relationship between Pi and Q over three times H. That’s a pretty neat connection to draw.
Lev: From my side, I’m mostly interested in the setup. They use the spatially flat Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric in unimodular gravity but they treat dark matter as a gas with conserved rest mass, which is key for what follows.
Kai: Right, so we’re starting with this core idea of matching these two different physical mechanisms—viscosity and diffusion—in this specific cosmological framework. It’s not just a mathematical trick; they are building something that links how things heat up and drain energy in these two gravity theories.
Mira: And the paper points out that whether unimodular cosmology is adiabatic depends entirely on whether you assign entropy to just the matter sector or to the total effective fluid, which really frames how we look at this.
Lev: That distinction about where you put the entropy is what makes it so complex; it’s not a simple yes or no answer for which model is adiabatic >
The paper's summary: Kai: The main takeaway from "Viscosity heats, diffusion drains: Open-system thermodynamics in unimodular cosmology" is that they show that the matter sector isn't adiabatic in either theory, and their balance, entropy and temperature equations only line up if you use this identification we talked about earlier.
Mira: Exactly. They introduce a way to account for this by assigning a hidden temperature TD to the reservoir that absorbs the diffused energy, and they show that this unified prescription works as limits when you let TD go to infinity or when it equals Tm.
Lev: So, essentially, they unify two different ways of thinking about how energy is handled in these systems: one where dissipation is internal bulk viscosity in GR and another where it's external energy diffusion in unimodular gravity.
Kai: It gets more interesting because they then break down the total entropy production per comoving volume into three distinct regimes based on that hidden temperature TD.
Mira: They have the matter limit where TD goes to infinity, which means the receiving sector absorbs heat without changing its entropy, and in that case, you require the rate of energy release Q over three times H to be less than or equal to zero.
Lev: Then there’s the reversible limit where TD equals Tm, which is what we expect when things are perfectly in equilibrium and you recover a standard adiabatic accounting of things.
Kai: And finally, there's the finite bath regime where TD is different from Tm, and here they require that the net heat flow Q over three times H times the difference between those temperatures must be non-negative, meaning heat flows from hotter to colder sectors.
The paper's improvements: Mira: Beyond just stating the result, the authors suggest several ways to push this research further. They point out that their formal correspondence is restricted only to the internal balance, entropy, and temperature equations of the matter sector; it fails when you try to include things like the Friedmann constraint or the entropy of a receiving sector.
Kai: That’s a big limitation they admit upfront, and they suggest fixing that by assigning that hidden temperature TD to unify these prescriptions as limiting cases of open-system entropy production.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, they are essentially proposing this temperature TD as the key parameter we need to pin down from microscopic inputs because it controls how the diffusion acts like heat conduction rather than just internal expansion work.
Mira: They also explore kinematic signatures, like how the deceleration parameter q and the diffusion rate j yield different constraints on dissipation; for instance, for pressureless dark matter, they get specific forms for Pi and Q over three times H that are different between GR and unimodular gravity.
Kai: And they use the ratio of Q over three times H times rho to control what they call the adiabatic sound speed of the unimodular effective fluid; this quantity is constrained by perturbative stability and causality, specifically being between zero and one.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up "Viscosity heats, diffusion drains: Open-system thermodynamics in unimodular cosmology," the core message is that assigning a temperature TD to the hidden reservoir unifies bulk viscosity and energy diffusion as limiting cases of open-system entropy production.
Mira: This framework allows them to treat diffusion as heat conduction governed by Q over three times H times the difference between temperatures, rather than just internal expansion work. It also shows how this affects the effective sound speed, which is constrained by stability and causality between zero and one.
Lev: From a hardware perspective, this means that if we model dark matter as a gas with conserved rest mass, it prevents phantom behavior and bounds the growth of the cosmological term by the available thermal reservoir.
Kai: And they draw a few important physical differences arising from the structural asymmetry between general relativity and unimodular gravity, like different adiabatic limits for viscous fluids and how they handle dark matter modeling.
Mira: They also show that cold dark matter with conserved particle number and mass cannot source a late-time logotropic dark fluid without having been relativistic at redshift one point two.
Lev: The open problems they leave are really about figuring out the evolution of that bath temperature TD and some friction coefficient beta bar, which depend on microscopic details we don't have yet.
Kai: Plus, we still need to figure out how to generalize the diffusion current beyond the FLRW metric for perturbations, which is a big hurdle for any full description.
Miguel Cruz, *, Samuel Lepe, *
Facultad de Física, Universidad Veracruzana · Instituto de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaěso
gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-11-09
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 11 pages, 1 figure
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: In general relativity with bulk viscosity and in unimodular gravity with energy diffusion, the matter sector is non-adiabatic, and its balance…
Key concepts
- Bulk Viscosity vs. Energy Diffusion
- These are two different physical processes: bulk viscosity in GR and energy diffusion in unimodular gravity. The paper investigates how they relate to each other, finding a formal correspondence between them concerning the matter sector's internal balance, entropy, and temperature equations.
- Open-System Entropy Production
- The total entropy production is calculated using a specific formula involving the bath temperature (TD) and matter temperature (Tm). This framework treats the system as open, allowing for heat exchange between the matter and a hidden reservoir. Different limits of this accounting define different physical regimes.
- Kinematic Signatures ($c^2_s$)
- The effective sound speed squared ($c^2_s$) in unimodular cosmology is related to the diffusion rate ($Q/ ext{3H} ho$). This quantity is crucial because it constrains perturbative stability and causality, showing that its value depends on the dissipation rate rather than just cosmic acceleration.
- Dark Matter Modeling Constraints
- Modeling dark matter as a gas with conserved rest mass imposes strict thermodynamic limits. This modeling shows that cold dark matter cannot source a late-time logotropic fluid unless it was already relativistic at very early times (z ~ 12), due to the limitations of the available thermal reservoir.
Terminology
Summary
In general relativity with bulk viscosity and in unimodular gravity with energy diffusion, the matter sector is non-adiabatic, and its balance, entropy and temperature equations coincide under the identification Π ↔ Q/˙ 3H <ref:2611. p. 013269#pg6>.
Formal Correspondence
The formal correspondence between bulk viscosity in general relativity and energy diffusion in unimodular gravity is restricted to the internal balance, entropy, and temperature equations of the matter sector. This correspondence fails when the Friedmann constraint and the entropy of the receiving sector are included. p. 8 The authors show that assigning a temperature TD to the hidden reservoir that absorbs the diffused energy unifies these two prescriptions as limiting cases of open-system entropy production. p. 8
Thermodynamic Accounting
The total entropy production per comoving volume is given by Q˙ (1/TD − 1/Tm). The authors identify three regimes for this production:
**(A) Matter limit (TD → ∞): the receiving sector absorbs heat without changing its entropy, the total entropy is that of matter alone, and the second law requires Q˙ ≤ 0. **
**(B) Reversible limit (TD = Tm): the total entropy is conserved for any Q˙, recovering the adiabatic accounting of Ref. p. 2 [20]. **
**(C) Finite-bath regime (finite TD ≠ Tm): the second law requires Q˙ (Tm − TD) ≥ 0, so that heat flows from the hotter to the colder sector. p. 2 The authors adopt a minimal linear-response closure where Q˙ = K (Tm − TD), with K ≥ 0. p. 3 This leads to a quadratic entropy production S˙m + S˙D/V = K (Tm − TD) 2 / TmTD ≥ 0. p. 3 The authors conclude that thermal equilibrium Tm = TD implies Q˙ = 0 for any finite K. p. 3 **
Kinematic Signatures
The cosmographic reading of the deceleration parameter q and the diffusion rate j yields different constraints on dissipation. For pressureless dark matter, this results in Π = H2 (2q − 1) and Q˙ = 2H3 (j − 1). p. 3 The authors note that cosmic acceleration requires dissipation in the viscous frame, but not in UG. p. 4 Furthermore, the ratio Q/˙ 3Hρ controls the adiabatic sound speed of the unimodular effective fluid, c 2s = ω + Q˙ / 3Hρ =˜ω. p. 4 This quantity is constrained by perturbative stability and causality, specifically 0 ≤ c 2s ≤ 1. p. 4
Physical Differences and Constraints
The authors highlight three physical differences arising from the structural asymmetry between GR and UG.
(i) Different adiabatic limits:
(ii) Thermodynamic status of ΛCDM:
(iii) Thermal meaning of the jerk:
The viscous reading is adiabatic only for a decelerating perfect fluid q = (1 + 3ω)/2, whereas the diffusive reading is adiabatic whenever j = 1+3ω(1+q). Since ΛCDM has j = 1, it represents the adiabatic limit of unimodular cosmology. p. 4 The authors also show that for q0 ≃ −0. p. 055, Eq. (30) yields Π/ρ = (1 − 2q0)/3 ≃ 0. p. 47, far outside the regime of quasi-equilibrium. p. 4 The sign of Eq. p. 0 (29) tracks the sign of Tm−TD. p. 4
Dark Matter Modeling
When dark matter is modeled as a gas with conserved rest mass, thermodynamically consistent diffusion removes thermal energy alone, precludes phantom behavior, and bounds the growth of the cosmological term by the available thermal reservoir. The second law prevents diffusion from extracting rest-mass energy, ensuring Tm > 0. p. 9 Because the growth of the cosmological term is bounded by the available thermal energy, ∆Q ≤ ε(t1), cold dark matter with conserved particle number and mass cannot source a late-time logotropic dark fluid without having been relativistic at z ≃ 12. p. 9 The logotropic dark fluid requires rest-mass conversion rather than thermal conduction to sustain its drain. p. 7 p. 7
Horizon Dynamics
The generalized second law (GSL) in unimodular gravity follows directly from the local one at the dynamical apparent horizon. The total entropy rate combines into S˙h + S˙in + S˙D,in = 16π2 (1 + q) 2H(1 − q) + VhQ˙ / (TD − Th). p. 8 For q < 1, the first term of Eq. p. 8 (57) is manifestly nonnegative and the second is non-negative by the local second law. p. 8 In GR, because ω > −1 ensures 2 − q + 3ω = (1 − q) + (1 + 3ω) > 0 across the accelerating and phantom regimes (q < 0), Eq. p. 8 (58) makes the GSL for q < 1 equivalent to q ≥ -1, i. p. 8e., Π ≥ −(1 + ω)ρ.
Open Problems
Four points remain open regarding the study of this system. These include determining the evolution of the bath temperature TD and friction coefficient β¯, which depend on microscopic inputs. p. 8 Perturbations require the diffusion current Jµ beyond FLRW, which neither phenomenological nor microscopic descriptions fix. p. 8 A dynamically relevant Q fed by cold dark matter requires rest-mass conversion. p. 8 Finally, a causal generalization of the Newton law (22) would require revisiting Eq. p. 8 (46) with thermal inertia. p. 8 The authors suggest that particle annihilation into the bath could achieve rest-mass conversion. p. 8
Concluding Remarks
The formal correspondence Π ↔ Q/˙ 3H between bulk viscosity in GR and energy diffusion in UG is restricted to the internal balance, entropy, and temperature equations of the matter sector. Assigning a temperature TD to the hidden reservoir that absorbs the diffused energy unifies these two prescriptions as limiting cases of open-system entropy production. p. 8 Under this open-system accounting, diffusion operates as heat conduction governed by Q˙ = K(Tm−TD) rather than internal expansion work. p. 9 Diffusion into a cold bath drains heat from an open fluid, is determined by the jerk j (making ΛCDM its adiabatic limit), and shifts the effective sound speed by c 2s −ω = Q/˙ 3Hρ independently of cosmic acceleration. p. 9 Because rest-mass is unavailable, the growth of the cosmological term is bounded by the available thermal energy, ∆Q ≤ ε(t1), cold dark matter with conserved particle number and mass cannot source a late-time logotropic dark fluid without having been relativistic at z ≃ 12. p. 9 The natural continuation is a microscopic determination of TD and K, the treatment of rest-mass conversion into the bath, and the extension of the diffusion current to perturbations. p. 9
Acknowledgments
MC work was partially supported by S.N.I.I (SECIHTI-M´exico). p. 9 SL acknowledges the FONDECYT grant N◦ 1250969, Chile. p. 9
Appendix A
For matter with conserved particle number, the Gibbs relation per particle reads dσ = dρ/(nT) − (ρ + p) dn/(n 2T). Along the flow, with ˙n = −3Hn, T˙ = (∂T /∂ρ)nρ˙ − 3Hn(∂T /∂n)ρ. p. 9 The general solution of Eq. p. 9 (A1) is T = ρ ω/(1+ω)F(y), y ≡ ρ 1/(1+ω) n, (A3). Along the flow, y˙ y = −Q˙(1 + ω)ρ / (UG), so y is conserved only without dissipation. p. 9 The ideal gas without rest mass is F(y) = ωy. p. 9 The gas with rest mass of Sec. p. 1 VI, Eq. (37), is not of the form p = ωρ, but it also satisfies Eq. p. 9 (A1), as shown below Eq. p. 2 (38). Along the flow, y˙ y = -Q˙(UG), so y is conserved only without dissipation. p. 9 The cold-bath limit εD = 0 encompasses the microscopic law of Ref. p. 5 p. 5 [13]. The Newton law (22) takes the form Q˙ = Γ (ε − εD), with Γ ≡ ωth K/n ≥ 0, εD ≡ nTD / ωth, where εD is the thermal energy density matter would have at the bath temperature and Γ = K/cV is the thermal exchange rate. p. 5 Substituting Eq. p. 3 (41) into Eq. (39) yields Newton’s law of cooling superposed on the adiabatic expansion cooling Tm ∝ a −3ωth, T˙m + 3ωthHTm = −Γ (Tm − TD). p. 5 The cold-bath limit εD = 0 encompasses the microscopic law of Ref. [13]. Applying the differential form of Gr¨onwall’s inequality immediately yields ε(t) ≥ ε(t0) exp − Z t/t0 [3(1 + ωth)H + Γ] dt'. The upper bound Q(t) − Q(t1) ≤ ε(t1), independent of the intermediate sign of Q˙. p. 6 The universal bound Q(t) − Q(t1) ≤ ε(t0), independent of the intermediate sign of Q˙. p. 6 The logotropic dark fluid requires rest-mass conversion rather than thermal conduction to sustain its drain. The saturating law Q˙ = 3AH/[1 + (a/a∗) 3] 2 of Ref. p. 7 [20], which keeps Law Removes Status in regime (C). p. 7 Table II summarizes the thermodynamic status of representative diffusion laws in the finite-bath regime (C). p. 7 p. 7 The second column states what each law removes from matter. p. 7 p. 7 p. 7 Table II summarizes the thermodynamic status of representative diffusion laws in the finite-bath regime (C). The second column states what each law removes from matter.
Table II
The second column states what each law removes from matter.
Figure 1
For ωth = 2/3, the values of Refs. [20, 23], and ε0/mn0 = 10−6, an upper value for cold dark matter. p. 7 (a) Thermal energy per unit rest mass that dark matter must have had in the past for the energy drained by the logotropic and saturating laws to be heat, Eq. p. 7 (54), compared with adiabatic evolution without diffusion; the shaded region is relativistic. p. 7 (b) Growth of the cosmological term after today, in units of the present thermal energy density. p. 7 The shaded region violates the bound (49); cold dark matter can lower ρa3 only by a fraction of order ε/ρ. p. 8
Table I
Bulk viscosity in GR and energy diffusion in UG under the finite-bath regime (C). Rows above the line are structural; rows below are the consequences derived in Secs. p. 4 V–VII.
Diffusion laws for dark matter with conserved rest mass, read through Eq. (41). The second column states what each law removes from matter.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can distinguish between bulk viscosity in General Relativity and energy diffusion in unimodular gravity by analyzing how each mechanism couples to the Friedmann constraint versus the Raychaudhuri equation, as
Q enters the constraint and not the Raychaudhuri equation, whereas Π enters the Raychaudhuri equation and not the constraint.
-
Improved AI system can determine if a cosmological model is adiabatic or dissipative by calculating both deceleration parameters qGR and qUG; for example,
The viscous reading is adiabatic only for a decelerating perfect fluid q = (1 + 3ω)/2, whereas by Eq. (29) the diffusive reading is adiabatic whenever j = 1+3ω(1+q).
-
Improved AI system can predict the effective sound speed of unimodular effective fluids using the kinematic identity derived from Eq. (1), specifically calculating c2s s = j - 1/3(1 + q) and relating it to Q/˙ 3Hρ, which is
governed by perturbative stability rather than cosmic acceleration.
-
Improved AI system can evaluate the thermodynamic status of the logotropic dark fluid by checking if its evolution
fails in both time directions: Forward in time, Tm and ε vanish at the scale factor ln aT = ln [1 + (1 + ωth)ε0/A] 3(1 + ωth) ≃ ε0 3A ≃ 3.5×10−5.
-
Improved AI system can assess the constraints on dark matter modeling by identifying that
cold dark matter with conserved particle number and mass cannot source a late-time logotropic dark fluid without having been relativistic at z ≃ 12.
Sources
- Dark energy genesis: modeling dissipative effects in primordial cosmology
- Causal Thermodynamics in Relativity
- Spatial curvature in Unimodular Gravity
- How Cold is Cold Dark Matter?
- DESI DR2 Results II: Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Cosmological Constraints
- Unimodular Diffusion and Interacting Vacuum Cosmology
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals