Measurement of the 169 Tm (gamma,n) 168 Tm Cross Section and Implications for gamma-Process Calculations

arXiv:2611.12994 · nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Measurement of the 169 Tm (gamma,n) 168 Tm Cross Section and Implications for gamma-Process Calculations".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section was measured at SLEGS with quasi-monoenergetic LCS γ-ray beams from 8.27 MeV to 14.61 MeV.

Kai: This measurement provides an independent benchmark for assessing the absolute normalization and energy dependence of the excitation function.

Mira: Measurement Methodology The experimental setup at SLEGS utilized laser-Compton-scattering γ rays to measure the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Kai: The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper, "Measurement of the one hundred sixty-nine Tm (gamma,n) one hundred sixty-eight Tm Cross Section and Implications for gamma-Process Calculations <ref:2611.12994#pg1,Cross Section and Implications for>." Essentially, they measured how often a gamma ray hits a one hundred sixty-nine thulium atom and knocks out a neutron to make one hundred sixty-eight thulium.

Mira: And the big deal here is that this measurement is supposed to be an independent benchmark for checking how accurately we know the absolute normalization and how the cross section changes with energy. It’s testing some fundamental physics assumptions in nuclear reaction calculations, which are used for things like gamma processes in stars <ref:2611.12994#pg2>.

Lev: For us on the ground, what they did was use quasi-monoenergetic laser Compton scattering gamma rays at SLEGS, covering an energy range from eight point two seven MeV up to fourteen point six one MeV <ref:2611.12994#pg1>. That whole setup is designed to get a clean energy distribution of those gamma rays.

Kai: Right, so they used this specific beam type to get these measurements, and the paper points out that they used an iterative unfolding method to turn the raw data into monoenergetic cross sections <ref:2611.12994#pg2>. I wonder how much correction those unfolding steps introduce because they said the unfolded cross sections are systematically higher near the threshold where the low-energy tail of that beam contributes a bigger correction <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Mira: That’s a key point, because if you don't account for that low-energy tail correctly, your resulting cross section will look wrong right near the threshold <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. The paper then joint fits this measurement data with existing NewSUBARU data to constrain the giant dipole resonance, which they found at an energy of one twenty point three MeV with a width of two point two MeV <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Lev: That constraint on the giant dipole resonance, that means they are using this measurement to pin down some fundamental properties of the nucleus itself, which is what we need for our models <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. But how does that input translate to a better nuclear model?

Kai: Well, they took that constrained giant dipole resonance strength function and used it as an input for their Hartree-Fock calculations in the TALYS two point zero code <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. They even derived a constraint on the E one strength function using this relation where the E one strength is roughly one over three pi squared times h bar squared times two c squared times sigma gamma n of energy times that gamma energy <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Mira: And what they found is that this derived E one strength function agrees with the NewSUBARU fit within about ten percent at the peak maxima <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. That agreement gives confidence in using their nuclear input for predicting stellar reaction rates <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Lev: For real hardware running error correction, that level of agreement with existing nuclear inputs is good because it suggests the input physics is sound for what we're trying to model <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. But let's talk about the application: they used these constrained strength functions to calculate stellar reaction rates for one hundred sixty nine thulium and one hundred sixty eight thulium <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Kai: And the result is that at temperatures around two point zero to three point five, the photodisintegration rate is about two times larger than the JINA REACLIB rate, with the only remaining uncertainty coming from the nuclear level density <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. That's a significant factor in how quickly these reactions happen in stellar environments.

Mira: So for someone just listening to this, what it means is that when we model core-collapse supernovae, specifically for the oxygen over neon shell of a twenty solar mass core-collapse supernova model, this revised rate has almost no effect on the final proton nucleus abundances <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. That suggests their work doesn't drastically change our predictions for what those stars end up making.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means that if we were trying to run simulations on real hardware for these reactions, the overhead from using this revised rate would be negligible compared to the nuclear level density uncertainty <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. It's not a huge computational burden just because of the refinement.

Kai: To wrap up, in this paper "Measurement of the one hundred sixty-nine Tm (gamma,n) one hundred sixty-eight Tm Cross Section and Implications for gamma-Process Calculations," they used quasi-monoenergetic laser Compton scattering gamma rays from eight point two seven MeV to fourteen point six one MeV <ref:2611.12994#pg1>.

Mira: The main thesis is that this measurement provides a way to test the giant dipole resonance and constrain the E one strength function, which they found agrees with NewSUBARU data within about ten percent at its peak maxima <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Lev: And ultimately, the implication for stellar physics is that their revised reaction rates have a negligible effect on the final proton nucleus abundances in core-collapse supernova models <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Kai: So, to sum up, this paper shows how experimental measurements of photoneutron cross sections can be used to pin down nuclear structure inputs for stellar reaction rate calculations <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of experimental validation for the models used in gamma processes <ref:2611.12994#pg2>. The work really helps confirm the statistical models used in this region of the rare-earth elements <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Lev: We see how tying experimental data to theoretical inputs, like those Hartree-Fock calculations, gives you a much tighter picture of what's actually happening in the nucleus <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Kai: That’s it for this talk on the paper. It shows that precise measurements can give us reliable inputs for complex astrophysical calculations <ref:2611.12994#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at the paper, "Measurement of the one hundred sixty-nine Tm (gamma,n) one hundred sixty-eight Tm Cross Section and Implications for gamma-Process Calculations." Essentially, they measured how frequently a gamma ray hits one hundred sixty-nine thulium and knocks out a neutron to make one hundred sixty-eight thulium.

Mira: And the authors are using that measurement to test some fundamental assumptions in nuclear reaction calculations, which are used for modeling things like gamma processes in stars. It’s about checking if our basic nuclear inputs match what we see experimentally.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, they took a measured quantity and tried to fit it into a larger model. That means they're testing the stability and accuracy of those models when you feed them real experimental data instead of just pure theory.

Kai: What’s interesting is how they use this cross section measurement to pin down the giant dipole resonance in that nucleus, which they found at about twelve point three MeV with a width of two point two MeV. That’s a specific piece of nuclear structure information they extracted from the data.

Mira: And that strength function they derived from the measurement agreed with other theoretical fits within about ten percent at the peak maxima. That level of agreement is what gives confidence to use that input for predicting stellar reaction rates in stars.

Lev: So, they used this constrained strength function to calculate how fast these reactions happen in stars, and the result shows that at temperatures between two point zero and three point five, the photodisintegration rate is about twice as fast as some other rates we usually look at.

Kai: The big picture here is that even though their revised rates are a bit higher, for the final proton abundances in a core-collapse supernova model, the effect on those abundances is pretty small. It means their experimental work confirms our general approach to these calculations without totally rewriting the stellar evolution models.

Mira: So, this paper shows how tying precise experimental data to theoretical inputs helps us get a tighter picture of what’s happening inside the nucleus. It gives us better numbers for predicting how gamma processes function in extreme astrophysical environments.

Lev: It confirms that even when you're dealing with complex nuclear physics and astrophysics, if your input constraints are solid, the resulting calculations remain stable enough to be used for modeling stellar outcomes.

Kai: Next time we talk about these types of reactions, we'll look at how those experimental setups actually handle the energy spread and what kind of noise that introduces.

De-Xin Wang, Su-Ya-La-Tu Zhang, Zi-Rui Hao, Han Guo, Wen-Yu Xin, Guo Li, Yong-Shun Huang, Jin Feng Bai, © Kai Wang, © Mei-Rong Huang, П Bao-Shan Xi

Institute of Nuclear Physics, College of Physics and Electronic Information, Inner Mongolia Minzu University · Shanghai Advanced Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences · Institute of Astronomy and Physics, Inner Mongolia University · CAS Key Laboratory of Optical Astronomy, National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences · HUN-REN Institute of Nuclear Research (ATOMKI) · University of Chinese Academy of Sciences

nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-08

Updated: 2026-11-08

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: The 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section was measured at SLEGS with quasi-monoenergetic LCS γ-ray beams from 8.27 MeV to 14.61 MeV.

Key concepts

Cross Section Measurement
This involves experimentally determining the probability that a specific nuclear reaction, like 169Tm absorbing a gamma ray and emitting neutrons, will occur at different energies. The researchers used laser-Compton-scattering gamma rays to measure this probability across a specific energy range.
Excitation Function
This describes how the cross section of the reaction changes as the energy of the incoming gamma ray changes. By measuring this function, scientists can understand the underlying nuclear structure and how these reactions behave under different conditions.
E1 Strength Function
This function represents a key property of nuclei, specifically related to electric dipole (E1) transitions. The measurement helped constrain this function by comparing it with other data sets, which is crucial for accurately calculating stellar reaction rates.
Stellar Reaction Rate
This refers to the rate at which nuclear reactions occur within stars or during events like core-collapse supernovae. The constrained cross section data allowed researchers to calculate these rates, showing that the revised rate has a small impact on final p-nucleus abundances.

Terminology

Summary

The 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section was measured at SLEGS with quasi-monoenergetic LCS γ-ray beams from 8. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A measurement at a different LCS facility, with an independent neutrondetection system, photon-flux determination, and unfolding analysis, therefore provides a complementary data set for examining the consistency of the available cross sections. In the present work, we measured the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section using LCS γ-ray beams at the Shanghai Laser Electron Gamma Source (SLEGS), from just above the neutron emission threshold to 14.

27 MeV to 14. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. Below 12 MeV, the present cross sections agree well with the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluations.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. Below 12 MeV, the present cross sections agree well with the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluations.

61 MeV. This measurement provides an independent benchmark for assessing the absolute normalization and energy dependence of the excitation function. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Differences in photon-flux determination, neutron-detection efficiency, energy calibration, target-thickness corrections, and unfolding procedures may contribute to the remaining discrepancy [22, 40]. The independent SLEGS measurement therefore provides a complementary benchmark for assessing the absolute normalization and energy dependence of the excitation function.

Measurement Methodology

The experimental setup at SLEGS utilized laser-Compton-scattering γ rays to measure the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section <ref:2611.12994#pg3>. The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Measurement of the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm Cross Section and Implications for γ-Process Calculations De-Xin Wang , 1, ∗ Su-Ya-La-Tu Zhang , 1, † Zi-Rui Hao , 2, ‡ Han Guo , 1, ∗ Wen-Yu Xin , 3 Guo Li , 1, 4 Yong-Shun Huang , 1 Jin-Feng Bai , 1 Kai Wang , 1 Mei-Rong Huang , 1 Bao-Shan Xi , 1 Peter Mohr , 5 Jian-Fang Zhang , 1 Gong-Tao Fan , 2, 6 and Hong-Wei Wang 2, 6 1 Institute of Nuclear Physics, College of Physics and Electronic Information, Inner Mongolia Minzu University, Tongliao 028000, China 2Shanghai Advanced Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 201210, China 3 Institute of Astronomy and Physics, Inner Mongolia University, Hohhot 010021, China 4CAS Key Laboratory of Optical Astronomy, National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China 5HUN-REN Institute of Nuclear Research (ATOMKI), H-4001 Debrecen, Hungary 6University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China The 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section has been measured at the Shanghai Laser Electron Gamma Source (SLEGS) using quasi-monoenergetic laser-Compton-scattering γ rays over the energy range from the neutron threshold to 14. The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method.

The measured excitation function is compared with existing data and HF calculations to test the predicted absolute magnitude and energy dependence of the cross section. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This energy range probes the near-threshold response and the lower-energy component of the deformation-split GDR. The measured excitation function is compared with existing data and HF calculations to test the predicted absolute magnitude and energy dependence of the cross section and to examine the sensitivity to the adopted γSF and NLD.

Cross-Section Analysis

The monoenergetic cross sections of the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm reaction were obtained using the iterative unfolding procedure described in Section III. The unfolded cross sections are systematically higher than the folded values near threshold, where the low-energy tail of the LCS beam contributes a larger fractional correction. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The points denote the quasi-monoenergetic cross sections, and the solid line with the shaded band represents the unfolded monoenergetic cross section together with its total uncertainty. For 169Tm, the unfolded cross sections are systematically higher than the folded values near threshold, where the low-energy tail of the LCS beam contributes a larger fractional correction.

A joint fit to the present and NewSUBARU data constrains the GDR, with the first component at Em1 ≃ 12. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The first two components, which describe the split GDR, are determined by the present SLEGS data and by the NewSUBARU points in the 8–20 MeV region, where the uncertainties are at the level of a few percent. In contrast, the third component is constrained solely by the NewSUBARU data above 20 MeV [20, 21], which are sparse and have large uncertainties.

3 MeV and Γ1 ≃ 2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. Below 12 MeV, the present cross sections agree well with the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluations.

2 MeV.

Constraint on Nuclear Inputs

The E1 strength function derived from the joint fit agrees with that obtained from the NewSUBARU fit to within about 10% at the peak maxima. This E1 strength function is used as the E1 input to the HF calculations in TALYS-2. p. 8

Where the paper says it

[21] on a linear scale: the two curves agree closely over the GDR region, differing by less than about 10% at the peak maxima, which shows that the two SLO descriptions of the 169Tm photoneutron data yield essentially the same E1 strength function In the lower-energy part of the measured region, around Eγ ≃ 9–11 MeV, the TALYS SMLO model follows the experimentally constrained strength relatively well, while the Gogny D1M HFB+QRPA calculation lies systematically above it by up to about a factor of two, although neither reproduces the shape of the split GDR over the full resonance region. None of the prescriptions tested here reproduces both the low-energy slope and the split GDR; the E1 strength of the joint SLO fit is therefore used as the E1 input to the HF calculations, with its extrapolation below the measured energy range given by the fitted SLO shape.

0. The constraint on the E1 strength is derived using the relation fE1(Eγ) ≃ 1/3π2ħ2c2σγn(Eγ)Eγ. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In the energy region above the neutron separation energy where neutron emission dominates the photoabsorption decay, the E1 strength can therefore be constrained from the measured photoneutron cross section according to fE1(Eγ) ≃ 1 3π 2ℏ 2c 2 σγn(Eγ) Eγ . (11) This relation provides the experimental constraint on the E1 strength in the photon-energy region covered by the present 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm measurement.

Stellar Reaction Rate Implications

The stellar reaction rate of 169Tm(γ, n) and 168Tm(n, γ) were calculated by incorporating these constrained γ-ray strength functions into the TALYS code. At T9 = 2–3.5 the photodisintegration rate is larger than the JINA REACLIB rate by a factor of about 2, with a remaining uncertainty from the nuclear level density. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The stellar photodisintegration rate is obtained by thermally averaging over the ground and excited target states, λ ∗ γn(T) = 1 G(T) X i 2Ji + 1 2J0 + 1 exp − Ei kBT λ (i) γn(T), (15) where Ei and Ji are the excitation energy and spin of the ith target state, respectively, J0 is the ground-state spin, and λ (i) γn(T) is the photodisintegration rate from that state. The temperature-dependent partition function G(T), normalized to the ground-state statistical weight, is given by [52] (2J0 + 1)G(T) = X im i=0 (2Ji + 1)e −Ei/kBT + Z Emax Eim X J,π (2J + 1)e −ϵ/kBT ρ(ϵ, J, π) dϵ, (16) where ρ(ϵ, J, π) is the spin- and parity-dependent nuclear level density.

Network calculations for the O/Ne shell of a 20 M⊙ core-collapse supernova model show that the revised rate has a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The calculated 169Tm(γ, n) rates were adopted in a full p-process reaction network for the shock-heated O/Ne-rich layers of a 20M⊙ core-collapse supernova model to perform a sensitivity analysis. The updated rates have a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances.

Conclusion

The 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm cross section was measured at SLEGS with quasi-monoenergetic LCS γ-ray beams from 8.27 MeV to 14.61 MeV. Below 12 MeV the present cross sections agree well with the analyzed NewSUBARU data and with the IAEA-2019. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr3(Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. Below 12 MeV, the present cross sections agree well with the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluations.

The revised rate has a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The calculated 169Tm(γ, n) rates were adopted in a full p-process reaction network for the shock-heated O/Ne-rich layers of a 20M⊙ core-collapse supernova model to perform a sensitivity analysis. The updated rates have a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grants No. 12465024 and No. 12365018). The authors gratefully acknowledge the accelerator operators and beamline engineers at the SLEGS facility [62] of the SSRF [63] for delivering a stable γ-ray beam throughout the experiment and for their invaluable technical assistance. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Interaction Chamber Multi-function Chamber Slant Scattering Mode Backward scattering Mode M1 γ-ray beam C5 T2 CO2Laser Shielding Wall Laser Hutch M4 M0 FED 169Tm Target Cu attenuator LaBr3 DAQ Gamma Absorber FIG. Schematic diagram of the photoneutron cross-section measurement setup at the SLEGS beamline.

The authors thank I. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The reaction flow is initiated mainly by (γ, n) reactions, which drive material toward the proton-rich side of the nuclear chart; as neutron separation energies increase, competing (γ, p) and (γ, α) channels redirect the flow toward lower atomic numbers, followed by β + decays or electron captures during freeze-out [3]. Several astrophysical environments have been investigated as potential γ-process sites, including the shock-heated O/Ne-rich layers of massive stars during core-collapse supernovae and the outer layers of exploding carbon–oxygen white dwarfs in Type ∗ These authors contributed equally to this work.

Gheorghe for providing the analyzed NewSUBARU 169Tm photoneutron data (private communication). p. 1
Where the paper says it

Photoneutron cross sections for 169Tm were previously measured with laser-Compton-scattering (LCS) γray beams at NewSUBARU, and preliminary results were provided to the IAEA coordinated research project that produced the IAEA-2019 photonuclear data library [20]. The NewSUBARU group has recently analyzed these measurements using updated photon-flux determinations and LCS γ-beam spectra, together with revised treatments of beam nonmonochromaticity and neutron-multiplicity sorting, yielding revised cross sections [21, 22].

Data Availability

The cross-section data of Table I and the stellar rates of Table III are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request. The NewSUBARU 169Tm photoneutron data used in this work were provided by I. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Within the rare-earth region, the stable, deformed odd-mass nucleus 169Tm offers an experimentally accessible case for testing the description of photoexcitation and neutron emission from the near-threshold region into the giant dipole resonance (GDR). Photoneutron cross sections for 169Tm were previously measured with laser-Compton-scattering (LCS) γray beams at NewSUBARU, and preliminary results were provided to the IAEA coordinated research project that produced the IAEA-2019 photonuclear data library [20].

Gheorghe (private communication). The analysis procedure is described in Ref. p. 5
Where the paper says it

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION A. Photoneutron cross sections The monoenergetic cross sections of the 169Tm(γ, n) 168Tm reaction were obtained using the iterative unfolding procedure described in Sec.

[21].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved cross-section extraction via iterative unfolding procedure: The system can accurately recover monoenergetic cross sections from measured yields by inverting the linear relation, ensuring that the resulting unfolded cross sections for 169Tm(gamma, n) 168Tm, together with their propagated total uncertainties, are shown in Fig. 4.

  2. Enhanced constraint on the E1 gamma ray strength function: The system can derive an E1 strength function used in all TALYS-2.0 calculations of this work by fitting the joint data to determine parameters like Em1, Emi, and Γi, which are then converted using the relation derived from fE1(Eγ) ≃ 1/3π2ħ2c2σγn(Eγ) Eγ.

  3. Superior stellar reaction rate calculation: The system can calculate stellar rates by incorporating thermally populated target states into the evaluation of the stellar rate, specifically using λ∗g n(T) = 1/G(T) X sum i=0 (2Ji + 1)/2J0 + 1 exp-Ei/kBT λ(i) γn(T), which accounts for low-lying excited states.

  4. Sensitivity analysis for p-nucleus production: The system can perform a sensitivity analysis by calculating the final p-process abundances using a full reaction network, showing that The updated rates have a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances.

Abstract

The 169 Tm(γ,n) 168 Tm cross section has been measured at the Shanghai Laser Electron Gamma Source (SLEGS) using quasi-monoenergetic laser-Compton-scattering γ rays over the energy range from the neutron threshold to 14.61 MeV. The photon flux and energy distribution were determined with a LaBr 3 (Ce) spectrometer, and monoenergetic cross sections were obtained using an iterative unfolding method. Below 12 MeV, the present cross sections agree well with the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluations. However, near the maximum of the (γ,n) excitation function, the present cross sections are significantly higher than both the NewSUBARU data and the IAEA-2019 evaluated values. The E1 γ-ray strength functions were derived by fitting the experimental cross sections measured at SLEGS and NewSUBARU. The stellar reaction rates for 169 Tm(γ,n) and 168 Tm(n,γ) were calculated by incorporating these constrained γ-ray strength functions into the TALYS code. The calculated 169 Tm(γ,n) rates were adopted in a full p-process reaction network for the shock-heated O/Ne-rich layers of a 20 M core-collapse supernova model to perform a sensitivity analysis. The updated rates have a negligible effect on the final p-nucleus abundances.

Sources

Related papers