Measurements of C!P violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Measurements of C!P violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Measurements of CP violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II presents preliminary results for CP asymmetry measurements in various charm hadron decays using data from Belle and Belle II <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Kai: These measurements cover modes such as D+ (s) → ηh+, D → ππ, D0 → K0S K0S, and D0 → π+π-π0, along with singly Cabibbo-suppressed baryon decays <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Mira: Search for CP violation in charm hadrons The decay-rate asymmetry for a charm hadron Xc and final state f is defined as ACP(Xc → f) = Γ(Xc → f) − Γ(Xc → ¯f) / Γ(Xc → f) + Γ(Xc → ¯f)> <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Kai: Neutral-meson asymmetries are time integrated and can contain both direct and indirect contributions> <ref:2611.11957#pg4>.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at the paper "Measurements of C!P violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II." It covers some really specific modes, like D plus s to eta plus h plus, and D zero to pi pi minus pi zero. It’s about checking if CP symmetry holds in these decays using data from both Belle and Belle II <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Mira: Exactly. The big picture here is using these charm hadron decays to probe CP violation in the up-type quark sector <ref:2611.11957#pg2>. It's important because small weak phase differences suppress Standard Model asymmetries, but strong interactions make predictions really hard <ref:2611.11957#pg2>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, the precision you get here depends heavily on how well you can tag those charm hadrons. We see they use the inclusive charm-flavor tagging, which gives them a tagging efficiency of forty-seven point nine one percent <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. That's pretty good for what we can expect to do with this kind of data.
Kai: The paper goes into how they calculate the decay-rate asymmetry, which they call ACP, and then explains how to get the raw yield asymmetry, Araw, which is equal to ACP plus Aprod plus Adet <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. This raw formula lets them correct for production and detection effects in neutral-meson asymmetries.
Mira: Right, because those additional terms describe the production and detection effects <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. That correction is crucial when you're trying to isolate the true CP violation signal from experimental quirks.
Lev: And for the neutral modes, they time-integrate those asymmetries <ref:2611.11957#pg4>, which can contain both direct and indirect contributions <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. That means we’re looking at a mix of things happening in the decay process itself and things happening before or after the decay state is formed.
Kai: They focus on specific modes like D plus s to eta plus h plus, D zero to pi pi minus pi zero, and singly Cabibbo-suppressed baryon decays <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. They also mention that the results for the charged-mode measurement and the neutral-mode analysis are consistent with CP symmetry <ref:2611.11957#pg5>.
Mira: That consistency is what they're aiming for, but they also point out that there are interfering amplitudes with different weak and strong phases in some modes, like D plus to eta pi plus and D plus s to eta K plus <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. That interference is where the complexity lies.
Lev: For the neutral decay D zero to pi zero pi zero, they use a D star plus tag and a fit involving M(D zero) and Delta M which is defined as M(D star plus) minus M(D zero) <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. That method helps them pull out the CP-odd contribution from that specific decay channel.
Title and authors: Kai: They also mention an isospin test, which combines three direct asymmetries to isolate a CP-odd contribution from the Delta I equals one half amplitude in D plus pi plus pi zero <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. This complements the Delta I equals three half test they did in D plus to pi plus pi zero <ref:2611.11957#pg5>.
Mira: So what this means for us is that they’re doing a lot of work to build up these tests, using things like the CF control modes used for correction <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. It shows how much experimental finesse you need to get a clean signal here.
Lev: And for real hardware, running this analysis would mean having to deal with that tagging efficiency of forty-seven point nine one percent <ref:2611.11957#pg4> and then fitting those complex distributions in the neutral modes <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. The overhead for that kind of detailed reconstruction is significant on a real detector setup.
Kai: Before we wrap up, let's look at how they suggest improving their analysis using AI. They mention that improved AI can perform precision measurements by integrating Belle II Run one data with Belle data for specific analyses like D zero to K zero S K zero S, achieving that high effective tagging efficiency of forty-seven point nine one percent using the inclusive charm-flavor tagging <ref:2611.11957#pg4>.
Mira: That integration sounds powerful because it lets the AI handle those complex data combinations better than what they might do manually <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. It’s about leveraging that combined dataset to clean up the signal.
Lev: And another improvement is using improved AI to calculate that raw yield asymmetry Araw using the formula Araw equal to ACP plus Aprod plus Adet, which lets them correct for production and detection effects in neutral-meson asymmetries <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. That correction is necessary because those production effects are non-trivial.
Kai: That’s about getting the raw number right before you even start looking for CP violation <ref:2611.11957#pg4>. And they also talk about detailed kinematic matching to correct detection asymmetries by using kinematically matched control modes, taking into account any known physical CP asymmetry of the control decay <ref:2611.11957#pg4>.
Mira: Kinematic matching is smart because it uses known physics to fix the measurement artifacts <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. It’s about using one well-understood process to correct for systematic errors in another.
Title and authors: Lev: On the theoretical side, they suggest improved AI can perform isospin tests by calculating a normalized combination R using the formula R equals g plus minus a plus minus g zero zero a zero zero minus two over three g plus zero a plus zero over g plus minus plus g zero zero <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. This specific combination isolates the CP-odd contribution from the Delta I equals one half amplitude in D plus pi plus pi zero <ref:2611.11957#pg5>.
Kai: That formula sounds very specific, focusing on that delta I equals one half amplitude <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. It’s a direct way to test the isospin structure of the decay process using just three direct asymmetries.
Mira: And they also point out that improved AI can test U-spin symmetry by performing sums of CP asymmetries for three-body charmed baryon decays, like ACP plus Lambda plus c to p K plus K minus and Xi plus c to Sigma plus pi plus <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Lev: They show those results are consistent with zero within seven percent precision <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. That level of consistency is what makes the test meaningful for U-spin symmetry, because it’s a very specific relationship between different quark symmetries.
Kai: So to wrap up on this paper, the main implication is that they are pushing the limits of precision measurements in charm decays using Belle and Belle II data <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. They've shown preliminary results for several important modes, and while everything so far is consistent with CP symmetry <ref:2611.11957#pg5>, they are building the tools—both experimental and computational—to look for any tiny deviations.
Mira: Exactly. The work on "Measurements of C!P violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II" is a step in mapping out where CP violation might hide in the Standard Model or perhaps point toward new physics <ref:2611.11957#pg2>. It’s all about using the constraints from charm to see if the universe behaves exactly as we expect it should <ref:2611.11957#pg2>.
Lev: For us building hardware, this paper shows that even with these complex final states and interference effects, you can extract meaningful information if you use sophisticated fitting techniques like the one for D star plus tag and Delta M <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. It’s a roadmap for how to handle those difficult neutral modes in future experiments.
Kai: We're leaving this paper here, but keep an eye on these results. The next step is seeing if we can push the precision even further with more data or better AI applications <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Mira: Right. And we’ll be listening for what comes next in this area of charm physics <ref:2611.11957#pg2>.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we're looking at what these preliminary results from Belle and Belle II show about CP violation in charm hadrons.
Mira: Basically, they used data from both experiments to measure asymmetries in several decays, like D plus s to eta plus h plus and neutral modes such as D zero to K zero S K zero S.
Kai: The main thing they’re doing is looking for a way to see if CP symmetry holds in the charm sector using these specific decay modes.
Mira: They’ve defined a decay-rate asymmetry, ACP, and then they talk about how that relates to the raw yield asymmetry, Araw, which is equal to ACP plus production effects plus detection effects.
Kai: That Araw formula is key because it lets them try and correct for stuff happening when you produce the particles or when you detect them in the detector.
Mira: They also use time integration for the neutral modes, which means they're looking at both direct and indirect contributions to that CP violation signal.
Kai: It’s interesting because they’ve found that their results for both the charged and neutral measurements are consistent with CP symmetry so far.
Mira: But they’re not stopping there; in some of the decays, like D plus to eta pi plus, they see interference from different weak and strong phases, which adds a layer of complexity.
Kai: And for those neutral modes, they use specific techniques involving a D star plus tag and some kind of fit to M zero and Delta M to pull out the CP-odd contribution.
Mira: They also have an isospin test that combines three direct asymmetries to isolate the CP-odd part coming from that delta I equals one half amplitude in D plus pi plus pi zero decays.
Kai: It shows they're building up these tests, using things like those control modes to correct for detection errors, and testing U-spin symmetry in three-body charmed baryon decays.
Mira: The results for the U-spin test are consistent with zero within about seven percent precision, which is a pretty tight constraint on that symmetry.
Kai: So they’re confirming CP symmetry holds in these modes, but they’re also setting up the tools to look for tiny deviations where new physics might show up.
Mira: That means the next step is really about pushing the precision even further with more data or maybe smarter ways to analyze that data using AI.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, what's the main point about how they suggest improving their analysis?
Mira: They suggest using AI to integrate data from both Belle Run one and Belle II for specific neutral modes like D zero to K zero S K zero S, aiming for that high effective tagging efficiency of forty-seven point nine one percent.
Lev: That integration sounds like it would be a big computational win for getting cleaner signals, especially since the inclusive charm-flavor tagging gives you that efficiency level.
Kai: Right, so the AI is meant to handle those complex data combinations better than what they might do manually with the Belle and Belle II datasets.
Mira: And they also propose using AI to calculate that raw yield asymmetry we talked about earlier, Araw equals ACP plus production effects plus detection effects, which helps correct for those production and detection quirks in neutral-meson asymmetries.
Lev: Correcting for those production effects is crucial because it's where a lot of the systematic error usually lands when you move from theory to real hardware.
Kai: They also suggest using detailed kinematic matching with control modes to fix detection errors by accounting for any known physical CP asymmetry in those control decays.
Mira: That's smart because it uses known physics from simpler, well-understood processes to correct the artifacts in the more complex charm decay measurements.
Lev: It means you need a solid set of those control modes ready to go so you can use them to fix errors on the main measurement record.
Kai: On the theoretical side, they suggest using AI for isospin tests by calculating a specific combination R which isolates that CP-odd contribution from the delta I equals one half amplitude in D plus pi plus pi zero decays.
Mira: That formula R is designed to be very specific, focusing only on that delta I equals one half amplitude, which helps isolate what's coming from the structure of those decay amplitudes.
Lev: If you want to run that calculation on real hardware, you need a way for the AI to handle those multi-part sums over the different asymmetries without introducing new errors.
Kai: They also suggest testing U-spin symmetry by summing CP asymmetries in three-body charmed baryon decays, like that D plus Lambda plus c to p K plus K minus and Xi plus c to Sigma plus pi plus.
Mira: They found those results consistent with zero within about seven percent precision, which gives us a pretty tight constraint on how U-spin symmetry should behave in these systems.
Lev: A seven percent precision for that kind of symmetry test is respectable, but it's still a lot of background noise you need to filter out on a real experiment.
Kai: So they’re confirming CP symmetry holds in these modes, but they’re also setting up the tools—both experimental and computational—to look for tiny deviations where new physics might show up.
Mira: That means the next step is really about pushing the precision even further with more data or maybe smarter ways to analyze that data using AI.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, they've looked at several charm hadron decays using data from both Belle and Belle II to measure CP violation in these particles <ref:2611.11957#pg3>.
Mira: Basically, the key finding is that while everything so far looks consistent with CP symmetry, they've built a lot of machinery—like the raw yield asymmetry Araw and various isospin tests—to find any tiny deviations that could signal new physics.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, it’s impressive how they’re using those control modes to fix detection errors in the neutral modes, which is where the real headache for building a detector comes from.
Kai: So, even though they see consistency now, the paper is really about setting up the tools needed to find those tiny deviations if we get more data.
Mira: Exactly; it’s not a definitive statement that CP violation isn't there, but rather a detailed roadmap for how to search for it with high precision.
Lev: And if you want to run that kind of analysis on real hardware, you need to be ready for those complex fits and the computational load involved in handling all those production and detection corrections.
Kai: It shows how much experimental finesse is required just to get a clean measurement record from these kinds of decays.
Mira: The implication is that charm physics could become a really sensitive probe for new interactions beyond the Standard Model if we can push this precision further with even more data.
Lev: We'll need to keep developing those error correction techniques because those production and detection terms are messy, and they have to be handled perfectly for any meaningful signal.
Kai: It’s a testament to how detailed these measurements are becoming, even as we deal with the complexities of integrating experiments like Belle II.
Mira: We’re definitely looking forward to seeing what comes next in these charm measurements and where this research leads us in searching for new physics at the fundamental level.
Jaeyoung Kim
Yonsei University
hep-ex, hep-ph, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-11-09
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure, conference proceedings for ICHEP 2026, on behalf of the Belle II Collaboration
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: Measurements of CP violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II presents preliminary results for CP asymmetry measurements in various charm hadron decays using data from Belle and Belle II…
Key concepts
- ACP(Xc -> f)
- This is the decay-rate asymmetry for a charm hadron Xc decaying into a final state f. It is calculated by comparing the decay rate of Xc to a specific final state with the rate of its antiparticle (¯Xc) decaying into the conjugate final state, normalized by their respective total rates.
- Araw
- The raw yield asymmetry is an initial measurement that includes direct CP violation alongside effects from production and detection. It is modeled as Araw = ACP + Aprod + Adet, where Aprod and Adet account for experimental biases related to how the charm hadrons are produced and detected in the experiment.
- Isospin Test (R)
- This test combines three direct asymmetries to isolate a CP-odd contribution specifically from the Delta I = 1/2 amplitude in D+ -> π⁺π⁰ final states. It uses a specific normalized combination formula to separate the desired CP-odd signal from other interfering amplitudes.
- Inclusive Charm-Flavor Tagger (CFT)
- The CFT is a method used to tag events containing charm hadrons by analyzing correlations among charged particles in the rest of the event. This technique provides an effective tagging efficiency, which is crucial for measuring asymmetries in these decays.
Terminology
Summary
Measurements of CP violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II presents preliminary results for CP asymmetry measurements in various charm hadron decays using data from Belle and Belle II <ref:2611. p. 0 Measurements of 𝑪𝑷 violation with charm hadrons at
Belle and Belle II
Jaeyoung Kim𝑎,∗ on behalf of the Belle II Collaboration
𝑎Department of Physics, Yonsei University,
03722, Seoul, Republic of Korea
E-mail: jaeyoung_kim@yonsei. kr
Recent searches for 𝐶𝑃 violation in charm-hadron decays at Belle and Belle II are presented. kr
Recent searches for 𝐶𝑃 violation in charm-hadron decays at Belle and Belle II are presented. The
measurements cover 𝐷
+
(𝑠) → 𝜂ℎ+
, 𝐷 → 𝜋𝜋, 𝐷
0 → 𝐾
0
𝑆
𝐾
0
𝑆
, and 𝐷
0 → 𝜋
+𝜋
−𝜋
0
, together with
the singly Cabibbo-suppressed baryon decays Ξ
+
𝑐 → Σ
+ℎ
+ℎ
−
and Λ
+
𝑐 → 𝑝ℎ+ℎ
−
, where ℎ =
𝜋, 𝐾.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Search for CP violation in charm hadrons
The decay-rate asymmetry for a charm hadron Xc and final state f is defined as ACP(Xc → f) = Γ(Xc → f) − Γ(Xc → ¯f) / Γ(Xc → f) + Γ(Xc → ¯f)> <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. Neutral-meson asymmetries are time integrated and can contain both direct and indirect contributions> <ref:2611. p. 1 Search for 𝐶𝑃 violation in charm hadrons
The decay-rate asymmetry for a charm hadron 𝑋𝑐 and final state 𝑓 is
𝐴𝐶𝑃(𝑋𝑐 → 𝑓 ) =
Γ(𝑋𝑐 → 𝑓 ) − Γ(𝑋¯
𝑐 → ¯𝑓 )
Γ(𝑋𝑐 → 𝑓 ) + Γ(𝑋¯
𝑐 → ¯𝑓 )
. (2)
Neutral-meson asymmetries are time integrated and can contain direct and indirect contributions. (2)
Neutral-meson asymmetries are time integrated and can contain direct and indirect contributions. Fits determine the raw yield asymmetry, which to first order is
𝐴raw ≃ 𝐴𝐶𝑃 + 𝐴prod + 𝐴det, (3)
where the additional terms describe production and detection effects. Charged hadrons are self-tagging; neutral 𝐷 flavor is conventionally identified by the slow
pion in 𝐷
∗+ → 𝐷
0𝜋
+
. The inclusive charm-flavor tagger (CFT) [5] instead uses charged-particle
correlations in the rest of the event, achieving an effective tagging efficiency of (47. https://pos. it/
arXiv:2611.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The paper reports preliminary measurements for several decay modes, including D+ (s) → ηh+, D → ππ, and D0 → K0S K0S <ref:2611.11957#pg3>. For the neutral modes, all pion 0 candidates are reconstructed via η0 → γγ > <ref:2611. p. 2 Measurements of 𝐶𝑃 violation with charm hadrons at Belle and Belle II Jaeyoung Kim
Both 𝜂 → 𝛾𝛾 and 𝜂 → 𝜋
+𝜋
−𝜋
0
are reconstructed and the results are combined. All 𝜋
0
candidates mentioned hereafter are reconstructed via 𝜋
0 → 𝛾𝛾. 1 𝐷
+
(𝑠) → 𝜂(𝜋
+
, 𝐾+
)
Belle II presents preliminary measurements of 𝐷
+
(𝑠) → 𝜂ℎ+
, with ℎ = 𝜋, 𝐾. The 𝐷
+ → 𝜂𝜋+
and 𝐷
+
𝑠 → 𝜂𝐾+ modes are singly Cabibbo suppressed (SCS) and sensitive to interfering amplitudes
with different weak and strong phases.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the gains come from
The analysis for D0 → π0π0 uses a D∗+ tag, BDT selection, and a fit to M(D0) and ΔM ≡ M(D∗+) − M(D0)> <ref:2611.11957#pg5>. The results for both the charged-mode measurement and the neutral-mode analysis are consistent with CP symmetry> <ref:2611. p. 3 (5)
Both are consistent with 𝐶𝑃 symmetry. The charged-mode measurement reduces the statistical
uncertainty by approximately 30% relative to the Belle measurement. (6)
This combination isolates a 𝐶𝑃-odd contribution from the Δ𝐼 = 1/2 amplitude, after correcting
neutral-mode asymmetries for indirect 𝐶𝑃 violation. A nonzero 𝑅 would establish 𝐶𝑃 violation
in this isospin sector, complementing the Δ𝐼 = 3/2 test in 𝐷
+ → 𝜋
+𝜋
0
[6].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform precision measurements of CP violation in charm hadron decays by integrating Belle II Run 1 data with Belle data for specific analyses like D0 to Ks0S, achieving a high effective tagging efficiency of 47.91% using inclusive charm-flavor tagging (CFT).
-
Improved AI can calculate the raw yield asymmetry Araw using the formula Araw equal to ACP plus Aprod plus Adet, allowing for the correction of production and detection effects in neutral-meson asymmetries.
-
Improved AI can perform isospin tests by calculating a normalized combination R using the formula R equals g+−a+− + g00a00 - 2/3 g+0a+0 / (g+− + g00 - 2/3 g+0), which isolates a CP-odd contribution from the Delta I equals 1/2 amplitude in D plus pi plus pi zero final states.
-
Improved AI can perform detailed kinematic matching to correct detection asymmetries by using kinematically matched control modes, taking into account any known physical CP asymmetry of the control decay.
-
Improved AI can test U-spin symmetry by performing sums of CP asymmetries for three-body charmed baryon decays, such as ACP(Lambda+c to pK+K-) plus ACP(Xi+c to Sigma+pi++), which are shown to be consistent with zero within 7% precision.
Abstract
Recent searches for C!P violation in charm-hadron decays at Belle and Belle II are presented. The measurements cover D+(s) toηh+, D toππ, D 0 to K S 0K S 0, and D 0 toπ+π-π 0, together with the singly Cabibbo-suppressed baryon decays Ξ c+ toΣ+h+h- and Λ c+ to ph+h-, where h=π,K. The Belle II analyses use the Run 1 data sample of 428, fb-1, supplemented by 980, fb-1 of Belle data for the K S 0K S 0 measurements. We report preliminary results for the ηh+ modes, complementary tests of the isospin structure of D toππ, and an application of inclusive charm-flavor tagging. The first individual decay-rate asymmetries in these three-body charmed-baryon modes also provide tests of U-spin symmetry. All reported asymmetries are consistent with C!P symmetry within the present precision.
Sources
- Observation of $C\!P$ violation in charm decays
- Measurement of the time-integrated $C\!P$ asymmetry in $D^0\to K^- K^+$ decays
- Belle II Technical Design Report
- Novel method for the identification of the production flavor of neutral charmed mesons
- Testing for new physics in singly Cabibbo suppressed D decays
- Measurement of the CP asymmetry in $D^+ \to \pi^+ \pi^0$ decays at Belle II
- Measurement of the time-integrated $CP$ asymmetry in $D^0\to\pi^0\pi^0$ decays at Belle II
- Measurement of the time-integrated CP asymmetry in $D^{0}\rightarrow K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{S}$ decays using Belle and Belle II data
- Measurement of the time-integrated $CP$ asymmetry in $D^0 \to K^0_{\rm S} K^0_{\rm S}$ decays using opposite-side flavor tagging at Belle and Belle II
- Measurement of the $CP$ asymmetry in $D^0\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0$ decays at Belle II
- Search for $CP$ violation in $\Xi_c^+\to\Sigma^+h^+h^-$ and $\Lambda_c^+\to ph^+h^-$ at Belle II
- U-Spin Sum Rules for CP Asymmetries of Three-Body Charmed Baryon Decays
Related papers
- DrSai: an agentic AI system toward autonomous physics analysis workflows at BESIII
- CANTON- mu Proposal: A Next-Generation Muon g-2 Measurement at Sub-0.1 ppm Precision
- Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer
- ANUBIS detector and its sensitivity to neutral long-lived particles
- How to scale your HEP ML models: A recipe for robust architecture comparisons at scale
- Search for the 16 O(ppp) to 13 C pi+ pi+ e+ Decay Mode in Super-Kamiokande Using Machine Learning Techniques