Role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment-mass distribution in 180 Hg fission

arXiv:2611.10452 · nucl-th · Submitted 2026-11-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment-mass distribution in 180 Hg fission".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The fission of 180Hg is investigated by studying the stochastic evolution on the potential energy surface calculated within the multidimensionally constrained relativistic Hartree–Bogoliubov (MDC-RHB) model The role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment-mass distribution in 180Hg fission is clarified by connecting microscopic deformation landscape, master-equation shape evolution, and nascent fragment properties Theoretical Framework The MDC-RHB model provides the zero-temperature potential-energy surface in the (β20, β30) plane and self-consistent density distributions, from which scission configurations are identified using a geometrical neck criterion The evolution toward scission is described by a master equation on the same deformation mesh, with transition rates determined by deformation-dependent microscopic level densities Covariant density functional theory (CDFT) describes the nuclear many-body system in terms of self-consistent scalar and vector fields constrained by Lorentz symmetry, thereby incorporating relativistic effects and the spin–orbit interaction within a unified microscopic framework The MDC-RHB model with the Bogoliubov transformation is one of two variants developed to study multidimensionally constrained covariant density functional theory PES and Scission Identification The potential-energy surface in the (β20, β30) plane exhibits a pronounced reflection-asymmetric valley The effective barrier-top region is found to lie close to the scission line, making the detailed energetic structure of the scission boundary particularly important for the fragment distribution Scission configurations are identified using a geometrical neck criterion where a configuration is identified as a scission configuration when Rneck ≤ Rcrit = 1.0 fm The scission-line itself exhibits an energetic preference for reflection-asymmetric configurations, with the minimum of the scission-line energy reflecting the combined microscopic structure and self-consistent deformation of the nascent fragments Dynamical Evolution and Scission Line Influence The shape evolution toward scission is described on the discretized collective mesh by a Markovian master equation, where transition rates are written in the Fermi golden-rule form The resulting fragment-mass distributions are compared with those obtained assuming equilibrium on the same scission line to assess the influence of the preceding shape evolution The stochastic master-equation result and equilibrium-on-scissionline calculations predict dominant peaks close to the experimentally observed AL/AH ≃ 80/100 split The similarity of the two calculations, particularly at higher excitation energy, indicates that much of the mass-asymmetry information is already encoded in the energetic structure of the scission line Fragment Mass Distributions The fragment-mass distribution is obtained by assigning the probability of each scission configuration to the corresponding light and heavy prefragment masses The Gaussian folding broadens the calculated peaks and improves their overall agreement with the experimental widths while retaining the asymmetric peak positions and their excitation-energy dependence The resulting mass distributions are compared with the available fusion-fission data in Fig.

Kai: 7 The present result indicates that, for 180Hg, the fragment mass distribution is governed not only by the topology of the PES but also by the detailed energetic structure of the scission boundary Future Directions Further improvements should include the explicit role of collective inertias, fluctuations beyond the (β20, β30) collective space, and post-scission neutron emission These ingredients will be important for a more quantitative description of the mass-width systematics and for testing the same mechanism in neighboring neutrondeficient Hg, Pb, and Pt nuclei The preferred asymmetric mass division persists in both the dynamical and equilibrium prescriptions, identifying the scission-line structure as an important constraint on the fragment masses The additional constraint analysis in the β40 direction shows that variations of this higher-order shape degree of freedom can produce an additional spread of the prefragment masses The resulting mass obtained from the lowest energy sampled solution represents the energetically favored central value, whereas configurations leading to masses farther from this value are increasingly suppressed as their potential energy rises The Gaussian form reflects the dominant weight of configurations near the energy minimum and the reduced contribution of configurations farther from it The adopted width is a phenomenological estimate guided by the mass variation found in the constrained β40 scan, rather than a fitted collective parameter The resulting mass-yield calculation combines the probability distribution along the scission line with the prefragment masses extracted from the self-consistent densities References

8: E.

Mira: M.

Kai: Kozulin, G.

Paper summary: Mira: So, summarizing the whole thing about this paper, the title itself points directly at what they are investigating: how important that scission-line structure is when you're looking at fragment masses for one hundred eighty Hg fission <ref:2611.10452#pg1>. They used a very detailed covariant density functional theory model to track how the nucleus evolves and where it splits.

Kai: It basically boils down to this: they found that the energetic properties of the scission line dictate which mass divisions are most likely to happen in one hundred eighty Hg fission, regardless of whether you look at the dynamic evolution or a static equilibrium on that line <ref:2611.10452#pg1>.

Lev: So for someone building error correction schemes, what's the practical implication? It means when we try to model these heavy systems, we need to pay close attention not just to the path taken but also to those specific configurations that define the boundary where it splits in first place.

Kai: That’s right. The paper shows that this structure is a key constraint on fragment masses, and they found that variations in the higher order beta-four zero degree of freedom can actually create an additional spread in those prefragment masses.

Mira: It’s about recognizing that the physics isn't just about the overall shape; it’s about the specific configuration at the point of scission, and this is what governs how those final mass distributions look when you increase the excitation energy.

Lev: So, we need to build our models to account for that energetic structure at scission, otherwise we miss some of that mass asymmetry information encoded there.

Kai: That’s the core message of "Role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment-mass distribution in one hundred eighty Hg fission <ref:2611.10452#pg1,Role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment>." It tells us that for heavy systems like Mercury, you need to study both how they evolve and what's happening right at the boundary where they separate.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we've been looking at this paper about one hundred eighty Mercury fission, and now we get to the conclusion section where they really nail down what this all means.

Mira: They're basically saying that for understanding why the fragments split into certain masses in one hundred eighty Mercury, you can't just look at the overall shape of the potential energy surface anymore.

Kai: No, it’s not about the general shape; it’s specifically about that scission line itself—the boundary where things actually break apart.

Mira: Exactly. They show that this energetic structure on the scission line dictates how likely a certain mass split is to happen, whether you're looking at a dynamic process or just static equilibrium.

Kai: So what does this title actually imply for us in the world of nuclear physics? It means we need to incorporate those fine details of the boundary conditions into our models if we want accurate predictions for heavy nuclei.

Mira: Right. They also pointed out that this asymmetry isn't just one thing; looking at a slightly different shape, like that higher order beta four degree of freedom, can actually add another bit of spread to those fragment masses.

Kai: That’s interesting because it suggests the mass distribution isn't as simple as a single peak dictated by the main potential energy valley.

Mira: The Gaussian folding they use in their final results shows that configurations close to that minimum energy point dominate, but those slightly higher energy configurations, near the scission line, still matter for getting the width right.

Kai: So we're looking at a picture where the shape evolution matters because it leads us to these specific boundary conditions that control the final mass yield.

Mira: And their conclusion is that this scission-line structure is a major constraint on those fragment masses, especially for one hundred eighty Mercury.

Kai: It sets up the next step, which is looking at how this mechanism works when we move to neighboring isotopes like Lead or Platinum, which they plan to test next.

Jin-Tian Liu, A. Rahmatinejad, Jie Zhao, T. M. Shneidman, N. V. Antonenko, Shan-Gui Zhou

Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences · School of Physical Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences · Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna · Engineering Research Center of Advanced Functional Materials and Intelligent Sensing, Education Department of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region · Guangxi Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology, Guangxi Normal University · School of Nuclear Science and Technology, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences

nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-11-07

Updated: 2026-11-07

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: The fission of 180Hg is investigated by studying the stochastic evolution on the potential energy surface calculated within the multidimensionally constrained relativistic Hartree–Bogoliubov…

Key concepts

MDC-RHB Model
This is a theoretical framework used to calculate the potential energy surface and density distributions of 180Hg. It incorporates relativistic effects and self-consistent density fields, allowing researchers to map out how the nucleus deforms as it fissions.
Scission Line Structure
This refers to the specific energetic path where a nucleus transitions from a single compound system into two separated fragments. The paper finds that this line has an energetic preference for reflection-asymmetric shapes, meaning the energy landscape favors certain asymmetric splits.
Master Equation Shape Evolution
This describes how the nuclear shape changes dynamically as it moves toward scission. It uses transition rates based on microscopic level densities to model the stochastic process of deformation, showing how initial shape influences final fragment masses.

Terminology

Summary

The fission of 180Hg is investigated by studying the stochastic evolution on the potential energy surface calculated within the multidimensionally constrained relativistic Hartree–Bogoliubov (MDC-RHB) model The role of the scission-line structure in the formation of the fragment-mass distribution in 180Hg fission is clarified by connecting microscopic deformation landscape, master-equation shape evolution, and nascent fragment properties

Theoretical Framework

The MDC-RHB model provides the zero-temperature potential-energy surface in the (β20, β30) plane and self-consistent density distributions, from which scission configurations are identified using a geometrical neck criterion The evolution toward scission is described by a master equation on the same deformation mesh, with transition rates determined by deformation-dependent microscopic level densities Covariant density functional theory (CDFT) describes the nuclear many-body system in terms of self-consistent scalar and vector fields constrained by Lorentz symmetry, thereby incorporating relativistic effects and the spin–orbit interaction within a unified microscopic framework The MDC-RHB model with the Bogoliubov transformation is one of two variants developed to study multidimensionally constrained covariant density functional theory

PES and Scission Identification

The potential-energy surface in the (β20, β30) plane exhibits a pronounced reflection-asymmetric valley The effective barrier-top region is found to lie close to the scission line, making the detailed energetic structure of the scission boundary particularly important for the fragment distribution Scission configurations are identified using a geometrical neck criterion where a configuration is identified as a scission configuration when Rneck ≤ Rcrit = 1.0 fm The scission-line itself exhibits an energetic preference for reflection-asymmetric configurations, with the minimum of the scission-line energy reflecting the combined microscopic structure and self-consistent deformation of the nascent fragments

Dynamical Evolution and Scission Line Influence

The shape evolution toward scission is described on the discretized collective mesh by a Markovian master equation, where transition rates are written in the Fermi golden-rule form The resulting fragment-mass distributions are compared with those obtained assuming equilibrium on the same scission line to assess the influence of the preceding shape evolution The stochastic master-equation result and equilibrium-on-scissionline calculations predict dominant peaks close to the experimentally observed AL/AH ≃ 80/100 split The similarity of the two calculations, particularly at higher excitation energy, indicates that much of the mass-asymmetry information is already encoded in the energetic structure of the scission line

Fragment Mass Distributions

The fragment-mass distribution is obtained by assigning the probability of each scission configuration to the corresponding light and heavy prefragment masses The Gaussian folding broadens the calculated peaks and improves their overall agreement with the experimental widths while retaining the asymmetric peak positions and their excitation-energy dependence The resulting mass distributions are compared with the available fusion-fission data in Fig. 7 The present result indicates that, for 180Hg, the fragment mass distribution is governed not only by the topology of the PES but also by the detailed energetic structure of the scission boundary

Future Directions

Further improvements should include the explicit role of collective inertias, fluctuations beyond the (β20, β30) collective space, and post-scission neutron emission These ingredients will be important for a more quantitative description of the mass-width systematics and for testing the same mechanism in neighboring neutrondeficient Hg, Pb, and Pt nuclei The preferred asymmetric mass division persists in both the dynamical and equilibrium prescriptions, identifying the scission-line structure as an important constraint on the fragment masses The additional constraint analysis in the β40 direction shows that variations of this higher-order shape degree of freedom can produce an additional spread of the prefragment masses The resulting mass obtained from the lowest energy sampled solution represents the energetically favored central value, whereas configurations leading to masses farther from this value are increasingly suppressed as their potential energy rises The Gaussian form reflects the dominant weight of configurations near the energy minimum and the reduced contribution of configurations farther from it The adopted width is a phenomenological estimate guided by the mass variation found in the constrained β40 scan, rather than a fitted collective parameter The resulting mass-yield calculation combines the probability distribution along the scission line with the prefragment masses extracted from the self-consistent densities

References

[8] E. M. Kozulin, G. N. Knyazheva, I. M. Itkis, M. G. Itkis, Y. S. Mukhamejanov, A A Bogachev, K V Novikov, D Kumar, T Banerjee, I N Diatlov, M Cheralu V V Kirakosyan Y S Mukhamejanov A N Pan I V Pchelintsev R S Tikhomirov I V Vorobiev M Maiti R Prajapat R Kumar G Sarkar W H Trzaska A N Andreyev I M Harca E Vardaci]

[10] T. Ichikawa, A Iwamoto, P M¨oller, and A J Sierk Contrasting fission potential-energy structure of actinides and mercury isotopes Phys. p. 0 Rev. C 86 024610]

[12] M Warda A Staszczak and W Nazarewicz Fission modes of mercury isotopes Phys. Rev. C 86 024601]

[13] J D McDonnell W Nazarewicz J A Sheikh A Staszczak and M Warda Excitation-energy dependence of fission in the mercury region Phys. Rev. C 90 021302(R)]

[14] P M¨oller and J Randrup Calculated fission-fragment yields in the region 74 ≤ Z ≤ 94 and 90 ≤ N ≤ 150 Phys. Rev. C 91 044316]

[16] Z Li S Chen Y Chen and Z Li Microscopic study on asymmetric fission dynamics of 180Hg within covariant density functional theory Phys. Rev. C 106 024307]

[22] Y Su Y-J Chen Z-Y Li L-L Liu G-X Dong and X-B Wang Asymmetric fission of 180Hg and the role of hexadecapole moment Nuclear Science and Techniques 36 237]

[4] K Nishio A Andreyev R Chapman X Derkx C Dullmann L Ghys F Heßberger K Hirose H Ikezoe J Khuyagbaatar B Kindler B Lommel H Makii I Nishinaka T Ohtsuki S Pain R Sagaidak I Tsekhanovich M Venhart Y Wakabayashi and S Yan Excitation energy dependence of fragment-mass distributions from fission of 180,190Hg formed in fusion reactions of 36Ar+144,154Sm Phys. Lett. B 748 89]

[6] A A Bogachev E M Kozulin G N Knyazheva I M Itkis M G Itkis K V Novikov D Kumar T Banerjee I N Diatlov M Cheralu V V Kirakosyan Y S Mukhamejanov A N Pan I V Pchelintsev R S Tikhomirov I V Vorobiev M Maiti R Prajapat R Kumar G Sarkar W H Trzaska A N Andreyev I M Harca E Vardaci Fission of 180,190Hg and 184,192,202Pb formed in the reactions with 36Ar and 40,48Ca ions Phys. Rev. C 104 024623]

[7] E Kozulin E Vardaci W Trzaska A Bogachev I Itkis A Karpov G Knyazheva and K Novikov Evidence of quasifission in the 180Hg composite system formed in the 68Zn +112Sn reaction Phys. Lett. B 819 136442]

[8] E M Kozulin G N Knyazheva I M Itkis M G Itkis Y S Mukhamejanov A A Bogachev K V Novikov V V Kirakosyan D Kumar T Banerjee M Cheralu M Maiti R Prajapat R Kumar G Sarkar W H Trzaska A N Andreyev I M Harca A Mitu and E Vardaci Fission of 180,182,183Hg∗ and 178Pt∗ nuclei at intermediate excitation energies Phys. Rev. C 105 014607]

[9] E Vardaci A Di Nitto T Banerjee A Pulcini P Setaro G Alifano G La Rana N Carjan A Cicchella S Spinosa E Kozulin W Trzaska I Itkis G Knyazheva D Kumar K Novikov I Vorobiev S Khlebnikov M Cheralu N Kozulina I Pchelintsev C Borcea S Calinescu D Filipescu I Harca and C Petrone The role of fission in the search of the super heavy land: Fission modes in heavy and superheavy nuclei Case study of 180Hg EPJ Web Conf. 304 01003]

[11] P M¨oller J Randrup and A J Sierk Calculated fission yields of neutron-deficient mercury isotopes Phys. Rev. C 85 024306]

[12] M Warda A Staszczak and L Pr´ochniak Comparison of self-consistent Skyrme and Gogny calculations for light Hg isotopes Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 19 787]

[13] J D McDonnell W Nazarewicz J A Sheikh A Staszczak and M Warda Excitation-energy dependence of fission in the mercury region Phys. Rev. C 90 021302(R)]

[15] G Scamps and C Simenel Effect of shell structure on the fission of sub-lead nuclei Phys. Rev. C 100 041602(R)]

[17] A V Andreev G G Adamian and N V Antonenko Mass distributions for induced fission of different Hg isotopes Phys. Rev. C 86 044315]

[20] S Panebianco J-L Sida H Goutte J-F Lemaˆıtre N Dubray and S Hilaire Role of deformed shell effects on the mass asymmetry in nuclear fission of mercury isotopes Phys. Rev. C 86 064601]

[21] P W Zhao Z P Li J M Yao and J Meng New parametrization for the nuclear covariant energy density functional with a point-coupling interaction Phys. Rev. C 82 054319]

[23] J Walecka A theory of highly condensed matter Ann. Phys. 83 491]

[24] B D Serot and J D Walecka The relativistic nuclear many-body problem Adv. Nucl. Phys. 16 1]

[25] P G Reinhard The relativistic mean field description of nuclei and nuclear dynamics Rep Prog. Phys. 52 439]

[26] P Ring Relativistic mean field theory in finite nuclei Prog Part. Nucl. Phys. 37 193]

[27] D Vretenar A Afanasjev G Lalazissis and P Ring Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory Static and dynamic aspects of exotic nuclear structure Phys. Rep. 409 101]

[28] J Meng H Toki S Zhou S Zhang W Long L Geng Relativistic continuum Hartree Bogoliubov theory for ground-state properties of exotic nuclei Prog Part. Nucl. Phys. 57 470]

[32] B.-N Lu E-G Zhao and S-G Zhou Potential energy surfaces of actinide nuclei from a multidimensional constrained covariant density functional theory Barrier heights and saddle point shapes Phys. p. 1 Rev. C 85 011301(R)]

[36] J Zhao B-N Lu E-G Zhao and S-G Zhou Tetrahedral shapes of neutron-rich Zr isotopes from a multidimensionally constrained relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov model Phys. Rev. C 95 014320]

[68] A Rahmatinejad A N Bezbakh T M Shneidman G Adamian N V Antonenko P Jachimowicz and M Kowal Level-density parameters in superheavy nuclei Phys. Rev. C 103 034309]

[71] J Randrup and P M¨oller Brownian shape motion on five-dimensional potential-energy surfaces Nuclear fission-fragment mass distributions Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 132503]

[72] J Randrup P M¨oller and A J Sierk Fission-fragment mass distributions from strongly damped shape evolution Phys. Rev. C 84 034613]

[82] P V Kostryukov A Dobrowolski B Nerlo-Pomorska M Warda Z Xiao Y Chen L Liu J Tian and K Pomorski Potential energy surfaces and fission fragment mass yields of even-even superheavy nuclei Chin. Phys. C 45 124108]

[84] R Han M Warda A Zdeb and L Robledo Scission configuration in self-consistent calculations with neck constraints Phys. Rev. C 104 064602]

[85] W Younes D Gogny Microscopic calculation of 240Pu scission with a finite-range effective force Phys. Rev. C 80 054313]

The fragment-mass distribution is obtained by assigning the probability of each scission configuration to the corresponding light and heavy prefragment masses The resulting mass distributions are compared with the available fusion-fission data in Fig. 7 Both calculated distributions include the Gaussian mass folding with σA = 4. p. 9 p. 90 u The excitation-energy dependence is visible in the relative peak heights, with increasing E∗, the yield around the symmetric division A ≃ 90 is enhanced, while the asymmetric peaks are reduced The preferred asymmetric mass division persists in both the dynamical and equilibrium prescriptions, identifying the scission-line structure as an important constraint on the fragment masses The similarity of the two calculations, particularly at higher excitation energy, indicates that much of the mass-asymmetry information is already encoded in the energetic structure of the scission line The fragment mass distribution is strongly influenced by the energetic structure of the scission line itself

Summary and Perspective

In summary, this work provides a covariant, density-based description of the asymmetric fission of 180Hg, connecting the microscopic deformation landscape, master-equation shape evolution, and nascent fragment properties with the observed asymmetric mass distribution The preferred asymmetric mass division persists in both the dynamical and equilibrium prescriptions, identifying the scission-line structure as an important constraint on the fragment masses An additional constraint analysis in the β40 direction shows that variations of this higher-order shape degree of freedom can produce an additional spread of the prefragment masses Further improvements should include the explicit role of collective inertias, fluctuations beyond the (β20, β30) collective space, and post-scission neutron emission The resulting fragment mass distributions are compared with experimental data in Fig. 7 Both calculated distributions include the Gaussian mass folding with σA = 4.0 u The excitation-energy dependence is visible in the relative peak heights, with increasing E∗, the yield around the symmetric division A ≃ 90 is enhanced, while the asymmetric peaks are reduced The trend reflects the increasing statistical access to configurations away from the lowest asymmetric portion of the scission line The preferred asymmetric mass division persists in both the dynamical and equilibrium prescriptions, identifying the scission-line structure as an important constraint on the fragment masses The preceding shape evolution mainly modifies the relative populations of scission configurations The present result indicates that, for 180Hg, the fragment mass distribution is governed not only by the topology of the PES but also by the detailed energetic structure of the scission boundary

--- Page 9 ---

The lower panel of Fig. 2 shows the energy along the scission line as a function of β30 A pronounced minimum occurs at finite octupole deformation β30 = 1. p. 775, while the energy increases toward both the nearly reflectionsymmetric and the more strongly asymmetric configurations The minimum of the scission-line energy reflects the combined microscopic structure and self-consistent deformation of the nascent fragments Their shell and pairing properties, Coulomb interaction, and deformation energy all contribute to the scission energy The importance of fragment stiffness has also been emphasized in improved scission-point calculations of Hg isotopes, where an explicit zero-point-vibration contribution was included and found to enhance the preference for asymmetric splitting around 180Hg

--- Page 10 ---

The rapid reduction of the neck in the pre-actinide mass region provides a natural basis for defining the scission boundary geometrically Near the abrupt decrease of the static path energy shown in Fig. 2(a), the neck becomes strongly reduced We identify scission configurations using a geometrical criterion applied to the self-consistent density distribution A configuration is identified as a scission configuration when Rneck ≤ Rcrit = 1. p. 6

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improvement of shape evolution modeling: The master equation for shape evolution can be made more accurate by incorporating collective inertias and fluctuations beyond the (beta20, beta30) collective space, as suggested in the summary to Further improvements should include the explicit role of collective inertias, fluctuations beyond the (beta20, beta30) collective space.

  2. Improvement of scission-line characterization: The system can be enhanced by explicitly considering how higher multipole shape degrees of freedom not constrained in the two-dimensional calculation affect mass distributions by performing an additional constrained calculation in the hexadecapole direction.

  3. Improvement of fragment mass distribution modeling: A phenomenological width Gaussian kernel, centered at the lowest-energy sampled solution, should be used to approximate the combined effect of omitted transverse collective fluctuations on fragment masses, replacing a single mass with a finite distribution as described in The Gaussian folding broadens the calculated peaks and improves their overall agreement with the experimental widths.

  4. Improvement of dynamics description: The comparison between stochastic master-equation results and equilibrium prescriptions can be deepened by ensuring that both calculations fully account for the geometrical scission criterion, which is defined as "Rneck <= Rcrit, Rcrit = 1.0 fm," to better reflect the close proximity of the effective barrier top and scission line in 180Hg.

Related papers