Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds

arXiv:2611.08484 · astro-ph.EP · Submitted 2026-11-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Observations and theory increasingly indicate that protoplanetary disks are weakly turbulent, implying that magnetized disk winds may dominate their angular momentum transport and long-term evolution The paper builds a parametric hybrid disk evolution model to investigate dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks Model Framework The study utilizes a parametric hybrid disk evolution model that incorporates turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to explore dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks The model employs the one-dimensional disk evolution code DustPy to simulate dust coagulation/fragmentation and transport while modifying the gas evolution to include the effect of magnetized disk winds following the formalism of J.

Vera: Chambers (2019) The simulation runs for a timescale of 1 Myr, varying initial total accretion rate, wind-driven mass loss rate, and turbulence strength Dust Growth and Concentration The simulations reveal that disks with weak turbulence and correspondingly stronger MHD disk wind-driven accretion are significantly more conducive to both the growth and the concentration of dust in the disk midplane This enhancement is attributed to two factors: weak turbulence results in more efficient dust settling onto the disk midplane due to lack of turbulent stirring, as well as increased collision rates because dust becomes more concentrated Furthermore, weak turbulence lowers collision velocities between dust particles, leading to more growth instead of fragmentation Dust-to-Gas Ratios and Streaming Instability The analysis of midplane dust-to-gas ratios shows an enhancement in weakly turbulent wind-driven disks due to efficient vertical settling and the removal of gas from the disk via wind-driven outflows With a combination of high initial accretion rate, weak turbulence, and strong outflows, midplane dust-to-gas mass ratios approach ∼ 0.4 at around 1 AU However, the streaming instability (SI) onset is only possible in a very narrow range of the parameter space explored, specifically with very weak turbulence and a very high mass loss rate Limitations and Future Directions The parametrized MHD wind model cannot create pressure maxima within the disk, which are necessary for planetesimal formation via SI, thus requiring more complete disk evolution models that include the dynamic evolution of the magnetic field and non-ideal MHD effects The study also notes that dust is depleted in the outer regions of disks with weak turbulence due to rapid radial drift, indicating that planetesimal formation in outer regions is unlikely without pressure bumps halting radial drift The findings indicate that planetesimal formation via SI is highly unlikely in smooth disks even when dust growth and concentration are aided by the presence of the disk wind, suggesting that a pressure bump-generating mechanism is necessary for creating dust traps The MHD disk winds may provide an alternative mechanism for creating rings and gaps in disks without needing to invoke the existence of a preexisting planet Model Limitations A main limitation of this first model is its inability to capture the back reaction of the magnetic field on the disk gas and dust, which is crucial for creating wind-driven substructures seen in higher-dimensional simulations The model also does not include the backreaction of dust on the gas, which becomes significant in regions of high dust concentration The level of ionization in the disk controls non-ideal MHD effects, which will be included in future work The paper concludes that planetesimal formation by SI is unlikely in laminar disks even with wind assistance, necessitating more physically motivated models to capture the beginning of the planet formation process The future work will focus on a model that includes both dynamic magnetic field evolution and non-ideal MHD effects to create pressure bumps for planetesimal formation The study's virtue lies in focusing on how dust evolves in unstructured disks undergoing a mixture of viscous and MHD wind-driven accretion Acknowledgments The authors thank Tommy Chi Ho Lau, Mario Flock and Til Birnstiel, and John Chambers for providing details regarding their hybrid disk model AG is supported by McMaster University REP is supported by a Discovery Grant from the National Science and Engineering Council (NSERC) of Canada TND is supported by The Royal Society Career Development Fellowship (grant number CDFR1241766) The computational work in this paper was achieved on the Fir computing cluster (previously Cedar), part of the Digital Research Alliance of Canada computing network, under resource allocation code ycg-982-af Author Contributions Olcay Ates Goksu was responsible for modifying the software (DustPy) to include the influence of the MHD wind, running models, generating Figures, conducting analysis of results, and writing the main body of this manuscript Ralph E.

Jocelyn: Pudritz was responsible for funding and supervising this work, guiding each step of the project, analysis of results and editing this manuscript Timmy N.

Vera: Delage was responsible for suggesting the software used for this work, providing many of the scripts used in the implementation of the hybrid disk model, providing essential guidance on implementation, providing critical feedback and suggestions on results and analysis, writing the Abstract and Introduction sections, and editing the main body of this manuscript Software: DustPy (S.

Paper summary: Vera: They build this parametric hybrid disk evolution model that includes turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to see how dust evolves in these magnetized disks. The main claim they are testing is whether these winds can enhance the growth and concentration of dust in the disk midplane. Subrahmanyan That sounds important because if we can get a better handle on dust evolution, it feeds into understanding planet formation processes across different types of disks.

Jocelyn: They found that disks with weak turbulence and stronger MHD disk wind-driven accretion are much better at both growing and concentrating dust down in the midplane. They attribute this to two things: weak turbulence means less stirring, so dust settles more efficiently onto the midplane, plus increased collision rates because the dust becomes more concentrated. Vera That makes sense; if you don't have lots of turbulence kicking things around, particles just drop out of the way and clump together faster.

Subrahmanyan: They also found that when you combine a high initial accretion rate, weak turbulence, and strong outflows, the midplane dust-to-gas mass ratios can get as high as zero point four at around one astronomical unit. That's a significant result for the dust inventory in the disk Jocelyn But they also found that the streaming instability onset is only possible in a very narrow range of parameters, specifically with very weak turbulence and a very high mass loss rate.

Vera: It shows that even with these wind effects, getting to those critical density points for planetesimal formation via streaming instability isn't easy to hit in this model. Subrahmanyan That brings us to the limitations they point out—the model can't create pressure maxima inside the disk which are needed for that instability.

Jocelyn: Plus, they noted that dust gets depleted way out in the outer regions of disks with weak turbulence because of rapid radial drift. So planetesimal formation out there seems unlikely unless you have those pressure bumps stopping the drift. Vera And a major limitation they mention is that this first model doesn't capture how the magnetic field reacts back on the disk gas and dust, which is something higher dimensional simulations show is crucial for creating wind-driven substructures.

Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at the full picture with "Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds," the authors are really zeroing in on how dust behaves when you have this mix of turbulent accretion and wind-driven accretion happening all at once in a magnetized disk. Jocelyn It boils down to this: even with the winds helping concentrate the dust, they still couldn't get the dust-to-gas ratios high enough to trigger planetesimal formation through streaming instability in these smooth disks.

Subrahmanyan: What this means for us cosmologically is that if we want to form planetesimals through that specific streaming instability mechanism, we can't just rely on a smooth disk with some wind assistance. Vera We need some kind of pressure bump—a trap—to stop the dust from drifting away in the outer regions, which means the next steps in modeling must focus on creating those bumps dynamically.

Jocelyn: The paper suggests that these MHD winds might offer an alternative way to create rings and gaps in disks without us having to assume a planet is already there. Subrahmanyan That's a big idea because it changes how we picture disk clearing and structure formation in the early universe, suggesting winds are doing more than just moving gas around.

Vera: The authors admit their model has limitations, specifically that it doesn't include the back reaction of the magnetic field on the gas and dust, which is important for making those complex wind structures seen in higher dimensional simulations. Jocelyn Their future work will focus on building a model that includes dynamic magnetic field evolution and ionization chemistry to create those pressure bumps we talked about.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like they're moving toward a more complete picture of planet formation, focusing on the physics needed to generate those necessary traps, rather than just seeing if the dust concentration is possible under current simple conditions.

Olcay Ates Goksu, Ralph E. Pudritz, Timmy N. Delage

Department of Physics and Astronomy, McMaster University · Astrophysics Group, Department of Physics, Imperial College London

astro-ph.EP

Submitted: 2026-11-05

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 23 pages, 13 Figures. Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Observations and theory increasingly indicate that protoplanetary disks are weakly turbulent, implying that magnetized disk winds may dominate their angular momentum transport and long-term evolution…

Key concepts

MHD Disk Winds
These are outflows of gas driven by magnetic fields within the disk. The paper investigates how these winds affect accretion and mass loss, showing they can influence dust transport and concentration in the disk.
Streaming Instability (SI)
SI is a process where dust grains aggregate rapidly due to their collective motion, leading to growth. The study explored whether this instability occurs in laminar disks even when aided by wind-driven accretion, finding it unlikely without external pressure bumps.
Dust Settling
This refers to the process where dust particles move vertically toward the disk's midplane. Weak turbulence helps this settling by reducing turbulent stirring, allowing dust to concentrate more efficiently at the center of the disk.
Pressure Bump
A pressure bump is a region in a disk where gas pressure increases, creating a trap for dust. The paper suggests that while winds can create structures, these traps are necessary for planetesimal formation via SI.

Terminology

Summary

Observations and theory increasingly indicate that protoplanetary disks are weakly turbulent, implying that magnetized disk winds may dominate their angular momentum transport and long-term evolution The paper builds a parametric hybrid disk evolution model to investigate dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks

Model Framework

The study utilizes a parametric hybrid disk evolution model that incorporates turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to explore dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks The model employs the one-dimensional disk evolution code DustPy to simulate dust coagulation/fragmentation and transport while modifying the gas evolution to include the effect of magnetized disk winds following the formalism of J. Chambers (2019) The simulation runs for a timescale of 1 Myr, varying initial total accretion rate, wind-driven mass loss rate, and turbulence strength

Dust Growth and Concentration

The simulations reveal that disks with weak turbulence and correspondingly stronger MHD disk wind-driven accretion are significantly more conducive to both the growth and the concentration of dust in the disk midplane This enhancement is attributed to two factors: weak turbulence results in more efficient dust settling onto the disk midplane due to lack of turbulent stirring, as well as increased collision rates because dust becomes more concentrated Furthermore, weak turbulence lowers collision velocities between dust particles, leading to more growth instead of fragmentation

Dust-to-Gas Ratios and Streaming Instability

The analysis of midplane dust-to-gas ratios shows an enhancement in weakly turbulent wind-driven disks due to efficient vertical settling and the removal of gas from the disk via wind-driven outflows With a combination of high initial accretion rate, weak turbulence, and strong outflows, midplane dust-to-gas mass ratios approach ∼ 0.4 at around 1 AU However, the streaming instability (SI) onset is only possible in a very narrow range of the parameter space explored, specifically with very weak turbulence and a very high mass loss rate

Limitations and Future Directions

The parametrized MHD wind model cannot create pressure maxima within the disk, which are necessary for planetesimal formation via SI, thus requiring more complete disk evolution models that include the dynamic evolution of the magnetic field and non-ideal MHD effects The study also notes that dust is depleted in the outer regions of disks with weak turbulence due to rapid radial drift, indicating that planetesimal formation in outer regions is unlikely without pressure bumps halting radial drift

Conclusion on Planet Formation

The findings indicate that planetesimal formation via SI is highly unlikely in smooth disks even when dust growth and concentration are aided by the presence of the disk wind, suggesting that a pressure bump-generating mechanism is necessary for creating dust traps The MHD disk winds may provide an alternative mechanism for creating rings and gaps in disks without needing to invoke the existence of a preexisting planet

Model Limitations

A main limitation of this first model is its inability to capture the back reaction of the magnetic field on the disk gas and dust, which is crucial for creating wind-driven substructures seen in higher-dimensional simulations The model also does not include the backreaction of dust on the gas, which becomes significant in regions of high dust concentration The level of ionization in the disk controls non-ideal MHD effects, which will be included in future work

Conclusion and Future Work

The paper concludes that planetesimal formation by SI is unlikely in laminar disks even with wind assistance, necessitating more physically motivated models to capture the beginning of the planet formation process The future work will focus on a model that includes both dynamic magnetic field evolution and non-ideal MHD effects to create pressure bumps for planetesimal formation The study's virtue lies in focusing on how dust evolves in unstructured disks undergoing a mixture of viscous and MHD wind-driven accretion

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Tommy Chi Ho Lau, Mario Flock and Til Birnstiel, and John Chambers for providing details regarding their hybrid disk model AG is supported by McMaster University REP is supported by a Discovery Grant from the National Science and Engineering Council (NSERC) of Canada TND is supported by The Royal Society Career Development Fellowship (grant number CDFR1241766) The computational work in this paper was achieved on the Fir computing cluster (previously Cedar), part of the Digital Research Alliance of Canada computing network, under resource allocation code ycg-982-af

Author Contributions

Olcay Ates Goksu was responsible for modifying the software (DustPy) to include the influence of the MHD wind, running models, generating Figures, conducting analysis of results, and writing the main body of this manuscript Ralph E. Pudritz was responsible for funding and supervising this work, guiding each step of the project, analysis of results and editing this manuscript Timmy N. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds Olcay Ates Goksu , 1 Ralph E. Pudritz , 1 and Timmy N.

Delage was responsible for suggesting the software used for this work, providing many of the scripts used in the implementation of the hybrid disk model, providing essential guidance on implementation, providing critical feedback and suggestions on results and analysis, writing the Abstract and Introduction sections, and editing the main body of this manuscript Software: DustPy (S. M. Stammler & T. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For that, we use the one-dimensional disk evolution code DustPy (S. Stammler & T.

Birnstiel 2022), numpy (C. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Stammler & T. Birnstiel 2022) to model dust coagulation/fragmentation and dust transport, and modify the gas evolution to include the effect of magnetized disk winds following the formalism of J.

R. Harris et al. 2020), matplotlib (J. p. 1
Where the paper says it

2009); (2) Smaller dust particles remain more tightly coupled to the gas and are therefore more sensitive to turbulent diffusion, which opposes both radial and vertical concentrations (P. Armitage 2020).

D. Hunter 2007), astropy (Astropy Collaboration et al. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Youdin & Y. Lithwick 2007; A.

2022), scipy (P. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Delage et al. 2022, 2023).

Virtanen et al. 2019)

Appendix A

In this Section, we provide comparisons between numerical solutions of the hybrid gas disk evolution equations in J. Chambers (2019) to our own implementation within DustPy Numerical solutions of J. p. 3

Where the paper says it

A comparison between numerical solutions of the wind-driven gas surface density evolution of J. Chambers (2019) and our own implementation is provided in Appendix A, for various combinations of fw and K.

Chambers (2019) can be found in the Appendix of their paper The comparisons can be found in Figure 9 Note that the inner boundaries of these simulations are 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

A comparison between numerical solutions of the wind-driven gas surface density evolution of J. Chambers (2019) and our own implementation is provided in Appendix A, for various combinations of fw and K.

01 AU instead of the 1 AU we use in our simulations, and that the simulations run for 10 Myr instead of 1 Myr Gas evolution within DustPy is not the limiting factor in terms of the computational costs of simulations; it is instead primarily the dust coagulation/fragmentation calculations Three combinations of fw (which govern the MHD wind-driven accretion flow and is converted to αwind in the main text) and K (which govern the mass loss rate) are provided in the Figure to demonstrate the accuracy of our implementation over the relevant parameter ranges

Appendix B

Both physical control parameters kept constant through our simulations and the properties of our simulation grids (both radial and mass) are provided in Table 2 The model consists of two grids: a radial grid and a mass grid Our choice of inner boundary in our radial grid is due to the high computational cost of drawing the inner boundary further in run times of our simulations go from days to weeks even with small changes to the inner boundary below 1 AU due to the much shorter timesteps required to accurately compute the coagulation/fragmentation of dust at these radii

Table 2

The model consists of two grids: a radial grid and a mass grid Gas disk parameters Parameter Description Value Mstar Stellar mass 1 M⊙ Mdisk Gas disk mass 0.05 Mstar p Self-similar disk exponent-1 rc Disk cut-off radius 50 AU r0 Reference radius 1 AU T0 Temperature at reference radius 300 K Dust disk parameters Parameter Description Value aini, max Maximum dust size in initial distribution 1 µm distExp Exponent of initial dust size distribution-7/2 Z Initial dust-to-gas ratio 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(1977), where n(a) ∝ a distExp, up to a maximum initial size of aini,max. We keep the initial disk mass fixed at Mdisk = 0.

01 ρmon Dust material density 1. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Dust In Wind-Driven Disks 5 vd,i = (vg − 2ηvKSti) 1 1 + St2 i , (17) where Sti is the Stokes number, and η is related to the radial pressure gradient in the disk as η = − 1 2 HP r 2 ∂ log P ∂ log r . (18) The value of the Stokes number Sti depends on whether dust is in the Epstein or Stokes I regime, and is given by Sti =    π 2 aiρmon Σg if ai < 9 4 λmfp (Epstein) 2π 9 a 2 i ρmon λmfpΣg if ai ≥ 9 4 λmfp (Stokes I), (19) where λmfp is the mean free path of the gas, λmfp = 1 √ 2 nσH2 , (20) with n the midplane gas number density, and we take the material density of dust to be ρmon = 1.

67 g/cm3 Grid properties Nr No. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Lombart et al. 2026), young PPDs inherit the dust properties provided by the interstellar medium (ISM), with characteristic sizes of ∼ 1 µm (J.

of radial grid cells 128 rmin Inner radial boundary 1 AU rmax Outer radial boundary 500 AU Nmbpd No. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We show these quantities for disks in Figure 6 with our different values of the initial total accretion rate. A consistent rise in midplane dustto-gas ratios mass across the entire radial extent of our disks, especially pronounced near the inner boundary of our simulations, can be seen for decreasing αturb in each of our panels (though most pronounced for higher initial total accretion rates in the top row).

of mass bins per mass decade 7 mmin Lower limit of mass grid 7 × 10−15 g mmax Upper limit of mass grid 4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Lastly, we compute estimates of dust sizes in the fragmentation and drift limits. The fragmentation limit represents the size beyond which dust will fragment into smaller sizes instead of growing due to dust-dust collisions, and the drift limit represents the size beyond which dust will rapidly drift into the star before having a chance to grow further.

48 × 108 g

Figure 9

Gas column densities of disks with various combinations of fw and K Solid lines showcase the evolution of the disk numerically solved by DustPy whereas dot-dashed lines are numerical solutions as shown in J. Chambers (2019), which are very well-matched in all cases

Figure 10

Comparison of midplane dust-to-gas ratios in the disk to SI thresholds of J. Lim et al. (2024) and R. Li & A. N. Youdin (2021) for all disks with mass loss rate parameter K = 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We build a parametric hybrid disk evolution model that includes turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to investigate dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks. We employ this model to carry out a parameter study in which the initial total accretion rate, the wind-driven mass loss rate, and the turbulence strength are varied.

4 1 Myr into the disks’ evolution When compared to Figure 7 (which shows 0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The bottom row of Figure 1 shows the evolution of bulk dust column densities, which are calculated by summing dust column densities for each mass bin in the simulation. It can be seen that changing the values of K has a weaker influence on bulk dust densities compared to the gas.

5 Myr), midplane dust-to-gas ratios are much lower at this point in the disks’ lifetime

Figure 11

Same as Figure 10, this time showing all disks with mass loss rate parameter K = 0.6: the highest mass loss we allow in our simulations The same trend as the K = 0. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Ueda et al. In addition, gas surface accretion due to magnetized disk winds, combined with dust settling onto the midplane, can allow disks to retain dust while the gas is accreted onto the central star, increasing dust-to-gas mass ratios (S.

4 is here with the evolution of midplane dust-to-gas ratios

Figure 7

Comparison between the midplane dust-to-gas ratios attained in the simulated disks and SI thresholds of R. Li & A. N. Youdin (2021) and J. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Whether the SI can operate depends sensitively on both the dust-to-gas mass ratio and the aerodynamic coupling of dust to the gas, which is expressed through the Stokes number (R. Youdin 2021; J.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Whether the SI can operate depends sensitively on both the dust-to-gas mass ratio and the aerodynamic coupling of dust to the gas, which is expressed through the Stokes number (R. Youdin 2021; J.

Lim et al. (2024) for all disks with K = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Draft version November 6, 2026 Typeset using LATEX twocolumn style in AASTeX7. 1 Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds Olcay Ates Goksu , 1 Ralph E.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Draft version November 6, 2026 Typeset using LATEX twocolumn style in AASTeX7. 1 Evolution of Dust In Protoplanetary Disks With Magnetized Winds Olcay Ates Goksu , 1 Ralph E.

4 J. Lim et al.(2024) thresholds are used for αturb = 10−3 and 10−4, while the R. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Other fixed parameters used across our simulations, along with their motivations, are provided in Appendix B. A complete list of our simulations, along with associated parameter values (M˙ acc,tot,init, αturb, αwind, K) is provided in Table 1.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Other fixed parameters used across our simulations, along with their motivations, are provided in Appendix B. A complete list of our simulations, along with associated parameter values (M˙ acc,tot,init, αturb, αwind, K) is provided in Table 1.

Li & A. N. Youdin (2021) threshold is used for αturb = 10−5

Figure 8

Same as Figure 7, now showing comparisons between midplane dust-to-gas ratios and SI thresholds for K = 0.6 For these disks, we see that the SI thresholds is crossed in the innermost regions of the disk only for our highest choice of initial accretion rate (M˙ acc,init = 10−7 M⊙/yr) and weakest turbulence (αturb = 10−5)

Figure 3

Top row: Evolution of total gas mass in our disks across time, where each panel is a different initial total accretion rate While there is some variance in the mass evolution over time for different values of αturb, αwind and K, the behavior is similar across the same M˙ acc,init Bottom row: Evolution of total dust mass in the disks Unlike the gas mass evolution, which is determined mainly by the initial total accretion and wind mass loss rates, the evolution of dust mass is mainly determined by the strength of turbulence

Figure 4

Evolution of dust sizes for an initial total accretion rate of 10−7 M⊙/yr, for K = 0.0 and K = 0.6 Each column represents a different balance between turbulence-driven accretion and wind-driven accretion, with turbulence weakening from left to right The top panel shows results for K = 0, representing a wind with negligible mass loss The bottom panel shows results for K = 0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Each column represents a different balance between turbulence-driven accretion and winddriven accretion, with turbulence weakening from left to right. The top panel shows results for K = 0, representing a wind with negligible mass loss.

6, representing a wind with high mass loss, with M˙ wind,acc ≈ M˙ wind,outflow

Figure 5

Representative Stokes numbers 0.5 Myr into disk evolution where each panel shows a different initial total accretion rate The St = 10−2 line is also provided as a reference Once again, we see the strength of turbulence as the dominant effect in determining the representative Stokes numbers

Figure 6

Midplane dust-to-gas ratios 0.5 Myr into disk evolution, where each panel represents a different initial total accretion rate In addition to steadily increasing dust-to-gas mass ratios with weakening turbulence, we also observe significantly higher dust-to-gas ratios with higher wind-driven mass loss rates

Figure 12

Evolution of dust bulk densities, similar to the bottom row of Figure 1 Both panels show disks with M˙ acc,tot,init = 10−8 M⊙/yr, with accretion driven primarily by turbulence on the left panel (αturb = 10−3) and by the wind on the right panel αturb = 10−4 The dust δ is set to be identical to αturb in the case of solid lines, and is reduced by a factor of 10 compared to αturb = 10−4 in the case of dot-dashed lines Whereas the evolution of dust column densities differ significantly for different choices of δ in the case of a turbulence-dominated disk, only slight differences can be observed when the turbulence is weak and the wind primarily drives the accretion flow

Figure 13

Gas column densities (left panel) and dust column densities (right panel) for disks with the same initial total accretion rate and same dust δ, but with different balances of turbulence-driven accretion and wind-driven accretion There is no mass loss in any of these runs, so K = 0 This set-up allows us to isolate the effect of the dominant accretion mechanism on dust evolution Dust appears to be evolving similarly across all simulations

Comparison between the midplane dust-to-gas ratios in our simulated disks and SI thresholds of R. Li & A. N. Youdin (2021) and J. Lim et al. (2024) for all disks with K = 0.4 J. Lim et al.(2024) thresholds are used for αturb = 10−3 and 10−4, while the R. Li & A. N. Youdin (2021) threshold is used for αturb = 10−5

Same as Figure 7, now showing comparisons between midplane dust-to-gas ratios and SI thresholds for K = 0.6 It can be seen that the SI thresholds is crossed in the innermost regions of the disk only for our highest choice of initial total accretion rate (M˙ acc,init = 10−7 M⊙/yr) and weakest turbulence (αturb = 10−5)

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that planetesimal formation by SI is unlikely in laminar disks even with wind assistance, suggesting that a pressure bump-generating mechanism is necessary for creating dust traps The MHD disk winds may provide an alternative mechanism for the creation of rings and gaps in disks without needing to invoke the existence of a preexisting planet

The main limitation of this first model is its inability to capture the back reaction of the magnetic field on the disk gas and dust, which is crucial for creating wind-driven substructures seen in higher-dimensional simulations The model also does not include the backreaction of dust on the gas, which can lead to a reduction in inflow of gas in regions of high dust concentration

The study's virtue is the focus on the simple but important question of how dust evolves in unstructured disks undergoing a mixture of viscous and MHD wind-driven accretion The authors intend to include both dynamic magnetic field evolution and ionization chemistry in future work This model, and pressure bumps created therein to allow for planetesimal formation, will be the focus of our next paper The study shows that even under the optimal conditions for exciting SI, midplane dust-to-gas ratios still fail to reach SI thresholds The authors note that more conservative thresholds (i.e., ϵmid exceeds the canonical threshold of 1) may be more prudent to use in studies such as this that do not directly model the SI mechanism

The study's virtue is the focus on the simple but important question of how dust evolves in unstructured disks undergoing a mixture of viscous and MHD wind-driven accretion The authors intend to include both dynamic magnetic field evolution and ionization chemistry in future work This model, and pressure bumps created therein to allow for planetesimal formation, will be the focus of our next paper The study shows that even under the optimal conditions for exciting SI, midplane dust-to-gas ratios still fail to reach SI thresholds The authors note that more conservative thresholds (i.e.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Develop a parametric hybrid disk evolution model capable of simultaneously modeling turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to investigate dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks over Myr timescales.

  2. Implement an AI system that can perform parameter studies by varying initial total accretion rate, wind-driven mass loss rate, and turbulence strength while ensuring the combination of turbulent and wind-driven accretion reproduces the prescribed initial total accretion rate.

  3. Enhance the system's ability to predict dust size distributions, dust-to-gas mass ratios, and potential streaming instability favorable regions based on varied disk parameters by utilizing results from a one dimensional disk evolution code like DustPy.

  4. Improve the AI's capacity to analyze and interpret results regarding the effect of wind mass loss parameter K on bulk dust densities compared to gas column densities, specifically noting that changing the values of K has a weaker influence on bulk dust densities compared to the gas.

  5. Enable the system to predict whether planetesimal formation via streaming instability is likely by calculating midplane dust-to-gas ratios and comparing them against SI threshold estimates derived from different literature sources, such as R. Li and A. N. Youdin (2021) and J. Lim et al. (2024).

  6. Allow the AI to identify the specific conditions under which planetesimal formation via streaming instability is most likely, such as a disk with a combination of very weak turbulence and very high mass loss rate being the only possible candidate in some explored parameter spaces.

  7. Provide an understanding of the limitations of current parametrized models by identifying that they cannot create such structures [pressure maxima] and require the dynamic evolution of the magnetic field in addition to the evolution of gas and dust.

Abstract

Observations and theory increasingly indicate that protoplanetary disks are weakly turbulent, implying that magnetized disk winds may dominate their angular momentum transport and long-term evolution. Yet dust evolution in wind-dominated disks remains poorly understood, despite its importance for planet formation. In particular, whether wind-dominated disk evolution can create regions with enhanced dust-to-gas mass ratios that enable planetesimal formation via the streaming instability is unclear. We build a parametric hybrid disk evolution model that includes turbulent accretion, wind-driven accretion, and wind-driven mass loss to investigate dust evolution in magnetized protoplanetary disks. We employ this model to carry out a parameter study in which the initial total accretion rate, the wind-driven mass loss rate, and the turbulence strength are varied. We find that although wind-dominated disks are more favorable to dust growth and concentration than turbulence-dominated disks, conditions suitable for the streaming instability arise only within the inner few au and only under the most extreme conditions: very weak turbulence (α turb = 10-5) where magnetized winds drive most of the accretion (M dot acc,tot M dot wind,acc), and wind-driven mass loss comparable to the accretion rate (M dot wind,outflow M dot acc,wind). Our results therefore imply that, beyond the inner few au, the parametric wind-driven evolution models considered in the literature do not by themselves produce conditions suitable for planetesimal formation via the streaming instability, motivating more physically complete models in which spontaneous, long-lived dust traps can arise.

Sources

Related papers