Active model B+ from run-and-tumble particles on a triangular lattice
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Active model B+ from run-and-tumble particles on a triangular lattice".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Active model B+ (AMB+) explains how motility-induced phase separation can be arrested by reverse Ostwald ripening, but its coefficients have not been derived from a microscopic lattice model that shows it Near the critical point (3/4, 4), coarsening is ordinary; further away, field theory predicts reverse Ostwald ripening of vapor bubbles above Pe > 4√3, and simulations show long-lived bubbly states.
Kai: Model and exact hydrodynamics The authors establish an explicit analytical connection between a microscopic lattice model of run-andtumble particles (RTPs) and the two-dimensional continuum field theory of AMB+.
Mira: The results are threefold: six-fold symmetry is the minimal lattice symmetry for which the fourth-order hydrodynamics is isotropic and can therefore take the AMB+ form.
Kai: Furthermore, the critical point and all AMB+ coefficients are fixed by a unique combination of microscopic rates, namely the P´eclet number Pe, which is dimensionless.
Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, the paper "Active model B+ from run-and-tumble particles on a triangular lattice" establishes an explicit analytical connection between microscopic run-and-tumble particles and a two dimensional continuum field theory for AMB+.
Mira: The thesis is that this model explains how motility induced phase separation can be arrested by reverse Ostwald ripening, but it also shows that the coefficients aren't derived from a simple microscopic lattice model.
Lev: They achieve this by providing an exact hydrodynamic description of a six-polarity lattice gas on a hexagonal geometry and using a full gradient expansion to derive AMB+ with every coefficient fixed by the Péclet number Pe.
Kai: What matters for us is that they show that near the critical point, coarsening is ordinary, which is consistent with Ising criticality, but away from it, field theory predicts reverse ripening above Pe greater than four times the square root of three.
Mira: And the simulations back this up by showing long-lived bubbly states when Pe exceeds that threshold. It’s interesting because it links microscopic particle dynamics directly to macroscopic phase separation phenomena.
Lev: The methodology involves using diffusive rescaling to make diffusion, self-propulsion, and tumbling contribute equally in the hydrodynamic limit, which allows for a closed evolution equation for the coarse grained density rho n r t.
Kai: That equation is d t rho n = D (one - rho) grad squared rho n + rho n grad squared rho - v e n · grad
(one - rho) rho n: + (gamma) <ref:2611.08296#pg1>. It’s complex, but that’s the framework they use.
Mira: They then expand this around the critical density of three over four, rho c equals three over four, to get the AMB+ form where all coefficients are functions of Pe.
Lev: The Péclet number Pe is dimensionless and acts as a single parameter that fixes every coefficient in this AMB+ framework through microscopic transition rates.
Kai: So, the real impact is showing how this specific particle model leads to these specific hydrodynamic equations that predict reverse Ostwald ripening above a certain Péclet number.
Conclusion: Mira: Thinking about the paper's title, "Active model B+ from run-and-tumble particles on a triangular lattice," it’s really about finding a specific physical system that yields this particular set of hydrodynamic equations.
Kai: It takes the complexity of active systems and simplifies it by showing that the six-fold symmetry is minimal for getting an isotropic AMB+ description at fourth order, which is important because square lattices are anisotropic sooner.
Lev: The implication for real hardware is that we need to consider how this behavior scales when you move beyond the critical region, where reverse ripening happens above Pe equals four times the square root of three.
Kai: So, in simple terms, this paper provides a rigorous framework showing that depending on how fast the particles are tumbling and moving relative to their diffusion, you can get different kinds of phase separation outcomes.
Mira: The main point is that this specific model connects microscopic rates to macroscopic phase behavior via the Péclet number Pe. It shows that the critical region is standard, but beyond it, reverse ripening happens under specific conditions.
Abir Bhowmick, *, P. K. Mohanty, ^†
Department of Physical Sciences, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Kolkata · Dutch Institute for Emergent Phenomena (DIEP), University of Amsterdam
cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.stat-mech
Submitted: 2026-11-05
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 4 pages, 4 figs, supplemental material (pdf, 5 pages)
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Active model B+ (AMB+) explains how motility-induced phase separation can be arrested by reverse Ostwald ripening…
Key concepts
- Active Model B+
- This is a continuum field theory describing how active particles move and interact. It explains phase separation in systems where self-propulsion drives the system towards clustering. The model's coefficients are determined by microscopic rates, linking particle behavior to macroscopic fluid dynamics.
- Reverse Ostwald Ripening (ROR)
- This is a process where smaller droplets shrink and larger ones grow, which is the opposite of normal ripening. In this active system, it happens when the competition between active forces favors the growth of smaller bubbles over larger ones above a certain Péclet number.
- Péclet Number (Pe)
- The Péclet number is a dimensionless parameter that relates self-propulsion to diffusion in an active system. It acts as a key tuning parameter, determining whether the system exhibits ordinary coarsening or reverse ripening, and fixing the critical point of the phase separation.
- Ising Criticality
- This refers to a type of phase transition behavior found near the critical point where systems exhibit universal scaling laws. The paper shows that near criticality in this model, the behavior is consistent with Ising criticality, meaning it follows predictable rules for how fluctuations behave at that specific density.
Terminology
Summary
Active model B+ (AMB+) explains how motility-induced phase separation can be arrested by reverse Ostwald ripening, but its coefficients have not been derived from a microscopic lattice model that shows it Near the critical point (3/4, 4), coarsening is ordinary; further away, field theory predicts reverse Ostwald ripening of vapor bubbles above Pe > 4√3, and simulations show long-lived bubbly states. p. 0
Model and exact hydrodynamics
The authors establish an explicit analytical connection between a microscopic lattice model of run-andtumble particles (RTPs) and the two-dimensional continuum field theory of AMB+. The results are threefold: six-fold symmetry is the minimal lattice symmetry for which the fourth-order hydrodynamics is isotropic and can therefore take the AMB+ form. p. 0 Furthermore, the critical point and all AMB+ coefficients are fixed by a unique combination of microscopic rates, namely the P´eclet number Pe, which is dimensionless. p. 0 Near criticality λ 0 ∀ Pe > 0) independently of the tumbling kernel, so the critical region shows ordinary MIPS, consistent with Ising criticality. p. 0 Away from criticality, a meanfield calculation shows that vapor bubbles ripen in reverse when Pe is increased above a threshold Pe∗ = 4√3. p. 0
Continuum Limit and Scale Invariance
The diffusive rescaling of space r = i/L and time t = τ /L2 makes all three processes (diffusion, self-propulsion and tumbling) contribute equally in the hydrodynamic limit. In this large L limit, local correlations become negligible at the macroscopic scale, allowing the evolution of the coarse-grained density ρn(r, t) to be described by a closed hydrodynamic equation. p. 1 This description relies on the “local equilibrium” assumption [57], under which the local statistics are approximated by product Bernoulli measures parametrized by the local densities. p. 1 The resulting correlation-free evolution equation reads ∂tρn = D(1 − ρ)∇2ρn + ρn∇2ρ − v en · ∇[(1 − ρ)ρn] + γ (ρn−1 + ρn+1 − 2ρn). p. 1
Angular harmonics and isotropy
The six-fold symmetry is necessary for the fourth-order hydrodynamics to be isotropic and take the AMB+ form. The conserved density is denoted by p0 = ρ, the polarization by p1 = mx + i my, and p2 = Q1 + i Q2 denotes the nematic tensor. p. 1 The third harmonic p3 describes the alternating-polarity mode. p. 1 By eliminating these modes, we obtain macroscopic continuity equation for ρ ≡ ρ(r, t) (see details at [56]). p. 1 The explicit retention of the second harmonic p2 is crucial in obtaining this form. p. 2
Field theory near criticality
Expanding ρ = ρc + ϕ about the critical density ρc = 3/4, recasts the full hydrodynamic equation to AMB+ form defined in Eq. (1) with constant coefficients, tunable by the dimensionless propulsion parameter Pe. p. 2 The parameters r, u, κ, λ, ζ are fixed by the microscopic transition rates through Pe. p. 2 Equation (5) takes the structure of the AMB+ framework defined in Eq. p. 2 (1), but the coefficients are nonlinear functions of the field ρ. p. 2 The homogeneous state ρ(r, t) = ¯ρ becomes unstable when the local compressibility µ′(¯ρ) vanishes, together with µ′′(¯ρ); this locates the critical point exactly at ρc = 3/4 and Pec = 4. p. 2
Microphase separation
The characteristic feature of AMB+ is formation of finite size clusters or bubbles [35]. Deep in the phase-separated state, a dense system creates steady vapor bubbles with interfaces spanning densities from ρ+ to ρ−, balancing the pressure P(ρ+) = P(ρ−) + σR, where ρ− is the bulk density inside the droplet and ρ+ is the same outside the droplet, and σ is the pseudo-tension. p. 2 The competition between the two nonequilibrium active gradient terms λ and ζ governs this process. p. 2 In particular, σ becomes negative in the regions λ, ζ have the same sign, favoring ROR. p. 2 For a generic density ¯ρ ≠ ρc, a simple estimate of the microphase-separated (µPS) region inside the binodal can be obtained from Eq. p. 3 (5) by expanding λˆ(ρ), ˆζ(ρ) near ρ = ¯ρ. p. 3 Since ˆζ(¯ρ) > 0 for any ¯ρ, the sign of λˆ(¯ρ) sets the criteria for µPS as, Pe > Pe∗ (¯ρ) = 2p ρbar− 2/3. p. 3 At ρ = ρc this gives Pe∗ = 4√3. p. 3
Simulations
To test the ROR process directly, simulations prepare an 2L × L system (L = 256) with two circular vapor bubbles of radii R1 > R2, one in each L×L half, at ρ¯ = 0.75 [Fig. 4(a)]. At Pe = 6.0, the larger bubble grows at the expense of the smaller one, as in ordinary Ostwald ripening. p. 3 At Pe = 8.0 however, the trend reverses: the larger bubble shrinks, and the smaller one grows. p. 3 For ρ¯ = 0.5 and 0.6, L(t) grows until they hit the bounds set by the size of the system; the growth follows t 1/3 law [60, 61] with the logarithmic corrections expected for conserved dynamics. p. 3 For ¯ρ ≥ 0.7, above the estimate ¯ρ∗ = 0. p. 3677 from Eq. p. 3 (7), the minority phase consists of vapor bubbles and L(t) saturates at a finite value. p. 3
Discussion
The derivation fixes every coefficient through the P´eclet number Pe, which directly relates to the microscopic transition rates. The information about the lattice structure enters the hydrodynamic description only through the ratio Γ2/Γ1, where Γ1,2 are the relaxation rates of the polarization and nematic modes. p. 3 If microscopic tumbling kernel allows all possible turns (±π/3, ±2π/3, π) with rates (γ1, γ2, γ3) respectively, we have Γ2/Γ1 = 3(γ1 + γ2)/(γ1 + 3γ2 + 2γ3). p. 3 The fact that the homogeneous state near criticality destabilizes to form MIPS (not µPS) is generic, independent of the tumbling kernel. p. 3 Three conclusions follow: First, a six-fold lattice is the minimal choice that gives an isotropic AMB+ at fourth order, whereas a square-lattice model is already anisotropic at the order where ζ appears. p. 3 Second, the critical region shows ordinary coarsening, consistent with Ising criticality [43, 45, 54, 55]. p. 3 Third, beyond the critical region, the exact hydrodynamics predicts, at mean-field level, reverse ripening of vapor bubbles for Pe > Pe∗ = 2p ρbar− 2/3), and simulations show reverse Ostwald ripening of bubble pairs and long-lived bubbly states at high density. p. 3
Acknowledgement
PKM gratefully acknowledge the support, hospitality, and stimulating research environment provided by the Dutch Institute for Emergent Phenomena (DIEP) and the Faculty of Science (FNWI) at the University of Amsterdam (UvA) during my tenure as a Global South Fellow.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
The improved AI system can accurately predict phase separation behavior in run-and-tumble particle systems by using a derived explicit dictionary between microscopic rates and macroscopic AMB+ field theory coefficients fixed by the Peclet number Pe. This allows for direct mapping from microscopic transition rates to phase diagram features, such as predicting reverse Ostwald ripening when Pe exceeds a threshold.
-
The system can accurately model the critical behavior of motility-induced phase separation by utilizing the derived relationship that "Near criticality lambda 0 ∀ Pe > 0) independently of the tumbling kernel, so the critical region shows ordinary MIPS, consistent with Ising criticality." This enables precise identification of the critical point at Pe = 4 and rho c = 3/4.
-
The system can distinguish between different types of phase separation states by calculating a threshold for microphase separation (µPS) using the estimate "Pe > Pe∗ (¯ρ) = 2/p(ρ¯− 2/3)," which indicates the point where interfacial active fluxes stabilize finite cluster sizes.
Sources
Related papers
- Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles
- Three-body corrections to the Brownian viscosity of hard spheres without hydrodynamic interactions
- Thin active nematohydrodynamic layers: asymptotic theories and instabilities
- Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid
- Soft material mechanical property degradation at high strain rates
- Avalanche criticality emerges by thermal fluctuation in a quiescent glass