Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid

arXiv:2404.17756 · cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.stat-mech, physics.chem-ph · Submitted 2024-04-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Understanding and ultimately controlling the transformations and properties of nanoscale systems, from proteins to synthetic nanomaterial assemblies, is limited by the inability to uncover their dynamics on their characteristic length and time scales.

Kai: Here, we nevertheless demonstrate this ability using MHz X-ray photon correlation spectroscopy (XPCS) – directly elucidating the characteristic microsecond-dynamics of density fluctuations of semiconductor nanocrystals (NCs), not only in a colloidal dispersion but also in a liquid phase consisting of densely packed, yet mobile, NCs with no long-range order.

Mira: We find the wavevector-dependent fluctuation rates in the liquid phase are suppressed relative to those in the colloidal phase and relative to observations of densely packed repulsive particles.

Kai: We show that the suppressed rates are due to a substantial decrease in the self-diffusion of NCs, which we attribute to explicit attractive interactions.

Paper summary: Kai: So, as we were saying, the paper "Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid" uses MHz XPCS to probe the dynamics of few-nanometer charged semiconductor nanocrystals. They set up experiments by changing the ionic strength to tune the electrostatic repulsion between these nanocrystals, which lets them create both stable colloidal and liquid phases.

Mira: The focus there is on carefully separating the actual intrinsic dynamics of these nanocrystals from any effects that come from the X-ray pulses themselves. They define their liquid phase as having densely packed, mobile nanocrystals but without long-range order.

Lev: The paper quantifies these characteristic dynamics by calculating two time correlation functions, C of q t1 t2, which they then use to derive autocorrelation functions g of two at a fixed average sample age t bar <ref:2404.17756#pg1>. That's the way they measure how fast things are decorrelating.

Kai: They find that the autocorrelation functions for both phases decay faster at higher q and decay more slowly in the liquid phase compared to the colloidal phase, which is a significant observation when comparing those two states.

Mira: When they extract the decorrelation rates, Γ of q t bar, they extrapolate them back to zero time to get what they call the rate associated with unperturbed nanocrystal dynamics. These rates are then compared against static structure factors and spatial arrangement descriptions for both phases.

Lev: A crucial part is how they characterize those interparticle interactions, relating the effective diffusivities to hydrodynamic functions using Di eff of q which depends on D0 Hi of q divided by Si of q.

Kai: And what they find in this analysis is that for colloidal phase nanocrystals, the function Hc of q is close to one at all values of q, which means the diffusion coefficient ratio D c s over D0 is equal to one.

Mira: But for those liquid-phase nanocrystals, they find a ratio of D l s over D0 that's zero point twenty-three when using the delta gamma method, and zero point eighteen from Brownian dynamics simulations.

Lev: Those ratios are below what you would expect for hard spheres or even charged spheres, which strongly suggests that explicit attractive interactions are the main reason for this suppressed D l s over D0.

Kai: So, in short, the paper is showing that these nanoscale interactions likely have long-range attractive tails that aren't present in larger microscale particles.

Mira: This finding provides a potential strategy to tune interparticle interactions to either avoid or enhance gelation during the self-assembly of nanoscale and microscale systems.

Lev: The limitation they point out is that they are focusing on the intrinsic dynamics in these specific phases, and their analysis is tied to the assumptions about how those interactions behave.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the title "Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid" and reading through this paper, the authors are really zeroing in on why things move slower in these dense, mobile liquid states compared to simpler systems.

Mira: The core message is that this suppression isn't just about how tightly packed the particles are; it’s fundamentally driven by attractive forces that dictate their self-diffusion rates.

Lev: What this means for us in terms of actual hardware or materials science is that if you're designing a system where you want a liquid state, you can no longer just rely on simple repulsion to keep things separated.

Kai: You have to consider those long-range attractive tails that the paper suggests are present, because those are what control the diffusion when things get crowded.

Mira: The authors point out that this insight is important for understanding complex fluids, not just nanoparticles, and it opens the door to looking at non-equilibrium self-assembly processes in proteins too.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means that when you're trying to control assembly, you need to be aware of these specific interaction potentials and how they influence transport properties.

Kai: It's about understanding the microscopic forces governing these dynamics so you can engineer the behavior of these nanoscale assemblies in a way that avoids unwanted gelation or achieves desired liquid-like states.

Christian P. N. Tanner, * Vivian R. K. Wall, Mumtaz Gababa, Joshua Portner, Ahhyun Jeong, Matthew J Hurley, Nicholas Leonard, Jonathan G Raybin, James K Utterback

Department of Chemistry, University of California, Berkeley Department of Chemistry, James Franck Institute and Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering University of Chicago Department of Physics Arizona State University Brookhaven National Laboratory Linac Coherent Light Source SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory European X-ray Free-Electron Laser Facility Chemical Sciences and Materials Sciences Divisions Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Kavli Energy NanoSciences Institute Center for Nanoscale Materials Argonne National Laboratory Department of Physics University of California, Berkeley Molecular Biophysics and Integrated Bioimaging Division Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Materials Sciences and Chemical Sciences Division STROBE NSF Science & Technology Center

cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.stat-mech, physics.chem-ph

Submitted: 2024-04-27

Updated: 2026-11-07

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 98/100

The gist: Understanding and ultimately controlling the transformations and properties of nanoscale systems, from proteins to synthetic nanomaterial assemblies…

Key concepts

MHz XPCS
This technique uses X-ray photons at megahertz frequencies to measure how density fluctuations change over time. It allows scientists to directly observe the characteristic microsecond dynamics of particles in complex fluids like nanoparticle suspensions.
Liquid Phase Dynamics
The liquid phase is characterized as a state where densely packed, mobile NCs exist without long-range order. The study found that the diffusion rates here are significantly slower than in colloidal phases, indicating strong internal interactions are slowing particle movement.
Interparticle Potential
This is a mathematical model describing the forces between individual nanoparticles. By fitting simulation results to this potential, researchers determined that attractive interactions, rather than just repulsion or hard-sphere effects, stabilize the liquid phase and suppress self-diffusion.

Terminology

Summary

Understanding and ultimately controlling the transformations and properties of nanoscale systems, from proteins to synthetic nanomaterial assemblies, is limited by the inability to uncover their dynamics on their characteristic length and time scales. p. 0 Here, we nevertheless demonstrate this ability using MHz X-ray photon correlation spectroscopy (XPCS) – directly elucidating the characteristic microsecond-dynamics of density fluctuations of semiconductor nanocrystals (NCs), not only in a colloidal dispersion but also in a liquid phase consisting of densely packed, yet mobile, NCs with no long-range order. p. 0 We find the wavevector-dependent fluctuation rates in the liquid phase are suppressed relative to those in the colloidal phase and relative to observations of densely packed repulsive particles. p. 0 We show that the suppressed rates are due to a substantial decrease in the self-diffusion of NCs, which we attribute to explicit attractive interactions. p. 0 Using coarse-grained simulations, we find that the extracted shape and strength of the interparticle potential explains the stability of the liquid phase, in contrast to the gelation observed via XPCS in many other charged colloidal systems. p. 0 This work opens the door to elucidating fast, condensed phase dynamics in complex fluids and other nanoscale soft matter, such as densely packed proteins and non-equilibrium self-assembly processes, in addition to designing microscopic strategies to avert gelation. p. 0

Experimental Methodology

The study utilizes MHz XPCS at the European X-ray free electron laser (XFEL) to measure density fluctuations of few-nanometer-diameter charged semiconductor nanocrystals (NCs) as a function of their volume fraction and interaction strength. By changing the ionic strength of the dispersing solution, the authors tune electrostatic repulsion between NCs, thereby controlling their interaction strength. p. 1 This tuning allows for the generation of both stable colloidal and liquid phases. p. 1 The liquid phase is characterized as consisting of densely packed, mobile NCs with no long-range order. p. 0 The authors carefully disentangle the intrinsic NC dynamics in the colloidal and liquid phases from X-ray-induced effects. p. 1

Dynamic Analysis of Fluctuations

The characteristic dynamics are quantified by calculating two-time correlation functions, C(q, t1, t2), defined as C(q, t1, t2) = ⟨δI(q, t1)δI(q, t2)⟩q ⟨I(q,t1)⟩q⟨I(q,t2)⟩q. Autocorrelation functions, g(2), are calculated from C(q, t1, t2) at a fixed average sample age, t¯ (Methods). p. 2 The autocorrelation functions of the colloidal and liquid phases decay faster at higher q and decay more slowly in the liquid phase than the colloidal phase. p. 2

Extraction of Transport Properties

The decorrelation rate associated with unperturbed NC dynamics is obtained by fitting an exponential model, g(2)(q, τ,t¯) = 1 + β(q) exp[−2Γ(q,t¯)τ] (curves in Figure 3b), to the autocorrelation functions and obtaining Γ(q, t¯). The decorrelation rates are extrapolated to t¯ → 0 to obtain the rate associated with unperturbed NC dynamics. p. 2 These rates are compared against static structure factors, Sc(q) and Sl(q), which describe the spatial arrangement of NCs in the colloidal and liquid phases. p. 2

Interparticle Interaction Characterization

The effective diffusivities are related to hydrodynamic functions, Hi(q), via Di eff(q) = D0Hi(q)/Si(q). The analysis reveals that for colloidal-phase NCs, Hc(q) ∼ 1 at all q, indicating that Dc s/D0 = 1. p. 3 For liquid-phase NCs, the ratio Dl s/D0 is found to be 0. p. 323 when using the δγ-method and 0. p. 318 from Brownian dynamics simulations. p. 3 These values are below those expected for hard spheres and charged spheres, suggesting explicit attractive interactions are predominantly responsible for the suppressed Dl s/D0. p. 1

Conclusion on Interactions

The findings suggest that nanoscale interparticle interactions likely possess long-range attractive tails that are absent in microscale particles. This provides a strategy to tune interparticle interactions to avoid or enhance gelation during self-assembly of nanoscale and microscale systems. p. 4 The work paves the way to more generally elucidating microscopic dynamics and interactions in a wide range of complex fluids. p. 4

Acknowledgments

We thank A. Omar and E. p. 4 Weiner for discussions. p. 4 This work was supported by the Office of Basic Energy Sciences (BES), US Department of Energy (DOE) (award DE-SC0019375). p. 4 We acknowledge the European XFEL in Schenefeld, Germany, for provision of XFEL beamtime at Scientific Instrument MID (Materials Imaging and Dynamics) under proposal 3049. p. 4 C.P.N.T. and V.R.K.W. were supported by the NSF Graduate Research Fellowship <ref:2404. p. 417756#pg6>. J.K.U was supported by an Arnold O'Beckman Postdoctoral Fellowship in Chemical Sciences <ref:2404.17756#pg6>. D.T.L was supported by an Alfred P. p. 4 Sloan Research Fellowship <ref:2404. p. 417756#pg6>. N.S.G was supported by a David and Lucile Packard Foundation Fellowship for Science and Engineering and Camille and a Henry Dreyfus Teacher-Scholar Award <ref:2404. p. 417756#pg6>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. AI systems can be improved by developing predictive models for non-equilibrium responses to perturbations based on microscopic equilibrium fluctuations, as Equilibrium fluctuations of a system’s microscopic parameters encode its nonequilibrium response to perturbations [1]. This allows AI to directly control dynamical system properties by manipulating these microscopic fluctuations.

  2. The improved AI can accurately predict the self-diffusion coefficients of nanoscale constituents in complex fluids, specifically finding that the self-diffusion of NCs in the liquid phase is suppressed relative to that of hard spheres [8] and charged spheres [8] at the same volume fraction.

  3. AI systems can be refined to model interparticle potentials for complex fluids by extracting interaction strengths from experimental data, such as finding a 2 kBT attractive interaction explains the stability of this liquid phase, which is crucial for understanding why NCs avoid kinetic arrest or gelation.

  4. The system can perform transfer learning on nanoscale dynamics by using the derived transport properties to design microscopic strategies to avert gelation in other complex fluids, such as densely packed proteins and non-equilibrium self-assembly processes.

  5. AI models can be enhanced to distinguish intrinsic dynamics from experimental artifacts by analyzing correlation functions, ensuring that the extracted decorrelation rates (Figure 3c) are not due to NCs exiting the X-ray probe volume via convection or evaporation.

Sources

Related papers