Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator develops a method to use the Wigner distribution (WD) description of the nuclear initial state of specific nuclei for quasielastic scattering in the NuWro Monte Carlo event generator.
Kai: This approach introduces a correlation between position and momentum that can be measured experimentally and is relevant for future neutrino oscillation experiments.
Mira: The WD is a quantum counterpart of a classical phase-space distribution, allowing one to calculate expectation values of operators that are sums of position and momentum dependent operators.
Kai: In finite nuclear systems, the WD features quantum effects and shell structure, unlike the classical probability distributions derived from Fermi gas models.
Paper summary: Kai: To get into specifics, the paper explains that the Wigner distribution is a quantum version of a classical phase space distribution that lets you calculate expectation values for operators involving both position and momentum.
Mira: The key part they focus on is how finite nucleus Wigner distributions have quantum effects and shell structure, which is something classical Fermi gas models miss entirely.
Kai: They introduce two algorithms to handle the problem of negative values in these Wigner distributions, because you can't just sample a distribution that has negative regions directly.
Lev: So they have to do something clever with those negative parts, either by adding them as negative event weights or by making an approximate non-negative phase-space distribution for unweighted events.
Mira: The authors show that both of these approaches lead to very similar results, and crucially, the inclusive cross section is guaranteed to be non-negative and equivalent to what you get from the plane-wave impulse approximation.
Kai: They also explain how they implement this in NuWro by sampling the shell, branch, radial position, and momentum magnitude according to specific probability distributions in a weighted mode.
Lev: And they mention that the binding energy is evaluated using an equation that depends on a removal energy defined as the binding energy minus the total time multiplied by tau.
Mira: The paper also compares their Wigner distribution predictions with experimental data, showing that when you integrate over position, they reduce to the plane-wave impulse approximation.
Kai: But the novel feature they highlight is that they introduce a non-trivial correlation between the initial nucleon momentum and its position, which is what makes this approach interesting for future experiments.
Conclusion: Mira: Looking at the paper "Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator," the authors are demonstrating that using Wigner distributions lets you model the nuclear initial state with position and momentum correlations.
Kai: The authors claim that this correlation is something that can be measured experimentally, which is a big deal because it's not what standard Fermi gas models predict.
Lev: From an engineering view, if you were to run this on real hardware, the overhead of incorporating these Wigner effects needs to be accounted for in your error correction scheme.
Mira: The implication is that if we want to understand neutrino interactions better, especially in experiments looking at oscillation effects, we need a description of the nuclear initial state that includes this spatial momentum correlation.
Kai: So it boils down to using the Wigner distribution as a phase-space density for occupied states directly usable in Pauli blocking recipes, which is something they suggest.
Lev: That direct usability for Pauli blocking is important because it makes the model more consistent with how nucleons actually behave inside the nucleus.
Rwik Dharmapal Banerjee, *Alexis Nikolakopoulos, †Jan T. Sobczyk, Hemant Prasad, Krzysztof M. Graczyk, §Josǩ L. Bonilla, Beata E. Kowal
Institute of Theoretical Physics, University of Wroc law · Department of Physics, University of Washington
nucl-th
Submitted: 2026-11-05
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 19 pages, 8 figures
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 87/100
The gist: Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator develops a method to use the Wigner distribution (WD) description of the nuclear initial state of specific nuclei…
Key concepts
- Wigner Distribution (WD)
- The WD is a quantum description of nuclear states that acts like a classical phase-space distribution. Unlike simpler models, it accounts for quantum effects and shell structure in finite nuclei by using the one-body density matrix to describe coordinate and momentum space densities.
- Position-Momentum Correlation
- The WD framework introduces a joint description linking where a nucleon is located (position) with its momentum. This correlation is a novel feature that can be measured experimentally and provides deeper insight into the initial nuclear state than simpler models.
- Negative Value Treatment
- To use the WD as a phase-space density, methods were developed to handle its negative values. Two algorithms were implemented: one samples positive and negative branches of the signed WD, while another creates an approximate non-negative distribution for unweighted event generation.
Terminology
Summary
Wigner distribution modeling of nuclear state in NuWro Monte Carlo event generator develops a method to use the Wigner distribution (WD) description of the nuclear initial state of specific nuclei for quasielastic scattering in the NuWro Monte Carlo event generator. p. 0 This approach introduces a correlation between position and momentum that can be measured experimentally and is relevant for future neutrino oscillation experiments. p. 0
Introduction to the Wigner Distribution
The WD is a quantum counterpart of a classical phase-space distribution, allowing one to calculate expectation values of operators that are sums of position and momentum dependent operators. In finite nuclear systems, the WD features quantum effects and shell structure, unlike the classical probability distributions derived from Fermi gas models. p. 0 The WD is defined using the one-body density matrix and is normalized such that it relates to coordinate- and momentum-space number densities. p. 1
Treatment of Negative Values
To incorporate the WD as a phase-space density, methods are proposed to deal with its negative values, which cannot be sampled directly. Two algorithms are implemented in NuWro: the first retains the signed, angle-averaged WD by sampling its positive and negative branches. p. 1 The second constructs an approximate non-negative phase-space distribution for unweighted event generation. p. 1 Both approaches lead to very similar results, guaranteeing that the inclusive cross section is nonnegative and equivalent to the plane-wave impulse approximation (PWIA). p. 1
Implementation in NuWro
The WD framework is implemented in NuWro to introduce a joint description of the position and momentum of the struck nucleon. In the weighted mode, events are generated by sampling the shell, branch, radial position, and momentum magnitude according to specific probability distributions. p. 6 The binding energy is evaluated from Eq. p. 5 (36), which depends on the removal energy defined as Erem = B - Tτ. p. 6
Comparison with Experimental Data
The WD predictions, when integrated over position, reduce to the PWIA cross section, and the novel feature is the introduction of a non-trivial correlation between initial nucleon momentum p and position r. The sensitivity to position–momentum correlations is quantified by comparing original shell-resolved WD with factorized constructions, showing that removing shell dependence changes the heights of the shell peaks by 7–10% in the missing-energy distribution measured by JSNS2. p. 8
Conclusion and Extensions
The work demonstrates that position-momentum correlations affect final-state interactions (FSI) modeled using the INC, as quantified in the missing-energy distribution. The shell dependence of the interaction point is shown to be a dominant effect, while intra-shell r–p correlation is a smaller effect confined to the 1p3/2 peak region. p. 9 Extensions include including spectroscopic factors and broadened removal-energy distributions without changing the radial sampling. The WD offers a phase-space description of occupied states directly usable for a consistent Pauli blocking recipe. p. 4
Appendix A: Shell Separation Energies
Table A1 collects the shell-dependent occupation numbers Nτ and separation energies Sτ used in the WD implementation. The table shows specific values for different nuclei like 40Ar and 56Fe. p. 0
Appendix B: Monte Carlo Implementation
The weighted mode retains the original signed WD by sampling its positive and negative components separately, while the unweighted mode constructs a non-negative coarse-grained distribution to preserve momentum marginals. The coarse-graining procedure preserves the integrated strength of each original WD slice, although it introduces a distortion to the radial density.
Table B2: Differential Cross Section in Q2
Figure B2 compares the differential cross section in Q2 for 500 MeV νµ scattering on 40Ar between the signed WD (weighted-event mode) and the coarse-grained distribution (unweighted-event mode). The results show nearly identical Q2 distributions within statistical fluctuation levels. p. 7
Table III: Comparison of Wigner Descriptions
Table III summarizes the mean radii and momenta for the three WD descriptions (CORR, shell-FACT, totR-FACT) used to test sensitivity to position–momentum correlations. The comparison shows that while overall fractions of QE events without rescattering differ by less than 2%, the shape of the Em distribution is sensitive to which nucleons rescatter.
Table I: Integrated Negative Fractions and Mean Radii
Table I summarizes integrated negative fractions fτ− and mean radial positions ⟨r⟩τ for the nuclei considered in this work. The negative fraction increases with nuclear mass, reflecting the increasingly oscillatory phase-space structure of the shell-resolved WDs in heavier nuclei. p. 4
Table A3: Comparison of Three Wigner Descriptions
Table A3 compares the mean radii and momenta for 1p3/2 and 1s1/2 shells across CORR, shell-FACT, and totR-FACT descriptions. The former should persist with a more realistic energy smearing and reduced occupations. p. 8 p. 8 p. 8 p. 8
Table B3: Comparison of the Three Wigner Descriptions for JSNS2 Missing-Energy Distribution
Table B3 summarizes the mean radii and momenta for the three Wigner descriptions when tested against recent JSNS2 measurements. The results show that counting the recoil energy of the residual nucleus changes the shape of the Em distribution considerably. p. 9 p. 9
Table II: WD Descriptions Used to Test Sensitivity to Position–Momentum Correlations
Table II lists the three Wigner descriptions used to test sensitivity to position–momentum correlations, detailing what information is retained in each description. The CORR description retains the full shell-dependent r–p structure. p. 8
Table B4: Normalized L1 Distances of Pτ(r) Induced by the Shell-Resolved Coarse-Grained Construction
Table B4 shows the normalized L1 distances of Pτ(r) induced by the shell-resolved coarse-grained construction for different targets. The induced distortion of the radial marginal is approximately 3% for 12C and 16O and increases to about 7% for 40Ar and 56Fe. p. 2 p. 2
Table B5: Total Positive and Negative Strengths
Table B5 defines the total positive and negative strengths N±τ based on the sampled branches of the WD. The negative fraction fτ− is listed in Table I. p. 3
Table III: Comparison of the Three Wigner Descriptions for JSNS2 Missing-Energy Distribution
Table III compares the mean radii and momenta for the three Wigner descriptions used to test sensitivity to position–momentum correlations. The former should persist with a more realistic energy smearing and reduced occupations.
Table B25: Coarse-Grained Distribution
Table B25 shows the resulting coarse-grained distribution wCGτ(r, p) = ητ(p) weCGτ(r, p) after rescaling. The coarse-graining procedure reproduces the original shell momentum distribution exactly. p. 6
Table B35: Momentum Marginal Preservation
Table B35 shows that for the unweighted mode, the integrated strength of each coarse-grained shell is equal to the strength of its corresponding original WD. This is because N CGτ = N SIGNτ. p. 1
Table B36: Shell Labeling in Unweighted Mode
Table B36 shows that for the unweighted mode, neither s nor Cτ is required because the coarse-grained distribution is used. The resulting distribution is non-negative by construction and reproduces the original shell momentum distribution exactly. p. 6
Table B32: Sampling in Unweighted Mode
Table B32 describes the sampling procedure in the unweighted mode, where the shell is selected according to its strength P(α τ). The momentum magnitude is then sampled from a conditional distribution at that radius P(p r). p. 6
Table B33: Sampling Radial Position
Table B33 describes how the interaction point is sampled from the radial marginal P CGτ(r). The momentum magnitude is subsequently sampled at the selected radius P CGτ(p r). p. 6
Table B34: Sampling Momentum Magnitude
Table B34 describes how the momentum magnitude is sampled at a given radius P CGτ(p r). This step is performed after selecting the shell and sampling the radial position. p. 6
Table B38: Radial Distortion Quantification
Table B38 defines the normalized L1 distance dτr as a measure of radial distortion between P CGτ(r) and P ORIGτ(r). The induced distortion of the radial marginal is approximately 3% for 12C and 16O and increases to about 7% for 40Ar and 56Fe.
Table A3: Comparison of Three Wigner Descriptions for JSNS2 Missing-Energy Distribution
Table A3 compares the mean radii and momenta for 1p3/2 and 1s1/2 shells across CORR, shell-FACT, and totR-FACT descriptions. The former should persist with a more realistic energy smearing and reduced occupations.
Table B33: Comparison of the Three Wigner Descriptions for the JSNS2 Missing-Energy Distribution
Table B33 compares the mean radii and momenta for the three Wigner descriptions when tested against recent JSNS2 measurements. The results show that counting the recoil energy of the residual nucleus changes the shape of the Em distribution considerably.
Table B34: Comparison of Three Wigner Descriptions for JSNS2 Missing-Energy Distribution
Table B34 compares the mean radii and momenta for 1p3/2 and 1s1/2 shells across CORR, shell-FACT, and totR-FACT descriptions. The former should persist with a more realistic energy smearing and reduced occupations.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can model nuclear initial states using Wigner distributions to provide a joint description of position and momentum of bound nucleons, which is different from standard Fermi gas models. This allows for effects that can be measured experimentally and may be relevant for future neutrino oscillation experiments.
-
Improved AI can handle the problem of negative values in Wigner distributions by implementing two algorithms: retaining the signed, angle-averaged WD by sampling positive and negative branches, or constructing an approximate non-negative phase space distribution. This ensures the inclusive cross section is guaranteed to be nonnegative, equivalent to plane-wave impulse approximation (PWIA).
-
Improved AI can incorporate a unique correlation between position and momentum at which nucleons are introduced in the intranuclear cascade (INC) by using the shell-resolved WD, rather than just a radial distribution function associated with the hole-state. This correlation affects final-state interactions (FSI) and the implication for JSNS2 data will be quantified.
-
Improved AI can calculate removal energy using equations derived from energy conservation for off-shell nucleons, such as Erem = S tau + TA minus 1, which explicitly retains information on the shell from which the nucleon is removed. This contrasts with standard GFG where binding energy B is treated as a constant and LFG where it involves an effective mean-field potential.
-
Improved AI can analyze sensitivity to position-momentum correlations by comparing three factorized constructions of Wigner distributions: CORR, shell FACT, and totRFACT. This comparison demonstrates that the shell dependence of the interaction point is the dominant effect on missing energy distribution, which can be quantified by observing how removing this dependence changes peak heights by 7% to 10%.
-
Improved AI can perform unweighted event generation by constructing a non-negative coarse-grained distribution that absorbs negative strength into adjacent positive strength, while preserving the relevant momentum marginals exactly. This coarse-graining procedure is shown to reproduce the prediction obtained by the original signed WD at the cross section level for 40Ar.
Sources
- Hyper-Kamiokande Design Report
- Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), Far Detector Technical Design Report, Volume I: Introduction to DUNE
- Final State Interactions Effects in Neutrino-Nucleus Interactions
- Nuclear Transparency in Monte Carlo Neutrino Event Generators
- The NEUT Neutrino Interaction Simulation
- Neutrino Interactions with Nucleons and Nuclei: Importance for Long-Baseline Experiments
- Tomography of Atomic Nuclei
- Coordinate-space solution of the Skyrme-Hartree-Fock-Bogolyubov equations within spherical symmetry. The program HFBRAD (v1.0)
- Simulations from a new neutrino event generator
- ACHILLES: A novel event generator for electron- and neutrino-nucleus scattering
- Neutrino event generators: foundation, status and future
- Spectrum of outgoing nucleons in quasielastic neutrino-nucleus interactions
- JLab spectral functions of argon in NuWro and their implications for MicroBooNE
- Spectral function approach in NuWro: modeling of multinucleon final states in quasielastic scattering
- Running Nuwro
- From eV to EeV: Neutrino Cross Sections Across Energy Scales
- An archive for quasi-elastic electron-nucleus scattering data
- Neutrino-nucleus cross section within the extended factorization scheme
- Lepton-Nucleus Interactions within Microscopic Approaches
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations