The Start Time of Ringdown

arXiv:2611.05472 · gr-qc, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.HE, hep-th · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The Start Time of Ringdown".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper determines the convergence of quasi-normal modes sums for a point-particle plunging into a Schwarzschild black hole and relates this convergence to properties of the particle’s trajectory The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: While a dynamical amplitude model reproduces the waveform after the particle crosses the bounce radius, a constant amplitude sum converges only after the start time tS, which corresponds to the advanced time at which the particle hits the central singularity Ringdown Modeling and Start Time Prediction The analysis focuses on determining when a constant amplitude sum of quasi-normal modes converges for a point-particle plunging into a nonrotating black hole.

Kai: The authors predict that this start time tS is related to the particle's trajectory, stating that for a plunge from the ISCO, tS ≃ 9.4M after the peak of the 22 mode.

Mira: After this time, dynamical and constant amplitudes models become equivalent, implying any “direct wave” must reduce to the late-time tail after tS.

Kai: Dynamical QNM Decomposition The GW strain is decomposed into multipoles hlm proportional to a master function Ψ of Zerilli type for even l + m and of Regge–Wheeler type for odd l + m.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today called "The Start Time of Ringdown". It’s about a point particle plunging into a black hole, and the main thing they’re pinning down is exactly when you can start summing up those quasi-normal modes.

Mira: Right. It sounds like they are trying to figure out that threshold for when the mathematical models we use for black hole ringing actually start matching what’s physically happening in the actual signal.

Lev: I mean, from an engineering standpoint, if you can predict when a sum converges, it tells us how much data you need to collect before you get a reliable answer.

Kai: Exactly. They look at the different ways we model the gravitational wave signal and see where they start behaving similarly in time.

Mira: It really zeroes in on this specific time point, which they call tS, and connects it directly to where the particle actually hits the singularity itself in advanced time.

Lev: That connection to advanced time is a big deal because it helps us define when we can trust the signal you are seeing.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what they found is that while a dynamical amplitude model gives you the waveform right after the particle crosses the bounce radius, a constant amplitude sum only starts converging after this specific time tS.

Mira: And they tie that convergence time directly to the advanced time when the particle actually hits the central singularity. That's quite a precise link between trajectory and convergence.

Lev: For someone trying to build an actual detector, knowing that you need to wait until that point tS before you can use a constant amplitude model gives you a clear operational limit on your measurement window.

Kai: They predict this start time tS depends on the particle's orbit; for instance, for a plunge starting from the innermost stable circular orbit, they say it's about nine point four times the mass after the peak of twenty-two modes.

Mira: That prediction is based on relating that start time to where you are in terms of orbital parameters. It shows that the trajectory dictates when those different mathematical descriptions become equivalent.

Lev: It’s interesting because it suggests that before tS, a direct wave might not be a good probe of the black hole's immediate vicinity at all.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest some improvements to how we think about this convergence region. They point out that using a dynamical QNM model is only good up to time uB because it includes the prompt response, but after tS, the constant amplitude sum converges exponentially.

Mira: That exponential decay suggests that once you pass tS, adding more overtones to your constant amplitude model doesn't actually improve accuracy much anymore; it just adds terms suppressed by e to the power of negative imaginary frequency times the time difference from tS.

Lev: If you're building an error correction system, this tells us that after uS, you might be able to simplify your computational load by sticking with a constant amplitude model with only a few overtones.

Kai: And they also found that the residual between the dynamical QNM model and what we actually measure scales as one over N when you truncate the sum, which is good for understanding how well the truncation works.

Mira: They also identified an algebraically special mode, specifically for k equal to eight which means a frequency of minus four i, that shows up in the time domain through a redshift mode.

Lev: So, even if n equals eight isn't one of the standard quasi-normal modes we expect to see from the black hole itself, it still contributes something measurable in our signal.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, the main point of "The Start Time of Ringdown" is that a direct wave should reduce to this late-time tail after time uS, meaning it’s not sensitive to the near-horizon geometry.

Mira: They also showed that this start time uS changes depending on the orbit; for a plunge from infinity, uS is about zero point eight times the mass after the bounce radius.

Lev: From an error correction view, this gives us a concrete time scale for when our simplified models become reliable and when we can switch to simpler versions of the model without losing accuracy.

Kai: This paper provides a clearer picture for interpreting gravitational waves by telling us exactly where the transition happens between different modeling regimes.

Mira: It suggests that focusing on that late-time tail after uS is the physically relevant part of the signal when studying ringdown, not trying to probe things right at the horizon.

Lev: I just think having this specific time scale helps ground all our simulations in a way that makes sense for actual hardware testing.

Adrien Kuntz

CENTRA · Department of Fisica · Instituto Superior Tecnico – IST · Universidade de Lisboa

gr-qc, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.HE, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Code: https://github.com/akuntz00/QNM-amplitudes-ISCO-Schwarzschild

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: The paper determines the convergence of quasi-normal modes sums for a point-particle plunging into a Schwarzschild black hole and relates this convergence to properties of the particle’s trajectory…

Key concepts

Quasi-Normal Modes (QNMs)
These are characteristic ringing frequencies of a black hole after a disturbance. The paper decomposes the gravitational wave strain into these modes to analyze how the signal evolves over time. They are essential for understanding how spacetime settles down around a black hole.
Ringdown Start Time (tS)
This is the specific time point after which summing constant amplitude QNM contributions converges. It is predicted to be related to the particle's trajectory, specifically calculated as tS ≃ uB + 3.37M for an ISCO plunge, marking a reliable window for constant amplitude modeling.
Dynamical vs. Constant Amplitude Models
Dynamical models use time-dependent amplitudes that capture the initial prompt response of the system. Constant amplitude models assume steady QNM amplitudes, which only converge after tS. This means that after tS, both models yield the same result, suggesting a direct wave signal is just the late-time tail.
Algebraically Special Mode
This refers to a specific frequency (k=8) that appears in the time-domain signal even if it is not a standard QNM. It manifests as a redshift mode, contributing significantly to the residual error between dynamical models and numerical waveforms before tS.

Terminology

Summary

The paper determines the convergence of quasi-normal modes sums for a point-particle plunging into a Schwarzschild black hole and relates this convergence to properties of the particle’s trajectory

The single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: While a dynamical amplitude model reproduces the waveform after the particle crosses the bounce radius, a constant amplitude sum converges only after the start time tS, which corresponds to the advanced time at which the particle hits the central singularity

Ringdown Modeling and Start Time Prediction

The analysis focuses on determining when a constant amplitude sum of quasi-normal modes converges for a point-particle plunging into a nonrotating black hole. The authors predict that this start time tS is related to the particle's trajectory, stating that for a plunge from the ISCO, tS ≃ 9.4M after the peak of the 22 mode. p. 0 After this time, dynamical and constant amplitudes models become equivalent, implying any “direct wave” must reduce to the late-time tail after tS. p. 0

Dynamical QNM Decomposition

The GW strain is decomposed into multipoles hlm proportional to a master function Ψ of Zerilli type for even l + m and of Regge–Wheeler type for odd l + m. The dynamical QNM amplitudes Cn(u) are obtained by convolving the Green function with the source, defined by an integral over the past light-cone depending on whether u uB. p. 1 For u > uB, Cn(u) is given by an expression involving F u and G u evaluated along the trajectory. p. 0

Regularization of Late-Time Behavior

To extract a physical constant QNM amplitude at late times where the sum might diverge, a regularization procedure is necessary. This involves expanding the integrand in terms of Kruskal coordinate U, which converges for u > uS, the ringdown start time. p. 1 The regularized constant QNM amplitude C˜n is defined by throwing away the upper bound of an integral in Eq. p. 1 (10).

Convergence and Physical Interpretation

The dynamical QNM model converges to the full waveform only for u > uB because earlier times include prompt response. The constant-amplitude sum diverges before uS but converges exponentially after it, with each overtone suppressed by e−Im ωn(u−uS). p. 3 This suggests that a constant amplitude model with few overtones should be more accurate a few M after uS. p. 3 The results imply that the direct wave should reduce to the late-time tail after uS, meaning it is not a probe of near-horizon geometry. p. 3

Algebraically Special Mode Contribution

The residual between the dynamical QNM model and the numerical waveform is completely given by the branch-cut integral and a dynamical QNM mode at an algebraically special frequency. Specifically, for k = 8, which corresponds to ω = −4i, this algebraically special mode appears in the time-domain signal through a redshift mode. p. 8 This contribution is explicitly shown in Eq. p. 8 (S12).

Orbit Dependence of Start Time

The start time uS depends on the orbit parameters, as shown by Eq. (12). For an ISCO plunge, the result is uS ≃ uB + 3. p. 237M ≃ upeak + 9. p. 04M, which is comparable with results from Ref. p. 3 [8] and to times where constant amplitude fits are reliable. p. 3 For a radial infall from infinity, uS ≃ uB + 0. p. 387M.

Supplemental Details on Orbits and Modes

The supplemental material provides explicit expressions for the point-particle orbits and the source term of Regge-Wheeler and Zerilli equations in the θ = π/2 plane. It details the numerical procedure for computing QNM frequencies, mode functions, and excitation coefficients. p. 6 The analysis shows that even if the start time seems to depend on interior geometry, it is fixed by the analytic continuation of the exterior trajectory. p. 3

Figure Analysis of Residuals

The figures illustrate how the residual of the dynamical QNM sum after truncation scales as 1/N. The residual between the dynamical QNM model and numerical waveform for u > uB can be attributed to the late-time tail. p. 2 The algebraically special mode is responsible for a somewhat large residual between the dynamical QNM model alone and the waveform at times uB ≤ u ≤ uS. p. 9 The 21 mode, being odd, does not contain GAS and its residual should stay small as soon as u ≥ uB. p. 9

Branch Cut Contribution

The branch cut integral contributes to the Green function for the Zerilli equation when closing the contour in the lower half-plane for u ≥ t′ + x′. This contribution is evaluated by switching on source functions F, G at times −600M < t < −400M with a technique used in Sec. p. 8 S1. The residual of the dynamical QNM model with the Zerilli mode and the cut is at the level of the error of the time-domain waveform, validating their numerical procedure. p. 8

Conclusion on Direct Wave Interpretation

The results make it clear that a direct wave should reduce to the late-time tail after uS, and is therefore not a probe of near-horizon geometry. The authors believe the picture developed in this Letter is clear enough to bypass the use of any filter regarding the physical interpretation of the signal. p. 3 The results hold for non-rotating BHs, and similar physics should extend to rotating cases. p. 3

Acknowledgments

The author thanks Marina de Amicis, Adam Pound and Ling Sun for discussions. Financial support was provided by FCT, Portugal through various grants. p. 3 The author also used Claude (Anthropic, Claude Opus 5. p. 35, via Claude Code) to carry out and check symbolic and numerical calculations. p. 3 All derivations, numerical results and statements were reviewed and verified by the author. p. 3

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Precision in Ringdown Start Time Prediction: The improved system can accurately predict ringdown start times for a point-particle plunging into a Schwarzschild black hole by calculating uS using Eq (12), relating it directly to orbit parameters, such as the ISCO plunge result of uS ≃ uB + 3.37M.

  2. Convergence Rate Quantification: The system can determine the rate of convergence for QNM sums by analyzing how dynamical and constant amplitude models converge, noting that constant-amplitude models converge much faster than dynamical QNMs after uS.

  3. Direct Wave Characterization: The AI can classify signals as a direct wave by determining if they reduce to the late-time tail after uS, which is derived from the branch-cut contribution to Eq (4), thus providing a physical interpretation independent of filtering.

  4. Algebraic Special Mode Identification: The system can detect and isolate the behavior of the algebraically special frequency k = 8, noting that even if n = 8 is not a QNM frequency, it appears in the time-domain signal through a redshift mode.

  5. Waveform Residual Analysis: The improved system can quantify model accuracy by calculating residuals using both dynamical QNM models and constant amplitude models, identifying that the residual between the constant-amplitude sum and the numerical waveform visible in Fig. 1(c) is also given by the late-time tail.

Sources

Related papers