Elliptic and triangular flow responses in O+O and Ne+Ne collisions from hydrodynamics and kinetic theory

arXiv:2611.05239 · nucl-th, hep-ph, nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Elliptic and triangular flow responses in O+O and Ne+Ne collisions from hydrodynamics and kinetic theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Recent light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider provide an opportunity to investigate the system-size dependence of hydrodynamization and whether the structure of light nuclei can be extracted from collective flow data Both objectives require an accurate understanding of how the collision dynamics converts initial-state geometry into final-state momentum anisotropies.

Kai: In both ultracentral and peripheral collisions, Ne+Ne-to-O+O elliptic flow ratios are robust against changes in dynamical description, supporting interpretations of data based on nuclear-geometry-driven effects.

Mira: Triangular-flow ratios instead show substantially stronger sensitivity to nonequilibrium dynamics.

Kai: Theoretical Frameworks The study compares simulations of O+O and Ne+Ne collisions in hydrodynamic and kinetic theory simulations across opacities.

Title and authors: Mira: To get into the specifics of "Elliptic and triangular flow responses in O+O and Ne+Ne collisions from hydrodynamics and kinetic theory," the paper is essentially comparing what happens when you use viscous hydrodynamics versus kinetic theory simulations for neon-neon and oxygen-oxygen collisions. They want to see which description better predicts the data we get from these systems.

Kai: It’s interesting because they aren't just looking at one thing, like just the standard elliptic flow, but they are also introducing a proxy for triangular flow so they can test that description too. This is a way of checking if hydrodynamics is a good stand-in for the more detailed kinetic theory calculations on these specific systems.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that comparison is key because it tells you where the approximations in the hydrodynamic model are breaking down when you try to predict something like triangular flow. It shows us the limits of using that simpler description for complex dynamics.

Mira: They also look at how nuclear structure, like the deformation of neon or oxygen, affects these flow results, which is a big part of their goal to see if they can use these ratios between systems like Ne+Ne and O+O to pin down the nuclear properties.

Kai: So it’s about using those flow ratios as a way to probe the structure without needing super complex simulations for every single event. It connects the initial geometry, which is dictated by nuclear structure, all the way to how fast things expand in real collisions.

The paper's summary: Kai: The paper summarizes that they are quantifying exactly how much hydrodynamics acts as a good proxy for full kinetic theory calculations when we look at the absolute values of flow coefficients, and also when we look at ratios between different light-ion systems.

Mira: And they found that the elliptic flow responses are tracked correctly by the hydrodynamic proxies, which is encouraging because it means our standard hydrodynamic tools are still doing a decent job there. But for triangular flow, they found something different: the proxy requires a linearization around equilibrium, and that approximation starts to fail when the interaction strength parameter gamma hat gets larger.

Lev: That failure point with gamma hat is what we need to watch out for in real experiments or simulations; it means that as the system gets denser and more interacting, our simplified hydrodynamic model won't accurately capture those non-equilibrium effects.

Kai: They also looked at the initial conditions generated by TRENTo and how nuclear structure inputs, like the prolate deformation of twenty neon or octupole deformation of sixteen oxygen, influence the subsequent dynamics in their simulations <ref:2611.05239#pg3>.

Mira: And they concluded that for ultracentral collisions, where you have a lot of system size, ratios of flow coefficients mostly cancel out those common initial-state features and uncertainties. This makes the results cleaner for constraining nuclear structure effects on neon and oxygen.

The paper's improvements: Lev: One improvement they suggest is using derived proxies like epsilon p for elliptic flow and epsilon p,three for triangular flow to bypass the need to rely solely on particle-based simulations when trying to compare kinetic theory and hydrodynamics <ref:2611.05239#pg1>. It gives a way to bridge that gap more directly.

Kai: That makes sense from a computational side; it’s about creating better metrics that tell us which description is working where, instead of just comparing raw flow numbers which can be messy. It’s like finding a better calibration standard for the two theories.

Mira: Another crucial point they raise is distinguishing between the dynamical descriptions by analyzing how those flow response ratios change against the opacity parameter gamma hat. They noted that triangular flow responses decrease in strength faster with decreasing opacity, and that the differences between kinetic theory and hydrodynamics already appear when you are at higher opacities.

Lev: That's a strong statement because it suggests that the limitations of hydrodynamics show up very quickly as the system becomes strongly interacting. It’s a good indicator of where we need more sophisticated models for error correction in real setups.

Kai: They also look at the event-by-event spread in flow responses, and they suggest that this spread isn't just modeling errors but is actually due to a larger effect of fluctuations on the initial state geometry.

Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up, the paper supports using viscous hydrodynamics within Bayesian analyses to precisely constrain nuclear correlations in neon and oxygen from ultracentral flow ratios because they showed the elliptic flow impact of neon deformation can be assessed with little uncertainty on how the dynamics are modeled.

Kai: And that triangular-flow ratio is pointed out as a really promising observable for isolating those specific nuclear-structure effects, especially when we look at larger systems. They suggest that higher harmonics, like quadrangular flow, might give us even more sensitivity to departures from purely hydrodynamic behavior.

Lev: For me, the main point is that the impact of deformation and clustering on this triangular flow ratio is less well understood than it is for the individual oxygen-oxygen value itself. It gives us a clearer focus for future work.

Kai: So, this paper shows us how to use these ratios to test nuclear structure without getting bogged down in needing perfect kinetic theory simulations every single time we want to constrain neon or oxygen properties. It's a solid way forward for our measurements at the collider.

Victor E. Ambrus, Giuliano Giacalone, Clemens Werthmann, Fabian Zhou

Fakultät für Physik, Universität Bielefeld · Department of Physics, West University of Timis-oara · Theoretical Physics Department, CERN · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Ghent University · Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Heidelberg · Instituto Galego de Física de Altas Enerxıas (IGFAE) · European Research Council

nucl-th, hep-ph, nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 15+5 pages, 9+3 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: Recent light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider provide an opportunity to investigate the system-size dependence of hydrodynamization and whether the structure of light nuclei can be…

Key concepts

Hydrodynamic vs. Kinetic Theory
These are two different mathematical frameworks used to model the collision dynamics. Hydrodynamics treats the system as a fluid, while kinetic theory uses the Boltzmann equation to track individual particle interactions. The study compares these methods to see which better describes the flow.
Elliptic Flow Ratios
These ratios compare flow measurements between different light-ion systems (like Ne+Ne and O+O). The paper found these are robust against changes in the dynamical model, suggesting they reliably reflect initial nuclear geometry effects rather than complex collision details.
Triangular Flow Ratios
This specific ratio is highly sensitive to non-equilibrium dynamics. Differences between kinetic theory and hydrodynamics for this ratio appear at higher interaction strengths (opacity), making it a promising observable to isolate dynamical effects.

Terminology

Summary

Recent light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider provide an opportunity to investigate the system-size dependence of hydrodynamization and whether the structure of light nuclei can be extracted from collective flow data Both objectives require an accurate understanding of how the collision dynamics converts initial-state geometry into final-state momentum anisotropies. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Vasile Pˆarvan 4, Timis,oara 300223, Romania 3Theoretical Physics Department, CERN, CH-1211 Gen`eve 23, Switzerland 4Department of Physics and Astronomy, Ghent University, 9000 Ghent, Belgium 5 Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Heidelberg, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany 6 Instituto Galego de F´ısica de Altas Enerx´ıas (IGFAE), Universidade de Santiago de Compostela E-15782 Galicia, Spain (Dated: November 4, 2026) Recent light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider provide an opportunity to investigate the system-size dependence of hydrodynamization and whether the structure of light nuclei can be extracted from collective flow data. Both objectives require an accurate understanding of how the collision dynamics converts initial-state geometry into final-state momentum anisotropies.

In both ultracentral and peripheral collisions, Ne+Ne-to-O+O elliptic flow ratios are robust against changes in dynamical description, supporting interpretations of data based on nuclear-geometry-driven effects. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To this end, and to assess the impact of the experimental results, we compare simulations of O+O and Ne+Ne collisions in hydrodynamic and kinetic theory simulations across opacities. In both ultracentral and peripheral collisions, Ne+Ne-to-O+O elliptic flow ratios are robust against changes in dynamical description, supporting interpretations of data based on nuclear-geometry-driven effects.

Triangular-flow ratios instead show substantially stronger sensitivity to nonequilibrium dynamics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In both ultracentral and peripheral collisions, Ne+Ne-to-O+O elliptic flow ratios are robust against changes in dynamical description, supporting interpretations of data based on nuclear-geometry-driven effects. Triangular-flow ratios instead show substantially stronger sensitivity to nonequilibrium dynamics.

Theoretical Frameworks

The study compares simulations of O+O and Ne+Ne collisions in hydrodynamic and kinetic theory simulations across opacities. The kinetic theory employs the relativistic Boltzmann equation in the Anderson-Witting relaxation-time approximation. p. 1

Where the paper says it

II E we introduce our observables. Kinetic theory For all results from kinetic theory based simulations in this paper, we employ the relativistic Boltzmann equation in the Anderson-Witting relaxation-time approximation [74, 75], p µ ∂µf = CAW = − p µuµ τR (f − feq), (1) where the relaxation time τR is fixed by imposing a constant shear viscosity to entropy density ratio η/s, τR = 5η sT , (2) where η = 4 5 τRP and s = 4P/T for massless particles.

The hydrodynamic setup utilizes the Müller-Israel-Stewart second-order hydrodynamics theory to model the evolution of the shear stress tensor. p. 2
Where the paper says it

To close the system of Eqs. (21), we employ the M¨uller-Israel-Stewart second-order hydrodynamics theory [88, 89], which models the evolution of the shearstress tensor π µν via τπDπ⟨µν⟩ + π µν = 2ησµν + 2τππ ⟨µ λ ω ν⟩λ − δπππ µνθ − τπππ λ⟨µσ ν⟩ λ + ϕ7π ⟨µ α π ν⟩α , (22) where ωµν = 1 2 (∇µuν−∇νuµ) is the vorticity tensor.

The opacity is characterized by a dimensionless parameter called the opacity ˆγ [80] which characterizes roughly how strongly interacting the system is. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This allows us to trade the relaxation time τR, governing the evolution described by the Boltzmann Eq. (1), for a dimensionless parameter called the opacity ˆγ [80], γˆ = 1 5η/s R πa dE0 dη 1/4 , (15) which characterizes roughly how strongly interacting the system is.

Initial State Characterization

The initial energy density is generated using TRENTo to produce event-by-event initial profiles of the energy density. The nuclear structure inputs for oxygen and neon are calculated from the ab initio Projected Generator Coordinate Method (PGCM) [70–73]. p. 0

Where the paper says it

RTA is also employed within the CoMBolt-RTA framework [67, 68], which was recently extended to nonconformal systems [69]. Regarding nuclear structure, we use oxygen and neon inputs calculated in [62] from the ab initio Projected Generator Coordinate Method (PGCM) [70–73].

The study investigates how nuclear properties, such as the prolate deformation of 20Ne or the octupole deformation of 16O, influence the subsequent dynamics. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Regarding nuclear structure, we use oxygen and neon inputs calculated in [62] from the ab initio Projected Generator Coordinate Method (PGCM) [70–73]. They allow us to investigate how nuclear properties, such as the prolate deformation of 20Ne or the octupole deformation of 16O, encoding possible α-clustering effects, influence the subsequent dynamics.

Flow Response Analysis

The analysis quantifies to which extent hydrodynamics is an appropriate proxy for full kinetic theory calculations on both absolute magnitudes of flow coefficients and on ratios taken between light-ion systems. The comparison shows that elliptic flow responses are tracked correctly by hydrodynamic proxies, while the triangular flow proxy requires a linearization around equilibrium which degrades for larger η/s. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In this case, no difference is visible between the two definitions. The proxy for triangular flow is defined based on a linearization around equilibrium, which thus degrades for larger η/s, and is not a good assumption at early times, as the plot also shows.

The final state observables are extracted at time τ = 3R where their evolution has generally plateaued due to system cooling down and interaction rates dropping off. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In particular, it is not zero when f is time-evolved according to free-streaming. We extract all final state observables at time τ = 3R, where their evolution has generally plateaued [63, 79] due to the system cooling down and interaction rates dropping off.

Nuclear Structure and Nonequilibrium Dynamics

The study assesses the robustness of the signals of the deformation of in particular 20Ne on the flow results, trying to establish whether a hydrodynamic framework would be appropriate for the inference of correlation properties of light ions from O+O and Ne+Ne data. For ultracentral collisions, ratios of flow coefficients largely cancel common initial-state features, flow responses, and associated uncertainties. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Flow ratios: nuclear structure and nonequilibrium dynamics We now assess the robustness of the signals of the deformation of in particular 20Ne on the flow results, trying to establish whether a hydrodynamic framework would be appropriate for the inference of correlation properties of light ions from O+O and Ne+Ne data. For this purpose, we focus first on ultracentral collisions with nearfull nuclear overlap, which are the most impacted by nuclear shapes, and consider ratios of flow coefficients taken between the two collision systems, as they largely cancel common initial-state features, flow responses, and associated uncertainties [62].

The triangular-flow ratios predicted by kinetic theory and hydrodynamics differ by about 2% at the phenomenologically relevant η/s. p. 9
Where the paper says it

A similar pattern emerges in the right panel of Fig. At the phenomenologically relevant η/s, however, the triangular-flow ratios predicted by kinetic theory and hydrodynamics differ by about 2%, a significant difference given the precision of the experimental measurements.

Conclusion and Outlook

The results support the use of viscous hydrodynamics in Bayesian analyses aimed at precisely constraining nuclear correlations in 20Ne and 16O from ultracentral flow ratios. The triangular-flow ratio is a promising observable for isolating nuclear-structure effects. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The octupole (or tetrahedral) deformation of oxygen is expected to modify the rms triangular flow by approximately 10% [113], comparable to the difference in absolute triangular-flow responses between the two frameworks shown in Fig. The smaller dynamical dependence of the neon-to-oxygen ratio thus makes it a promising observable for isolating nuclear-structure ef-

Future work suggests that higher harmonics such as quadrangular flow may provide even greater sensitivity to departures from hydrodynamic behavior. p. 7
Where the paper says it

This confirms the well-known feature that higher order harmonic flow is more sensitive to viscous effects [104–107], and therefore also more sensitive to the deviation from hydrodynamic behavior. One point worth mentioning is that, compared to our earlier work, while we observed in these new results a smooth transition of the flow response from an opacitylinear limit to a saturation in the ideal hydrodynamic limit at large opacities, the flow responses in different centrality classes no longer collapse onto the same curve.

The study concludes that the impact of deformation and clustering on this ratio is less well-understood than on the individual O+O value. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Characterizing the matter produced in these small systems has thus emerged as one of the central goals of high-energy nuclear physics and the study of out-ofequilibrium QCD matter [13]. In parallel, the possibility of probing the initial states has also received a lot of attention in recent years [14], as they encode information on the spatial structure of the collided nuclei, opening a new experimental window onto low-energy nuclear structure and correlations [15–24], and associated phenomena such as deformation [25–35] and clustering [36–40].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform precise comparison between hydrodynamic and kinetic theory results by using derived proxies like epsilon p for elliptic flow and epsilon p,3 for triangular flow to circumvent ambiguities in particle-based simulations.

  2. The improved system can accurately assess the impact of nuclear structure deformation, such as the prolate deformation of Neon or octupole deformation of Oxygen, on final state observables by utilizing ratios between collision systems like Ne+Ne and O+O.

  3. The AI can distinguish between dynamical descriptions by analyzing flow response ratios against opacity, noting that Triangular flow responses decrease in strength faster with decreasing opacity and that differences between kinetic theory and hydrodynamics appear already at higher opacities.

  4. The system can identify the role of nonlinear couplings by examining the event-by-event spread in flow responses, concluding that this spread is due to larger effect of fluctuations on the initial state geometry rather than just modeling errors.

  5. The improved AI can better constrain nuclear structure parameters in Bayesian analyses by using flow ratios, as the impact of the deformation of 20Ne on elliptic flow can be assessed from the ratio data with little uncertainty on the dynamical modeling.

Abstract

Recent light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider provide an opportunity to investigate the system-size dependence of hydrodynamization and whether the structure of light nuclei can be extracted from collective flow data. Both objectives require an accurate understanding of how the collision dynamics converts initial-state geometry into final-state momentum anisotropies. To this end, and to assess the impact of the experimental results, we compare simulations of O+O and Ne+Ne collisions in hydrodynamic and kinetic theory simulations across opacities. In both ultracentral and peripheral collisions, Ne+Ne-to-O+O elliptic flow ratios are robust against changes in dynamical description, supporting interpretations of data based on nuclear-geometry-driven effects. Triangular-flow ratios instead show substantially stronger sensitivity to nonequilibrium dynamics.

Sources

Related papers