Pionization experiments in light nuclei

arXiv:2611.04991 · nucl-th, hep-ex, nucl-ex · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Pionization experiments in light nuclei".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The zero-energy antiproton absorption in light nuclei is considered, and the ratios Rn/p of antiprotonneutron versus antiproton-proton capture rates in the lightest nuclei 2H, 3He and 4He are analyzed.

Kai: Antiprotonic atoms and very low-energy scattering of antiprotons off nuclei offer a number of advantages for nuclear and low-energy particle physics.

Mira: The studies of atomic level shifts and widths allow us to test hadron-nucleon scattering amplitudes below the threshold, as one or both particles are bound.

Kai: Furthermore, the nuclei and in particular light nuclei allow to test antiproton-neutron interactions which complement the knowledge of isospin dependence of NN¯ forces.

Title and authors: Kai: So the title itself tells us we are looking at how much the ratio of antiproton-neutron to antiproton-proton captures is changing in these light nuclei.

Mira: It’s not just about the capture rates; it’s about using those specific pionization results—the charge distributions of pions—to figure out the underlying nucleon-antiproton interactions.

Lev: That means they are using what they see in the pion spectra to constrain the absorption and charge-exchange probabilities, which are key things we need for building realistic models.

Kai: They also use these rates to predict the angular momentum states of the antiproton system, specifically looking at S, P, and D states.

Mira: That whole setup is designed to test whether our current understanding of the nucleon-antiproton interaction works across different energy scales and nuclear environments.

Lev: And they are using those capture rates as a way to probe the relevant energy in the antiproton neutron system that leads to those experimental ratios, which is a big unknown for us.

Kai: So, it’s about figuring out what's going on at the annihilation moment when an antiproton hits a light nucleus.

Mira: Exactly. They are trying to determine the center-of-mass energies involved in these different reactions because those energies dictate which angular momentum states are relevant for the absorption.

The paper's summary: Kai: The core of this paper is analyzing the pionization results obtained from Helium and Helium-three nuclei and comparing them to what happens in elementary antiproton-proton or antiproton-neutron reactions <ref:2611.04991#pg1>.

Mira: They are using the differences between those elementary distributions and what they find in Helium to figure out the rates for two final state reactions: absorption and charge exchange.

Lev: And then they calculate these rates for three expected angular momentum states: S, P, and D. That’s a lot of calculation tied directly to experimental observables like the pion multiplicity distributions shown in Table II.

Kai: The paper points out that the results obtained in Helium are quite different from what other theoretical models predict, which is a key discrepancy they highlight.

Mira: They find that if you only use the Paris potential, you can get a ratio of antiproton-neutron to antiproton-proton capture rates of about one half, and that only happens if the system is in an S-wave nucleon-antinucleon state.

Lev: That suggests an alternative scenario is needed, either a modification to the Paris potential or experiments using gas targets instead of vacuum ones are capturing most of those absorptions happening in high nS or nP atomic states.

Kai: It’s showing that the light nuclei environment introduces effects that aren't captured by simpler models on their own.

Mira: And they are testing three different nucleon-antiproton interaction models against both the ratio measurements and the level shifts calculated from those potentials.

The paper's improvements: Kai: One of the main points they push for is that we need to calculate two specific probabilities per single produced meson: the charge-exchange probability lambda and the absorption probability omega.

Mira: They then use these probabilities to calculate an average transmission probability, which they define as T alpha, based on some integral involving the antiproton wave function overlap and the transition matrix element.

Lev: That transmission probability calculation is complex because it depends heavily on the angular momentum state L of the antiproton system, and that L depends strongly on how you calculate those overlaps.

Kai: So they are trying to get a better picture of where these absorptions happen within the nucleus by calculating the densities of antiproton-nucleon annihilation based on those wave function overlaps.

Mira: They also suggest that predicting the relative weights of different capture states, like L equals zero, one, and two, can be done using minimization procedures based on experimental transition data to find those wL values.

Lev: If we could pin down those wL values accurately, it would give us a much better handle on the dynamics of the nuclear capture processes in these light systems.

Kai: Overall, they are suggesting a more detailed way to understand the absorption region by accounting for all those different angular momentum states.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up, they found that in medium and heavy antiprotonic atoms, the ratio of antiproton-neutron to antiproton-proton captures is close to one across most models.

Kai: But for Helium, their data yielded a ratio of about one half, which only matched what you get with the Paris potential if you assume an S-wave nucleon-antinucleon state.

Lev: The paper notes that while the three nucleon-antiproton potentials they presented fare well compared to experimental level widths, the Paris and Kohno-Weise models fail badly in those respects.

Mira: They also point out a limitation: the old pionization experiments used Helium gas targets, whereas future experiments like PUMA are planned for vacuum.

Kai: So the implication is that the atomic capture states might be different from what we currently assume, and those upcoming vacuum experiments could solve this puzzle.

Lev: From an error correction view, this paper highlights that we need to account for these state-dependent effects because they are clearly influencing the observables in these light systems.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work because it directly compares different interaction models against experimental data from light nuclei like Helium and Deuterium.

Kai: This whole study on "Pionization experiments in light nuclei" gives us a clearer picture of where the next generation of experiments needs to focus to really nail down these nucleon-antiproton interactions.

Slawomir Wycech, ★ Guillaume Hupin, ☑ Jaume Carbonell

National Centre for Nuclear Research, Warsaw, Poland · Universit Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, IJCLab

nucl-th, hep-ex, nucl-ex

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: To appear in Phys Rev C

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: The zero-energy antiproton absorption in light nuclei is considered, and the ratios Rn/p of antiprotonneutron versus antiproton-proton capture rates in the lightest nuclei 2H…

Key concepts

Pionization
This involves measuring the distribution of charged pions created when an antiproton annihilates with a nucleus. By comparing these distributions to those from elementary $ar{p}p$ or $ar{p}n$ reactions, researchers can deduce the probabilities of different final state reactions like absorption and charge exchange within the nucleus.
Rn/p Ratio
This ratio compares the capture rate of an antiproton with a neutron ($ar{pn}$) to its capture rate with a proton ($ar{pp}$). Analyzing this ratio across light nuclei helps test how different nucleon-antinucleon forces behave, providing insight into the isospin dependence of these fundamental interactions.
Antiprotonic Atoms
These are exotic atoms where an antiproton orbits a nucleus. Studying their atomic level shifts and widths allows physicists to probe hadron-nucleon scattering amplitudes at very low energies, testing nuclear physics principles under extreme conditions where both particles are bound.
NN¯ Interaction Models
These are theoretical frameworks used to describe the fundamental forces between nucleons (protons and neutrons) and antinucleons. The paper tests three different models against experimental data like level shifts and capture ratios to see which model best explains the observed behavior in light nuclei.

Terminology

Summary

The zero-energy antiproton absorption in light nuclei is considered, and the ratios Rn/p of antiprotonneutron versus antiproton-proton capture rates in the lightest nuclei 2H, 3He and 4He are analyzed. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Pionization experiments in light nuclei Slawomir Wycech∗ National Centre for Nuclear Research, Warsaw, Poland Guillaume Hupin† and Jaume Carbonell‡ Universit´e Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, IJCLab, 91405, Orsay, France (Dated: November 4, 2026) The zero-energy antiproton absorption in light nuclei is considered. The ratios Rn/p of antiprotonneutron versus antiproton-proton capture rates in the lightest nuclei 2H, 3He and 4He are analyzed, both from the experimental results and from some selected theoretical models.

Introduction to Experimental Context

Antiprotonic atoms and very low-energy scattering of antiprotons off nuclei offer a number of advantages for nuclear and low-energy particle physics. The studies of atomic level shifts and widths allow us to test hadron-nucleon scattering amplitudes below the threshold, as one or both particles are bound. p. 0

Where the paper says it

PACS numbers: I. INTRODUCTION Antiprotonic atoms and very low-energy scattering of antiprotons off nuclei offer a number of advantages for nuclear and low-energy particle physics: First, the studies of atomic level shifts and widths allow us to test hadron-nucleon scattering amplitudes below the threshold, as one or both particles are bound.

Furthermore, the nuclei and in particular light nuclei allow to test antiproton-neutron interactions which complement the knowledge of isospin dependence of NN¯ forces. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Second, atomic level shifts and detection of atomic decay modes of these systems are well established methods to study the structure of nuclear surfaces. Third, the nuclei and in particular light nuclei allow to test antiproton-neutron interactions which complement the knowledge of isospin dependence of NN¯ forces.

In this work we concentrate on a specific form of antiprotonic studies consisting in measurements of charged pion spectra created in nuclear annihilation of antiprotons ”pionization”. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Third, the nuclei and in particular light nuclei allow to test antiproton-neutron interactions which complement the knowledge of isospin dependence of NN¯ forces. In this work we concentrate on a specific form of antiprotonic studies consisting in measurements of charged pion spectra created in nuclear annihilation of antiprotons (”pionization”).

Analysis of Pionization Results

The paper introduces the pionization results, i.e. the π-meson charge distributions obtained in 3He and 4He nuclei. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The present paper is organized as follows: Section II introduces the pionization results, i. the π-meson charge distributions obtained in 3He and 4He nuclei.

These results are compared to those of the elementary reactions ¯pp → mesons and ¯pn → mesons. p. 1
Where the paper says it

the π-meson charge distributions obtained in 3He and 4He nuclei. These results are compared to those of the elementary reactions ¯pp → mesons and ¯pn → mesons.

Differences of the elementary distributions and those obtained in Helium are used to establish the rates of two final state reactions of the mesons: absorptions and charge-exchanges. p. 1
Where the paper says it

These results are compared to those of the elementary reactions ¯pp → mesons and ¯pn → mesons. Differences of the elementary distributions and those obtained in Helium are used to establish the rates of two final state reactions of the mesons: absorptions and charge-exchanges.

Next, these rates are calculated for three expected antiproton-nucleus angular momentum states: S, P and D. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Differences of the elementary distributions and those obtained in Helium are used to establish the rates of two final state reactions of the mesons: absorptions and charge-exchanges. Next, these rates are calculated for three expected antiproton-nucleus angular momentum states : S, P and D.

Testing NN¯ Interaction Models

Section III discusses the predictions of three different NN¯ interaction models and tests these against the Rn/p and level shift measurements. The first question is: what is the relevant energy in the NN¯ system that leads to the experimental value of Rn/p? p. 6

Where the paper says it

Below we analyze several results. The first question is: what is the relevant energy in the NN¯ system that leads to the experimental value of Rn/p ?

p. 6
Where the paper says it

Below we analyze several results. The first question is: what is the relevant energy in the NN¯ system that leads to the experimental value of Rn/p ?

Calculations performed in ref. p. 6
Where the paper says it

This allows to determine energies in the NN¯ center of mass system as ECM = 2MN − ES − EA − EREC where: ES is a separation energy of the nucleon, EA is a (small) antiproton binding energy and EREC is a recoil energy of NN¯ pair with respect to the residual nucleus. Calculations performed in ref.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

This allows to determine energies in the NN¯ center of mass system as ECM = 2MN − ES − EA − EREC where: ES is a separation energy of the nucleon, EA is a (small) antiproton binding energy and EREC is a recoil energy of NN¯ pair with respect to the residual nucleus. Calculations performed in ref.

[19] yield values shown in table XI. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Calculations performed in ref. [19] yield the values shown in table XI.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

Calculations performed in ref. [19] yield the values shown in table XI.

The second question is: what are spin states of the NN¯ system at the annihilation? p. 6
Where the paper says it

It turns out that Rn/p are generated at subthreshold energies of about −34 MeV in 4He and about −14 MeV in 3He. The second question is: what are spin states of the NN¯ system at the annihilation ?

p. 6
Where the paper says it

It turns out that Rn/p are generated at subthreshold energies of about −34 MeV in 4He and about −14 MeV in 3He. The second question is: what are spin states of the NN¯ system at the annihilation ?

The absorption in this state is essentially given by Born term and we operate on spin averaged amplitudes. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In atomic D waves the result is given by expressing the atomic spin state in terms of internal spin of the NN¯ . The absorption in this state is essentially given by Born term and we operate on spin averaged amplitudes.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

In atomic D waves the result is given by expressing the atomic spin state in terms of internal spin of the NN¯ . The absorption in this state is essentially given by Born term and we operate on spin averaged amplitudes.

Conclusion on Capture States

The analysis of data in light nuclei requires calculations of charge-exchange probability λ and absorption probability ω per single produced meson. The results obtained in He are different, yielding Rn/p to be about one half and a comparable result is obtained only by the Paris potential and in an S-wave nucleon - antinucleon state. p. 9

Where the paper says it

At present, Paris model is the only potential that offers small Rn/p values, and only in the S-wave. It comes as a result of an I=0 baryonium state formed in the NN¯ system.

This suggests an alternative: either a change of Paris potential or in experiments with gas targets the majority of nuclear absorptions happening in high nS, nP atomic states. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Reliable NN¯ potentials are needed and the forthcoming experiments should be helpful. Apart from the pionization experiments, the majority of low-energy antiproton experiments involve X-ray measurements which yield atomic level width and shifts due to nuclear interactions of p.

Atomic Level Widths and Shifts

Finally we give results for atomic level shifts and level widths calculated with the three discussed potentials. The method of multiple scattering series summation discussed in reference [19] was used. p. 2

Where the paper says it

An analysis of reference [16] shows that angular averaging over mesonic trajectories allows us, to a good approximation, to discuss the π mesons as born at an initial point r. In the next section, the experimental spectra are discussed.

The results obtained in He are different, and the pionization experiments yield Rn/p to be about one half and a comparable result is obtained only by the Paris potential and in an S-wave nucleon - antinucleon state. p. 9
Where the paper says it

At present, Paris model is the only potential that offers small Rn/p values, and only in the S-wave. It comes as a result of an I=0 baryonium state formed in the NN¯ system.

Summary of Key Findings

The ratio of antiproton-neutron to antiproton-proton captures Rn/p was calculated with several NN¯ interaction models. In medium and heavy antiprotonic atoms, this ratio is dominated by P-waves nucleon-antinucleon interactions and is close to unity in all studied models. The results obtained in He are different, yielding Rn/p to be about one half. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Subsequent comparison of the phenomenological and the calculated results is used to determine the relative weights of these states in the nuclear capture process. Section III discusses the predictions of three different NN¯ interaction models and tests these against the Rn/p and level shift measurements.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Subsequent comparison of the phenomenological and the calculated results is used to determine the relative weights of these states in the nuclear capture process. Section III discusses the predictions of three different NN¯ interaction models and tests these against the Rn/p and level shift measurements.

The three presented nucleon-antinucleon potentials fare well in comparison to experimental level widths. p. 6
Where the paper says it

05) which leads to Rn/p = 0. An open problem is understanding of the Rn/p in terms of nucleon - antinucleon potentials.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

05) which leads to Rn/p = 0. An open problem is understanding of the Rn/p in terms of nucleon - antinucleon potentials.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

05) which leads to Rn/p = 0. An open problem is understanding of the Rn/p in terms of nucleon - antinucleon potentials.

The Dover-Richard potential is compatible also with the level shifts. p. 8
Where the paper says it

2: Below threshold amplitudes for the Kohno-Weise potential [31]. 3: Below threshold amplitudes for the Dover-Richard model [30].

p. 8
Where the paper says it

2: Below threshold amplitudes for the Kohno-Weise potential [31]. 3: Below threshold amplitudes for the Dover-Richard model [30].

p. 8
Where the paper says it

2: Below threshold amplitudes for the Kohno-Weise potential [31]. 3: Below threshold amplitudes for the Dover-Richard model [30].

However, the Paris and Kohno-Weise fail badly in this respect. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We have computed the S- and P-waves amplitudes t 0 L (E) for the NN¯ optical potentials in configuration space that we have examined in [28], i. Paris 2009 [29] Dover-Richard model 2 [30] and Kohno-Weise model [31].

p. 7
Where the paper says it

We have computed the S- and P-waves amplitudes t 0 L (E) for the NN¯ optical potentials in configuration space that we have examined in [28], i. Paris 2009 [29] Dover-Richard model 2 [30] and Kohno-Weise model [31].

p. 7
Where the paper says it

We have computed the S- and P-waves amplitudes t 0 L (E) for the NN¯ optical potentials in configuration space that we have examined in [28], i. Paris 2009 [29] Dover-Richard model 2 [30] and Kohno-Weise model [31].

The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Also, as shown in ref[19], it is inconsistent with level shifts in light antiprotonic atoms. The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Also, as shown in ref[19], it is inconsistent with level shifts in light antiprotonic atoms. The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Also, as shown in ref[19], it is inconsistent with level shifts in light antiprotonic atoms. The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum.

The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The ratio Rn/p is calculated with several NN¯ interaction models. The first question is: what is the relevant energy in the NN¯ system that leads to the experimental value of Rn/p? Calculations performed in ref. [19] yield values shown in table XI. The second question is: what are spin states of the NN¯ system at the annihilation? The absorption in this state is essentially given by Born term and we operate on spin averaged amplitudes.

How the training signal is built

The analysis of data in light nuclei requires calculations of charge-exchange probability λ and absorption probability ω per single produced meson. The average transmission probability is calculated as Tα = 1/Θ Z dr ψL(r)2 Σnφn(r)2 Z dLcmMpN→M2Tα(r, k). p. 3

Where the paper says it

Single charge-exchange The probability of charge-exchange reaction (3) per single meson is denoted by λ. The relation of multiplicity probabilities in sectors Nb = 0 and Nb = 1 is driven by λ and one has for each number of π +π − pairs.

p. 3
Where the paper says it

Single charge-exchange The probability of charge-exchange reaction (3) per single meson is denoted by λ. The relation of multiplicity probabilities in sectors Nb = 0 and Nb = 1 is driven by λ and one has for each number of π +π − pairs.

Where the gains come from

The results obtained in He are different, yielding Rn/p to be about one half. The three presented nucleon-antinucleon potentials fare well in comparison to experimental level widths. The Dover-Richard potential is compatible also with the level shifts. However, the Paris and Kohno-Weise fail badly in this respect. The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle.

The analysis of data in light nuclei requires calculations of charge-exchange probability λ and absorption probability ω per single produced meson. The average transmission probability is calculated as Tα = 1/Θ Z dr ψL(r)2 Σnφn(r)2 Z dLcmMpN→M2Tα(r, k). The results obtained in He are different, yielding Rn/p to be about one half. The three presented nucleon-antinucleon potentials fare well in comparison to experimental level widths. The Dover-Richard potential is compatible also with the level shifts. However, the Paris and Kohno-Weise fail badly in this respect. The old pionization experiments used Helium gas, while the planned PUMA experiment will be performed in vacuum. The atomic capture states are likely to be different and possibly the coming experiment will solve the puzzle.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of antiproton-nucleus capture rates by incorporating both experimental results from pionization measurements and theoretical models of nucleon-nucleon interactions to determine level shifts and widths accurately.

  2. Enhanced ability to predict the ratio Rn/p for light nuclei by establishing a mixed procedure that extracts this ratio directly from experimental final state mesonic charges while simultaneously determining the unknown capture states, addressing uncertainties i) and ii).

  3. Better constraint on nucleon-antinucleon potentials by testing different models against both level shift measurements and Rn/p ratios, allowing researchers to identify which potential, such as the Paris model for S-waves, is most consistent with experimental data in specific systems like Helium.

  4. Refined understanding of the antiproton absorption region within the nucleus by calculating the densities of antiproton-nucleon annihilation based on atomic wave function overlaps and angular momentum states L, which depends strongly on L.

  5. Ability to predict the relative weights of different capture states L=0, 1, and 2 in nuclear capture processes using minimization procedures based on experimental transition data to determine wL values.

Abstract

The zero-energy antiproton absorption in light nuclei is considered. The ratios R n/p of antiproton-neutron versus antiproton-proton capture rates in the lightest nuclei squared H, cubed He and 4 He are analyzed, both from the experimental results and from some selected theoretical models. These models are used as key input in determining the level shifts and widths of the lowest states. We establish the capture orbit in cubed He to be states of angular momentum L=2. Several N-N optical potentials are used to compute the R n/p values for several heavy nuclei and the results are found to be consistent with the data. However, the old chamber experiments studying pionization in Helium, are not consistent with models. Only the Paris potential is likely to succeed provided baryonia states predicted by this model are better understood.

Related papers