On mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes

arXiv:2611.04618 · gr-qc · Submitted 2026-11-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Mass inflation in non-extremal regular black holes with a non-linear dependence of the Misner-Sharp mass M on the asymptotic mass m > 0 may be a transient phenomenon followed by a model-dependent non-exponential late-time divergence The paper aims to provide a complementary perspective on mass inflation and late-time divergences for a class of static spherically symmetric and asymptotically flat regular black holes with a de Sitter core and an m-independent upper bound on the Misner-Sharp mass density The analysis considers regular black holes where the Misner-Sharp mass M depends non-linearly on the asymptotic mass m > 0, in the form of metric (1).

Kai: A crucial requirement is that the scalar function ψ(m, r) be universally bounded by inverse powers of a fundamental length scale l, i.e., ψ(m, r) ≤ ψmax = 1/l2.

Mira: This boundedness condition is compatible with the assumption that the regular black holes have a de Sitter core with l acting as an effective regularisation length parameter in an expansion of the metric around r = 0.

Kai: Review of Dynamical Equations The discussion grounds itself on a generalization of the Ori model

13: to analyze mass inflation and late-time divergences The outgoing perturbation is modeled by a pressureless null thin shell Σ placed between the apparent inner and outer horizon, dividing the spacetime into an inside region (+) an outside region (−).

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "On mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes", and who wrote it. It's about how mass inflation behaves in non-extremal regular black holes where the Misner Sharp mass M depends on the asymptotic mass m greater than zero.

Mira: The authors are exploring whether this growth is just a quick transient thing, or if it can lead to a kind of late-time divergence that depends on the specific model used, specifically when you have those regular black holes with a de Sitter core and an upper bound on the mass density.

The paper's summary: Kai: We're talking about the core of this paper, "On mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes." It summarizes their findings on how mass inflation can be transient or lead to a model-dependent non-exponential divergence.

Mira: Basically, they are looking at regular black holes that have a de Sitter core and an upper bound on the Misner Sharp mass density, and they use that structure to study the dynamics of perturbations.

Lev: What this means for us is they're trying to provide a complementary view on mass inflation and late-time divergences in these specific types of black holes.

Kai: They discuss how the initial exponential growth of M at the inner apparent horizon can be either transient, or it can lead to a non-exponential divergence after that initial period.

Mira: The key is that they analyze this based on a generalized Ori model for static spherically symmetric and asymptotically flat regular black holes with those specific core assumptions.

Lev: So, if you're thinking about simulating these things, this paper tells us the behavior isn't always the same; it really depends on the specific assumptions about how M relates to m.

Kai: They are looking at a few generating functions that satisfy certain conditions and showing how late-time power-law scaling of the Misner Sharp mass density can be made very weak for large but finite n.

Mira: For instance, they consider a generating function where the ratio between this function and its derivative is linear to leading order, which suggests that for those black holes mass inflation will be eternal.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, that makes sense; if it suggests eternal growth, you need to see how much overhead that translates into actual physical parameters on a real system before the model breaks down.

Kai: They also show examples where the unphysical parameter m plus v becomes negative or complex as time goes to infinity for different choices of n.

Mira: This confirms that if you look at these different choices, you get very different long-time behaviors for the physical mass density, from exponential to polynomial divergence.

Lev: So this is important because it helps us understand the range of outcomes we might expect in simulations before we even start running things.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests a few ways to make their analysis better. They want to improve how they derive the late-time power-law scaling for the Misner Sharp mass density by using an approximated master equation, specifically equation thirty-nine, and solving it in terms of a Bernoulli differential equation.

Mira: That would give them a better tool for getting those power law scalings. It's a more robust mathematical approach than just looking at the final result.

Lev: For us, using an approximated master equation to solve that kind of differential equation means we have something that's more tractable for numerical work, which is less prone to numerical instability when dealing with the actual coupled system.

Kai: They also suggest they can numerically solve these coupled systems of differential equations that govern the radial position of the shell R plus v and the mass parameter m plus v to map out regimes where physical quantities grow beyond their limiting values.

Mira: That would give us direct access to seeing exactly where those physical quantities exceed their expected limits in a simulation setup, which is more concrete than just theoretical proof.

Lev: Being able to map those regimes would let us test the model against real hardware constraints, like how much computational overhead that actually lands on our system before we hit a wall.

Kai: They also propose checking if there's a necessary condition for eternal late-time divergence by checking if a model-dependent function associated with an eternal late-time divergence of H psi plus v as time goes to infinity is proportional to gamma psi plus v plus o psi plus v, which is equation eighty three.

Mira: That specific check would give us a concrete condition we can test against in our theoretical framework, linking the mathematical condition directly to the dynamical behavior.

Lev: That's useful because it means we have a benchmark for when to stop looking for solutions, or when the theory itself might be breaking down under certain conditions.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "On mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes," the main implication is that an eternal late-time divergence of the physical Misner Sharp mass density is tied to a curvature singularity in a dynamical real extension of the static spacetime.

Mira: This suggests that such divergences are necessary to allow for growth past maximal values and ensure there's no fixed point as time goes on towards infinity.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, it means that we need to see how the model handles those extreme growth scenarios before we can trust our results.

Kai: The authors also suggest that this kinematic statement might extend to quasitopological gravitational theories where limiting-curvature regular black holes are vacuum solutions generically.

Mira: That's a big idea; it implies this kind of behavior isn't just limited to the models they studied, but could be a general feature of certain gravitational theories.

Lev: It gives us something to think about when designing more robust error correction schemes that need to handle these kinds of extreme dynamical extensions.

Kai: We're finished with this paper on mass inflation and late-time divergences in limiting-curvature regular black holes, and we'll move on to the next one.

Mira: It was a deep look at how model dependence affects long-term behavior for these specific black hole models, and I think it gives us a lot to chew on.

Lev: It was good seeing how they link the mathematical conditions to what would actually need to be simulated in practice.

Johanna Borissova

Abdus Salam Centre for Theoretical Physics, Imperial College London

gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-11-03

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 28 pages, 14 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Mass inflation in non-extremal regular black holes with a non-linear dependence of the Misner-Sharp mass M on the asymptotic mass m > 0 may be a transient phenomenon followed by a model-dependent…

Key concepts

Misner-Sharp Mass M
This mass parameter describes the gravitational structure of a regular black hole. In this study, its dependence on the asymptotic mass 'm' is non-linear, which influences how the black hole behaves over time and whether it diverges at late times.
Mass Inflation
This refers to an initial growth in the Misner-Sharp mass M caused by outgoing perturbations. The analysis shows that this growth can be exponential or polynomial depending on the specific mathematical form relating M to other variables, determining if the inflation is transient or eternal.
Limiting Curvature Condition
This condition sets an upper bound on the Misner-Sharp mass density and curvature for regular black holes. The paper uses this constraint to analyze when mass inflation leads to unbounded growth, often requiring unphysical parameters like a negative mass variable.

Terminology

Summary

Mass inflation in non-extremal regular black holes with a non-linear dependence of the Misner-Sharp mass M on the asymptotic mass m > 0 may be a transient phenomenon followed by a model-dependent non-exponential late-time divergence

Introduction and Setup

The paper aims to provide a complementary perspective on mass inflation and late-time divergences for a class of static spherically symmetric and asymptotically flat regular black holes with a de Sitter core and an m-independent upper bound on the Misner-Sharp mass density The analysis considers regular black holes where the Misner-Sharp mass M depends non-linearly on the asymptotic mass m > 0, in the form of metric (1). A crucial requirement is that the scalar function ψ(m, r) be universally bounded by inverse powers of a fundamental length scale l, i. p. 1e., ψ(m, r) ≤ ψmax = 1/l2. p. 1 This boundedness condition is compatible with the assumption that the regular black holes have a de Sitter core with l acting as an effective regularisation length parameter in an expansion of the metric around r = 0. p. 1

Review of Dynamical Equations

The discussion grounds itself on a generalization of the Ori model [13] to analyze mass inflation and late-time divergences The outgoing perturbation is modeled by a pressureless null thin shell Σ placed between the apparent inner and outer horizon, dividing the spacetime into an inside region (+) an outside region (−). The dynamics are encoded in a coupled set of differential equations determining the radial position of the shell R(v) and the mass parameter m+(v) once m−(v) has been prescribed as in (15). p. 4

Mass Inflation Dynamics

The asymptotic late-time dynamics of the Misner-Sharp mass M can be analyzed based on an approximate solution for R(v) in the limit v → ∞. The first term linear in M+(v) in equation (39) triggers an initially exponential growth (in magnitude) of the solution, i. p. 7e., standard mass inflation. p. 7 The case when this function is proportional to positive integer powers M+(v)n+1 for n ≥ 1 leads to a polynomial divergence of M+(v) for v → ∞. p. 7

Quasi-topological Class Analysis

The Hayward regular black hole serves as an example where the limiting curvature condition (11) is satisfied with a universal m-independent upper bound given by Kmax = α/l4. The analysis shows that mass inflation triggering an unbounded growth of the physical Misner-Sharp mass M+(v) requires the mass parameter m+(v) to become negative dynamically. p. 8 This unphysical mass variable approaches a finite negative value corresponding to the physical singularity of the negative-mass Hayward spacetime. p. 8

Generalization and Conclusion

The work extends these observations to a broader class of regular black holes with limiting Misner-Sharp mass density and curvature. The authors conclude that an eternal late-time divergence of the physical Misner-Sharp mass density is associated with the curvature singularity of an appropriate dynamical real extension of the static spacetime. p. 0 This supports the viewpoint that such divergences are necessary to accommodate growth past maximal values and ensure eternal late-time divergence as v → ∞. p. 8 The paper also investigates model-dependent conditions for whether mass inflation is eternal or subexponential. p. 0 The study suggests that the Ori null thin-shell model may fail to capture the full nature of the inner-horizon instability in continuous crossflow perturbations. p. 3

Example and Generating Functions

For a one-parameter family of generating functions hn(ψ) satisfying h n(ψ)h'n(ψ) = ψ 1 - l 2nψ n, the late-time power-law scaling of the Misner-Sharp mass density can be made extremely weak for large but finite n. This is achieved by considering a correction term ∼ ψ(v)n+1 for n ≫ 1. p. 7 The corresponding unphysical parameter mn+(v) necessarily becomes negative for n = 2, imaginary for n = 3, and complex with non-vanishing real and imaginary parts for finite n > 2 as v → ∞. p. 8

Other Example of a Generating Function

A different example considered is the generating function h(ψ) = ψ(1-l 2ψ) squared. For this function, the ratio between this function and its derivative is linear to leading order, suggesting that for the corresponding regular black hole mass inflation will be eternal. p. 0 This leads to an eternal exponential divergence in the case of a specific solution branch. p. 7

Conclusion Summary

The paper confirms that an eternal late-time divergence of the physical Misner-Sharp mass density is associated with the curvature singularity of an appropriate dynamical real extension of the static spacetime. This phenomenon is essential for accommodating growth past maximal values and ensuring eternal late-time divergence as v → ∞. p. 0 The authors suggest that this kinematic statement may extend to quasitopological gravitational theories giving rise to limiting-curvature regular black holes as vacuum solutions generically. p. 5

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Ra´ul Carballo-Rubio and Antonio Panassiti for insightful discussions, and are grateful to Alfio Bonanno for useful comments on a previous version of the manuscript.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved system can perform analytical derivations of late-time power-law scaling for mass density by utilizing the approximated master equation (39) and its solution in terms of a Bernoulli differential equation (56).

  2. Improved system can numerically solve coupled systems of differential equations, such as those governing the radial position of the shell R(v) and the mass parameter m+(v), to map out regimes where physical quantities grow beyond their limiting values.

  3. Improved system can identify necessary conditions for eternal late-time divergence by checking if a model-dependent function associated with an eternal late-time divergence of H(ϱ+(v)) as v -> infinity is proportional to γpsi+(v) + o(psi+(v)) (83).

  4. Improved system can distinguish between scenarios leading to exponential versus subexponential growth of physical mass density by analyzing the sign and magnitude of the universal late-time scaling quantity ϱ+(v)H′(ϱ+(v))H(ϱ+(v)) (85).

  5. Improved system can verify kinematic statements about curvature singularities by checking if the infinite resummation series resulting in functions h(psi) associated with de Sitter core regular black holes is pushed out of its radius of convergence dynamically.

Sources

Related papers