Experimental Searches for Muon to Electron Conversion in Nuclei
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Experimental Searches for Muon to Electron Conversion in Nuclei".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV) is probed by muon to electron conversion (mu- to e- N conversion), a process where a negatively charged muon bound in a muonic atom converts into an electron while conserving total lepton number.
Kai: The experimental signature is a single, monoenergetic electron with energy E mu e about m mu - B mu - E recoil, which depends on the target nucleus.
Mira: This process is sensitive to both dipole operators (via mu+ to e+ gamma) and four-fermion contact interactions involving two leptons and two quarks.
Kai: The coherent spin-independent (SI) conversion rate, CR SI(mu- N to e- N), is controlled by nuclear structure factors like overlap integrals (D, S(p,n), V(p,n)), which depend on the target nucleus.
Paper summary: Kai: So, focusing on what 'Experimental Searches for Muon to Electron Conversion in Nuclei' actually claims, the paper is essentially reviewing how we search for this muon conversion process in nuclei.
Mira: It lays out the physics motivation and gives us a picture of the basic experimental principles needed to actually set up these searches.
Lev: I mean, it discusses the key background sources that we have to worry about when trying to find a tiny signal in these experiments.
Kai: And it talks about the search strategies for past and next-generation experiments like COMET and Mu2e, showing where things are now and where they're going.
Mira: It gives us some specific targets, like COMET Phase-I aiming for a single-event sensitivity of three point one times ten to the power of fifteen with about one hundred fifty days of data.
Lev: And then Mu2e is designed to accumulate three point six times ten to the power of twenty protons on target over six hundred eighty days, targeting a single-event sensitivity around three point zero times ten to the power of seventeen.
Kai: It also mentions that future concepts like PRISM and PRIME might improve things by letting us use storage rings to manipulate muon beams, which could push sensitivities toward ten to the power of eighteen.
Mira: But it also emphasizes that if we find a signal, comparing the results from different target nuclei and other searches for other muon CLFV decay modes is essential for figuring out what's going on.
Lev: And it also points out some limitations of current approaches, like how the suppression factor in the dipole operator versus four-fermion operators depends on which one dominates.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper 'Experimental Searches for Muon to Electron Conversion in Nuclei', it's really about systematically searching for this muon to electron conversion process in different nuclei.
Mira: The authors are setting the stage by talking about how this search probes physics beyond the Standard Model through both dipole and four-fermion contact interactions.
Lev: What this means for us is that we need incredibly precise measurements and a good understanding of nuclear structure factors to interpret any data we get.
Kai: It highlights that experiments like COMET and Mu2e are pushing sensitivities down to levels around ten to the power of seventeen, which is a huge step up from older limits.
Mira: The paper emphasizes that the way these different interaction types appear depends heavily on whether one type dominates over the other in the process.
Lev: And it stresses that if we see rates much higher than expected for certain processes, it would clearly signal that the source isn't just one specific operator, like a dipole operator.
Kai: So, in simple terms, this paper is mapping out how experimental searches for muon to electron conversion can help us find new physics by comparing results from different nuclear targets and different types of interactions.
Yoshitaka Kuno
The University of Osaka · Research Center for Nuclear Physics
hep-ex
Submitted: 2026-11-02
Updated: 2026-11-02
Comments: Contribution to the Encyclopedia of Nuclear Physics
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV) is probed by muon to electron conversion (mu- to e- N conversion)…
Key concepts
- Charged Lepton Flavor Violation (CLFV)
- This refers to hypothetical physics where a muon can transform into an electron, violating the conservation of lepton flavor. It is searched for through processes like $\mu^- \to e^- N$ conversion, which requires new physics beyond the Standard Model.
- Coherent Spin-Independent (SI) Conversion Rate
- This is the rate at which a negatively charged muon converts into an electron while keeping the nuclear spin unchanged. This rate is highly dependent on specific properties of the target nucleus, such as its overlap integrals ($D$, $S(p,n)$, $V(p,n)$).
- Single-Event Sensitivity (SES)
- SES measures the sensitivity of an experiment to a single event—in this case, a muon conversion. COMET targets SES around $3.1 \times 10^{-15}$, while Mu2e aims for $3 \times 10^{-17}$. This metric defines the minimum measurable rate achievable with a given amount of data.
- Nuclear Structure Factors
- These are parameters derived from nuclear physics that describe how the muon interacts with the target nucleus. They include overlap integrals and distributions of protons, neutrons, and charge within the nucleus, which are essential for interpreting conversion rates.
Terminology
Summary
Charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV) is probed by muon to electron conversion (mu- to e- N conversion), a process where a negatively charged muon bound in a muonic atom converts into an electron while conserving total lepton number. p. 2 The experimental signature is a single, monoenergetic electron with energy E mu e about m mu - B mu - E recoil, which depends on the target nucleus. p. 3 This process is sensitive to both dipole operators (via mu+ to e+ gamma) and four-fermion contact interactions involving two leptons and two quarks. p. 1
The coherent spin-independent (SI) conversion rate, CR SI(mu- N to e- N), is controlled by nuclear structure factors like overlap integrals (D, S(p,n), V(p,n)), which depend on the target nucleus. p. 6 Measurements across different nuclei are crucial for discriminating between various CLFV operators. p. 6
Next-generation experiments, such as COMET (at J-PARC) and Mu2e (at Fermilab), aim to improve sensitivity by up to four orders of magnitude over previous limits (like SINDRUM II's CR(mu- Au to e- Au) < 7 times 10-13). Achieving sensitivities around 10-16 requires total samples of O(10 18) stopped muons, necessitating high-intensity beam techniques like solenoid pion capture and curved-solenoid muon transport systems. p. 3
COMET Phase-I targets a single-event sensitivity (SES) of 3. p. 91 times 10-15 with about 150 days of data, aiming for an upper limit of CR(mu- Al to e- Al) < 7 times 10-15. p. 6 Mu2e is designed to accumulate 3. p. 06 times 10 20 protons on target over about 680 days, targeting a SES of about 3 times 10-17, corresponding to an upper limit of CR(mu- Al to e- Al) < 8 times 10-17. p. 5
Both experiments share core strategies: solenoid pion capture, curved-solenoid muon transport, pulsed proton beams, delayed measurement windows, and cosmic-ray vetoing. p. 4 Differences exist in the beamline layout (COMET Phase-II uses a C-shaped system; Mu2e uses an S-shaped Transport Solenoid). p. 1 Future concepts like PRISM/PRIME and AMF aim for qualitative improvements by manipulating muon beams using storage rings, potentially allowing access to higher-Z targets or thinner stopping targets, pushing sensitivities toward 10-18.
Complementary searches include mu- to e+ N' conversion, which probes lepton-number violation (LNV) in addition to CLFV. The signature is a monoenergetic positron with energy E mu e+ about m mu - B mu - E recoil + M(A, Z) - M(A, Z-2). p. 3 Backgrounds for this search are dominated by radiative muon capture (RMC) and radiative pion capture (RPC). p. 3
Experimental interpretation requires precise background control using knowledge of muon decay in orbit (DIO), RMC, RPC, and antiproton production rates. p. 3 Furthermore, accurate nuclear physics inputs—specifically nuclear charge, proton, and neutron distributions—and analyses based on nonrelativistic effective theory (NRET) are essential to relate observed rates to specific CLFV operators. p. 6
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform model discrimination by using target dependence of coherent mu minus e minus conversion ratios to discriminate among CLFV operators, as
measurements using different target nuclei can help discriminate among CLFV operators and theoretical models.
-
Improved AI can predict the necessary experimental conditions for next-generation searches by calculating the required total stopped muon samples, such as
accumulating 1018 stopped muons corresponds to an average rate of about 1011 stopped mu minus per second for a running time of 107 s.
-
Improved AI can optimize detector design by performing calculations on the stopping-target geometry to maximize useful stopped-muon yield while preserving momentum resolution, such as
arrays of thin foils with appropriate spacing between them, which provide sufficient stopping power while minimizing the amount of material traversed by the outgoing signal electrons.
-
Improved AI can perform background suppression strategy optimization by evaluating beam extinction requirements, such as requiring
extinction at the level of 10 minus 10 or better
to suppress out-of-time protons between nominal proton pulses. -
Improved AI can provide refined signal region definitions by accounting for the electron spectrum's steep fall and endpoint effects, using the formula
Ee ∼ E′end 5 (1 − Ee/E′end!5 + delta).
Sources
- COMET - A submission to the 2020 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics on behalf of the COMET collaboration
- Low energy effects of neutrino masses
- Mu2e Run I Sensitivity Projections for the Neutrinoless $\mu^- \to e^-$ Conversion Search in Aluminum
- New limit on the \mu+->e+\gamma decay with the MEG II experiment
- Accelerator system for the PRISM based muon to electron conversion experiment
- Muon conversion to electron in nuclei in type-I seesaw models
- Technical design of the phase I Mu3e experiment
- Mu2e Technical Design Report
- The design of the MEG II experiment
- The Mu2e Experiment
- Charged Lepton Flavor Violation: An Experimenter's Guide
- On Lepton-Number-Violating Searches for Muon to Positron Conversion
- A New Determination of the (Z,A) Dependence of Coherent Muon-to-Electron Conversion
- Mu2e-II: Muon to electron conversion with PIP-II
- Charged Lepton Flavour Violation: An Experimental and Theoretical Introduction
- Large-angle production of charged pions with 3-12.9 GeV/c incident protons on nuclear targets
- On the model discriminating power of mu -> e conversion in nuclei
- Spin-dependent $\mu \to e$ conversion
- Next-to-leading order scalar contributions to $\mu\rightarrow e$ conversion
- MuSIC: delivering the world's most intense muon beam
Related papers
- DrSai: an agentic AI system toward autonomous physics analysis workflows at BESIII
- CANTON- mu Proposal: A Next-Generation Muon g-2 Measurement at Sub-0.1 ppm Precision
- Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer
- ANUBIS detector and its sensitivity to neutral long-lived particles
- How to scale your HEP ML models: A recipe for robust architecture comparisons at scale
- Search for the 16 O(ppp) to 13 C pi+ pi+ e+ Decay Mode in Super-Kamiokande Using Machine Learning Techniques