Evaluation of 2 nu beta beta decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei

arXiv:2611.02382 · nucl-th · Submitted 2026-11-02 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Evaluation of 2 nu beta beta decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques.

Kai: The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states.

Mira: Both methods simultaneously preserve the total GT strengths associated with the initial and final nuclei.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The 2νββ/2νECEC decay NME is expressed as a sum over intermediate 1+ states in the intermediate nucleus.

Title and authors: Mira: So, to summarize what we've heard so far about this paper, it’s about two new ways—the dual-sided Lanczos strength-function and the block-Lanczos strength-function—to calculate those NMEs without needing a full set of intermediate states.

Kai: It’s important to stress that these methods are designed to be efficient, meaning they converge with a relatively small number of iterations starting from the Gamow-Teller doorway states.

Lev: Because if you have to iterate for too many steps, it just becomes a slow calculation on real hardware, and we need things that scale better than that.

Mira: And what makes this specific approach interesting is that it preserves the total Gamow-Teller strengths from both the parent and daughter nuclei in a more consistent way than some previous treatments of the single-sided Lanczos strength-function.

Kai: That consistency, I think, is where they’re really pushing forward; they say this symmetric treatment enables a more accurate calculation of those intermediate-state contributions while keeping the computational efficiency high.

The paper's summary: Lev: What does the actual paper say in terms of results? They benchmarked these approaches for forty-eight calcium in the f p shell using the GXPF1A effective interaction, and they found that the cumulative nuclear matrix element calculated with SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF methods converges to a value of zero point zero five one one after thirty iterations.

Mira: Thirty iterations is a lot for a quantum calculation, but for them, it shows convergence. They also mentioned that the energy-denominator-free sums they got from all three methods reproduce the directly calculated double Gamow-Teller transition matrix elements, which is a big validation point.

Kai: So basically, they are showing that these intermediate representations generated by these Lanczos methods actually recover the complete energy-denominator-free sums under the same calculation conditions used for two nu beta beta and two nu ECEC NMEs <ref:2611.02382#pg1>.

Lev: That agreement with the direct double Gamow-Teller transition matrix element is a strong test of whether their intermediate state representations are truly capturing everything that matters in those sums.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Now, moving on to the improvements they suggest for this work, they’re looking at how these techniques can be applied to larger systems and different mass regions. They tested these methods on forty-eight calcium in the sdpf shell, as well as seventy-six germanium in a different shell structure.

Kai: They also looked at isotopes like one hundred thirty tellurium and used different effective interactions to see how robust these approaches are across various nuclear models and mass regions.

Lev: But there's a specific point they make about the sdpf space for forty-eight calcium: including cross-shell excitations up to two h bar omega reduces the calculated NME relative to the full f p shell result, and that brings it closer to what experimental estimates suggest for two nu beta beta decay <ref:2611.02382#pg2>.

Mira: And then they look at something slightly different with fifty-eight nickel in the f p shell, where they presented a calculation for the two neutrino double-beta plus electron capture NME, which suggests there might be a need for more sensitive measurements of those specific half-lives.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on this paper, what we’ve seen is that these dual-sided Lanczos methods offer an efficient way to calculate two nu beta beta and two nu ECEC NMEs by preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both nuclei <ref:2611.02382#pg1,preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both>.

Mira: The key finding is the agreement between the energy-denominator-free sums derived from their methods and the exact double Gamow-Teller transition matrix elements calculated via a closure relation for all nuclei considered.

Lev: It confirms that these intermediate representations are indeed recovering the complete energy-denominator-free sums under those calculation conditions, which is a solid validation for using this approach to find NMEs.

Kai: The paper shows they can do this with relatively few iterations, like thirty for forty-eight calcium in the f p shell, proving it’s a practical framework for calculating these NMEs in large shell-model spaces <ref:2611.02382#pg2,NMEs in large shell-model spaces>.

Mira: It provides a consistent and robust treatment of the intermediate-state contributions, which is exactly what we need when we want an accurate picture of these decay rates.

Lev: So, this paper on the "Evaluation of two nu beta beta decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei" shows a promising path forward for making these calculations more practical and reliable <ref:2611.02382#pg1,decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from>.

Deepak Patel, Anil Kumar, Noritaka Shimizu, Yutaka Utsuno

Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo · Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba · Advanced Science Research Center, Japan Atomic Energy Agency

nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-11-02

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC)…

Key concepts

Lanczos Strength-Function (LSF)
This technique uses the Lanczos algorithm to efficiently find a limited set of excited states (1+ states) in the intermediate nucleus. Instead of calculating every possible state, it focuses on generating a sufficient representation of the relevant intermediate states needed for NME calculations.
Dual-Sided Lanczos Strength-Function (DLSF)
DLSF performs limited Lanczos iterations starting from both the initial and final nuclear vectors. This generates two sets of intermediate 1+ states, ensuring that the total Gamow-Teller strengths associated with both the parent and daughter nuclei are preserved throughout the calculation.
Block-Lanczos Strength-Function (BLSF)
BLSF uses a block Krylov subspace to speed up calculations. This technique significantly reduces the number of iterations required compared to standard methods, making it computationally efficient for calculating NMEs in larger nuclear systems.
Energy-Denominator-Free Sum
This is a key metric comparing the results from DLSF/BLSF against exact double-Gamow-Teller (DGT) matrix elements. If these sums match, it validates that the intermediate states generated by the Lanczos methods correctly capture all necessary contributions to the decay process.

Terminology

Summary

We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Evaluation of 2νββ decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei Deepak Patel , 1, ∗ Anil Kumar , 2, † Noritaka Shimizu , 2, 1, ‡ and Yutaka Utsuno 3, 1, § 1Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan 2Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tennodai, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8577, Japan 3Advanced Science Research Center, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai, Ibaraki 319-1195, Japan (Dated: November 3, 2026) We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques. The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states.

The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Evaluation of 2νββ decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei Deepak Patel , 1, ∗ Anil Kumar , 2, † Noritaka Shimizu , 2, 1, ‡ and Yutaka Utsuno 3, 1, § 1Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan 2Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tennodai, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8577, Japan 3Advanced Science Research Center, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai, Ibaraki 319-1195, Japan (Dated: November 3, 2026) We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques. The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states.

Both methods simultaneously preserve the total GT strengths associated with the initial and final nuclei. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states. Both methods simultaneously preserve the total GT strengths associated with the initial and final nuclei.

Theoretical Framework

The 2νββ/2νECEC decay NME is expressed as a sum over intermediate 1+ states in the intermediate nucleus. The half-life for the 2νββ decay is expressed as T 2ν 1/2 = 1/G 2ν(gA)4M 2ν squared. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In our calculations, a common energy shift is applied to all intermediate 1+ states to reproduce the experimental energy of the lowest 1+ state [22], except for 130Te, for which the shell-modelpredicted energies are used without a shift because the experimental energy of the lowest 1+ state in 130I is not identified. The half-life for the 2νββ decay is expressed as T 2ν 1/2 = 1 G2ν(gA) 4|M2ν| 2 .

The DLSF method involves performing a limited number of Lanczos iterations for both initial vectors in Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

After constructing the two starting vectors above, the following two formulations are adopted for the respective methods. DLSF method In this approach, we perform a limited number of Lanczos iterations for both initial vectors in Eq.

(3), generating two sets of an equal number of 1+ states for the intermediate nucleus. p. 1
Where the paper says it

DLSF method In this approach, we perform a limited number of Lanczos iterations for both initial vectors in Eq. (3), generating two sets of an equal number of 1+ states for the intermediate nucleus.

The BLSF method utilizes a block Krylov subspace to mitigate the computational bottleneck by substantially decreasing the number of iterations. p. 2
Where the paper says it

These Ritz vectors |ψ R1 i ⟩ are then used as the intermediate 1+ states in the 2νββ/2νECEC NME calculation. BLSF method In the diagonalization procedure for the shell-model Hamiltonian, when a large number of states are to be calculated, the BL method is an efficient approach to mitigate the computational bottleneck of on-the-fly matrix element generation by substantially decreasing the number of iterations, thereby effectively shortening the total elapsed time [15].

Benchmark for 48Ca in f p Shell and Computational Efficiency

The methods were benchmarked for 48Ca in the f p shell using the GXPF1A effective interaction. The cumulative NME calculated with SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF converges to a value of 0. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Using these 59 intermediate 1+ states, the calculated 2νββ NME converges to a value of 0. Similarly, in the BLSF method, 30 iterations generate 60 intermediate 1+ states.

0511 after 30 iterations. p. 3
Where the paper says it

10 C u m ula tiv e M G T 2 MGT 2 = 0. 0511 (a) 30 iterations with SLSF 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 1 + state energies in 48Sc (MeV) 0.

This convergence is achieved within 15 iterations for the SLSF method. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Thus, DLSF and BLSF exhibit very similar convergence behavior in this case. The SLSF method also reaches the fully converged value within 15 iterations, although its cumulative NME shows a somewhat different convergence pattern at 5 and 10 iterations.

The energy-denominator-free (EDF) sums obtained with all three methods reproduce the directly calculated DGT matrix elements, demonstrating that they correctly recover the complete intermediate-state contributions. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We have performed the same comparison for several other candidates across different mass regions and obtained consistent results. The agreement between the energy-denominator-free sums and the directly calculated DGT matrix elements demonstrates that SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF correctly recover the complete intermediate-state contributions for the cases considered here.

Application to Larger Systems in Different Mass Regions

The methods were applied to 48Ca in the sdpf shell, 76Ge in the f5/2pg9/2 shell, and 130Te in the g7/2dsh11/2 shell using different interactions. For 48Ca in the sdpf space, including cross-shell excitations of up to 2ħω reduces the calculated 2νββ NME relative to the full-f p-shell result and brings it closer to the experimental estimate. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Specifically, the methods were applied to 48Ca, 58Ni, 76Ge, and 130Te in the sdpf, f p, f5/2pg9/2, and g7/2dsh11/2 model spaces using the SDPF-MU, GXPF1A, JUN45, and SN100PN interactions, respectively. For 48Ca, including cross-shell excitations of up to 2ℏω in the sdpf model space reduces the calculated 2νββ NME relative to the full-f p-shell result and brings it closer to the experimental estimate.

For 58Ni in the f p shell, a calculation of the 2νβ+EC/2νECEC NME was presented, indicating the need for a more sensitive measurement of the 2νβ+EC half-life. p. 9
Where the paper says it

For 58Ni, we have presented, to our knowledge, the first shell-model calculation of the 2νβ+EC/2νECEC NME. The theoretical 2νβ+EC NME is approximately two orders of magnitude smaller than the current experimental upper limit, indicating the need for a more sensitive measurement of the 2νβ+EC half-life.

Energy-Denominator-Free Sum of the NME Versus Direct Double-GT Transition

The energy-denominator-free sum in the 2νββ/2νECEC NME is compared with the exact DGT matrix element, which provides a stringent test of whether SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF recover the complete intermediate-state contributions. For all nuclei considered, the three methods reproduce the corresponding direct DGT matrix elements. p. 9

Where the paper says it

As an independent validation of the intermediate-state representations, we compared the energy-denominatorfree sums obtained with SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF with the corresponding DGT matrix elements calculated directly between the initial and final ground states. For all nuclei considered, the three methods reproduce the corresponding direct DGT matrix elements.

This agreement demonstrates that the intermediate-state representations generated by these methods recover the complete energydenominator-free sums under the same calculation conditions used for the 2νββ/2νECEC NMEs. p. 9
Where the paper says it

For all nuclei considered, the three methods reproduce the corresponding direct DGT matrix elements. This agreement demonstrates that the intermediate-state representations generated by these methods recover the complete energydenominator-free sums under the same calculation conditions used for the 2νββ/2νECEC NMEs.

Summary and Conclusions

We have developed two approaches for calculating 2νββ/2νECEC NMEs within the nuclear shell model framework, based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos methods. Both approaches avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged 2νββ/2νECEC NMEs using a relatively small number of iterations starting from GT doorway states. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Evaluation of 2νββ decay nuclear matrix elements using Lanczos techniques preserving Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei Deepak Patel , 1, ∗ Anil Kumar , 2, † Noritaka Shimizu , 2, 1, ‡ and Yutaka Utsuno 3, 1, § 1Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan 2Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tennodai, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8577, Japan 3Advanced Science Research Center, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai, Ibaraki 319-1195, Japan (Dated: November 3, 2026) We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2νECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques. The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow–Teller (GT) doorway states.

The methods were first benchmarked for 48Ca in the f p shell using the GXPF1A interaction and were subsequently applied to 2νββ/2νECEC candidates in different mass regions. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Unlike the previous singlesided Lanczos strength-function approach, the present DLSF and BLSF methods simultaneously preserve the total GT strengths associated with both the initial and final nuclei. The methods were first benchmarked for 48Ca in the f p shell using the GXPF1A interaction and were subsequently applied to 2νββ/2νECEC candidates in different mass regions.

The agreement between the energy-denominator-free sums and the directly calculated DGT matrix elements demonstrates that SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF correctly recover the complete intermediate-state contributions for the cases considered here. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We have performed the same comparison for several other candidates across different mass regions and obtained consistent results. The agreement between the energy-denominator-free sums and the directly calculated DGT matrix elements demonstrates that SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF correctly recover the complete intermediate-state contributions for the cases considered here.

The Lanczos strength-function method has previously been applied to evaluate the ultrasoft-neutrino contribution to the 0νββ amplitude of 136Xe. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This agreement demonstrates that the intermediate-state representations generated by these methods recover the complete energydenominator-free sums under the same calculation conditions used for the 2νββ/2νECEC NMEs. The Lanczos strength-function method has previously been applied to evaluate the ultrasoft-neutrino contribution to the 0νββ amplitude of 136Xe [40].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can efficiently calculate two-neutrino double-beta decay (2νββ) and two-electron capture (2νECEC) nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) using dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods. These methods avoid explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates while preserving the total Gamow-Teller strengths from both parent and daughter nuclei.

  2. Improved AI system can benchmark these new computational approaches against existing ones, such as the single-sided Lanczos strength-function (SLSF) method, for various candidate nuclei across different mass regions (e.g., 48Ca in f p shell, 58Ni in f p shell, 130Te in g7/2dsh11/2 shell).

  3. Improved AI system can perform energy-denominator-free sum comparisons by comparing the cumulative energy-denominator-free sums obtained from DLSF and BLSF methods directly with the corresponding exact double-Gamow-Teller (DGT) transition matrix element calculated via a closure relation. This provides an independent validation of the intermediate-state representations, demonstrating that the intermediate-state representations generated by these methods recover the complete energydenominator-free sums under the same calculation conditions.

  4. Improved AI system can determine computational convergence criteria for NMEs, as shown by results indicating that only 30 iterations with each of the SLSF, DLSF, and BLSF methods are sufficient to accurately reproduce the converged NME for 48Ca in the f p shell.

  5. Improved AI system can account for physical effects like center-of-mass motion by incorporating a c.m. Hamiltonian into the shell-model Hamiltonian using H = HSM + beta cmHcm, which is necessary when applying these methods to larger systems like 48Ca with cross-shell excitations up to 2hbar omega in the sdpf model space.

Abstract

We present two efficient shell-model approaches for calculating nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for two-neutrino double-beta (2νββ) decay and two-neutrino double-electron capture (2ν ECEC), based on the Lanczos strength-function and block-Lanczos techniques. The dual-sided Lanczos strength-function (DLSF) and block-Lanczos strength-function (BLSF) methods avoid the explicit calculation of a complete set of exact intermediate 1+ eigenstates and yield fully converged NMEs with a relatively small number of iterations starting from Gamow--Teller (GT) doorway states. Both methods simultaneously preserve the total GT strengths associated with the initial and final nuclei. We benchmark the methods for 48 Ca in the fp shell and apply them to candidates in different mass regions, including 58 Ni, 76 Ge, and 130 Te. For 48 Ca, a calculation allowing cross-shell excitations of up to 2 ω in the sdpf model space yields a 2νββ NME closer to the experimental estimate than the result obtained in the fp shell. For 58 Ni, we present, to our knowledge, the first shell-model calculation of the 2νβ+ EC/ 2ν ECEC NME. Comparison with the current experimental upper limit on the NME indicates the need for a more sensitive measurement of the 2νβ+ EC half-life. As an independent validation, the energy-denominator-free sums obtained with the proposed methods are compared with the corresponding double-GT matrix elements calculated directly between the initial and final ground states. Their agreement demonstrates that the methods correctly recover the complete energy-denominator-free intermediate-state sums.

Sources

Related papers