Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes is studied by deriving an exact expression for the coefficient of a logarithmic enhancement in gravitational wave fluxes emitted by an ultrarelativistic particle near a Schwarzschild black hole at first order in the mass ratio Near the threshold between scattering and capture by a Schwarzschild black hole, a particle spends a long time close to an unstable circular orbit, which in the ultrarelativistic limit approaches the light ring Here we study the behavior of the gravitational wave fluxes emitted by such an ultrarelativistic particle at first order in the mass ratio The fluxes radiated to infinity and absorbed by the horizon diverge as the inverse distance from the light ring multiplied by its logarithm Using the Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin (WKB) approximation to solve the Regge-Wheeler equation and treating the infinite harmonic sum analytically, we derive an exact expression for the coefficient of this logarithmic enhancement and show that it is identical for both fluxes We then estimate the coefficients of the subleading pole contributions by combining numerical calculations at low multipoles with the exact asymptotics at large multipoles Derivation of Flux Asymptotics The energy flux emitted at infinity (∞) and down the horizon (H) behaves like F X/H = α ln(1/δ) + β inf/H δ + o(1/δ) as δ → 0+ We find that the logarithmic divergence is entirely controlled by the WKB calculation, which can be written in an analytical closed form This term is universal, being the same coefficient for both fluxes to infinity and down the horizon, taking the value α ≈ 0.021217676364 Combining numerical results for the low-l modes exactly on the light ring with analytical WKB results for the high-l modes, we also compute numerical values for the subleading pole contribution, which differ between the infinity and horizon fluxes WKB Solution to Radial Equations The radial Regge-Wheeler equation can be rewritten in a form analogous to the stationary Schrödinger equation using a tortoise coordinate x = r − 3 + 2 ln(r − 2) The WKB approximation is valid when the local wavelength varies slowly, namely Q'(x)m Q(x) 3/2≪1 Moreover, as the radius of the orbit approaches the light ring, we will have δ≪1: this is interpreted as the case where the energy is near the peak of the potential The WKB solution is fixed uniquely using standard boundary conditions at r∗ → ±∞ and is valid far from the ‘classical turning points’, which are defined as zeros of Q(x) Asymptotic Behavior of Fluxes The asymptotic behavior of the flux modes reads F inf/H = 1/mδ squared 4p(k)-k!
Kai: 27π/3 (⌊k/2⌋!)2 ×
1 + 2k + mδ squared 1-p(k): e − π(1+2k+mδ) / (4i (1+2k+mδ) 4 / 8) The coefficient of the logarithm solely arises from the large-m asymptotics, which is controlled using WKB It is universal, being the same for the flux at infinity and down the horizon Comparison with Numerical Results The numerical data for very large values of m confirms that the analytical results converge to their predictions The comparison shows that no information from the data at δ > 0 enters Eq.
Mira: (2), as the coefficient α is known in closed form, and β inf/H are determined from the fluxes at δ = 0 Conjecture for Kerr Fluxes We propose that the Kerr mode fluxes admit a WKB expansion F inf/H m+k,m(a) ∼ Φ(a) gˆk(mδ(a)) mδ(a) In the Schwarzschild case (a = 0), we recover r⊙ = 3 and Φ(0) = Ψ(0) = 1, such that δ(0) = r0 − 3 We thus recover our original definition for ε
Eq. [Kai: (30b)] as well as the Schwarzschild expression for the flux Discussion This work has highlighted the efficiency of analytical methods in regions of parameter space where numerical methods become very expensive An obvious extension of this work is that of a particle around a Kerr black hole The analytic coefficient α and the estimated coefficients β inf/H characterize the ultrarelativistic behavior of the coefficient of the logarithmic enhancement of scattering losses near the separatrix The analytical expression for α, derived from an integral representation, is real valued as required because the imaginary part of the integrand is odd in τ and integrates to zero We can thus only keep the real part of the integrand and reduce the integration domain to positive τ The final values obtained are α ≈ +0.021217676364...
Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper today. It’s called "Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes." It focuses on what happens when a particle gets extremely close to the light ring of a black hole as it approaches capture.
Mira: Yeah, it zeroes in on that threshold between scattering and capture and looks at the gravitational wave fluxes emitted by an ultrarelativistic particle near that unstable circular orbit. It’s about how those fluxes diverge as they get really close to the light ring.
Lev: From my side, I'm thinking about what this means for real hardware running error correction codes; if these divergences are this strong, we need to be extremely careful about modeling the losses when simulating these extreme situations.
Kai: Exactly, and what the paper does is derive an exact expression for the coefficient of that logarithmic enhancement in gravitational wave fluxes. It shows that this coefficient is actually the same for both fluxes heading out to infinity and those getting absorbed by the black hole horizon.
Mira: That’s a key result, because it means there’s this universal term controlling that divergence, and they derive it using the Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin WKB approximation to solve the radial equations.
Lev: The WKB approximation is what we use for many of our analyses; it works when the local wavelength changes slowly. What I want to know is how robust this analytical result is when you try to map it onto a real system with finite precision.
Kai: Well, they show that this logarithmic divergence is entirely controlled by that WKB calculation, and they write it down in an analytical closed form which they say reproduces the numerical estimate of alpha found in reference thirty-eight <ref:2610.20708#pg2>.
Mira: They also confirm that this term is universal; it takes the value of alpha approximately zero point zero two one two one seven six three six three four.
Lev: That number, that exact constant for alpha, does it help us when we try to calculate the actual energy and angular momentum losses on real quantum hardware?
Kai: It helps immensely because they also compute numerical values for the subleading pole contributions by combining low-multipole numerical calculations with the exact asymptotics from high multipoles.
Mira: And those subleading contributions, the beta terms, they actually differ between the flux to infinity and the flux down the horizon. They find beta infinity is approximately zero point zero zero zero nine one one seven six and three, and beta H is negative zero point zero three five two eight three zero five.
Lev: That difference between beta infinity and beta H tells us something specific about how we would need to model the losses when we consider both emission and absorption channels in a real simulation.
Kai: It's also interesting because they show that these fluxes determine the divergent parts of scattering losses, both at infinity and at the horizon, right near that separatrix between scattering and capture.
Mira: And they confirm this prediction by comparing their analytical expression for the asymptotic behavior of flux modes with high-precision numerical calculations on hyperboloidal slices, getting relative errors below ten to sixteen at the closest radii.
Title and authors: Lev: That level of precision is important because it shows that even when dealing with these extreme limits, we can get reliable estimates if we use the correct approximation methods.
Kai: They also propose a conjecture for Kerr mode fluxes, suggesting that they admit a WKB expansion of F infinity over H proportional to Phi of a times g hat k times m delta over a.
Mira: That conjecture is really interesting because in the Schwarzschild case, with zero spin, they recover the original definition for epsilon and the Schwarzschild expression for the flux.
Lev: If we extend this idea to Kerr black holes, it means we could use this WKB expansion to test predictions against numerical data for different spins a.
Kai: So what's left is a summary of what all these results mean when you put it together. The paper, "Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes," provides an analytical expression for the coefficient of logarithmic enhancement in gravitational wave fluxes near the light ring that is universal for both infinity and horizon fluxes.
Mira: It’s important to note that they combine WKB methods with numerical results to estimate those subleading pole contributions, like beta infinity and beta H, which are different between the two directions.
Lev: What this means for us in error correction is that we have a solid analytical starting point for these divergences, and we can use it to guide how we should approach more complex numerical modeling of these unstable orbits.
Kai: It also gives us the specific values for alpha and those subleading coefficients, which they show agree very well with their numerical data for unstable circular orbits between three and six M.
Mira: And they suggest that the Kerr mode fluxes might follow a specific WKB expansion involving the spin a, which opens up new avenues for probing more complex black hole spacetimes.
Lev: For me, the implication is that we have a way to quantify these losses analytically at the leading order in mass ratio, which is something we really need when running simulations where we have very small masses relative to the black hole.
Kai: So, in conclusion of this paper on "Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes," they show how analytical methods can capture these divergences as the distance from the light ring approaches zero.
Mira: The main takeaway is that for this specific problem, there’s a universal coefficient for that logarithmic enhancement, and they provide concrete values for both the leading and subleading terms.
Lev: I just want to say that having these analytical tools helps us understand the limits of what we can simulate with our current error correction models before we have to rely purely on brute force numerical methods.
Kai: Right, so that’s what they did with this paper. We're all ready for the next one when we get it in.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper today about gravitational wave fluxes near the light ring of a black hole as something gets really ultrarelativistic.
Mira: It boils down to finding an exact expression for how those fluxes shoot off and diverge when a particle is right on that unstable orbit, especially when it’s approaching capture.
Kai: Basically, they used this Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin approximation to solve the math for the radial equations and figured out that there's a universal coefficient controlling the logarithmic enhancement of these fluxes.
Mira: That universal part is what they found is identical whether you're looking at the flux going off to infinity or the flux getting absorbed by your black hole horizon.
Kai: The results show this coefficient is roughly zero point zero two one two one seven six three six three four and they derive it using an integral representation involving the gamma function.
Mira: They also look at how those other, smaller contributions, the pole terms, behave by combining numerical calculations for low multipoles with these exact asymptotic results from high multipoles.
Kai: Those subleading contributions are different between the flux going to infinity and the flux going down the horizon; they get estimated as zero point zero zero zero nine one one seven six three and negative zero point zero three five two eight three zero five respectively.
Mira: It’s interesting because they show that these analytical methods capture the divergence of both fluxes as you approach the light ring distance, even when you are dealing with a black hole geometry.
Kai: And they actually propose a way to describe how Kerr mode fluxes behave by suggesting a specific Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin expansion involving the spin of the black hole.
Mira: That means if we look at rotating black holes, we can test that proposed expansion against numerical data for different spins to see if it holds up.
Kai: So what this means for us is that we have a solid analytical starting point for quantifying these losses when dealing with small mass ratios and approaching unstable orbits.
Mira: It gives us concrete numbers for the leading and subleading terms, which helps pin down the behavior near the threshold between scattering and capture.
Kai: This work really shows how analytical methods can handle regions of parameter space where running a full numerical simulation would take way too much time.
Mira: The next thing we need to look at is extending this idea to Kerr black holes, because that’s where things get more complex with the spin involved.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, we're looking at how this paper suggests they can improve on their original findings about those gravitational wave fluxes near the light ring.
Mira: They are focusing on how to make the math even more robust by adding an integral representation for that alpha coefficient.
Kai: That integral representation is a way to get that alpha value, which they found using it, because it’s real valued, which is what you need for these kinds of physical quantities.
Mira: It also helps them restrict the integration domain to just positive values of tau, which cleans up the calculation and keeps it mathematically sound.
Kai: And by doing this, they confirm that their calculated alpha value matches what they got from a separate integral representation involving the gamma function.
Mira: This is important because it builds a double check on that universal coefficient for the logarithmic enhancement across different mathematical tools.
Kai: They are also refining how they estimate those subleading pole contributions, the beta terms, by using numerical modes on the light ring and matching them to that large multipole tail.
Mira: This combination is what allows them to get those distinct values for beta infinity and beta H which we saw earlier.
Kai: So what this means is they're not just giving us a number; they're showing us how the analytical structure of the problem dictates exactly where those different behaviors in the fluxes come from.
Mira: It’s like they’ve mapped out the landscape of divergence, telling us precisely which parts of the calculation control which physical effects, whether it's emission or absorption.
Kai: This refinement makes their model more trustworthy for predicting how these fluxes behave when you push them into those extreme ultrarelativistic limits.
Mira: And they are hinting that this whole framework might be extendable to Kerr black holes, which is where the spin of the black hole comes into play.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes."
Mira: Essentially, this paper provides a solid analytical framework for understanding how gravitational wave fluxes behave as a particle gets extremely close to the light ring of a black hole.
Kai: They nail down that universal coefficient for the logarithmic enhancement and give us those specific numbers for the leading and subleading pole terms.
Mira: It means we have these concrete values, like alpha, which helps us benchmark our numerical simulations against known theoretical limits.
Kai: And they show that this analytical method works really well to capture the divergence of both fluxes as you get closer to that threshold.
Mira: This work changes how we model those losses in strong-field gravity because it gives us a way to calculate them even when the math gets impossibly complex for direct simulation.
Lev: For me, this analytical framework is useful because it tells me exactly what kind of precision I need to aim for in my error correction codes when simulating these extreme scattering events.
Kai: Exactly, so we have a better target for what those simulations should be achieving at the leading order in mass ratio.
Mira: And it opens the door for us to test this idea on rotating black holes, which is a much more realistic scenario in astrophysics.
Kai: Right, so we've got this exact expression for alpha and those two subleading terms from that paper.
Lev: I just want to say that having these analytical tools helps us understand the limits of what we can simulate with our current error correction models before we have to rely purely on brute force numerical methods.
Mira: The main thing here is that for this specific problem, there’s a universal coefficient for that logarithmic enhancement, and they provide concrete values for both the leading and subleading terms.
Kai: And they suggest that the Kerr mode fluxes might follow a specific Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin expansion involving the spin of the black hole.
Lev: That means we’re looking at how to implement those higher-order corrections on real hardware, which is where things get really demanding with fidelity requirements.
Mira: The next thing we need to look at is extending this idea to Kerr black holes, because that’s where things get more complex with the spin involved.
Kai: That's what we'll be tackling next time when we look at how those same effects play out around a spinning black hole.
David Trestini, Riccardo Gonzo, Benjamin Leather
Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris · Centre national d’etudes spatiales (CNES) · School of Mathematical Sciences and STAG Research Centre, University of Southampton · Queen Mary University of London
gr-qc, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-10-14
Updated: 2026-11-15
Comments: 20 pages + appendices, 9 figures, 2 ancillary data files. v2: improved numerical checks for Kerr
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes is studied by deriving an exact expression for the coefficient of a logarithmic…
Key concepts
- Light Ring
- The light ring is a specific radius near a black hole where the spacetime structure becomes highly unstable for particles. In this context, it represents the threshold between scattering and capture, where particles spend long times in unstable circular orbits before plunging into the horizon.
- Logarithmic Enhancement
- This refers to a specific type of divergence in gravitational wave fluxes near the light ring. The flux behaves like $1/ ext{distance} imes ext{log}( ext{distance})$, meaning it diverges slowly as one approaches this critical radius, and the paper finds an exact, universal coefficient for this divergence.
- WKB Approximation
- The Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) approximation is a mathematical technique used to solve differential equations (like the Regge-Wheeler equation) when the wavelength of the particle varies slowly. It allows for an analytical solution, which is crucial here for handling the complex asymptotic behavior near the light ring.
- Regge-Wheeler Equation
- This is a key differential equation describing gravitational perturbations (waves) around a Schwarzschild black hole. The paper uses this equation, transformed into an analogous Schrödinger form using tortoise coordinates, and solves it via WKB to find the asymptotic behavior of the particle's radiation fluxes.
Terminology
Summary
Towards ultrarelativistic scattering near the light ring: asymptotic divergence of gravitational-wave fluxes is studied by deriving an exact expression for the coefficient of a logarithmic enhancement in gravitational wave fluxes emitted by an ultrarelativistic particle near a Schwarzschild black hole at first order in the mass ratio Near the threshold between scattering and capture by a Schwarzschild black hole, a particle spends a long time close to an unstable circular orbit, which in the ultrarelativistic limit approaches the light ring Here we study the behavior of the gravitational wave fluxes emitted by such an ultrarelativistic particle at first order in the mass ratio The fluxes radiated to infinity and absorbed by the horizon diverge as the inverse distance from the light ring multiplied by its logarithm Using the Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin (WKB) approximation to solve the Regge-Wheeler equation and treating the infinite harmonic sum analytically, we derive an exact expression for the coefficient of this logarithmic enhancement and show that it is identical for both fluxes We then estimate the coefficients of the subleading pole contributions by combining numerical calculations at low multipoles with the exact asymptotics at large multipoles
Derivation of Flux Asymptotics
The energy flux emitted at infinity (∞) and down the horizon (H) behaves like F X/H = α ln(1/δ) + β inf/H δ + o(1/δ) as δ → 0+ We find that the logarithmic divergence is entirely controlled by the WKB calculation, which can be written in an analytical closed form This term is universal, being the same coefficient for both fluxes to infinity and down the horizon, taking the value α ≈ 0.021217676364 Combining numerical results for the low-l modes exactly on the light ring with analytical WKB results for the high-l modes, we also compute numerical values for the subleading pole contribution, which differ between the infinity and horizon fluxes
WKB Solution to Radial Equations
The radial Regge-Wheeler equation can be rewritten in a form analogous to the stationary Schrödinger equation using a tortoise coordinate x = r − 3 + 2 ln(r − 2) The WKB approximation is valid when the local wavelength varies slowly, namely Q'(x)m Q(x) 3/2≪1 Moreover, as the radius of the orbit approaches the light ring, we will have δ≪1: this is interpreted as the case where the energy is near the peak of the potential The WKB solution is fixed uniquely using standard boundary conditions at r∗ → ±∞ and is valid far from the ‘classical turning points’, which are defined as zeros of Q(x)
Asymptotic Behavior of Fluxes
The asymptotic behavior of the flux modes reads F inf/H = 1/mδ squared 4p(k)-k! 27π/3 (⌊k/2⌋! p. 8)2 × [1 + 2k + mδ squared 1-p(k)] e − π(1+2k+mδ) / (4i (1+2k+mδ) 4 / 8) The coefficient of the logarithm solely arises from the large-m asymptotics, which is controlled using WKB It is universal, being the same for the flux at infinity and down the horizon
Comparison with Numerical Results
The numerical data for very large values of m confirms that the analytical results converge to their predictions The comparison shows that no information from the data at δ > 0 enters Eq. (2), as the coefficient α is known in closed form, and β inf/H are determined from the fluxes at δ = 0
Conjecture for Kerr Fluxes
We propose that the Kerr mode fluxes admit a WKB expansion F inf/H m+k,m(a) ∼ Φ(a) gˆk(mδ(a)) mδ(a) In the Schwarzschild case (a = 0), we recover r⊙ = 3 and Φ(0) = Ψ(0) = 1, such that δ(0) = r0 − 3 We thus recover our original definition for ε [Eq. (30b)] as well as the Schwarzschild expression for the flux
Discussion
This work has highlighted the efficiency of analytical methods in regions of parameter space where numerical methods become very expensive An obvious extension of this work is that of a particle around a Kerr black hole The analytic coefficient α and the estimated coefficients β inf/H characterize the ultrarelativistic behavior of the coefficient of the logarithmic enhancement of scattering losses near the separatrix
Conclusion
The analytical expression for α, derived from an integral representation, is real valued as required because the imaginary part of the integrand is odd in τ and integrates to zero We can thus only keep the real part of the integrand and reduce the integration domain to positive τ The final values obtained are α ≈ +0.021217676364. p. 2.. β inf/H ≈ +0.0009117(6) β H ≈ −0. p. 20352830(5) The α coefficient agrees with the numerical estimate of Eq. p. 2 (3) of Ref. p. 1 [38] The distinct subleading pole coefficients β inf and β H are estimated by combining numerical modes on the light ring with the analytical large-m tail
Appendix A
The coefficients appearing in Eqs. (23) and (11) are given by complex expressions involving r0 and m
Appendix B
The derivation of the WKB solution involves matching the asymptotic behavior of the parabolic cylinder functions to those of the WKB solutions in regions I, II, and III The standard “in” and “up” solutions are uniquely specified by their asymptotics
Appendix C
The asymptotic expression for sYm+k,m(π/2, 0) is given by Eq. (35) in the main text We find that at subleading order in m, we only require α i, 2i-n(k, s) for n ∈ [[0, 3]]
Appendix D
An integral representation of α is derived using the integral representation of the gamma function The final expression for α is given by Eq. (D7) in the main text The sum over k can be performed exactly, yielding a convergent series
Appendix E
The paper concludes by comparing the asymptotic expansion with numerical results, showing that the analytical expression captures the divergence of both fluxes as δ → 0+ The numerical error is negligible in comparison to the analytical prediction
REFERENCES
[1] C. W. Misner, R. A. Breuer, D. R. Brill, P. L. Chrzanowski, H. G. Hughes, and C M Pereira, Gravitational synchrotron radiation in the schwarzschild geometry, Phys Rev Lett 28 998 (1972)
[2] M Davis R Ruffini J Tiomno and F Zerilli Can synchrotron gravitational radiation exist Phys Rev Lett 28 1352 (1972)
[3] J M Bardeen W H Press and S A Teukolsky Rotating black holes: Locally nonrotating frames energy extraction scalar synchrotron radiation Astrophys J 178 347 (1972)
[4] D M Chitre and R H Price Nature of gravitational synchrotron radiation Phys Rev Lett 29 185 (1972)
[5] R A Breuer J Tiomno and C V Vishveshwara Polarization of gravitational synchrotron radiation Lett Nuovo Cim 4S2 857 (1972)
[6] R A Breuer R Ruffini J Tiomno and C V Vishveshwara Vector and tensor radiation from schwarzschild relativistic circular geodesics Phys Rev D 7 1002 (1973)
[7] R A Breuer P L Chrzanowski H G Hughes and C W Misner Geodesic synchrotron radiation Phys Rev D 8 4309 (1973)
[8] P L Chrzanowksi and C W Misner Geodesic synchrotron radiation in the Kerr geometry by the method of asymptotically factorized Green’s functions Phys Rev D 10 1701 (1974)
[9] R A Breuer Gravitational Perturbation Theory and Synchrotron Radiation Lecture Notes in Physics Vol 44 Springer Berlin Heidelberg 1975
[10] E Poisson Gravitational radiation from a particle in circular orbit around a black hole Phys Rev D 47 1497 (1993)
[105] S A Teukolsky and W H Press Perturbations of a rotating black hole Astrophys J 185 635 (1973)
[26] S Iyer and C M Will Black Hole Normal Modes A WKB Approach. Foundations and Application of a Higher Order WKB Analysis of Potential Barrier Scattering Phys Rev D 35 3621 (1987)
[27] S Iyer BLACK HOLE NORMAL MODES A WKB APPROACH. 2 SCHWARZSCHILD BLACK HOLES Phys Rev D 35 3632 (1987)
[28] J W Guinn C M Will Y Kojima and B F Schutz High Overtone Normal Modes of Schwarzschild Black Holes Class Quant Grav 7 L47 (1990)
[29] K D Kokkotas and B F Schutz Black Hole Normal Modes A WKB Approach 3 The Reissner-Nordstrom Black Hole Phys Rev D 37 3378 (1988)
[30] E Seidel and S Iyer BLACK HOLE NORMAL MODES A WKB APPROACH 4 Kerr Black Holes Phys Rev D 41 374 (1990)
[31] C M Will and J W Guinn Tunneling near the peaks of potential barriers Consequences of higher-order Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin corrections Phys Rev A 37 3674 (1988)
[32] K W Ford D L Hill M Wakano and J A Wheeler Quantum effects near a barrier maximum Annals of Physics 7 239 (1959)
[40] T Damour and A Nagar Faithful effective-one-body waveforms of small-mass-ratio coalescing black-hole binaries Phys Rev D 76 064028 (2007)
[43] L Barack R Gonzo B Leather O Long N Warburton Resummed energy loss in extrememass-ratio scattering using critical orbits Phys Rev D 113 104042 (26) including data in UnstableCircularOrbitFluxes.dat
[56] C Heissenberg and R Russo Revisiting gravitational angular momentum and mass dipole losses in the eikonal framework Class Quant Grav 42 045014 (2025)
[67] D Bini T Damour and A Geralico Radiated momentum and radiation reaction in gravitational two-body scattering including time-asymmetric effects Phys Rev D 107 024012 (23)
The coefficients entering Eq. (14) read 0blm = s(l − 1)l(l + 1)(l + 2) r0 4 (r0 − 3) 0Y l mπ/2, 0, -1blm = s(l − 1)(l + 2) r0-3-1Y l mπ/2, 0, -2blm = s 1 r0 (r0 − 3)-2Y l mπ/2, 0
The integral representation of α is derived using the integral representation of the gamma function The final expression for α is given by Eq. (D7) in the main text The sum over k can be performed exactly, yielding a convergent series
[1] C. W. Misner, R. A. Breuer, D. R. Brill, P. L. Chrzanowski, H G Hughes and C M Pereira Gravitational synchrotron radiation in the schwarzschild geometry Phys Rev Lett 28 998 (1972)
[2] M Davis R Ruffini J Tiomno and F Zerilli Can synchrotron gravitational radiation exist Phys Rev Lett 28 1352 (1972)
[3] J M Bardeen W H Press and S A Teukolsky Rotating black holes: Locally nonrotating frames energy extraction scalar synchrotron radiation Astrophys J 178 347 (1972)
[4] D M Chitre and R H Price Nature of gravitational synchrotron radiation Phys Rev Lett 29 185 (1972)
[5] R A Breuer J Tiomno and C V Vishveshwara Polarization of gravitational synchrotron radiation Lett Nuovo Cim 4S2 857 (1972)
[6] R A Breuer R Ruffini J Tiomno and C V Vishveshwara Vector and tensor radiation from schwarzschild relativistic circular geodesics Phys Rev D 7 1002 (1973)
[8] P L Chrzanowksi and C W Misner Geodesic synchrotron radiation in the Kerr geometry by the method of asymptotically factorized Green’s functions Phys Rev D 10 1701 (1974)
[9] R A Breuer Gravitational Perturbation Theory and Synchrotron Radiation Lecture Notes in Physics Vol 44 Springer Berlin Heidelberg 1975
[10] E Poisson Gravitational radiation from a particle in circular orbit around a black hole Phys Rev D 47 1497 (1993)
[105] S A Teukolsky and W H Press Perturbations of a rotating black hole Astrophys J 185 635 (1973)
[26] S Iyer and C M Will Black Hole Normal Modes A WKB Approach. Foundations and Application of a Higher Order WKB Analysis of Potential Barrier Scattering Phys Rev D 35 3621 (1987)
[27] S Iyer BLACK HOLE NORMAL MODES A WKB APPROACH. 2 SCHWARZSCHILD BLACK HOLES Phys Rev D 35 3632 (1987)
[28] J W Guinn C M Will Y Kojima and B F Schutz High Overtone Normal Modes of Schwarzschild Black Holes Class Quant Grav 7 L47 (1990)
[29] K D Kokkotas and B F Schutz Black Hole Normal Modes A WKB Approach 3 The Reissner-Nordstrom Black Hole Phys Rev D 37 3378 (1988)
[30] E Seidel and S Iyer BLACK HOLE NORMAL MODES A WKB APPROACH 4 Kerr Black Holes Phys Rev D 41 374 (1990)
[31] C M Will and J W Guinn Tunneling near the peaks of potential barriers Consequences of higher-order Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin corrections Phys Rev A 37 3674 (1988)
[32] K W Ford D L Hill M Wakano and J A Wheeler Quantum effects near a barrier maximum Annals of Physics 7 239 (1959)
[40] T Damour and A Nagar Faithful effective-one-body waveforms of small-mass-ratio coalescing black-hole binaries Phys Rev D 76 064028 (2007)
[43] L Barack R Gonzo B Leather O Long N Warburton Resummed energy loss in extrememass-ratio scattering using critical orbits Phys Rev D 113 104042 (26) including data in UnstableCircularOrbitFluxes.dat
[56] C Heissenberg and R Russo Revisiting gravitational angular momentum and mass dipole losses in the eikonal framework Class Quant Grav 42 045014 (2025)
[67] D Bini T Damour and A Geralico Radiated momentum and radiation reaction in gravitational two-body scattering including time-asymmetric effects Phys Rev D 107 024012 (23)
The asymptotic expression for sYm+k,m(π/2, 0) is given by Eq.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved analytical control over gravitational wave fluxes near the light ring by providing an exact expression for the coefficient of logarithmic enhancement, which is identical for both fluxes to infinity and absorbed by the horizon.
-
Enhanced ability to estimate subleading pole contributions at large multipoles by combining numerical calculations at low multipoles with exact asymptotics at large multipoles.
-
Capability to analytically compute the divergent parts of energy and angular momentum losses, specifically providing expressions like delta E infinity/H = nu squared r0 squared F infinity/H(r0) p/(6M - r0) ln Lcrit(r0) Lp - Lcrit(r0).
-
Precision in characterizing the asymptotic behavior of spin-weighted spherical harmonics by providing explicit expressions for sYl m (pi/2, 0) in terms of partitions and Stirling numbers.
-
Accurate numerical validation of analytical results by comparing WKB expressions for fluxes near the light ring with high-precision numerical calculations on hyperboloidal slices, achieving relative errors below 10 to 16 at the closest radii.
-
Prediction of Kerr mode flux behavior by conjecturing a WKB expansion F infinity/H m+k,m(a) Phi(a) g hat k (m delta(a)) m delta(a), which allows for testing predictions against numerical data for various spins a.
Sources
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- Geodesic stability, Lyapunov exponents and quasinormal modes
- On an Expansion Method for Black Hole Quasinormal Modes and Regge Poles
- Analytic determination of high-order post-Newtonian self-force contributions to gravitational spin precession
- A semi-analytic treatment of quasinormal excitation factors in the eikonal regime
- Modeling the horizon-absorbed gravitational flux for equatorial-circular orbits in Kerr spacetime
- Divergences in gravitational-wave emission and absorption from extreme mass ratio binaries
- Comparing Effective-One-Body gravitational waveforms to accurate numerical data
- Faithful Effective-One-Body waveforms of small-mass-ratio coalescing black-hole binaries
- Improved resummation of post-Newtonian multipolar waveforms from circularized compact binaries
- From the confluent Heun equation to a new factorized and resummed gravitational waveform for circularized, nonspinning, compact binaries
- Resummed energy loss in extreme-mass-ratio scattering using critical orbits
- Amplitudes, Observables, and Classical Scattering
- Radiative contribution to classical gravitational scattering at the third order in $G$
- Radiative Classical Gravitational Observables at $\mathcal O(G^3)$ from Scattering Amplitudes
- Gravitational Bremsstrahlung in the Post-Minkowskian Effective Field Theory
- Radiated momentum in the Post-Minkowskian worldline approach via reverse unitarity
- Classical Gravitational Bremsstrahlung from a Worldline Quantum Field Theory
- Radiated Angular Momentum and Dissipative Effects in Classical Scattering
- Classical Gravitational Observables from the Eikonal Operator
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals