A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays reveals that while exact SU(3)F symmetry leads to a significant disagreement with Standard Model predictions, this discrepancy can be resolved by including approximately 20% SU(3)F breaking effects in the analysis Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper investigates the decay amplitudes for B¯ → DP and B¯ → DP¯ decays under the assumption of flavor SU(3) symmetry
SU(3)F: and includes SU(3)F-breaking corrections The authors find that a fit to the 15 measured branching ratios of B¯ → DP decays shows a > 5σ disagreement with the SMSU(3)F limit, which can be removed by adding ∼ 20% SU(3)F-breaking effects Furthermore, a combined fit of B¯ → DP and B¯ → DP¯ decays again finds a > 5σ disagreement with the SMSU(3)F limit, which is explained by including ∼ 60% SU(3)F-breaking effects.
Kai: Formalism of Amplitudes The analysis employs reduced matrix elements (RMEs) and topological diagrams to describe the decay amplitudes in both the SU(3)F limit and with SU(3)F-breaking corrections In the SU(3)F limit, B¯ → DP decays involve three RMEs: O15¯, O6, and O¯3 For B¯ → DP¯ decays, four RMEs appear: S15, S3, Tbar6, and T3.
Mira: SU(3)F-breaking corrections are introduced via the spurion field Qbrk = uu¯ + d¯d − 2ss¯ This leads to a set of 9 SU(3)F-breaking RMEs for B¯ → DP and 13 for B¯ → DPbar decays.
Kai: Observable Analysis The observables used in the analysis include branching ratios, defined as B(B¯ → f) = Af 2Φ, and direct CP asymmetries (ACP), defined as ACP ≡ Γ(B¯ → f) − Γ(B → ¯f) / Γ(B¯ → f) + Γ(B → ¯f) Direct CP asymmetry can only be generated if the decay B¯ → f involves at least two contributing amplitudes with nonzero relative weak and strong phases, which is not the case for all B¯ → DP decays.
Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper "A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays," it seems the main message is that exact flavor SU(three) symmetry fails when you look at these decays in the Standard Model <ref:2610.20611#pg1,A global analysis of B>.
Mira: Exactly. The authors show that while a small amount of breaking, about twenty percent, can fix the individual B to DP fits, combining all the data requires more, suggesting up to sixty percent breaking might be necessary <ref:2610.20611#pg3>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it means that if we were trying to build a detector or a machine that measures these decays and wants it to match reality, we can't rely on the simplest SU(three) symmetry assumption alone; we need to account for those breaking terms <ref:2610.20611#pg1>.
Kai: Right. And the title itself sets up this analysis—it’s not just about B to DP decays in isolation, but looking globally at both B to DP and B to D P bars <ref:2610.20611#pg1>.
Mira: It points out that these amplitudes can actually interfere with each other when you look at direct and indirect CP asymmetries, which is why they include all those observables in their combined fit <ref:2610.20611#pg3>.
Lev: It tells us that the Standard Model isn't perfectly capturing the dynamics here, and those SU(three)F breaking terms are what bridge the gap between theory and measurement <ref:2610.20611#pg1>.
Kai: So, this paper suggests that to understand these B decays fully, we can’t just stick to perfect symmetry; we have to include that significant breaking effect in our models <ref:2610.20611#pg3>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper, "A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays," it looks at how we measure these B meson decays using flavor SU(three) symmetry and what that actually tells us about the Standard Model.
Mira: It’s not just one kind of decay they’re looking at; they're combining both the B to D P and the B to D P bar decays, which is important because it lets them test things more robustly.
Lev: From my side, it means we can’t treat these measurements in isolation anymore. If you only look at one set of data, you’re missing a lot of context about how the decay amplitudes behave overall.
Kai: Exactly. The authors found that to get a good fit to all those measured branching ratios and CP asymmetries, exact flavor SU(three) symmetry just doesn't work on its own in this Standard Model setup.
Mira: They show that you need about twenty percent of SU(three) breaking effects just for the B to D P decays by themselves.
Lev: But when they combine all twenty-five observables, including both the B to D P and B to D P bar channels, that number jumps up significantly. They found you might need sixty percent breaking effects just to get a good fit across the board.
Kai: So what does that actually mean for us? It suggests that if we want our models of these decays to match reality, we have to include those SU(three) breaking terms in our calculations, not just ignore them.
Mira: It’s a big signal because it points toward where the Standard Model might be missing some pieces in how these particles interact.
Lev: For the hardware side, that means any real experiment trying to measure this needs to be very careful about those breaking effects; you can't just assume perfect symmetry in your error calculations.
Kai: And this leads us right into how they actually calculated those amplitudes and what those specific breaking terms are that are causing all this trouble.
Department of Natural Sciences, Lawrence Technological University · Physique des Particules, Université de Montrບl
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-10-14
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 36 pages, 3 figures, submitted to a volume of "Journal of Physics G" honouring Ashutosh Kumar Alok; typos corrected in this version 2
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays reveals that while exact SU(3)F symmetry leads to a significant disagreement with Standard Model predictions…
Key concepts
- SU(3)F Symmetry
- This is a theoretical assumption that flavor symmetry exists between different quark generations (up, down, strange). In this context, it simplifies the description of B meson decays by assuming certain relationships between decay amplitudes are fixed. When exact SU(3)F is assumed, it severely disagrees with measured experimental results.
- SU(3)F-breaking corrections
- These are small deviations from the perfect SU(3) symmetry assumption. The analysis introduces these corrections to account for the differences observed in real-world decays. By including these effects, the theoretical predictions can be made to match the experimental data much more closely.
- Branching Ratios
- Branching ratios are a measure of how often a specific decay channel occurs compared to all possible decays of a B meson. The analysis uses these measured values as key observables. They are calculated by multiplying the absolute value squared of the decay amplitude by some normalization factor.
- Direct CP Asymmetry (ACP)
- This observable measures the difference in decay rates between a particle and its antiparticle, normalized by their total rates. A non-zero ACP indicates that there are different weak and strong phases involved in the decay process, which is necessary for this asymmetry to occur.
Terminology
Summary
A global analysis of B to DP and B to D P decays reveals that while exact SU(3)F symmetry leads to a significant disagreement with Standard Model predictions, this discrepancy can be resolved by including approximately 20% SU(3)F breaking effects in the analysis
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The paper investigates the decay amplitudes for B¯ → DP and B¯ → DP¯ decays under the assumption of flavor SU(3) symmetry [SU(3)F] and includes SU(3)F-breaking corrections The authors find that a fit to the 15 measured branching ratios of B¯ → DP decays shows a > 5σ disagreement with the SMSU(3)F limit, which can be removed by adding ∼ 20% SU(3)F-breaking effects Furthermore, a combined fit of B¯ → DP and B¯ → DP¯ decays again finds a > 5σ disagreement with the SMSU(3)F limit, which is explained by including ∼ 60% SU(3)F-breaking effects.
Formalism of Amplitudes
The analysis employs reduced matrix elements (RMEs) and topological diagrams to describe the decay amplitudes in both the SU(3)F limit and with SU(3)F-breaking corrections In the SU(3)F limit, B¯ → DP decays involve three RMEs: O15¯, O6, and O¯3 For B¯ → DP¯ decays, four RMEs appear: S15, S3, Tbar6, and T3. SU(3)F-breaking corrections are introduced via the spurion field Qbrk = uu¯ + d¯d − 2ss¯ This leads to a set of 9 SU(3)F-breaking RMEs for B¯ → DP and 13 for B¯ → DPbar decays. p. 4
Observable Analysis
The observables used in the analysis include branching ratios, defined as B(B¯ → f) = Af 2Φ, and direct CP asymmetries (ACP), defined as ACP ≡ Γ(B¯ → f) − Γ(B → ¯f) / Γ(B¯ → f) + Γ(B → ¯f) Direct CP asymmetry can only be generated if the decay B¯ → f involves at least two contributing amplitudes with nonzero relative weak and strong phases, which is not the case for all B¯ → DP decays.
Fit Scenarios and Results
The study performs three types of fits: Fit 1 (B¯ → DP only), Fit 2 (B¯ → DPbar only), and Fit 3 (combined fit) Hypothesis (a), exact SU(3)F symmetry, is rejected by the combined data with χ 2min/d.o.f = 153.4/12. Hypothesis (b), up to 30% SU(3)F breaking, is found to be sufficient to explain the data in B¯ → DP decays alone However, for the combined fit of all 25 observables under hypothesis (b), χ 2min = 16. p. 199, suggesting that greater than 30% SU(3)F breaking is preferred. p. 0 Hypothesis (c), allowing up to 60% SU(3)F breaking, yields a better fit with χ 2min = 2. p. 08.
Conclusion on Breaking Effects
The combined analysis of B¯ → DP and B¯ → DPbar decays indicates that the > 5σ discrepancy with SMSU(3)F in the exact SU(3)F limit is removed by adding ∼ 60% SU(3)F-breaking effects. The data confirms hypothesis (b), but suggests that greater than 30% SU(3)F breaking is needed when including CP-violating observables in the combined fit. p. 0
Model-Independent Relationships
In the combined fit under hypothesis (c), an additional contribution to χ 2min of ∼ 1.4 arises from a model-independent relationship between indirect CP asymmetries and branching ratios in B¯0 → D+π− and B¯0 → D−π+. p. 0 This suggests that 60% SU(3)F breaking is sufficient to explain the combined data, as χ 2min = 2. p. 08 for R ≥ 60%.
Acknowledgments
This work was financially supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. PHY-2609773 (B.B.) and by NSERC of Canada (R. p. 0B., D.L.) The authors acknowledge the financial support received from these organizations.
Appendix A
The appendix details the equivalence between RMEs and diagrams in both SU(3)F-invariant and SU(3)F-breaking cases For B¯ → DP decays, three RMEs are related to three diagrams in the SU(3)F limit. In the SU(3)F-breaking case, eight RMEs and eight diagrams are related For B¯ → DPbar decays, eleven RMEs and eleven diagrams are related when SU(3)F breaking is included. p. 6 The relationships for these equivalences are explicitly listed in Appendix A. p. 6
References
[1] R. Berthiaume, B. Bhattacharya, R. p. 0 Boumris, A. p. 0 Jean, S. Kumbhakar, and D. London, Anomalies in Hadronic B Decays, Phys Rev Lett 133 211802 (2024), arXiv:2311. p. 018011
[2] B. Bhattacharya, M. p. 0 Bouchard, L. Hudy, A Jean, D London, and C MacKenzie, Anomalies in hadronic B decays An update Phys Rev D 112 056014 (2025), arXiv:2505. p. 011492
[3] J. Davies, S Schacht, N Skidmore, and A Soni, Reappraisal of SU(3)-flavor breaking in B→DP Phys Rev D 109 113006 (2024), arXiv:2403.04878
[4] M Gronau and D London, How to determine all the angles of the unitarity triangle from B0d→DKS and B0s→Dphi Phys Lett B 253 483–488 (1991)
[5] M Gronau and D Wyler, On determining a weak phase from CP asymmetries in charged B decays Phys Lett B 265 172–176 (1991)
[6] M Gronau, O F Hernandez, D London, and J L Rosner, Broken SU(3) symmetry in twobody B decays Phys Rev D 52 6356–6373 (1995), arXiv:hep-ph/9504326
[7] M Gronau, O F Hernandez, D London, and J L Rosner, Decays of B mesons to two light pseudoscalars Phys Rev D 50 4529–4543 (1994), arXiv:hep-ph/96>
[8] M Gronau, O F Hernandez, D London, and J L Rosner, Electroweak penguins and two-body B decays Phys Rev D 52 6374–6382 (1995), arXiv:hep-ph/9504327
[9] S Navas et al. (Particle Data Group), Review of particle physics Phys Rev D 110 030001 (2024)
[10] R Fleischer and E Malami, Using B0s → Dmp K Decays as a Portal to New Physics Phys Rev D 106 56004 (2022), arXiv:2109.04950
[11] D Atwood, I Dunietz, and A Soni, Enhanced CP violation with B → KD0 (D 0) modes and extraction of the CKM angle gamma Phys Rev Lett 78 3257–3260 (1997), arXiv:hepph/9612433
[12] I Dunietz and R Sachs, Asymmetry Between Inclusive Charmed and Anticharmed Modes in B0, Anti-b0 Decay as a Measure of CP Violation Phys Rev D 37 3186 (1988)
[13] R Fleischer, New strategies to obtain insights into CP violation through Bs → D±s K∓, D∗±s K∓,... and Bd → D±π∓, D∗±π∓ decays Nucl Phys B 671 459–482 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/03]
[14] R Fleischer, New, efficient and clean strategies to explore CP violation through neutral B decays Phys Lett B 562 234–244 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/03]
[15] B Kayser and D London, Exploring CP Violation with B0d → DKS Decays Phys Rev D 35 (1999), arXiv:hep-ph/99)
[16] D Atwood and A Soni, Getting β − α without penguins Phys Rev D 68 033009 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/02]
[17] R Fleischer, A Closer look at Bd,s → Dfr decays and novel avenues to determine γ Nucl Phys B 659 321–355 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/03]
[18] R Aleksan, I Dunietz, and B Kayser, Determining the CP Violating Phase gamma Z. Phys C 54 653–660 (1992)
[19] K De Bruyn, R Fleischer, R Knegjens, M Merk, M Schiller, and N Tuning, Exploring Bs → D(∗)s Kmp Decays in the Presence of a Sizable Width Difference ΔΓs Nucl Phys B 868 351–367 (2013), arXiv:1208.6463
[20] Y S Amhis et al. (HFLAV), Averages of b-hadron, c-hadron, and τ-lepton properties as of 2021 Phys Rev D 107 052008 (2023), arXiv:hep-ex/23]
[21] F James and M Roos, Minuit: A System for Function Minimization and Analysis of the Parameter Errors and Correlations Comput Phys Commun 10 343–367 (1975)
[22] Y S Amhis et al. (HFLAV), Averages of b-hadron, c-hadron, and τ-lepton properties as of 2018 Eur Phys J C 81 226 (2021), arXiv:hep-ex/19]
Table I: List of B¯ → DP decays and B¯ → DPbar decays
The table lists the decay modes for B¯ → DP and B¯ → DPbar decays
Table IV: Branching ratios for B¯ → DP decays
This table shows the measured values of the branching ratios for various B¯ → DP decays
Table V: Branching ratios for B¯ → DPbar decays
This table shows the measured values of the branching ratios for various B¯ → DPbar decays
Table VI: Direct CP asymmetries in B− → DP − decays, P = π, K
This table lists the direct CP asymmetries in B− → DP − decays
Table VII: Direct and indirect CP-asymmetries in neutral B-meson decays
This table lists the direct and indirect CP-asymmetries in neutral B-meson decays
Table VIII: Summary of various fits detailed in this section
This table summarizes the various fits performed, including the number of observables, parameters, and degrees of freedom (d.o.f.)
Table IX: Best-fit values of the parameters for the fit of B¯ → DP decays assuming exact SU(3)F symmetry
This table shows the best-fit values for the five unknown parameters when assuming exact SU(3)F symmetry
Table X: Best-fit values of the parameters for the fits of ∆S = 0 and ∆S = 1 B¯ → DP decays, respectively on the left and right
This table shows the best-fit values for the parameters when fitting individual ∆S = 0 and ∆S = 1 B¯ → DP decays
Table XI: Best-fit values of the 15 fit parameters for hypothesis (b)
This table presents the best-fit values of the 15 fit parameters when testing hypothesis (b), up to 30% SU(3)F breaking
Table XIII: Best-fit values of the 19 parameters for the fit of B¯ → DPbar decays assuming hypothesis (b)
This table presents the best-fit values of the 19 parameters when testing hypothesis (b) for B¯ → DPbar decays
Table XIX: Best-fit values of the 35 fit parameters for the combined fit to B¯ → DP and B¯ → DPbar decays, assuming hypothesis (b)
This table presents the best-fit values of the 35 parameters when testing hypothesis (b) for combined data
Table XVIII: Sizeable contributions to χ 2min from CP-violating observables in the combined fit to B¯ → DP and B¯ → DPbar decays under hypothesis (b)
This table lists the size of the contributions to χ 2min from CP-violating observables in the combined fit
This table presents the best-fit values of the 35 parameters when testing hypothesis (b) for combined data.
Table XX: Sizeable contributions to χ 2min from CP-violating observables in the combined fit to B¯ → DP and B¯ → DPbar decays under hypothesis (b)
This table lists the size of the contributions to χ 2min from CP-violating observables in the combined fit.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Automated SU(3)F breaking estimation: The AI system can now automatically assess which level of SU(3)F breaking is required to explain measured branching ratios by comparing the chi squared minimum values from fits assuming different symmetry limits (hypothesis a, b, and c).
-
Interference prediction engine: The system can predict whether direct or indirect CP asymmetries will be generated in B to DP decays based on whether D0 and D-bar0 mesons decay to the same final state, as described by
This happens if the D0 and D-bar0 decay to the same final state (e.g., K+K−, π+π−, K±π∓, etc.)
. -
Parameter space exploration for new physics: The system can systematically explore parameter spaces defined by SU(3)F breaking ratios up to 60% and determine if the required deviation from exact symmetry is consistent with experimental constraints or suggests new physics beyond the Standard Model.
-
CP asymmetry extraction tool: The AI can perform a combined fit of all 25 observables, including direct and indirect CP asymmetries, to test hypotheses about SU(3)F breaking, allowing for the extraction of CKM angles like gamma using measured values from Table XIV.
Sources
- Anomalies in Hadronic $B$ Decays
- Anomalies in Hadronic $B$ Decays: an Update
- Reappraisal of SU(3)-flavor breaking in $B\rightarrow DP$
- Broken SU(3) Symmetry in Two-Body B Decays
- Decays of $B$ Mesons to Two Light Pseudoscalars
- ELECTROWEAK PENGUINS AND TWO-BODY B DECAYS
- Using $B^0_s\to D_s^\mp K^\pm$ Decays as a Portal to New Physics
- Enhanced CP Violation with $B\to K D^0 (\overline D^0)$ Modes and Extraction of the CKM Angle gamma
- New Strategies to Obtain Insights into CP Violation Through $B_s\to D_s^{\pm}K^\mp, D_s^{\ast\pm}K^\mp, ...$ and $B_d\to D^{\pm}\pi^\mp, D^{\ast\pm}\pi^\mp, ...$ Decays
- New, Efficient and Clean Strategies to Explore CP Violation Through Neutral B Decays
- Exploring CP Violation with B_d -> D K_s Decays
- Getting beta-alpha without penguins
- A Closer Look at $B_{d,s}\to D f_r$ Decays and Novel Avenues to Determine $\gamma$
- Exploring $B_s \to D_s^{(*)\pm} K^\mp$ Decays in the Presence of a Sizable Width Difference $\Delta\Gamma_s$
- Averages of $b$-hadron, $c$-hadron, and $\tau$-lepton properties as of 2021
- Averages of $b$-hadron, $c$-hadron, and $\tau$-lepton properties as of 2018
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses