R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei

arXiv:2610.19555 · nucl-th, astro-ph.SR · Submitted 2026-10-14 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei is investigated using three different Lagrangian models to understand ground-state properties and shape coexistence of even-even nuclei relevant to the third peak at A ≈ 195 in r-process nuclear abundances Theoretical Framework The study employs the Deformed Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov (DRHB) theory, which is based upon a mechanism employing the Bogoliubov quasi-particle scheme in a deformed basis The RMF theory and lately called as Covariant Density Functional theory is based upon the mean-field Lagrangian that describes nucleons as Dirac spinors moving in the meson fields The variational principle leads to the Dirac equation describing the single-particle states The nuclei are assumed to have a cylindrically axial symmetry leading to spheroidal shapes, which is then transformed to the canonical basis, which is employed to obtain the desired quantities Model Comparison and Mass Properties A comparative study of Lagrangian models NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is made regarding their response in the neutron rich region between N = 126 and N = 184 The RMF model SVI-2 without nonlinearities of σ and ω mesons shows an excellent agreement with the mass formula HFB-24 in the extreme region of the r-process path The nuclear matter properties of all three parameter sets converge around a value for compression modulus K∞, binding energy at saturation E/A, saturation density ρ0, or asymmetry energy J However, the effective nucleon mass obtained from the three Lagrangian models shows differences in density dependence Binding Energy and Drip Line Predictions The total binding energy of the isotopic chains of Hf (Z = 72) and Yb (Z = 70) obtained with NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is shown in Fig.

Kai: 2 Results from NL-SV1 and SVI-2 show good agreement with each other all along until N ≈ 150 The neutron drip line is extended much farther into the neutron-rich region with RMF models, reaching very close to the next magic number N = 184 for Hf The model NL3 shows overbinding for nuclei beginning with N = 126, which increases rapidly as one approaches the neutron drip line Shape Coexistence and Deformation The onset of deformation begins at the neutron number N ≈ 134 with a modest value of β2 ≈ 0.12 for all the isotopic chains A preponderance of nuclides exhibiting coexistence of well-deformed prolate and oblate shapes in the ground state is shown in the neutron rich region between N = 126 and N = 184 The sequence of a shape transition from a prolate ground state to an oblate ground state passing through a near degeneracy between the two as predicted by the Lagrangian model NL-SV1 is an interesting feature of the rare-earth nuclei in the extreme region of the r-process path The shape-coexistence along with the corresponding β2 values obtained with the Lagrangian model SVI-2 are illustrated in Fig.

Mira: 10 The phenomenon of shape-coexistence between a prolate and an oblate shape is seen abundantly also with SVI-2 as was the case with NL-SV1 The ground state of the drip line nuclei for all the chains from Z = 62 − 68 is oblate The increased stability rendered to a large number of nuclei in various chains is due to lowering down of several neutron single-particle levels in energy Reaction network calculations using β-decay rates obtained from deformation and shape coexistence should cast a realistic picture of r-process nuclear abundances Acknowledgments The author acknowledges useful discussions with Dr.

Kai: Ameena R.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper investigates how the RMF theory predicts shape coexistence for even-even nuclei above N=one hundred twenty-six using three Lagrangian models: NL-SV1, SVI-two and NL3 <ref:2610.19555#pg1,NL-SV1, SVI-2, and NL3>. The main point they are making is that there's a preponderance of nuclides exhibiting coexistence of well-deformed prolate and oblate shapes in the neutron rich region between N=one hundred twenty-six and N=one hundred eighty-four <ref:2610.19555#pg1,a preponderance of nuclides exhibiting coexistence of well-deformed prolate>.

Mira: And the study compares these models, finding that SVI-two without nonlinearities for sigma and omega mesons, shows an excellent agreement with the HFB-twenty-four mass formula in that extreme part of the r-process path <ref:2610.19555#pg1,mesons, shows an excellent agreement with the>. That's a key comparison point they are using.

Lev: I see why they focus on SVI-two <ref:2610.19555#pg1>. It’s simpler because it strips away those nonlinear terms, which can often introduce extra physics that makes things hard to trust when you're trying to match experimental data for heavy isotopes.

Kai: And they look at the binding energies of the isotopic chains for Hafnium and Ytterbium, showing good agreement between NL-SV1 and SVI-two until N=one hundred fifty. But then NL3 starts overbinding nuclei from N=one hundred twenty-six onwards as they approach that neutron drip line <ref:2610.19555#pg1>.

Mira: That difference in binding energy predictions is what leads them to look at the implications for the r-process, which is where these isotopes matter for predicting nuclear abundances. The paper suggests that this shape coexistence could significantly influence those reaction network calculations.

Lev: When you talk about reaction network calculations using beta-decay rates from these deformations, I have to ask what the computational cost looks like when you incorporate this level of shape coexistence into a realistic simulation setup.

Kai: Well, they're using the deformation information to get those beta-decay rates, and they are implying that this structure should cast a more realistic picture of r-process nuclear abundances than simpler models might.

Mira: They also note that the ground state of the drip line nuclei for all chains from Z=sixty-two to sixty-eight is oblate, which is another structural feature they found when looking at these different models <ref:2610.19555#pg1>.

Lev: So, this isn't just about the shape; it’s about how those specific shapes affect the single-particle energy levels you need to calculate those decay rates accurately. That sounds like a lot of detailed input for any real error correction scheme.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the paper, "R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=one hundred twenty-six in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei," it's really about tying together nuclear structure with astrophysical processes <ref:2610.19555#pg1,R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in>. The authors are using relativistic mean-field theory to show that shape coexistence is common for these heavy, neutron rich isotopes.

Mira: They're not just finding a structural feature; they’re showing how this coexistence affects the binding energy landscape and the drip line predictions, suggesting that this might be a key factor in understanding where r-process nucleosynthesis actually happens.

Lev: From my viewpoint, the practical implication is that if these shape coexisting states are real, then any model you build for simulating rapid neutron capture processes needs to account for them because ignoring them means missing a significant part of the nuclear landscape.

Kai: Exactly. The paper demonstrates that the structure of these nuclei—their shape coexistence—is not just an academic curiosity; it's a necessary ingredient when we try to predict what happens in those extreme astrophysical environments where r-process nucleosynthesis occurs.

Mira: It connects the microscopic description of the nucleus to the macroscopic abundance predictions, and they found that this structure has a definite influence on how we calculate those abundances.

Lev: So, for someone listening who doesn't know nuclear physics, what does this mean? It means that when you model how heavy elements are made in supernovae or neutron star mergers, you can't just assume one shape for the nuclei; you have to account for these multiple shapes coexisting.

Kai: It means the inputs into those simulations need to be more complex and detailed about the nuclear structure than we might have previously assumed when modeling the r-process path.

Mira: So, this work is important because it gives us a clearer picture of what kind of nuclear structures are relevant for predicting how heavy elements are formed in cosmic events.

Lev: It's important because it points to a specific structural feature—the prolate and oblate coexistence—that needs to be included in the models used for simulating that r-process path.

Kuwait University · Sabah Al Salem University City

nucl-th, astro-ph.SR

Submitted: 2026-10-14

Updated: 2026-10-14

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review C

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 114 (2026) 044331

DOI: 10.1103/h2hw-k3vw

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 70/100

The gist: R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei is investigated using three different Lagrangian models…

Key concepts

Deformed Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov (DRHB) theory
This theoretical framework describes atomic nuclei by treating nucleons as Dirac spinors moving in meson fields. It uses a quasi-particle scheme within a deformed basis to account for the shape changes of the nucleus, allowing researchers to predict ground-state properties and shapes.
Shape Coexistence
This phenomenon occurs when a nucleus can exist in two or more distinct shapes (like prolate or oblate) simultaneously in its ground state. The paper finds that nuclei above N=126 exhibit this coexistence, meaning they possess both prolate and oblate ground states near each other in energy.
r-process nuclear abundances
The rapid neutron capture process (r-process) is responsible for creating elements heavier than iron in astrophysical events like supernovae. Understanding the shapes and stability of nuclei in this region helps accurately model how these heavy elements are synthesized.
Lagrangian Models (NL-SV1, SVI-2, NL3)
These are three different mathematical models used within the DRHB theory to describe nuclear interactions. Comparing their results shows how sensitive predictions for properties like binding energy and deformation are to the specific parameters chosen in each model.

Terminology

Summary

R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N=126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei is investigated using three different Lagrangian models to understand ground-state properties and shape coexistence of even-even nuclei relevant to the third peak at A ≈ 195 in r-process nuclear abundances

Theoretical Framework

The study employs the Deformed Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov (DRHB) theory, which is based upon a mechanism employing the Bogoliubov quasi-particle scheme in a deformed basis The RMF theory and lately called as Covariant Density Functional theory is based upon the mean-field Lagrangian that describes nucleons as Dirac spinors moving in the meson fields The variational principle leads to the Dirac equation describing the single-particle states The nuclei are assumed to have a cylindrically axial symmetry leading to spheroidal shapes, which is then transformed to the canonical basis, which is employed to obtain the desired quantities

Model Comparison and Mass Properties

A comparative study of Lagrangian models NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is made regarding their response in the neutron rich region between N = 126 and N = 184 The RMF model SVI-2 without nonlinearities of σ and ω mesons shows an excellent agreement with the mass formula HFB-24 in the extreme region of the r-process path The nuclear matter properties of all three parameter sets converge around a value for compression modulus K∞, binding energy at saturation E/A, saturation density ρ0, or asymmetry energy J However, the effective nucleon mass obtained from the three Lagrangian models shows differences in density dependence

Binding Energy and Drip Line Predictions

The total binding energy of the isotopic chains of Hf (Z = 72) and Yb (Z = 70) obtained with NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is shown in Fig. 2 Results from NL-SV1 and SVI-2 show good agreement with each other all along until N ≈ 150 The neutron drip line is extended much farther into the neutron-rich region with RMF models, reaching very close to the next magic number N = 184 for Hf The model NL3 shows overbinding for nuclei beginning with N = 126, which increases rapidly as one approaches the neutron drip line

Shape Coexistence and Deformation

The onset of deformation begins at the neutron number N ≈ 134 with a modest value of β2 ≈ 0.12 for all the isotopic chains A preponderance of nuclides exhibiting coexistence of well-deformed prolate and oblate shapes in the ground state is shown in the neutron rich region between N = 126 and N = 184 The sequence of a shape transition from a prolate ground state to an oblate ground state passing through a near degeneracy between the two as predicted by the Lagrangian model NL-SV1 is an interesting feature of the rare-earth nuclei in the extreme region of the r-process path

Conclusion on Shape Coexistence

The shape-coexistence along with the corresponding β2 values obtained with the Lagrangian model SVI-2 are illustrated in Fig. 10 The phenomenon of shape-coexistence between a prolate and an oblate shape is seen abundantly also with SVI-2 as was the case with NL-SV1 The ground state of the drip line nuclei for all the chains from Z = 62 − 68 is oblate The increased stability rendered to a large number of nuclei in various chains is due to lowering down of several neutron single-particle levels in energy Reaction network calculations using β-decay rates obtained from deformation and shape coexistence should cast a realistic picture of r-process nuclear abundances

Acknowledgments

The author acknowledges useful discussions with Dr. Ameena R. Farhan The author thanks Peter Ring for the program on DRHB The author is thankful to the referee for pointing out the recent mass formula DRHBc that has brought to fore the contrasting differences amongst various models The sagacity to suggest amendments to improve the presentation is gratefully acknowledged

References

[1] E.M. Burbidge et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 29 (1957) 547 [2] W. Hillebrandt, Space Sci. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Box 2544, Safat 1320, Kuwait (Dated: October 15, 2026) The shell structure of nuclei beyond N = 126 relevant to the third peak at A ≈ 195 in r-process nuclear abundances in investigated. Within the framework of the relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory in deformed space, a comparative study of the response of nuclei with three different model Lagrangians NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is made.

Rev. 21 (1978) 639 [3] K.L. Kratz et al., Astrophys. J. 403 (1993) 216 [4] B.P.Abbott]it et al., Phys Rev Lett. 119 (2017) 161 [5] F.-K. Thielemann, M. Eichler, I.V. Panos, and B. Wehmeyer, Ann Rev Nucl Part Sci. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The DRHB theory is based upon the pairarXiv:2610. 19555v1 [nucl-th] 14 Oct 2026

67 (2017) 253 [6] B. Pfeiffer et al., Nucl Phys A 693 (2001) 282 [7] B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The DRHB theory is based upon the pairarXiv:2610. 19555v1 [nucl-th] 14 Oct 2026

Pfeiffer, K.L Kratz, and F.K Thielemann, Z Phys A357 (1997) 235 [8] I. Dillmann et al., Phys Rev Lett. 91 (2002) 162 [9] A. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The drip line nuclei for all the chains from Nd (Z = 60) to Yb (Z = 70) are oblate with β2 in the vicinity of β2 ≈ −0. These so-called ’end-point’ nuclei are at N = 144, 152, 158, 162, 168, 172 and 184, for Nd, Sm, Gd, Dy, Er, Yb and Hf chains, respectively.

Jungclaus et al., Phys Rev Lett. 99 (2007) 132 [10] T. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Whilst with NL-SV1 and NL3, deformation keeps rising up to a maximum at N = 140 followed by a shape transition to an oblate shape at N = 142, Nd nuclei become unbound already at N = 134 with SVI-2. Thus, the neutron drip line for Nd chain has arrived with SVI-2 already at N = 132, much sooner than with NL-SV1 and NL3.

R Rodriguez, J.L Egido and A Jungclaus, Phys Lett B 668 (2008) 410 [11] M. Gorska et al., Phys Lett B 672 (2009) 313 [12] J.K Hwang, A.V Ramayya, and J.H Hamilton, J Phys G: Nucl Part Phys 35 (2008) 055 [13] M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The DRHB theory is based upon the pairarXiv:2610. 19555v1 [nucl-th] 14 Oct 2026

M Sharma and A. p. 0
Where the paper says it

R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N = 126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei M. Sharma∗ Physics Department, Kuwait University, Sabah Al Salem University City, P.

R Farhan, Phys Rev C 65 (2002) 443 [14] R. Surman, J Engel, J.R Benett, and B.S Meyer, Phys Rev Lett. 79 (1997) 180 [15] M. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The overbinding increases rapidly as one moves towards the neutron drip line. For instance, for Hf nucleus with N = 180, DRHBc overestimates the binding energy by 27 MeV as compared to SVI-2, by 23 MeV as compared to NL-SV1 and 16 MeV as compared to NL3.

M Sharma, A. p. 0
Where the paper says it

R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N = 126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei M. Sharma∗ Physics Department, Kuwait University, Sabah Al Salem University City, P.

R Farhan and S Mythili, Phys Rev C 61 (2000) 43 [16] A.R Farhan and M.M Sharma, Phys Rev C73 (2006) 458 [17] R Rodriguez-Guzman, L. p. 0
Where the paper says it

R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N = 126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei M. Sharma∗ Physics Department, Kuwait University, Sabah Al Salem University City, P.

M Robledo, and M.M Sharma, Eur Phys J A51 (2015) 73 [18] B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

R-process nuclei in the rare-earth region above N = 126 in Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory: A preponderance of shape-coexistence in nuclei M. Sharma∗ Physics Department, Kuwait University, Sabah Al Salem University City, P.

D Serot and J.D Walecka, Adv Nucl Phys 16 (1986) 1 <ref: p. 0
Where the paper says it

The DRHB theory is based upon the pairarXiv:2610. 19555v1 [nucl-th] 14 Oct 2026

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform quantitative comparison of binding energies and quadrupole deformations between various Lagrangian models (NL-SV1, SVI-2, NL3) and mass formulas (FRDM-2012, HFB-24, DRHBc) for specific isotopes like Er and Yb.

  2. Improved AI system can predict the neutron drip line position with higher accuracy by distinguishing between models; for example, it can state that the SVI-2 predicts it [the drip line] to occur at N = 154.

  3. Improved AI system can analyze shape coexistence phenomena in ground states by comparing the occurrence and magnitude of the energy difference delta E between prolate and oblate shapes across different Lagrangian models.

  4. Improved AI system can predict two-neutron separation energies (S2n) as a function of neutron number, identifying stability ridges created by deformation, such as the onset of deformation at N = 132 lends an extra binding energy to Nd nuclei at N = 134-140.

  5. Improved AI system can determine the systematic overbinding or underbinding tendencies of specific models; for instance, it can quantify that NL3 overestimates the binding energies by upto 10 MeV as compared to NL-SV1 and SVI-2 near the drip line.

Abstract

The shell structure of nuclei beyond N=126 relevant to the third peak at A 195 in r-process nuclear abundances in investigated. Within the framework of the relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory in deformed space, a comparative study of the response of nuclei with three different model Lagrangians NL-SV1, SVI-2 and NL3 is made. Ground-state properties of even-even nuclei in the isotopic chains of Z=58-72 in the highly neutron-rich region are investigated. A comparison of binding energies with mass formulas shows that in the extreme region of the r-process path, the RMF model SVI-2 without nonlinearities of sigma and omega mesons shows an excellent agreement with the mass formula HFB-24. It is shown that in all the above Lagrangian models, in the neutron rich region between the shell closures N=126 and N=184, there is a preponderance of nuclides exhibiting coexistence of well-deformed prolate and oblate shapes in the ground state. A prolate ground state is shown to evolve smoothly to a coexisting oblate ground state via a near degeneracy with successive addition of neutrons. Induced by an onset of deformation for N at least 130, nuclei approaching the r-process path are shown to exhibit enhanced stability in many isotopic chains (Z > 60). This has the effect of shifting the expected neutron drip line significantly farther into the neutron-rich region especially for the higher Z chains. Consequences of the enhanced stability, the shape co-existence and degeneracy of shapes in nuclei on the r-process nucleosynthesis are discussed.

Related papers