Time-temperature-composition equivalence of the glass transition in digitally mixed 3D-printed polymers

arXiv:2610.14986 · cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-10-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Time-temperature-composition equivalence of the glass transition in digitally mixed 3D-printed polymers".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper introduces a Time-Temperature-Composition Equivalence (TTCE) to describe the linear viscoelastic behavior of digitally mixed polymers created through multimaterial 3D printing, which is important because it provides a unified description for designing architected and functionally graded structures based on composition, temperature, and loading frequency The core finding is that the storage modulus of all five digitally mixed compositions collapses onto one master curve via a single reduced variable that combines the three factors Establishing the Equivalence The authors extend the classical time–temperature equivalence (TTE) to composition by establishing a TTCE across all measured temperatures, frequencies, and compositions.

Kai: This equivalence is demonstrated by showing that temperature and frequency enter through one reduced variable that combines the three factors.

Mira: Compositional Effects on Viscoelasticity Composition is shown to translate the transition, stretch its breadth, and increase the rubbery plateau modulus.

Kai: Specifically, for digitally mixed polymers, increasing the Vero fraction moves the glass transition to higher temperatures and broadens the transition while increasing the rubbery plateau modulus.

Paper summary: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper from arXiv called "Time-temperature-composition equivalence of the glass transition in digitally mixed three dee-printed polymers <ref:2610.14986#pg1,Time-temperature-composition equivalence of the>." It’s about how you can describe a whole family of these mixed materials using just three variables: time, temperature, and composition.

Mira: Exactly. The big idea here is that they extend the time–temperature equivalence, which is classical TTE, to include composition in these digitally mixed polymers made through multimaterial three dee printing <ref:2610.14986#pg1>. What they claim is that the storage modulus of all five different compositions collapses onto one master curve using a single reduced variable that combines temperature and frequency.

Lev: So, it's not just about fitting data; they are proposing a unified description for designing architected structures based on composition, temperature, and loading frequency. That sounds like it could simplify the design process significantly if we can predict the behavior across all those dimensions simultaneously.

Kai: It matters because these digitally mixed polymers are a new class of materials—they're elastomeric and glassy resins mixed voxel by voxel in specific ratios during three dee printing, which is what they call digitally mixed polymers <ref:2610.14986#pg1,mixed voxel by voxel in>.

Mira: Right. The authors show that composition doesn't just add noise; it actively moves the glass transition, it stretches its breadth, and it increases the rubbery plateau modulus of these materials. Specifically, increasing the Vero fraction moves the glass transition to higher temperatures and broadens that transition while increasing the rubbery plateau modulus of the material.

Lev: That suggests that composition is a very active ingredient in determining how stiff or compliant a structure will be under different conditions, which is crucial when we think about how these materials will perform in real-world applications.

Kai: Mathematically, they formulate this equivalence by expressing the storage modulus as log10 E prime equals log10 E prime r plus delta multiplied g of u, where u is a reduced variable defined by z equals log10 f plus log10 a T (T; phi V).

Mira: And that reduced variable z is what ties everything together. The glass transition index g follows the master curve g of u equals exp minus exp minus u. This formula shows how temperature and frequency enter through this single reduced variable, which is the core of their time-temperature-composition equivalence.

Lev: For a real hardware scenario, that means we don't need to test every single composition individually across every temperature and frequency point; we just need to map it onto that master curve defined by z. The overhead for running this model would be in establishing the initial calibration data for all those five compositions they tested.

Paper summary: Kai: They didn't stop there though. They extended this equivalence to the loss and the relaxation spectrum by using position shift and breadth stretch operations, showing that the phase angle also superposes under the same translation and stretch as the storage modulus.

Mira: That’s a strong point because it means you get a consistent description for both how much energy is stored, which is related to stiffness, and how much energy is lost, which relates to damping. Plus, they found that a Prony series fitted jointly to the TTE master curves of the storage modulus and loss factor reproduces their behavior.

Lev: A Prony series fitting both factors simultaneously would be computationally intensive for real-time simulation on hardware; we'd need a very robust method for extracting those relaxation times from just the measured data.

Kai: The implication here is pretty big for how we design things, because this TTCE provides a physical basis for designing functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures.

Mira: Because the closed-form TTCE gives us the storage and loss moduli directly, which guides graded and architected designs for elasticity and dissipation. This principle makes composition a third variable of viscoelastic behavior alongside temperature and frequency.

Lev: So, if we are designing something complex, like a lattice structure that needs to have specific stiffness in one part and specific damping in another, this framework gives us a direct path to specifying those properties based on the material's composition within the three dee print <ref:2610.14986#pg1>.

Kai: They also mapped the storage modulus and loss factor over the plane of composition and temperature at a fixed frequency, showing that a change of composition is equivalent to a change of temperature across certain stiffness contours.

Mira: But there's this caveat they highlight: equal stiffness does not imply equal damping because composition moves the plateaus and stretches the transition. That’s an important distinction for design specifications.

Lev: That means you can target a specific stiffness contour, but you have to be careful about the resulting energy dissipation, which is vital for things like vibration control or impact absorption in those three dee printed parts <ref:2610.14986#pg1>.

Kai: And they looked at how fabrication variables enter this framework by showing how a fabrication variable translates, stretches, and moves plateaus in the TTE structure.

Mira: This suggests that a similar TTCE might hold for other three dee printing processes that set composition voxel by voxel <ref:2610.14986#pg1>. It’s not just limited to this specific digitally mixed family of materials.

Lev: If it holds generally, it means we could apply these equivalence principles to other additive manufacturing techniques where material mixing is controlled at the smallest scale.

Kai: Physically, the basis for this TTCE rests on the mobility of molecular chain segments in the polymer. Increasing the Vero fraction slows segmental motion and broadens the distribution of relaxation times across all those measurements.

Paper summary: Mira: So each mixture behaves like one single material whose molecular mobility is somewhere in between two reference states, specifically intermediate between Agilus and Vero. That gives us a physical intuition for why composition matters so much here.

Lev: Understanding that intermediate mobility is key because it explains the observed stretching and shifting of the transition, which is what we'd see if we tried to model this with a simple single-material TTE approach.

Kai: The study was calibrated on five compositions printed on one machine and holds for the linear viscoelastic response at small strain, and they verified everything across five compositions from the neat elastomeric resin to the neat glassy resin.

Mira: It’s rigorous because they took a comprehensive look at different material limits to build this model, ensuring that it covers the full range of material behaviors relevant to three dee printing <ref:2610.14986#pg1>.

Lev: The paper also notes that while this TTCE is calibrated on five specific compositions, the authors acknowledge that they are exploring how this principle might extend beyond those initial calibration points.

Kai: This leads us into what we call the conclusion of this discussion about "Time–temperature–composition equivalence of the glass transition in digitally mixed three dee-printed polymers <ref:2610.14986#pg1,Time–temperature–composition equivalence of the>."

Mira: Essentially, they’ve established a closed-form mathematical relationship that allows you to calculate the storage and loss moduli for an entire family of these mixtures continuously across composition, temperature, and frequency.

Lev: This means that by knowing your composition within the printed part, you can predict its stiffness and damping properties without having to run separate tests for every single combination of temperature or frequency.

Kai: The implication is that this TTCE provides a physical basis for designing functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures. It makes composition a third variable of viscoelastic behavior alongside temperature and frequency.

Mira: That’s the main point—it gives designers a tool to guide the creation of complex, graded parts where you control both mechanical stiffness and energy dissipation precisely based on the material mix.

Lev: For real-world implementation, this means we can use this framework to predict how a part will behave under different thermal loads or dynamic stresses before we even start printing it.

Kai: So, the whole concept hinges on composition being intrinsically linked to shifting and stretching those key viscoelastic features—the transition and the plateaus—in a predictable way.

Mira: Precisely; when you change the Vero fraction, you are changing how that material samples its space in time, which is what drives all those observed changes in modulus.

Lev: It’s about understanding that molecular mobility across these mixtures isn't just a linear average; it has a specific intermediate character that dictates the entire response.

Kai: That gives us a solid starting point for how we should approach modeling these complex, voxel-by-voxel manufactured materials in future simulations.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up our look at this paper on "Time–temperature–composition equivalence of the glass transition in digitally mixed three dee-printed polymers."

Mira: Yeah, basically they’ve built a unified way to describe how these mixed materials behave using just time, temperature, and composition.

Lev: So they found that all five different material mixes collapse onto one master curve when you use that reduced variable.

Kai: It means you don't need to test every single mixture separately across every frequency and temperature point if you use this rule.

Mira: Composition isn't just some random noise; it actively moves the glass transition and stretches out how wide that transition is.

Lev: That stretching is important because it affects how stiff or compliant the part ends up being.

Kai: The authors show that a change in composition acts like a shift in temperature across certain stiffness levels.

Mira: And they found that this equivalence actually extends to the loss factor too, meaning you get a consistent picture of both storage and dissipation.

Lev: That’s interesting because it suggests we can design architected structures based on these material mixes with more predictable performance.

Kai: So, in simple terms, this paper gives us a mathematical tool to predict the mechanical response of these three dee printed polymers by just knowing their composition.

Mira: It makes composition a third key variable alongside temperature and frequency when you're designing things like functionally graded parts.

Lev: The real impact is that it gives designers a physical basis for controlling both stiffness and damping in these complex, voxel-by-voxel materials.

Kai: We need to see if this principle holds up when we try to apply it to other types of additive manufacturing processes.

Beijun Shen, Sanat K. Kumar, Mary C. Boyce

Department of Mechanical Engineering, Columbia University · Department of Chemical Engineering, Columbia University

cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-10-10

Updated: 2026-11-01

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures; Supporting Information appended (7 pages)

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: The paper introduces a Time-Temperature-Composition Equivalence (TTCE) to describe the linear viscoelastic behavior of digitally mixed polymers created through multimaterial 3D printing…

Key concepts

Time-Temperature-Composition Equivalence (TTCE)
A unified mathematical relationship showing how the mechanical properties of digitally mixed polymers are affected by time, temperature, and material composition simultaneously. It allows engineers to predict behavior across different conditions using a single master curve.
Reduced Variable (z)
A single variable combining the effects of frequency and temperature (z = log10 f + log10 aT). This variable captures how time and temperature influence the polymer's relaxation processes, simplifying the description of viscoelastic changes.
Compositional Effects
How changing the ratio of different polymers in a mixture alters mechanical properties. Specifically, increasing one component (like Vero fraction) shifts the glass transition temperature higher and broadens its transition range while increasing stiffness.

Terminology

Summary

The paper introduces a Time-Temperature-Composition Equivalence (TTCE) to describe the linear viscoelastic behavior of digitally mixed polymers created through multimaterial 3D printing, which is important because it provides a unified description for designing architected and functionally graded structures based on composition, temperature, and loading frequency

The core finding is that the storage modulus of all five digitally mixed compositions collapses onto one master curve via a single reduced variable that combines the three factors

Establishing the Equivalence

The authors extend the classical time–temperature equivalence (TTE) to composition by establishing a TTCE across all measured temperatures, frequencies, and compositions. This equivalence is demonstrated by showing that temperature and frequency enter through one reduced variable that combines the three factors. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Every composition shows a single glass transition and obeys TTE. The proposed TTCE will show that the storage modulus of all five, at every measured temperature and frequency, collapses onto one master curve via a single reduced variable that combines the three.

Compositional Effects on Viscoelasticity

Composition is shown to translate the transition, stretch its breadth, and increase the rubbery plateau modulus. Specifically, for digitally mixed polymers, increasing the Vero fraction moves the glass transition to higher temperatures and broadens the transition while increasing the rubbery plateau modulus. p. 9

Where the paper says it

The present family is made by digitally mixing an elastomeric resin (Agilus) and a glassy resin (Vero). Increasing the Vero fraction is found to move the glass transition to higher temperature, broaden the transition and increase the rubbery plateau modulus.

Mathematical Formulation of TTCE

The storage modulus of each composition is expressed as log10 E′ = log10 E′r + ∆ · g(u), where u is a reduced variable defined by z = log10 f + log10 aT (T; ϕV). The glass-transition index g follows the master curve g(u) = exp[− exp(−u)]. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Both are in decades of reduced frequency and depend on composition, as discussed below. Against u, the index of every composition is found to follow one master curve, g(u) = exp[− exp(−u)] .

Extension to Loss and Spectrum

The equivalence extends to the loss and the relaxation spectrum by using the position shift and breadth stretch operations. The phase angle is found to superpose under the same translation and stretch as the storage modulus. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Composition will be shown to translate the transition and to also stretch the breadth of the transition, and to increase the rubbery plateau modulus. Furthermore, the phase angle and the relaxation spectrum are then found to superpose under the same translation and stretch as the storage modulus.

Furthermore, a Prony series fitted jointly to the TTE master curves of the storage modulus and loss factor reproduces its behavior. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Figure 6b tests the equivalence of the relaxation spectrum. A Prony series was fitted jointly to the TTE master curves of the storage modulus and loss factor of each composition, with one relaxation mode per decade of relaxation time (Methods and Supplementary Figure 2).

Implications for Design

The TTCE provides a physical basis for designing functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures. The closed-form TTCE gives the storage and loss moduli, guiding graded and architected designs for elasticity and dissipation. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The phase angle and relaxation spectrum superpose under the same operations, so the family shares one distribution of relaxation times. A single closed-form TTCE gives the storage and loss moduli of the family, guiding graded and architected designs for elasticity and dissipation.

This principle makes composition a third variable of viscoelastic behavior alongside temperature and frequency. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Specifically, we extend the classical TTE principle to composition and establish, experimentally, a TTCE of the glass transition and the viscoelastic response. Figure 1 presents the concept with sketches of the dependence of the storage modulus on temperature, frequency and composition.

Stiffness and Damping Relationships

The study maps the storage modulus and loss factor over the plane of composition and temperature at a fixed frequency. It is shown that a change of composition is equivalent to a change of temperature across certain stiffness contours. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Along any contour, a change of composition is thus equivalent to a change of temperature. The measured 1 Hz sweeps, which are not used to build the map, cross 1000, 100 and 30 MPa within 4 ◦C of the computed contours (open circles, Supplementary Table 3).

Equal stiffness does not imply equal damping because composition moves the plateaus and stretches the transition. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Composition, however, also moves the plateaus and stretches the transition. Two compositions of equal stiffness sit at different points of their transitions, and their phase angles scale with different values of ∆/W (Section 2.

Fabrication Variable Integration

The work shows how a fabrication variable enters the framework of TTE by translating, stretching, and moving plateaus. This suggests a similar TTCE might hold for other 3D printing processes that set composition voxel by voxel. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Multimaterial 3D printing provides new opportunities in design. A designer can choose the material composition at each voxel, set by the mixing ratio, and the spatial arrangement of compositions within the part[3, 4].

Conclusion on Molecular Mobility

The physical basis of the TTCE rests on the mobility of molecular chain segments, where increasing the Vero fraction slows segmental motion and broadens the distribution of relaxation times. Each mixture thus behaves as one material whose molecular mobility is intermediate between Agilus and Vero. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Figure 4a sketches these differences for Agilus, an intermediate mixture and Vero. We capture them in one expression by writing the storage modulus of each composition as log10 E ′ = log10 E ′ r + ∆ · g(u), ∆ = log10 E ′ g − log10 E ′ r , (1) where E′ r and E′ g are the rubbery and glassy plateau values of the master curve of that composition, and ∆ is the increase of log10 E′ from rubbery to glassy (Figure 4a).

Summary of Key Results

The TTCE provides a unified description for the viscoelasticity of the digitally mixed family. Temperature and frequency act only through z, which translates the transition along the frequency axis and leaves its shape unchanged. p. 6

Where the paper says it

In summary, Equations (1) to (5) provide the TTCE for the storage modulus. Temperature and frequency act only through z: they translate the transition of a composition along the frequency axis and leave its shape unchanged.

Composition, in contrast, translates and stretches the distribution and moves the plateaus. p. 6
Where the paper says it

A different reference temperature shifts z and zc by the same amount and leaves W and u unchanged. Composition also translates the transition, and in addition stretches the transition and moves the plateaus.

This equivalence rests on and supports the homogeneous mixing of the two resins. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A designer can choose the material composition at each voxel, set by the mixing ratio, and the spatial arrangement of compositions within the part[3, 4]. The two choices underlie architected and energy-absorbing composites[5–7], functionally graded structures[8–10], composites with programmed shape memory[11, 12], and viscoelastic metamaterials and wearable devices in which stiffness and damping are distributed by design[13, 14].

Final Synthesis for Design

The closed-form TTCE gives the storage and loss moduli, and hence the stiffness and damping, of the entire family continuously in composition, temperature and frequency. Four quantities of a composition, its two plateaus, its position and its breadth, together with its shift factors return its full linear viscoelastic response. p. 5

Where the paper says it

No composition serves as a reference, because each transition carries its own anchor point zc. The position and breadth are the only fitted quantities, and both are found to be linear in the Vero fraction.

The TTCE principle thus provides a physical basis for the design of functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The TTCE, calibrated on five compositions, describes the entire digitally mixed family. The equivalence provides a physical basis for the design of functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures.

This paper makes composition a third variable of viscoelastic behavior alongside temperature and frequency. p. 0
Where the paper says it

E-mail(s): mb3814@columbia. edu; Abstract The linear viscoelastic behavior of a polymer shows an equivalence of loading frequency and temperature, the time–temperature equivalence (TTE).

Methodological Rigor

The study was calibrated on five compositions printed on one machine and holds for the linear viscoelastic response at small strain. The TTCE is calibrated on five compositions, from the neat elastomeric resin to the neat glassy resin. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Composition, given by the Vero volume fraction ϕV , is intrinsic to the material, fixed at printing, and moves the glass transition. We measure five compositions, from the neat elastomeric resin to the neat glassy resin, through the glass transition at four frequencies over three decades of frequency.

The authors verified all content and take full responsibility for the paper

Data Availability

Source data for Figures 2, 3 and 5 to 7 and Supplementary Figures 1 and 2 will be provided with the paper

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by Columbia University. The authors thank Prof. Yevgeniy Yesilevskiy for laboratory management and equipment maintenance, and Dr. Will Hunnicutt for DMA training and for coordinating equipment use at the Carleton Laboratory, Columbia University. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Kumar2 , Mary C. Boyce1* 1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Columbia University, New York, NY, 10027, USA.

Author Contributions

B.S.: conceptualization, methodology, investigation, formal analysis, data curation, software, validation, visualization, writing (original draft, review and editing). S.K.K.: methodology, writing (review and editing). p. 5

Where the paper says it

Figure 4a sketches these differences for Agilus, an intermediate mixture and Vero. We capture them in one expression by writing the storage modulus of each composition as log10 E ′ = log10 E ′ r + ∆ · g(u), ∆ = log10 E ′ g − log10 E ′ r , (1) where E′ r and E′ g are the rubbery and glassy plateau values of the master curve of that composition, and ∆ is the increase of log10 E′ from rubbery to glassy (Figure 4a).

M.C.B.: conceptualization, methodology, supervision, funding acquisition, resources, writing (review and editing). p. 5
Where the paper says it

Figure 4a sketches these differences for Agilus, an intermediate mixture and Vero. We capture them in one expression by writing the storage modulus of each composition as log10 E ′ = log10 E ′ r + ∆ · g(u), ∆ = log10 E ′ g − log10 E ′ r , (1) where E′ r and E′ g are the rubbery and glassy plateau values of the master curve of that composition, and ∆ is the increase of log10 E′ from rubbery to glassy (Figure 4a).

Competing Interests

The authors declare no competing interests. The paper is titled Time–temperature–composition equivalence of the viscoelastic behavior through the glass transition of digitally mixed 3D-printed polymers

References

[1] Mueller, J., Courty, D., Spielhofer, M., Spolenak, R. & Shea, K. Mechanical properties of interfaces in inkjet 3D printed single- and multi-material parts

[2] Zorzetto, L. et al. Properties and role of interfaces in multimaterial 3D printed composites

[3] Truby, R. L. & Lewis, J. A. Printing soft matter in three dimensions

[4] Skylar-Scott, M. A., Mueller, J., Visser, C. W. & Lewis, J. A. Voxelated soft matter via multimaterial multinozzle 3D printing

[5] Wang, L., Lau, J., Thomas, E. L. & Boyce, M. C. Co-continuous composite materials for stiffness, strength, and energy dissipation

[6] Mora, S., Pugno, N. M. & Misseroni, D. 3D printed architected lattice structures by material jetting

[7] Kim, J.-W. et al. Hybrid epoxy–acrylate resins for wavelength-selective multimaterial 3D printing

[8] Flores Ituarte, I., Boddeti, N., Hassani, V., Dunn, M. L. & Rosen, D. W. Design and additive manufacture of functionally graded structures based on digital materials

[9] Kuang, X. et al. Grayscale digital light processing 3D printing for highly functionally graded materials

[10] Ahn, S.-J., Lee, H. & Cho, K.-J. 3D printing with a 3D printed digital material filament for programming functional gradients

[11] Yuan, C. et al. 3D printing of multi-material composites with tunable shape memory behavior

[12] Yuan, C., Wang, F., Rosen, D. W. & Ge, Q Voxel design of additively manufactured digital material with customized thermomechanical properties

[13] Karimi Mahabadi, R. & Salahshoor, H. Data-driven-design (D3) of multi-material systems: a novel framework and its application to viscoelastic metamaterials

[14] Wirth, M., Chapuis, J. N. & Shea, K. Inverse design of stochastic, voxelated thermo-viscoelastic digital materials

[15] Williams, M. L., Landel, R. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Shifting each isotherm along log10 f produces the master curves of Figure 3b, which extend the three measured decades of frequency to more than twenty decades of reduced frequency (all five compositions are given in Supplementary Figure 1). The shift factors (Figure 3c) follow an Arrhenius form below Tg and the Williams– Landel–Ferry form above it (Methods and Table 1).

F. & Ferry, J. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Shifting each isotherm along log10 f produces the master curves of Figure 3b, which extend the three measured decades of frequency to more than twenty decades of reduced frequency (all five compositions are given in Supplementary Figure 1). The shift factors (Figure 3c) follow an Arrhenius form below Tg and the Williams– Landel–Ferry form above it (Methods and Table 1).

D The temperature dependence of relaxation mechanisms in amorphous polymers and other glass-forming liquids

[16] Ferry, J. D Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers 3rd edn (Wiley, New York, 1980)

[17] Li, C.-Q., Winter, H. H., Fan, Y.-Q., Xu, G.-X. Time–concentration superposition for linear viscoelasticity of polymer solutions

[18] Bair, S. & Qureshi, F. Time–temperature–pressure superposition in polymer thickened liquid lubricants

[19] Suarez-Martinez, P. C., Batys, P., Sammalkorpi, M. & Lutkenhaus, J. L. Time–temperature and time–water superposition principles applied to poly(allylamine)/poly(acrylic acid) complexes

[20] Liu, S. et al. Time–temperature–moisture superposition principle of hydrophilic polymer amorphous cellulose

[21] Adolf, D. & Martin, J. E. Time–cure superposition during crosslinking

[22] Phansalkar, S. P. & Han, B Novel test method to measure time–cure superposition shift factors of filled-thermoset under isocure testing conditions

[23] Plazek, D. J. Effect of crosslink density on the creep behavior of natural rubber vulcanizates

[24] Song, Y. & Zheng, Q Linear rheology of nanofilled polymers

[25] Liu, J., Cao, D., Zhang, L. & Wang, W. Time–temperature and time–concentration superposition of nanofilled elastomers: a molecular dynamics study

[26] Keshavarz, B. et al. Time–connectivity superposition and the gel/glass duality of weak colloidal gels

[27] Baeza, G. P. et al. Network dynamics in nanofilled polymers

[28] Mujtaba, A. et al. Detection of surface-immobilized components and their role in viscoelastic reinforcement of rubber–silica nanocomposites

[29] Robertson, C. G., Lin, C. J., Rackaitis, M. & Roland, C. M Influence of particle size and polymer–filler coupling on viscoelastic glass transition of particle-reinforced polymers

[30] Plazek, D. J., Riande, E., Markovitz, H. & Raghupathi, N Concentration dependence of the viscoelastic properties of polystyrene–tricresyl phosphate solutions

[31] Fox, T. G. Influence of diluent and of copolymer composition on the glass temperature of a polymer system

[32] Gordon, M. & Taylor, J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In plasticized polystyrene, the reduction over concentration holds within the transition zone and within the terminal zone, with different shift factors in each[30]. The Fox[31], Gordon– Taylor[32] and Couchman–Karasz[33] relations give Tg of a miscible blend as a function of its composition, and TTE holds in blends whose component Tg are close[34] but fails when they are far apart[35, 36], because the local composition differs from segment to segment and broadens the transition from that of both polymers[36, 37].

S Ideal copolymers and the second-order transitions of synthetic rubbers I Non-crystalline copolymers

[33] Couchman, P. R. & Karasz, F. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In plasticized polystyrene, the reduction over concentration holds within the transition zone and within the terminal zone, with different shift factors in each[30]. The Fox[31], Gordon– Taylor[32] and Couchman–Karasz[33] relations give Tg of a miscible blend as a function of its composition, and TTE holds in blends whose component Tg are close[34] but fails when they are far apart[35, 36], because the local composition differs from segment to segment and broadens the transition from that of both polymers[36, 37].

E A classical thermodynamic discussion of the effect of composition on glass-transition temperatures

[34] Pathak, J. A., Colby, R. H., Kamath, S. Y., Kumar, S. K. & Stadler, R Rheology of miscible blends: SAN and PMMA

[35] Colby, R. H Breakdown of time–temperature superposition in miscible polymer blends

[36] Pathak, J. A., Colby, R. H., Floudas, G. & J´erˆome, R Dynamics in miscible blends of polystyrene and poly(vinyl methyl ether)

[37] Lodge, T. P. & McLeish, T. C. B Self-concentrations and effective glass transition temperatures in polymer blends

[38] Krishnan, A. S. & Spontak, R J Factors affecting time–composition equivalence in ternary block copolymer/cosolvent systems

[39] Torres, N., Barzycki, D. C., Bauer, Z. R., Duclos, C. & Ricarte, R G Immiscible polydimethylsiloxane/polybutadiene vitrimer blends

[40] Slesarenko, V. & Rudykh, S Towards mechanical characterization of soft digital materials for multimaterial 3D-printing

[41] Daneshdoost, N., Peloquin, J. & Gall, K. Structure-performance relationships of multi-material jetting polymeric composites designed at the voxel scale: distribution and composition effects

[42] Lee, S. et al. Mechanical anisotropy of 3D-printed digital materials at large strains

[43] Ho, C., Bao, J. & Xu, J Thermomechanical properties of PolyJet voxel-printed parts and the effect of percolation

[44] Shen, B. & Boyce, M. C. Composition-dependent nonlinear viscoelastic–viscoplastic behavior and constitutive framework for digitally mixed polymers spanning the glass transition Preprint at https://arxiv. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Time–temperature–composition equivalence of the viscoelastic behavior through the glass transition of digitally mixed 3D-printed polymers Beijun Shen1 , Sanat K. Kumar2 , Mary C.

org/abs/2609.04399

[45] Garc´ıa-Avila, J., Shen, B., Rausch, M., Boyce, M. C. & Buganza Tepole, A Data-driven discovery of composition-dependent constitutive models for hyperelasticity and viscoelasticity of digital materials Preprint at https://arxiv. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The equivalence provides a physical basis for the design of functionally graded and architected multimaterial structures. The TTCE is also the small-strain counterpart of the composition dependence in our finite-strain constitutive model[44] and in data-driven constitutive models of Agilus-rich mixtures of the family[45].

org/abs/2609.04541

[46] Lee, G. et al. Tunable viscoelasticity in phase-separated soft materials

[47] Abayazid, F. F. & Ghajari, M Material characterisation of additively manufactured elastomers at different strain rates and build orientations

[48] Kohlrausch, R. Theorie des elektrischen rückstandes in der Leidener Flasche Ann. Phys. 167, 179–214 (1854)

[49] Williams, G. & Watts, D. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In reduced frequency for each mixture, Eq. (3) is a stretched exponential, g = exp[−(fc/fr) β ] with fr = f aT , fc = 10zc and β = 1/(W ln 10), the established Kohlrausch– Williams–Watts form of relaxation in polymers[48, 49].

C. Non-symmetrical dielectric relaxation behaviour arising from a simple empirical decay function Trans. p. 8
Where the paper says it

2 in u of the peak of gδ(u), and a slow decay on the glassy side. The five materials thus share one distribution of relaxation times in terms of the reduced variable u.

Faraday Soc. 66, 80–85 (1970)

[50] Lindsey, C. P. & Patterson, G. D Detailed comparison of the Williams–Watts and Cole–Davidson functions J. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In reduced frequency for each mixture, Eq. (3) is a stretched exponential, g = exp[−(fc/fr) β ] with fr = f aT , fc = 10zc and β = 1/(W ln 10), the established Kohlrausch– Williams–Watts form of relaxation in polymers[48, 49].

Chem. Phys. 73, 3348–3357 (1980)

[51] Schwarzl, F. & Staverman, A J Higher approximation methods for the relaxation spectrum from static and dynamic measurements of visco-elastic materials Appl. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Here the breadth W of the transition is only three to five decades of reduced frequency, so the spectrum changes appreciably within one decade of relaxation time. The shape of gδ(u) is therefore taken from the measurements, as the mean of the five curves at each u (Methods).

Sci. Res. A 4, 127–141 (1953)

[52] Baumgaertel, M. & Winter, H. H Determination of discrete relaxation and retardation time spectra from dynamic mechanical data Rheol. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The dynamic mechanical data and transition temperatures were first reported, as small-strain characterization, in our earlier work[44]. 2 Time–temperature equivalence of each digital mixture TTE is established first for each composition.

Acta 28, 511–519 (1989)

[53] Mao, Y. et al. Sequential self-folding structures by 3D printed digital shape memory polymers Sci. p. 0

Where the paper says it

A designer can choose the material composition at each voxel, set by the mixing ratio, and the spatial arrangement of compositions within the part[3, 4]. The two choices underlie architected and energy-absorbing composites[5–7], functionally graded structures[8–10], composites with programmed shape memory[11, 12], and viscoelastic metamaterials and wearable devices in which stiffness and damping are distributed by design[13, 14].

Rep. 5, 13616 (2015)

[54] Wu, J. et al. Multi-shape active composites by 3D printing of digital shape memory polymers Sci. p. 0

Where the paper says it

A designer can choose the material composition at each voxel, set by the mixing ratio, and the spatial arrangement of compositions within the part[3, 4]. The two choices underlie architected and energy-absorbing composites[5–7], functionally graded structures[8–10], composites with programmed shape memory[11, 12], and viscoelastic metamaterials and wearable devices in which stiffness and damping are distributed by design[13, 14].

Rep. 6, 24224 (2016)

[55] Yue, L. et al. Single-vat single-cure grayscale digital light processing 3D printing of materials with large property difference and high stretchability Nat. p. 0

Where the paper says it

A single closed-form TTCE gives the storage and loss moduli of the family, guiding graded and architected designs for elasticity and dissipation. Keywords: viscoelasticity, glass transition, multimaterial 3D printing, digital mixtures, time–temperature equivalence, time–temperature–composition equivalence 1 Introduction Multimaterial photopolymer jetting (PolyJet) deposits droplets of different liquid photopolymers voxel by voxel and cures each layer with ultraviolet light[1, 2].

Commun. 14, 1251 (2016)

[56] Larson, N. M. et al. Rotational multimaterial printing of filaments with subvoxel control Nature 613, 682–688 (2023)

[57] Brown, N. C., Ames, D. C. & Mueller J Multimaterial extrusion 3D printing printheads Nat. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Horizontal shifting extends moduli measured over limited ranges to much wider ranges, through the glass transition. Multimaterial 3D printing has created digitally mixed polymers, a new class in which elastomeric and glassy resins are mixed voxel by voxel in prescribed ratios.

Rev. Mater. 10, 807–825 (2025)

[58] Doolittle, A. K Studies in Newtonian flow II The dependence of the viscosity of liquids on free-space J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The glass transition depends on the time scale of loading. A polymer is rubbery and compliant when its chain segments can freely sample space within the time scale of loading, and glassy and stiff when intermolecular interactions hinder such sampling.

Appl. Phys. 22, 1471–1475 (1951)

[59] O’Connell, P. A. & McKenna, G. B Arrhenius-type temperature dependence of the segmental relaxation below Tg J. p. 1

Where the paper says it

A polymer is rubbery and compliant when its chain segments can freely sample space within the time scale of loading, and glassy and stiff when intermolecular interactions hinder such sampling. Decreasing the temperature lengthens the time needed for segmental relaxation, and increasing the frequency shortens the time available for that relaxation.

Chem. Phys.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Master curve generation for digital mixtures can be performed using a single closed form TTCE that combines time, temperature, and composition to describe storage and loss moduli across all measured conditions. This allows AI systems to predict viscoelastic response for any combination of material properties without needing extensive separate data points for every mixture.

  2. AI systems can accurately design architected structures by using the closed form TTCE to determine the stiffness and damping of entire printed families continuously in composition, temperature, and frequency. This enables automated generation of functionally graded and architected designs based on target mechanical properties.

  3. The proposed TTCE allows for the identification of intermediate compositions that are not explicitly measured in a database, providing a physical basis for designing materials beyond known mixtures. AI can use this closed form to calculate the viscoelastic response for any composition within the digitally mixed family.

  4. AI systems can predict how fabrication variables, such as composition or degree of cure, enter the framework of TTE by translating the transition and also stretching it and moving the plateaus, extending this principle to other 3D printing processes like grayscale photopolymerization. This enables predictive modeling for new material families.

Abstract

For more than seventy years, time-temperature equivalence (TTE) has enabled a few measurements to describe the linear viscoelasticity of polymers over many decades of frequency. Multimaterial 3D printing now combines elastomeric and glassy resins voxel by voxel into digitally mixed polymers. Composition shifts the glass transition along the frequency axis, as temperature does, but also broadens it and increases the rubbery plateau modulus. A translation, the only operation of TTE, cannot capture these changes. Here we establish a time-temperature-composition equivalence (TTCE) from dynamic mechanical measurements of five compositions of a printed family. A shift of the transition along the reduced-frequency axis, a stretch of its breadth and a normalization between its plateaus collapse the storage modulus onto one master curve. The collapse holds at every measured temperature, frequency and composition, through a single reduced variable. The position and breadth of the transition change linearly with the volume fraction of the glassy resin. The phase angle and the relaxation spectrum superpose with the same parameters, so the family shares one distribution of relaxation times. The resulting closed form gives the storage and loss moduli continuously in composition, temperature and frequency, and quantitatively predicts two further mixtures withheld from the calibration. The same shift, stretch and normalization also collapse published temperature sweeps of a patterned composite family of different resins, pointing to broader applicability. Composition thus joins temperature and frequency as a third variable of one equivalence, and the closed form can guide the design of graded and architected printed structures.

Sources

Related papers