Breit interaction in elastic scattering of vortex electron on Hydrogen atomic target

arXiv:2609.34578 · physics.atom-ph · Submitted 2026-09-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Breit interaction in elastic scattering of vortex electron on Hydrogen atomic target".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The Breit interaction in elastic scattering of a vortex electron on a hydrogen atomic target is studied to show that it dominates when the total angular momentum of the vortex electron is sufficiently large, which contradicts conventional notions for low-Z atoms.

Kai: The interaction of electron vortex beams with atoms is fundamental to their applications.

Mira: Existing studies on elastic scattering have considered only the Coulomb interaction, but the role of the Breit interaction has not been systematically examined.

Kai: This paper studies the elastic scattering of a 300 keV vortex electron by a hydrogen atomic target with emphasis on the role of the Breit interaction.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper about the Breit interaction in elastic scattering of a vortex electron on a hydrogen atomic target. Basically, they're checking if this relativistic correction to the Coulomb potential matters when you have a vortex electron and an atom.

Mira: The main point here is that existing studies usually only look at the simple Coulomb interaction, but this paper systematically looks at how important the Breit interaction becomes. It claims it dominates when the total angular momentum of that vortex electron gets quite large, which goes against what we normally think about low-Z atoms and their scattering.

Lev: If we think about running this on real hardware, what does that mean? Does this require us to cool things down to some extreme temperature, or are we talking about achievable fidelities with current setups?

Kai: Well, the paper says they're looking at a three hundred keV vortex electron hitting a hydrogen target <ref:2609.34578#pg1,a 300 keV vortex electron>. They compare just the Coulomb part against the Coulomb and Breit parts together. The core claim is that for large total angular momentum of the vortex electron, this Breit interaction takes over completely in how the scattering happens.

Mira: That dominance comes from something specific: a vortex electron with large angular momentum has a substantial magnetic moment, and it's precisely that magnetic moment interaction that the Breit term describes. It suggests that for these highly energetic or highly structured particles, we can't ignore this relativistic correction anymore.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we want to simulate this on a real system, the overhead of accounting for the Breit interaction means we need very precise control over both the orbital and spin aspects of the electron beam simultaneously. The computational cost for modeling that full four-component spinor wave function is significant even before we get to scattering results.

Kai: The paper does look at how this depends on things like the total angular momentum, which they call mv, and they show a critical value where the Breit and Coulomb contributions become comparable in magnitude. This threshold really changes what's happening in the scattering process depending on how much angular momentum you put into that vortex electron.

Paper summary: Mira: And it's interesting because this threshold isn't fixed; it actually depends on the size of the target itself, which they call the mesoscopic target case versus the single-atom case. A larger target radius pushes that threshold to a higher total angular momentum requirement to see the Breit interaction take over.

Lev: So, for us building error correction systems, if we were designing a detector based on this scattering process, we'd have to design it with an awareness of this size-dependent threshold because the physics shifts dramatically above that point. It tells us where the physics changes regime.

Kai: The implication is that what's conventional in low-Z atom electron scattering, where you mostly ignore the Breit interaction, breaks down when dealing with high angular momentum states. This whole analysis of "Breit interaction in elastic scattering of vortex electron on Hydrogen atomic target" suggests we need a more complete relativistic description for these specific types of beams.

Mira: And what this means for the broader field is that if you're working with systems that generate high topological charge, like certain laser modes or beam structures, you can't just rely on the simplest Coulomb calculations anymore; you have to include these magnetic moment interactions because they become significant.

Lev: The limitation I see here is that they are focusing on a hydrogen target and a specific electron energy of three hundred keV; we don't know how robust this scaling is if we try to apply it to, say, much heavier atoms or lower energy electrons <ref:2609.34578#pg1>. It's a very specific regime study.

Kai: Exactly. They show that for the parameters they used, like mv equals thirty point five, the distribution for the Coulomb and Breit cases peaks in completely different places; one is around zero point zero one five of a degree, and the other is much sharper at zero point zero one degree.

Mira: That dramatic difference when mv is three point zero five shows just how sensitive the scattering outcome is to that total angular momentum input, confirming that it's not negligible in this high-momentum regime.

Lev: If we were trying to implement a detector where we needed high precision for these specific angular momentum inputs, the fact that the effect grows by six orders of magnitude at mv equals thirty point zero five means our noise floor has to be incredibly low just to resolve that change.

Paper summary: Kai: So, if you look at the paper's conclusion about a critical value around mv equals twenty point five for the single-atom case, it sets up a clear rule: below that, Coulomb dominates; above it, Breit dominates. This is a concrete prediction derived from their calculations on the transition amplitudes and differential number of events.

Mira: And the size dependence they found—the threshold moving from mv equals fifty-eight point five for one nanometer target to mv equals ninety-eight point five for two nanometers—is a crucial detail that ties the angular momentum requirement directly to the physical scale of the target material.

Lev: That dependency on target size is what makes this interesting for experimental design; it means we can't just pick an arbitrary large angular momentum and assume we'll see this effect, because you need to match it to a specific geometry.

Kai: So, when you look at the authors Pengcheng Zhao et al.'s work on "Breit interaction in elastic scattering of vortex electron on Hydrogen atomic target," the main thing they deliver is showing that for high total angular momentum, the Breit term isn't just a small correction; it becomes the leading term describing how that magnetic moment interacts with the atom.

Mira: It moves beyond just saying "relativistic corrections exist" to showing exactly *when* and *how* those corrections become the main driver of the scattering dynamics in systems involving vortex electrons.

Lev: For future work, I think they need to move away from hydrogen targets and test this scaling on heavier atomic systems where the magnetic moment coupling might be more complex, which is where my error correction simulations would start getting really interesting overheads.

Kai: Right, so the paper shows that for these specific parameters, the Breit interaction dominates when the total angular momentum is high enough, and this dominance depends on both the angular momentum and how big your target is.

Mira: It’s a careful look at how quantum properties translate into observable scattering patterns, showing that for systems with large topological charge, we need to keep those magnetic interactions in our calculations.

Lev: And the implication for us is that if you're designing an experiment targeting these high-momentum electron beams, you have to factor in this threshold based on your target size right from the start.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at the paper titled "Breit interaction in elastic scattering of vortex electron on Hydrogen atomic target."

Mira: Basically, they found that for these specific vortex electron beams, the Breit interaction—that relativistic magnetic moment part of the potential—starts dominating when you have a high enough total angular momentum.

Lev: That's what we're seeing in theory, but for us, the real question is how big that momentum has to be before our error correction setup actually needs to account for it.

Kai: It’s interesting because it contradicts the idea that we can safely ignore that magnetic interaction when you’re scattering off low-Z atoms like hydrogen.

Mira: Exactly. The paper shows a sharp threshold where the Coulomb contribution stops being the main thing and this Breit term takes over completely in how the electrons scatter.

Lev: The big implication for us is that if you're building hardware to measure these states, you can't just stick to simple Coulomb models because above that threshold, your measurement is going to be dominated by spin-magnetic effects.

Kai: So, it means the physics changes depending on the total angular momentum of the electron beam in a way we didn't expect for this type of scattering.

Mira: It really highlights how important it is to use these full relativistic descriptions when dealing with beams that carry significant topological charge.

Lev: And because this threshold depends on the target size, you can't just pick a number; you have to match your experimental setup—the target radius—to the required angular momentum.

Kai: If we want to actually see this effect in an experiment, Lev, what does that mean for how small we need to make our atomic targets?

Lev: It means we should aim for the smallest possible target size you can manage; since the threshold for seeing the Breit dominance gets higher as the target gets bigger.

Mira: That’s a practical constraint then. So this work confirms that high angular momentum beams demand a more complete calculation involving these magnetic terms rather than just standard Coulomb scattering.

Kai: Right, so we're moving from ignoring small corrections to needing them when the beam has high topological charge and you're looking at specific target sizes.

Lev: This sets up the next thing we need to figure out: how this scaling holds up when we move away from hydrogen targets onto heavier atoms.

State Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology, Institute of Quantum Matter, South China Normal University · Guangdong Basic Research Center of Excellence for Structure and Fundamental Interactions of Matter, Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Nuclear Science

physics.atom-ph

Submitted: 2026-09-28

Updated: 2026-11-14

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 66/100

The gist: The Breit interaction in elastic scattering of a vortex electron on a hydrogen atomic target is studied to show that it dominates when the total angular momentum of the vortex electron is…

Key concepts

Breit Interaction
This is a specific term describing the magnetic part of the electron-electron interaction potential. It accounts for relativistic effects and spin interactions between particles, which are crucial when dealing with highly energetic or high-angular-momentum electrons.
Vortex Electron
A vortex electron is an electron beam carrying orbital angular momentum, similar to a swirling wave. These beams possess specific topological properties that influence how they interact with atomic targets during scattering experiments.
Total Angular Momentum (TAM)
This refers to the combined orbital and spin angular momentum carried by the vortex electron. The paper explores how increasing this TAM changes which interaction—Coulomb or Breit—is stronger in determining the final scattering outcome.

Terminology

Summary

The Breit interaction in elastic scattering of a vortex electron on a hydrogen atomic target is studied to show that it dominates when the total angular momentum of the vortex electron is sufficiently large, which contradicts conventional notions for low-Z atoms. p. 0

Introduction and Motivation

The interaction of electron vortex beams with atoms is fundamental to their applications. Existing studies on elastic scattering have considered only the Coulomb interaction, but the role of the Breit interaction has not been systematically examined. p. 0 This paper studies the elastic scattering of a 300 keV vortex electron by a hydrogen atomic target with emphasis on the role of the Breit interaction. p. 0 Numerous results show that the Breit interaction dominates the scattering process when the total angular momentum of vortex electron is sufficiently large, which breaks with the conventional notion that the Breit interaction has little contribution to electron scattering for low-Z atoms. p. 0 This phenomenon arises primarily because a vortex electron with large angular momentum possesses a substantial magnetic moment, and the Breit interaction precisely describes the interaction between magnetic moments. p. 0

Theoretical Framework

The interaction potential is given by the sum of Coulomb and Breit terms: V (r, r′) = VCoulomb(r, r′) + VBreit(r, r′). The transition amplitude is expressed as M = MC + MB. p. 1 The Breit potential is defined by VBreit(r, r′) = −e squared / 4πϵ0 (1/2R) α · α′ + (α · R)(α′ · R)/R squared. p. 1 Vortex particles are described by vortex solutions of the equations of motion expressed in cylindrical coordinates. p. 1 The Dirac spinor wave function for the hydrogen atom is described by a four-component spinor. p. 3

Scattering Results in Single-Atom Targets

The differential number of events is calculated as a function of the scattering angle θp and the topological charge mv. For the single-atom target case, for mv = 10. p. 75 and mv = 30.5, the distributions for both Coulomb only and Coulomb+Breit cases peak around θp = 0. p. 7015. For mv = 30.5, the distribution differs dramatically from the “Coulomb only” result: it peaks sharply at θp = 0. p. 701 with a magnitude exceeding the Coulomb-only value by six orders of magnitude. p. 7

Dependence on Total Angular Momentum

The mv dependence of the relative differential number of events W(mv, θp) and the ratio MV B/MV C is shown in FIG. 2. For the pure Coulomb contribution, the differential number of events decreases rapidly with increasing mv, indicating an approximately exponential suppression of the form ∝ 10−αmv with α > 0. p. 9 The total differential number of events also decreases with increasing mv, although its rate of decrease is slower than that of the “Coulomb only” case for mv above a certain critical value. p. 9 This critical value can be identified from the ratio MV B/MV C, which is mv = 20. p. 95, corresponding to the point at which the ratio crosses unity as mv increases. p. 9

Mesoscopic Target Comparison

For the mesoscopic target case, there exists a critical value of mv around which the Breit and Coulomb contributions are comparable in magnitude. The threshold is mv = 58. p. 95 for R = 1 nm and mv = 98.5 for R = 2 nm, as can be read off from the “Ratio” curve in the right panel of FIG. p. 9 3. The larger the target radius, the larger the threshold. p. 9

Conclusion

Our results demonstrate that there exists a critical value of mv around which the Breit and Coulomb contributions are comparable in magnitude. Below the threshold, the Coulomb contribution dominates the process. p. 9 Above the threshold, the Breit contribution dominates. p. 9 This behavior departs from conventional expectation that the Breit interaction can be safely neglected in elastic electron scattering from low-Z atoms. p. 9 The threshold depends on the target size: the larger the target, the larger the threshold. p. 9 Since the differential number of events decreases with increasing TAM, the target size should be made as small as possible in experiments to facilitate observation of this effect. p. 9 Notably, for the several-nanometer targets considered here, the TAM threshold at which the Breit contribution becomes significant is well within the range of angular momenta currently achievable in experiments.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by Grants No. NSFC-12447117. The references used are [1] through [30]. p. 1

References

[1] L.Allen, M.W.Beijersbergen, R.J.C.Spreeuw, and J.P.Woerdman.

[2] M Uchida M and A Tonomura.

[3] R Shiloh, Y Lereah, Y Lilach, and A Arie.

[4] J Verbeeck, H Tian, and P Schattschneider.

[5] V Grillo, E Karimi, G C Gazzadi, S Frabboni.

[6] P Schattschneider, M St¨oger-Pollach, and J Verbeeck.

[7] E Mafakheri, A H Tavabi, P H Lu.

[8] A B´ech´e, R V Boxem, G V Tendeloo.

[9] A H Tavabi, P Rosi, A Roncaglia.

[10] J Verbeeck, H Tian, and G V Tendeloo.

[11] R Juchtmans, A B´ech´e, A Abakumov.

[12] J Rusz, S Muto, J Spiegelberg.

[13] I P Ivanov and D V Karlovets.

[14] R Juchtmans and J Verbeeck.

[15] P Schattschneider, V Grillo, and D Aubry.

[16] A Koneˇcn´a, M K Schmidt, R Hillenbrand.

[17] K Y Bliokh, I P Ivanov, G Guzzinati.

[18] I P Ivanov.

[19] R V Boxem, B Partoens, and J Verbeeck.

[20] R V Boxem, B Partoens, and J Verbeeck.

[21] V Serbo, I P Ivanov, S Fritzsche.

[22] V K Ivanov, A D Chaikovskaia.

[23] D V Karlovets, G L Kotkin.

[24] D V Karlovets, G L Kotkin.

[25] N Sheremet, A Chaikovskaia, D Grosman.

[26] V P Kosheleva, V A Zaytsev, A Surzhykov.

[27] G Breit. p. 0

[28] G Breit. p. 0

[29] H A Bethe and E E Salpeter.

[30] I P Grant.

Appendix

The appendix contains the list of references [1] through [30]. The references are listed as follows:

[1] L.Allen, M WBeijersbergen R J CSpreeuw and J PWoerdman Orbital angular momentum of light and the transformation of laguerre-gaussian laser modes Phys Rev A 45:8185 1992. p. 0

[2] M Uchida M and A Tonomura Generation of electron beams carrying orbital angular momentum Nature 464:737–739,2010. p. 0

[3] R Shiloh, Y Lereah, Y Lilach, and A Arie Sculpturingtheelectronwavefunctionusingnanoscalephasemasks Ultramicroscopy 144:26–31, 2014.

[4] J Verbeeck, H Tian, and P Schattschneider Production and application of electron vortex beams Nature 467:301–304,2010. p. 0

[5] V Grillo, E Karimi, G C Gazzadi, S Frabboni M R Dennis and R W Boyd Generation of nondiffracting electron bessel beams Phys Rev X 4:0. p. 01013, 2014.

[6] P Schattschneider, M St¨oger-Pollach, and J Verbeeck Novel vortex generator and mode converter for electron beams Phys Rev Lett. p. 9 109:084801, 2012.

[7] E Mafakheri, A H Tavabi, P H Lu R Balboni F Venturi C Menozzi G C Gazzadi S Frabboni A Sit R Dunin-Borkowski E Karimi and V Grillo Magnetic monopole field exposed by electrons Appl Phys Lett. p. 0 110:093113,2017.

[8] A B´ech´e, R V Boxem, G V Tendeloo and J Verbeeck Realization of electron vortices with large orbital angular momentum using miniature holograms fabricated by electron beam lithography Nature Physics 10:26–29, 2014. p. 0

[9] A H Tavabi, P Rosi, A Roncaglia E Rotunno M Beleggia P H Lu L Belsito G Pozzi S Frabboni P Tiemeijer R E Dunin-Borkowski and V Grillo Generation of electron vortex beams with over 1000 orbital angular momentum quanta using a tunable electrostatic spiral phase plate Appl Phys Lett. p. 0 121:073506, 2022.

[10] J Verbeeck, H Tian, and G V Tendeloo How to manipulate nanoparticles with an electron beam Advanced Materials 25:1114–1117, 2013.

[11] R Juchtmans, A B´ech´e, A Abakumov M Batuk and J Verbeeck Using electron vortex beams to determine chirality of crystals in transmission electron microscopy Phys Rev B 91:094112, 2015. p. 0

[12] J Rusz, S Muto, J Spiegelberg R Adam K Tatsumi D E¨urgler P M Oppeneer and C M Schneider Magnetic measurements with atomic-plane resolution Nature Communications 7:12672, 2016. p. 0

[13] I P Ivanov and D V Karlovets Detecting transition radiation from a magnetic moment Phys Rev Lett. p. 0 110:264801, 2013.

[14] R Juchtmans and J Verbeeck Local orbital angular momentum revealed by spiral-phase-plate imaging in transmissionelectron microscopy Phys Rev A 93:023811, 2016. p. 0

[15] P Schattschneider, V Grillo, and D Aubry Spin polarisation with electron bessel beams Ultramicroscopy 176:188–193, 2017. p. 0

[16] A Koneˇcn´a, M K Schmidt, R Hillenbrand and J Aizpurua Probing the electromagnetic response of dielectric antennas by vortex electron beams Phys Rev Research 5:023192, 2023. p. 0

[17] K Y Bliokh, I P Ivanov, G Guzzinati L Clark R V Boxem A B´ech´e R Juchtmans M A Alonso P Schattschneider F Nori and J Verbeeck Theory and applications of free-electron vortex states Physics Reports 690:1–70, 2017. p. 0

[18] I P Ivanov Promises and challenges of high-energy vortex states collisions Prog Part Nucl Phys. p. 6 127:103987, 2022.

[19] R V Boxem, B Partoens, and J Verbeeck Rutherford scattering of electron vortices Phys Rev A 89:032715, 2014. p. 0

[20] R V Boxem, B Partoens, and J Verbeeck Inelastic electron-vortex-beam scattering Phys Rev A 91:032703, 2015. p. 0

[21] V Serbo, I P Ivanov, S Fritzsche D Seipt and A Surzhykov Scattering of twisted relativistic electrons by atoms Phys Rev A 92:012705, 2015. p. 0

[22] V K Ivanov, A D Chaikovskaia and D V Karlovets Studying highly relativistic vortex-electron beams by atomic scattering Phys Rev A 108:062803, 2023. p. 0

[23] D V Karlovets, G L Kotkin and V G Serbo Scattering of wave packets on atoms in the born approximation Phys Rev A 92:052703, 2015. p. 0

[24] D V Karlovets, G L Kotkin, V G Serbo and A Surzhykov Scattering of twisted electron wave packets by atoms in the born approximation Phys Rev A 95:032703, 2017. p. 0

[25] N Sheremet, A Chaikovskaia, D Grosman and D Karlovets Elastic scattering of laguerre-gaussian electron packets on atoms 2024. p. 0

[26] V P Kosheleva, V A Zaytsev, A Surzhykov V M Shabaev and Th St¨ohlker Elastic scattering of twisted electrons by an atomic target Going beyond the born approximation Phys Rev A 98:022706, 2018. p. 0

[27] G Breit The effect of retardation on the interaction of two electrons Phys Rev. p. 0 34:553, 1929.

[28] G Breit Dirac’s equation and the spin-spin interactions of two electrons Phys Rev. p. 2 39:616, 1932.

[29] H A Bethe and E E Salpeter Quantum mechanics of one-and two-electron atoms Springer Science & Business Media New York, 2013. p. 0

[30] I P Grant Relativistic Quantum Theory of Atoms and Molecules Theory and Computation Springer Science & Business Media New York, 2007. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate Breit interaction into scattering models for vortex electron beams to accurately predict scattering distributions when total angular momentum is large, as this breaks with the conventional notion that the Breit interaction has little contribution to electron scattering for low-Z atoms.

  2. Enable AI systems to differentiate between Coulomb only and Coulomb plus Breit contributions in elastic scattering by analyzing the ratio |MV B/MV C |, allowing them to determine if a large TAM vortex electron causes a switch from Coulomb dominance to Breit dominance.

  3. Allow AI systems to predict the critical total angular momentum (mv) threshold required for the Breit contribution to become significant, providing specific thresholds based on target size: The threshold depends on the target size: the larger the target, the larger the threshold.

  4. Improve simulation capabilities by allowing researchers to systematically compare single-atom, mesoscopic, and macroscopic target cases to understand how the target size significantly influences the observability of the Breit-induced effects.

  5. Develop algorithms that utilize a weighted sum of squared transition amplitudes for mesoscopic targets to express the total scattering amplitude as a weighted sum of the squared transition amplitudes for single-atom targets, each associated with a different initial TAM.

Related papers