Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics demonstrates that frame-invariant scalar-tensor gravity admits a Jordan-frame-like invariant representation where matter is minimally coupled and the effective imperfect fluid interpretation is manifest Scalar degrees of freedom are a characteristic feature of scalar-tensor theories, arising from motivations like the Jordan–Brans–Dicke idea and appearing in various cosmological contexts The invariant approach constructs combinations of metric, scalar field, and model functions that remain unchanged under simultaneous Weyl rescalings and scalar-field reparametrizations to address frame dependence This distinction between frame dependence and representation dependence is essential for effective thermodynamic interpretations because quantities like heat flux can depend on how the scalar sector is organized Construction of the Jordan-like Invariant Metric The paper constructs a Jordan-like invariant representation defined by the invariant matter metric g˜ab = e 2α(Φ)gab, where matter is minimally coupled to g˜ab by construction When written in terms of this metric and the invariant scalar Ψ, the action takes the Brans-Dicke-Bergmann-Wagoner form with invariant functions U(Ψ) and ωinv(Ψ), retaining the Hessian sector characteristic of Jordan-frame scalar-tensor gravity This representation is called Jordan-like because it coincides with the usual Jordan metric in a Jordan parametrization where α = 0 Derivation of the Invariant Action The Jordan-like invariant action (34) is derived directly from the original scalar-tensor action (2) by choosing the invariant matter metric as the basic geometrical variable This leads to an action where every quantity appearing in it is invariant under frame transformations, yet it retains the exact Brans–Dicke–Bergmann–Wagoner (BDBW) structure The kinetic term in this form is expressed as −ωinv(Ψ)/Ψ (∇˜ Ψ)2, which is derived from the invariant coupling function ωinv(Ψ) Imperfect-Fluid Structure and Thermodynamic Identifications Varying the action in the Jordan-like representation yields field equations where the Hessian contribution is explicit, leading to an effective imperfect-fluid structure in the decomposition of T(g)ab In a generic congruence, this structure results in nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress In the scalar-comoving frame, these structures reduce to identifications KJTJ = −Ψ˙ /(κ 2Ψ) and ηJ = Ψ˙ /(2κ 2Ψ), which are recovered as invariant Jordan-like variables Comparison of Representations The Einstein-like invariant representation organizes the scalar sector as a minimally coupled perfect fluid with vanishing temperature, whereas the Jordan-like representation leaves the nonminimal-coupling/Hessian sector explicit, leading to a temperature-based imperfect-fluid interpretation The comparison shows that while both representations are mathematically legitimate, they provide different but equally invariant organizations of the same underlying scalar-tensor dynamics The vanishing of the scalar-sector temperature is a property of the Einstein-like organization, not of the invariant formalism independently of representation choice The Jordan-like metric is equally invariant and leads instead to the imperfect-fluid organization displayed in Eqs.
Kai: (52)-(69) The two descriptions are distinct invariant organizations of the same dynamics, adapted to different choices of metric representation The comparison between the Einstein-like and Jordan-like invariant representations shows that the Einstein-like representation describes the scalar sector as a perfect fluid with vanishing temperature, while the Jordan-like representation exhibits an effective imperfect fluid structure with nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress This clarifies that the vanishing temperature conclusion is contingent on the specific invariant organization chosen The Jordan-like representation is distinguished by minimal matter coupling, whereas the Einstein-like representation is distinguished by minimal gravitational dynamics The invariant formalism clarifies that different invariant representations can support different effective thermodynamic descriptions of the same conformal class Future Directions Extensions could involve applying this construction to multiscalar-tensor gravity to explore a richer imperfect-fluid decomposition Formulating the entropy current and entropy production directly in Jordan-like invariant variables would allow for a more detailed comparison between the temperature-based and chemical-potential-based descriptions Examining the role of perturbations and matter observables is necessary to understand if these different invariant organizations lead to distinct practical advantages in applications Acknowledgments This work was supported by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) through national funds under the research grant UID/04434/2025 (DOI 10.54499/UID/04434/2025) References
1: P.
Mira: Jordan, Z.
Kai: Phys.
Paper summary: Kai: To follow up on that, this paper starts by setting up this framework using an invariant matter metric defined as e two alpha times the original metric. Then they show how when you write everything in terms of this new metric and an invariant scalar field Psi, the action ends up taking a Brans-Dicke-Bergmann-Wagoner form with specific functions U Psi and omega inv Psi.
Mira: That construction is key because it means the matter is minimally coupled to that new metric by construction, which is important for how we interpret things thermodynamically later on. They derive the action directly from the original scalar-tensor action by picking this invariant matter metric as their base geometrical variable.
Lev: The crucial part they emphasize in this section is that when you look at the resulting field equations, that Hessian sector characteristic of Jordan-frame scalar-tensor gravity appears explicitly and it generates an effective imperfect fluid decomposition.
Kai: So, what we're hearing is that by choosing this specific invariant matter metric, the dynamics naturally produce those nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress structures when you decompose the stress tensor T sub ab in a generic congruence.
Mira: And they then reduce these complex structures down to specific invariant variables like K JT J equals minus Psi dot over kappa squared Psi and eta J equals Psi dot over two kappa squared Psi, which are what they call invariant Jordan-like variables.
Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper "Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics," it really boils down to this comparison between the Einstein-like and Jordan-like descriptions.
Mira: The core argument they make is that while both ways are mathematically valid descriptions of the same conformal class, they provide different organizational structures for the dynamics.
Lev: The implication for us as researchers is that you can't just pick one way to look at the scalar sector and assume you have a fixed thermodynamic picture; you have to acknowledge which representation you're using.
Kai: So, in simple terms, it means the vanishing temperature conclusion isn't universally true for this theory; it only holds if you choose that specific Einstein-like organization for the scalar sector.
Mira: The Jordan-like representation is what they show leads to an effective imperfect fluid structure with nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress, which is a different thermodynamic picture entirely.
Lev: So the paper suggests that understanding this distinction between frame dependence and representation dependence is essential when you're trying to interpret the physics of these scalar-tensor theories in terms of thermodynamics.
Departamento de Física, Faculdade de Ciências da Universidade de Lisboa · Instituto de Astrofísica e Ciências do Espaço
gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-07-24
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 10 pages; Matches published version
Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D 114 (2026) 10, 104020
DOI: 10.1103/jlgv-6rr6
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 89/100
The gist: Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics demonstrates that frame-invariant scalar-tensor gravity admits a Jordan-frame-like…
Key concepts
- Invariant Formalism
- This approach builds combinations of metric, scalar field, and model functions that remain unchanged even when the coordinate system or scalar field parametrization is changed (Weyl rescalings or reparametrizations). It's crucial for getting physically meaningful results because it separates genuine physical properties from arbitrary frame choices.
- Jordan-like Invariant Metric
- This specific metric, defined as g˜ab = e^2α(Φ)gab, is constructed to be invariant under the required transformations. When used, it forces matter to be minimally coupled. This structure retains the Hessian sector characteristic of Jordan-frame scalar-tensor gravity, distinguishing it from other representations.
- Imperfect-Fluid Structure
- When deriving field equations using this representation, the stress-energy tensor decomposition shows an effective imperfect fluid. Unlike a perfect fluid (which has zero heat flux), this structure explicitly results in nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress in generic congruences, providing a temperature-based thermodynamic interpretation.
Terminology
Summary
Jordan-like invariant representations of scalar-tensor gravity and the return of imperfect-fluid thermodynamics demonstrates that frame-invariant scalar-tensor gravity admits a Jordan-frame-like invariant representation where matter is minimally coupled and the effective imperfect fluid interpretation is manifest
Introduction to Invariant Formalism
Scalar degrees of freedom are a characteristic feature of scalar-tensor theories, arising from motivations like the Jordan–Brans–Dicke idea and appearing in various cosmological contexts The invariant approach constructs combinations of metric, scalar field, and model functions that remain unchanged under simultaneous Weyl rescalings and scalar-field reparametrizations to address frame dependence This distinction between frame dependence and representation dependence is essential for effective thermodynamic interpretations because quantities like heat flux can depend on how the scalar sector is organized
Construction of the Jordan-like Invariant Metric
The paper constructs a Jordan-like invariant representation defined by the invariant matter metric g˜ab = e 2α(Φ)gab, where matter is minimally coupled to g˜ab by construction When written in terms of this metric and the invariant scalar Ψ, the action takes the Brans-Dicke-Bergmann-Wagoner form with invariant functions U(Ψ) and ωinv(Ψ), retaining the Hessian sector characteristic of Jordan-frame scalar-tensor gravity This representation is called Jordan-like because it coincides with the usual Jordan metric in a Jordan parametrization where α = 0
Derivation of the Invariant Action
The Jordan-like invariant action (34) is derived directly from the original scalar-tensor action (2) by choosing the invariant matter metric as the basic geometrical variable This leads to an action where every quantity appearing in it is invariant under frame transformations, yet it retains the exact Brans–Dicke–Bergmann–Wagoner (BDBW) structure The kinetic term in this form is expressed as −ωinv(Ψ)/Ψ (∇˜ Ψ)2, which is derived from the invariant coupling function ωinv(Ψ)
Imperfect-Fluid Structure and Thermodynamic Identifications
Varying the action in the Jordan-like representation yields field equations where the Hessian contribution is explicit, leading to an effective imperfect-fluid structure in the decomposition of T(g)ab In a generic congruence, this structure results in nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress In the scalar-comoving frame, these structures reduce to identifications KJTJ = −Ψ˙ /(κ 2Ψ) and ηJ = Ψ˙ /(2κ 2Ψ), which are recovered as invariant Jordan-like variables
Comparison of Representations
The Einstein-like invariant representation organizes the scalar sector as a minimally coupled perfect fluid with vanishing temperature, whereas the Jordan-like representation leaves the nonminimal-coupling/Hessian sector explicit, leading to a temperature-based imperfect-fluid interpretation The comparison shows that while both representations are mathematically legitimate, they provide different but equally invariant organizations of the same underlying scalar-tensor dynamics
Conclusion on Representation Dependence
The vanishing of the scalar-sector temperature is a property of the Einstein-like organization, not of the invariant formalism independently of representation choice The Jordan-like metric is equally invariant and leads instead to the imperfect-fluid organization displayed in Eqs. (52)-(69) The two descriptions are distinct invariant organizations of the same dynamics, adapted to different choices of metric representation
Summary Table
The comparison between the Einstein-like and Jordan-like invariant representations shows that the Einstein-like representation describes the scalar sector as a perfect fluid with vanishing temperature, while the Jordan-like representation exhibits an effective imperfect fluid structure with nonvanishing heat flux and anisotropic stress This clarifies that the vanishing temperature conclusion is contingent on the specific invariant organization chosen The Jordan-like representation is distinguished by minimal matter coupling, whereas the Einstein-like representation is distinguished by minimal gravitational dynamics The invariant formalism clarifies that different invariant representations can support different effective thermodynamic descriptions of the same conformal class
Future Directions
Extensions could involve applying this construction to multiscalar-tensor gravity to explore a richer imperfect-fluid decomposition Formulating the entropy current and entropy production directly in Jordan-like invariant variables would allow for a more detailed comparison between the temperature-based and chemical-potential-based descriptions Examining the role of perturbations and matter observables is necessary to understand if these different invariant organizations lead to distinct practical advantages in applications
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) through national funds under the research grant UID/04434/2025 (DOI 10.54499/UID/04434/2025)
References
[1] P. Jordan, Z. Phys. 157, 112 (1959)
[2] C. H. Brans and R. p. 0 H. Dicke, Phys. p. 8 Rev. 124, 925 (1961)
[3] P. G. Bergmann, Int. p. 8 J. Theor. Phys. 1, 25 (1968)
[4] R. V. Wagoner, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 1, 3209 (1970)
[5] Y. Fujii and K. p. 8-i. Maeda, The Scalar-Tensor Theory of Gravitation (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2003)
[6] V. Faraoni, Cosmology in Scalar-Tensor Gravity, Fundamental Theories of Physics, Vol. p. 8 139 (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 2004)
[7] T. Clifton, P. p. 8 G. Ferreira, A. p. 8 Padilla, and C. p. 8 Skordis, Phys. p. 8 Rept. 513, 1 (2012), arXiv:1106. p. 82476 [astro-ph. p. 8CO]
[8] D. S. Pereira, Phys. p. 8 p. 8 Lett. B 875, 140312 (2026), arXiv:2412. p. 806984 [gr-qc]
[9] D. S. Pereira, S. p. 8 Capozziello, F. p. 8 S. N. Lobo, and J. p. 8 P. Mimoso, Phys. p. 8 p. 8 Rev. D 113, 064055 (2026), arXiv:2511. p. 809208 [gr-qc]
[10] E. Di Valentino et al. p. 8 (CosmoVerse Network), Phys. p. 8 Dark Univ. 49, 101965 (2025), arXiv:2504. p. 801669 [astro-ph. p. 8CO]
[11] Y. Akrami et al. p. 8 (CANTATA), Modified Gravity and Cosmology. p. 8 An Update by the CANTATA Network, edited by E. p. 8 N. Saridakis, R. p. 8 Lazkoz, V. Salzano, P. p. 8 Vargas Moniz, S. p. 8 Capozziello, J. p. 8 Beltrán Jiménez, M. p. 8 De Laurentis, and G. p. 8 J. Olmo (Springer, 2021) arXiv:2105. p. 812582 [gr-qc]
[12] T. P. Sotiriou and V. p. 8 Faraoni, Rev. p. 8 Mod. Phys. 82, 451 (2010), arXiv:0805. p. 81726 [gr-qc]
[13] T. Damour and K. p. 8 Nordtvedt, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 48, 3436 (1993)
[14] L. Järv, P. Kuusk, M. Saal, and O. p. 8 Vilson, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 91, 024041 (2015), arXiv:1411. p. 81947 [gr-qc]
[15] V. Faraoni and A. p. 8 p. 8 Giusti, Phys. p. 8 p. 8 Rev. D 103, L121501 (2021), arXiv:2103. p. 805389 [gr-qc]
[16] V. Faraoni, S. p. 8 Giardino, A. p. 8 Giusti, and R. p. 8 Vanderwee, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 107, 023530 (2023), arXiv:2208. p. 804051 [grqc]
[17] V. Faraoni and A. Giusti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 211406 (2025), arXiv:2502. p. 818272 [gr-qc]
[18] N. Banerjee, A. p. 8 Giusti, V. Faraoni, L. p. 8 p. 8 Gallerani, and A. p. 8 Maltais-Gosselin, (2026), arXiv:2605. p. 824133 [gr-qc]
[19] V. Faraoni, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 112, L021504 (2025), arXiv:2505. p. 808322 [gr-qc]
[20] V. Faraoni and J. p. 8 Houle, Eur. p. 8 Phys. J. C 83, 521 (2023), arXiv:2302. p. 801442 [gr-qc]
[21] S. Giardino, V. p. 8 Faraoni, and A. p. 8 Giusti, JCAP 04 (04), 053, arXiv:2202. p. 807393 [gr-qc]
[22] V. Faraoni, A. p. 8 Giusti, S. Jose, and S. p. 8 Giardino, Phys. p. 8 Rev. D 106, 024049 (2022), arXiv:2206. p. 802046 [gr-qc]
[31] L. Järv and S. p. 2 Karamitsos, (2026), arXiv:2604. p. 816094 [gr-qc]
[32] V. Faraoni, L. Gallerani, A. p. 8 Maltais-Gosselin, S. p. 8 NovoaCattivelli, and U. p. 8 Gorman, (2026), arXiv:2606. p. 827799 [gr-qc]
[33] D. S. Pereira and J. p. 8 P. Mimoso, Phys. Rev. D 113, 084021 (2026), arXiv:2512. p. 820553 [gr-qc]
[34] D. S. Pereira, (2026), arXiv:2607. p. 816437 [gr-qc]
[35] D. S. Pereira, Phys. Rev. D 114, 024041 (2026), arXiv:2604. p. 816907 [gr-qc] p. 8
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
System can perform frame-invariant thermodynamic analysis by constructing Jordan-like invariant representations, which are not restricted to Einstein-frame like perfect fluid descriptions as in previous work.
-
The improved system can derive the Jordan-like invariant action directly from the original scalar tensor action by choosing the invariant matter metric as the basic geometrical variable, clarifying that this representation arises naturally rather than just being a reversal of an Einstein-like construction.
-
The AI can explicitly calculate heat flux and anisotropic stress in a generic congruence within the Jordan-like invariant representation, showing they are nonvanishing while recovering standard first-order thermodynamic identifications in invariant variables.
-
The system can compare the Einstein-like and Jordan-like invariant representations by showing they provide different but equally invariant organizations of the same scalar tensor dynamics, distinguishing between a perfect fluid description (Einstein) and an imperfect fluid description (Jordan).
-
The AI can identify that the vanishing temperature conclusion obtained in the Einstein-like representation is specific to that organization rather than a property of the invariant formalism itself, clarifying that
the vanishingtemperature conclusion is correct within the representation defined by Eq. (12), where the scalar sector is minimally coupled.
Sources
- Modified Gravity and Cosmology
- Scalar-tensor baryogenesis: a scalar-tensor completion of gravitational baryogenesis
- Novel scalar degrees of freedom emerging from hybrid metric-Palatini gravity
- The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
- Modified Gravity and Cosmology: An Update by the CANTATA Network
- f(R) Theories Of Gravity
- Invariant quantities in the scalar-tensor theories of gravitation
- Thermodynamics of scalar-tensor gravity
- Scalar field as a perfect fluid: thermodynamics of minimally coupled scalars and Einstein frame scalar-tensor gravity
- Thermal origin of the attractor-to-general-relativity in scalar-tensor gravity
- Towards a causal effective thermodynamics of scalar-tensor gravity
- Black hole interiors in the thermal view of scalar-tensor gravity
- More on the first-order thermodynamics of scalar-tensor and Horndeski gravity
- First-order thermodynamics of scalar-tensor cosmology
- Peculiar thermal states in the first-order thermodynamics of gravity
- First-order thermodynamics of scalar-tensor gravity
- First-order thermodynamics of Horndeski gravity
- The thermal view of $f(R)$ cosmology
- The thermal view of singularity-free scalar-tensor spacetimes
- Thermal aspects of the anomalous $\omega \to \infty$ limit of Brans-Dicke gravity
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals