Direct Numerical Simulation of Thermoacoustically Unstable Flames Via Non-Drifting Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Conditions

arXiv:2609.05656 · physics.flu-dyn, cs.NA, math.NA, physics.comp-ph · Submitted 2026-09-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Direct Numerical Simulation of Thermoacoustically Unstable Flames Via Non-Drifting Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Conditions".

Paper summary: Kai: Building on what we just heard about the coupling between heat release and acoustics, this paper directly simulates thermoacoustically unstable idealised premixed flames in a tube with acoustically closed upstream and open downstream ends.

Mira: The main point is that they demonstrate nonlinear saturation of the primary instability as the flame flattens, which happens when intrinsic flame instability modes get stabilized.

Lev: And they also found a secondary thermoacoustic instability that causes parametric flame instability and a drastic growth in acoustic amplitudes, which is something we need to watch out for when thinking about damage potential.

Kai: The paper presents Direct Numerical Simulations of these phenomena in this specific tube setup, which is important because high-quality imagery of each stage of instability is produced in the work seven eight <ref:2609.05656#pg2,high-quality imagery of each stage of instability is produced in>.

Mira: The complexity they tackle is that the coupled flame-flow system has intrinsic instabilities like Darrieus Landau or thermodiffusive instability, and various theoretical models exist for these two therm.

Lev: So, the paper isn't just looking at one thing; it's grappling with this three-way multiscale coupling between the flame, surrounding hydrodynamics, and acoustics of the combustion chamber.

Kai: The authors are showing that their approach handles this complexity by using Direct Numerical Simulations for these thermoacoustically unstable idealised premixed flames in a tube with acoustically closed upstream and open downstream ends.

Mira: They are presenting the results here to show how this coupling manifests in a way that standard models might miss because of the complex interplay between the flame, flow, and sound waves.

Lev: It’s important for us to see how these instabilities actually play out in terms of fluid dynamics before we even think about adding error correction overhead to real hardware.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, this paper is titled Direct Numerical Simulation of Thermoacoustically Unstable Flames Via Non-Drifting Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Conditions.

Mira: The authors introduced the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition and the Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation method to suppress numerical velocity and pressure drift in their simulations.

Lev: So, the implication is that these boundary conditions can contain the flame within a direct numerical simulation domain and respond as expected to both primary and secondary thermoacoustic instabilities.

Kai: And it suggests that this setup isn't just for ideal flames; it shows the methods could easily be applied to more realistic flames later on involving multiple species, mixture averaged properties, and temperature-dependent transport properties.

Mira: It’s about showing a robust way to study these phenomena numerically when you have those complex boundary conditions that keep drifting in standard models.

Lev: For someone working on error correction for real hardware, it shows that getting the boundary conditions stable is a critical part of the process before you even worry about the physics of the instability itself.

Benjamin L Cookman, Jack R C King, Raphaél C Assier, Steven J Lind

School of Engineering, University of Manchester · Department of Mathematics, University of Manchester · School of Engineering, Cardiff University

physics.flu-dyn, cs.NA, math.NA, physics.comp-ph

Submitted: 2026-09-04

Updated: 2026-11-17

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Thermoacoustic instability in premixed flames results from the coupling between the flame’s heat release, as determined by combustion parameters, and surrounding acoustics…

Key concepts

Thermoacoustic Instability
This occurs when heat released by a premixed flame interacts with surrounding sound waves, causing the flame structure to become unstable. The coupling between combustion parameters (heat release) and acoustic properties (combustor geometry) drives this instability.
Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC)
This method models how acoustic waves enter and leave the computational domain after a time delay ($ au_{U,D}$). It uses the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition to simulate this delayed reentry, effectively truncating the acoustic domain up and downstream from the flame.
Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR)
This is a new drift control method designed to manage numerical errors. It uses moving averages as a low-pass filter for high frequencies and an integral term to eliminate non-zero equilibrium drift, ensuring the simulation remains stable while controlling inflow velocity and outflow pressure.

Terminology

Summary

Thermoacoustic instability in premixed flames results from the coupling between the flame’s heat release, as determined by combustion parameters, and surrounding acoustics, as determined by combustor geometry <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Assier2 , and Steven J. Lind3 1School of Engineering, University of Manchester 2Department of Mathematics, University of Manchester 3School of Engineering, Cardiff University September 2026 Abstract Thermoacoustic instability in premixed flames results from the coupling between the flame’s heat release, as determined by combustion parameters, and surrounding acoustics, as determined by combustor geometry.

05656#pg2>. Results herein demonstrate nonlinear saturation of the primary instability as the flame flattens as well as an oscillating flame fingering characteristic of the unsteady Rayleigh-Taylor effect <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work, Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of thermoacoustically unstable idealised premixed flames in a tube with acoustically closed upstream and open downstream ends are presented. Results herein demonstrate nonlinear saturation of the primary instability as the flame flattens as well as an oscillating flame fingering characteristic of the unsteady Rayleigh-Taylor effect.

05656#pg2>.

Simulation Methodology and Boundary Conditions

Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) are presented for thermoacoustically unstable idealised premixed flames in a tube with acoustically closed upstream and open downstream ends <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. To reduce computational cost, DNS is performed only on the region surrounding the flame <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Results herein demonstrate nonlinear saturation of the primary instability as the flame flattens as well as an oscillating flame fingering characteristic of the unsteady Rayleigh-Taylor effect. To reduce computational cost, we perform DNS only on the region surrounding the flame.

05656#pg2>. Acoustics at in- and outflows are described using the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition (NSCBC) method to model their delayed reentry into the domain in a formulation referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

To reduce computational cost, we perform DNS only on the region surrounding the flame. Acoustics at in- and outflows are described using the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition (NSCBC) method to model their delayed reentry into the domain in a formulation referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method.

05656#pg2>. A new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is also introduced, which modifies the Classic Linear Relaxation (CLR) method to maintain time-averaged values of inflow velocity and outflow pressure <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Acoustics at in- and outflows are described using the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition (NSCBC) method to model their delayed reentry into the domain in a formulation referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method. A new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is also introduced, which modifies the Classic Linear Relaxation (CLR) method to maintain time-averaged values of inflow velocity and outflow pressure.

05656#pg2>.

Acoustic Modeling Details

The Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method models the delayed reentry of acoustic waves into the computational domain after a time delay τU and τD <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. This time delay takes the form of τU,D = 2LU,D/cU,D <ref:2609. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Attenuation due to acoustics is neglected for these time scales by Stokes’ law of sound attenuation [53]. The time delay takes the form: τU,D = LU,D cU,D − uU,D + LU,D cU,D + uU,D = 2LU,D cU,D 1 1 − Ma2 U,D .

05656#pg2>. The method is employed to truncate the acoustic domain up- and downstream from the flame in a manner similar to [47] <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The truncated domain reproduces the correct acoustic modes surrounding a flame anchored to a cylinder in a tube at reduced computational expense. In this article, we truncate the acoustic domain up- and downstream from the flame in a manner similar to [47].

05656#pg2>. Acoustic waves in these regions are modelled using the NSCBC formulation via their delayed reentry into the computational domain, referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Acoustic waves in these regions are modelled using the NSCBC formulation via their delayed reentry into the computational domain. This is herein referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method.

05656#pg2>.

Drift Control and Relaxation Terms

To control in- and outflow drift in the presence of acoustic waves under thermoacoustic instability, a new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is introduced <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. This method uses moving averages to act as a low-pass filter for frequencies corresponding to the characteristic tube frequency and above <ref:2609. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Any resulting formulation is likely, then, to have close to full reflections for frequencies associated with relaxation time scales and diminishing reflections for frequencies corresponding to the physical system’s acoustics. The work of [46] uses the same wave sampling formulation as [45], but improves upon convergence times by including a low-pass filter of the sampled outgoing acoustics in the P controller.

05656#pg2>. An integral term is also introduced to suppress non-zero equilibrium drift <ref:2609. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is also introduced, which modifies the Classic Linear Relaxation (CLR) method to maintain time-averaged values of inflow velocity and outflow pressure. Here, an integral control term is used to remove non-zero equilibrium time-averaged inflow velocities which impinge control over flame position.

05656#pg2>.

Instability Analysis Results

In a 10 cm tube, the fundamental mode continues to grow whilst the flame is flat with reduced growth rate so no limit cycle is reached in this case <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. In the 10 cm tube case, non-dimensional wavenumber k = 3 cellular parametric flame instability was observed as the flame oscillates subharmonically and results in periodic flame fingering <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

When a threshold acoustic amplitude is met, parametric instability occurs in which higher wavenumber perturbations to the flame front grow proportional to forcing frequency. A cellular flame front is formed which oscillates with double the period of the dominant acoustic mode (subharmonic oscillation).

05656#pg2>. The APILR drift control terms effectively contain the flame in the DNS domain and respond as expected to the primary and secondary thermoacoustic instability <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The resulting relaxation terms are referred to as the Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method. Later on, the ADCBC method enables DNS of the scarcely simulated cellular and non-cellular parametric flame instabilities resulting from thermoacoustic instability.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

The resulting relaxation terms are referred to as the Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method. Later on, the ADCBC method enables DNS of the scarcely simulated cellular and non-cellular parametric flame instabilities resulting from thermoacoustic instability.

05656#pg2>.

Conclusion

The Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method has been introduced <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. The Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method has also been introduced for these boundary conditions to suppress numerical velocity and pressure drift <ref:2609. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Acoustics at in- and outflows are described using the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition (NSCBC) method to model their delayed reentry into the domain in a formulation referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method. A new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is also introduced, which modifies the Classic Linear Relaxation (CLR) method to maintain time-averaged values of inflow velocity and outflow pressure.

05656#pg2>. The APILR drift control terms effectively contain the flame in the DNS domain and respond as expected to the primary and secondary thermoacoustic instability <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. The boundary conditions can just as easily be applied to more realistic flames involving e. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Later on, the ADCBC method enables DNS of the scarcely simulated cellular and non-cellular parametric flame instabilities resulting from thermoacoustic instability. The focus of this work are developments in boundary conditions, so the results can be applied to any existing e.

g. multiple species, mixture averaged and temperature-dependent transport properties and multiple step chemistry <ref:2609. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Having said this, the results contained herein can be trivially extended to e. mixtures of multiple species reacting in many steps and using transport which is mixture averaged and temperature-varying.

05656#pg2>.

A Calculation of Acoustic Eigenmodes

The linearised equations for acoustic pressure and velocity in the closed-open tube’s primary axis are the wave equations <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. The low-Mach assumption is responsible for (A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

This is due to the computational challenge associated with resolving thin reactive and diffusive regions in space and simulating acoustics in the full domain, all whilst obeying hyperbolic and parabolic stability constraints on time step. On top of this, many popular combustion codes use the low-Mach assumption (such as PeleLM [29], HOLOMAC [30] Nek5000 [31]), which precludes the relevant acoustic waves.

2b) as the corresponding jump condition in [58] is first-order in Mach number <ref:2609. p. 5
Where the paper says it

This solves the linear acoustic problem in the tube up- and downstream of the flame to leading order in Mach number whenever the assumption of one-dimensional acoustics is valid. We refer to this as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method.

05656#pg2>.

B Mathieu Equation Stability Analysis

Stability of the solutions to (B.1) can be determined entirely by the eigenvalues of the matrix A <ref:2609. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The vector b contains source terms acting on the primitive variables. The matrix Ax = Ax(V ) represents nonlinear terms like the advection terms in the x-direction and has real eigenvalues λm = λm(V ) and left-eigenvectors ℓm = ℓm(V ).

05656#pg2>. Stability is achieved when σ = max(λ1, λ2) 1 <ref:2609. p. 4
Where the paper says it

5) using the chosen primitive variables [41]: λ1 = u − c, ℓ T 1 = (0,−ρc, 0, 0, 1, 0) and L1 = λ1 ( ∂p ∂x − ρc ∂u ∂x) , (2. 10a) λ2 = u, ℓ T 2 = (c 2 , 0, 0, 0,−1, 0) and L2 = λ2 (c 2 ∂ρ ∂x − ∂p ∂x) , (2.

05656#pg2>.

The linearised equations for acoustic pressure and velocity in the closed-open tube’s primary axis are the wave equations <ref:2609.05656#pg2>. The wave equation model involves no damping terms so an imaginary component of f is not required <ref:2609. p. 6

Where the paper says it

where L Delay +,IN (t, y) ∶= RUL−,IN(t − τU, y) and L Delay +,OUT(t, y) ∶= RDL−,OUT(t − τD, y). 3) The first terms L NR + are the required condition described in Section 2.

05656#pg2>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved boundary conditions allow for Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of thermoacoustically unstable idealised premixed flames in a tube with acoustically closed upstream and open downstream ends by using the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method.

  2. The introduction of moving averages and integral terms in the Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method enables the suppression of numerical velocity and pressure drift, ensuring that the flat flame remains stationary in a counterflow equal to the laminar flame speed.

  3. The system can accurately simulate cellular secondary thermoacoustic instability by modeling the response of a flame flattened under primary thermoacoustic instability to harmonic transverse perturbations using the damped Mathieu equation.

  4. The improved control terms allow for the numerical simulation of combustion instabilities at significantly reduced computational expense by enabling the premixed flame can be contained in the DNS region over longer simulation times.

Abstract

In this work, Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of thermoacoustically unstable free flames in closed-open tubes are presented. Simulations demonstrate nonlinear saturation of the primary instability as the flame flattens, resulting in a quasiperiodic acoustic limit cycle. Acoustic forcing is used to trigger secondary parametric instability, causing an oscillatory flame fingering characteristic of the unsteady Rayleigh-Taylor effect. To reduce computational cost, we perform DNS only on the region surrounding the flame. Acoustics at in- and outflows are described using the Navier-Stokes Characteristic Boundary Condition (NSCBC) method to model their delayed reentry into the domain in a formulation referred to as the Acoustic Delay Characteristic Boundary Condition (ADCBC) method. A new Averaged Proportional and Integral Linear Relaxation (APILR) method is also introduced, which modifies the Classic Linear Relaxation (CLR) method to maintain time-averaged values of inflow velocity and outflow pressure. Many moving averages may be used consecutively to increase the damping rate of boundary reflection coefficients. An integral control term is used to remove non-zero equilibrium time-averaged inflow velocities which adversely affect control over flame position in the DNS region. Both new boundary methods demonstrate their capability in inert and counterflow flames test cases. In the case of a 100 cm long tube, these methods enable the numerical simulation of combustion instabilities at 98% reduced computational expense.

Related papers