Low-lying states of neutron-rich N=50 isotones in multi-reference covariant density functional theory

arXiv:2609.01364 · nucl-th · Submitted 2026-09-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Low-lying states of neutron-rich N=50 isotones in multi-reference covariant density functional theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Predictions for the systematics of low-lying states in neutron-rich N = 50 isotones from Zn 80 to Ca 70 exhibit substantial model dependence The low-energy structure exhibits a nonmonotonic evolution from spherical to strongly deformed and subsequently back to spherical shapes, consistent with valence-space shell-model predictions This work investigates these nuclei using multi-reference covariant density functional theory based on a relativistic energy density functional The results provide a coherent microscopic description of the structural evolution from the doubly magic Ni 78 to the neutron-rich N = 50 isotones.

Kai: Theoretical Framework The investigation employs multi-reference covariant density functional theory (MR-CDFT), specifically the generator coordinate method (GCM) with particle-number and angular-momentum projections This BMF approach restores broken symmetries and accounts for quantum shape fluctuations of reference states from mean-field calculations in the full single-particle space, thus avoiding effective charges in calculating electric transition strengths.

Mira: The nuclear collective wave function is constructed via configuration mixing of particle-number and angular-momentum projected meanfield states.

Kai: Structural Evolution Along the Isotonic Chain The potential energy surfaces (PESs) reveal a gradual transition from a soft spherical minimum in Ca 70 to a deformed prolate shape in Cr 74, abruptly interrupted by the doubly magic Ni 78 with a rigid spherical minimum.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "Low-lying states of neutron-rich N=fifty isotones in multi-reference covariant density functional theory", what does it really tell us about these nuclei <ref:2609.01364#pg1,Low-lying states of neutron-rich N=50 isotones in multi-reference>? It shows that the low energy structure isn't simple for these neutron rich systems.

Mira: They show a nonmonotonic evolution from spherical to deformed and back to spherical shapes, which is consistent with what we see in valence space shell model predictions. This means the magic numbers are not as rigid as we thought when you go far from stability.

Lev: For us building real hardware, that means your error correction overhead might have to adapt constantly depending on which specific nucleus you're targeting along that chain, because the underlying physics isn't staying constant.

Kai: The authors found a unified picture using their multi-reference covariant density functional theory, specifically the generator coordinate method. They successfully reproduced the key spectroscopic fingerprints of Nickel seventy eight and established coexistence between a spherical ground state band and a deformed rotational band.

Mira: And this success is encouraging because it shows that even in this complex region, you can get a self consistent description using this BMF approach without needing those effective charges in transition calculations.

Lev: That's good for the theory side; it means we don't have to introduce extra parameters just to make the calculation fit some experimental numbers.

Kai: The paper suggests that future work should focus on measurements of electric transition strengths and lifetimes in this neutron rich N=fifty region, because those are hard to measure right now <ref:2609.01364#pg1>.

Mira: Right, and they point out that while their results are strong constraints on collectivity and deformation, describing extremely neutron rich isotopes is still tough due to strong correlations and continuum coupling.

Lev: That's the caveat; so the physics is well constrained in this region of N=fifty but pushing further out requires tackling those strong correlations explicitly, which is a harder problem for any simulation <ref:2609.01364#pg1>.

Conclusion: Mira: So, this paper is about looking at how nuclei around neutron number fifty behave when they get very neutron rich.

Kai: It focuses on those isotopes from Zinc eighty to Calcium seventy and what their low-energy states actually look like.

Lev: The main thing here is that the structure isn't simple; it goes from one shape to another and then back again, which means the magic numbers aren't as fixed as we thought.

Mira: Yeah, they used this multi-reference covariant density functional theory method, specifically the generator coordinate method.

Kai: They got a consistent picture by avoiding those effective charges in their transition calculations by using a full single-particle space approach.

Lev: That's what matters for real hardware; it means you don't have to guess those correction factors just to get an electric transition strength right.

Mira: The results show that the doubly magic Nickel seventy eight is different from its neighbors in how it mixes spherical and deformed configurations.

Kai: It confirms that the structure evolves non-monotonically along this neutron fifty chain, which is what valence space shell model predictions expected.

Lev: But remember, they're still dealing with strong correlations and continuum coupling, so describing the very heaviest isotopes out there is still a big challenge for any simulation.

Mira: Exactly; the paper gives us really strong constraints on collectivity and deformation in this specific region of N fifty.

Kai: So, this unified description helps us map out how nuclear structure changes as you move away from stability in these exotic systems.

Lev: It sets a benchmark for how we should approach these many-body problems when scaling up to more complex systems.

Mira: Next, we're going to look at what this means for predicting the behavior of these nuclei in astrophysical environments like neutron star mergers.

School of Physics, Jiangxi Normal University · College of Physics and Electronic Engineering, Chongqing Normal University

nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-09-01

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: Predictions for the systematics of low-lying states in neutron-rich N = 50 isotones from Zn 80 to Ca 70 exhibit substantial model dependence The low-energy structure exhibits a nonmonotonic evolution…

Key concepts

Multi-reference Covariant Density Functional Theory (MR-CDFT)
This is an advanced theoretical method used to study nuclei. It combines relativistic mean-field calculations with a generator coordinate method to account for quantum shape fluctuations and broken symmetries in the nuclear wave function, offering a detailed view of nuclear structure.
Generator Coordinate Method (GCM)
A specific technique within MR-CDFT, GCM constructs the collective wave function by mixing particle-number and angular-momentum projected mean-field states. This allows researchers to explore different shapes and configurations simultaneously, which is crucial for describing shape coexistence in nuclei.
Shape Coexistence
This phenomenon occurs when a nucleus can exist in multiple distinct shapes at low energies, such as a spherical shape and a strongly deformed shape, simultaneously. The paper examines how this coexistence manifests along the N=50 isotones.
Electric Transition Strength (B(E2))
This quantity measures the probability of an electric quadrupole transition between two nuclear states. The MR-CDFT approach calculates these strengths by including full single-particle space, meaning it avoids needing effective charges, giving a more fundamental description.

Terminology

Summary

Predictions for the systematics of low-lying states in neutron-rich N = 50 isotones from Zn 80 to Ca 70 exhibit substantial model dependence The low-energy structure exhibits a nonmonotonic evolution from spherical to strongly deformed and subsequently back to spherical shapes, consistent with valence-space shell-model predictions This work investigates these nuclei using multi-reference covariant density functional theory based on a relativistic energy density functional The results provide a coherent microscopic description of the structural evolution from the doubly magic Ni 78 to the neutron-rich N = 50 isotones. p. 0

Theoretical Framework

The investigation employs multi-reference covariant density functional theory (MR-CDFT), specifically the generator coordinate method (GCM) with particle-number and angular-momentum projections This BMF approach restores broken symmetries and accounts for quantum shape fluctuations of reference states from mean-field calculations in the full single-particle space, thus avoiding effective charges in calculating electric transition strengths. p. 1 The nuclear collective wave function is constructed via configuration mixing of particle-number and angular-momentum projected meanfield states. p. 1

Structural Evolution Along the Isotonic Chain

The potential energy surfaces (PESs) reveal a gradual transition from a soft spherical minimum in Ca 70 to a deformed prolate shape in Cr 74, abruptly interrupted by the doubly magic Ni 78 with a rigid spherical minimum. The evolution of shell structure along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain exhibits several key features:

  1. A transition from spherical to strongly deformed and back to spherical shapes, which aligns with valence-space shell-model predictions. p. 1

  2. The emergence of deformed ground states in Fe 76 and Cr 74 is accompanied by enhanced quadrupole collectivity and stronger shape mixing. p. 0

  3. The absence of triaxial minima in the PESs obtained with the EDFs PC-PK1 (see Fig. p. 2 1) and D1S [36] restricts all subsequent BMF calculations to axisymmetric quadrupole deformations. p. 2

Spectroscopic Signatures and Model Comparison

The GCM calculations reproduce key spectroscopic fingerprints of the doubly magic closure in Ni 78, yielding an electric transition energy of E(2+1) = 2.64 MeV. The intraband B(E2; 2+2 → 0+2) = 451 e squared fm4 predicted by GCM is consistent with LSSM (516) [28], MCSM (641) [30], and CC (572 ± 86) [34] values. p. 3 Furthermore, the R42 = E(4+1)/E(2+1) ratios in Fig. p. 3 4(c) trace the evolution of collectivity along the N = 50 isotonic chain, showing that deformation and collectivity set in for Fe 76 and Cr 74. p. 3

Shape Coexistence and Collectivity Probes

Electric monopole transitions are sensitive probes of shape coexistence along the N = 50 isotonic chain. For Ni 78, the small ρ 2(E0; 0+2 → 0+1) value indicates weak shape mixing between the spherical and deformed configurations. p. 4 In contrast, enhanced collectivity in Cr 74 and Fe 76 yields much larger ρ 2(E0) values of about 20 × 10-3. p. 4

Conclusion

The findings provide a unified picture of N = 50 shell evolution from the spherical doubly magic nucleus Ni 78 to neutron-rich nuclei, and call for future measurements of transition strengths and lifetimes in this key region. The persistent N = 50 shell closure at Ni 78 is supported by models that yield E(2+1) ≥ 2. p. 330 MeV, significantly higher than neighboring nuclei. p. 3 Nevertheless, describing extremely neutron-rich isotopes remains challenging owing to strong correlations and continuum coupling. p. 5

--- Page 1 ---

Low-lying states provide a sensitive probe of nuclear shell structure The magic numbers that define closed proton or neutron shells have been a cornerstone of nuclear physics [1–3]. However, the evolution of shell structure away from stability provides stringent tests of modern many-body theories [4–6] and crucial inputs for rprocess nucleosynthesis [7–10], as manifested in the erosion of magic numbers [11, 12], the emergence of islands of inversion [13–15], and the appearance of shape coexistence [16, 17]. p. 0 The N = 50 isotones, ranging from the doubly magic Ni 78 (Z = 28) to more neutron-rich nuclei, offer an ideal testing ground for these phenomena, challenging both experimental and theoretical studies. p. 0 Recent experiments at next-generation radioactive-ion-beam facilities have investigated the neutron-rich N = 50 shell closure [18–20] and established low-lying states in Cu 79 [21] and Zn 79 [22]. p. 0 Taniuchi et al. p. 0 [23] reported the first spectroscopy of Ni 78, revealing E(2+1) = 2. p. 060 MeV and a tentative 2+ at 2. p. 091 MeV, which indicate spherical closure and deformation, respectively, and suggest shape coexistence. p. 0 The signature of shape coexistence has also been identified in measurements from neighboring nuclei [24, 25]. p. 0 Nevertheless, the evolution of shell structure in low-lying states along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain remains an open question [26, 27]. p. 0 Theoretically, various advanced approaches have been applied to study the low-lying states of neutron-rich N = 50 isotones. p. 0 Valence-space-based approaches, such as largescale shell model (LSSM) [28], Monte Carlo shell model (MCSM) [29, 30], realistic shell model (RSM) [31], and valence-space density matrix renormalization group (VSDMRG) [32], along with full-space-based methods including coupled-cluster (CC) [33, 34] and in-medium similarity renormalization group (IM-SRG) [23, 2609. p. 001364] have reproduced the shell structure and shape coexistence in Ni 78 and explored the structural evolution along the neutronrich N = 50 isotonic chain from Zn 80 to Ca 70. p. 0 In valencespace approaches, model-space truncation influences lowlying spectra, while effective charges in transition operators affect electric transition strengths, particularly in neutron-rich nuclei. p. 0 As a result, quantitative predictions for electric transition strengths, particularly B(E2) and E0 strengths, exhibit substantial model dependence across the neutron-rich N = 50 chain. p. 0 Within the energy density functional (EDF) framework, the beyond-mean-field (BMF) approach based on meanfield calculations in the full single-particle space, namely the five-dimensional collective Hamiltonian (5DCH) [36], has been employed using the Gogny D1S interaction to perform systematic calculations of low-lying states. p. 0 In contrast to the methods discussed above, 5DCH underestimates E(2+1), fails to describe a prolate rotational band built on the 0+ state of Ni 78, and does not exhibit the predicted evolution of the 2+1 excitation energies, B(E2) strengths, and R42 ratios along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain from 80Zn toward 70Ca. p. 0

--- Page 2 ---

In this letter, we adopt the multi-reference covariant density functional theory (MR-CDFT), i.e., the generator coordinate method (GCM) with particle-number and angular-momentum projections [37–41] to investigate the low-lying states in this region. p. 1 This BMF approach restores broken symmetries and accounts for quantum shape fluctuations of reference states from mean-field calculations in the full single-particle space, thus avoiding effective charges in calculating electric transition strengths. Our calculations reproduce key spectroscopic fingerprints of the doubly magic closure in Ni 78 and establish the coexistence of a spherical ground-state band and a deformed rotational band. p. 1 The successful description of Ni 78 encourages us to extend the study to the low-lying states and related electric transition strengths of N = 50 isotones from Zn 80 to Ca 70. p. 1 The low-energy structure exhibits a nonmonotonic evolution from spherical to strongly deformed and back to spherical shapes, in line with valence-space shell-model predictions but in contrast to the 5DCH results. p. 1 Our results provide robust constraints on collectivity and deformation in this key region, offering a unified and self-consistent BMF description of structural evolution along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain. p. 1

--- Page 3 ---

Sec. 2 briefly outlines the theoretical method In the MR-CDFT framework, the nuclear collective wave function is constructed via configuration mixing of particle-number and angular-momentum projected meanfield states Ψ JNZα i = X β f Jα(β)PˆJMKPˆN PˆZΦ(β) i, (1) where α labels different collective states for a given angular momentum J. p. 1 The reference states Φ(β) i are obtained from the relativistic mean-field plus Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (RMF+BCS) calculations [42–44]. p. 1 Applying the variational principle to the weight functions f Jα(β) yields the Hill-Wheeler-Griffin (HWG) equation. p. 1 Solving the HWG equation yields the collective weight functions and the energy spectrum, from which electric multipole transition strengths are calculated. p. 1

--- Page 4 ---

The electric quadrupole transition strength from the initial state (Ji, αi) to the final state (Jf, αf) is calculated by B(E2; Ji, αi → Jf, αf) = 1/2 Ji + 1 with the reduced transition matrix element hJf, β' Q 2Ji, βi = (2Jf + 1)(2Ji + 1)(5+2M=−-J f squared Ji 0 M −M! × Z π 0 sin θ dθ dJ i∗−M0(θ)hΦ(β')Q 2Me iθY P N P ZΦ(β) i, (4) where Q 2M ≡ er 2Y2M is the electric quadrupole moment operator. In addition, the electric monopole transition from the 0+2 to the 0+1 state is given by ρ 2(E0; 0+2 → 0+1) = h J +2 T(E0) +1 i eR 2 i / (4) with R0 = rA(1/3) and the transition matrix element h J+2 T(E0) +1 i = 1/2 X β', β f J2=0∗ 0+2 (β') f J1=0 +1 (β) × Z π 0 sin θ dθ hΦ(β')T(E0)e iθY P N P ZΦ(β) i, (6) where T J(E0) = P i eir 2 i. Since the full single-particle space is taken into account, no extra effective charges are needed to calculate the electric transition strengths; instead, the bare nucleon charges ep = 1 and en = 0 are directly adopted (see Refs. p. 1 [37–41]. The mean-field calculations are performed using the relativistic EDF PC-PK1 [48] with a harmonic oscillator basis of 10 major shells, under parity, x-simplex, and time-reversal symmetries. p. 1 Pairing correlations are treated within the BCS approximation using a densityindependent δ force implemented with a smooth cutoff factor [49]. p. 1

--- Page 5 ---

Fig. 1 illustrates the evolution of shell structure along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain via potential energy surfaces (PESs) in the (β, γ) plane, obtained from RMF+BCS calculations with the EDF PCPK1. p. 1 PESs reveal a gradual transition from a soft spherical minimum in Ca 70 to a deformed prolate shape in Cr 74, abruptly interrupted by the doubly magic Ni 78 with a rigid spherical minimum. p. 2 For N = 50 isotones with Z ≥ 28, the deformed relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory in continuum with PC-PK1 predicts spherical minima [51]. p. 2 In contrast, Gogny D1S [36] predicts spherical minima for all N = 50 isotones from Ti 72 to Zn 80. p. 2 Notably, removing two protons from Ni 78 to Fe 76 induces weak prolate softness, while adding two protons to Zn 80 preserves sphericity, underscoring the robust N = 50 shell closure along the Zn chain, in agreement with Ref. p. 2 [52].

--- Page 6 ---

Fig. 2 displays the projected PECs for neutron-rich N = 50 isotones. p. 2 For the spherical nuclei Ca 70, Ni 78, and Zn 80, the J = 0 PEC exhibits two near-degenerate minima at prolate and oblate shapes close to sphericity. p. 2 Projection generally deepens the RMF minima and extends the deformed region, as seen in Fe 76 [Fig. p. 2 2(d)], lying between spherical Ni 78 and deformed Cr 74. p. 0 The absence of-0. p. 24-0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4-0-.4 -.2.

--- Page 7 ---

Fig. 3 displays the low-lying spectrum of Ni 78. p. 2 Our GCM calculations are consistent with LSSM, MCSM, and CC, revealing two distinct bands and supporting the interpretation that the spherical band is dominated by valence-space configurations, while the deformed band originates from particle-hole (ph) excitations across the Z = 28 and N = 50 shell closures. p. 2 The GCM result for E(2+1), 2. p. 264 MeV, agrees well with the experimental value (2. p. 260), compared with LSSM (3. p. 215) [28], MCSM(a) (2. p. 057) [29], MCSM(b) (2. p. 030) [30], CC (2.45) [33, 34]. The deformed-band states predicted by GCM, LSSM, MCSM, and CC are indicated by dashed lines. p. 3

--- Page 8 ---

The 5DCH result is notably lower, indicating a quenched shell closure. Nevertheless, all models except 5DCH yield E(2+1) ≥ 2. p. 3 p. 330 MeV, significantly higher than the neighboring Ni 76 (0. p. 3 p. 399 MeV) and Zn 80 (1. p. 0 p. 049 MeV) [56]. p. 0 p. 0 For the second 0+ state, IM-SRG predicts a considerably higher excitation energy than the other model calculations, likely due to missing collective correlations. p. 3 p. 3 Moreover, the intraband B(E2; 2+2 → 0+2) = 451 e squared fm4 predicted from GCM is consistent with LSSM (516) [28], MCSM (641) [30], and CC (572 ± 86) [34] values. p. 3

--- Page 9 ---

The 5DCH result is notably lower, indicating a quenched shell closure. Nevertheless, all models except 5DCH yield E(2+1) ≥ 2.30 MeV, significantly higher than the neighboring Ni 76 (0.99 MeV) and Zn 80 (1.49 MeV) [56]. For the second 0+ state, IM-SRG predicts a considerably higher excitation energy than the other model calculations, likely due to missing collective correlations. Moreover, the intraband B(E2; 2+2 → 0+2) = 451 e squared fm4 predicted from GCM is consistent with LSSM (516) [28], MCSM (641) [30], and CC (572 ± 86] values. p. 3

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can accurately predict low-lying energy spectra for neutron-rich N = 50 isotones by employing multi-reference covariant density functional theory based on a relativistic energy density functional, as described in the paper's abstract and method sections.

  2. The improved AI system can identify and characterize shape coexistence in nuclei like Ni 78 by analyzing the low-lying states of Ni 78 and predicting a prolate rotational band built on the second 0+ state.

  3. The AI can map the structural evolution along the neutron-rich N = 50 isotonic chain from Zn 80 to Ca 70, specifically identifying a nonmonotonic evolution from spherical to strongly deformed and subsequently back to spherical shapes, which is consistent with valence-space shell-model predictions.

  4. The system can distinguish between theoretical approaches by comparing results, such as noting that the multi-reference covariant density functional theory (MR-CDFT) restores broken symmetries and accounts for quantum shape fluctuations of reference states from mean-field calculations in the full single-particle space.

  5. The improved AI can quantify electric transition strengths like B(E2) by calculating them using the method described in Section 2, which shows that no extra effective charges are needed to calculate the electric transition strengths; instead, the bare nucleon charges ep = 1 and en = 0 are directly adopted.

Related papers