Black hole apparent horizons become comoving with the universe
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Black hole apparent horizons become comoving with the universe".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving with the universe, confirming the necessity of a cosmological coupling and raising possibilities for early black hole growth The paper addresses the question of how a black hole horizon evolves in an expanding universe by showing that regular black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving, which confirms the necessity of a cosmological coupling The motivation stems from compelling evidence suggesting supermassive black holes grew very fast at high redshifts, which is difficult to explain via standard astrophysical channels Furthermore, the possibility that fundamental physics is missing in the description of early growth warrants investigation.
Kai: Astrophysical black holes are usually modeled using the vacuum Kerr solution, but their embedding in a universe means tiny effects of cosmic expansion could become relevant over billions of years.
Mira: Formal Setup and Definitions The study utilizes apparent horizons (AHs) to describe time-dependent black holes embedded in an FLRW universe, as event horizons are too teleological for this context.
Kai: The line element is given by ds2 = −T 2(t, r) dt squared + a 2(t, r) dr squared + r squared domega c(t, r) squared (1).
Title and authors: Kai: So we know the authors are Faraoni and Rinaldi and they tackle this evolution problem using apparent horizons in an FLRW universe. What's their main point about how these things behave?
Mira: They focus on the mathematical description of how the areal radius of these apparent horizons changes over time, which leads to a crucial relationship involving the black hole mass and its growth rate >
Lev: The core result they derive is that this mass growth rate is directly linked to the Hubble function at that horizon, which tells us about that cosmological coupling we talked about earlier >
Kai: So when you look at what they found, it seems like they've set up three possible scenarios for how fast these horizons can expand relative to the universe itself >
Mira: Right. They classify them as exactly comoving, slower than comoving, and faster than comoving scenarios based on the behavior of that radial velocity component >
Lev: And what they show is that only one scenario is physically viable in the long run, which is when that radial velocity component goes to zero >
The paper's summary: Kai: So what does this mean in plain English? It means that regardless of how fast a black hole starts growing or moving, it eventually gets locked into moving with the expansion of the universe >
Mira: That’s right. The key finding is that once you have an apparent horizon, its inherent coupling forces it to become comoving with the surrounding FLRW universe as time goes on >
Lev: From a real hardware perspective, this suggests that if we were ever looking at primordial black holes in the early universe during inflation, they wouldn't just be floating around independently >
Kai: That’s because this result gives us a potential mechanism for why supermassive black holes might have grown so quickly at very high redshifts where standard astrophysical growth models struggle >
Mira: It points toward something fundamental happening during inflation that could seed the growth of these massive objects in a way we haven't fully accounted for >
The paper's improvements: Lev: They do suggest a few things to make this analysis more useful. First, they identify exactly how the radial velocity component relates to the critical value of that Hubble function >
Kai: And they show that if you look at the condition where it's faster than comoving, which we call the faster than comoving RAH case, it leads to either divergence or asymptotic behavior >
Mira: The improvement here is showing that in those scenarios, if the mass and radius keep increasing, they either approach a constant value from below or they diverge entirely >
Lev: And in one of those cases where things diverge, the paper notes that if you look at the second term in that mass growth equation, it can dominate and make the expansion rate negative >
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "Black hole apparent horizons become comoving with the universe," it confirms that regular black hole apparent horizons are destined to become comoving with their surrounding FLRW universe >
Mira: This strongly supports the necessity of a cosmological coupling and opens up new avenues for thinking about how black holes grew during inflation, which is where they might have gotten their initial boost >
Lev: From an error correction perspective, this means that any future models we build for these early black holes need to account for this inevitable coupling when dealing with the expansion of spacetime >
Kai: So the main thing here is that it settles the puzzle of supermassive black hole growth at early epochs by suggesting a fundamental mechanism during inflation might be involved >
Mira: It’s a solid finding, and we can look forward to how other researchers build on this idea next >
Department of Physics & Astronomy, Bishop’s University · Department of Physics, University of Trento · Trento Institute for Fundamental Physics and Applications (TIFPA) — INFN
gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-08-21
Updated: 2026-11-14
Comments: Version accepted by Physical Review Letters
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 76/100
The gist: Black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving with the universe, confirming the necessity of a cosmological coupling and raising possibilities for early black hole growth Motivation for Study…
Key concepts
- Apparent Horizon (AH)
- An apparent horizon is used to describe time-dependent black holes embedded in an expanding FLRW universe. It's a quasi-local surface that describes the boundary of the region from which light cannot escape, unlike an event horizon which requires knowing the entire spacetime structure.
- Cosmological Coupling
- This refers to the interaction between a black hole and its surrounding expanding universe. The study shows that regular black hole apparent horizons are intrinsically coupled to this expansion, meaning they tend to adjust their motion to become comoving with the cosmic fluid over time.
- Areal Radius (R)
- The areal radius is a geometric invariant defined as R(t, r) = a(t, r)r. It represents the physical size of the horizon at a given location in spacetime. It is crucial for analyzing how the black hole's physical size changes over time relative to the cosmic scale factor 'a'.
Terminology
Summary
Black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving with the universe, confirming the necessity of a cosmological coupling and raising possibilities for early black hole growth
Motivation for Study
The paper addresses the question of how a black hole horizon evolves in an expanding universe by showing that regular black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving, which confirms the necessity of a cosmological coupling The motivation stems from compelling evidence suggesting supermassive black holes grew very fast at high redshifts, which is difficult to explain via standard astrophysical channels Furthermore, the possibility that fundamental physics is missing in the description of early growth warrants investigation. Astrophysical black holes are usually modeled using the vacuum Kerr solution, but their embedding in a universe means tiny effects of cosmic expansion could become relevant over billions of years. p. 0
Formal Setup and Definitions
The study utilizes apparent horizons (AHs) to describe time-dependent black holes embedded in an FLRW universe, as event horizons are too teleological for this context. The line element is given by ds2 = −T 2(t, r) dt squared + a 2(t, r) dr squared + r squared domega c(t, r) squared (1). p. 0 The areal radius is defined as R(t, r) = a(t, r)r. p. 0 The physical radii of apparent horizons are determined by the real positive roots of the equation ∇cR(t, r)∇cR(t, r) = 0 (2). p. 0
Evolution Analysis
The total time derivative of the areal radius is given by dRAH/dt = R˙ AH + ˙rAHaAH / (1 + a'AHrAH / aAH). Combining this with the Misner-Sharp-Hernandez mass definition, one finds 1/RAH dRAH/dt = HAH / (1 - aAHr˙AH/TAH) = 1/M dM/dt (8). p. 1 This quantity is crucial for determining the growth rate of the black hole mass M(t), which reflects the strength of the cosmological coupling. p. 1
Possible Horizon Behaviors
Three possible situations arise based on whether r˙AH is compared to the critical value TAH/aAH.
-
Exactly comoving apparent horizon: This occurs when r˙AH = 0, leading to M(t) = M0 a(t) (11), which implies 1/M dM/dt = HAH (12). p. 1
-
Slower than comoving apparent horizon: If r˙AH > 0 but less than the critical value, then 1/τBH < HAH, meaning the black hole mass increases slower than the cosmic background. p. 1
-
Faster than comoving RAH: If r˙AH HAH, and M and RAH always increase (if H ≥ 0) or asymptote to a constant value from below. p. 2
Conclusion on Physical Viability
The only physically viable scenario is where r˙AH → 0, which implies that once an apparent horizon forms, it is destined to become comoving with the surrounding FLRW universe due to its intrinsic coupling. This result suggests black holes eventually adjust themselves to become comoving with the universe independently of their initial velocity. p. 3 The paper concludes that this finding goes in the right direction for solving the puzzle of supermassive black hole growth at early epochs, potentially suggesting a fundamental growth mechanism during inflation. p. 3
--- Page 1 ---
Black hole apparent horizons become comoving with the universe Valerio Faraoni ID 1, ∗ and Massimiliano Rinaldi ID 2, 3, † Department of Physics & Astronomy, Bishop’s University, J1M 1Z7 Department of Physics, University of Trento, Via Sommarive 14, 38122 Povo (TN), Italy Trento Institute for Fundamental Physics and Applications (TIFPA) — INFN, Via Sommarive 14, 38122 Povo (TN), Italy It has been shown that static black hole event horizons cannot exist in time-dependent backgrounds without becoming naked singularities In light of this, we are left with the question “how does a black hole horizon evolve in an expanding universe?” Here we offer a solution to this puzzle by showing in full generality that regular black hole apparent horizons tend to become comoving, thus confirming the necessity of a cosmological coupling and raising intriguing possibilities for the early growth of black holes. p. 0 Introduction—There is now compelling evidence that supermassive black holes at the centres of galaxies have grown very fast at redshifts z > 6 It is very difficult, if not impossible, to explain this growth via standard astrophysical channels [1, 2] Stellar mass black holes are not free of problems either: the gravitational waves detected by LIGO and arising from binary mergers point to the existence of black holes in a mass gap forbidden by well-established stellar evolution [3–5] Given these difficulties, it is worth considering whether fundamental physics is missing in the description. p. 0 In other words, it is possible that there is some fundamental reason for early growth that is completely independent of environmental factors. p. 0 Apart from interactions with test fluids and plasmas, astrophysical black holes are usually modelled using the vacuum Kerr solution of general relativity, which is isolated and asymptotically flat [6], but astrophysical black holes are embedded in the universe instead. p. 0 Astrophysical and cosmological scales are vastly separated but, over billions of years, tiny effects of the cosmic expansion on black holes could accumulate and become astrophysically relevant. p. 0 Ref. [7] studied black hole populations in red elliptical galaxies at redshifts 0 < z ≤ 2. p. 05 and reported tentative evidence of coupling between the masses of supermassive black holes and the scale factor of the ambient Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) universe [7, 8], which is also in agreement with the recent DESI results on the redshift evolution of the dark energy equation of state [9, 10] Potentially observable effects might also appear in the spectrum of the stochastic background of gravitational waves generated by slowly inspiralling supermassive black holes [11, 12] and in the orbital timing of black hole - pulsar binary systems [13]. p. 0 Although very preliminary and widely questioned ([12, 14–22] and references therein), the suggestion that black holes may “feel” the cosmic expansion, given enough time to sample it, cannot be discarded a priori. p. 0 A more speculative context in which black holes cannot be approximated by the asymptotically flat Schwarzschild or Kerr solution is that of primordial black holes in the early universe. p. 0 At very early epochs, and especially during inflation, the Hubble scale is much smaller than in the present universe and the separation between black hole and cosmological scales is not as sharp [23–26] The search for exact solutions of the Einstein equations describing black holes (or other objects) in a FLRW universe began with McVittie [27] and Einstein & Straus [28], but has not been fruitful due to the lack of generic solutions (as opposed to asymptotically flat black holes in which case the Kerr solution is generic). p. 0 For this reason, here we study the problem of the evolution of black holes in general terms without referring to specific solutions of the Einstein equations. p. 0 In a previous work we showed that a black hole event horizon (a null surface) that locally resembles a Schwarzschild one cannot be rigorously static (even momentarily) in an evolving environment, since this requirement forces it to become a naked (null) singularity ([29], see also [30]). p. 0 This result raises the question of how a black hole evolves in the specific environment of an expanding FLRW universe. p. 0 Time-dependent black holes are best described by apparent horizons (AHs), which are defined quasi-locally, instead of event horizons which are teleological and can only be defined by knowing the entire spacetime structure, including future infinity. p. 0 Apparent horizons— To describe a central black hole embedded in a FLRW universe, consider the line element ds2 = −T 2(t, r) dt2 + a 2(t, r) dr squared + r squared domega c(t, r) squared (1) depicting a general time-dependent and spherically symmetric manifold in isotropic coordinates. p. 0 Here, domega c(t, r) squared = dϑ squared + sin squared ϑ dϕ squared is the line element on the unit 2-sphere and T ≥ 0, a > 0. p. 0 At large radial distances r from the central black hole, T (t, r) must reduce to unity and a(t, r) ≃ a(t) loses its spatial dependence (we restrict to spatially flat FLRW “backgrounds” for simplicity, but there is no problem of principle in considering spatially curved universes). p. 0 The areal radius is the geometric invariant R (t, r) = a (t, r) r. p. 0 If apparent horizons exist, their physical radii RAH(t) = a (t, rAH(t)) rAH(t) are determined by the real positive roots of the equation ∇cR(t, r)∇cR(t, r) = 0 (2). p. 0 In these expressions, and from now on an overdot and a prime denote, respectively, partial differentiation with respect to t and r. p. 0 Since R˙ = ˙ar and R′ = a + a'r by construction at the apparent horizon Eq. (2) yields a˙ AHrAH TAH = ± 1 + a'AHrAH / aAH, where the positive sign describes a cosmological apparent horizon since, for large radii, it reduces to the well-known expression rAH ≃ 1/a˙, or RAH ∼ 1/H, where H ≡ a/a˙ is the Hubble function [31]. Choosing the negative sign, which describes the black hole apparent horizon, we have R˙ AH = −TAHR′ / aAH. p. 1 From now on we drop the arguments of the functions rAH and aAH unless necessary. p. 1 In an expanding universe R˙ = ˙ar > 0, thus we infer from Eq. p. 1 (5) that R′ AH < 0. R˙ = ˙ar by construction since r˙ = 0, thus we also have R˙ AH = ˙aAHrAH (however, this does not imply that rdotAH/dt vanishes). p. 1 With this in mind, we write Eq. p. 1 p. 1 (5) as a˙ AHrAH TAH + a'AHrAH / aAH + 1 = 0. In an expanding universe a >˙ 0 everywhere, thus also2 a˙ AH > 0 and the equation above can only be satisfied if a'AH < 0. Our goal is to understand whether the black hole apparent horizon expands, and at which rate. p. 1 p. 1 A natural question is whether the black hole apparent horizon can expand faster, slower, or at the same rate as the cosmic substratum in which it is embedded. p. 1 p. 1 Therefore, the main quantity to study is the total time derivative of the areal radius of the apparent horizon. p. 1 p. 1 By recalling that R˙ AH = ˙aAHrAH we find dRAH/dt = R˙ AH + ˙rAHaAH / (1 + a'AHrAH / aAH). By combining Eqs. p. 1 p. 1 (6) and (7), we find 1/RAH dRAH/dt = HAH / (1 - aAHr˙AH/TAH) = 1/M dM/dt, where HAH is the Hubble function at the apparent horizon. p. 1 p. 1 The last equality follows from the definition of the Misner-Sharp-Hernandez mass M [33, 34] At the apparent horizon, 2MAH = RAH which mimics the well known expression of the Schwarzschild radius. p. 1 p. 1 The value of the quantity within the round brackets of Eq. p. 1 p. 1(8) is crucial to determine the growth rate of the black hole mass M(t), hence the strength of the cosmological coupling. p. 1 p. 1 Three possible situations arise in principle, which we discuss separately. p. 1 p. 1 They do not necessarily occur, but we need to contemplate them all to figure out the only possible physical situation. p. 1 p. 1 Exactly comoving apparent horizon — In this case r˙AH = 0, rAH = r0 = const. p. 1 p. 1, and RAH = a (t, r0) r0 ≡ a(t) r0, M(t) = M0 a(t) (with M0 constant) are exactly comoving with the cosmic fluid and Slower than comoving apparent horizon — If r˙AH > 0, the comoving radius rAH of the apparent horizon grows, (1 − aAHr˙AH/TAH) τcosmic, where τBH and τcosmic are the time scales of variation of the black hole apparent horizon and of the surrounding cosmological “background”, respectively. p. 1 Faster than comoving RAH — The last possibility is r˙AH 1 in Eq. p. 2 p. 2 (8) and to 1/τBH = 1/M dM/dt > HAH = 1/τcosmic > 0, M and RAH always increase (if H ≥ 0) and either asymptote to constant values from below or diverge. p. 2 p. 2 In the first case, they would be contained inside a naked null singularity dividing spacetime into two disconnected regions, which is unphysical. p. 2 p. 2 In the second case, since rAH decreases and is bounded from below by zero, it either reaches zero with non-zero derivative and the apparent horizon disappears, which is unphysical, or else it asymptotes to a constant value r0 > 0, with M and RAH becoming asymptotically comoving. p. 2 p. 2 To summarize, the only physically viable scenario is one where r˙AH → 0
--- Page 2 ---
2 respect to t and r Since R˙ = ˙ar > 0, thus we infer from Eq. (5) that R′ AH < 0. R˙ = ˙ar by construction since rdotAH/dt vanishes, thus we also have R˙ AH = ˙aAHrAH (however, this does not imply that rdotAH/dt vanishes). p. 1 With this in mind, we write Eq. (5) as a˙ AHrAH TAH + a'AHrAH / aAH + 1 = 0. In an expanding universe a >˙ 0 everywhere, thus also2 a˙ AH > 0 and the equation above can only be satisfied if a'AH < 0. Our goal is to understand whether the black hole apparent horizon expands, and at which rate. A natural question is whether the black hole apparent horizon can expand faster, slower, or at the same rate as the cosmic substratum in which it is embedded. Therefore, the main quantity to study is the total time derivative of the areal radius of the apparent horizon. By recalling that R˙ AH = ˙aAHrAH we find dRAH/dt = R˙ AH + ˙rAHaAH / (1 + a'AHrAH / aAH). By combining Eqs. (6) and (7), we find 1/RAH dRAH/dt = HAH / (1 - aAHr˙AH/TAH) = 1/M dM/dt, where HAH is the Hubble function at the apparent horizon. The last equality follows from the definition of the Misner-Sharp-Hernandez mass M [33, 34] At the apparent horizon, 2MAH = RAH which mimics the well known expression of the Schwarzschild radius. The value of the quantity within the round brackets of Eq.(8) is crucial to determine the growth rate of the black hole mass M(t), hence the strength of the cosmological coupling. Three possible situations arise in principle, which we discuss separately. They do not necessarily occur, but we need to contemplate them all to figure out the only possible physical situation. Exactly comoving apparent horizon — In this case r˙AH = 0, rAH = r0 = const., and RAH = a (t, r0) r0 ≡ a(t) r0, M(t) = M0 a(t) (with M0 constant) are exactly comoving with the cosmic fluid Slower than comoving apparent horizon — If r˙AH > 0, the comoving radius rAH of the apparent horizon grows, (1 − aAHr˙AH/TAH) τcosmic, where τBH and τcosmic are the time scales of variation of the black hole apparent horizon and of the surrounding cosmological “background”, respectively. p. 1 Faster than comoving RAH — The last possibility is r˙AH 1 in Eq. (8) and to 1/τBH = 1/M dM/dt > HAH = 1/τcosmic > 0, M and RAH always increase (if H ≥ 0) and either asymptote to constant values from below or diverge. In the first case, they would be contained inside a naked null singularity dividing spacetime into two disconnected regions, which is unphysical. In the second case, since rAH decreases and is bounded from below by zero, it either reaches zero with non-zero derivative and the apparent horizon disappears, which is unphysical, or else it asymptotes to a constant value r0 > 0, with M and RAH becoming asymptotically comoving.
--- Page 3 ---
3 The fact that M decreases can be interpreted by saying that, in comparison with a comoving sphere which incorporates more and more cosmic material as it expands, a less-than-comoving sphere loses mass Since they are bounded from below by zero and monotonic, they eventually either vanish, which is unphysical for realistic black holes, or they asymptote to constant values and the black hole approaches the pathological null event horizon-singularity, which becomes barely covered by the apparent horizon. p. 2 By “pathological” we mean a solution that hosts a null, naked singularity at the would-be static event horizon, according to what was shown in [29]. p. 2 The well-known McVittie solution [27] is a concrete example of this scenario [31, 32] Moreover, by slowing down its evolution, the black hole horizon eventually reaches an adiabatic regime in which black hole thermodynamics is meaningful [31, 35–37] and the decreasing apparent horizon area AAH = 4πR 2AH implies a decreasing entropy S = AAH/4, contradicting a tenet of black hole physics (cf. p. 2 Ref. [29]). If r˙AH is initially larger than the critical value, r˙AH > TAH/aAH > 0, then RAH and M decrease monotonically. p. 1 Since they are bounded from below by zero and monotonic, they eventually either vanish, which is unphysical for realistic black holes, or they asymptote to constant values and the black hole approaches the pathological null event horizon-singularity, which becomes barely covered by the apparent horizon. In the first case, since the universe expands and aAH → +∞ as t → +∞, there are two possibilities. p. 2 Either r˙AH → 0, in which case the bla… p. 2
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can predict whether a black hole apparent horizon expands faster, slower, or at the same rate as its cosmic substratum by analyzing Eq (8). This allows for a determination of whether 1 over M dM over dt is less than or greater than 1 over HAH.
-
Improved AI can classify the evolution of black hole mass M(t) based on the value of r dot AH relative to the critical value TAH/aAH. This classification includes scenarios where
Exactly comoving apparent horizon,
Slower than comoving apparent horizon,
andFaster than comoving RAH.
-
Improved AI can infer a fundamental growth mechanism for supermassive black holes by linking the required decrease in r dot AH to the exponential growth of the scale factor during inflation, suggesting a possible fundamental mechanism forming larger black holes than expected.
Sources
- The Assembly of the First Massive Black Holes
- The origins of massive black holes
- GW190521: A Binary Black Hole Merger with a Total Mass of $150 ~ M_{\odot}$
- GWTC-3: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the Second Part of the Third Observing Run
- Observing intermediate-mass black holes and the upper--stellar-mass gap with LIGO and Virgo
- Observational evidence for cosmological coupling of black holes and its implications for an astrophysical source of dark energy
- Positive neutrino masses with DESI DR2 via matter conversion to dark energy
- DESI Dark Energy Time Evolution is Recovered by Cosmologically Coupled Black Holes
- Implications of cosmologically coupled black holes for pulsar timing arrays
- Constraints on cosmological coupling from the accretion history of supermassive black holes
- Implications of Symmetry and Pressure in Friedmann Cosmology. I. Formalism
- Constraints on the Cosmological Coupling of Black Holes from the Globular Cluster NGC 3201
- Constraints on the cosmological coupling of black holes from Gaia
- Can cosmologically-coupled mass growth of black holes solve the mass gap problem?
- Constraints on cosmologically coupled black holes from gravitational wave observations and minimal formation mass
- Quasi-local masses and cosmological coupling of black holes and mimickers
- Cosmological coupling of nonsingular black holes
- Cosmological coupling of local gravitational systems
- Cosmologically coupled compact objects: a single parameter model for LIGO--Virgo mass and redshift distributions
- Apparent horizons in cosmologically-embedded black holes
Related papers
- Accurate waveforms for generic planar-orbit binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv6EHM
- Analytic Marginalization Over Calibration Uncertainties in Gravitational Wave Inference and Application to Black Hole Ringdown
- A catalog of long, eccentric and precessing binary black hole simulations from ICTS-TIFR
- Pole Skipping, Avoided Crossing, and Resonant Excitation in Kerr Quasinormal Modes near Algebraically Special Frequencies
- Gravitational Waves from Green's Function Decomposition for a Kerr black hole: I. Equatorial ISCO Plunge
- A New Spin on Dissipative Tides: First-Post-Newtonian Effects in Compact Binary Inspirals