Search for C!P violation in D+ to phi pi+ decays

arXiv:2607.20276 · hep-ex · Submitted 2026-07-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Search for C!P violation in D+ to phi pi+ decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The input provided is fragmented and contains both numerical results and methodological descriptions, which I will now synthesize into a comprehensive summary.

Kai: Here is the detailed summary of the research: The study investigates charge-parity (CP) violation within the Cabibbo-suppressed decay D+ to phi pi+ using data collected by the LHCb experiment during Run 2, specifically utilizing an integrated luminosity of 6 fb-1 at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV.

Mira: The primary measurement focuses on the direct CP asymmetry, defined as a CP(D+ to phi pi+).

Kai: The initial measurement yields a value of a CP(D+ to phi pi+) = (0.1 plus or minus 4.9 (stat) plus or minus 2.4 (syst)) times 10-4.

Title and authors: Kai: Let’s talk about the paper, "Search for C!P violation in D+ to phi pi+ decays," and the folks who wrote it. The title itself tells you right away that they are hunting for charge parity violation in a specific charm decay channel.

Mira: I read the abstract and see they used LHCb data from Run two specifically six femtobarns of integrated luminosity at a center-of-mass energy of thirteen teraelectron volt <ref:2607.20276#pg1>. That sets the experimental context very clearly for anyone trying to understand the scope of the measurement.

Lev: The authors are doing this work on probing a complementary flavor sector compared to K and B mesons because charm decays involve up type quarks, which means they’re sensitive to different classes of potential new interactions according to the Standard Model.

Kai: So, they’re using charm hadrons as a unique laboratory for looking for new sources of CP violation that might be suppressed in the strange and beauty sectors. That's a pretty important distinction.

Mira: They are motivated by the fact that the Standard Model contribution to CP violation is not enough to explain why there is more matter than antimatter in our universe, which drives these precision searches for additional sources.

Lev: And from an engineering view, they’re focusing on a system where the SM contributions are expected to be strongly suppressed, which means any signal we see here could point towards physics beyond the Standard Model.

The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what this paper is actually doing, they are measuring the direct CP asymmetry in the D plus to phi pi plus decay. They found a baseline result of zero point one plus or minus four point nine statistical and two point four systematic times ten to the negative four <ref:2607.20276#pg1>.

Mira: But they didn't stop there. They investigated not just that asymmetry, but also the modulus of the ratio and relative strong phase between two decay amplitudes: D plus to K zero pi plus and D plus to K zero pi plus.

Lev: This is where it gets interesting for us because they use a time dependent model for neutral kaon detection asymmetry that includes interference between charm final state and decay state charm decay amplitudes.

Kai: That model lets them determine the hadronic parameters, r pi and delta pi, directly from data without needing to rely on external theoretical inputs for those things.

Mira: They found best fit values for those parameters are r pi equal negative zero point nine five and delta pi equal negative three pi over four. They also reported alternative results by fixing those strong parameters to either theoretical predictions or experimental constraints.

Lev: So, they’re essentially using the D plus to K zero S pi plus decays as a calibration mode to correct for asymmetries arising from production and detection effects associated with the charged pion accompanying the phi meson.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests some real improvements in how we approach these CP violation searches. They point out that incorporating interference between Cabibbo favoured and doubly Cabibbo suppressed D plus to K zero pi plus decay amplitudes allows for enhanced precision in extracting the direct CP asymmetry.

Mira: That’s a big deal because it means we can determine those hadronic parameters r pi and delta pi directly from data, superseding the reliance on external theoretical inputs that we usually have to use.

Lev: And they suggest using a frequentist profile likelihood method to determine confidence intervals for r pi and delta pi based on data alone, instead of just relying on external theoretical predictions or simple approximations like r pi equal zero.

Kai: For instance, they found that under certain constraints from the FAT prediction, they got r pi equal negative zero point seven three plus or minus zero point four under those conditions.

Mira: And delta pi was negative one point three nine plus one point three radians under those same constraints, which shows how much the results shift depending on the assumptions we put in there.

Lev: It’s a lot of parameters to track for real hardware, so having a method that lets us quantify the uncertainty based purely on data is really valuable for designing systems.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper, the main implication is that they have provided a rigorous, data driven determination of CP violation parameters in this decay channel while simultaneously testing and constraining theoretical models of neutral kaon dynamics.

Mira: They’ve established that their best fit for the direct CP asymmetry in D plus to phi pi plus decay is zero point one plus or minus four point nine statistical and two point four systematic times ten to the negative four <ref:2607.20276#pg1,the direct CP asymmetry in>.

Lev: For us, it means we have a concrete handle on those hadronic parameters, which is crucial if we want to build experiments that can actually run on real hardware with high fidelity.

Kai: This paper, "Search for C!P violation in D+ to phi pi+ decays," gives us a data driven determination of CP violation parameters in this decay channel.

Mira: It shows how important it is to look at these complex interference effects when searching for new sources of CP violation that might be strongly suppressed.

Lev: We’re ready for the next paper, and we need to think about how we translate all this data into something that runs reliably on a real machine.

European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)

hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-07-22

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: All figures and tables, along with machine-readable versions and any supplementary material and additional information, are available at https://lbfence.cern.ch/alcm/public/analysis/full-details/5870/ (LHCb public pages)

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: The input provided is fragmented and contains both numerical results and methodological descriptions, which I will now synthesize into a comprehensive summary.

Key concepts

Direct CP Asymmetry ($a_{CP}$)
This measures the difference in decay rates between a particle and its antiparticle. It indicates whether the decay process violates charge-parity symmetry, providing a direct probe of fundamental CP violation in charm decays.
$r_ ext{pi}$ and $\delta_ ext{pi}$
These are hadronic parameters derived from analyzing the interference between different charm decay amplitudes. They describe the relative strong phases and magnitudes of these amplitudes, allowing researchers to test theoretical models of neutral kaon dynamics.
Time-Dependent Model for Neutral Kaon Asymmetry
This sophisticated model describes how neutral kaons are detected by incorporating interference between Charm Final State (CF) and Decay-State (DCS) charm decay amplitudes. This approach allows for the direct extraction of $r_ ext{pi}$ and $\delta_ ext{pi}$ from experimental data.
LHCb Run 2 Data Analysis
The research utilized high-precision data collected by the LHCb experiment during Run 2, specifically using $6 ext{ fb}^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity at a center-of-mass energy of $13 ext{ TeV}$ to perform the measurement.

Terminology

Summary

The input provided is fragmented and contains both numerical results and methodological descriptions, which I will now synthesize into a comprehensive summary.

Here is the detailed summary of the research:

The study investigates charge-parity (CP) violation within the Cabibbo-suppressed decay D+ to phi pi+ using data collected by the LHCb experiment during Run 2, specifically utilizing an integrated luminosity of 6 fb-1 at a center-of-mass energy of 13 TeV. The primary measurement focuses on the direct CP asymmetry, defined as a CP(D+ to phi pi+). p. 2

Where the paper says it

Within the SM, CP-violating effects in charm decays are expected to be very small, typically of the order of 10−4 to 10−3 , owing to the strong suppression of flavour-changing neutral currents by the Glashow–Iliopoulos–Maiani (GIM) mechanism and the smallness of the relevant CKM matrix elements [5, 6]. Singly Cabibbo-suppressed D→ f (D→ f) decays, where the initial D state can be D+, D0 , D+ s , provide one of the most sensitive tests of CP violation through the measurement of the direct asymmetry, defined as aCP (D→ f) ≡ Γ(D→ f) − Γ(D→ f) Γ(D→ f) + Γ(D→ f) , (1) where Γ(D→ f) (Γ(D→ f)) denotes the partial decay width of the initial D (D) meson into the final state f (f).

The initial measurement yields a value of a CP(D+ to phi pi+) = (0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Within the SM, CP-violating effects in charm decays are expected to be very small, typically of the order of 10−4 to 10−3 , owing to the strong suppression of flavour-changing neutral currents by the Glashow–Iliopoulos–Maiani (GIM) mechanism and the smallness of the relevant CKM matrix elements [5, 6]. Singly Cabibbo-suppressed D→ f (D→ f) decays, where the initial D state can be D+, D0 , D+ s , provide one of the most sensitive tests of CP violation through the measurement of the direct asymmetry, defined as aCP (D→ f) ≡ Γ(D→ f) − Γ(D→ f) Γ(D→ f) + Γ(D→ f) , (1) where Γ(D→ f) (Γ(D→ f)) denotes the partial decay width of the initial D (D) meson into the final state f (f).

1 plus or minus 4.9 (stat) plus or minus 2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The direct CP asymmetry in the D+ → ϕπ+ decay is measured to be aCP (D+ → ϕπ+) = (0. 9 (stat) ± 2.

4 (syst)) times 10-4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

9 (stat) ± 2. 4 (syst)) × 10−4 .

The total statistical uncertainty for this baseline result is estimated at 3. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Within each bin, the kinematic distributions of the D+→ ϕπ+ candidates are weighted to match those of the corresponding D+→ K0 Sπ + candidates. This procedure yields a smaller final statistical uncertainty on aCP (D+→ ϕπ+) than would be obtained by weighting the kinematics of the D+→ K0 Sπ + candidates to those of the signal D+→ ϕπ+ candidates.

3 times 10-4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The inclusion of these new effects in the model enables the usage of the full available data sample, including for the first time the D+→ K0 Sπ + decays where the K0 S mesons decay downstream of the vertex detector acceptance. These decays correspond to longer kaon decay times, where interference and regeneration effects are amplified and can be controlled more precisely.

Crucially, the analysis extends beyond a simple asymmetry measurement by investigating the modulus of the ratio and the relative strong phase between two decay amplitudes: D+ to K 0 pi+ and D+ to K 0 pi+. p. 0

Where the paper says it

For the first time at a hadron collider, the modulus of the ratio and the relative strong phase of the D+ → K0π + to D+ → K 0 π + decay amplitudes are also investigated. Two-dimensional confidence intervals are reported for these parameters.

To achieve this, the analysis employs D+ to K 0 S pi+ decays as a calibration mode to effectively correct for any detection asymmetries. p. 0
Where the paper says it

EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN) CERN-EP-2026-158 LHCb-PAPER-2026-011 July 22, 2026 Search for CP violation in D+ → ϕπ+ decays LHCb collaboration† Abstract A search for charge-parity (CP) violation in the Cabibbo-suppressed D+ → ϕπ+ decay is presented, using proton-proton collision data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 6 fb−1 , collected at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV with the LHCb detector during Run 2. An abundant sample of D+ → K0 S π + decays is employed to correct for asymmetries arising from the production of the charmed meson and from detection effects associated with the charged pion accompanying the ϕ meson.

The methodology involves developing a time-dependent model for the neutral-kaon detection asymmetry. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The result supersedes the previous LHCb measurement based on a partial dataset [31], and utilises D+→ K0 Sπ + decays as calibration, to precisely remove detection asymmetries. For the first time, the phenomenological model of the neutral-kaon asymmetry in matter has been extended to accurately account for the contribution from incoherent K0 S regeneration 2

This model is sophisticated, incorporating interference between Charm Final State (CF) and Decay-State (DCS) charm decay amplitudes. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The third, instead, arises when two or more charm decay amplitudes contribute to the same final state. In the specific case of the D+→ K0 Sπ + decay, the interference between the CF and DCS decay amplitudes A(D+→ K0π +) and A(D+→ K0π +), combined with neutral-kaon mixing and regeneration, induces an additional time-dependent asymmetry.

This approach is significant because it allows for the direct determination of hadronic parameters, specifically r pi and delta pi, without relying on external theoretical inputs. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In addition, this paper presents a frequentist template-based fit to the ∆As values, allowing for the direct determination of confidence intervals for the strong parameters rπ and δπ from the data. This represents the first measurement of these parameters in a hadronic environment.

These parameters are incorporated by extending phenomenological models of neutral-kaon asymmetry in matter to include contributions from incoherent K 0 S regeneration and CF-DCS interference. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The result supersedes the previous LHCb measurement based on a partial dataset [31], and utilises D+→ K0 Sπ + decays as calibration, to precisely remove detection asymmetries. For the first time, the phenomenological model of the neutral-kaon asymmetry in matter has been extended to accurately account for the contribution from incoherent K0 S regeneration 2

The best-fit values derived from this comprehensive analysis for the direct CP asymmetry are a CP(D+ to phi pi+) = (0. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The best-fit value of aCP (D+→ ϕπ+) was examined only after the analysis strategy was finalised, to avoid experimenter bias. In addition, this paper presents a frequentist template-based fit to the ∆As values, allowing for the direct determination of confidence intervals for the strong parameters rπ and δπ from the data.

1 plus or minus 4.9) times 10-4, with best-fit strong parameters found to be r hat pi = -0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The best-fit value of aCP (D+→ ϕπ+) was examined only after the analysis strategy was finalised, to avoid experimenter bias. In addition, this paper presents a frequentist template-based fit to the ∆As values, allowing for the direct determination of confidence intervals for the strong parameters rπ and δπ from the data.

095 and delta hat pi = -3 pi/4.

Alternative determinations of a CP(D+ to phi pi+) are also reported by fixing the strong parameters to either theoretical predictions or experimental constraints. p. 3

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, rπ and δπ are governed by strong-interaction dynamics. Experimental constraints on the combination of these parameters can be obtained by comparing the rates of D+ → K0 S/L π + decays [36], while model-dependent estimates were obtained within the factorisationassisted topological amplitudes (FAT) theoretical framework [30,37].

These alternative results yield values such as a CP(D+ to phi pi+; FAT-) = (-2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Their inclusion also increases the yield of D+→ K0 Sπ + decays by more than a factor of two. In addition to the CP asymmetry measurement, this article also reports the first determination at a hadron collider of the values of the strong parameters rπ and δπ of D+→ K0 Sπ + decays.

2 plus or minus 3.3) times 10-4 and a CP(D+ to phi pi+; R pi) = (0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The inclusion of these new effects in the model enables the usage of the full available data sample, including for the first time the D+→ K0 Sπ + decays where the K0 S mesons decay downstream of the vertex detector acceptance. These decays correspond to longer kaon decay times, where interference and regeneration effects are amplified and can be controlled more precisely.

4 plus or minus 5.0) times 10-4. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The inclusion of these new effects in the model enables the usage of the full available data sample, including for the first time the D+→ K0 Sπ + decays where the K0 S mesons decay downstream of the vertex detector acceptance. These decays correspond to longer kaon decay times, where interference and regeneration effects are amplified and can be controlled more precisely.

The total uncertainty associated with these alternative strategies ranges from 3. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Experimentally, the precision of the aCP (D+→ ϕπ+) measurement is limited by the accuracy in controlling detection and production asymmetries. These effects are largely cancelled by measuring the CP-violating asymmetry of interest relative to that of one or more abundant calibration modes with similar kinematic properties, for which the physics asymmetry is expected to be much smaller than the overall experimental uncertainty.

8 times 10-4 for the baseline result to up to 5. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The inclusion of these new effects in the model enables the usage of the full available data sample, including for the first time the D+→ K0 Sπ + decays where the K0 S mesons decay downstream of the vertex detector acceptance. These decays correspond to longer kaon decay times, where interference and regeneration effects are amplified and can be controlled more precisely.

7 times 10-4 when external constraints on r pi and delta pi are utilized. p. 3
Where the paper says it

On the other hand, rπ and δπ are governed by strong-interaction dynamics. Experimental constraints on the combination of these parameters can be obtained by comparing the rates of D+ → K0 S/L π + decays [36], while model-dependent estimates were obtained within the factorisationassisted topological amplitudes (FAT) theoretical framework [30,37].

The resulting confidence regions established in the (r pi, delta pi) plane are found to be compatible with predictions derived from topological amplitude approaches. In essence, the research provides a rigorous, data-driven determination of CP violation parameters in this decay channel while simultaneously testing and constraining theoretical models of neutral-kaon dynamics. p. 3

Where the paper says it

On the other hand, rπ and δπ are governed by strong-interaction dynamics. Experimental constraints on the combination of these parameters can be obtained by comparing the rates of D+ → K0 S/L π + decays [36], while model-dependent estimates were obtained within the factorisationassisted topological amplitudes (FAT) theoretical framework [30,37].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Correcting CP violation searches by incorporating interference between Cabibbo-favoured and doubly Cabibbo-suppressed D+ to K0Spi+ decay amplitudes allows AI systems to extract the direct CP asymmetry aCP (D+ -> ϕpi+) with enhanced precision. This capability enables the system to determine hadronic parameters rpi and delta pi directly from data, superseding reliance on external theoretical inputs.

  2. Developing a time-dependent model of neutral kaon detection asymmetry that includes interference between CF and DCS charm decay amplitudes allows AI systems to constrain rpi and delta pi directly from data without external approximations like rpi = 0. This enables the system to determine aCP (D+ -> ϕpi+) using the best-fit value qˆ = aCP (D+-> ϕpi+) = (0.1 ± 4.9) × 10−4, which is compatible with previous LHCb results and other measurements.

  3. Implementing a frequentist profile likelihood method to determine confidence intervals for rpi and delta pi allows AI systems to quantify the uncertainty on CP violation parameters based on data alone, rather than relying solely on external theoretical predictions or approximations like rpi = 0. This provides robust estimates for these hadronic parameters, such as the FAT prediction yielding rpi = -0.073 ± 0.004 and delta pi = -1.39 (+1.39) rad under certain constraints.

Abstract

A search for charge-parity (C!P) violation in the Cabibbo-suppressed D+ to ϕπ+ decay is presented, using proton-proton collision data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 6 fb-1, collected at a centre-of-mass energy of 13 TeV with the LHCb detector during Run 2. An abundant sample of D+ to K S 0 π+ decays is employed to correct for asymmetries arising from the production of the charmed meson and from detection effects associated with the charged pion accompanying the ϕ meson. Asymmetries induced by interference of multiple processes, such as neutral kaon mixing, regeneration of neutral kaons, and interference between the Cabibbo-favoured D+ to 0 π+ and the doubly Cabibbo-suppressed D+ to K 0 π+ decay, are subtracted. The direct C!P asymmetry in the D+ to ϕπ+ decay is measured to be a C!P(D+ to ϕπ+) = (0.1 plus or minus 4.9(stat) plus or minus 2.4(syst)) times 10-4. For the first time at a hadron collider, the modulus of the ratio and the relative strong phase of the D+ to K 0 π+ to D+ to 0 π+ decay amplitudes are also investigated. Two-dimensional confidence intervals are reported for these parameters.

Sources

Related papers