A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials

arXiv:2607.07086 · cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-07-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency <ref:2607.07086#pg2> The authors introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap <ref:2607.07086#pg14> Screening the Materials Project database with this metric reveals recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in the materials with the most promising refractive index/transparency trade-offs Hybrid density functional theory calculations reveal that the chalconitride (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family can achieve a combination of ultra-high refractive indices, low effective masses and transparency windows extending deep into the UV, surpassing state-of-the-art TiO2 and SiC Our results establish (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 compounds as a unique and largely unexplored material family for next-generation photonic applications.

Kai: Modified Figure of Merit The researchers define a modified Moss factor Medge as Medge = Eedge/Egen4/95 eV <ref:2607.07086#pg14> This single substitution of the fundamental gap Eg by the absorption edge Eedge shifts the figure of merit from a purely electronic quantity to one that reflects a material's actual onset of optical losses <ref:2607.07086#pg14>.

Mira: Materials with Medge = 1 behave as heuristically predicted by the Moss rule, while materials with Medge > 1 perform better than predicted and can be qualified as super-Mossian <ref:2607.07086#pg14>.

Kai: Material Screening and Compositional Trends The study queried the Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1.2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1.6 eV Thermodynamic stability was enforced by only considering materials that lie within 0.05 eV/atom of the convex stability hull Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a).

Paper summary: Kai: We’re diving deeper into how this paper, "A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials," sets out its main argument. It starts by saying the traditional empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between getting a high refractive index and keeping the material transparent >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg1,empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between>.

Mira: The authors then introduce this modified Moss rule, which is anchored to the optical absorption edge energy, E edge, instead of relying only on the fundamental bandgap E g >Page two> <ref:2607.07086#pg2>.

Lev: They explain that this shift captures materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above that electronic gap, such as symmetry and momentum selection rules >Page two> <ref:2607.07086#pg2,symmetry and momentum selection rules>.

Kai: By using this metric, they screen the Materials Project database to reveal recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in materials with the most promising refractive index and transparency trade-offs >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg1,recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in>.

Mira: They also identify specific material classes like chalcopyrites, Zintl pnictides, and early transition metal multi-anion chalconitrides or oxychalcogenides compounds as potential candidates >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg1,chalcopyrites, Zintl pnictides, and early transition metal multi-anion chalconitrides>.

Lev: The paper then moves into the results section where they show that hybrid density functional theory calculations reveal the (Hf,Zr)two(S,Se)N2 family can achieve ultra-high refractive indices along with low effective masses and transparency windows extending deep into the ultraviolet spectrum >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg2>.

Kai: So what this means is that by changing the reference point for screening from the bandgap to where absorption actually starts, they uncover materials like (Hf,Zr)two(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides that were previously overlooked >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg2>.

Mira: And when they look at the specific calculations for beta-Hf2SeN2, they find it stands out with a calculated Moss factor of one point nine seven and an HSE absorption edge in the ultraviolet >Page fourteen>.

Lev: The authors also found that this compound has the largest offset between its direct bandgap and its absorption threshold of all compounds considered, which is zero point eight seven electron volts >Page fourteen> <ref:2607.07086#pg3>.

Kai: So for someone who only listens to the show, this paper is about finding a better way to predict high-index transparent materials by looking at where they actually start absorbing light, not just their theoretical bandgap >Page two> <ref:2607.07086#pg2>.

Mira: It’s about moving beyond the standard screening funnel that misses materials whose absorption edge is pushed by complex physical effects like symmetry or poor wavefunction overlap >Page two> <ref:2607.07086#pg2,materials whose absorption edge is pushed>.

Lev: And the method itself, the simulation package using VASP with a plane wave energy cutoff of five hundred fifty electron volts, neglects other sources of absorption like indirect transitions and excitonic effects >Page three> <ref:2607.07086#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this discussion on "A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials," the authors argue that this new rule anchored to the optical absorption edge provides a physically meaningful figure of merit for finding high refractive index, low-loss materials >Page fourteen> <ref:2607.07086#pg3>.

Mira: And they establish that the (Hf,Zr)two(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides are a structurally coherent prototype that combines large refractive indices with wide transparency windows >Page nine>.

Lev: Essentially, this work sets up (Hf,Zr)two(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides as a compelling material family for next-generation photonic applications >Page fourteen>.

Kai: It’s about establishing this new family as a strong contender for designing optical components that need high refractive index and good transparency simultaneously >Page one> <ref:2607.07086#pg1>.

Mira: The main implication is that we should be focusing experimental synthesis efforts on controlling the polymorphism of these compounds through careful tuning of thin film growth conditions and thermal processing >Page fourteen> <ref:2607.07086#pg3>.

Lev: And they warrant experimental realization of such compounds as thin films and validating their dopability and optical properties >Page fourteen> <ref:2607.07086#pg3>.

National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab) · Technical University of Denmark

cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-07-08

Updated: 2026-11-06

DOI: 10.1021/acsphotonics.6c01721

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency…

Key concepts

Modified Moss Factor (Medge)
This metric replaces the standard bandgap with the material's actual optical absorption edge (Eedge). A Medge value greater than 1 indicates a material performs better than predicted by traditional rules, suggesting superior refractive index and transparency characteristics.
Absorption Edge (Eedge)
Instead of using the fundamental electronic bandgap (Eg), this concept uses the energy level where optical absorption starts to become significant. This is more physically relevant because various mechanisms can suppress absorption well above the electronic gap, leading to a more accurate measure of transparency.
(Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ Family
This specific family of chalconitrides was identified as a structural prototype for high-index materials. These compounds exhibit large refractive indices and wide transparency windows due to the combination of structural features and electronic properties, making them ideal candidates for photonic devices.

Terminology

Summary

High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency <ref:2607. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials Eugène Bertin* , Finja Tadge, Andrea Crovetto* National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab), Technical University of Denmark *corresponding authors Abstract High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency. We introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap.

07086#pg2> The authors introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap <ref:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials Eugène Bertin* , Finja Tadge, Andrea Crovetto* National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab), Technical University of Denmark *corresponding authors Abstract High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency. We introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap.

07086#pg14> Screening the Materials Project database with this metric reveals recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in the materials with the most promising refractive index/transparency trade-offs Hybrid density functional theory calculations reveal that the chalconitride (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family can achieve a combination of ultra-high refractive indices, low effective masses and transparency windows extending deep into the UV, surpassing state-of-the-art TiO2 and SiC Our results establish (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 compounds as a unique and largely unexplored material family for next-generation photonic applications. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Hybrid density functional theory calculations reveal that the chalconitride (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ family can achieve a combination of ultra-high refractive indices, low effective masses and transparency windows extending deep into the UV, surpassing stateof-the-art TiO₂ and SiC. Our results establish (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ compounds as a unique and largely unexplored material family for next-generation photonic applications.

Modified Figure of Merit

The researchers define a modified Moss factor Medge as Medge = Eedge/Egen4/95 eV <ref:2607.07086#pg14> This single substitution of the fundamental gap Eg by the absorption edge Eedge shifts the figure of merit from a purely electronic quantity to one that reflects a material's actual onset of optical losses <ref:2607.07086#pg14>. Materials with Medge = 1 behave as heuristically predicted by the Moss rule, while materials with Medge > 1 perform better than predicted and can be qualified as super-Mossian <ref:2607. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We define a modified Moss factor Medge as 𝑀𝑒𝑑𝑔𝑒 = 𝐸𝑒𝑑𝑔𝑒𝑛0 4 95 𝑒𝑉 ; this single substitution of the fundamental gap Eg by the absorption edge Eedge shifts the figure of merit from a purely electronic quantity to one that reflects a material's actual onset of optical losses. Materials with Medge = 1 behave as heuristically predicted by the Moss rule, while materials with Medge > 1 perform better than predicted and can be qualified as superMossian [1].

07086#pg14>.

Material Screening and Compositional Trends

The study queried the Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1.2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Methods We query Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1. 2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

2 Methods We query Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1. 2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1.

6 eV Thermodynamic stability was enforced by only considering materials that lie within 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Since the semi-local PBE functional [8] used throughout Materials Project systematically underestimates bandgaps, the true absorption edges of this set of high-n compounds are expected to fall close or above the visible/UV edge, with transparency potentially spanning the entire visible spectrum. Thermodynamic stability of the screened materials is enforced by only considering materials that lie within 0.

05 eV/atom of the convex stability hull Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a). p. 2
Where the paper says it

Interestingly, BeSiP2, Zr2SN2 and ZrOS were all screened as candidate transparent conductors; this establishes forbidden transitions as a shared design handle for transparent conductors and high-n optical materials. Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a); a few notable experimentally reported examples are ZnSiP2, AlCuTe2, Zr2SN2, Mg(BeAs)2, NaCuTe, Mg(BeP)2, Hf2SN2, CuBS2, ZrSO, Al2BiSe4 and HfSO.

Notable experimentally reported examples include ZnSiP2, AlCuTe2, Zr2SN2, Mg(BeAs)2, NaCuTe, Mg(BeP)2, Hf2SN2, CuBS2, ZrSO and Al2BiSe4 and HfSO. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Interestingly, BeSiP2, Zr2SN2 and ZrOS were all screened as candidate transparent conductors; this establishes forbidden transitions as a shared design handle for transparent conductors and high-n optical materials. Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a); a few notable experimentally reported examples are ZnSiP2, AlCuTe2, Zr2SN2, Mg(BeAs)2, NaCuTe, Mg(BeP)2, Hf2SN2, CuBS2, ZrSO, Al2BiSe4 and HfSO.

Structural Prototypes

The analysis reveals recurring structural prototypes that suggest promising material classes These prototypes include:

  1. (i) pnictide and chalcogenide chalcopyrites. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Screening the Materials Project database for high refractive index compounds uncovers several recurring elements, such as Be, Si, Mg, Zr, Cu, Al, Hf cations and P, S, N anions. There are also recurring structural prototypes, such as (i) pnictide and chalcogenide chalcopyrites, (ii) Zintl pnictides, and (iii) multi-anion chalconitrides and oxichalcogenides of early transition metals.

  2. (ii) Zintl pnictides. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    Screening the Materials Project database with this metric reveals recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in the materials with the most promising refractive index/transparency trade-offs. These materials include chalcopyrites, Zintl pnictides, and early transition metal multi-anion chalconitrides and oxychalcogenides compounds.

  3. (iii) multi-anion chalconitrides and oxichalcogenides of early transition metals. p. 7

    Where the paper says it

    Screening the Materials Project database for high refractive index compounds uncovers several recurring elements, such as Be, Si, Mg, Zr, Cu, Al, Hf cations and P, S, N anions. There are also recurring structural prototypes, such as (i) pnictide and chalcogenide chalcopyrites, (ii) Zintl pnictides, and (iii) multi-anion chalconitrides and oxichalcogenides of early transition metals.

The class of (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides stands out as a structural prototype promoting high refractive indices and transparency The family crystallizes in the α or the β phase, two hexagonal structures that only differ in the stacking sequence along the c axis of the Zr2N2 layers, bonded by S interlayers. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Compounds of the (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family may crystallize in the α or the β phase, two hexagonal structures that only differ in the stacking sequence along the c axis of the Zr2N2 layers, bonded by S interlayers [25]. We derive more accurate values of the absorption edge Eedge, the sub-bandgap refractive index n0, and Medge for all the α and β polymorphs of the (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family using hybrid DFT (Figure 2, Table S1).

Performance of Specific Compounds

Detailed hybrid DFT analysis shows that β-Hf2SeN2 stands out as an experimentally unreported but chemically plausible compound with a large calculated Moss factor of 1.97 and an HSE absorption edge in the UV This compound is the choice when a wider transparency window is needed (HSE Eedge > 3. p. 6

Where the paper says it

97 and an HSE absorption edge in the UV, improving on β-Zr2SN2. Additionally, we find that βHf2SN2, with its larger Eedge with minimal compromise on n0, is the compound of choice when a wider transparency window is needed (HSE Eedge > 3.

7 eV) because it exhibits the largest offset ΔEedge between direct bandgap and absorption threshold of all compounds considered, reaching 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Additionally, we find that βHf2SN2, with its larger Eedge with minimal compromise on n0, is the compound of choice when a wider transparency window is needed (HSE Eedge > 3. Notably, β-Hf2SN2 exhibits the largest offset ΔEedge between direct bandgap and absorption threshold of all compounds considered, reaching 0.

87 eV.

Anisotropy and Future Directions

The c-axis direction systematically displays transparency in the (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family with an absorption onset at higher energy for light polarized along c compared to the symmetry-equivalent a and b axis. This anisotropy translates into an exceptionally high Moss factor along the c direction, up to 2. p. 6

Where the paper says it

10 at photon energies below 2 eV, because of a larger anisotropy in the β-phase as compared to α-phase. This anisotropy translates into an exceptionally high Moss factor along the c direction, up to 2.

35 for β-Hf2SeN2. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a); a few notable experimentally reported examples are ZnSiP2, AlCuTe2, Zr2SN2, Mg(BeAs)2, NaCuTe, Mg(BeP)2, Hf2SN2, CuBS2, ZrSO, Al2BiSe4 and HfSO. Several experimentally unrealized materials such as BeSiAs2, Hf2SeN2, BeSiP2 also stand out.

Precise control of the α/β polymorphism is important to maximize the potential of these materials. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We showed that very large refractive indices can be achieved in compounds from the (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family. Precise control of the α/β polymorphism is important to maximize the potential of these materials.

The effective masses m∗ for both holes and electrons in (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 compounds are low (0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

For future photonic devices, control of the films’ orientation would allow to align the light’s polarization axis with the crystal axis with the most favourable Medge. All the effective masses m* for both holes and electrons in (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 compounds are low (0.

39 < m∗ < 0.46), yielding exciting prospects for this family of compounds as high refractive index transparent conductors. p. 6
Where the paper says it

46, Table S1), due to the similar band structures. Combining this with previous predictions of ambipolar conductivity [18] and our observation of degenerate conductivity in Zr2SN2 [4] yields exciting prospects for this family of compounds as high refractive index transparent conductors.

The authors warrant experimental realization of such compounds as thin films and validation of their dopability and optical properties. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Combining this with previous predictions of ambipolar conductivity [18] and our observation of degenerate conductivity in Zr2SN2 [4] yields exciting prospects for this family of compounds as high refractive index transparent conductors. This warrants experimental realisation of such compounds as thin films and validation of their dopability and optical properties.

Conclusion

In summary, the modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge provides a physically meaningful figure of merit for identifying high refractive index, low-loss materials. The (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family emerges as a structurally coherent prototype combining large refractive indices with wide transparency windows. p. 7

Where the paper says it

These findings reinforce the motivation to move beyond oxides and single-anion materials in general. Within this landscape, the (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ family emerges as a structurally coherent prototype, combining large refractive indices with wide transparency windows.

Detailed hybrid DFT analysis of the full α/β polymorph space reveals that β-Hf2SeN2 achieves a sub-bandgap refractive index of 2. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Within this landscape, the (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ family emerges as a structurally coherent prototype, combining large refractive indices with wide transparency windows. Detailed hybrid DFT analysis of the full α/β polymorph space reveals that β-Hf₂SeN₂ achieves a sub-bandgap refractive index of 2.

74 and an absorption edge in the UV. p. 0
Where the paper says it

1 A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials Eugène Bertin* , Finja Tadge, Andrea Crovetto* National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab), Technical University of Denmark *corresponding authors Abstract High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency. We introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap.

These findings establish (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides as a compelling material family for next-generation photonic applications. p. 7
Where the paper says it

β-Hf₂SN₂ offers the broadest transparency window across the family. These findings establish (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ chalconitrides as a compelling material family for next-generation photonic applications and motivate experimental thin film synthesis efforts aimed at controlling polymorphism and crystal orientation through careful tuning of thin film growth conditions and thermal processing.

The authors motivate experimental thin film synthesis efforts aimed at controlling polymorphism and crystal orientation through careful tuning of thin film growth conditions and thermal processing. p. 7
Where the paper says it

β-Hf₂SN₂ offers the broadest transparency window across the family. These findings establish (Hf,Zr)₂(S,Se)N₂ chalconitrides as a compelling material family for next-generation photonic applications and motivate experimental thin film synthesis efforts aimed at controlling polymorphism and crystal orientation through careful tuning of thin film growth conditions and thermal processing.

Acknowledgements

The authors are grateful to Søren Raza for insightful discussions. This work was funded by the European Union (ERC, IDOL, 101040153) and supported by a research grant (42140) from VILLUM FONDEN. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them. This work was also supported by a research grant (42140) from VILLUM FONDEN.

References

The paper cites numerous foundational and recent works related to high-throughput screening, density functional theory, and specific material classes like chalcopyrites and Zintl phases The references span computational methods like hybrid functionals [11] and experimental demonstrations of similar high-index materials [4]. Foundational works on bandgap screening [3] and high-throughput screening using the Materials Project [9, 2607. p. 7

Where the paper says it

8 4 Conclusions In summary, we introduced a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than to the fundamental bandgap, providing a physically meaningful figure of merit for identifying high refractive index, low-loss materials. Screening the Materials Project database for high refractive index compounds uncovers several recurring elements, such as Be, Si, Mg, Zr, Cu, Al, Hf cations and P, S, N anions.

0708615> are also cited to support the methodology The work builds upon previous observations regarding forbidden transitions in materials like Zr2SN2 [4]. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The β phase always has a lower zero-temperature formation energy, but the difference in formation enthalpy ΔHf,β - ΔHf,α between α and β is minimal (< 18 meV/atom in absolute value, Table S1), hinting that there is no strong thermodynamic drive towards one of the other. This is consistent with previous observations in thin film Zr2SN2 [4], where we evidenced a composite structure composed of epitaxial α and β layers.

Foundational DFT methods are referenced, including those by Perdew et al. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Materials with Medge = 1 behave as heuristically predicted by the Moss rule, while materials with Medge > 1 perform better than predicted and can be qualified as superMossian [1]. 2 Methods We query Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1.

[8] and Kresse et al. [13–17] for simulations The study also references literature concerning specific material families such as chalcopyrite phosphides [21, 2607. p. 4
Where the paper says it

This fits previous observations of exceptional refractive index and exotic optical properties [21] in other chalcopyrite phosphides such as ZnGeP2 [22,23]. The Mg(BeAs)2 group (AB2C2 | P-3m1) hosts alkaline earth Zintl pnictides [24] (Ca(MgAs)2, Mg(BeAs)2 and Mg(BeP)2), hinting at the superMossian potential of this class material, in accordance to ref.

0708615> and Zintl pnictides [24]] to contextualize the findings. p. 7
Where the paper says it

There are also recurring structural prototypes, such as (i) pnictide and chalcogenide chalcopyrites, (ii) Zintl pnictides, and (iii) multi-anion chalconitrides and oxichalcogenides of early transition metals. These findings reinforce the motivation to move beyond oxides and single-anion materials in general.

The methodology for screening high-n materials is supported by studies on dielectric constant and refractive index benchmarking [6, 2607. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Persson, F. Prinz, Benchmarking density functional perturbation theory to enable high-throughput screening of materials for dielectric constant and refractive index, Phys.

0708615> and works searching for materials with high refractive index and wide band gap [20]]. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Hautier, L. Rignanese, Searching for materials with high refractive index and wide band gap: A first-principles high-throughput study, Phys.

The paper also references literature discussing the importance of polymorphism in Zr2SN2 [4] to justify the investigation into the α/β phases of (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2. p. 4
Where the paper says it

For this reason, we further investigate the optical properties of these compounds. In a recent study [4], we discussed the importance of polymorphism in Zr2SN2.

The references provide the necessary context for establishing forbidden transitions as a shared design handle for transparent conductors and high-n optical materials The citation of specific experimental results, such as those on BeSiP2 [18], validates the screening method The paper also references literature on structural prototypes like chalcopyrites [21] and Zintl pnictides [24] to support the material classification. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Materials already demonstrated or screened as high-n transparent materials appear, such as Zr2SN2 [4,18] validating the method. Interestingly, BeSiP2, Zr2SN2 and ZrOS were all screened as candidate transparent conductors; this establishes forbidden transitions as a shared design handle for transparent conductors and high-n optical materials.

The reference list is extensive, covering computational materials science, optical properties, and specific material systems

--- Page 1 ---

<ref:2607.07086#pg14> A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials Eugène Bertin, Finja Tadge, Andrea Crovetto National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab), Technical University of Denmark corresponding authors. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 A modified Moss rule highlights underexplored classes of high refractive index materials Eugène Bertin* , Finja Tadge, Andrea Crovetto* National Centre for Nano Fabrication and Characterization (DTU Nanolab), Technical University of Denmark *corresponding authors Abstract High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency. We introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap.

--- Page 2 ---

Woods-Robinson et al. showed that screening for optical transparency based on the fundamental gap alone systematically overlooks materials whose absorption edge is pushed to much higher photon energies by various physical mechanisms This framework motivated our recent experimental demonstration of Zr2SN2 as thin films with a wide transparency range and large refractive index [4]

--- Page 3 ---

In this work, we build on the significant role of forbidden transitions and propose a modified Moss rule anchored not to the fundamental gap Eg but to the absorption edge Eedge i.e. the energy at which absorption becomes non-negligible We query the Materials Project [5] for the two key quantities required for assessing high refractive index materials’ performance

--- Page 4 ---

We query Materials Project for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1.2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1.6 eV Since the semi-local PBE functional [8] used throughout Materials Project systematically underestimates bandgaps, the true absorption edges of this set of high-n compounds are expected to fall close or above the visible/UV edge, with transparency potentially spanning the entire visible spectrum

--- Page 5 ---

Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a) Several experimentally unrealized materials such as BeSiAs2 and Hf2SeN2 also stand out Importantly, many of these compounds have forbidden transitions at the lowest direct bandgap (diamond-shaped markers on Figure 1a – as calculated by Woods-Robinson et al. [18]) contributing to their high Medge

--- Page 6 ---

Compositionally diverse compounds stand out as potential super-Mossian materials (Figure 1a) We extract the most common elements in the dataset (Figure 1b) In particular Zr and Hf early transition metals in the d0 electronic configuration seem particularly promising, due to the conjunction of high Eedge and Medge, in accordance with Naccarato’s et al. [20] chemical design

--- Page 7 ---

Beyond uncovering individual candidate compounds, this dataset reveals interesting links between elemental composition, transparency and high refractive index, as theorized by Naccarato et al. [2] and Arai et al [19] A significant fraction of super-Mossian compounds like Hf2SN2 belong to multi-anion chemistries The above arguments hint at the importance of moving beyond single-anion oxide chemistry for the discovery of exceptional super-Mossian materials

--- Page 8 ---

The β phase is consistently more transparent than the α-phase (Figure 2) This increase in transparency can be explained by a combination of slightly wider bandgaps, weaker transition dipole moments and stricter symmetry selection rules in β in comparison to α [4]

--- Page 9 ---

The class of (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides stands out as a structural prototype promoting high refractive indices and transparency

--- Page 12 ---

The β phase is consistently more transparent than the α-phase (Figure 2) This increase in transparency can be explained by a combination of slightly wider bandgaps, weaker transition dipole moments and stricter symmetry selection rules in β in comparison to α [4]

--- Page 12 ---

The substitution of Zr by Hf and Se by S lead to a widening of both the indirect and direct gaps (Table S1)

--- Page 12 ---

All the α and β polymorphs of this family generally have a large Moss factor The β phase is consistently more transparent than the α-phase (Figure 2)

--- Page 13 ---

In such structures, the different mechanisms causing low transition dipole moments (incompatible band symmetry, momentum change, poor wavefunction overlap) are present simultaneously Therefore, the class of (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 chalconitrides stands out as a structural prototype promoting high refractive indices and transparency

--- Page 14 ---

The β-Hf2SeN2 stands out as an experimentally unreported but chemically plausible compound with a large calculated Moss factor of 1.97 and an HSE absorption edge in the UV, improving on β-Zr2SN2 Additionally, we find that βHf2SN2, with its larger Eedge with minimal compromise on n0, is the compound of choice when a wider transparency window is needed (HSE Eedge > 3. p. 6

Where the paper says it

97 and an HSE absorption edge in the UV, improving on β-Zr2SN2. Additionally, we find that βHf2SN2, with its larger Eedge with minimal compromise on n0, is the compound of choice when a wider transparency window is needed (HSE Eedge > 3.

7 eV)

--- Page 14 ---

Notably, β-Hf2SeN2 exhibits the largest offset ΔEedge between direct bandgap and absorption threshold of all compounds considered, reaching 0.87 eV This anisotropy translates into an exceptionally high Moss factor along the c direction, up to 2. p. 6

Where the paper says it

10 at photon energies below 2 eV, because of a larger anisotropy in the β-phase as compared to α-phase. This anisotropy translates into an exceptionally high Moss factor along the c direction, up to 2.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Incorporate a modified Moss rule anchored to optical absorption edge energy instead of fundamental bandgap energy into materials screening algorithms to better capture materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap. This allows systems to identify super-Mossian materials with a figure of merit defined by Medge = Eedge / 95 eV.

  2. Enhance Materials Project database screening by querying for materials combining a modified Moss factor above 1.2 with a PBE absorption edge above 1.6 eV, which are expected to have transparency potentially spanning the entire visible spectrum. This refines the search for high-n low loss candidates beyond traditional bandgap constraints.

  3. Integrate hybrid density functional theory calculations using the HSE06 functional with specific exchange and screening parameters to obtain accurate refractive index and absorption coefficient spectra for promising candidates like the (Zr,Hf)2(S,Se)N2 family. This provides more reliable predictions of ultra-high refractive indices and transparency windows.

  4. Develop a structural prototype grouping mechanism based on chemical formula template and space group to identify recurring structures such as (i) pnictide and chalcogenide chalcopyrites, (ii) Zintl pnictides, and (iii) multi-anion chalconitrides. This allows the system to recognize structurally coherent prototype families that promote high refractive indices.

  5. Implement an analysis step that correlates elemental composition with optical properties, specifically identifying that Zr and Hf early transition metals in the d0 electronic configuration seem particularly promising, due to the conjunction of high Eedge and Medge. This guides chemical design by suggesting specific element combinations for superior performance.

  6. Introduce a polymorphism analysis routine that compares calculated HSE06-level optical properties for different crystal phases (alpha and beta) of compounds like (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2. The system should be able to predict which phase offers the best trade-off, noting that The beta phase is consistently more transparent than the alpha-phase (Figure 2), which generally leads to higher Moss factors for the beta compounds.

  7. Train a predictive model on calculated directional properties, specifically using data from Table S1, to predict which crystal axis will yield the most favorable performance. This system can determine that the c-axis direction systematically displays transparency, with an absorption onset at higher energy for light polarized along c, guiding future experimental orientation strategies.

Abstract

High refractive index dielectrics are central to photonic applications, yet the empirical Moss rule imposes a fundamental trade-off between refractive index and optical transparency. We introduce a modified Moss rule anchored to the optical absorption edge rather than the fundamental bandgap, capturing materials where various physical mechanisms suppress absorption well above the electronic gap. Screening the Materials Project database with this metric reveals recurring chemical compositions and structural prototypes in the materials with the most promising refractive index/transparency trade-offs. These materials include chalcopyrites, Zintl pnictides, and early transition metal multi-anion chalconitrides and oxichalcogenide compounds. Hybrid density functional theory calculations reveal that the chalconitride (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 family can achieve a combination of ultra-high refractive indices, low effective masses and transparency windows extending into the UV, potentially surpassing state-of-the-art TiO2. Our results establish (Hf,Zr)2(S,Se)N2 compounds as a unique and largely unexplored material family for next-generation photonic applications.

Sources

Related papers