First measurement of the masses of the upsilon 1(1D) and upsilon 3(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to upsilon J(1D) eta and e+e-to upsilon J(1D) pi+ pi-

arXiv:2607.04369 · hep-ex, hep-ph · Submitted 2026-07-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "First measurement of the masses of the 1(1D) and 3(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi-".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. First measurement of the masses of the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi- is reported using Belle data collected at center-of-mass energies between 10.73 and 11.02 GeV Experimental Setup and Data Utilization The study utilizes a 142.5 fb−1 data sample, including a 122 fb−1 near the Υ(10860) peak at √s = 10.866 GeV, collected with the Belle detector at the KEKB asymmetric-energy e+e- collider The analysis examines processes such as e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η and e+e− → ΥJ(1D)π+π− across 19 energy points in the range of 10.73 GeV to 11.02 GeV The reconstruction involves separating the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D) states through exclusive reconstruction, applying a kinematic constraint, and performing a three-dimensional (3D) fit Mass Measurements and Splittings The mass for the Υ2(1D) state was measured to be (10167.0±1.0±0.2) MeV/c2 The mass splittings determined are ∆m12 = m(Υ2(1D)) − m(Υ1(1D)) and ∆m23 = m(Υ3(1D)) − m(Υ2(1D)), which are (11.8 ± 1.5 ± 0.4) MeV/c2 and (7.6 ± 2.4 ± 0.6) MeV/c2 respectively The statistical significances for the signals are reported as 5.1σ for Υ1(1D), >10σ for Υ2(1D), and 3.1σ for Υ3(1D) when including systematic uncertainties Cross Section Measurements and Evidence The authors report first evidence for the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states in the η channel, as well as measurements of the ΥJ(1D) masses For the energy point at √s = 10.866 GeV, they determine the product of the Born cross section for e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η (e+e− → ΥJ(1D)π+π−) and the branching fraction of ΥJ(1D) → χb1,b2γ The results for the cross sections are presented in Table IV and Table V Theoretical Context and Systematic Uncertainties Bottomonium serves as an exemplary probe for elucidating the properties of non-perturbative quantum chromodynamics The mass splittings are compared with predictions from various theoretical models, such as the relativized quark model and screened potential model Systematic uncertainties include contributions from photon energy calibration and fit model, with the uncertainty due to the fit interval being dominant Multiplicative systematic uncertainties are also considered, including those from detection efficiency and branching fractions of intermediate states The dressed cross sections as a function of c.m.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now, "First measurement of the masses of the one(1D) and three(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi-" <ref:2607.04369#pg1,1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e>. It’s a study from Belle data collected between ten point seven three and eleven point zero two GeV, looking at some specific particles called the ΥJ (1D) states, which are like excited bottomonium systems <ref:2607.04369#pg2>.

Mira: Yeah, it's about measuring the masses of these three states—the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D)—and how the production cross sections for them change as you scan across that energy range <ref:2607.04369#pg2,the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D>. It’s a pretty detailed look at some exotic bottomonium physics.

Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, I'm interested in how they reconstruct these states, because getting a good mass measurement is the first hurdle before you even think about running real hardware to test anything on it >

Kai: Exactly. They use this method where they separate the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D) states through exclusive reconstruction, then they apply a kinematic constraint and perform a three-dimensional fit to get those masses <ref:2607.04369#pg2,the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D>. It sounds like a complex procedure for getting the actual mass determination right >

Mira: And what they found on the masses is pretty significant, especially for that middle state, the Υ2(1D), which they measured at ten thousand one hundred sixty-seven point zero±one point zero±zero point two MeV/c2. They also got these mass splittings: delta m one two and delta m two three are about eleven point eight plus or minus one point five plus or minus zero point four MeV/c2 and seven point six plus or minus two point four plus or minus zero point six MeV/c2 respectively >

Lev: Those splittings give us some constraints on the potential models, which is what we need to connect this experimental mass data to the underlying theory of QCD >

Kai: And the statistical significance they report for these states is interesting too. They say five point one sigma for Υ1(1D), greater than ten sigma for Υ2(1D), and three point one sigma for Υ3(1D) when you include systematic uncertainties > <ref:2607.04369#pg2>

Title and authors: Mira: That ten sigma on the second state is pretty strong, which points toward a real signal, but the three point one sigma on the third state means they’re still in a more exploratory phase for that particular particle >

Lev: And I'm thinking about what that means for running simulations. If we want to build error correction codes for these states, we need to know how much noise is involved, so these mass uncertainties are crucial inputs >

Kai: Well, moving on from the masses, they also report first evidence for the Υ1(1D) and the Υ3(1D) states in the eta channel <ref:2607.04369#pg1>. They measured some cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi- across those nineteen energy points from ten point seven three GeV to eleven point zero two GeV >

Mira: And what they did with the cross sections was determining the product of the Born cross section for e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η or e+e− → ΥJ(1D)π+π− and the branching fraction of ΥJ(1D) → χb1,b2γ > <ref:2607.04369#pg1,for e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η>

Lev: That actually links the production mechanism to how those excited states decay, which is important because it tells us about the transition rates >

Kai: They present these results in Table IV and Table V. It shows how the cross sections behave across that energy range, which lets us see if it matches what theoretical models predict for these transitions >

Mira: And then they compare those mass splittings they found with predictions from various theoretical models, like the relativized quark model and screened potential model >

Lev: That comparison is vital. We can only tell if a theory is good or bad by how well it matches the data we actually get from experiments like this one >

Kai: For systematic uncertainties, they include things like photon energy calibration and the fit model, with that uncertainty from the fit interval being the biggest part of it >

Mira: They also consider multiplicative systematic uncertainties, which come from things like detection efficiency and branching fractions of those intermediate states >

Title and authors: Lev: And I want to talk about what they *don't* do. They mention that their method for analyzing data outside the main peak relies on event counting methods for Nobs equal to zero or fitting with functions like f(x) equals two times p2x plus p3 minus p1 plus p1 ln p1 over (p2x plus p3) P4(x) to parameterize the dependence >

Kai: So they are trying to cover the whole range, from just before the peak up through ten point seven three GeV and beyond, even where there's no signal > <ref:2607.04369#pg2>

Mira: They also mentioned using event counting methods for Nobs equal to zero or fitting with functions like that to parameterize the dependence outside the main peak >

Lev: That means they aren't just looking at the peak data; they are trying to characterize the background behavior too, which is necessary for a complete picture >

Kai: So, as we wrap up on this paper, what’s really important is that they’ve provided first measurements of these specific states and have mapped out their energy dependence >

Mira: They're showing us how the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi- behave as you move through that ten point seven three to eleven point zero two GeV range > <ref:2607.04369#pg2>

Lev: For me, the biggest implication is that these experimental mass measurements provide concrete benchmarks against which we can test the predictions of our error correction codes for bottomonium systems >

Kai: So, in summary, this paper provides first measurement of the masses of the one(1D) and three(1D) states and maps out their energy dependence in the eta and pi plus pi minus channels > <ref:2607.04369#pg1,first measurement of the masses of the>

Mira: It’s a solid step forward because it gives us concrete numbers for these excited states and sets up comparisons with our theoretical models >

Lev: And for the real hardware side, having these mass measurements is the first necessary step before we can calculate how much error correction overhead those specific mass uncertainties actually introduce >

Kai: So that’s what this paper does. They give us data points to check our physics against, and they lay out a framework for how we can test those models in the future >

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap this paper, they’ve measured the masses of three new bottomonium states—the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D)—and they’ve also charted how the production cross sections for the eta and pi plus pi minus channels change between ten point seven three GeV and eleven point zero two GeV in that energy window <ref:2607.04369#pg2,the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D>.

Mira: Yeah, what I find interesting is how they are using this data to test some specific theoretical models, like the relativized quark model and screened potential model, by comparing their mass splittings to those predictions.

Lev: From my side as someone building error correction hardware, the three-dimensional fit they use for mass reconstruction is a crucial piece because it tells us exactly what kind of noise we're dealing with when we try to measure these excited states in a real system.

Kai: And they report some specific values for those splittings, like delta m one two and delta m two three, which are around eleven point eight MeV/c2 and seven point six MeV/c2 respectively, though the third state only gets a three point one sigma significance.

Mira: That ten sigma significance on the second state is what really stands out, suggesting that the signal for that particular state is pretty solid based on their analysis, even if the third one is still more exploratory.

Lev: If you want to actually build an error correction scheme for these bottomonium systems, those mass uncertainties are definitely a primary input because they set the scale for how much energy and precision you need in your setup.

Kai: And beyond just the masses, they’re reporting first evidence for the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states in the eta channel, which is a significant step in confirming these structures exist <ref:2607.04369#pg1,the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states>.

Mira: They’re also looking at how those production cross sections scale with energy across that entire range, which helps us map out the dynamics of how these particles are created.

Lev: Understanding that energy dependence is vital because it tells us about the underlying forces and potentials governing these interactions, which is what we need to input into any simulation for real hardware testing.

Kai: So essentially, this work gives us concrete experimental numbers for masses and cross sections in a critical energy region, helping to constrain how we should think about bottomonium physics.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So we're moving on to how they suggest making this analysis better, and what those suggested changes mean for the science here.

Kai: They point out that for measuring those excited states, using a three-dimensional fit on the recoil mass spectra is a way to get a much more precise mass determination than just looking at the peak position alone.

Mira: That makes sense because when you're dealing with complex systems like these bottomonium states, you need to account for all the kinematic constraints to separate them cleanly from background noise.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that’s good because it reduces the ambiguity in our mass reconstruction, which directly impacts the fidelity we can expect if we were trying to replicate this measurement on real detectors.

Kai: And they also suggest fitting those dressed cross sections as a function of center-of-mass energy using functions like that P4(x) to better map out how the production cross sections behave across the whole range from ten point seven three GeV to eleven point zero two GeV.

Mira: That fits with what we need because it lets us see the energy dependence more clearly, which is crucial for testing our models against different theoretical predictions.

Lev: Mapping that dependence is key, because if we can accurately model the cross section as a function of energy, we can use those results to check the assumptions in our error correction simulations.

Kai: They also talk about calculating the product of the Born cross section and the branching fraction for decay into chi b one or two gamma using specific equations involving intermediate states like eta or pi plus pi minus.

Mira: That calculation is important because it connects what we measure directly to how those particles actually decay, which gives us more information about the internal structure of these J(1D) states <ref:2607.04369#pg1>.

Lev: It’s a good link, but remember that for real hardware, you need to know the branching fractions accurately too, so you can factor in those multiplicative uncertainties they mentioned earlier.

Kai: They also show how they are calculating upper limits on those cross sections using the Poissonian limit estimator program called POLE when looking at both Belle and Belle II data.

Mira: Calculating upper limits is important for setting bounds when a signal isn't strong enough to claim a discovery yet, which is what we have here for some of these states.

Lev: And when you do those upper limit calculations, you need to be careful with the background subtraction methods used in POLE because those assumptions directly influence the final bound you get.

Kai: Finally, they mention accounting for systematic uncertainties by varying things like the ratio of yields between eta and pi plus pi minus channels to see how sensitive their results are to those assumptions.

Mira: That shows they’re being careful about the model dependencies, which is always necessary when you're trying to extract new physics from experimental data.

Lev: It means we need robust simulations that can handle those kinds of parameter variations, because if the result shifts significantly when you change a ratio by just a little bit, it tells us our theoretical assumptions are shaky.

Kai: So these suggestions show they’re trying to be very transparent about where their analysis is strong and where it’s most sensitive to modeling choices.

Conclusion: Tom: We're wrapping up this look at "First measurement of the masses of the one(1D) and three(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi-" <ref:2607.04369#pg1,1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e>.

Kai: So, basically, this paper gave us solid first measurements for those new bottomonium states—the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D)—and it mapped out how the cross sections change as we scan through that ten point seven three GeV to eleven point zero two GeV energy range <ref:2607.04369#pg2,the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D>.

Mira: It’s a solid data set because it lets us actually compare those measured mass splittings against what various theoretical models, like the relativized quark model, are predicting.

Lev: And for us on the hardware side, getting these concrete experimental numbers for the masses is exactly what we need to build better error correction codes; it gives us a real target to test our fidelity against.

Kai: The implication is that we now have a benchmark for these states, and they’ve set up a clear path for how we should be looking at them in future experiments.

Mira: They’re also showing that the energy dependence of those cross sections helps us understand the dynamics of how these excited bottomonium particles are being produced in this region.

Lev: If we can model that energy dependence accurately, it means our error correction overhead calculations for those systems will be much more reliable when we try to run them on actual cryogenic hardware.

Kai: Overall, this paper gives us the first solid experimental anchors for these specific J(1D) states and shows us how they behave across a range of energies <ref:2607.04369#pg1>.

Mira: It’s a very useful piece of work because it takes those theoretical predictions and grounds them in real, high-precision measurements from Belle data.

Lev: So, the next thing we have to worry about is taking these experimental results and figuring out exactly how much noise they introduce when we try to implement the error correction protocols for these specific mass uncertainties.

Belle and Belle II Collaborations

hep-ex, hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-07-05

Updated: 2026-10-29

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures; accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters

Code: https://github.com/JIASenBelle2/Y_J-1D-

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: First measurement of the masses of the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi- is reported using Belle data collected…

Key concepts

ΥJ(1D) States
These are specific excited states of bottomonium (Υ) mesons, denoted as Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D). The study focuses on measuring their masses and how they are produced in various decay channels like eta or pi+pi-.
Mass Splittings
These refer to the differences in mass between the different excited states, such as the distance between Υ1(1D) and Υ2(1D) ($Δm12$) and between Υ2(1D) and Υ3(1D) ($Δm23$). These splittings are compared against theoretical predictions to test models of strong interactions.
Cross Sections
Cross sections describe the probability that a specific interaction, like electron-positron annihilation into a particular state (e.g., e+e- to ΥJ(1D)eta), will occur at a given energy. The paper measures these cross sections across an energy range to understand the dynamics of this production process.
Bottomonium
Bottomonium refers to bound states of a bottom antiquark (b) and a bottom quark ($ar{b}b$). It is used as an important system in physics because its properties help researchers study the complex, non-perturbative nature of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the theory describing the strong nuclear force.

Terminology

Summary

First measurement of the masses of the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states and the energy dependence of the cross sections for e+e-to J(1D) eta and e+e-to J(1D) pi+ pi- is reported using Belle data collected at center-of-mass energies between 10. p. 073 and 11.02 GeV

Experimental Setup and Data Utilization

The study utilizes a 142.5 fb−1 data sample, including a 122 fb−1 near the Υ(10860) peak at √s = 10. p. 1866 GeV, collected with the Belle detector at the KEKB asymmetric-energy e+e- collider The analysis examines processes such as e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η and e+e− → ΥJ(1D)π+π− across 19 energy points in the range of 10. p. 173 GeV to 11. p. 102 GeV The reconstruction involves separating the Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D) states through exclusive reconstruction, applying a kinematic constraint, and performing a three-dimensional (3D) fit

Mass Measurements and Splittings

The mass for the Υ2(1D) state was measured to be (10167.0±1.0±0.2) MeV/c2 The mass splittings determined are ∆m12 = m(Υ2(1D)) − m(Υ1(1D)) and ∆m23 = m(Υ3(1D)) − m(Υ2(1D)), which are (11. p. 18 ± 1.5 ± 0.4) MeV/c2 and (7. p. 16 ± 2.4 ± 0.6) MeV/c2 respectively The statistical significances for the signals are reported as 5. p. 21σ for Υ1(1D), >10σ for Υ2(1D), and 3. p. 21σ for Υ3(1D) when including systematic uncertainties

Cross Section Measurements and Evidence

The authors report first evidence for the Υ1(1D) and Υ3(1D) states in the η channel, as well as measurements of the ΥJ(1D) masses For the energy point at √s = 10.866 GeV, they determine the product of the Born cross section for e+e− → ΥJ(1D)η (e+e− → ΥJ(1D)π+π−) and the branching fraction of ΥJ(1D) → χb1,b2γ The results for the cross sections are presented in Table IV and Table V

Theoretical Context and Systematic Uncertainties

Bottomonium serves as an exemplary probe for elucidating the properties of non-perturbative quantum chromodynamics The mass splittings are compared with predictions from various theoretical models, such as the relativized quark model and screened potential model Systematic uncertainties include contributions from photon energy calibration and fit model, with the uncertainty due to the fit interval being dominant Multiplicative systematic uncertainties are also considered, including those from detection efficiency and branching fractions of intermediate states The dressed cross sections as a function of c.m.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform precise mass reconstruction of ΥJ (1D) states by utilizing a three-dimensional fit to recoil mass spectra, as described in we separate Υ1(1D), Υ2(1D), and Υ3(1D) states through exclusive reconstruction, applying a kinematic constraint, and performing a three-dimensional (3D) fit.

  2. Improved AI can determine the energy dependence of cross sections for e+e− → ΥJ (1D)η and e+e− → ΥJ (1D)π+π− across a range of center-of-mass energies from 10.73 to 11.02 GeV by fitting to the dressed cross sections shown in Figure 2.

  3. Improved AI can calculate the product of Born cross section for e+e− → ΥJ (1D)η and the branching fraction for ΥJ (1D) → χb1,b2γ, using Eq. (1), where B int i = B(η → γγ) B(Υ(1S) → l +l−) or B(η → π+π−π0) B(Υ(1S) → l +l−).

  4. Improved AI can calculate the Born cross section for e+e− → ΥJ (1D)π+π− using a similar equation to determine sigma (2) Born, incorporating the vacuum polarization factor 1 − Π2 = 0.93 at each energy point.

  5. Improved AI can perform upper limit calculations on the Born cross sections for e+e− → ΥJ (1D)η and e+e− → ΥJ (1D)π+π− at Belle and Belle II using the Poissonian limit estimator (POLE) program, as described in The upper limits are calculated directly using POLE, with the same configuration as in Ref. [25].

  6. Improved AI can account for systematic uncertainties by varying parameters such as the ratio Nsig(η → γγ)/Nsig(η → π+π−π0) from 4.2 to 4.1 and 4.3, taking the difference in the yield as a systematic uncertainty, and conservatively considering the largest deviation of fit results compared to the nominal result as the additive systematic uncertainty.

  7. Improved AI can analyze data at energies outside the main peak by using event counting methods for Nobs = 0 or fitting with functions like [2] f(x) = 2(p2x + p3 − p1 + p1ln p1 / (p2x + p3) P4(x) to parameterize the dependence.

Sources

Related papers