Tuning topological phase and Dirac point position via Pb and Sb substitution in Mn 1-x Pb x (Bi 1-y Sb y) 2 Te 4
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Tuning topological phase and Dirac point position via Pb and Sb substitution in Mn 1-x Pb x (Bi 1-y Sb y) 2 Te 4".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Tuning topological phase and Dirac point position via Pb and Sb substitution in Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 presents a systematic investigation into controlling the electronic structure and magnetic properties of Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 crystals over wide concentration ranges to achieve independent control of the topological phase and Fermi level position The value of the bulk band gap is determined exclusively by the Pb concentration, closing at Pb 40–50%, which corresponds to a topological phase transition The position of the Dirac point is determined by the Pb/Sb ratio, rather than the absolute Sb content The simultaneous substitution of Mn and Bi allows independent control of the topological phase and the position of the Fermi level Electronic Structure Modulation ARPES measurements revealed that substituting Bi with Sb leads to p-type doping, which is characterized by a shift of the electronic structure toward lower binding energies Increasing the Pb concentration at a constant Sb concentration decreases the bulk band gap value until it closes at Pb concentrations of approximately 40–50% As the Pb concentration increases, Rashba-like states emerge and intensify, shifting toward higher binding energies The position of the Dirac point ED in the Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 system depends on the concentrations of Pb and Sb Dirac Point Determination The functional dependence of ED and Eg on composition was established using machine learning methods, showing that the value of the bulk band gap Eg is almost entirely determined by the Pb concentration, with a relative importance of ≈0.75 A different dependence is found for the Dirac point position ED, where the dominant factor turned out to be not the Sb concentration but rather the concentration ratio x y (or equivalently y x) — its importance was approximately 0.7–0.85 The transition from n-type to p-type conductivity occurs at a Pb/Sb ratio of ∼0.5, which corresponds to a compensated semiconductor Topological Phase Control The topological phase transition, accompanied by the closure of the bulk band gap and the disappearance of the TSS, occurs at Pb ∼40–50% irrespective of the Sb concentration Substituting Mn with Pb induces this transition, whereas substituting Bi with Sb does not affect the topological phase but allows tuning of the Dirac point position TSS are preserved for Pb < 40%, while at Pb ∼50%, states with the characteristic TSS signature cannot be resolved, confirming the transition from the TI phase Magnetic Property Preservation Antiferromagnetic order is preserved in Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 across the entire studied composition range (x = 10–60%, y = 5–60%) For samples containing ∼20% Pb (regardless of the Sb content: 32% or 58%), the N´eel temperature is 19–20 K, and the spin-flop transition field is 1.6–2 T The results show that substituting Bi for Sb, which alters the electron density (and thus the electronic structure), has virtually no effect on the magnetic properties In contrast, the substitution of Mn with Pb leads to a dilution of the magnetic sublattice, causing a monotonic decrease in TN and Hsf Experimental Techniques The study employed ARPES measurements at photon energies of 21.2 eV to study the bulk band structure and 6.3 eV for investigating the TSS Circular dichroism ARPES (CD-ARPES) was used to distinguish TSS from bulk states, showing a sign inversion of the difference intensity when crossing the plane of incident light SQUID magnetometry was utilized to assess temperature dependencies of magnetic susceptibility χ(T) and magnetization as a function of applied magnetic field M(H) The work was supported by the St.
Kai: Petersburg State University grant No.
Paper summary: Kai: So to recap, this paper investigates how substituting lead and antimony in Mn one-half lead sub bismuth antimony double telluride crystals allows for independent control over two key material properties: the topological phase and the position of the Dirac point.
Mira: The central thesis is that by carefully controlling these substitutions, you can independently tune both the topological phase transition and where the Fermi level sits relative to that Dirac point. This is significant because it suggests a systematic way to engineer materials with desired electronic structures for topological applications.
Lev: It matters because traditional methods of tuning these properties often involve complex external conditions like pressure or temperature, but chemical substitution offers a direct way to manipulate them during synthesis, which is much more relevant for scalable manufacturing.
Kai: They specifically claim that the bulk band gap value is determined exclusively by the lead concentration, and it closes at lead concentrations between forty and fifty percent, marking the topological phase transition.
Mira: But they also found that the position of that Dirac point isn't just about how much antimony you have; rather, it depends on the ratio of lead to antimony concentration. This ratio has a dominant factor in determining the Dirac point location.
Lev: That dependence on the substitution ratio sounds like a very precise knob for tuning things up, which is what we want when designing new quantum devices where precise energy control is everything.
Kai: So, they show that the simultaneous substitution of manganese and bismuth lets us have this independent control over both the topological phase and the position of the Fermi level. That's what makes this work interesting for controlling these states.
Mira: It points toward a material system where we can design materials that naturally fall into a specific topological state just by choosing our starting chemistry, rather than relying on external forces to get there.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, having tunable parameters like the Dirac point position means we have more flexibility in designing the Hamiltonian of the system before even worrying about noise and decoherence.
Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the title, it’s all about tuning the topological phase and Dirac point position via lead and antimony substitution in Mn one-half lead sub bismuth antimony double telluride crystals. It highlights that we are using chemical changes to directly manipulate these fundamental electronic properties.
Mira: The implication is that we can use these substitutions as a tool to design materials with specific, controllable topological features, which moves us closer to realizing functional topological materials for real devices.
Lev: For the hardware guys, this means our focus should shift from just achieving a single material state to designing families of materials where we can tune the properties across different compositions.
Kai: So instead of finding one perfect material, we have a recipe that lets us dial in exactly where you want the Dirac point to be and which phase you want to land in. It's about making the process repeatable.
Mira: It’s about moving from discovery to design when it comes to these materials, using chemical substitution as our primary tool for controlling the physics.
Lev: If we can achieve this level of control, it opens up new avenues for designing devices that rely on topological effects being predictable and tunable based on simple material chemistry.
Saint Petersburg State University · Center for Advanced Mesoscience and Nanotechnology Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology Center for Advanced Mesoscience and Nanotechnology Rzhanov Institute of Semiconductor Physics Siberian Branch Russian Academy of Sciences Synchrotron radiation facility SKIF Boreskov Institute of Catalysis Siberian Branch Russian Academy of Sciences Sobolev Institute of Geology and Mineralogy Siberian Branch Russian Academy of Sciences Research Institute for Synchrotron Radiation Science Hiroshima University Graduate School of Advanced Science and Engineering International Institute for Sustainability with Knotted Chiral Meta Matter WPI-SKCM2 Hiroshima University Research Institute for Semiconductor Engineering RISE
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2026-06-30
Updated: 2026-06-30
DOI: 10.1103/v9dd-m7bh
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 69/100
The gist: Tuning topological phase and Dirac point position via Pb and Sb substitution in Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 presents a systematic investigation into controlling the electronic structure and magnetic…
Key concepts
- Topological Phase Transition
- This is a change in the material's fundamental electronic structure, specifically related to its topology. In this material, it occurs when the bulk band gap closes around 40-50% Pb concentration. This transition marks a shift from one topological state (like a Topological Insulator) to another, which is crucial for its unique quantum properties.
- Dirac Point Position
- This refers to the specific energy level where the electronic bands cross, known as the Dirac point. The paper shows that this position is primarily controlled by the ratio of Pb and Sb concentrations (x/y), not just how much Sb is present. This means researchers can precisely tune where this critical energy level sits within the material's band structure.
- Bulk Band Gap
- This is the energy difference between the top of the valence band and the bottom of the conduction band in a crystal. The paper determined that this gap value is almost entirely dictated by how much lead (Pb) is substituted into the crystal. Increasing Pb concentration reduces this gap until it closes at 40-50%.
- Antiferromagnetic Order Preservation
- This refers to the magnetic ordering within the material, specifically antiferromagnetism. The study found that this magnetic order remains stable across a wide range of substitutions for both Mn and Bi. However, substituting Mn with Pb weakens this order by diluting the magnetic atoms, leading to a decrease in its strength (Néel temperature).
Terminology
Summary
Tuning topological phase and Dirac point position via Pb and Sb substitution in Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 presents a systematic investigation into controlling the electronic structure and magnetic properties of Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 crystals over wide concentration ranges to achieve independent control of the topological phase and Fermi level position
The value of the bulk band gap is determined exclusively by the Pb concentration, closing at Pb 40–50%, which corresponds to a topological phase transition The position of the Dirac point is determined by the Pb/Sb ratio, rather than the absolute Sb content The simultaneous substitution of Mn and Bi allows independent control of the topological phase and the position of the Fermi level
Electronic Structure Modulation
ARPES measurements revealed that substituting Bi with Sb leads to p-type doping, which is characterized by a shift of the electronic structure toward lower binding energies Increasing the Pb concentration at a constant Sb concentration decreases the bulk band gap value until it closes at Pb concentrations of approximately 40–50% As the Pb concentration increases, Rashba-like states emerge and intensify, shifting toward higher binding energies The position of the Dirac point ED in the Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 system depends on the concentrations of Pb and Sb
Dirac Point Determination
The functional dependence of ED and Eg on composition was established using machine learning methods, showing that the value of the bulk band gap Eg is almost entirely determined by the Pb concentration, with a relative importance of ≈0.75 A different dependence is found for the Dirac point position ED, where the dominant factor turned out to be not the Sb concentration but rather the concentration ratio x y (or equivalently y x) — its importance was approximately 0. p. 3 A different dependence is found for the Dirac point
position ED. Unexpectedly, the dominant factor turned
out to be not the Sb concentration but the concentration ratio x
y
(or equivalently y
x
) — its importance was
approximately 0. This also helps position the Fermi level inside the band
gap; therefore, the sensitivity of ED to the Pb/Sb ratio
decreases, and the curve reaches a plateau. The transition from n-type to p-type conductivity occurs at a Pb/Sb ratio of ∼0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Topological Phase Control
The topological phase transition, accompanied by the closure of the bulk band gap and the disappearance of the TSS, occurs at Pb ∼40–50% irrespective of the Sb concentration Substituting Mn with Pb induces this transition, whereas substituting Bi with Sb does not affect the topological phase but allows tuning of the Dirac point position TSS are preserved for Pb < 40%, while at Pb ∼50%, states with the characteristic TSS signature cannot be resolved, confirming the transition from the TI phase
Magnetic Property Preservation
Antiferromagnetic order is preserved in Mn1−xPbx(Bi−ySb y)2Te4 across the entire studied composition range (x = 10–60%, y = 5–60%) For samples containing ∼20% Pb (regardless of the Sb content: 32% or 58%), the N´eel temperature is 19–20 K, and the spin-flop transition field is 1.6–2 T The results show that substituting Bi for Sb, which alters the electron density (and thus the electronic structure), has virtually no effect on the magnetic properties In contrast, the substitution of Mn with Pb leads to a dilution of the magnetic sublattice, causing a monotonic decrease in TN and Hsf
Experimental Techniques
The study employed ARPES measurements at photon energies of 21.2 eV to study the bulk band structure and 6. p. 1 We used photon energies of 21. 2 eV to study the bulk band structure
and 6. For samples with a Pb concentration of 25% and an Sb
concentration of 20% (Fig. 4 a), the TSS are clearly distinguishable in both dispersion and constant-energy cuts
- a sign inversion of the difference intensity (blue → red)
is observed when crossing the plane of incident light. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by the St. Petersburg State
University grant No.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced predictive modeling for topological phase transitions based on concentration ratios: The machine learning model can predict whether a system will undergo a topological phase transition by analyzing features like
Pb/Sb ratio
with an importance of approximately 0.7 to 0.85, which is the dominant factor for Dirac point position in the doubly substituted system. -
Independent tuning of electronic and magnetic properties: The improved AI can determine the specific Pb and Sb concentrations required to independently control the topological phase (via Pb concentration) and the position of the Fermi level (via Pb/Sb ratio) while preserving antiferromagnetic order across a wide range.
-
Topological phase identification in complex spectra: The system can be trained to distinguish between topological surface states (TSS) and bulk states by analyzing Circular dichroism ARPES data, as the characteristic CD signal is preserved upon Bi-for-Sb substitution for samples with low Pb content.
Abstract
This study presents a systematic investigation of Mn 1-x Pb x (Bi 1-y Sb y) 2 Te 4 crystals over a wide range of concentrations (x = 10-60%, y = 5-60%). It was found that the value of the bulk band gap is determined exclusively by the Pb concentration and it closes at Pb 40-50 %, which corresponds to a topological phase transition. The position of the Dirac point is determined by the Pb/Sb ratio, rather than the absolute Sb content. The magnetic properties depend on the dilution of the Mn sublattice by Pb and are weakly sensitive to Sb. We show that the simultaneous substitution of Mn and Bi allows independent control of the topological phase and the position of the Fermi level.
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion