Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A First-Principles Study
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects in Li2CO3 and Li2O2".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Lithium carbonate is thermodynamically stable and exhibits poor ionic and electronic conductivities, making its stability and decomposition behavior closely related to defect formation and charge transport properties.
Kai: This study first-principles calculations were performed to systematically analyze the intrinsic point-defect energetics of Li2CO3 and to evaluate the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in Li2CO3 and Li2O2.
Mira: Intrinsic defect analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects.
Kai: Intrinsic Defect Analysis The intrinsic defect energetics of pristine Li2CO3 were evaluated by considering both neutral and charged defects.
Title and authors: Kai: So, focusing on the title and authors of this paper, "Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A First-Principles Study," we see a very specific focus on how those defects interact with fluorine.
Mira: The authors are taking the stability of lithium carbonate, which is already known to be stable, and they are testing what happens when you dope it with fluorine to see how that changes the defect energetics for both Li two CO three and Li two O two <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, the point is that if we can predict how doping affects vacancy formation energy, we get a handle on whether adding fluorine helps us control the decomposition pathway.
Kai: It’s about moving past just saying Li two CO three decomposes to understanding exactly how much easier or harder it becomes to break apart when you introduce fluorine at the oxygen sites <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Mira: The key thing is that they are systematically analyzing intrinsic point defects and evaluating the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in both Li two CO three and Li two O two to see how stability changes <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: It’s a targeted study because it zeroes in on lithium-related defects as the main drivers of this behavior, which is more useful for designing actual batteries.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, what's the high-level summary they give us? They start by saying that Li two CO three is thermodynamically stable, but its stability and how it breaks apart are really linked to those defect formation and charge transport properties <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Mira: The study first does intrinsic defect analysis on pristine Li two CO three finding that the behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects across the whole system <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: Then they move to fluorine doping, and what they found is that fluorine selectively lowers the formation energies for lithium and carbon vacancies in Li two CO three but oxygen vacancy formation energy stays pretty much unchanged <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Kai: That selective lowering of lithium and carbon vacancies suggests that the carbonate framework itself gets partially destabilized when you substitute fluorine, which is a really important detail to hear.
Mira: And they quantify this by showing that the lithium vacancy formation energy drops from one point six three electron volts to negative one point seven five electron volts when fluorine substitutes at the oxygen site and we are at three point eight two volt.
Lev: That drop of about three point four eight electron volts is significant because it shows a substantial thermodynamic cost reduction for removing lithium, which is what you want to avoid in a battery system.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out some important improvements they made to the analysis, especially concerning how they modeled these defects and the voltage dependence of them.
Mira: They introduced neutral vacancy defects into both pristine and fluorine-doped structures for each system, but they also used complex vacancy defects like VLi two CO three zero using direct supercell calculations <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: That’s good because it shows how the system behaves when you have clustered vacancies, which is a much more realistic scenario than just looking at single empty spots.
Kai: And they also noted that lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies show voltage dependence, while oxygen vacancy formation energies remain voltage independent across the applied cell voltage.
Mira: That distinction is key because it suggests that lithium extraction accompanied by electronic compensation might be thermodynamically favored during charging, whereas oxygen vacancies don't behave that way.
Lev: If we are building real hardware, knowing this voltage dependence means we have to account for the charge state of the defects when calculating the actual kinetic barriers for decomposition.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on "Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A First-Principles Study," they conclude that fluorine doping modifies the defect energetics through a richer set of mechanisms than in Li two O two <ref:2606.25408#pg1,Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A>.
Mira: They emphasize that this is not just about lowering lithium vacancy formation, but it also reduces the carbon vacancy formation energy, which is something you don't see in Li two O two <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: The big implication here for the world is that fluorine doping seems to destabilize both discharge products through a common mechanism of destabilizing the cation sublattice, and it actually weakens the carbonate framework in Li two CO three too <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Kai: It means we might be able to use these same fluorine doping strategies that work for lithium peroxide to also control lithium carbonate decomposition pathways.
Mira: They suggest that this could help reduce the thermodynamic cost associated with forming those lithium deficient Li two-x O two phases, which is really relevant for performance degradation in LOBs <ref:2606.25408#pg1>.
Lev: I just want to say that while this study shows a mechanism, the authors themselves flag that they are still looking at intrinsic defects and haven't fully incorporated polaron dynamics or kinetic barriers yet to explain the full decomposition process under realistic electrochemical conditions.
Department of Materials Engineering, The University of Tokyo · Institute of Industrial Science, the University of Tokyo · National Institute for Fusion Science, Gifu 509-5292 · Research Center for Solar Energy Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering Science, The University of Osaka · Innovative Catalysis Science Division, Institute for Open Transdisciplinary Research Initiatives
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2026-06-24
Updated: 2026-11-13
Comments: 41 pages, 10 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: Lithium carbonate is thermodynamically stable and exhibits poor ionic and electronic conductivities, making its stability and decomposition behavior closely related to defect formation and charge…
Key concepts
- Defect Formation Energy
- This measures the energy cost required to create a specific defect (like a missing atom) within the crystal structure. Lower formation energies mean that defects are more likely to form under certain conditions, which dictates the material's stability and decomposition behavior.
- Fluorine Doping Effects
- Introducing fluorine into Li2CO3 selectively lowers the energy needed to create lithium and carbon vacancies, but has little effect on oxygen vacancies. This indicates that fluorine strongly perturbs the local environment around lithium sites, affecting cation stability more than anion stability.
- Voltage Dependence of Defects
- The formation energies of lithium and carbon vacancies change depending on the cell voltage (U). This means that during battery operation, the thermodynamic favorability of removing lithium is linked to the applied voltage, allowing AI to predict which defect mechanism dominates under specific electrochemical states.
Terminology
Summary
Lithium carbonate is thermodynamically stable and exhibits poor ionic and electronic conductivities, making its stability and decomposition behavior closely related to defect formation and charge transport properties. p. 2 1–9 Due to the robust bonding
network of carbonate units, Li2CO3 is thermodynamically stable and exhibits poor ionic and
electronic conductivities. 7 These characteristics make Li2CO3 difficult to decompose
electrochemically once formed, and its stability and decomposition behavior are closely related to
defect formation and charge transport properties. However, compared
with Li2O2, the intrinsic defect thermodynamics of Li2CO3 and how chemical doping modifies its
defect energetics remain insufficiently understood. In this study, first-principles calculations were
performed to systematically analyze the intrinsic point-defect energetics of Li2CO3 and to evaluate
the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in Li2CO3 and Li2O2. In this study, first-principles calculations were
performed to systematically analyze the intrinsic point-defect energetics of Li2CO3 and to evaluate
the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in Li2CO3 and Li2O2. Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Intrinsic Defect Analysis
The intrinsic defect energetics of pristine Li2CO3 were evaluated by considering both neutral and charged defects. The formation energies of intrinsic point defects in bulk Li2CO3 were calculated as a function of the Fermi level across its band gap (7. p. 9 (b) is a
carbonate unit. The formation energies of intrinsic point defects in bulk Li2CO3 were calculated as a function of
the Fermi level across its band gap (~7. The formation energies of intrinsic point defects in bulk Li2CO3 were calculated as a function of
the Fermi level across its band gap (~7. 98 eV) as shown in Figure 2. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. This voltage-dependent definition of 𝜇𝐿𝑖 was applied to both discharge products. The equilibrium
voltages of Li2O2 and Li2CO3 were used as reference electrochemical conditions for evaluating
voltage-dependent vacancy formation energies.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Fluorine Doping Effects on Stability
Fluorine doping selectively decreases the lithium and carbon vacancies formation energies in Li2CO3, whereas oxygen vacancy formation is only weakly affected. The reduction in lithium vacancy formation energy for fluorine substitution at the O(f) site was from 1. p. 1 Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. 29 In this respect, fluorine differs from
many other dopants that would require deliberate synthetic incorporation. Second, owing to its
similar ionic radius to oxygen and its exceptional electronegativity, fluorine substitution at oxygen
sites is expected to selectively perturb the local bonding environment around lithium ions,
potentially modifying cation sublattice stability without wholesale structural disruption. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparative Doping Mechanisms
The magnitude of the fluorine doping effect on lithium vacancy formation was approximately twice as large in Li2CO3 (ΔE ≈ −3. p. 1 In this study, first-principles calculations were
performed to systematically analyze the intrinsic point-defect energetics of Li2CO3 and to evaluate
the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in Li2CO3 and Li2O2. Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. 1
Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects
in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A First-Principles Study
Youjeong Choi1
, Tasuku Sugiura2
, Keisuke Mukai3
, Nanako Ishihara4
, Shuji Nakanishi4, 5, and
Teruyasu Mizoguchi1, 2, *
1 Department of Materials Engineering, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-8656, Japan
2
Institute of Industrial Science, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 153-8505, Japan
3 National Institute for Fusion Science, Gifu 509-5292, Japan
4 Research Center for Solar Energy Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering Science, The
University of Osaka, Osaka 560-8531, Japan
5
Innovative Catalysis Science Division, Institute for Open Transdisciplinary Research
Initiatives, The University of Osaka, Osaka 565-0871, Japan
*Corresponding author. E-mail: teru@iis. 1
Intrinsic Defect Energetics and Fluorine Doping Effects
in Li2CO3 and Li2O2: A First-Principles Study
Youjeong Choi1
, Tasuku Sugiura2
, Keisuke Mukai3
, Nanako Ishihara4
, Shuji Nakanishi4, 5, and
Teruyasu Mizoguchi1, 2, *
1 Department of Materials Engineering, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-8656, Japan
2
Institute of Industrial Science, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 153-8505, Japan
3 National Institute for Fusion Science, Gifu 509-5292, Japan
4 Research Center for Solar Energy Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering Science, The
University of Osaka, Osaka 560-8531, Japan
5
Innovative Catalysis Science Division, Institute for Open Transdisciplinary Research
Initiatives, The University of Osaka, Osaka 565-0871, Japan
*Corresponding author. E-mail: teru@iis. In contrast, carbon vacancy formation leads to a slight increase in
magnetization, suggesting further perturbation of the local electronic structure within the carbonate
framework. Oxygen vacancy formation results in only a minor change in magnetization,
corroborating the selective nature of fluorine doping toward cation vacancy formation rather than
anion vacancy formation. Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion and Implications
Fluorine doping modifies the defect energetics of Li2CO3 through a richer set of mechanisms than in Li2O2, including a reduction in carbon vacancy formation energy that is absent in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping not only facilitates lithium removal but may also partially destabilize the carbonate network itself, potentially providing an additional decomposition pathway. p. 1 Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries. Third,
while halogen doping effects including fluorine have been theoretically explored in Li2O2. 19,20 a
systematic investigation of fluorine doping in Li2CO3 remains absent. Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. 7 These characteristics make Li2CO3 difficult to decompose
electrochemically once formed, and its stability and decomposition behavior are closely related to
defect formation and charge transport properties. Therefore, understanding the intrinsic defect
energetics of Li2CO3 is crucial for clarifying the thermodynamic factors governing its stability
across lithium-based electrochemical systems.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
REFERENCE
B3pg3
B5pg5
B7pg7
B11pg11
B13pg13
F2pg8
F9pg8
Sufficient Data for Analysis
The study utilized density functional theory (DFT) as implemented in the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) for all calculations. The electron–ion interactions were described by the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method. p. 4 METHODS
DFT calculations and structure formation
All calculations were performed within the framework of density functional theory (DFT) as
implemented in the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP). 36–38 The electron–ion
interactions were described by the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method. 36–38 The electron–ion
interactions were described by the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method. 39 For structural
relaxations, the exchange-correlation energy was treated using the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof
(PBE) functional within the generalized gradient approximation (GGA). 40 For Li, the Li_sv PAW
potential including both 1s and 2s states in the valence was employed, whereas default PAW
datasets were used for O, C, and F. The plane-wave cutoff energy was set to 520 eV, and Brillouin
zone integrations were performed using Γ-centered k-point grids generated with a reciprocal-space
resolution of 0. The plane-wave cutoff energy was set to 520 eV, and Brillouin
zone integrations were performed using Γ-centered k-point grids generated with a reciprocal-space
resolution of 0. 025 Å-1
. 005 eV/Å for the residual ionic forces. Spin polarization was included
in all calculations, as its role becomes evident upon fluorine substitution in Li2CO3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Chemical Potential Definitions
The lithium chemical potential was defined to account for the electrochemical conditions of LOBs environment. p. 7 𝜇𝑖
is the chemical potential of species i. The lithium chemical potential was defined to account for the electrochemical conditions of
LOBs environment. In this environment, the applied cell voltage U exists between the lithium
metal anode and the discharge products formed at the cathode. Accordingly, the lithium chemical
potential depends on U and was expressed as:48
𝜇Li(𝑈) = 𝜇Li
bulk − e𝑈 (2)
where 𝜇Li
bulk is the energy per atom of bulk lithium metal at 𝑈 = 0, and e is the elementary charge. 96 V vs Li+/Li (3)
4Li+ + 4e
− + 2CO2 + O2 ⇌ 2Li2CO3, 𝑈eq = 3. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Phase Diagram Constraints
The chemical potentials used for the voltage-dependent analysis and those obtained from the Li–C–O phase diagram are summarized in Table S1(a) and Table S1(b). The Li–C–O phase diagram is shown in Figure S1. p. 9 The formation energies of intrinsic point defects in bulk Li2CO3 were calculated as a function of
the Fermi level across its band gap (~7. 98 eV) as shown in Figure 2. The formation energies of intrinsic point defects in bulk Li2CO3 were calculated as a function of
the Fermi level across its band gap (~7. 98 eV) as shown in Figure 2. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Defect Formation Energy Definition
The defect formation energy of a defect X in charge state q was defined as follows:Ef[Xq] = Etot[Xq] − Etot[ref] −∑nimui + qEF + Ecorr (1). The reference supercell is the pristine supercell for intrinsic defects and the fluorinesubstituted supercell for vacancy defects in doped systems. p. 7 8
𝐸
𝑓
[𝑋
𝑞
] = 𝐸tot
[𝑋
𝑞
] − 𝐸tot[ref] −∑𝑛𝑖𝜇𝑖
𝑖
+ 𝑞𝐸F + 𝐸corr (1)
Where 𝐸tot[𝑋
𝑞
] and 𝐸tot[ref] denote the total energies of the defective and reference supercells,
respectively. The reference supercell is the pristine supercell for intrinsic defects and the fluorinesubstituted supercell for vacancy defects in doped systems. The lithium chemical potential was defined to account for the electrochemical conditions of
LOBs environment. In this environment, the applied cell voltage U exists between the lithium
metal anode and the discharge products formed at the cathode. The lithium chemical potential was defined to account for the electrochemical conditions of
LOBs environment. In this environment, the applied cell voltage U exists between the lithium
metal anode and the discharge products formed at the cathode.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Chemical Potential Calculations
The O2 correction procedure was expressed as follows: ∆Hfcal(Li2O2) = EDFT(Li2O2) − 2 EDFT(Libulk) − EDFT (O2). The DFT energy of O2 was increased by 0. p. 4 This work offers
thermodynamic insight into how fluorine doping modifies the defect energetics of Li2CO3 and
Li2O2, which may inform doping design strategies for controlling the stability of lithium-based
discharge products. METHODS
DFT calculations and structure formation
All calculations were performed within the framework of density functional theory (DFT) as
implemented in the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP). 96 V vs Li+/Li (3)
4Li+ + 4e
− + 2CO2 + O2 ⇌ 2Li2CO3, 𝑈eq = 3. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Fluorine Substitution Energies
The fluorine substitution energies calculated using different fluorine reference reservoirs are summarized in Table S3. The LiF-based values therefore represent conservative upper-bound estimates under equilibrium bulk conditions. p. 8 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 10
The oxygen atoms in the carbonate unit can be classified into two inequivalent sites, denoted as
O(f) and O(e). According to the optimized structure, the C–O bond length at the O(f) site is 1. 10
The oxygen atoms in the carbonate unit can be classified into two inequivalent sites, denoted as
O(f) and O(e). According to the optimized structure, the C–O bond length at the O(f) site is 1. Therefore, understanding the intrinsic defect
energetics of Li2CO3 is crucial for clarifying the thermodynamic factors governing its stability
across lithium-based electrochemical systems. The stability and decomposition behavior of Li2CO3 has become especially important in LOBs,
where Li2CO3 forms alongside Li2O2 as discharge products. 49–51
RESULTS and DISCUSSION
Structural Properties and intrinsic defect energetics of Li2CO3
The structural model used in this study is a monoclinic Li2CO3 supercell with space group C2/c,
as presented in Figure 1 together with the local structure of the carbonate unit and the distinct
atomic sites considered for defect modeling. The Wyckoff positions and fractional coordinates of
all inequivalent atomic sites in the optimized structure are summarized in Table S2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Structural Details
Li2CO3 consists of ionic interactions between Li+ cations and CO3 2− anions. Within each CO3 2− unit, the carbon atom is coordinated by three oxygen atoms in a trigonal planar geometry, reflecting the covalent character of the C–O bonds. p. 8 Li2CO3
consists of ionic interactions between Li+ cations and CO3
2− anions. Within each CO3
2− unit, the
carbon atom is coordinated by three oxygen atoms in a trigonal planar geometry, reflecting the
covalent character of the C–O bonds. 10
The oxygen atoms in the carbonate unit can be classified into two inequivalent sites, denoted as
O(f) and O(e). According to the optimized structure, the C–O bond length at the O(f) site is 1. 10
The oxygen atoms in the carbonate unit can be classified into two inequivalent sites, denoted as
O(f) and O(e). According to the optimized structure, the C–O bond length at the O(f) site is 1. According to the optimized structure, the C–O bond length at the O(f) site is 1. 31
Å and is coordinated by three neighboring lithium ions. 31
Å and is coordinated by three neighboring lithium ions. In contrast, the C–O bond length at the
O(e) site is 1. In contrast, the C–O bond length at the
O(e) site is 1. 29 Å and is coordinated by two neighboring lithium sites.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Defect Modeling Approach
Neutral vacancy defects were introduced into both pristine and fluorine-doped structures for each system. Complex vacancy defects, such as VLi2CO3 0, were evaluated using direct supercell calculations by removing one Li2CO3 formula unit from the lattice as a clustered vacancy. p. 6 In the fluorine-doped structures, vacancy sites were selected in
the vicinity of the substituted fluorine atom to evaluate the local influence of fluorine substitution
on vacancy formation energies. Complex vacancy defects, such as VLi2CO3
0
, were evaluated using
direct supercell calculations by removing one Li2CO3 formula unit from the lattice as a clustered
vacancy. This direct approach explicitly includes local structural relaxation and interactions among
the constituent vacancies, instead of approximating the complex defect energy by summing the
formation energies of individual charged vacancies. The supercells were optimized at the PBE level with fixed lattice parameters, allowing only
internal atomic coordinates to relax. The supercells were optimized at the PBE level with fixed lattice parameters, allowing only
internal atomic coordinates to relax. The PBE-relaxed structures were used for single-point total
energy calculations using the Heyd–Scuseria–Ernzerhof (HSE) functional to evaluate defect
formation energies. The PBE-relaxed structures were used for single-point total
energy calculations using the Heyd–Scuseria–Ernzerhof (HSE) functional to evaluate defect
formation energies. 43–45 The HSE mixing parameter was set to α = 0. 43–45 The HSE mixing parameter was set to α = 0. 35, following previous work,46
in which this value was adopted as an intermediate choice within the range of reported GW band
gap estimates for Li2O2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Voltage Dependence of Defects
The voltage-dependent defect behavior of Li2CO3 was generally governed by lithium-related defects, while carbon- and oxygen-related intrinsic defects remained thermodynamically unfavorable. In particular, the dominant formation of VLi− near and above the equilibrium voltage of Li2O2 suggests that Li+ extraction accompanied by electronic compensation may be thermodynamically favored during charging. p. 7 This voltage-dependent definition of 𝜇𝐿𝑖 was applied to both discharge products. The equilibrium
voltages of Li2O2 and Li2CO3 were used as reference electrochemical conditions for evaluating
voltage-dependent vacancy formation energies. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Selectivity of Fluorine Effect
In the fluorine-doped structure, the lithium and carbon vacancies formation energies were generally lowered compared to pristine state, whereas oxygen vacancy exhibits no significant change. This cation-selective destabilization, attributable to the strong electronegativity of fluorine perturbing the local electrostatic environment around lithium sites, not only lowers the thermodynamic cost of lithium removal but also partially weakens the carbonate framework itself. p. 3 29 In this respect, fluorine differs from
many other dopants that would require deliberate synthetic incorporation. Second, owing to its
similar ionic radius to oxygen and its exceptional electronegativity, fluorine substitution at oxygen
sites is expected to selectively perturb the local bonding environment around lithium ions,
potentially modifying cation sublattice stability without wholesale structural disruption. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Comparison to Li2O2
Fluorine doping reduced the lithium vacancy formation energies compared with the pristine state for both systems. In Li2O2, fluorine doping reduced the lithium vacancy formation energy from 1. p. 1 Intrinsic defect
analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. This voltage-dependent definition of 𝜇𝐿𝑖 was applied to both discharge products. The equilibrium
voltages of Li2O2 and Li2CO3 were used as reference electrochemical conditions for evaluating
voltage-dependent vacancy formation energies. In contrast, carbon vacancy formation leads to a slight increase in
magnetization, suggesting further perturbation of the local electronic structure within the carbonate
framework. Oxygen vacancy formation results in only a minor change in magnetization,
corroborating the selective nature of fluorine doping toward cation vacancy formation rather than
anion vacancy formation. 10–16 In LOBs, the accumulation of
Li2CO3 on the cathode impedes charge transport and requires high charging overpotentials for
decomposition, leading to severe losses in the energy efficiency and cyclability of LOBs. 6,8,17,18
To enhance charge transport and decomposability within the discharge products of LOBs, doping
strategies have been actively investigated, particularly for Li2O2. Second, owing to its
similar ionic radius to oxygen and its exceptional electronegativity, fluorine substitution at oxygen
sites is expected to selectively perturb the local bonding environment around lithium ions,
potentially modifying cation sublattice stability without wholesale structural disruption. Third,
while halogen doping effects including fluorine have been theoretically explored in Li2O2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Summary of Findings
The study reveals that fluorine doping selectively reduces the lithium and carbon vacancies formation energies in both systems while exerting limited influence on oxygen vacancies. This cation-selective destabilization demonstrates that fluorine at oxygen sites has a stronger effect on cation sublattices rather than the anion sublattices. p. 5 In contrast, carbon vacancy formation leads to a slight increase in
magnetization, suggesting further perturbation of the local electronic structure within the carbonate
framework. Oxygen vacancy formation results in only a minor change in magnetization,
corroborating the selective nature of fluorine doping toward cation vacancy formation rather than
anion vacancy formation. 19–22 For example, dopants such
as Ba, Na+
, and K+
have been reported to promote lithium vacancy formation and lower the
charging overpotential. 23–28 Meanwhile, electrolyte additives have been used to modify the
structural characteristics of Li2O2; fluorinated amide-based electrolytes have been experimentally
shown to induce the formation of lithium-deficient Li2−xO2 and maintain a low charging voltage. Upon
fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3,
partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation
energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect
energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling
the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium–
oxygen batteries. First, from a practical standpoint, fluorinated electrolytes may serve as a source of
fluorine-containing species under realistic battery operating conditions. Although the effects of
fluorinated electrolytes on Li2CO3 have not been directly examined, their reported role in
promoting the formation of lithium-deficient Li2−xO2 discharge products provides practical
motivation for investigating fluorine as a dopant candidate. Third,
while halogen doping effects including fluorine have been theoretically explored in Li2O2. 19,20 a
systematic investigation of fluorine doping in Li2CO3 remains absent.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Supporting Information Details
The supporting information is available at the end of this preprint. Chemical potential calculations, structural information, and additional defect formation energy results (PDF). p. 8 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1. The carbon chemical potential was determined by the
thermodynamic stability condition of Li2CO3. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1. 49–51
RESULTS and DISCUSSION
Structural Properties and intrinsic defect energetics of Li2CO3
The structural model used in this study is a monoclinic Li2CO3 supercell with space group C2/c,
as presented in Figure 1 together with the local structure of the carbonate unit and the distinct
atomic sites considered for defect modeling. The Wyckoff positions and fractional coordinates of
all inequivalent atomic sites in the optimized structure are summarized in Table S2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Chemical Potential Tables
Table S1 shows the chemical potential conditions used for defect formation energy calculations. Table S3 presents the fluorine substitution energies calculated using different fluorine reference reservoirs. p. 8 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1.Where the paper says it
Structural Data
Table S2 summarizes the Wyckoff positions and fractional coordinates of the optimized Li2CO3 structure. Table S1(a) summarizes the voltage-dependent chemical potential conditions used in the main analysis. p. 7 This voltage-dependent definition of 𝜇𝐿𝑖 was applied to both discharge products. The equilibrium
voltages of Li2O2 and Li2CO3 were used as reference electrochemical conditions for evaluating
voltage-dependent vacancy formation energies. 9
defined using LiF as the thermodynamic reference reservoir, assuming equilibrium among Li2O2,
O2, and LiF:20
𝜇F = 𝐸(LiF) −
1
2
𝐸(Li2O2
) +
1
2
𝐸(O2
) (5)
This represents a conservative upper-bound estimate of the substitution cost under equilibrium
bulk conditions; additional fluorine chemical potentials were calculated using F2 and OF2 as
fluorine-rich reference states. The detailed chemical potential calculations, phase stability
boundaries, and definitions of the alternative fluorine reference states are described in Supporting
Information S1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Context
The experimental value was taken as ∆Hfexp(Li2O2, 300 K) = −6.57 eV. The applied cell voltage U exists between the lithium metal anode and the discharge products formed at the cathode. The oxygen chemical potential was corrected to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT calculations. p. 7 96 V vs Li+/Li (3)
4Li+ + 4e
− + 2CO2 + O2 ⇌ 2Li2CO3, 𝑈eq = 3. 82 V vs Li+/Li (4)
The oxygen chemical potential was fixed by equilibrium with molecular O2 in the atmosphere,
with a correction applied to account for the well-known overbinding error of gas-phase O2 in DFT
calculations; the correction was derived from the experimental formation enthalpy of Li2O2 as
described in Supporting Information S1.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved defect energetics modeling for lithium carbonate (Li2CO3) by incorporating fluorine doping effects specifically on cation sublattice stability, which lowers lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies while weakening the carbonate framework itself. This allows AI systems to predict how fluorine doping modifies the thermodynamic stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under battery-relevant conditions.
-
Enhanced predictive capability for parasitic discharge product control by using voltage-dependent chemical potentials derived from Eq. (2) to model lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies in LOBs, as the paper shows that
lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies exhibit voltage dependence.
This enables AI to assess the thermodynamic favorability of Li+ extraction during charging versus direct carbonate framework dissociation. -
Tailored doping strategy design by quantifying the magnitude of fluorine doping effects, noting that
the magnitude of the fluorine doping effect on lithium vacancy formation was approximately twice as large in Li2CO3 (Delta E approximately-3.4 eV to-3.9 eV) as in Li2O2.
This allows AI to prioritize dopants based on their specific, system-dependent impact on defect energetics. -
Selective sublattice perturbation analysis by leveraging the finding that
fluorine doping selectively reduces the lithium and carbon vacancies formation energies in Li2CO3, whereas oxygen vacancy formation is only weakly affected.
This enables AI models to predict that fluorine at oxygen sites has a stronger effect on cation sublattices than anion sublattices.
Abstract
Lithium carbonate, Li2CO3, is a thermodynamically stable carbonate phase whose defect energetics are closely related to its stability and decomposition behavior in various lithium-based electrochemical systems. These properties of Li2CO3 are particularly important in lithium-oxygen battery environments. In these systems, Li2CO3 can form as a parasitic discharge product alongside Li2O2, the primary discharge product, leading to performance degradation. However, compared with Li2O2, the intrinsic defect thermodynamics of Li2CO3 and how chemical doping modifies its defect energetics remain insufficiently understood. In this study, first-principles calculations were performed to systematically analyze the intrinsic point-defect energetics of Li2CO3 and to evaluate the effects of fluorine doping on vacancy formation energies in Li2CO3 and Li2O2. Intrinsic defect analysis reveals that defect behavior is predominantly governed by lithium-related defects. Upon fluorine doping, lithium and carbon vacancy formation energies decrease selectively in Li2CO3, partially destabilizing the carbonate framework, while a reduction in lithium vacancy formation energy is also observed in Li2O2. These results suggest that fluorine doping modulates the defect energetics of both discharge products, potentially providing a thermodynamic basis for controlling the stability of Li2CO3 and Li2O2 under thermodynamic conditions representative of lithium-oxygen batteries.
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion