Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders

arXiv:2606.20798 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2026-06-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders computes resummed and matched predictions for jet angularities in hadronic Z+jet events where the jet is initiated by a b-quark Observable Definition and Process Setup The study focuses on observables belonging to the family of jet angularities, which probe both the angular and transverse-momentum distribution of particles within a given jet These observables are defined by the formula involving particle kinematics.

Kai: The analysis considers jets produced in association with a Z-boson in proton–proton collisions, specifically comparing light-flavour jets to b-jets.

Mira: The process definition involves three hard-process configurations: heavy-flavour production, light-flavour production, and inclusive production.

Kai: Theoretical Framework for Resummation and Matching The theoretical framework employs NLL resummation matched to NLO accuracy using the Caesar formalism implemented in Sherpa The framework accounts for massive radiator legs by translating modifications from the massless case into the Caesar formalism.

Title and authors: Kai: So, to wrap up this piece on "Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders": it really hammers home that jet shape measurements are sensitive indicators for heavy quark mass effects and dead-cone suppression <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Mira: Yeah, the main thing is that we can use these angularity probes to study how those heavy quark masses influence radiation, which is really important for our theory of QCD <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Lev: And then they show that for groomed jets, using SoftDrop, things get different because it closes up some phase space and creates a specific bump in the first bin that’s really telling about the underlying physics.

Kai: What this means for us is that we have a consistent way to study these heavy quark effects using jet substructure measurements, even when we have to worry about non-perturbative smearing.

Mira: It gives us a solid foundation for more detailed, flavor-tagged measurements where we can really see those mass effects clearly.

Lev: We also get confirmation that at high transverse momentum, heavy quark jets are pretty clean samples of quark jets, which simplifies the simulation setup in those high energy regions.

Kai: But they're still subleading in inclusive jet samples, so it doesn't drastically change how we describe the overall data right now.

Mira: The dependence on the angular exponent and transverse momentum is key; it tells us exactly where in our kinematic space we need to focus our attention for these mass effects.

Lev: So, if you're building real hardware, you have to account for that migration between parton and hadron levels when you use those transfer matrices they mentioned.

Kai: Right. And the comparison with the CMS data across all those angular exponents gives us confidence in the whole methodology used here <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Mira: This paper confirms that jet angularities are a probe for heavy quark mass effects and how dead-cone suppression works in radiation, which is fundamental to understanding these processes at colliders.

Lev: Moving forward, the next step would be pushing the accuracy of those resummation calculations even higher and looking at more complex final states like Z plus b bar b production <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap this piece: this paper looks at how jet angularities are sensitive probes for heavy quark mass effects and dead-cone suppression of radiation in Z plus jet events.

Mira: Right, they're essentially showing that if you measure the shape of a jet, you can tell something about the heavy quark mass because it affects how those emissions look.

Lev: They also show that grooming techniques like SoftDrop are really important because they reveal a peak in the first bin for b-jets that exists right at the parton level <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Kai: What this means is that we need to be careful when we try to match these simulations to real hardware, because those non-perturbative effects smear things out a bit.

Mira: They suggest that for future work, the resummation needs to be even more accurate, maybe pushing it toward NLL prime accuracy for both ungroomed and groomed jets <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Lev: And they point out that extending this framework to more complex final states like Z plus b bar b production is the logical next thing to explore <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Kai: From an engineering standpoint, running those higher-order calculations on real hardware will definitely increase the computational overhead because we're dealing with these intricate matching procedures.

Mira: It sounds like the next big thing is using this consistent basis to do more differential or flavor-tagged measurements where these mass effects can be really isolated <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Mira: That’s right. The paper sets up a framework that works well for untagged jets, but it's the substructure analysis that really unlocks the physics of heavy quarks.

Lev: So we're looking at refining the theoretical tools to match those experimental observables more precisely, which is exactly what we need when you start building detectors sensitive to these subtle effects.

The paper's improvements: Lev: I just want to say that the consistency across different observables, whether you look at ungroomed or groomed jets, gives us a really robust tool for planning experimental setups <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Kai: It means we have this consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavor-tagged measurements <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Mira: And that's great because the comparison with CMS data shows good agreement across all those angular exponents alpha, which validates the approach we took here <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Lev: For me, it just confirms that the underlying physics we’re modeling is sound enough to be tested against real LHC data, even with these complex resummation techniques <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Kai: So, for now, this paper gives us a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavor-tagged measurements <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. We’ve got a solid tool now for our analyses.

Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this piece on "Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders." It really hammers home that measuring jet shapes is a sensitive indicator for heavy quark mass effects and dead-cone suppression <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Mira: Yeah, the main thing is that we can use these angularity probes to study how those heavy quark masses influence radiation, which is really important for our theory of QCD <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Lev: I just want to say that the consistency across different observables, whether you look at ungroomed or groomed jets, gives us a really robust tool for planning experimental setups <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Kai: It means we have this consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavor-tagged measurements <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Mira: And that's great because the comparison with CMS data shows good agreement across all those angular exponents alpha, which validates the approach we took here <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Lev: For me, it just confirms that the underlying physics we’re modeling is sound enough to be tested against real LHC data, even with these complex resummation techniques <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Kai: So, this paper confirms that jet angularities are sensitive probes for heavy-quark mass effects and dead-cone suppression of collinear radiation <ref:2606.20798#pg1>.

Mira: The finding about the peak structure in groomed jets is quite distinct from what we see in ungroomed samples <ref:2606.20798#pg3>.

Lev: I agree, the non-perturbative effects smear that contribution a bit, but those configurations remain where after SoftDrop grooming, the jet contains only the B hadron <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. That’s a concrete prediction we can test.

Kai: It's about how this separation between heavy- and light-flavor jets depends on both the angularity exponent alpha and the jet transverse momentum <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. We need to keep that dependence in mind for our future searches.

Mira: And remember, the mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, but they diminish at higher transverse momenta <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. That tells us where the most interesting physics lies kinematically.

Lev: We need to keep pushing the accuracy of those resummation calculations and looking at more complex final states like Z plus b bar b production for even better constraints <ref:2606.20798#pg1>. That's where we go next.

Kai: So, the overall implication is that this framework gives us a consistent way to study heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavor-tagged measurements <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. We’ve got a solid tool now for our analyses.

Mira: It's a good foundation, and the comparison with CMS data indicates heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. That’s a pragmatic starting point for our next steps.

Lev: I just want to say that this framework developed here provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavor-tagged measurements <ref:2606.20798#pg3>. That consistency is what we need for robust experimental planning.

Technical University of Munich School of Natural Sciences Physics Department Institute für Theoretische Physik Georg-August-Universitét Göttingen

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-06-18

Updated: 2026-11-11

Comments: 49 pages, 14 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders computes resummed and matched predictions for jet angularities in hadronic Z+jet events where the jet is initiated by a b-quark…

Key concepts

Jet Angularities
These observables measure the angular and transverse momentum distribution of particles inside a jet using specific kinematic formulas. They are used to probe the internal structure and properties of jets, particularly how heavy quarks influence their shape.
NLL Resummation Matched to NLO
This is a theoretical technique where calculations involving large logarithms (like those from QCD) are resummed to all orders (Next-to-Leading Logarithmic accuracy) and then matched precisely to fixed-order calculations at Next-to-Leading Order. This ensures accurate predictions across different energy scales.
SoftDrop Grooming
This is a technique used to define 'groomed' jets by removing soft, wide radiation from the jet structure. It helps isolate specific substructures within the jet, which is crucial for resolving effects like the dead-cone effect and enhancing sensitivity to collinear emissions.
Heavy-Flavour Mass Effects
The mass of a heavy quark (like a b-quark) alters how jets are formed compared to light quarks. The paper shows that these mass effects are significant for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, affecting the jet's distribution shape.

Terminology

Summary

Phenomenology of heavy-flavour jet angularities at hadron colliders computes resummed and matched predictions for jet angularities in hadronic Z+jet events where the jet is initiated by a b-quark

Observable Definition and Process Setup

The study focuses on observables belonging to the family of jet angularities, which probe both the angular and transverse-momentum distribution of particles within a given jet These observables are defined by the formula involving particle kinematics. The analysis considers jets produced in association with a Z-boson in proton–proton collisions, specifically comparing light-flavour jets to b-jets. p. 4 The process definition involves three hard-process configurations: heavy-flavour production, light-flavour production, and inclusive production. p. 4

Theoretical Framework for Resummation and Matching

The theoretical framework employs NLL resummation matched to NLO accuracy using the Caesar formalism implemented in Sherpa The framework accounts for massive radiator legs by translating modifications from the massless case into the Caesar formalism. The resummed cumulative distribution is given by a generic master formula involving hard function, multiple-emission function, soft function, and collinear radiators. p. 6 For ungroomed jet shapes, the radiator for a b-quark is presented in equation (3. p. 89).

Particle-Level Corrections and Non-Perturbative Effects

To incorporate non-perturbative corrections, the authors perform full particle-level simulations with the Sherpa event generator framework These simulations are used to extract parton-to-hadron transfer matrices via the transfer-matrix approach. The hadron-level cross section is given by equation (4. p. 24). This method accounts for effects of hadronization and the underlying event, facilitating a more direct comparison with experimental measurements. p. 3

Comparison with Experimental Data

The final results are compared against CMS data for untagged jets, showing good agreement across all values of the angular parameter α. The comparison shows that the b-quark mass reduces the logarithmic enhancement of the spectrum, replacing double-logarithmic behaviour with single-logarithmic contributions for ungroomed jets. p. 2 For groomed observables, the interplay between dead-cone effect and SoftDrop condition results in a partial closure of the phase space, leading to a pronounced enhancement in the first bin once non-perturbative effects are included. p. 2

Conclusions and Outlook

The study provides a phenomenological validation that jet angularities are sensitive probes of heavy-quark mass effects and dead-cone suppression of collinear radiation The findings confirm that the separation between heavy- and light-flavour jets depends on both the angularity exponent and the jet transverse momentum. Future work suggests extending accuracy of resummation and investigating more complex final states like Z + b¯b production. p. 3 The framework provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. p. 2 The work confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they diminish at higher transverse momenta. p. 5 The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive. The most striking difference between b-jet and light-jet spectra is the presence of a pronounced peak in the first bin for groomed jets. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The study concludes that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, but the framework provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure. p. 2 The comparison with CMS data indicates good agreement across all values of α, consistent with previous results. p. 1 The study confirms that the presence of a peak-like structure in the first bin for groomed heavy-flavour jets is qualitatively reproduced by parton-shower simulations. p. 3 The separation between heavy- and light-flavour jets depends on both the angularity exponent and jet transverse momentum, being most pronounced for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta. p. 5 The study confirms that the presence of a peak in the first bin for groomed jets originates already at parton level because grooming and the dead cone close up the logarithmic phase space. p. 4 The non-perturbative effects smear this contribution but configurations remain where after SoftDrop grooming, the jet contains only the B hadron, leading to an enhancement near zero. p. 2 The study confirms that heavy-flavour jets at high transverse momentum constitute a pure sample of quark-initiated jets. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The study provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The comparison with CMS data indicates that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 The framework developed here provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 The study confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they gradually diminish at higher transverse momenta. p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive. The most striking difference between b-jet and light-jet spectra is the presence of a pronounced peak in the first bin for groomed jets. The study confirms that heavy-flavour jets at high transverse momentum constitute a pure sample of quark-initiated jets. The study provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The comparison with CMS data indicates that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data. The framework developed here provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The study confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they gradually diminish at higher transverse momenta. The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive. The most striking difference between b-jet and light-jet spectra is the presence of a pronounced peak in the first bin for groomed jets. The study confirms that heavy-flavour jets at high transverse momentum constitute a pure sample of quark-initiated jets. The study provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The comparison with CMS data indicates that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data. The framework developed here provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The study confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they gradually diminish at higher transverse momenta. The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive. The most striking difference between b-jet and light-jet spectra is the presence of a pronounced peak in the first bin for groomed jets. The study confirms that heavy-flavour jets at high transverse momentum constitute a pure sample of quark-initiated jets. The study provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The comparison with CMS data indicates that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data

How the training signal is built

The analysis uses a set of fiducial phase space cuts identical to those used in the CMS measurement presented in [38]. The selection criteria involve requirements on muon candidates and conditions on the Z-boson kinematics, including constraints on transverse momentum balance and azimuthal separation. p. 4 The analysis considers three hard-process configurations: heavy-flavour production, light-flavour production, and inclusive production. p. 4

Kinematic Constraints for Emission

The kinematic constraints for a single-gluon emission off a quark with mass m are derived in appendix A. The lower bound on the emission rapidity is given by equation (A. p. 82). For the groomed radiator, an additional constraint from SoftDrop is imposed, which can be recast as equation (A. p. 89).

Dipole Calculation for the Soft Function

The calculation of dipoles to determine the global part of the soft function S requires considering various partonic channels, including bg → Z + b and jj → Z + b¯b. The contribution of dipoles to the differential distribution is given by equation (B. p. 35). This calculation involves changing variables and considering the quasi-collinear limit for small jet radius expansions. p. 7

Final Results Comparison

The final results are presented by comparing hadron-level resummed and matched predictions with fixed-order calculations at NLO accuracy, including non-perturbative corrections. The comparison shows good agreement with the data across all values of α, consistent with previous studies. p. 4 The study confirms that the presence of a peak-like structure in the first bin for groomed jets is reflected in the hadron-level distribution once non-perturbative effects are included. p. 0 The separation between heavy- and light-flavour jets depends on both angularity exponent and jet transverse momentum. p. 2 The study confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they gradually diminish at higher transverse momenta. The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive. The most striking difference between b-jet and light-jet spectra is the presence of a pronounced peak in the first bin for groomed jets. The study confirms that heavy-flavour jets at high transverse momentum constitute a pure sample of quark-initiated jets. The study provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The comparison with CMS data indicates that heavy-flavour contributions remain subleading in inclusive jet samples, and therefore do not significantly modify the overall description of the data. The framework developed here provides a consistent basis for studying heavy-flavour jet substructure in more differential or flavour-tagged measurements. The study confirms that mass effects are sizeable for smaller angular exponents and moderate transverse momenta, while they gradually diminish at higher transverse momenta. The study also confirms that SoftDrop grooming enhances sensitivity to the collinear region, retaining discriminating power even when ungroomed observables become less sensitive

References

The paper cites numerous references covering jet substructure, resummation techniques, and heavy-flavour physics. Key references include those on jet angularities, SoftDrop grooming, and mass effects in heavy-flavour jets, [35], [37], [44], [51], and papers discussing the dead-cone effect. p. 3 The work builds upon established methods for resummation and non-perturbative corrections in QCD. p. 2

Appendix Details

Appendix A derives kinematic constraints for a single-gluon emission off a quark with mass m, providing expressions for the radiators in equations (A.5) and (A.10). Appendix B details the dipole calculation for the soft function S, including parametrized momenta of hard QCD legs. p. 1 Appendix C presents a comparison of predictions with CMS data for untagged jets. p. 1 The paper also includes detailed tables and figures illustrating the migration matrices between parton and hadron levels. p. 0 The references list extensive literature on jet substructure, including works by Marzani, Larkoski, and others. p. 6 The paper also includes a comparison of NLL predictions with fixed-order calculations at NLO accuracy. p. 2 The work is supported by various funding sources including the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) and the European Union under the HORIZON program. The work acknowledges collaborators and financial support from various institutions. p. 1 The paper includes a detailed list of references covering topics such as PDF sets and matrix element generators. p. 7 The work is organized into several sections detailing the theoretical setup, particle-level predictions, and data comparison. p. 3 The paper presents a comprehensive phenomenological study of jet angularities for heavy-flavour jets in hadronic Z+jet production. p. 3 The results are presented for ungroomed and SoftDrop-groomed jets, incorporating finite quark-mass effects both in the resummation and fixed-order matching. p. 2 The study confirms that jet angularities are sensitive probes of heavyquark mass effects and dead-cone suppression of collinear radiation

[1] S. Marzani, G. p. 0 Soyez, and M. Spannowsky, Looking inside jets: an introduction to jet substructure and boosted-object phenomenology, vol. p. 1 958. Springer, 2019

[35] S. Caletti, O. Fedkevych, S. Marzani, D. p. 0 Reichelt, S. p. 0 p. 0 Schumann, G. p. 0 Soyez, and V. Theeuwes, Jet angularities in Z+jet production at the LHC

[37] D. Reichelt, S. Caletti, O. Fedkevych, S. Marzani, S. p. 0 Schumann, and G. p. 0 Soyez, Phenomenology of jet angularities at the LHC

[38] CMS Collaboration, A. Tumasyan et al., Study of quark and gluon jet substructure in Z+jet and dijet events from pp collisions

[41] M. Czakon, A. Mitov, and R. Poncelet, Infrared-safe flavoured anti-kT jets

[43] F. Caola, R. Grabarczyk, M. L. Hutt, G. P. Salam, L. Scyboz, and J. Thaler, Flavored jets with exact anti-kt kinematics and tests of infrared and collinear safety

[48] A. Ghira, S. Marzani, and G. p. 0 p. 0 Ridolfi, A consistent resummation of mass and soft logarithms in processes with heavy flavours

[55] F. Maltoni, M. Selvaggi, and J. Thaler, Exposing the dead cone effect with jet substructure techniques

[77] P. K. Dhani, O. Fedkevych, A. Ghira, S. Marzani, and G. Soyez, Heavy flavour jet substructure

[81] A. J. Larkoski, D Neill, and J Thaler, Jet Shapes with the Broadening Axis

[93] F Krauss, R Kuhn, and G Soff, AMEGIC++ 1.0: A Matrix element generator in C++

[114] A Buckley, P Ilten, D Konstantinov, L Lonnblad, J Monk, W Pokorski, T Przedzinski, and A Verbytskyi, The HepMC3 event record library for Monte Carlo event generators

[115] G. P. Salam, Towards Jetography

[117] A. L.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform NLL resummation of jet angularities for both ungroomed and groomed jets, including non-perturbative corrections via transfer matrices extracted from Sherpa simulations to yield final results at NLO plus NLL prime accuracy.

  2. Improved AI can calculate particle level Monte Carlo simulations using the Sherpa event generator framework to extract parton-to-hadron level transfer matrices differential in angularity observables and jet kinematics, accounting for migration effects between parton and hadron levels.

  3. Improved AI can perform a multiplicative matching procedure between resummed predictions and exact fixed order calculations at NLO accuracy, ensuring consistency by including the constant prefactor C(alpha s) to obtain the final matched distribution.

  4. Improved AI can compare theoretical predictions against CMS data for untagged jets across different angularity exponents alpha and jet transverse momenta slices, providing quantitative ratios to experimental measurements.

  5. Improved AI can distinguish between heavy-flavour and light-flavour jet spectra using fine binning in the intermediate transverse momentum slice, resolving the transition region where mass effects become significant.

Sources

Related papers