Observation of electroweak production of pairs of Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at 13 TeV

arXiv:2606.20558 · hep-ex · Submitted 2026-06-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Observation of electroweak production of pairs of Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at 13 TeV".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The first evidence of electroweak (EW) production of pairs of Z bosons in association with two jets (jj) in the final state ZZjj → llννjj, where l = e, µ, is reported by the CMS experiment.

Kai: This observation is significant because it provides a measurement of electroweak production cross section in agreement with the standard model prediction.

Mira: Signal Observation and Cross Section Measurement The analysis focuses on the VBS process with EW production of two Z bosons accompanied by two jets, using proton-proton (pp) collision data collected with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC with √s = 13 TeV during 2016–2018.

Kai: The selection criteria for candidate events include exactly two identified leptons of opposite sign and same flavor (OSSF), large missing transverse momentum (p miss T)

3: , and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass.

Paper summary: Kai: Thinking about the title again, "Observation of electroweak production of pairs of Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at thirteen TeV," it really highlights what this experiment was actually built to do <ref:2606.20558#pg1,Observation of electroweak production of pairs of Z bosons in proton-proton>. It's a direct observation of this specific interaction happening at that particular energy level.

Mira: And it confirms that the standard model’s description of how W and Z bosons scatter is correct when you look at these measured cross sections, especially when combined with other results they have from previous years.

Lev: It implies that for now, the Brout–Englert–Higgs mechanism is doing what we expect in these vector boson scattering processes without needing any immediate adjustments to the fundamental structure of the theory.

Kai: So, in simple terms, this paper confirms that when you smash protons together at thirteen TeV, you can see two Z bosons produced alongside two jets exactly how the standard model predicts it should <ref:2606.20558#pg1>.

Mira: The implication is that this channel is a solid piece of evidence for the electroweak sector of particle physics at this energy scale. It validates the framework we use to understand these heavy particles interacting.

Lev: For someone who only listens to this, it means that when you look at the data, it doesn't scream "new physics" yet for this specific channel; it fits neatly into the established picture of particle physics right now.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about finding evidence for two Z bosons being produced together in proton collisions at thirteen teraelectron volts, which is pretty fundamental stuff to look at.

Mira: Right, they're talking about this specific process where you get a pair of Z bosons alongside some jets. The authors are focusing on how these events look when you put them through their analysis pipeline.

Lev: From my side, I'm wondering what kind of detector setup they used to actually see these events clearly in the first place. It has to be a pretty complex reconstruction because you're looking for exactly those lepton signatures and that missing momentum.

Kai: It is complex, yeah. The fidelity of seeing those leptons and measuring that missing transverse momentum really depends on how well the calorimeter is calibrated at this energy level.

Mira: And what they did is compare their measured production rate against what the standard model predicts for electroweak physics in this channel. They found a cross section that lines up pretty well with what we expect from the standard model.

Lev: So, they got a measurement of zero point three seven plus or minus zero point one four minus negative zero point one two statistical and plus or minus zero point six systematic femtobarns for that cross section. That's the number they are reporting.

Kai: And that number matches the standard model prediction of zero point three nine plus or minus zero point six femtobarns. So, it fits within our current understanding, no major surprises there on the basic production rate itself.

Mira: But they also used this data to check for these anomalous quartic gauge couplings, which are interactions among four gauge bosons that we don't see in the standard model yet. They put limits on those BSM interactions based on this measurement.

Lev: Those limits are consistent with what other experiments have already found, which is good because it means no immediate need to rethink the entire theory of how these particles interact at this level.

Kai: So, for someone just listening, the main point is that they've confirmed a key electroweak process in proton collisions and it agrees with our established physics framework.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of confirmation for the electroweak sector of particle physics right now. But this doesn't mean we stop looking for things that might be slightly off from what we know.

Lev: We still need to push the limits on those anomalous couplings, even if this specific result looks clean and standard model compliant. That’s where the next set of measurements gets interesting for us.

European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN)

hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-06-18

Updated: 2026-11-04

Comments: Replaced with the published version. Added the journal reference and the DOI. All the figures and tables can be found at http://cms-results.web.cern.ch/cms-results/public-results/publications/SMP-23-001 (CMS Public Pages)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 137 (2026) 181801

DOI: 10.1103/jydv-n2js

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: The first evidence of electroweak (EW) production of pairs of Z bosons in association with two jets (jj) in the final state ZZjj → llννjj, where l = e, µ, is reported by the CMS experiment.

Key concepts

ZZjj Production
This refers to the specific physical process where two Z bosons are produced simultaneously in a proton-proton collision, along with two jets (particles resulting from quarks or gluons). The experiment looked for this specific signature to test electroweak theory.
Cross Section ($\sigma$)
The cross section is a measure of the probability that a specific interaction—in this case, producing ZZjj—will occur in a given volume of proton-proton collisions. The measured value was compared directly against the theoretical prediction from the Standard Model to check if nature's behavior matches established physics.
Anomalous Quartic Gauge Couplings (aQGCs)
These are deviations from Standard Model predictions concerning how four gauge bosons (like Z bosons) interact with each other. The analysis used this data to set limits on these potential 'beyond the Standard Model' interactions, checking for new physics.
Standard Model Prediction
This is the theoretical value calculated using the current best understanding of particle physics, which describes how particles like Z bosons should interact according to established laws. The experimental measurement was compared against this prediction to verify the consistency of our fundamental physical theory.

Terminology

Summary

The first evidence of electroweak (EW) production of pairs of Z bosons in association with two jets (jj) in the final state ZZjj → llννjj, where l = e, µ, is reported by the CMS experiment. p. 0

Where the paper says it

EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN) CERN-EP-2026-144 2026/06/19 CMS-SMP-23-001 Observation of electroweak production of pairs of Z bosons in proton-proton collisions at 13 TeV The CMS Collaboration* Abstract The first evidence of electroweak (EW) production of pairs of Z bosons in association with two jets (jj) in the final state ZZjj → ℓℓννjj, where ℓ = e, µ, is reported by the CMS experiment. The analysis is based on a data sample of proton-proton (pp) collisions at √ s = 13 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 138 fb−1 .

This observation is significant because it provides a measurement of electroweak production cross section in agreement with the standard model prediction. p. 7
Where the paper says it

1 standard deviations. The measured fiducial cross section is in agreement with the standard model predictions. p. 7

Where the paper says it

1 standard deviations. The measured fiducial cross section is in agreement with the standard model predictions.

Signal Observation and Cross Section Measurement

The analysis focuses on the VBS process with EW production of two Z bosons accompanied by two jets, using proton-proton (pp) collision data collected with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC with √s = 13 TeV during 2016–2018. The selection criteria for candidate events include exactly two identified leptons of opposite sign and same flavor (OSSF), large missing transverse momentum (p miss T) [3], and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass. p. 2

Where the paper says it

These results are combined with the results previously reported in the channel with four charged leptons [2] to determine the statistical significance of the measurement of the EW ZZ production. In the analysis presented here, we select candidate events with exactly two identified leptons (electrons or muons) of opposite sign and same flavor (OSSF), large missing transverse momentum (p miss T ) [3], and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass.

The EW production cross section in a fiducial volume is reported as σEW(pp → ZZjj → llννjj) = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Events are selected by requiring exactly two leptons of same flavor and opposite charge, large missing transverse momentum, and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass. The EW production cross section in a fiducial volume is σEW(pp → ZZjj → ℓℓννjj) = 0.

37+0.14 −0.12 (stat)+0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The EW production cross section in a fiducial volume is σEW(pp → ZZjj → ℓℓννjj) = 0. 12 (stat)+0.

06 −0.06 (syst) fb, which agrees with the standard model prediction of 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

12 (stat)+0. 06 (syst) fb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 0.

39 ± 0.06 fb.

Background Modeling and Discrimination

The analysis models signal and background events with Monte Carlo (MC) simulations, reweighted to account for known discrepancies between data and simulated events. The irreducible background is the QCD ZZ process, where α mEW and α nS represent the orders of the electroweak and strong couplings. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In the analysis presented here, we select candidate events with exactly two identified leptons (electrons or muons) of opposite sign and same flavor (OSSF), large missing transverse momentum (p miss T ) [3], and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass. Figure 1 shows examples of Feynman diagrams for the O(α 6 EW) VBS processes (EW ZZ), as well as the O(α 4 EWα 2 S ) quantum chromodynamics (QCD) induced process (QCD ZZ) that can produce the same final state and represents the irreducible background, where α m EW and α n S represent the orders of the electroweak and strong couplings, respectively.

Other important backgrounds include WZ and WW production with leptonic decays of the W and Z bosons, tt, and Drell–Yan (DY) production of Z + jet. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Figure 1 shows examples of Feynman diagrams for the O(α 6 EW) VBS processes (EW ZZ), as well as the O(α 4 EWα 2 S ) quantum chromodynamics (QCD) induced process (QCD ZZ) that can produce the same final state and represents the irreducible background, where α m EW and α n S represent the orders of the electroweak and strong couplings, respectively. The other important backgrounds are WZ and WW production with leptonic decays of the W and Z bosons, tt, and Drell–Yan (DY) production of Z + jet.

To enhance the separation of the rare EW ZZ signal from backgrounds, a multivariate discriminator based on a graph neural network (GNN) is employed. p. 4
Where the paper says it

We employ a control sample of single-photon events (γ + jets) in data as a proxy for Z + jets events, as described in the End Matter. To further enhance the separation of the rare EW ZZ signal from backgrounds, we employ a multivariate discriminator based on a graph neural network (GNN) [38], which operates on a graph-structured representation of the data.

Systematic Uncertainties and Combination

Systematic uncertainties are incorporated as nuisance parameters in the likelihood fit, accounting for both normalization and shape effects on the signal and background predictions. The dominant systematic uncertainties arise from theoretical modeling, in particular renormalization and factorization scale variations and PDFs, as well as experimental effects related to the jet energy scale (JES) and resolution (JER). p. 5

Where the paper says it

The estimation of the contributions of individual sources of systematic uncertainty are described in more detail in the End Matter. The dominant systematic uncertainties arise from theoretical modeling, in particular renormalization and factorization scale variations and PDFs, as well as experimental effects related to the jet energy scale (JES) and resolution (JER).

A combination with the previously reported result from the ZZ decay channel with four charged leptons yields an observed (expected) significance of 5. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Limits on anomalous quartic gauge couplings are derived in terms of dimension-8 effective field theory operators. A combination with the previously reported result from the ZZ decay channel with four charged leptons yields an observed (expected) significance of 5.

0 (4.5) standard deviations for the EW production of Z boson pairs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

A combination with the previously reported result from the ZZ decay channel with four charged leptons yields an observed (expected) significance of 5. 5) standard deviations for the EW production of Z boson pairs.

Anomalous Physics Probing

The analysis uses this data sample to probe anomalous quartic gauge couplings (aQGCs) [4], which correspond to beyond-the-SM (BSM) interactions among four gauge bosons. Possible deviations from the SM are parameterized using dimension-8 operators in the SM effective field theory (SMEFT) framework [5, 6]. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Such effects can modify the production of ZZ pairs in VBS processes. In this analysis, possible deviations from the SM are parameterized using dimension-8 operators in the SM effective field theory (SMEFT) framework [5, 6].

Limits on each operator are obtained by varying one coefficient at a time, while fixing all other coefficients to zero. p. 7
Where the paper says it

We fit using a maximum likelihood estimator to derive two-sided 95% confidence level (CL) intervals on the couplings f i/Λ4 of dimension-8 operators describing anomalous quartic gauge interactions, where f i are dimensionless Wilson coefficients and Λ denotes the energy scale of new physics in the effective field theory. Limits on each operator are obtained by varying one coefficient at a time, while fixing all other coefficients to zero.

The limits on these anomalous quartic gauge couplings are consistent with and generally comparable to previous aQGC measurements reported by CMS [9, 45–49]. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The expected and observed limits at 95% CL obtained from the likelihood fits are shown in Fig. These limits are consistent with and generally comparable to previous aQGC measurements reported by CMS [9, 45–49].

Conclusion on Gauge Boson Production

With the addition of this result, the CMS experiment has observed EW production of all pairs of massive gauge bosons: WW (both same-sign and opposite-sign), WZ, and ZZ. The observed (expected) significance for the combination of channels is 5. p. 6

Where the paper says it

5) standard deviations. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The observed (expected) significance of the signal is 3. 8) standard deviations.

The observed and expected significances of the individual channels and their combination are summarized in Table 2.

0 (4.5) standard deviations. The measured fiducial cross section is in agreement with the standard model predictions.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform high-precision searches for anomalous quartic gauge couplings by fitting dimension-8 effective field theory operators to data distributions, as described in Figure 3 (right). This allows the system to derive limits on coupling coefficients f i/Lambda4 based on observed and expected limits at 95% CL.

  2. The system can utilize a graph neural network (GNN) for event discrimination, using a graph-structured representation of the data where individual physics objects are nodes and pairwise relationships are edges. This enables the AI to learn subtle differences between signal and background by processing inputs like pT, eta, and azimuthal angle phi of leptons and jets.

  3. The analysis pipeline can incorporate a combination of measurements from different channels, such as the combination with the previously reported result from the ZZ decay channel with four charged leptons, to determine a higher statistical significance for EW production. This combined approach yields an observed (expected) significance of 5.0 (4.5) standard deviations for EW production of Z boson pairs.

  4. The system can implement a flexible background estimation strategy using control regions, such as the 3l CR, which is dominated by WZ events, to constrain background contributions in the signal region. This involves defining control regions orthogonal to the signal region to assess background contributions and using maximum likelihood fits incorporating correlations among systematic uncertainties.

  5. The system can incorporate detailed uncertainty modeling by treating systematic uncertainties as nuisance parameters with probability density functions [51]. This allows for the propagation of variations, including those from renormalization and factorization scale variations and PDFs, to estimate the impact on final yields.

Abstract

The first evidence of electroweak (EW) production of pairs of Z bosons in association with two jets (jj) in the final state ZZjj to νν jj, where = e, μ, is reported by the CMS experiment. The analysis is based on a data sample of proton-proton (pp) collisions at sqrt s = 13 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 138 fb-1. Events are selected by requiring exactly two leptons of same flavor and opposite charge, large missing transverse momentum, and two jets with a large rapidity separation and large invariant mass. The EW production cross section in a fiducial volume is σ EW (pp to ZZjj to νν jj) = 0.37+0.14-0.12 (stat)+0.06-0.06 (syst) fb, in agreement with the standard model prediction of 0.39 plus or minus 0.06 fb. The observed (expected) significance of the signal is 3.1 (2.8) standard deviations. Limits on anomalous quartic gauge couplings are derived in terms of dimension-8 effective field theory operators. A combination with the previously reported result from the ZZ decay channel with four charged leptons yields an observed (expected) significance of 5.0 (4.5) standard deviations for the EW production of Z boson pairs.

Sources

Related papers