Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals

arXiv:2606.15150 · gr-qc, astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2026-06-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology. The day in general relativity and quantum cosmology.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, and this study investigates how neglecting eccentric corrections in waveform models can lead to misinterpretations of near-extremally spinning components The paper demonstrates that binaries retaining significant eccentricity up to merger can be misinterpreted as near-extremally spinning when non-circular corrections are neglected Eccentricity in Disguise The research focuses on quantifying the extent to which eccentric signals can be misidentified as noneccentric by comparing available numerical relativity waveforms against a quasi-spherical model.

Kai: The authors define a measure of statistical consequence of an incorrect signal hypothesis, denoted as the reduction in maximum log-likelihood ∆ ln L ≡ ln Lˆ(λ) − ln Lmax(θ) relative to the model This metric relates this reduction to faithfulness (Apostolatos 1995), F = max Λ (s h(θ)) p (s s) (h h).

Mira: Method and Dataset Construction To assess when eccentric signals can be misidentified as quasicircular in high-mass BBH systems, the researchers constructed ∼1000 signals by rescaling 128 eccentric NR waveforms from the ICCUB catalogue to detector-frame total masses in the range 200–400 M⊙.

Kai: They computed extrinsic-parameter maximised faithfulness F−θext defined in Eq.

Paper summary: Lev: So, looking at the paper "Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals", the authors are essentially saying that neglecting eccentricity corrections in waveform models can lead to misinterpretations of near-extremally spinning components.

Kai: They show how binaries retaining significant eccentricity up to merger can be misinterpreted as near-extremally spinning when non-circular corrections are neglected.

Mira: The implication is that if you’re analyzing gravitational wave data, you need to be careful about the assumptions you make about the binary’s shape, especially for systems like GW231123 which has a total mass around two hundred fifty solar masses.

Lev: They conclude that at signals with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than twenty, it is possible to distinguish between quasi-spherical and eccentric signal hypotheses when you use appropriate waveform models.

Kai: They ultimately say that highly eccentric merger scenarios with initial eccentricity e zero greater than zero point five are disfavored relative to quasi-spherical interpretations, which provide a better overall description of GW231123.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion, the paper is titled "Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals." It’s about how we can be tricked by looking at gravitational wave data if we ignore the shape of the binary.

Mira: Exactly. They are looking at a specific signal, GW231123, which is a merger of two black holes with a total mass around two hundred fifty solar masses. The core idea is that if you don't account for eccentricity—if you treat it like the orbit is perfectly round—you can mistake an eccentric system for one where the components are spinning near their absolute limit.

Lev: From my side, this means we’re talking about phase and amplitude changes accumulating over time in a way that our standard models don't capture if they are too simple. It’s about those non-circular corrections being missing from the math.

Kai: So, what does it actually mean for us out there? If we miss this eccentricity, we might misinterpret the spin of those black holes significantly.

Mira: It suggests that when you analyze a signal like GW231123, you can’t just rely on one type of model. You need to check if the data fits a circular one or an eccentric one.

Lev: The paper says they found that at signal-to-noise ratios greater than twenty, we can actually tell the difference between the two hypotheses using certain diagnostics and models.

Kai: So, it’s not a total giveaway, but it’s not impossible either. It depends on how good your waveform model is.

Mira: Right. And they found that even if you have a decent model, highly eccentric scenarios with an initial eccentricity e zero greater than zero point five are actually less likely compared to the circular ones that the data best fit.

Lev: That’s a strong constraint on what we expect from these mergers. It pushes us toward simpler descriptions unless the data strongly demands that eccentricity.

Koustav Chandra, Johann Fernandes, Akshita Mittal, Gregorio Carullo

Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics · Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos, Penn State University · Indian Institute of Technology Bombay · Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI) · INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso · School of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Gravitational Wave Astronomy, University of Birmingham

gr-qc, astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2026-06-13

Updated: 2026-06-13

Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Mon Not R Astron Soc (2026)

DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stag1934

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙…

Key concepts

Eccentricity in Disguise
This refers to the phenomenon where a signal from a binary system that is actually orbiting eccentrically (not perfectly circular) looks very similar to one that is perfectly circular, especially when using simplified waveform models. The paper quantifies how much this disguise can mislead analysis.
Reduction in Maximum Log-Likelihood ($\Delta \ln L$)
This metric measures the statistical consequence of assuming an incorrect signal hypothesis. It compares the likelihood of the true eccentric signal against a simpler, incorrect model, helping researchers determine how much evidence is lost when eccentricity is ignored.
Faithfulness ($F$)
Faithfulness is a measure related to how well a physical system (like an eccentric binary) matches its theoretical description. A higher faithfulness score indicates that the signal's features align more closely with the underlying physics, helping distinguish true signals from model artifacts.

Terminology

Summary

GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, and this study investigates how neglecting eccentric corrections in waveform models can lead to misinterpretations of near-extremally spinning components The paper demonstrates that binaries retaining significant eccentricity up to merger can be misinterpreted as near-extremally spinning when non-circular corrections are neglected

Eccentricity in Disguise

The research focuses on quantifying the extent to which eccentric signals can be misidentified as noneccentric by comparing available numerical relativity waveforms against a quasi-spherical model. The authors define a measure of statistical consequence of an incorrect signal hypothesis, denoted as the reduction in maximum log-likelihood ∆ ln L ≡ ln Lˆ(λ) − ln Lmax(θ) relative to the model This metric relates this reduction to faithfulness (Apostolatos 1995), F = max Λ (s h(θ)) p (s s) (h h). p. 2

Where the paper says it

2017; Benetti et al. A convenient measure of the statistical consequence of an incorrect signal hypothesis is the reduction in the maximum log-likelihood ∆ ln L ≡ ln Lˆ(λ) − ln Lmax(θ) relative to the model 2 .

Method and Dataset Construction

To assess when eccentric signals can be misidentified as quasicircular in high-mass BBH systems, the researchers constructed ∼1000 signals by rescaling 128 eccentric NR waveforms from the ICCUB catalogue to detector-frame total masses in the range 200–400 M⊙. They computed extrinsic-parameter maximised faithfulness F−θext defined in Eq. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Throughout, we construct our NR waveforms with radiation multipoles (ℓ, m) = {(2, ±2),(2±1),(2, 0),(3±3),(3, ±2),(4, ±4),(4±3)}, thereby neglecting subdominant modes that will contribute negligibly. For each signal, we compute the extrinsic-parametermaximised faithfulness F−θext defined in Eq.

(1), where intrinsic parameters are held fixed to isolate discrepancies arising from physical effects absent in the waveform model. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Throughout, all intrinsic binary parameters shared by the signal and template are held fixed. This choice isolates discrepancies arising from physical effects absent in the waveform model, so the resulting quantity should be interpreted as a waveform-modelling measure of the signal-template discrepancy.

Results of Misidentification

The dominant trend observed is the expected monotonic decrease in F¯−θext with increasing total mass, indicating that it becomes progressively difficult to distinguish an eccentric signal from non-eccentric ones. At fixed total mass, increasing χeff generally leads to smaller unfaithfulness values, although this trend breaks down for MT ≥ 350M⊙. p. 3

Where the paper says it

2025)—these features are expected to be comparatively difficult to observe at current SNR. At fixed total mass, increasing χeff generally leads to smaller unfaithfulness values, although this trend breaks down for MT ≥ 350M⊙.

The authors find that short-duration signals from eccentric binaries with modest component spins can be misinterpreted as originating from quasi-spherical systems with large in-plane spins χ1 ≳ 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We find that short-duration signals from eccentric binaries with modest component spins aligned with the orbital angular momentum (χ1,2 ≲ 0. 5) can be misinterpreted as originating from quasi-spherical systems with large in-plane spins (χ1 ≳ 0.

8 at 90% credibility. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Remarkably, under standard priors, the system features among the fastest-spinning binary components confidently measured in binary mergers, χ1,2 ≳ 0. 7 at 90% one-dimensional credibility, according to the most accurate model employed.

Astrophysical Consequences of Incorrect Modeling

The paper quantifies the bias through two complementary approaches: (1) a full frequency-domain Bayesian inference with a quasi-spherical BBH waveform model, and (2) a targeted time-domain post-peak ringdown analysis using multiple Kerr quasinormal modes combinations. Full inference is susceptible to any eccentricity-induced phase and amplitude modulations accumulated over the entire waveform and to the lack of noncircular calibration in the merger-ringdown sector. p. 4

Where the paper says it

These two analyses are complementary because they are sensitive to different aspects of the signal. The full inference is susceptible to any eccentricity-induced phase and amplitude modulations accumulated over the entire waveform and to the lack of noncircular calibration in the merger-ringdown sector.

Conclusion

The analysis shows that at SNRs ≳ 20, it is possible to distinguish between quasi-spherical and eccentric signal hypotheses for GW231123 using indistinguishability criteria and model selection diagnostics when appropriate waveform models are employed. Ultimately, highly eccentric (e0 ≳ 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

1: eccentric features in the signal can be partially absorbed by correlated shifts in the quasi-spherical parameter space. Although the detailed features of the posteriors vary across catalogues, reflecting differences in eccentricity definitions, waveform construction, and numerical systematics, the qualitative conclusion remains unchanged: for short-lived, high-mass signals, quasi-spherical waveform models can incorrectly infer high spin components, especially when the true signal is highly eccentric.

5) merger scenarios are disfavoured relative to quasi-spherical interpretations, which provide a better overall description of GW231123. p. 8
Where the paper says it

However, better IMR models or analysis methodologies will be required to ascertain the correct interpretation of GW231123 data, and the most conservative description remains in agreement with NRSur7dq4. 2 On the exceptionality of the GW231123 signal As a final check, we assess how unusual GW231123 is relative to the observed BBH population by reanalysing the data using the NRSur7dq4 waveform model using two different non-eccentric priors: (1) a population-agnostic prior with choices similar to LVK.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Rossella Gamba and Matthew Mould for helpful comments and suggestions. The authors acknowledge the use of an OpenAI language model (ChatGPT) for assistance in improving the presentation of figures. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In this regime, we find that the preferred modes are typically the {(221),(210)}, in agreement with theoretical expectations (Cheung et al. Still, the evidence for these additional modes never reaches statistical significance, indicating that the contributions beyond the fundamental mode are negligible and that adding them to the model incurs an Ockham penalty without improving the fit.

The research has made use of data obtained from the Gravitational Wave Open Science Center (gwosc. p. 0
Where the paper says it

3 Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals Koustav Chandra1,2 ⋆ Johann Fernandes3 , Akshita Mittal4,5 Gregorio Carullo6 1 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany 2 Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos, Department of Physics, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA 3 Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Mumbai-400076, India 4 Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI), I-67100 L’Aquila, Italy 5 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, I-67100 Assergi, Italy 6 School of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Gravitational Wave Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, United Kingdom 16 June 2026 ABSTRACT GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, the largest ever detected by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra Collaboration.

org), a service of the LIGO Scientific Collaboration, the Virgo Collaboration, and KAGRA. p. 0
Where the paper says it

3 Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals Koustav Chandra1,2 ⋆ Johann Fernandes3 , Akshita Mittal4,5 Gregorio Carullo6 1 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany 2 Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos, Department of Physics, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA 3 Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Mumbai-400076, India 4 Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI), I-67100 L’Aquila, Italy 5 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, I-67100 Assergi, Italy 6 School of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Gravitational Wave Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, United Kingdom 16 June 2026 ABSTRACT GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, the largest ever detected by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra Collaboration.

This material is based upon work supported by NSF’s LIGO Laboratory, a major facility fully funded by the National Science Foundation, together with support from the Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC) of the United Kingdom, the Max Planck Society (MPS), and the State of Niedersachsen/Germany for the construction of Advanced LIGO and the construction and operation of the GEO600 detector. p. 0
Where the paper says it

3 Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals Koustav Chandra1,2 ⋆ Johann Fernandes3 , Akshita Mittal4,5 Gregorio Carullo6 1 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany 2 Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos, Department of Physics, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA 3 Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Mumbai-400076, India 4 Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI), I-67100 L’Aquila, Italy 5 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, I-67100 Assergi, Italy 6 School of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Gravitational Wave Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, United Kingdom 16 June 2026 ABSTRACT GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, the largest ever detected by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra Collaboration.

Additional support for Advanced LIGO was provided by the Australian Research Council. p. 0
Where the paper says it

2025b) are consistent with mergers of two black holes (BHs), resulting in a remnant BH with mass Mf > 100 M⊙. Their properties place the progenitor binary components in the tail of the mass distribution of the binary black hole (BBH) population observed by the Advanced LIGO–Virgo–Kagra network (Aasi et al.

Data Availability Statement

The NR waveforms analysed in this work are publicly available through the SXS, RIT, and ICCUB waveform catalogues. The gravitational-wave strain data for GW231123 used in this study are available through the Gravitational Wave Open Science Centre (Abac et al. p. 0

Where the paper says it

3 Eccentricity in Disguise? Insights from GW231123 and Numerically Simulated Binary Black Hole Merger Signals Koustav Chandra1,2 ⋆ Johann Fernandes3 , Akshita Mittal4,5 Gregorio Carullo6 1 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), Am M¨uhlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam, Germany 2 Institute for Gravitation & the Cosmos, Department of Physics, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA 3 Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay, Mumbai-400076, India 4 Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI), I-67100 L’Aquila, Italy 5 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, I-67100 Assergi, Italy 6 School of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Gravitational Wave Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, United Kingdom 16 June 2026 ABSTRACT GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass ∼ 250M⊙, the largest ever detected by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra Collaboration.

2026) and can be accessed here. p. 0
Where the paper says it

MNRAS 000, 000–000 (0000) Preprint 16 June 2026 Compiled using MNRAS LATEX style file v3. 3 Eccentricity in Disguise?

Most of the analysis scripts and code used to generate the figures in this work are available on GitHub. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In the following, before turning to full parameter estimation, we will use this metric to quantify the level of agreement between the models we employ and the numerical waveforms. 2 Throughout this work, ln L or “log-likelihood” is used as shorthand for the log-likelihood ratio between the signal and noise hypotheses.

Others will be made available on reasonable request. p. 6
Where the paper says it

The NR simulation ICCUB:0001 is analysed using the quasi-spherical NRSur7dq4 waveform model in zero noise. Despite providing a reasonable fit around merger, the recovered waveform fails to reproduce the post-peak structure of the NR signal.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve parameter estimation by incorporating eccentricity into waveform models to prevent misidentification of eccentric signals as quasi-spherical systems, as Numerically simulated eccentric BBH signals with modest component spins can be recovered as quasi-spherical systems with large in-plane spin components, as missing eccentric features are partially absorbed.

  2. Enhance model selection capabilities by using model selection diagnostics like the Akaike information criterion to decisively disfavour the quasi-spherical hypothesis for short-lived, high-mass signals, as for short-lived, high-mass signals, quasi-spherical waveform models can incorrectly infer high spin components.

  3. Develop a robust ringdown analysis that uses an unbiased estimate of the signal peak to recover remnant properties consistent with Kerr expectations even when using non-eccentric templates, as post-peak analyses at sufficiently late times recover remnant parameters consistent with Kerr expectations, as the latetime ringdown is mainly determined by the remnant’s mass and spin.

  4. Improve population modeling accuracy by using empirically obtained population priors instead of population-agnostic priors for tail events like GW231123, as the population-informed prior favours an even larger total mass and is in tension with the conclusions of Mandel (2026), who rely on prior reweighting.

  5. Implement a method to distinguish between eccentric and quasi-spherical hypotheses using model selection diagnostics when Signal-to-Noise Ratios are greater than 20, as "for signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) >= 20, model-selection diagnostics can confidently distinguish between eccentric and quasi-spherical hypotheses."

Abstract

GW231123 is a gravitational-wave signal originating from the merger of a black hole binary with total mass about 250 M, the largest ever detected by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra Collaboration. Remarkably, under standard priors, the system features among the fastest-spinning binary components confidently measured in binary mergers, χ 1,2 0.7 at 90% one-dimensional credibility, according to the most accurate model employed. As typical binary mergers result in remnants with χ about 0.7, such spin values are challenging to obtain even from previous (hierarchical) mergers. These inferred properties rely on waveform models lacking eccentric corrections in the merger-ringdown stage. Here, we show that binaries retaining significant eccentricity up to merger can be misinterpreted as near-extremally spinning when non-circular corrections are neglected. Binary-agnostic ringdown analysis instead provides unbiased estimates of the remnant properties, provided that a robust estimate of the signal peak can be obtained. We re-analyse GW231123 using available eccentric numerical-relativity catalogues, finding that although eccentric templates can provide a good fit to the data, quasi-spherical templates are still favoured. Ringdown analyses confirm a secondary likelihood peak correlated with large eccentricity values, but improved eccentric models will be required to assess the reliability of this interpretation. Finally, analysing GW231123 under population-informed parametric priors confirms the exceptional nature of this event within the current black hole binary population.

Sources

Related papers