When and how particles are removed by drops
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "When and how particles are removed by drops".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Particulate contaminants decrease the power output of solar panels, the transparency of windows, and are detrimental to microelectronics, where even a single particle can induce a short circuit.
Kai: Here, by combining lattice Boltzmann simulations and confocal microscopy experiments, we show that at least six different scenarios arise from the complex interplay between capillary and friction forces when a drop collides with a particle on a surface.
Mira: The Core Problem Particulate contaminants pose significant issues across various domains, from reducing power output in photovoltaic panels to causing short circuits in microelectronics.
Kai: Existing cleaning strategies are often chemically harmful, energy-intensive, or impractical for large areas.
Paper summary: Mira: To wrap up with the title of "When and how particles are removed by drops", it’s clear the paper is moving away from just describing particle removal to providing a predictive framework for it. They're showing that we can use this dimensionless parameter C to predict capture versus deposition based on particle and surface properties.
Kai: And I think the authors succeeded in combining lattice Boltzmann simulations with confocal microscopy experiments to show these six different scenarios arising from the interaction of capillary and friction forces. That’s a pretty concrete demonstration of how these forces are coupled.
Lev: From an engineering view, it's valuable because it gives us a clear criterion, C greater than one, to check before we invest resources into surface treatments based on this mechanism. It cuts down on unnecessary testing of surfaces that probably won't work well.
Mira: The implication for the field is that surface design shouldn't just be about making things super hydrophobic; it has to include minimizing particle–surface friction as a crucial design goal for effective self-cleaning surfaces.
Kai: It’s about realizing that the optimal surface contact angle isn't just one fixed number; it changes depending on how much friction there is and how hard the particle is pressing against the surface. That level of detail is what makes this work important for practical applications like those in microelectronics or solar panels.
Lev: It’s a nice piece of theoretical modeling that helps us understand the physical constraints involved, which is always useful when we are trying to design something that actually runs on real hardware with limited precision.
Mira: So, the paper gives us a way to predict whether a surface will successfully remove contaminants by summarizing how capillary and friction forces balance out in this specific collision event. It connects fundamental fluid dynamics right down to the practical problem of keeping surfaces clean.
Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about figuring out when and how raindrops actually remove particles from surfaces like solar panels or microchips, which we call drops that are cleaning things up naturally.
Mira: Right, it’s called "When and how particles are removed by drops." The authors did this by combining computer simulations with actual microscope experiments to see the complex forces at play when a liquid drop hits a tiny particle on a surface.
Lev: It shows six different ways this collision can go, some resulting in the particle sticking to the surface and some where it gets deposited somewhere else.
Kai: They developed this dimensionless number, called C, which helps predict whether capture happens or if the particle just gets stuck in a non-ideal way based on how slippery the drop and surface are.
Mira: The core idea is that you need to balance these capillary forces against friction forces, and that parameter C tells you if the force pulling it toward the particle wins over the drag.
Lev: For us in error correction, knowing this means we can start thinking about designing surfaces where this capture condition C greater than one is always met for whatever contaminants we expect.
Kai: So what does this mean for the people who build these panels and chips? It suggests a way to design a surface that cleans itself without needing harsh chemicals or energy-heavy cleaning processes.
Mira: Exactly, it points toward designing surfaces that are naturally easy to clean by simply letting water do the work, provided you get the balance of forces right.
Lev: The real challenge is making sure this works reliably on a real chip or a massive solar array where those microscopic details matter so much for performance.
Kai: But they found that the optimal surface angle isn't just one fixed number; it depends on how much friction there is between the particle and the surface itself, which adds another layer of complexity to the design.
Mira: It’s about maximizing that capture parameter C by finding a specific contact angle that works for both the particle interaction and its own sliding behavior across the surface.
Lev: If we can nail that contact angle optimization, it means we move from guessing surface properties to calculating exactly what geometry you need to achieve reliable self-cleaning.
Kai: It’s a lot of physics packed into this little study, and they gave us the tools to predict particle removal without needing a full simulation every time.
Mira: This gives us a solid framework for understanding the physics behind why some surfaces clean themselves better than others, connecting fluid dynamics directly to material science.
Lev: It’s a good starting point for our next steps in figuring out how this translates into something we can actually manufacture and test on real hardware with all its imperfections.
Institute for Multiscale Thermofluids, School of Engineering, University of Edinburgh · Physics at Interfaces group, Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research
cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, physics.flu-dyn
Submitted: 2026-06-10
Updated: 2026-09-17
Journal ref: Science Advances 12,eaef8434(2026)
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: Particulate contaminants decrease the power output of solar panels, the transparency of windows, and are detrimental to microelectronics, where even a single particle can induce a short circuit.
Key concepts
- Capillary Force (Fγ)
- This force arises from the deformation of the liquid-air interface when a drop touches a particle. It has both horizontal and vertical components. The horizontal component is key for driving particles away, while the normal component can sometimes hinder removal, depending on how the particle and surface are wetted.
- Friction Force (µF)
- This force opposes motion between the particle and the surface. In this context, it represents resistance to sliding. The removal of a particle depends on whether the capillary force is strong enough to overcome this friction, specifically when the horizontal component of the capillary force exceeds a frictional threshold.
- Capillary Capture Parameter (C)
- This dimensionless parameter is used to predict particle removal. It compares the combined effects of capillary and friction forces against a frictional term involving particle properties. A value greater than 1 suggests that the capillary force can successfully overcome friction, leading to particle capture.
- Surface Wettability/Contact Angle
- This describes how water interacts with the surface, determined by the contact angle. The optimal surface for easy cleaning is one that maximizes the capillary capture parameter. This often means designing a surface that is sufficiently hydrophobic so the drop maintains its shape rather than spreading out.
Terminology
Summary
Particulate contaminants decrease the power output of solar panels, the transparency of windows, and are detrimental to microelectronics, where even a single particle can induce a short circuit. p. 1 Abstract
Particulate contaminants decrease the power output of solar panels, the transparency of
windows, and are detrimental to microelectronics, where even a single particle can induce a
short circuit. Despite significant research on particle adhesion and self-cleaning, it remains
unclear when and how a drop can remove a particle from a surface, thus efficiently cleaning
the surface. Despite significant research on particle adhesion and self-cleaning, it remains
unclear when and how a drop can remove a particle from a surface, thus efficiently cleaning
the surface. Here, by combining lattice Boltzmann simulations and confocal microscopy
experiments, we show that at least six different scenarios arise from the complex interplay
between capillary and friction forces when a drop collides with a particle on a surface.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Core Problem
Particulate contaminants pose significant issues across various domains, from reducing power output in photovoltaic panels to causing short circuits in microelectronics. Existing cleaning strategies are often chemically harmful, energy-intensive, or impractical for large areas. p. 2 Existing strategies for cleaning surfaces include applying liquids containing chemical detergents, mechanical wiping, applying adhesive peel-off tapes, vacuuming, or repelling particles using electric fields (6–11). However, these approaches can be chemically harmful,
mechanically damaging, energy-intensive, costly, or impractical over large areas. However, these approaches can be chemically harmful,
mechanically damaging, energy-intensive, costly, or impractical over large areas. In contrast, a promising strategy is to develop surfaces that are inherently easy to clean, so that
particles are removed naturally by raindrops sliding across the surface.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Mechanisms of Particle Removal
The removal process is governed by a coupled capillary–frictional mechanism. When a drop encounters a particle, the liquid–air interface deforms and exerts a capillary force Fγ ∼ γRp on the particle. p. 2 Drops offer an effective way to remove particles due to capillarity. When a drop encounters
a particle on a surface, the liquid–air interface deforms and exerts a capillary force Fγ ∼ γRp
3 Here, by combining lattice Boltzmann simulations and confocal microscopy
experiments, we show that at least six different scenarios arise from the complex interplay
between capillary and friction forces when a drop collides with a particle on a surface. Notably, the capillary force plays a dual role in particle removal: while its tangential component
always drives removal, its normal component can also hinder it. A particle that is eventually
left behind can also travel (4) inside or (5) to the side of the drop but then detach from the
drop, or it can (6) remain in a water film behind the drop. We show that the magnitude of the capillary force is primarily determined by the particle wettability, but its orientation depends on both the particle wettability and the surface
wettability.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Framework for Prediction
To predict whether a particle can be captured, a dimensionless capillary capture parameter is introduced which successfully describes particle removal across a broad range of particle and surface properties. This parameter is defined as C = max(Fxγ + µFzγ) / (µFp) and indicates whether the capillary force can overcome the friction force, with capture expected when C > 1. p. 4 In particular, the vertical component of the capillary force has a dual role: it
can lift the particle and reduce friction, promoting removal, or press the particle against
the substrate and increase friction, preventing removal. To predict whether a particle can
be captured, we introduce a dimensionless capillary capture parameter that successfully describes particle removal across a broad range of particle and surface properties. 1 and 2, we obtain the following criterion for a successful capture:
F
x
γ > µ(Fp − F
z
γ
). (3)
Equation 3 highlights that the horizontal force component F
x
γ plays a direct role in overcoming the friction force.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Design Implications
The results reveal previously underappreciated strategies for designing easy-to-clean surfaces, suggesting that the surface needs to be sufficiently hydrophobic so that the receding side of the drop maintains its shape rather than elongating into a residual liquid film. Crucially, it is also important to minimize particle–surface friction. p. 4 The surface needs to be sufficiently hydrophobic so that the receding side of the drop maintains
its shape rather than elongating into a residual liquid film. However, rather than only
maximizing surface hydrophobicity, it is crucial to also minimize particle–surface friction. We introduce a dimensionless capillary capture parameter that successfully predicts particle removal across a wide
range of particle and surface properties. Our results reveal that the design of easy-to-clean
surfaces should not focus only on maximizing hydrophobicity, but also on minimizing the
particle–surface friction.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Validation
Experiments involving varied particle and surface wettabilities reveal six collision scenarios, categorized into capture (first three scenarios) and deposition (last three scenarios). The phase diagram analysis shows that the main scenario leading to successful capture corresponds to when the particle enters the drop and remains attached at the rear (Fig. p. 6 The particle stayed at the drop–air interface, moved around the drop perimeter, and
remained attached at the rear (Fig. The particle stayed at the drop–air interface, but unlike the above scenario, it traveled
under the drop rather than on the side to reach the rear (Fig. Our
numerical method allows us to control all these parameters independently, providing insight
into how each parameter affects the collision scenario. In the simulations, we moved the drop by directly applying a force to it.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Dimensionless Capillary Capture Parameter (Equation 5) can be used to efficiently predict particle removal outcomes by calculating C = max(Fxγ + µFzγ) / (µFp). This parameter allows for rapid prediction of which collision scenario will occur without needing full, computationally expensive three-dimensional simulations.
-
The model can predict the optimal surface contact angle for easy-to-clean surfaces, identifying that it is a function of both the friction coefficient and the normal contact force between the particle and surface. This shifts design focus beyond just maximizing hydrophobicity to finding a balance that maximizes C while minimizing particle-surface friction (µ).
-
The system can predict whether a particle is captured by comparing Fxγ to the total resistive force Ff, where Ff is related by Eq 2: Ff = µ(Fp − Fzγ). This allows for the prediction of capture versus deposition scenarios based on the vertical component of the capillary force (Fzγ).
Abstract
Particulate contaminants decrease the power output of solar panels, the transparency of windows, and are detrimental to microelectronics, where even a single particle can induce a short circuit. Despite significant research on particle adhesion and self-cleaning, it remains unclear when and how a drop can remove a particle from a surface, thus efficiently cleaning the surface. Here, by combining lattice Boltzmann simulations and confocal microscopy experiments, we show that at least six different scenarios arise from the complex interplay between capillary and friction forces when a drop collides with a particle on a surface. Notably, the capillary force plays a dual role in particle removal: while its tangential component always drives removal, its normal component can also hinder it. We introduce a dimensionless capillary capture parameter that successfully predicts particle removal across a wide range of particle and surface properties. Our results reveal that the design of easy-to-clean surfaces should not focus only on maximizing hydrophobicity, but also on minimizing the particle-surface friction.
Related papers
- Coarse-graining dense, deformable active particles
- Three-body corrections to the Brownian viscosity of hard spheres without hydrodynamic interactions
- Thin active nematohydrodynamic layers: asymptotic theories and instabilities
- Origins of suppressed self-diffusion of nanoscale constituents of a complex liquid
- Soft material mechanical property degradation at high strain rates
- Avalanche criticality emerges by thermal fluctuation in a quiescent glass