Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations describes a data-driven method to calibrate the relative polarisation angle between CMB experiments using cross-correlations of observations over a common sky region Unlike standard self-calibration approaches, this method does not assume vanishing isotropic cosmic birefringence or primordial EB correlations when estimating the relative misalignment angle, and therefore preserves sensitivity to parity-violating physics.
Vera: As a proof of concept, it forecasts the performance of this method using the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs) as a calibrated reference.
Jocelyn: The Problem of Miscalibration Accurate recovery of the CMB E- and B-mode signals requires precise knowledge of the instrument’s polarisation orientation.
Vera: A small miscalibration in the polarimeter orientation rotates the measured polarisation basis and induces leakage from E- to B-modes.
Title and authors: Vera: Okay, let’s talk about who wrote this and what they’re calling this work, "Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations." The authors are Claire Rigouzzo, Eugene Lim, Susanna Azzoni, and Yiqi Liu.
Jocelyn: It’s interesting that the title says it uses cross-experiment correlations to calibrate polarization. It sounds very practical because it’s about using data from different telescopes to check each other.
Subrahmanyan: The authors are tackling the fundamental problem of instrument calibration, which is usually a nuisance but becomes a serious cosmological constraint when you’re looking for subtle effects like cosmic birefringence or primordial electron-b correlations.
Vera: They introduce this data-driven method specifically because it avoids the pitfalls of standard self-calibration approaches by not assuming vanishing isotropic cosmic birefringence or primordial electron-b correlations when they estimate the relative misalignment angle.
Jocelyn: That’s a big deal, because as we saw on page three, that degeneracy between instrumental misalignment and cosmic birefringence significantly limits our ability to constrain the latter.
Subrahmanyan: So if this method can isolate the misalignment angle without being completely blind to those parity-violating signals, it opens up a different way to probe physics beyond the Standard Model.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, what’s the actual mechanism they propose? They use cross-correlations between different instruments to build an estimator for the relative misalignment angle. They call this quantity R sub i j, which directly estimates the difference between telescope misalignment angles using only their cross-spectra.
Jocelyn: That sounds like they are using the way one instrument’s measurement correlates with another one’s, even if they aren't observing exactly the same patch of sky simultaneously.
Subrahmanyan: The key thing about R sub i j is that it provides a direct estimate of that difference without needing any prior assumptions about the intrinsic electron-b mode spectrum or whether cosmic birefringence beta is present at all. That’s a very clean probe.
Vera: Right, because the paper says this estimator targets precisely the observable that is both measurable and free from degeneracy with parity-violating physics. It’s a very clever target for calibration.
Jocelyn: If you can measure something that isn't confused with the physics you’re trying to find, that makes it much more useful for constraining things like primordial electron-b correlations.
The paper's improvements: Vera: The practical improvement they highlight is how this method can be used to improve constraints on parity-breaking physics in Section IV of the paper. They show how you can assess whether parity-violating physics is present by looking at the case where beta equals zero, which helps constrain the primordial electron-b mode spectrum.
Jocelyn: But they also showed that assuming beta equals zero and using only one instrument lets you read out the primordial electron-b mode power spectrum. That comparison really shows you how much precision you can get depending on what data set you use.
Subrahmanyan: What’s interesting is the performance forecast they give, using the Simons Observatory Small Aperture Telescopes, or SATs, as a calibrated reference point. They show that if those SATs can be calibrated to an uncertainty of zero point zero eight degrees, then Planck and LAT could potentially be calibrated to uncertainties of zero point one zero degrees and zero point one seven degrees at around one hundred forty-five gigahertz.
Vera: So the forecast shows a real potential for retrospective cross-calibration. It suggests that existing datasets from experiments like Planck and LAT can be tightened significantly if they use this method against a well-calibrated reference like the SATs.
Conclusion: Jocelyn: So, to wrap up, the central result of this paper is that an antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument electron-b mode spectra isolates this relative misalignment angle while remaining insensitive to both cosmic birefringence and intrinsic electron-b signals. It’s a robust way to extract what you need.
Subrahmanyan: This approach enables a significant reduction in systematic uncertainties, which means we can get better constraints on parity-violating physics in the early universe. It really shows the power of cross-instrument analyses for improving polarization calibration across different experiments.
Vera: The key result is that this antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument electron-b mode spectra isolates this relative angle while remaining insensitive to both birefringence and intrinsic electron-b signals. That’s what makes it so powerful, because it removes the noise from those other physical effects.
Jocelyn: It identifies a specific observable that can be robustly extracted from two experiments at the level of two-point functions and provides a direct estimator for it. The forecasts show that assuming a well-calibrated reference instrument such as the Simons Observatory SATs, this method can achieve polarization-angle uncertainties of zero point one zero degrees for the LAT and zero point one seven degrees for Planck at one hundred forty-five gigahertz including both systematic and statistical errors.
Subrahmanyan: And while they show how to get better calibration, they also flag a limitation: the largest source of uncertainty comes from the pixel covariance term, which tells us that even with this method, you still have some room for error in achieving that sharp precision.
Vera: So it’s a great tool for improving calibration and probing new physics at the level of two-point functions, but we need to be careful about those covariance terms when we try to achieve those tight error bars. That’s what this paper on "Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations" shows us.
Laboratory for Theoretical Particle Physics and Cosmology, King’s College London · Joseph Henry Laboratories of Physics, Princeton University
astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.IM
Submitted: 2026-06-09
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures, 3 appendices. Published in the Open Journal of Astrophysics
Code: https://github.com/simonsobs/so_noise_models
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations describes a data-driven method to calibrate the relative polarisation angle between CMB experiments using cross-correlations of…
Key concepts
- Miscalibration Problem
- When instrument polarimeters are misaligned, they rotate the measured polarization basis. This rotation causes leakage of E-mode power into B-mode measurements, complicating the extraction of true sky signals and parity-violating physics.
- Cross-Correlation Estimator (Rij)
- This estimator uses cross-correlations between independent instruments to directly estimate the difference in their telescope misalignment angles. Crucially, it does not require assumptions about the intrinsic CMB spectrum or cosmic birefringence, making it model-independent for this specific parameter.
- Parity Violation Probe
- The method can test for parity violation by setting the cosmic birefringence angle ($eta$) to zero and measuring the primordial C_EB power spectrum. Conversely, using only one instrument with $eta=0$ allows reading the primordial C_EB spectrum, showing how this technique separates calibration errors from fundamental physics signals.
- Reference Instrument Calibration
- The performance of the method is forecasted using a well-calibrated reference, such as the Simons Observatory SATs. This demonstrates that by anchoring relative measurements to a high-precision instrument, existing datasets like Planck and LAT can be calibrated with improved accuracy.
Terminology
Summary
Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations describes a data-driven method to calibrate the relative polarisation angle between CMB experiments using cross-correlations of observations over a common sky region Unlike standard self-calibration approaches, this method does not assume vanishing isotropic cosmic birefringence or primordial EB correlations when estimating the relative misalignment angle, and therefore preserves sensitivity to parity-violating physics. p. 0 We describe a data-driven method to calibrate the relative polarisation
angle between CMB experiments using cross-correlations of observations over a common sky region. Unlike standard self-calibration approaches, this method does not assume vanishing isotropic cosmic
birefringence or primordial EB correlations when estimating the relative misalignment angle, and
therefore preserves sensitivity to parity-violating physics. Unlike standard self-calibration approaches, this method does not assume vanishing isotropic cosmic
birefringence or primordial EB correlations when estimating the relative misalignment angle, and
therefore preserves sensitivity to parity-violating physics. As a proof of concept, we forecast the
performance of this method using the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs)
as a calibrated reference.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Problem of Miscalibration
Accurate recovery of the CMB E- and B-mode signals requires precise knowledge of the instrument’s polarisation orientation. A small miscalibration in the polarimeter orientation rotates the measured polarisation basis and induces leakage from E- to B-modes. p. 1 THE PROBLEM OF MISCALIBRATION
Accurate recovery of the CMB E- and B-mode signals requires precise knowledge of the instrument’s polarisation orientation. A small miscalibration in the polarimeter orientation rotates the measured polarisation
basis and induces leakage from E- to B-modes [17–19]. The observed EB power spectrum therefore reads
[41, 44]:
C
EB,o
ℓ = C
EB
ℓ
cos(4α) + C
EE
ℓ − C
BB
ℓ
cos(2α) sin(2α) . (3)
The observed C
EB,o
ℓ
thus receives two contributions: a
sky term C
EB
ℓ
, and a rotation-induced term proportional
to C
EE
ℓ − C
BB
ℓ
. , cosmic birefringence) or astrophysical foregrounds
– and instrumental polarisation angle miscalibration. Our goal is to disentangle the contribution arising from
the misalignment angle from the true sky signal C
EB
ℓ
,
which encodes information about parity violation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The method exploits cross-correlations between different instruments to construct an estimator of the relative misalignment angle by exploiting cross-correlations between independent instruments. The quantity Rij provides a direct estimate of the difference between the telescope misalignment angles using only their cross-spectra, without requiring prior assumptions about the intrinsic C EB,l spectrum or the presence of cosmic birefringence β. p. 3 | {z }
≡Rij
. (8)
The ratio Rij provides a direct estimate of the difference between the telescope misalignment angles using only their cross-spectra, without requiring prior assumptions about the intrinsic C
EB
ℓ
spectrum or the presence of cosmic birefringence β. 5
particularly powerful: it targets precisely the observable
that is both measurable and free from degeneracy with
parity-violating physics. It therefore provides a modelindependent probe of the relative polarisation-angle calibration.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the gains come from
The method's performance is forecasted using the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs) as a calibrated reference. The resulting calibration accuracy can also be leveraged by the LAT and other CMB experiments observing overlapping regions of the sky. p. 1 2
campaigns. We will show that the resulting calibration
accuracy can also be leveraged by the LAT and other
CMB experiments observing overlapping regions of the
sky. In the case of the polarised Galactic foreground calibration method, for instance, incorporating all frequency channels led to a twofold reduction in the error, see [42] in comparison with [68]. A
more detailed implementation of this SAT–LAT crosscalibration approach, including map-based simulations,
an exploration of different calibration regimes, updated
SO noise models, foreground treatment, will be presented
in an upcoming Simons Observatory paper [47]. If they can be calibrated to an uncertainty of 0. 08◦
, as anticipated from
the SO wire grid calibration system, we show that the SO Large Aperture Telescope and Planck
could be calibrated to uncertainties of 0. 10◦
and 0. 17◦
, respectively, at ∼ 145 GHz.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Constraining Parity-Violation
The method can be used to assess whether parity-violating physics is present by separately investigating the case where β = 0, to constrain the primordial C EB,l. Conversely, assuming β = 0 and using only one instrument allows reading the primordial C EB,l power spectrum [42]. p. 6 Using only one instrument, from Eq. (3), we can read the
primordial C
EB
ℓ
power spectrum [42]:
C
EB
ℓ ≃ C
EB,o
ℓ,ii − 2αi
C
EE,o
ℓ,ii − C
BB,o
ℓ,ii
. 8 This gives us an idea of the amplitude and shape
necessary to be detectable with our current calibration
method. 4 we observe that the SAT is achieving the best precision, but has a very limited ℓ range.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Discussion and Outlook
The central result is that an antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument EB spectra isolates this relative angle while remaining insensitive to both birefringence and intrinsic EB signals. p. 7 By
leveraging cross-correlations between different experiments [30], we demonstrated that any datasets that share
some sky coverage can be recalibrated using the SO
SATs. The central result is that an antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument EB spectra isolates this relative
angle while remaining insensitive to both birefringence
and intrinsic EB signals, as shown in Eq. Encouragingly, additional calibration
strategies, including drone-based systems, are being developed and offer promising avenues for achieving highprecision absolute calibration. This approach enables a significant reduction of systematic uncertainties and enhances our ability to constrain or detect signatures of parity-violating physics in
the early universe. This approach enables a significant reduction of systematic uncertainties and enhances our ability to constrain or detect signatures of parity-violating physics in
the early universe. More generally, this method highlights the potential of cross-instrument analyses to improve polarisation calibration across experiments.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion
In this work, we have examined the impact of polarisation-angle miscalibration as a key limitation in extracting parity-violating signals from the CMB. The central result is that an antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument EB spectra isolates this relative angle while remaining insensitive to both birefringence and intrinsic EB signals. This identifies the specific observable that can be robustly extracted from two experiments at the level of two-point functions and provides a direct estimator for it. p. 7 The central result is that an antisymmetric combination of cross-instrument EB spectra isolates this relative
angle while remaining insensitive to both birefringence
and intrinsic EB signals, as shown in Eq. This
identifies the specific observable that can be robustly extracted from two experiments at the level of two-point
functions, and provides a direct estimator for it. While
cross-correlations are widely used in CMB analyses, this
formulation makes explicit how they can be used to calibrate polarisation angles without imposing assumptions
that would otherwise remove the very signals of interest. Our forecasts show that, assuming a well-calibrated
reference instrument such as the Simons Observatory
SATs, this method can achieve polarisation-angle uncertainties of 0. As a concrete application, we demonstrate how this
approach can leverage the expected precise calibration of
the SO SATs [31–34] to calibrate other telescopes. The
Simons Observatory, located in Chile, consists of two
complementary surveys using the SATs and the Large
Aperture Telescope (LAT) [35]. 10◦
for the LAT and 0. 17◦
for Planck at
145/143 GHz (including both systematic and statistical
errors). This demonstrates that cross-instrument calibration can significantly improve the effective calibration of
existing datasets, thereby enhancing their sensitivity to
parity-violating physics. A key requirement of this approach is the availability of at least one accurately calibrated instrument to anchor the relative measurements.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgments
We are very grateful to Kam Arnold, Carlos Herv´ıas-Caimapo, Jo Dunkley, Lam Hui, Mudit Jain, Anto Lonappan and David Marsh for discussions and insightful feedback. We would also like to thank the organisers of the GC2024 conference at the Yukawa Institute where this work was originally conceived in a discussion between the authors and Jo Dunkley. p. 8 Acknowledgments: We are very grateful to Kam
Arnold, Carlos Herv´ıas-Caimapo, Jo Dunkley, Lam Hui,
Mudit Jain, Anto Lonappan and David Marsh for discussions and insightful feedback. We would also like to thank
the organisers of the GC2024 conference at the Yukawa
Institute where this work was originally conceived in a
discussion between the authors and Jo Dunkley. We would also like to thank
the organisers of the GC2024 conference at the Yukawa
Institute where this work was originally conceived in a
discussion between the authors and Jo Dunkley. acknowledges support from the Science and Technology
Facilities Council (STFC).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix A: Isotropic cosmic birefringence
We demonstrate how the presence of parity-violating interactions affecting photons can be probed through the rotation of their polarisation plane. Consider a parity violating pseudoscalar field ϕ, that couples to photons through a Chern-Simons term ϕFµνF˜µν, where F˜µν = 1/2ϵµναβFαβ. p. 1 Isotropic Cosmic Birefringence
The presence of parity-violating interactions for photons can be measured via the rotation of their polarisation plane. Consider for example a pseudoscalar field ϕ,
that couples to photons through a Chern-Simons term
ϕFµνF˜µν, where F˜
µν = 1/2ϵµναβF
αβ. Consider for example a pseudoscalar field ϕ,
that couples to photons through a Chern-Simons term
ϕFµνF˜µν, where F˜
µν = 1/2ϵµναβF
αβ. As is shown in
Appendix A, the presence of such a term would impact
the right-handed and left-handed photons asymmetrically, rotating the plane of polarisation between the last
scattering surface and today.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix B: What we cannot do with cross-correlating between different detectors
Unfortunately there exists no such relationship for ˜α+ij – one cannot “undo” the rotation of R(2˜αi) by adding another rotation to it since we do not know what the original datum point is. In terms of correlation functions, this conundrum manifests itself as an identity as follows. p. 8 (B4)
Again, ˜α
+
ij is not present. In terms of correlation functions, this conundrum manifests itself as an identity as
follows.Where the paper says it
Appendix C: Additional data
Table IV provides a comparison of the calibration precision σRij between analytical estimates and simulations for SAT + Planck and SAT + LAT frequency combinations. Table V compares the 1σ deviation on the isotropic birefringence angle β for LAT and Planck for different frequency channels. p. 9 48
Table V. Comparison of the 1σ deviation on the isotropic birefringence angle β for LAT and Planck for different frequency
channels. For these forecasts, we only use
the 143/145, GHz channel. the largest source of uncertainty comes from the pixel covariance term: ΞEB,o
ℓ,ii , which indicates that the calibration uncertainty has reached sharp enough precision. For these forecasts, we only use
the 143/145, GHz channel. the largest source of uncertainty comes from the pixel covariance term: ΞEB,o
ℓ,ii , which indicates that the calibration uncertainty has reached sharp enough precision.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Table III Summary of calibration methods
Type of calibration Precision C EB l = 0? β = 0? References. p. 3 4
Type of calibration Precision C
EB
ℓ = 0? References
Self-calibration 0. Summary of existing polarisation angle calibration
methods, including their typical precision and the assumptions they require on the parity-violating sky signal. *Note that the wire-grid calibration is currently planned only
for the SO SATs, and its achievable precision will be validated
with additional on-sky data.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Table IV Comparison of calibration precision
Experiment pair f [GHz] σα [◦] σα˜ [◦] σβ [◦] References. The correlation SATs + LAT is 0. p. 1 We will show that the resulting calibration
accuracy can also be leveraged by the LAT and other
CMB experiments observing overlapping regions of the
sky. We describe how this method can be used to calibrate
other instruments via cross correlation with the SATs,
specifically for Planck [39, 40] and LAT data. We will show that the resulting calibration
accuracy can also be leveraged by the LAT and other
CMB experiments observing overlapping regions of the
sky. We describe how this method can be used to calibrate
other instruments via cross correlation with the SATs,
specifically for Planck [39, 40] and LAT data.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Table V Comparison of the 1σ deviation on the isotropic birefringence angle β
LAT 93 0.17. Planck 143 0. p. 5 6
reference instrument and either the LAT or Planck as
the second dataset. For the 143 GHz channel, we find:
(
σR12 ≃ 0.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Cross-instrument calibration for CMB experiments allows datasets to be recalibrated using a well-calibrated reference instrument, such as Simons Observatory SATs, enabling retrospective cross-calibration of existing datasets at minimal additional cost.
-
The proposed method determines the relative misalignment angle between two instruments by exploiting cross-correlations between different instruments, which is
robust to the presence of parity-violating signals such as cosmic birefringence or primordial C EB l.
-
The estimator derived from Eq. (8) provides a
modelindependent probe of the relative polarisation-angle calibration
because it targetsprecisely the observable that is both measurable and free from degeneracy with parity-violating physics.
-
Improved AI systems can perform precise estimation of the difference between telescope misalignment angles using only their cross-spectra, without requiring prior assumptions about intrinsic C EB l spectrum or the presence of cosmic birefringence beta.
-
The method forecasts calibration uncertainties for Planck and LAT based on an assumed 0.08 degree precision for the SO SATs, showing that this approach can
significantly improve the effective calibration of existing datasets.
Abstract
Parity-violating physics in the Universe can generate correlations between the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) E - and B-modes, but detecting such signals requires extremely accurate calibration of instruments. We describe a data-driven method to calibrate the relative polarisation angle between CMB experiments using cross-correlations of observations over a common sky region. Unlike standard self-calibration approaches, this method does not assume vanishing isotropic cosmic birefringence or primordial EB correlations when estimating the relative misalignment angle, and therefore preserves sensitivity to parity-violating physics. As a proof of concept, we forecast the performance of this method using the Simons Observatory (SO) Small Aperture Telescopes (SATs) as a calibrated reference. If they can be calibrated to an uncertainty of 0.08, as anticipated from the SO wire grid calibration system, we show that the SO Large Aperture Telescope and Planck could be calibrated to uncertainties of 0.10 and 0.17, respectively, at about 145 GHz. This approach relies on the availability of at least one well-calibrated instrument, and provides a complementary path to improving polarisation calibration across experiments, enabling more robust searches for parity-violating physics in the CMB, such as cosmic birefringence.
Sources
- The Scientific Programme of Planck
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) First Year Observations: TE Polarization
- CMB Polarization Systematics Due to Beam Asymmetry: Impact on Inflationary Science
- BICEP/Keck XVIII: Measurement of BICEP3 polarization angles and consequences for constraining cosmic birefringence and inflation
- The Simons Observatory: Design, integration, and testing of the small aperture telescopes
- The Simons Observatory: Beam characterization for the Small Aperture Telescopes
- The Simons Observatory: Science Goals and Forecasts for the Enhanced Large Aperture Telescope
- Dark Energy Survey Year 6 Results: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clustering and Weak Lensing
- DESI DR2 Results II: Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Cosmological Constraints
- LSST: from Science Drivers to Reference Design and Anticipated Data Products
- Planck intermediate results. XLIX. Parity-violation constraints from polarization data
- Planck 2018 results. XI. Polarized dust foregrounds
- Simultaneous determination of the cosmic birefringence and miscalibrated polarisation angles from CMB experiments
- Robustness of cosmic birefringence measurement against Galactic foreground emission and instrumental systematics
- Modeling parity-violating spectra in Galactic dust polarization with filaments and its applications to cosmic birefringence searches
- Gauge-flation: Inflation From Non-Abelian Gauge Fields
- Anomalous CMB polarization and gravitational chirality
- Cosmological Signature of New Parity-Violating Interactions
- Finding the chiral gravitational wave background of an axion-SU(2) inflationary model using CMB observations and laser interferometers
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 Power Spectra, Likelihoods and $\Lambda$CDM Parameters
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference